Airworthiness Directives; Lockheed Model L-1011-385 Series Airplanes

FederalRegulations

Ask Donna

How this section applies to your facts.

Federal Register › Vol. 60 › 60 FR 336

This text was captured on Sep 30, 2026. It is a snapshot, not a live feed, so check the official code before relying on it.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

14 CFR Part 39

[Docket No. 94-NM-17-AD; Amendment 39-9104; AD 94-26-09]

Airworthiness Directives; Lockheed Model L-1011-385 Series

Airplanes

AGENCY: Federal Aviation Administration, DOT.

ACTION: Final rule.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: This amendment adopts a new airworthiness directive (AD),

applicable to certain Lockheed Model L-1011-385 series airplanes, that

requires an initial servicing or overhaul of the ram air turbine (RAT),

and incorporating repetitive overhaul actions into the FAA-approved

maintenance program. This amendment is prompted by reports indicating

that, during routine maintenance of the RAT, the turbine blade assembly

separated during spin tests. The actions specified by this AD are

intended to prevent separation of the turbine blade assembly, which

could damage the airplane structure and systems, and, under certain

circumstances, could lead to reduced controllability of the airplane.

DATES: Effective February 3, 1995.

The incorporation by reference of certain publications listed in

the regulations is approved by the Director of the Federal Register as

of February 3, 1995.

ADDRESSES: The service information referenced in this AD may be

obtained from Lockheed Aeronautical Systems Support Company, Field

Support Department, Dept. 693, Zone 0755, 2251 Lake Park Drive, Smyrna,

Georgia 30080. This information may be examined at the Federal Aviation

Administration (FAA), Transport Airplane Directorate, Rules Docket,

1601 Lind Avenue, SW., Renton, Washington; or at the FAA, Small

Airplane Directorate, Atlanta Aircraft Certification Office, Campus

Building, 1701 Columbia Avenue, Suite 2-160, College Park, Georgia; or

at the Office of the Federal Register, 800 North Capitol Street, NW.,

suite 700, Washington, DC.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Thomas Peters, Aerospace Engineer,

Flight Test Branch, ACE-160A, FAA, Small Airplane Directorate, Atlanta

Aircraft Certification Office, Campus Building, 1701 Columbia Avenue,

Suite 2-160, College Park, Georgia 30337-2748; telephone (404) 305-

7367; fax (404) 305-7348.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: A proposal to amend part 39 of the Federal

Aviation Regulations (14 CFR part 39) to include an airworthiness

directive (AD) that is applicable to certain Lockheed Model L-1011-385

series airplanes was published in the Federal Register on April 25,

1994 (59 FR 19683). That action proposed to require an initial

servicing or overhaul of the ram air turbine (RAT), and incorporating

repetitive overhaul actions into the FAA-approved maintenance program.

Interested persons have been afforded an opportunity to participate

in the making of this amendment. Due consideration has been given to

the comments received.

One commenter supports the proposal.

The Air Transport Association (ATA) of America, on behalf of some

of its member operators, suggests that the proposal be withdrawn

because it is ``an inappropriate use of the airworthiness directive.''

This commenter states that AD's are not the proper vehicle for

addressing maintenance problems. The commenter points out that the AD

is based on failures that have been reported, not during service, but

during routine maintenance of the RAT. Further, the commenter states

that the FAA's analysis identifies the problem area as the turbine

blade assembly, and the maintenance deficiency as lack of lubrication;

yet the FAA's proposed corrective action is a complete overhaul of the

unit. The commenter questions whether the FAA considered a ``simpler

remedy,'' such as a periodic lubrication requirement or increased

frequency of functional checks. The commenter requests that the FAA

examine vehicles other than the AD to ensure that appropriate

maintenance is performed.

The FAA does not concur with the commenter's request to withdraw

the AD, nor does it concur with the commenter's implication that the AD

is not the proper vehicle for addressing the unsafe condition.

According to section 39.1 of the Federal Aviation Regulations (FAR) (14

CFR 39.1), the issuance of an AD is based on the finding that an unsafe

condition is likely to exist or develop in aircraft of a particular

type design. The responsibilities placed on the FAA by the Federal

Aviation Act do not limit it from making any unsafe condition--whether

resulting from maintenance, design defect, or otherwise--the proper

subject of an AD. Therefore, regardless of the cause or the source of

an unsafe condition, the FAA has the authority to issue an AD when it

is found that an unsafe condition is likely to exist or develop on

other products of the same type design.

Further, it is within the FAA's authority to issue AD's to require

actions to address unsafe conditions that are not otherwise being

addressed (or addressed adequately) by normal maintenance procedures.

The FAA may address such unsafe conditions by requiring revisions to

maintenance programs as a condition under which airplanes may continue

to be operated. While the subject of this AD relates to a problem with

the RAT assembly that was identified during regular maintenance

procedures, the FAA points out that reports of this problem came from

several different operators. From the data garnered from these reports,

the FAA has identified the existence of an unsafe condition. Although

the unsafe condition is one that, feasibly, could have been addressed

by the operators' maintenance programs, it is obvious that the current

maintenance programs are inadequate in addressing it. In light of this,

the unsafe condition is likely to exist or develop in the affected

airplanes. As a result, the FAA is issuing this AD to eliminate the

unsafe condition by revising the maintenance programs accordingly. The

AD is the appropriate vehicle for mandating such actions.

The FAA acknowledges that some operators currently may have better

maintenance programs that address an unsafe condition. If a program is

adequate, an operator would already be in compliance with the AD, or

would be in a position to obtain an approval for an alternative method

of compliance with the AD (i.e., to follow the operator's current

program rather than revise it to comply with the AD). The obligation of

the FAA to issue the AD and address an unsafe condition remains,

however, and the rule must apply to everyone to ensure that all

affected airplanes are covered, regardless of who operates them.

In developing this AD action, the FAA did consider optional actions

to address strictly the bearing lubrication problem. However, in

reviewing the available data, the FAA found that there were no

mandatory replacement or refurbishment times for the RAT in the

majority of affected operators' maintenance programs. Under normal

maintenance procedures, the RAT's are functionally tested on the an

average of every 48 months or 4,000 flights (at a ``D'' check). In

cases where operators had replaced or refurbished the RAT's, those

actions were accomplished ``on condition'' only, that is, after the

RAT's had failed certain functional (spin-up) testing. In the reported

incidents, the RAT's had not been serviced, nor had functional testing

indicated that they needed servicing, since new. It is likely that

RAT's have been installed on many other affected airplanes, and have

had no servicing whatsoever since delivery that would

ensure adequate lubrication of the turbine bearing. In light of this,

the FAA has clearly identified an unsafe condition that must be

addressed by the actions specified by this AD to be incorporated in the

operators' maintenance programs.

Further, the FAA points out that the normal means for air carriers

to comply with AD's such as this is to incorporate the repetitive

requirements into their approved maintenance program. Therefore, the

FAA could accomplish this same result by enumerating the specific

overhaul/servicing actions identified by the maintenance program

revision. However, from an administrative point of view, there is a

distinct advantage in requiring a maintenance program revision. By

imposing the overhaul/servicing requirements, compliance with the AD

with respect to each action would have to be recorded in the operator's

maintenance records; whereas, in the case of this AD, the only required

recording of the compliance relates to the one-time changes in the

maintenance program required by paragraph (b) of the rule.

One commenter requests that the proposal be revised to require only

a one-time inspection and servicing of the RAT. Data gathered from the

results of the inspection could then be evaluated to determine the

condition of the fleet and if additional actions are warranted. This

commenter believes that the reported bearing failures were isolated

incidents, and that issuance of the proposed AD is an ``overreaction''

to these reports. The FAA does not concur. From data already obtained,

the FAA has determined that a sufficient number of failures have

occurred which clearly indicate that the RAT installed in the Model L-

1011-385 is likely to develop problems in the turbine bearing unless

measures are implemented to periodically lubricate the bearing.

Issuance of this AD is the result of that determination.

One commenter supports the intent of the proposed rule, but

requests that proposed paragraph (b) be revised to delete the

requirement for a complete overhaul of the RAT every eight years. The

commenter considers this to be excessive. The commenter states that the

turbine separation problems, like those that have occurred, should be

correctable by periodically performing only the servicing procedures in

accordance with Lockheed TriStar L-1011 Service Bulletin 093-29-098,

dated December 6, 1993 (reference Dowty Service Bulletin RAT16C10-29-

168). The FAA concurs that the servicing procedures are acceptable in

ensuring that the addressed problems associated with the turbine blade

assembly are monitored and corrected in a timely manner. Accordingly,

the FAA has revised paragraph (b) to provide operators with the option

of accomplishing either the complete overhaul of the RAT or the

servicing procedures, at eight-year intervals.

Another commenter requests that the proposal be revised to allow

RAT's that have been overhauled previously in accordance with Dowty

Overhaul Manual 29-21-01 to be considered in compliance with the AD,

even though the overhaul manual does not call for the replacement of

the roller bearing, part number RA56341. The commenter states that the

lubrication problem addressed by the proposed AD occurs mainly in the

turbine ball bearing (part number 601017118), not the roller bearing.

The Dowty Overhaul Manual does not call for replacement of the roller

bearing if it is still serviceable; however, Lockheed TriStar L-1011

Service Bulletin 093-29-098, dated December 6, 1993, which was cited in

the proposed rule, calls for the replacement of the roller bearing,

regardless of its condition. The FAA does not concur with the

commenter's request. The replacement of the roller bearing, as called

for in the referenced service bulletin, is necessary because of

corrosion damage problems that can occur in the roller bearing. This

corrosion damage may be difficult to detect by visual inspection alone;

thus, initial replacement of the bearing (during overhaul) is all the

more important. However, this corrosion problem will be monitored and

corrected, if necessary, during the regular repetitive servicing or

overhaul (every eight years) required by this AD. In light of this,

inspection and reinstallation of both the roller and ball bearings, if

serviceable, would be acceptable at the recurrent actions required by

the AD. A note has been added to the final rule to clarify that

replacement of the roller bearing is necessary when initially

overhauling the RAT.

The FAA has recently reviewed the figures it has used over the past

several years in calculating the economic impact of AD activity. In

order to account for various inflationary costs in the airline

industry, the FAA has determined that it is necessary to increase the

labor rate used in these calculations from $55 per work hour to $60 per

work hour. The cost estimate information, below has been revised to

reflect this increase in the specified hourly labor rate.

After careful review of the available data, including the comments

noted above, the FAA has determined that air safety and the public

interest require the adoption of the rule with the changes previously

described. The FAA has determined that these changes will neither

increase the economic burden on any operator nor increase the scope of

the AD.

Cost Estimate

There are approximately 236 Lockheed Model L-1011-385 series

airplanes of the affected design in the worldwide fleet. The FAA

estimates that 117 airplanes of U.S. registry will be affected by this

AD.

For operators electing to service the RAT, it will take

approximately 48 work hours per RAT to accomplish those actions, at an

average labor rate of $60 per work hour. Based on these figures, the

total cost impact of the servicing actions on U.S. operators is

estimated to be $2,880 per RAT.

For operators electing to overhaul the RAT, it will take

approximately 170 work hours per RAT to accomplish those actions, at an

average labor rate of $60 per work hour. Based on these figures, the

total cost impact of the overhaul actions on U.S. operators is

estimated to be $10,200 per RAT.

The number of work hours that will be required to perform either

the servicing or overhaul of the RAT, as indicated above, is presented

as if those actions were to be accomplished as ``stand alone'' actions.

However, in actual practice, these actions for the most part could be

accomplished coincidentally or in combination with normally scheduled

airplane inspections and other maintenance program tasks. Therefore,

the actual number of any necessary additional work hours will be

minimal in many instances. Additionally, any costs associated with

special airplane scheduling will be minimal.

Incorporation of the requirements of this AD into the FAA-approved

maintenance program will require approximately 40 work hours per

operator to accomplish, at an average labor rate of $60 per work hour.

Based on these figures, the total cost impact of incorporation of the

maintenance program change on U.S. operators is estimated to be $2,400

per operator.

The FAA recognizes that the obligation to maintain aircraft in an

airworthy condition is vital, but sometimes expensive. Because AD's

require specific actions to address specific unsafe conditions, they

appear to impose costs that would not otherwise be borne by operators.

However, because of the general obligation of operators to

maintain aircraft in an airworthy condition, this appearance is

deceptive. Attributing those costs solely to the issuance of this AD is

unrealistic because, in the interest of maintaining safe aircraft, most

prudent operators would accomplish the required actions even if they

were not required to do so by the AD.

A full cost-benefit analysis has not been accomplished for this AD.

As a matter of law, in order to be airworthy, an aircraft must conform

to its type design and be in a condition for safe operation. The type

design is approved only after the FAA makes a determination that it

complies with all applicable airworthiness requirements. In adopting

and maintaining those requirements, the FAA has already made the

determination that they establish a level of safety that is cost-

beneficial. When the FAA, as in this AD, makes a finding of an unsafe

condition, this means that the original cost-beneficial level of safety

is no longer being achieved and that the required actions are necessary

to restore that level of safety. Because this level of safety has

already been determined to be cost-beneficial, a full cost-benefit

analysis for this AD would be redundant and unnecessary.

Regulatory Impact

The regulations adopted herein will not have substantial direct

effects on the States, on the relationship between the national

government and the States, or on the distribution of power and

responsibilities among the various levels of government. Therefore, in

accordance with Executive Order 12612, it is determined that this final

rule does not have sufficient federalism implications to warrant the

preparation of a Federalism Assessment.

For the reasons discussed above, I certify that this action (1) is

not a ``significant regulatory action'' under Executive Order 12866;

(2) is not a ``significant rule'' under DOT Regulatory Policies and

Procedures (44 FR 11034, February 26, 1979); and (3) will not have a

significant economic impact, positive or negative, on a substantial

number of small entities under the criteria of the Regulatory

Flexibility Act. A final evaluation has been prepared for this action

and it is contained in the Rules Docket. A copy of it may be obtained

from the Rules Docket at the location provided under the caption

ADDRESSES.

List of Subjects in 14 CFR Part 39

Air transportation, Aircraft, Aviation safety, Incorporation by

reference, Safety.

Adoption of the Amendment

Accordingly, pursuant to the authority delegated to me by the

Administrator, the Federal Aviation Administration amends part 39 of

the Federal Aviation Regulations (14 CFR part 39) as follows:

PART 39--AIRWORTHINESS DIRECTIVES

1. The authority citation for part 39 continues to read as follows:

Authority: 49 U.S.C. App. 1354(a), 1421 and 1423; 49 U.S.C.

106(g); and 14 CFR 11.89.

Sec. 39.13 [Amended]

2. Section 39.13 is amended by adding the following new

airworthiness directive:

94-26-09 Lockhead: Amendment 39-9104. Docket 94-NM-17-AD.

Applicability: Model L-1011-385 series airplanes having serial

numbers 193A through 193Y inclusive, 293A through 293F inclusive,

and 1002 through 1250 inclusive; certificated in any category.

Compliance: Required as indicated, unless accomplished

previously.

To prevent separation of the turbine blade assembly, which could

damage the airplane structure and systems, and, under certain

circumstances, lead to reduced controllability of the airplane,

accomplish the following:

(a) Remove, disassemble, inspect, test, and service the ram air

turbine (RAT) in accordance with Lockheed TriStar L-1011 Service

Bulletin 093-29-098, dated December 6, 1993; or completely overhaul

the RAT in accordance with Chapter 29-21-01 of Dowty Aerospace

Hydraulics--Cheltenham Overhaul Manual; at the applicable time

specified in either paragraph (a)(1) or (a)(2) of this AD:

Note 1: Overhaul of the RAT in accordance with this paragraph

includes replacement of the roller bearing (part number RA56341).

(1) For airplanes on which the RAT has not been serviced or

overhauled within 6 years prior to the effective date of this AD:

Accomplish the procedures within 2 years after the effective date of

this AD.

(2) For airplanes on which the RAT has been serviced or

overhauled within 6 years prior to the effective date of this AD in

accordance with a method that is equivalent to the procedures

described in Dowty Aerospace Hydraulics--Cheltenham Service Bulletin

RAT16C10-29-168, dated December 1, 1993: Accomplish the procedures

within 8 years after the date of the immediately preceding servicing

of the RAT.

(b) Within 24 months after the effective date of this AD, revise

the FAA-approved maintenance program to incorporate procedures for

servicing of the RAT in accordance with Lockheed TriStar L-1011

Service Bulletin 093-29-098, dated December 6, 1993; or complete

overhaul of the RAT in accordance with Chapter 29-21-01 of Dowty

Aerospace Hydraulics--Cheltenham Overhaul Manual. One or the other

of these actions must be accomplished at intervals not to exceed 8

years.

(c) An alternative method of compliance or adjustment of the

compliance time that provides an acceptable level of safety may be

used if approved by the Manager, Atlanta Aircraft Certification

Office (ACO), FAA, Small Airplane Directorate. Operators shall

submit their requests through an appropriate FAA Principal

Maintenance Inspector, who may add comments and then send it to the

Manager, Atlanta ACO.

Note 2: Information concerning the existence of approved

alternative methods of compliance with this AD, if any, may be

obtained from the Atlanta ACO.

(d) Special flight permits may be issued in accordance with

sections 21.197 and 21.199 of the Federal Aviation Regulations (14

CFR 21.197 and 21.199) to operate the airplane to a location where

the requirements of this AD can be accomplished.

(e) The servicing actions shall be done in accordance with

Lockheed TriStar L-1011 Service Bulletin 093-29-098, dated December

6, 1993. This incorporation by reference was approved by the

Director of the Federal Register in accordance with 5 U.S.C. 552(a)

and 1 CFR part 51. Copies may be obtained from Lockheed Aeronautical

Systems Support Company, Field Support Department, Dept. 693, Zone

0755, 2251 Lake Park Drive, Smyrna, Georgia 30080. Copies may be

inspected at the FAA, Transport Airplane Directorate, 1601 Lind

Avenue, SW., Renton, Washington; or at the FAA, Atlanta Aircraft

Certification Office, Small Airplane Directorate, Campus Building,

1701 Columbia Avenue, Suite 2-160, College Park, Georgia; or at the

Office of the Federal Register, 800 North Capitol Street, NW., suite

700, Washington, DC.

(f) This amendment becomes effective on February 3, 1995.

Issued in Renton, Washington, on December 19, 1994.

Darrell M. Pederson,

Acting Manager, Transport Airplane Directorate, Aircraft Certification

Service.

[FR Doc. 95-52 Filed 1-3-95; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 4910-13-U

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.