Airworthiness Directives; Fokker Model F27 Series Airplanes (Excluding Mark 050 Series Airplanes)
FederalRegulations
Ask Donna
How this section applies to your facts.
Federal Register › Vol. 60 › 60 FR 332
Text
DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
14 CFR Part 39
[Docket No. 93-NM-229-AD; Amendment 39-9103; AD 94-26-08]
Airworthiness Directives; Fokker Model F27 Series Airplanes
(Excluding Mark 050 Series Airplanes)
AGENCY: Federal Aviation Administration, DOT.
ACTION: Final rule.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: This amendment adopts a new airworthiness directive (AD),
applicable to certain Fokker Model F27 series airplanes, that requires
accomplishment of certain structural modifications. This amendment is
prompted by reports of incidents involving fatigue cracking and
corrosion in transport category airplanes that are approaching or have
exceeded their economic design goal. These incidents have jeopardized
the airworthiness of the affected airplanes. The actions specified by
this AD are intended to prevent degradation in the structural
capabilities of the affected airplanes. This action also reflects the
FAA's decision that long term continued operational safety should be
assured by actual modification of the airframe rather than repetitive
inspections.
DATES: Effective February 3, 1995.
The incorporation by reference of certain publications listed in
the regulations is approved by the Director of the Federal Register as
of February 3, 1995.
ADDRESSES: The service information referenced in this AD may be
obtained from Fokker Aircraft USA, Inc., 1199 North Fairfax Street,
Alexandria, Virginia 22314. This information may be examined at the
Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), Transport Airplane Directorate,
Rules Docket, 1601 Lind Avenue, SW., Renton, Washington; or at the
Office of the Federal Register, 800 North Capitol Street, NW., suite
700, Washington, DC.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Mark Quam, Aerospace Engineer,
Standardization Branch, ANM-113, FAA, Transport Airplane Directorate,
1601 Lind Avenue, SW., Renton, Washington 98055-4056; telephone (206)
227-2145; fax (206) 227-1320.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: A proposal to amend part 39 of the Federal
Aviation Regulations (14 CFR part 39) to include an airworthiness
directive (AD) that is applicable to certain Fokker Model F27 series
airplanes was published in the Federal Register on March 14, 1994 (59
FR 11737). That action proposed to require certain structural
modifications of certain Fokker Model F27 series airplanes prior to
their economic design goal. -
Interested persons have been afforded an opportunity to participate
in the making of this amendment. Due consideration has been given to
the comments received. -
One commenter supports the proposed rule. -
One commenter requests a revision to the applicability statement to
specify the series of Fokker Model F27 airplanes affected
by the proposal. The commenter states that listing the series of the
affected airplane model in the proposal would avoid confusion. The
commenter notes that attempting to list all exclusions, as in the
proposal, would require listing all future series and derivatives of
future models, which would be impossible. The FAA concurs. The final
rule has been revised to specify that the rule is applicable to Model
F27 Mark 100, 200, 300, 400, 500, 600, and 700 airplanes.-
This commenter also requests that the proposal be revised to
specify the service bulletins referenced in Fokker Report Number SE-
278, ``F27 Aging Aircraft Project--Final Document,'' Issue 3, dated
February 1, 1993 (hereinafter referred to as the ``Fokker Report''),
rather than merely referencing Part II of the Fokker Report, as was
done in the proposal. The commenter requests this change because Fokker
Service Bulletin F27/57-68, which was referenced in Part II of the
Fokker Report, has been revised since issuance of the Fokker Report.
Thus, this commenter contends that referring to the Fokker Report will
not reflect this latest revision to that service bulletin. One
commenter notes that the Rijksluchtvaartdienst (RLD), which is the
airworthiness authority of the Netherlands, has issued a correction to
Netherlands Airworthiness Directive (BLA) 91-058/5 (A), dated July 16,
1993, to reference Revision 1 of Fokker Service Bulletin F27/57-58,
dated May 17, 1993.
The FAA concurs in part. Fokker Service Bulletin F27/57-68,
Revision 1, dated May 17, 1993, was revised to correct the reference to
the Netherlands airworthiness directive number, to add further
explanatory information in the Description section of the service
bulletin, and to make minor editorial changes to the Accomplishment
Instructions. The FAA finds that none of these changes are substantive
in nature; therefore, these changes do not warrant a revision to the
specific service information referenced in the final rule. However, the
FAA recognizes that operators may choose to comply with Revision 1 of
that service bulletin. For those operators, a new NOTE 2 has been added
to paragraph (a) of the final rule stating that compliance with
Revision 1 of that service bulletin would constitute compliance with
the requirements of Fokker Service Bulletin F27/57-68, dated July 17,
1992, which is referenced in the Fokker Report. Further, when the
Fokker Report is revised to incorporate substantive revisions of
service bulletins referenced in it, the FAA may consider further
rulemaking to incorporate those changes. -
Several commenters request that the proposal be revised to include
the modification of certain lower stringers in the outer wing of the
airplane described in Fokker Service Bulletin F27/57-70. These
commenters contend that the threshold, resource requirements, and
modification procedures specified in Fokker Service Bulletin 57-70 are
identical to those described in Fokker Service Bulletin 57-68; the only
difference is that Fokker Service Bulletin 57-68 specifies modification
of certain upper stringers in the outer wing of the airplane. Fokker
Service Bulletin 57-68 is referenced in the Fokker Report. These
commenters assert that the modifications specified in both of these
service bulletins should be included in the requirements of the
proposed rule. Further, these commenters note that the RLD has
classified Fokker Service Bulletin F27/57-70 as mandatory and has
issued Netherlands Airworthiness Directive (BLA) 93-094 in order to
ensure that the modification is accomplished on airplanes in the
Netherlands. -
The FAA does not concur that a revision to the rule to include a
requirement for the additional modification should be made at this
time. To do so would necessitate, under the provisions of the
Administrative Procedure Act, reissuing the notice, reopening the
period for public comment, considering additional comments received,
and eventually issuing a final rule. The FAA does not consider it
appropriate to delay issuance of this final rule further in order to
undertake those procedures. However, the FAA may consider further
rulemaking action to require modification of the lower stringers in
which cracking was detected coincidentally while accomplishing the
modification described in Fokker Service Bulletin F27/57-68.-
Several commenters request an extension of the proposed compliance
date of January 1, 1995, to accomplish the modification described in
Fokker Service Bulletin F27/57-68, which is one of the service
bulletins referenced in the Fokker Report. For airplanes that have
accumulated more than 30,000 total landings, that Fokker service
bulletin recommends accomplishment of the modification of certain upper
stringers of the outer wing prior to January 1, 1995. These commenters
state that such a compliance time would impose a tremendous economic
burden, since a majority of the airplanes in their fleet have already
accumulated more than 30,000 total landings; therefore, some of these
commenters suggest a compliance date of January 1, 1996, instead. One
of these commenters requests that the compliance time be revised to an
interval that coincides with the operator's regularly scheduled
maintenance.-
The FAA concurs that the compliance time for accomplishing the
modification described in Fokker Service Bulletin F27/57-68, Revision
1, dated May 17, 1993, may be extended to January 1, 1996, for
airplanes that have accumulated more than 30,000 total landings.
However, the FAA finds that in order to ensure safety in the interim,
an additional x-ray inspection must be performed until such time that
the airplane is modified, or prior to January 1, 1996. This extension
to the compliance time should allow operators to accomplish the
modification coincidentally with regularly scheduled maintenance.
Accordingly, the final rule has been revised to add a new paragraph (b)
to specify this provision. -
As a result of recent communications with the Air Transport
Association (ATA) of America, the FAA has learned that, in general,
some operators may misunderstand the legal effect of AD's on airplanes
that are identified in the applicability provision of the AD, but that
have been altered or repaired in the area addressed by the AD. The FAA
points out that all airplanes identified in the applicability provision
of an AD are legally subject to the AD. If an airplane has been altered
or repaired in the affected area in such a way as to affect compliance
with the AD, the owner or operator is required to obtain FAA approval
for an alternative method of compliance with the AD, in accordance with
the paragraph of each AD that provides for such approvals. A note has
been added to this final rule to clarify this requirement. -
Additionally, the FAA has recently reviewed the figures it has used
over the past several years in calculating the economic impact of AD
activity. In order to account for various inflationary costs in the
airline industry, the FAA has determined that it is necessary to
increase the labor rate used in these calculations from $55 per work
hour to $60 per work hour. The economic impact information, below, has
been revised to reflect this increase in the specified hourly labor
rate.-
After careful review of the available data, including the comments
noted above, the FAA has determined that air safety and the public
interest require the adoption of the rule with the changes previously
described. The FAA has determined that these changes will neither
increase the economic burden on any operator nor increase
the scope of the AD.-
The FAA estimates that 58 airplanes of U.S. registry will be
affected by this AD, within the initial threshold. Since not all
affected airplanes will be required to accomplish every modification
referenced in each of the service bulletins, the cost impact of the
modifications required by this AD is estimated in the following table.
This cost includes the price of modification kits, and the estimated
labor rate is $60 per work hour. It does not include the cost of
downtime, planning, set up, familiarization, or tool acquisition.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
No. of Cost of Total cost for
Service bulletin number affected No. of work parts per Cost per affected
airplanes hours airplane airplane airplanes
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
55-33 (B-77)................................ 5 40 $314 $2,714.00 $13,570.00
55-12 (B-67)................................ 5 20 121 1,321.00 6,605.00
55-12 (Part II)............................. 5 30 168 1,968.00 9,840.00
55-61 Revision 2............................ 13 45 2,235 4,935.00- 64,155.00
57-68 Revision 1............................ 58 556 1,279 34,639.00 2,009,062.00
53-19 (B-45) Issue 3........................ 5 22 0 1,320.00 6,600.00
53-58 (B-149)............................... 5 16 0 960.00 4,800.00
53-76 (B-211)............................... 13 0.25 0 15.00 195.00
57-7 Issue 1................................ 5 32 400 2,320.00 11,600.00-
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Based on the above figures, the total cost impact of the proposed
AD on U.S. operators is estimated to be 2,126,427.-
The total cost impact figure discussed above is based on
assumptions that no operator has yet accomplished any of the
requirements of this AD action, and that no operator would accomplish
those actions in the future if this AD were not adopted. -
The FAA recognizes that the modifications will require a large
number of work hours to accomplish. However, the threshold specified in
each of the service bulletins referenced by the Fokker Report should
allow ample time for the accomplishment of the modifications
coincidentally with scheduled major airplane inspection and maintenance
activities, thereby minimizing the costs associated with special
airplane scheduling.-
The FAA recognizes that the obligation to maintain aircraft in an
airworthy condition is vital, but sometimes expensive. Because AD's
require specific actions to address specific unsafe conditions, they
appear to impose costs that would not otherwise be borne by operators.
However, because of the general obligation of operators to maintain
aircraft in an airworthy condition, this appearance is deceptive.
Attributing those costs solely to the issuance of this AD is
unrealistic because, in the interest of maintaining safe aircraft, most
prudent operators would accomplish the required actions even if they
were not required to do so by the AD. -
A full cost-benefit analysis has not been accomplished for this AD.
As a matter of law, in order to be airworthy, an aircraft must conform
to its type design and be in a condition for safe operation. The type
design is approved only after the FAA makes a determination that it
complies with all applicable airworthiness requirements. In adopting
and maintaining those requirements, the FAA has already made the
determination that they establish a level of safety that is cost-
beneficial. When the FAA, as in this AD, makes a finding of an unsafe
condition, this means that the original cost-beneficial level of safety
is no longer being achieved and that the required actions are necessary
to restore that level of safety. Because this level of safety has
already been determined to be cost-beneficial, a full cost-benefit
analysis for this AD would be redundant and unnecessary.-
The regulations adopted herein will not have substantial direct
effects on the States, on the relationship between the national
government and the States, or on the distribution of power and
responsibilities among the various levels of government. Therefore, in
accordance with Executive Order 12612, it is determined that this final
rule does not have sufficient federalism implications to warrant the
preparation of a Federalism Assessment.-
For the reasons discussed above, I certify that this action (1) is
not a ``significant regulatory action'' under Executive Order 12866;
(2) is not a ``significant rule'' under DOT Regulatory Policies and
Procedures (44 FR 11034, February 26, 1979); and (3) will not have a
significant economic impact, positive or negative, on a substantial
number of small entities under the criteria of the Regulatory
Flexibility Act. A final evaluation has been prepared for this action
and it is contained in the Rules Docket. A copy of it may be obtained
from the Rules Docket at the location provided under the caption
ADDRESSES.
List of Subjects in 14 CFR Part 39-
Air transportation, Aircraft, Aviation safety, Incorporation by
reference, Safety.
Adoption of the Amendment -
Accordingly, pursuant to the authority delegated to me by the
Administrator, the Federal Aviation Administration amends part 39 of
the Federal Aviation Regulations (14 CFR part 39) as follows:
PART 39--AIRWORTHINESS DIRECTIVES-
1. The authority citation for part 39 continues to read as follows:
Authority: 49 U.S.C. App. 1354(a), 1421 and 1423; 49 U.S.C.
106(g); and 14 CFR 11.89.
Sec. 39.13 [Amended]-
2. Section 39.13 is amended by adding the following new
airworthiness directive:
94-26-08 Fokker: Amendment 39-9103. Docket 93-NM-229-AD.
Applicability: Model F27 Mark 100, 200, 300, 400, 500, 600, and
700 airplanes, as listed in Fokker Report Number SE-278, ``F27 Aging
Aircraft Project--Final Document,'' Issue 3, dated February 1, 1993;
certificated in any category.
-Note 1: This AD applies to each airplane identified in the
preceding applicability provision, regardless of whether it has been
modified, altered, or repaired in the area subject to the
requirements of this AD. For airplanes that have been modified,
altered, or repaired so that the performance of the requirements of
this AD is affected, the owner/operator must use the authority
provided in paragraph (c) to request approval from the FAA. This
approval may address either no action, if the current configuration
eliminates the unsafe condition; or different actions necessary to
address the unsafe condition described in this AD. Such a request
should include an assessment of the effect of the
changed configuration on the unsafe condition addressed by this AD.
In no case does the presence of any modification, alteration, or
repair remove any airplane from the applicability of this AD. -
Compliance: Required as indicated, unless accomplished
previously. -
To prevent structural failure, accomplish the following: -
(a) Except as provided for by paragraph (b) of this AD, prior to
reaching the incorporation thresholds listed in Part II of Fokker
Report Number SE-278, ``F27 Aging Aircraft Project--Final
Document,'' Issue 3, dated February 1, 1993 (hereinafter referred to
as the ``Fokker Report''), accomplish the structural modifications
listed in Part II of the Fokker Report.
Note 2: Compliance in accordance with Fokker Service Bulletin
F27/57-68, Revision 1, dated May 17, 1993, constitutes compliance
with Fokker Service Bulletin F27/57-68, dated July 17, 1992, which
is referenced in the Fokker Report.-
Note 3: The modifications required by this paragraph do not
terminate the inspection requirements of any other AD unless that AD
specifies that any such modification constitutes terminating action
for that inspection requirement.
(b) For airplanes that have accumulated 30,000 total landings or
more as of the threshold specified in Fokker Service Bulletin F27/
57-68, Revision 1, dated May 17, 1993, referenced in the Fokker
Report: The incorporation threshold for accomplishing the structural
modification may be extended to January 1, 1996, if an x-ray
inspection of the stringers at stations 11260, 12660, and 13460 is
performed in accordance with Part 2 of Fokker Service Bulletin F27/
57-68, Revision 1, dated May 17, 1993, at the time specified in
either paragraph (b)(1) or (b)(2) of this AD, as applicable. If
cracking is detected, prior to further flight, repair in accordance
with paragraph 1.D.(1)(c) of the service bulletin.-
(1) For airplanes on which the inspections of the top skin of
stringers 4 through 7 are currently being performed in accordance
with Part 2 of Fokker Service Bulletin F27/57-68, Revision 1, dated
May 17, 1993: Within 4,000 landings from the immediately preceding
inspection.-
(2) For airplanes on which the inspections of the top skin of
stringers 4 through 7 are not currently being performed in
accordance with Part 2 of Fokker Service Bulletin F27/57-68,
Revision 1, dated May 17, 1993: Within 2 months after the effective
date of this AD, -
(c) An alternative method of compliance or adjustment of the
compliance time that provides an acceptable level of safety may be
used if approved by the Manager, Standardization Branch, ANM-113,
FAA, Transport Airplane Directorate. Operators shall submit their
requests through an appropriate FAA Principal Maintenance Inspector,
who may add comments and then send it to the Manager,
Standardization Branch, ANM-113.
-Note 4: Information concerning the existence of approved
alternative methods of compliance with this AD, if any, may be
obtained from the Standardization Branch, ANM-113.
(d) Special flight permits may be issued in accordance with
sections 21.197 and 21.199 of the Federal Aviation Regulations (14
CFR 21.197 and 21.199) to operate the airplane to a location where
the requirements of this AD can be accomplished. -
(e) The structural modifications shall be done in accordance
with Fokker Report Number SE-278, ``F27 Aging Aircraft Project--
Final Document,'' Issue 3, dated February 1, 1993, which contains
the following list of effective pages:-
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Revision
Page number- level shown Date shown on page
on page-
------------------------------------------------------------------------
-1-3, II.3..................... 3 February 1, 1993.
4-7, I.2-I.14.................. 2 February 1, 1993.
I.1, I.15, I.16, II.1, II.2, 1 May 3, 1991.
II.4, III.1, III.2.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
APPENDIX A
------------------------------------------------------------------------
APP. A-1....................... 2 February 1, 1993.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
APPENDIX B
------------------------------------------------------------------------
1-13........................... 2 February 1, 1993.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
APPENDIX C
------------------------------------------------------------------------
1.............................. Original September 27, 1990.
2-5-........................... (These
pages are
not dated)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
APPENDIX D
------------------------------------------------------------------------
1-5-........................... Original February 1, 1993.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
APPENDIX E
------------------------------------------------------------------------
``Structural Maintenance May 22, 1991.-
Program Guidelines. . .''.
``Structural Maintenance May 22, 1991.
Program Task. . .''.
Table of Contents.............. May 22, 1991.
1-17........................... Original May 22, 1991.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
This incorporation by reference was approved by the Director of
the Federal Register in accordance with 5 U.S.C. 552(a) and 1 CFR
part 51. Copies may be obtained from Fokker Aircraft USA, Inc., 1199
North Fairfax Street, Alexandria, Virginia 22314. Copies may be
inspected at the FAA, Transport Airplane Directorate, 1601 Lind
Avenue, SW., Renton, Washington; or at the Office of the Federal
Register, 800 North Capitol Street, NW., suite 700, Washington, DC.-
(f) This amendment becomes effective on February 3, 1995.
Issued in Renton, Washington, on December 19, 1994.
Darrell M. Pederson,
Acting Manager, Transport Airplane Directorate, Aircraft Certification
Service.
[FR Doc. 95-51 Filed 1-3-95; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 4910-13-U
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.