Airworthiness Directives; Boeing Model 727 Series Airplanes Modified in Accordance With Supplemental Type Certificate ST00015AT

FederalRegulations

Ask Donna

How this section applies to your facts.

Federal Register › Vol. 64 › 64 FR 2038

This text was captured on Sep 30, 2026. It is a snapshot, not a live feed, so check the official code before relying on it.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

Federal Aviation Administration

14 CFR Part 39

[Docket No. 97-NM-80-AD; Amendment 39-10963; AD 98-26-20]

RIN 2120-AA64

Airworthiness Directives; Boeing Model 727 Series Airplanes

Modified in Accordance With Supplemental Type Certificate ST00015AT

AGENCY: Federal Aviation Administration, DOT.

ACTION: Final rule; technical public meeting.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: This amendment adopts a new airworthiness directive (AD),

applicable to certain Boeing Model 727 series airplanes that have been

converted from a passenger to a cargo-carrying (``freighter'')

configuration, that requires limiting the payload on the main cargo

deck by revising the Limitations Sections of all Airplane Flight

Manuals (AFM), AFM Supplements, and Airplane Weight and Balance

Supplements for these airplanes. This amendment also provides for the

submission of data and analyses that substantiate the strength of the

main cargo deck, or modification of the main cargo deck, as optional

terminating action for these payload restrictions. This amendment is

prompted by the FAA's determination that under certain conditions

unreinforced floor structure of the main cargo deck is not strong

enough to enable the airplane to safely carry the maximum payload that

is currently allowed in this area. The actions specified by this AD are

intended to prevent failure of the floor structure, which could lead to

loss of the airplane.

DATES: Effective February 16, 1999.

The public meeting will be held January 20, 1999, at 9:00 a.m., in

Seattle, Washington. Registration will begin at 8:30 a.m. on the day of

the meeting.

ADDRESSES: Information concerning this amendment may be obtained from

or examined at the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), Transport

Airplane Directorate, Rules Docket, 1601 Lind Avenue, SW., Renton,

Washington, by appointment only between the hours of 8:00 a.m. and 2:00

p.m.

The public meeting will be held at the following location: The

Radisson Hotel, 17001 Pacific Highway South, Seattle, Washington 98188;

telephone (206) 244-6000.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Questions concerning the airworthiness

directive should be directed to Michael O'Neil, Aerospace Engineer,

Airframe Branch, ANM-120L, FAA, Transport Airplane Directorate, Los

Angeles Aircraft Certification Office, 3960 Paramount Boulevard,

Lakewood, California 90712; telephone (562) 627-5320; fax (562) 627-

5210.

Requests to present a statement at the public meeting regarding the

logistics of the meeting should be directed to Mike Zielinski, Federal

Aviation Administration, Northwest Mountain Region, Transport Airplane

Directorate, ANM-113, 1601 Lind Avenue, SW, Renton, Washington 98055-

4056; telephone (425) 227-2279; fax (425) 227-1149.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: A proposal to amend part 39 of the Federal

Aviation Regulations (14 CFR part 39) to include an airworthiness

directive (AD) that is applicable to certain Boeing Model 727 series

airplanes that have been converted from a passenger to a cargo-carrying

(``freighter'') configuration was published in the Federal Register on

July 15, 1997 (62 FR 37788). At the same time, the FAA issued three

other similar notices of proposed rulemaking (NPRM's) to address

airplanes similarly converted in accordance with STC's held by FedEx,

Aeronautical Engineers, Inc., and Pemco. That action proposed to

require limiting the payload on the main cargo deck by revising the

Limitations Sections of all Airplane Flight Manuals (AFM), AFM

Supplements, and Airplane Weight and Balance Supplements for these

airplanes. That action also proposed to provide for the submission of

data and analyses that substantiate the strength of the main cargo

deck, or modification of the main cargo deck, as optional terminating

action for these payload restrictions.

On February 4, 1998, in order to obtain additional public

participation in these NPRM's, the FAA reopened the comment period for

a period of 90 days and scheduled two sets of public meetings, which

were held in Seattle, Washington, on February 18 and 19, 1998, and

April 1 and 2, 1998. In addition to the comments submitted during the

original comment period, the comments that were provided at the public

meetings and submitted to the Rules Dockets during the reopened comment

period also are discussed below.

Comments

Interested persons have been afforded an opportunity to participate

in the making of this amendment. Due consideration has been given to

the comments received.

The FAA has received comments in response to the four NPRM's

discussed previously (i.e., Docket No.'s 97-NM-09-AD, 97-NM-79-AD, 97-

NM-80-AD, and 97-NM-81-AD). Some of these comments addressed only one

NPRM, while others addressed all four. For example, although the

comments submitted by FedEx address only the NPRM applicable to its

STC's (i.e., Docket No. 97-NM-09-AD), other commenters referenced

FedEx's comments and requested that those comments be considered in the

context of the other three NPRM's, as well. Because in most cases the

issues raised by the commenters are generally relevant to all four

NPRM's, each final rule includes a discussion of all comments received.

Existence of Unsafe Condition

Several commenters disagree with the FAA's finding of an unsafe

condition and refer to the following statement in the NPRM's, ``[a]

design which does not meet [certification] standards is presumed to be

unsafe.'' The commenters contend that, while this statement is

``convenient,'' the FAA is still obliged to issue the AD in accordance

with 14 CFR part 39. In accordance with part 39, prior to the issuance

of an AD, the FAA must establish that an unsafe condition exists in a

product and that this condition is likely to exist in other products of

the same type design.

From this comment, the FAA infers that the commenters believe the

proposed AD is merely a consequence of non-compliance with Civil Air

Regulations (CAR) part 4b, which are the design standards to which the

Model 727 was certificated, and that the unsafe condition has not been

substantiated. The FAA does not concur. The context of the quoted

statement in the NPRM's was an explanation of the FAA's method used in

the design review that led to issuance of the NPRM's. Initially, the

FAA had identified the potential non-compliance based on observation

and review of original certification data. Since, in accordance with

the Federal Aviation Act, CAR part 4b standards establish the minimum

level of safety, the FAA considered that further evaluation was

necessary and appropriate to determine whether this potential non-

compliance created an unsafe condition warranting an AD. As explained

in the NPRM's, the FAA determined not only that the design was non-

compliant, but that the degree of non-compliance was highly

significant, and resulted in substantial negative structural margins of

safety. The FAA's analysis addressed the ``up'' load case, which was

considered to be the most likely critical load case, in the sense that

it was likely to be the load case that would present the most serious

negative margins of safety. The analysis verified these negative

margins and confirmed the FAA's concerns that serious negative margins

may exist for other load cases, as well. The effect of these

substantial negative margins is that the likelihood of catastrophic

failure of the floor structure is unacceptably high. The FAA's finding

of unsafe condition arises from this determination rather than from a

finding of non-compliance with CAR part 4b.

Risk From Actual Operations

Several commenters state that the FAA's finding of an unsafe

condition in the NPRM's is incorrect because, based on the way the

airplanes are actually loaded and operated, the likelihood of

encountering conditions specified in CAR part 4b that would exceed the

strength of the floor structure is extremely improbable.

The FAA does not concur. The FAA's evaluation was based on the

potential for a catastrophic event occurring as a result of an airplane

encountering severe gust conditions while transporting containers

loaded with maximum allowable payloads. (Unless otherwise stated,

throughout the preamble of this AD the FAA uses the term ``container''

to refer to all unit load devices, including pallets.) The fact that

operators may transport containers with maximum payloads only for a

small percentage of their operations does not diminish the seriousness

of the unsafe condition when they do transport such containers. (It

should be noted that one commenter stated that its operations with even

one container at maximum allowable payload are only a small percentage

of its total operations, but also stated that it engages in such

operations daily.)

In addition, the FAA disagrees with the commenters' conclusions

regarding the probability of catastrophic events. The events that may

cause a catastrophic failure occur randomly and, thus, cannot be

reliably predicted and avoided for any particular operation. Although

the probability of large gusts or excessive maneuvers (as specified in

CAR part 4b) is low (approximately once in the lifetime of an airplane

for a large gust), because of the large negative margins of safety

associated with these unreinforced floor structure designs (discussed

in the NPRM's), less severe events (i.e., lower gusts or milder

maneuvers) also could result in catastrophic failure. Therefore,

because the likelihood of encountering

less severe events is significantly greater than the likelihood of

encountering the events contemplated by CAR part 4b standards, and

because the consequences of such encounters may be catastrophic, the

FAA considers that the risk is unacceptable.

During the public meetings, several commenters suggested using

analytical methods developed to show compliance with 14 CFR 25.1309 in

assessing risks from gust loads. Their position was that if such

analysis were performed, it would demonstrate that the unsafe condition

addressed by the proposed AD is ``extremely improbable;'' therefore, an

AD is unnecessary to address it.

The FAA does not concur. The purpose of section 25.1309 is to

require that type certificate applicants demonstrate the robustness of

the airplane systems and equipment. Therefore, it is not applicable to

the assessment of the seriousness of an unsafe condition associated

with identified structural deficiencies. Nevertheless, assuming that it

is appropriate, section 25.1309(a) states that the airplane systems,

equipment, and installations ``must be designed to ensure that they

perform their intended functions under any foreseeable operating

condition.'' This means that the airplane must function properly if it

is being operated within its approved operating and environmental

conditions. As discussed in the NPRM's, the FAA's analysis demonstrates

that the affected airplanes, when operated with allowable payload

weights and distributions (which is foreseeable), could experience

catastrophic failure if they encounter gust conditions that are also

foreseeable. Therefore, applying the analytical methods of section

25.1309(a), these STC designs would be found not to comply.

In addition, section 25.1309(b) requires that any system failure

condition that would result in a catastrophic event be shown to be

extremely improbable, even if the system failure occurred concurrently

with environmental conditions that would reduce the capability of the

airplane or the ability of the crew to cope with the system failure.

Probabilistic analyses are used to demonstrate compliance with section

25.1309(b) by estimating the probability of random system and equipment

failures occurring on the airplane. The consequences of failures that

are more probable must be shown to be relatively minor; failures with

more serious consequences must be shown to have lower probabilities.

However, in providing guidance for compliance with this requirement,

Advisory Circular (AC) No. 25.1309-1A advises: ``In any system or

subsystem, the failure of any single element, component or connection

during any one flight * * * should be assumed, regardless of

probability. Such single failures should not prevent continued safe

flight and landing * * *.''

Applying this analytical method to the circumstances of this AD, if

the failure of the floor beam is assumed, the consequences are likely

to be catastrophic, preventing continued safe flight and landing.

Therefore, under the analytical approaches of either section 25.1309(a)

or (b), the operations with understrength floors without limitations is

unacceptable.

During the reopened comment period, FedEx submitted a risk

assessment from which it concluded that, even assuming the NPRM

identified a potential unsafe condition, the probability of occurrence

was sufficiently small (i.e., once every 300 years) so that AD action

should be postponed until additional testing and analysis has been

completed. Other commenters referenced this analysis and supported

FedEx's conclusion.

The FAA has evaluated the risk assessment submitted to Rules Docket

No. 97-NM-09-AD, and does not concur with the commenters' conclusion.

Regarding the general relevance of the kind of risk assessment

submitted by the commenter, it should be noted that the probability of

the limit gust event has already been considered when establishing the

gust intensities specified in CAR section 4b.211(b). CAR part 4b

requires that all airplanes be capable of structurally withstanding a

gust of the intensities specified therein, as such a gust is expected

to occur at some time in the airplane's operating life.

Regarding the specific data presented in the FedEx risk assessment,

the FAA does not concur with the assumption that extreme gusts will be

encountered by a cargo carrying Boeing Model 727 airplane only once in

5 million flight hours. As its basis for this assumption, the commenter

states that ``FAA data indicate that, in approximately 50 million

flight-hours of experience among US domestic 727s, there have been five

pilot reports of extreme gusts that exceeded federal thresholds for

danger.'' The commenter states that this equates to a rate of

occurrence of approximately once every 10 million flights. The

commenter also states that due to potential errors, it would be

conservative to double this rate to 10 total events, and use an

estimate of 1 occurrence per 5 million hours.

The FAA does not concur with the commenter's statement that FAA

data show that only five cases of extreme gust have been encountered by

the U.S. 727 fleet. Turbulence events must be reported only if they

result in detected airplane damage or passenger injuries. During

certain gust events, the gust loads encountered in the cockpit are

substantially less severe than those encountered in the aft portion of

the airplane. Therefore, some large gust encounters may not ``feel''

very severe to the flight crew. As a result, the FAA recognizes that

not all severe turbulence events are reported. Further, in the NPRM's,

the FAA provided five cases of turbulence as examples, to illustrate

that turbulence is a real occurrence, and not merely theoretical. These

five examples were obtained from data showing 87 reported severe

turbulence events, which resulted in passenger injuries, on the Boeing

727 from 1966 to March 1997. The FAA selected the five reports because

the airplane operators had reported the magnitude of the turbulence

event after obtaining this information from the flight data recorder.

Operators are not required to obtain data regarding the magnitude of

the turbulence event, and therefore it is rarely reported.

During the public meeting held on Thursday, February 19, 1998, the

FAA explained that these turbulence cases were just examples and had

been selected because the reports included information regarding event

magnitude. The FAA further explained at that meeting that it was

inappropriate to use these data in a probabilistic analysis. The

commenter's risk assessment provides no information to change the FAA's

views.

A section of the commenter's report states, ``Detailed equations

that combine empirical evidence and physical theory estimate how

frequently gusts of different magnitudes arise at different

altitudes.'' The commenter states that its calculations indicate that

gusts with intensities that equal or exceed 50 feet per second are

encountered once per 50 million flight hours at 35,000 feet. The report

does not provide the equations themselves, does not describe the

methodology used to determine the 1 in 50 million flight hours

probability value, and does not specifically identify the referenced

source data. Therefore, the FAA cannot assess the validity of the

commenter's conclusions.

The commenter also refers to graphs contained in a 1988 American

Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics (AIAA) publication by

Frederic M. Hoblit that the commenter states indicate even lower

encounter rates for gusts during

climb and descent. The FAA has examined this publication, and does not

concur with the commenter's statements regarding these data. First, the

commenter appears to be incorrectly referencing the graphs, which

represent continuous turbulence, and not discrete gusts, as provided in

CAR 4b. The two types of atmospheric disturbances are different, and to

reference these graphs is inappropriate. Secondly, the commenter's risk

assessment only addresses gusts ``that exceed the Federal threshold''

(which the FAA infers to mean limit load gusts) in combination with

cargo loads with two adjacent containers having a total weight that

equals or exceeds 9,600 lbs. This approach is unconservative. As

discussed in the NPRM, the cargo floor has a high negative margin of

safety, and the risk of structural collapse exists at gust intensities

well below the limit gust load when carrying currently allowed payloads

above 9,600 lbs. The greater the weight being carried in the container,

the lower the gust needed to cause catastrophic failure of the floor.

The lower the gust intensity, the more common the gust occurrence

becomes.

Based on the foregoing, the FAA has determined that the risk

assessment submitted by FedEx does not provide a basis for delaying the

final rule.

One group of commenters, identifying themselves as airmen for one

of the affected operators, supports issuance of the final rule, as

proposed. The commenters state that they do not have procedures to

avoid clear air turbulence, and based on their knowledge, if any of

them had encountered a similar wind condition to that experienced by a

Boeing 747 in January 1998, their airplane would ``come apart, in-

flight.''

The FAA concurs that there is no reliable means to forecast or to

avoid clear air turbulence. The flight conditions encountered by the

referenced 747 could be very hazardous to one of the affected airplanes

if encountered while critically loaded with heavy containers.

Change in Applicable Standards

Several commenters state that the NPRM's reflect a radical change

in the assumptions that certificate holders are permitted to use to

substantiate the main deck floor structure. The FAA does not concur. As

discussed below, the FAA's analysis is consistent with the applicable

CAR part 4b standards, which became effective in 1953.

``Infinitesimal Probability''

One commenter states that the proposed AD would impose unnecessary

costs which would then be passed to its customers, for what the FAA's

Director of Aircraft Certification Service has stated is an

``infinitesimal probability of a safety related happening.'' The

referenced comment is contained in an article in the April 15, 1997,

issue of ``Commercial Aviation Report.''

From this comment, the FAA infers that the commenter believes the

reference to ``infinitesimal probability'' belies the need for an AD.

The commenter has taken the remark out of context. The actual quote is,

``What is the probability of it [catastrophe] happening in the next

month? Infinitesimal.'' This remark was made in response to a question

regarding why the FAA was issuing an NPRM rather than an emergency AD.

The Director of the Aircraft Certification Service was explaining that,

although the FAA had determined that the unsafe condition must be

addressed by issuance of an AD, the urgency of the issue was not so

great as to preclude the normal legally required process of providing

public notice and opportunity to comment.

Accident Data

One commenter states that the fact that no crashes have occurred

with the affected airplanes has nothing whatsoever to do with these

airplanes being of a safe design. They merely have had the good fortune

to have not yet encountered a critical condition. The FAA concurs.

``Erroneous Certification''

One commenter states that it counted on the competence of the FAA

when obtaining the affected airplanes, as the cargo modifications were

FAA-approved. The commenter further states that the FAA's error in

issuing these approvals is going to severely hurt small operators of

these airplanes, who are neither culpable nor negligent. While the FAA

understands that the impact of this AD may be significant for some

operators, the FAA cannot ignore the fact that an unsafe condition

exists that requires action to ensure the continued operational safety

of the fleet. If the FAA had been aware of these deficiencies at the

time of the original STC issuance, the FAA would not have issued the

STC's.

One commenter points out that the FAA design review team observed

that the original passenger floor beams had not been structurally

reinforced, and that this fact is immediately apparent from the

technical drawings associated with the STC. The commenter questions why

the FAA has not expressed any concern or noticed these facts earlier.

The applicant for any design approval is responsible for compliance

with all applicable FAA regulations. The FAA has the discretion to

review or otherwise evaluate the applicant's compliance to the degree

the FAA considers appropriate in the interest of safety. The normal

certification process allows for the review and approval of data by FAA

designees. Consequently, the FAA office responsible for the

certification of an airplane or modification to an airplane or an

aeronautical appliance may not review all details regarding compliance

with the appropriate regulations. Also, the fact that the cargo floor

structure was unmodified does not necessarily lead to the conclusion

that the floors are structurally deficient. As explained in the NPRM,

the understrength floors on certain 747 airplanes converted to

freighters caused the FAA to question the adequacy of all STC-converted

passenger-to-freighter cargo floor structures. This AD arises from this

evaluation.

An FAA/Industry Team

Several commenters request that the FAA establish an industry team

comprised of the FAA, STC holders, and operators before issuing an AD

to establish the requirements and a corrective action plan to resolve

the problems with the STC's in a logical manner. One commenter states

that ``too much time has been spent going in different directions to

resolve common problems for all STC's,'' and that ``the FAA has not

been sufficiently clear in their requirements for the re-design.''

The FAA does not concur that issuance of the AD should be delayed.

An unsafe condition has been identified, and the FAA must take action

to ensure an acceptable level of safety of the affected fleet of

airplanes. The STC holders and operators are certainly free to form an

industry team to find common solutions, and the FAA is willing to

participate in such efforts. The FAA also does not concur that the

requirements for re-design are unclear; as the FAA has stated

repeatedly, the standards for evaluating proposed corrective actions

are the original certification basis for the airplane, CAR part 4b. Any

non-compliance with CAR part 4b would have to be shown to provide an

acceptable level of long-term safety.

FAA/Industry Communication

One commenter states that there has been ``virtually no opportunity

for technical exchange'' and, therefore, the FAA should delay issuance

of the final rule until such an exchange has taken

place. The FAA does not concur. Since as early as November 1996, the

STC holders have been made aware of the FAA's concerns regarding the

cargo floor structure. More specifically, meetings were held with each

of the affected STC holders in January 1997 to discuss further details

regarding FAA concerns.

On February 14, 1997, the FAA again discussed its concerns with the

affected industry and again requested that industry provide the FAA

with valid data to address those FAA concerns. Subsequently, over the

course of the next four months as the FAA prepared the NPRM's, only one

STC holder provided any data relative to the merits of the proposed

AD's, and that data did not alleviate the FAA's concerns. In response

to the NPRM's first comment period, three of the affected STC holders

did not submit technical data and, for reasons discussed below, the

data submitted by the fourth STC holder (FedEx) did not alleviate the

FAA's concerns. During the reopened comment period, the FAA engaged in

further extensive discussion with the affected industry and those

discussions continue in the context of on-going efforts to identify

necessary actions to address the unsafe condition. Based on this

history, the FAA considers that sufficient opportunity for technical

exchange has been provided and that further delay is unwarranted and

unnecessarily jeopardizes public safety.

Delay Issuance

Two commenters state that additional time is necessary so that the

airplanes would be removed from service only once to incorporate all

needed corrective actions (i.e., not only for the floors, but also for

other problems identified in the NPRM) due to the high cost of

incorporating partial solutions to the overall problem. One commenter

requests that all problems associated with the STC's be identified,

solutions provided, and methods for accomplishment of the solutions be

agreed upon prior to the issuance of any AD. The FAA does not concur.

In light of the seriousness of the unsafe condition, the FAA has

determined that it would first address the strength of the cargo floor

structure. All of the remaining issues will be addressed in future

rulemaking efforts. Even though this AD addresses only the cargo floor

structure, it should not inhibit industry from taking corrective action

with regard to the remaining issues. In fact, in order to minimize the

inefficiencies identified by the commenter, the FAA is committed to

working with industry to identify as expeditiously as possible

necessary corrective actions for all of the problems discussed in the

NPRM.

The Cargo Airline Association (CAA) requests that the FAA not adopt

an AD imposing interim limits. Since the CAA believes that the risk of

a catastrophic failure is ``virtually nonexistent,'' and since several

potential STC holders with varying solutions to issues raised are in

the process of working with FAA, scarce resources should be devoted to

ensuring expeditious approval of these proposals.

Another commenter requests that the FAA delay issuance of the final

rules until industry solutions are approved [estimating an additional

60 to 90 days for Israel Aircraft Industries (IAI) to complete its

analysis, as it has only recently had access to Boeing drawings]. The

commenter also states that the FAA rulemaking process has caused

industry to make significant progress and aggressively pursue solutions

that will likely meet with relatively prompt FAA approvals. The

commenter also states that although these approvals will result in a 25

percent reduction in allowable payload, it is willing to operate with

that limitation. This commenter, and several other commenters reference

the FedEx risk assessment, which purports to demonstrate a low

probability of catastrophic failure, as a basis for delaying the final

rules.

Another commenter requests 4 to 6 months for completion of certain

industry tests and risk analysis, as the 3-month timetable for the

reopened comment period was not adequate, due to the highly complex and

time-consuming nature of testing and evaluation procedures.

For the reasons discussed above under the heading ``Risk From

Actual Operations,'' the FAA does not agree that the risk assessment

submitted by FedEx warrants delaying this rulemaking. Furthermore, the

FAA does not agree that correction of the unsafe condition can be

assured within 60 to 90 days, or 4 to 6 months without this final rule.

The STC holders and many operators have been aware of this issue since

the fall of 1996. The FAA anticipates that, with the adoption of this

AD, industry will continue recent significant progress in addressing

these issues, which will result in timely implementation of appropriate

corrective action.

Extension of Interim Operational Period

Several commenters state that the proposed 120-day interim

allowances must have been determined to be safe by the FAA, with

positive margins of safety. Therefore, the commenters request that the

interim time limits be extended. Some of the commenters request that

the extension coincide with regularly scheduled heavy maintenance. The

CAA requests that the interim limits should be allowed to continue for

however long it takes to modify the airplanes to bring them up to the

original design limits. This commenter states that under normal

operations, there is no risk of floor beam failure, and also states

that the FedEx risk assessment shows that the likelihood of

encountering conditions set forth in the NPRM are virtually

nonexistent.

As discussed above under the heading ``Risk from Actual

Operations,'' the FAA does not concur that the information provided in

the FedEx risk assessment provides a basis for an extension of the

interim period. However, for other reasons, the FAA concurs that the

interim operational period can be extended.

In the NPRM, the FAA stated, ``because the determination of the

effects of operational limitations on payload is based on

approximations, the resulting payload limits may be unconservative.''

The 120-day interim limit was based on this potential unconservatism.

Since issuance of the NPRM, the FAA has received data (Reports DFE-

72701 and DFE-72702, submitted during the initial comment period as

Appendices 5 and 6 to FedEx's comments to the NPRM) that partially

confirm these approximations. In addition, although some progress has

been made by industry in developing corrective actions, neither

industry's proposal (as discussed in the NPRM) nor the FAA's

expectations have been fulfilled. Based on current information

regarding the status of various efforts to develop corrective actions,

the FAA estimates that the entire affected fleet can incorporate

corrective actions during scheduled heavy maintenance within 28 months

after the effective date of this AD. In light of this new information,

the FAA has reassessed the proposed interim period of 120 days and

concluded that the period should be extended to 28 months. Therefore,

the FAA has revised the final rule accordingly.

The FAA's decision to extend the interim limitations does not imply

that the cargo floor structure has been determined by the FAA to be

safe for an indefinite period, or in compliance with CAR part 4b

requirements. As stated in the NPRM, the FAA's analysis considered only

the most likely critical load case, and the proposed interim

limitations were based on that analysis. The confirming data referenced

above still does not address other potential critical load cases or all

locations within

the airplane. Nevertheless, in light of the balance of the safety and

economic factors discussed above, the FAA considers that the level of

safety provided by the interim limitations is adequate for the time

period of 28 months. However, it is less than the level of safety

provided by demonstrated compliance with CAR part 4b standards, and the

FAA considers that compliance with those standards is a necessary

objective to ensure the long term safety of the affected fleet. The

balancing that the FAA has considered in establishing this interim

compliance period is typical of the balancing that occurs in all AD's

establishing interim requirements and is fully consistent with the

FAA's obligation to consider economic impacts, such as those imposed by

Executive Order 12866.

Increased Interim Payload Limits

Several commenters also request that, due to ``highly

conservative'' methodologies used by FAA, the proposed interim weight

limit should be expanded to allow an average maximum container weight

of 6,000 lbs. The FAA does not concur that its methodologies are highly

conservative. As discussed in the NPRM and in more detail below, the

FAA's analytical methods are typical of industry practice, and the

commenters have not demonstrated how these methods are highly

conservative. The FAA has not been provided with any acceptable data to

support the allowance for 6,000-lb. containers, except as discussed

below under the heading ``Position-by-Position Limitations.'' A

commenter requests that the FAA maximize the interim limits. The FAA

concurs that the interim limits should be maximized to the extent that

they are consistent with the necessity of addressing the unsafe

condition. The FAA considers that the interim limits established in the

final rule meet this objective; however, as discussed below, the FAA

will continue to work to approve higher limitations, once their safety

is substantiated.

Federal Express submitted report 98-026 ``Substantiation of Side

Vertical Cargo Restraint Installation Using Static Test Results,''

Revision A, during the reopened comment period. FedEx states that this

report ``proves conclusively that the side restraint installation is

adequate to restrain the applied container loads due to vertical

gust.'' The FAA concurs, and has changed the final rule (Rules Docket

No. 97-NM-09-AD) applicable to the FedEx STC's to allow the higher

interim limits with the FedEx side restraints installed.

Position-by-Position Limitations

The CAA requests that the FAA consider ``position-by-position''

limitations, which would establish individual weight limits for each

container position on the airplane, based on the strength of the floor

structure at that location. The CAA states that this would allow a

higher total payload, while addressing the unsafe condition. The FAA

concurs with the concept of position-by-position limitations, and will

consider any such proposal when presented with supporting data.

For example, one commenter, Amerijet, has submitted a position-by-

position proposal, which includes analysis providing for increased

weights for certain container positions relative to those determined by

the FAA for the interim period. This proposal also contained lower

limits for other container positions and presupposes the installation

of sidelocks. The commenter stated at the April 2 public meeting that

it intends to install vertical side restraints [sidelocks], but has not

submitted any data to the FAA on a sidelock installation. The FAA has

determined that this proposal would provide an acceptable level of

safety for the 28-month interim period, when the affected airplanes are

equipped with approved sidelocks. The commenter's proposal would not be

acceptable to the FAA for indefinite operations, however, as the

analysis did not consider other issues such as CAR part 4b emergency

landing loads. The FAA will continue to work with the commenter, or any

other interested parties, to refine these proposals so that they may be

approved under paragraph (f) or (g) of the final rule.

FedEx also submitted a position-by-position proposal, which also

contained both higher and lower limits as compared to the FAA's

proposed interim limits. FedEx's proposal also is promising, however,

its analysis is based on assumptions which the FAA has determined to be

inaccurate, given the limitations of the weight and balance manual. For

example, FedEx's assumption for the percentage of the load distributed

to the sidelocks (40 percent) was derived from its ``Inverted Container

Test.'' As discussed below under the heading ``FedEx's Tests,'' the FAA

considers this assumption to be unconservative. The FAA also will

continue to work with FedEx to refine its proposal, so that it may be

approved under paragraph (f) or (g) of the final rule.

The CAA also submitted a finite element analysis (FEA) and, based

on this analysis, requested that the final rule allow interim container

payload limitations (regardless of whether sidelocks are installed) of

approximately 3,500 lbs. in the most forward and aft positions, and

8,000 lbs. over the wing and wheel well. All other positions would be

limited to 4,800 lbs. per container position with no sidelocks

installed, and 5,000 lbs. with sidelocks installed. The CAA also

requested that, after unspecified frame modifications are incorporated

and sidelocks installed, interim limitations of 6,000 lbs. per

container be allowed. Three other commenters submitted similar

proposals.

As stated previously, the FAA is willing to work with commenters to

establish interim limits other than those established in the final

rule. However, the data submitted with the comment do not establish

that the model used in CAA's FEA accurately represents the airplane.

The CAA states that the model was made using the Boeing Structural

Repair Manual (SRM) and various unspecified measurements of the

airplane, but without access to the type design data that define the

airplane configuration. It is, therefore, based on numerous assumptions

regarding the configuration, which have not been validated.

Furthermore, the model purports only to represent a 120-inch long

section of the fuselage. The model does not account for the numerous

fuselage cutouts for cargo and passenger doors, which affect the way

the floor structure reacts to loads. Also, the model does not address

the different structural design of the wing box or wheel well areas.

Even if it were assumed that the model is accurate for some

airplanes, it is based on the cargo container locations used by FedEx,

which are different from those of the other affected airplanes. The

positions of the containers and locks determine the loads introduced

into the floor beams. Therefore, using the FedEx container layout

produces a result which, even if valid, would be only applicable to the

FedEx airplanes. Based on the foregoing, the FAA does not consider that

the model provides a sufficient basis for revising the interim limits.

Several commenters state that the FAA's findings of negative

margins of safety are too conservative over the wing box and wheel

well, as these areas are capable of supporting higher container

payloads due to their stronger design. The FAA concurs partially. The

FAA has determined that an unsafe condition exists by analyzing the

basic floor structure rather than the much more complex wheel well or

wing box

structure. These areas are capable of supporting greater loads, but the

commenters have submitted insufficient data to determine what loads may

be safe in these areas.

However, the FAA has issued STC's which substantiate the wing box

and wheel well areas for payload capabilities equivalent to the

carriage of 6,000- to 10,000-lb. containers, depending on the

individual airplane's structural capability, which has increased as the

727's type design has evolved. The FAA notes that, although no

structural reinforcement was added to the wing box and wheel well for

these STC's, limitations were sometimes imposed in consideration of the

individual airplane's structural capability.

The FAA has considered the greater strength of the wing box and

wheel well and has determined that an acceptable level of safety will

be achieved by allowing a total payload of 12,000 lbs. for any two

adjacent containers in this area, without other limitations, for the

28-month interim period. To eliminate potential ambiguity as to the

containers to which this limitation applies, the final rule specifies

that this alternative limitation applies to containers located

completely or partially between body stations (BS) 740 to 950. However,

the FAA does not consider that it is acceptable to allow combined

payloads above 12,000 lbs. for this interim period, or to allow 12,000-

lb. combined payloads indefinitely, because the FAA does not have the

detailed information or resources necessary to determine the

appropriate payload and operational limitations for all configurations

of the affected airplanes. Operators who desire further increased

loading in this area are invited to submit their requests and

supporting data to the FAA in accordance with paragraph (f) or (g) of

this AD.

Paragraph (a) of the NPRM did include a limited position-by-

position proposal, in that it specified a reduced payload limitation in

the area of the cargo door (BS 440 to BS 660). As with the wing box and

wheel well area, to eliminate potential ambiguity as to the containers

to which this limitation applies, the final rule specifies that this

limitation applies to containers located completely or partially

between BS 440 and BS 660.

Extension of Initial Compliance Time

One commenter states that the NPRM's will ``wreak havoc'' on the

express industry and shipping public. The commenter states that it has

no way of knowing when the effective date of the AD will be. The 48-

hour implementation of the load limits will inevitably result in

serious disruption to cargo already booked or in transit when the final

AD's are issued. Several other commenters requested 120 days after AD

issuance for interim limits to become effective, as this time was

necessary to alter manuals, provide personnel training, and generally

prepare for a significantly different loading procedure. The FAA

concurs partially. The FAA has changed the final rule to extend the

compliance time from 48 hours to 90 days. The AD becomes effective 35

days after the date of publication in the Federal Register. As

requested by the commenters, this allows a total of 125 days for

operators to make necessary changes to the FAA-approved Airplane Flight

Manual and cargo loading procedures.

All Container Types

Several commenters state that the proposed AD should address the

use of all possible containers, pallets, and the intermixing of pallets

and containers. Other commenters followed with similar statements about

pallets, bulk loading, oversized cargo, and combi configurations (i.e.,

configurations with provisions for passenger seating and cargo on the

main deck). One of the commenters requests that the wording of the

proposed AD be changed to contain generalized wording that would

address all container sizes, using a ratio of the length and width of

other containers to the 88- by 125-inch container specified in the

proposed AD as a means to determine the container payload limit. The

commenter further states that this could help the implementation of the

rule. The commenters request these changes to avoid the disruption that

might result from having to obtain individual approvals for each of the

types of containers.

The FAA concurs partially. In light of the administrative burden of

approving individual container types, the FAA has reassessed this

proposed requirement. The FAA recognizes that, except for half-size

containers (discussed below), the FAA analysis used to establish the

payload limits for containers measuring 88 by 125 inches also is

applicable to any container within the same floor area. The reasons are

that the analysis considered the effect of the container weight on the

floor structure supporting the container, and that the differences in

the stresses in the floor structure associated with the different

container types are not sufficient to warrant different limits.

Therefore, the FAA has revised the final rule to specify the same

limitations for container size codes ``A,'' ``B,'' and ``C,'' as

defined in National Aerospace Standard (NAS) 3610, which is the

specification referenced in FAA's Technical Standard Order (TSO) C90c

for cargo unit load devices (containers).

For half-size containers (i.e., size code ``D'' or ``E'' of NAS

3610, or the FedEx ``Demi'' container), the final rule specifies

payload limits that are one-half those for other containers. Since

these half-size containers are designed to be placed side-by-side

across the fuselage, this separate limit is necessary to ensure proper

load distribution within the area. It should be noted that paragraph

(g) of the final rule allows operators to establish different container

payload limits from those specified in the rule by substantiating that

those limits provide an acceptable level of safety.

For oversize cargo, operators may apply for approval of alternative

methods of compliance in accordance with paragraph (f) or (g) of the AD

by proposing appropriate limitations for such cargo.

Service History

One commenter claims that, for the converted 727 freighters,

``successful flight history is direct evidence which supports [the

commenter's] analysis showing the airplanes to be safe.'' The commenter

references CAR sections 4b.202, 4b.270, and 4b.300 to show that service

history is a reliable indicator ``to support or define a substantiation

methodology.''

The FAA does not concur. The requirements of CAR part 4b that the

commenter references are related to the determination of the fatigue

strength of structure, where it is acceptable to utilize the service

history of airplanes of similar structural design. However, the unsafe

condition addressed in this AD is not related to fatigue, but is the

result of the existing floor structure being significantly

understrength. The only conclusion that can be drawn analytically from

the accumulated flight history of the converted 727 freighters is that

these airplanes have yet to encounter a sufficiently severe gust

condition when critically loaded with an allowable payload

configuration to cause failure of the floor structure.

Deflection of Floor Beams

One commenter states that the FAA did not provide a reasoned

explanation of the NPRM claim that ``even if the floor beams of the

main cargo deck only become deformed, the results could be

catastrophic.'' The commenter compares this statement to McDonnell

Douglas Report MDC-J5568, applicable to Model DC-10 series airplanes,

which was approved by the FAA and showed

significant and permanent deformation of the wing.

From this comment, the FAA infers that the commenter believes that,

if the wing can bend safely and even deform permanently when it has

cables/fuel lines, etc., passing through the structure, then the floor

beams also must be capable of safely deforming or bending.

The FAA does not concur. The NPRM states why deformation of the

floor beams could be catastrophic. For the ``up'' load case analyzed by

the FAA, which consisted of ``up'' loads applied to the containers due

to a down gust on the airplane, the floor beams common to the forward

and aft locks of a container bend upward due to the applied upward

load. The adjacent floor beams underneath the containers that are not

attached to the container do not bend. If this deflection relative to

the adjacent floor beams is excessive, this could result in the bending

and stretching of all control cables and fuel lines passing through the

floor beams. Such bending and stretching could result in uncommanded

flight control inputs at a critical time when the airplane is subject

to severe gust conditions. In addition, the fuel lines located in the

floor beams are not designed to flex in the same manner as fuel lines

located in the wing structure of an airplane and, therefore, may crack,

bend, or rupture.

The occurrence of either an uncommanded flight control input during

critical flight conditions or the rupture of a fuel line can be

catastrophic. The McDonnell Douglas report referenced by the commenter

is not applicable to the floor beam deflections of a 727 converted

freighter since the fuel lines and control cables located in the wing

of Model DC-10 series airplanes are specifically designed to

accommodate large wing deflections and are in compliance with the

applicable regulations.

Safety Factor

One commenter states that the use of a safety factor as small as

1.5 presupposes very accurate analysis, knowledge of loads and material

properties, and sound engineering practices. Structure with negative

margins of safety of -0.63 clearly indicates that some or all of these

suppositions have not been achieved. In addition, some operating

conditions, such as gusts, are beyond human control. The safety factor

of 1.5, as required by CAR part 4b, is necessary to maintain the safety

of the airplanes. The FAA concurs with the commenter, but notes that

the finding of unsafe condition in this AD is based on the FAA's

determination that the risk of catastrophic failure of the

understrength floor structure is unacceptably high, rather than on a

simple finding of non-compliance with CAR part 4b.

Fore and Aft Center Of Gravity Shifts

Several commenters objected to the FAA's analytical use of the

trapezoidal method for evaluating shifts in the center of gravity (cg)

within a container. One commenter, FedEx, states that the FAA's use of

the trapezoidal shift results in impracticable--if not impossible--

circumstances that exceed the requirements of CAR section 4b.210.

In order to gain a better understanding of this and other FedEx

comments, the FAA met with FedEx on September 19, 1997, having first

provided FedEx with a series of questions to be discussed at the

meeting. (The minutes of this meeting are included in Rules Docket No.

97-NM-09-AD.) At this meeting, FedEx reported that it had only recently

obtained a scale that would allow it, for the first time, to determine

the actual locations of the cg's inside its containers. FedEx stated

that it had weighed and determined the cg location on a sampling of

1,500 containers, but did not provide any data to the FAA at the

meeting. In any case, the FAA does not consider it appropriate to

evaluate only an operator's average container payload when establishing

the safety of the affected airplanes. The unsafe condition determined

by the FAA's analysis is based on the payload weight and distribution

with which these airplanes are currently allowed to operate.

In addition, in a letter dated November 4, 1997, to the FAA (a copy

of which has been placed in Rules Docket No. 97-NM-09-AD), FedEx states

that ``A review of container weights, quadrant weights, and cg's for

the `SAA' (88- by 125-inch) container finds no containers in the 4,000

to 8,000 lb. range with a cg offset greater than 8.67%.'' However,

FedEx did not provide data (e.g., the numbers and types of containers

reviewed; the percentage of cg shift for different container weights)

to substantiate the value of 8.67 percent. Therefore, the FAA is unable

to determine the significance of this comment.

FedEx states that it chose to use a ``stair step'' or ``box''

method to evaluate the effects of cg shifts within a container. FedEx

also states that the FAA rejected this method for use on the 727

converted freighters without a reasoned explanation.

The FAA does not concur with the comments regarding the FAA's

methodology. As stated in the NPRM, the large negative margins of

safety calculated using the FAA's analysis included consideration of

the effect of a horizontal cg shift of 10 percent within the container

(e.g., 8.8 inches from the geometric center of the base of the

container for the forward and aft direction). Shifts in cg are

particularly important in considering the ``up'' load case because the

container loads are applied primarily to the floor beams at the forward

and aft edges of the container where the container locks are located.

The effect of the cg shift is to increase the loading on the beam in

the direction of the cg shift. For example, if the cg is shifted aft,

the applied loads will be increased on the floor beam located at the

aft edge of the container.

In analyzing the effects of forward or aft cg shifts, the FAA

employed a ``trapezoidal method.'' The trapezoidal method is well

accepted and used by both Type Certificate (TC) and STC holders. The

trapezoidal method is analogous to shifting sand in a box. With no cg

shift, the weight of the cargo is uniformly distributed across the base

of the container. As the cg is shifted, the load or ``sand'' is taken

from one side and applied to the other side. This results in a sloping

load distribution, with a load ``peak'' on one end of the container,

and a load ``valley'' on the other end. Another acceptable method for

considering forward or aft cg shifts is the ``box'' or ``stair step''

method. In this method, rather than sloping, the load ``steps'' up from

a low level on one end, to a high level on the other.

The FAA does not concur that the trapezoidal shift used in the

FAA's analysis exceeds the requirements of CAR section 4b.210. For

``up'' loads on the container, and a forward or aft cg shift (which the

FAA has identified as the most likely critical case), if the airplane

is not equipped with side vertical restraints (sidelocks), the results

of the loads analysis are the same regardless of whether the stair step

or trapezoidal method is used. Since all loads are carried by the floor

beams that support the forward and aft container locks, the loads on

the beams will be identical for any method that shifts the cg a

particular percentage within the container. It is the percentage of cg

shift that is important, not how that cg shift was achieved. This

represents the majority of the airplanes affected by these four AD's.

For those airplanes equipped with sidelocks, there is a maximum

difference of 14 percent in the two methods for ``up'' loads, at the

``peak'' of the trapezoid. In consideration of the varying locations of

sidelocks and the manner in which loads are actually distributed among

all locks, this difference does not

significantly affect the FAA's analysis or alter the finding of the

unsafe condition.

The FAA considered 10 percent as the appropriate amount to shift

the cg within the container, as it is realistic and typical of cg shift

limitations contained in operator weight and balance manuals.

Consideration of a 10 percent cg shift also represents an industry

standard as evidenced by NAS 3610 (contained in the Rules Dockets). The

vast majority of containers used by operators comply with this

standard. FedEx has not provided any data that indicate that a 10

percent cg shift is unreasonable, or that show that the FAA's use of a

trapezoidal shift is unrealistic. The data that FedEx provided (average

container densities ranging from 7 to 18 lb./cubic foot) concern only

the average weight of a container used in its operations and assumes

the weight to be equally distributed throughout the container.

FedEx also states that the trapezoidal method results in load

distributions that greatly exceed the 90 lb./inch ``running load''

(freight payload per inch of airplane floor length) limitation

specified in the FedEx weight and balance manual. FedEx states that the

trapezoidal shift method will result in possible freight densities of

40 lb./cubic foot in approximately 1/4 of the container volume. FedEx

states that this equates to an average value of over 200 lb./inch

running load in this area of the container. FedEx reports that its

daily average operational load density is approximately 7 to 7.5 lb./

cubic foot, and on rare occasions may have reached the 18 lb./cubic

foot range; therefore, the FAA's analysis bears no relationship to

operational reality. (An average density of 18 lb./cubic foot over the

entire volume for the full-size FedEx container equates approximately

to a 7,920-lb. container, or about 90 lb./inch running load.)

The FAA acknowledges that, in its analysis described in the NPRM,

it was not constrained by the 90 lb./running inch limitation specified

in the FedEx weight and balance manual. However, the FAA does not

concur that this results in inaccurate weight limits. The FAA notes

that, for a FedEx container at the maximum permitted payload of 8,000

lbs., the running load limit is exceeded even with no shift in the

container cg (88-inch container width times 90 lbs. per inch equals

7,920 lbs.). For any forward/aft cg shift within the container, using

either the trapezoidal or ``box'' method, the degree to which the limit

is exceeded increases in direct relation to the magnitude of the cg

shift.

In addition, the FAA reviewed FedEx's loading procedures during a

visit to its flight line at Sea-Tac International Airport, Seattle,

Washington, on February 5, 1997. During this review, the FAA became

aware that FedEx neither determines the actual cg location of the cargo

within each container nor has the necessary equipment at all of its

loading facilities to determine that it is operating within the cg and

running load limitations of its weight and balance manual.

Based on other comments received in response to the NPRM, it

appears that FedEx's practice is not unusual even though it is

inconsistent with its weight and balance manuals. In light of the fact

that, to the FAA's knowledge, no operators are measuring the cg's for

all containers, and that a recent sampling accomplished by FedEx shows

cg shifts as high as 8.67 percent, the FAA concludes that use of 10

percent cg shift in its analysis is not only an appropriate reflection

of industry cargo loading practice, but may actually be unconservative.

Finally, the FAA does not concur that it has rejected the use of

the ``box'' method proposed by FedEx. FedEx did not consider a cg shift

effect in the original substantiation documentation for its original

STC design, but later proposed to employ a ``box'' method used by

McDonnell Douglas for the certification of a DC-10 freighter (submitted

by FedEx as a comment during the first comment period in Appendix 2,

Report 97-028, Revision I/R, dated April 1, 1997). After review of this

method, the FAA accepted it in a meeting with FedEx on April 29, 1997.

The basis for this acceptance is that it provides an acceptable level

of conservatism in the absence of more rational data to predict the cg

within a container. As discussed above, the use of the ``box'' method

does not significantly affect the FAA's analysis or alter its finding

of an unsafe condition.

FAA's Methodology

Boeing states that the FAA's analysis is similar to that used by

Boeing for initial certification of Model 727 series airplanes.

However, Boeing also states that while the analysis is conventional,

some of the assumptions made are not typical of industry practice for

the floor beam analysis and are conservative relative to the original

certification practice of Boeing, with respect to trapezoidal loading

and credit for pressurization. Boeing states that, when it evaluates cg

offsets in containers, it uses the stepped rectangular or ``box''

method to determine cg shifts.

The FAA concurs partially. As explained previously, the trapezoidal

loading assumption is nominally more conservative than the stepped

rectangular or ``box method.'' For the ``up'' load case, this nominal

difference only affects those airplanes with sidelocks. In any case,

this difference does not significantly affect the FAA's analysis or

alter its finding of an unsafe condition.

The FAA does not concur that its analysis is inappropriately

conservative because it considered zero fuselage pressurization.

Fuselage pressurization tends to provide an increase in floor beam load

carrying capability because the pressurized fuselage, to which the ends

of the floor beams are attached, pulls outward on the ends of the floor

beams, which makes the floor beams act stiffer. Severe gust conditions,

such as microbursts, may be encountered at low altitudes when the

fuselage is not pressurized; therefore, it is realistic to consider

those conditions. Even with credit for fuselage pressurization, the

FAA's conclusion would be unchanged because the pressurization effects

do not significantly affect the substantial negative margins of safety

found as a result of the analysis. Furthermore, CAR section

4b.216(c)(1) requires that ``The airplane structure shall have

sufficient strength to withstand the flight loads combined with

pressure differential loads from zero up to the maximum relief valve

setting.''

Another commenter, FedEx, states that the FAA's analytical

techniques are too conservative and, therefore, result in artificially

low payload numbers (container weights) for the 727 converted

freighters. The FAA does not concur. The FAA reviewed the

substantiating data submitted for the original certification of FedEx's

727 freighter conversion STC and found that this data package lacked

any stress analysis substantiating the floor structure. Lacking this

data, the FAA reviewed the analytical methods used by others in

industry. The FAA determined that other industry analytical methods for

cargo systems used conservative overlapping assumptions to ensure that

the design resulted in a safe product that complied with CAR part 4b.

The FAA's decision to use these methods to perform an analysis of the

floor structure of the affected 727 converted freighters is consistent

with industry standard practices.

One commenter expresses concern over the methods utilized in the

structural substantiation of floor beam loads in the documentation

contained in these Rule Dockets, although the commenter did not

identify a basis for the concern. The commenter states that over the

course of the last two decades

it has developed stringent methods for accurately predicting cargo

induced loads in airplane structure. The commenter requests that the

FAA consider these methods in performing its evaluations. The commenter

submitted data regarding its analytical methodology used in development

of numerous STC approvals of cargo handling systems.

The FAA has reviewed the commenter's methods and considers that

this methodology utilized conservative, overlapping assumptions to

``bracket'' unknown variables and utilized a trapezoidal distribution

of cargo in defining its cg offsets. The FAA agrees that these are

appropriate methods for determining loads for cargo floor structure and

are consistent with those employed by the FAA. These methods result in

conclusions that are consistent with the FAA's findings that the floor

structure addressed by these AD's presents an unsafe condition.

Further, the FAA notes that these conclusions are consistent with those

derived from other methods commonly used in industry.

Boeing addresses the statement in the FAA's analysis of the floor

beam allowables (contained in the Rules Dockets) that the analysis is

``partial'' and ``unconservative.'' Boeing states that, for the

``down'' load case (i.e., ``down'' loads applied to the container), the

FAA's analysis is sufficiently conservative for the following reasons:

(1) the critical section selected for analysis reflects the worst case

hole-out situation; (2) all significant [down] load cases were dealt

with; (3) the critical section analyzed would have no degradation of

[safety] margins because of secondary bending effects; and (4) the

critical section analyzed has no shear on it by first principles and,

therefore, any shear interaction effects should be small.

The FAA concurs with the commenter's statement; however, the FAA

notes that this statement was carefully limited to apply to ``the down

load case being considered'' and does not address all load cases, the

actual strength of the floor, or the floor beam as a whole.

The FAA does not concur that the commenter's statement is valid for

all load cases and all floor beam structure. The FAA's statement that

the analysis is ``partial'' and ``unconservative'' relates to the fact

that there are many floor beams, several with differing applied loads,

load carrying capabilities, and critical cross-sections. As a result,

the FAA's analysis could not be considered complete (therefore

partial), nor could the FAA state that it had accounted for all

effects, which may result in yet higher stress levels and larger

negative margins of safety (therefore unconservative).

One commenter states that the standard being pursued by the FAA for

the converted 727 freighter includes all known theoretical

possibilities, plus an additional safety factor of indeterminate size.

The commenter refers to a statement in the NPRM that ``airplanes may

encounter severe turbulence that exerts wind gust forces beyond the

critical case forces of CAR part 4b * * *'' as implying that the FAA is

imposing standards beyond that of CAR part 4b.

The FAA does not concur. The FAA's analysis of the converted 727

freighter floor beams was accomplished using the standards identified

in CAR part 4b. No new standard is being applied to these airplanes.

The commenter has taken the NPRM statement out of context. The FAA's

reference to gusts that exceed CAR part 4b critical load cases is in a

portion of the NPRM that addresses the basis for the retention of the

1.5 factor of safety, which is required by CAR section 4b.200(a). This

factor is used to protect the airplane from failure when experiencing

limit load, the highest expected actual in-flight loading, and other

unknown situations.

As stated in the NPRM, interested parties had requested that the

FAA eliminate the safety factor during preparation of the NPRM, which

would allow higher payloads. The statement that the commenter

characterizes as implying ``new standards,'' and a safety factor of

``indeterminate size,'' was simply a discussion of the existing level

of safety established by the CAR part 4b standards (this airplane was

originally certificated to those standards over 30 years ago).

One commenter quotes from CAR section 4b.210 that the analysis must

be conducted using ``any practicable distribution of disposable

loads.'' The commenter states that the loading scenarios the FAA uses

are much higher than the maximum [loading] experienced in actual

service. Several other commenters characterize the FAA's assumptions

and analysis as ``ultra conservative.''

The commenters appear to have misinterpreted the referenced CAR

section 4b.210. The word ``practicable,'' which means possible to put

into practice, appears to be read as ``practical.'' Subpart C of CAR

part 4b requires that analysis be conducted for conditions (e.g.,

critical altitude, critical load, or maximum/minimum weight) that are

possible; Subpart C is not restricted to normal, average, or practical

conditions. Designing airplanes to withstand only average loads would

result in a greater potential for catastrophic failures whenever those

loads are exceeded.

Boeing Data

FedEx states that none of Boeing's analysis for the affected 727

airplanes provides any baseline for comparison of the unit load device

(ULD) cg shifts, container load distribution, or other key

methodologies. The FAA does not concur. As a check to verify that its

analysis was generally correct, the FAA examined some of the type

certification data that Boeing had submitted prior to certification of

727 passenger and freighter airplanes. The Boeing data verified the

FAA's analysis in the following two significant respects:

1. Boeing's stress analysis that established allowable floor beam

strength for the passenger version was entirely consistent with the

FAA's stress analysis; and

2. Boeing's loads analysis for the freighter version, while using a

different methodology from that used by the FAA, would result in

substantial negative margins of safety for passenger floor structure

when carrying 8,000-lb. containers.

In accordance with CAR part 4b, Boeing's analysis of the 727

freighter considered all aspects of cargo loading, including cg

offsets, load distribution, and multiple other facets. It should be

noted that Boeing found it necessary to substantially strengthen the

floor structure for its freighter version in order to carry the same

payloads currently allowed by the subject STC's and remain in full

compliance with CAR part 4b.

FedEx's Analysis

In support of its position that there is no unsafe condition, FedEx

states that it has used a rational, conservative analytical approach

for determining that the cargo floor structure is safe, which has not

been accepted by the FAA. Specifically, FedEx references individual

floor beam analysis and tests conducted with combinations of loads,

offsets, container positioning, airplane weight, and flight maneuvers

that create conditions exceeding any that statistically will occur.

The FAA does not concur. Except for the lateral floor beams over

the 80-inch long wheel well area, which is discussed below under the

heading ``Data Showing Floors to be Safe,'' FedEx has not yet submitted

a complete analysis of the floor structure, or of a single floor beam.

The tests that have been run to date are of limited relevance

as discussed under the heading ``FedEx's Tests.'' Further, as discussed

previously, the FAA also does not concur that the unsafe condition is

so improbable that it should not be addressed.

FedEx states that the statement in the NPRM that the FAA used

commonly accepted analytical methods in its structural analysis is

misleading because it fails to address other ``commonly accepted

analytical methods.'' In particular, FedEx references the FAA's use of

a pinned end column fixity coefficient (``c'') of 1.0, and in contrast

points out that a ``c'' of 2.58 is used in an example problem contained

in ``Analysis and Design of Flight Vehicle Structures'' by E.F. Bruhn.

FedEx considers this example problem to be analogous to a floor beam

lower cap analysis. FedEx states that other alternative analytical

methods (such as Bruhn) result in a significant increase in allowable

loads for the floor beams (therefore potentially higher allowable

container weights), but these methods have been rejected by the FAA as

inapplicable to the converted 727 freighters, even though they have

been accepted previously by the FAA on other certification efforts.

The FAA does not concur. The selection of this coefficient can have

a significant effect on the determination of the allowable payloads. A

low column fixity coefficient of 1.0 means that the ends of the beam

are ``pinned'' (i.e., free to rotate or move like a hinge). A column

fixity coefficient of 4.0 means that the ends of the beam are fully

``fixed'' (i.e., unable to rotate or move for any applied load). The

FAA's analysis uses a ``pin end coefficient'' because it represents the

airplane structure. As stated previously, the FAA's analysis considered

the ``up'' load case to be the most likely critical case. For this load

case, the lower horizontal member or ``chord'' of the ``I'' shaped

floor beam will be in compression and, therefore, will behave in the

same manner as a column under compression. It will be free to rotate or

move like a hinge, not fixed as a higher fixity coefficient would

suggest.

FedEx's proposed ``c'' coefficient of 2.58 does not appear in any

of its analysis in support of its comments to the NPRM. At the

September 19 meeting, FedEx stated that it did not use the 2.58 value

in any of its analyses submitted in its comments. FedEx also stated at

the meeting that the 2.58 value was merely an illustration of a fixity

coefficient that could be found in the Bruhn handbook for a similar

problem. Nevertheless, FedEx maintained at that meeting that it

estimates the true value of ``c'' is in excess of 1.2, and may be as

high as 2.58, although FedEx did not provide any data to the FAA to

show that a ``c'' of 2.58 would be representative of the structure.

In addition, in FedEx's analysis submitted to the NPRM, FedEx used

a ``c'' value of 1.2. (Document 97-021, initial release, dated February

28, 1997, submitted to the NPRM (Rules Docket No. 97-NM-09-AD) as

Appendix 1 during the first comment period). However, in a later

version of the same document, FedEx also used a ``c'' coefficient of

1.01 (Document 97-021, dated March 24, 1997, but designated as the

initial release of the document, as well), submitted to the FAA for

review on April 7, 1997. The FAA has determined that there is

essentially no difference between 1.00 and 1.01 for a column end fixity

coefficient. Therefore, the FAA concludes that the more recent data

submitted by FedEx is consistent with the value of 1.0 for the column

fixity coefficient used in the FAA's analysis.

FedEx states that it has submitted reports to the Seattle Aircraft

Certification Office (ACO) that employ assumptions that were used by

Douglas Aircraft Company and were accepted by the Los Angeles ACO for

the original certification of the Model DC-10 airplane. FedEx also

states that the Los Angeles ACO's earlier approval of the assumptions

used in the Model DC-10 analysis affirms that it is using an

appropriate method to substantiate the integrity of its converted 727

freighters. FedEx states that the FAA has not explained how the

methodology can be accepted by the Los Angeles ACO and not accepted by

the Seattle ACO.

The FAA acknowledges that use of the particular assumption(s)

referenced in the DC-10 analysis, if applicable to FedEx's 727

analysis, may allow higher container weights than those specified in

the proposed AD.

The FAA does not concur with the commenter's statements. For many

certification projects, it has been acceptable to use a particular

assumption which may not be conservative, provided that there are other

quantifiable assumptions used which account for the lack of

conservatism and result in the overall design being conservative and in

compliance with CAR part 4b. Therefore, an unconservative assumption

used as part of a particular approved methodology is not equally

acceptable for another methodology without ensuring that the lack of

conservatism is accounted for elsewhere in the methodology and that the

overall design is conservative.

At the July 24, 1997, meeting with FedEx, an FAA representative

from the Los Angeles ACO stated that it was the responsibility of FedEx

to demonstrate that the analytical assumptions and methodologies used

on the DC-10 were conservative for the Boeing 727. To date, FedEx has

not made that demonstration. During the September 19 meeting with

FedEx, the FAA asked FedEx if it had used the entire analytical

methodology that was used for the DC-10. FedEx replied that it had not.

Therefore, the FAA does not agree that the two ACO's have been

inconsistent.

FedEx states that neither it nor the FAA has a complete, accurate

model which objectively demonstrates the actual performance of the vast

array of the TSO and STC ULD's in any one of the hundreds of individual

airplane cargo positions and latch configurations of in-service

airplanes. The FAA concurs that there is no accurate model which

demonstrates the actual loads input into the structure of the 727

converted freighters for the myriad of possible configurations.

However, an analysis using conservative overlapping (or enveloping)

assumptions can be performed to show the design is safe for the

proposed usage and is in compliance with CAR section 4b.200(c). This

approach has been successfully used by aerospace companies for many

years and is acceptable to the FAA.

FedEx's Tests

FedEx states that three tests (descriptions follow) indicate that

the floor structure of the existing main cargo deck is in compliance

with CAR part 4b when supporting existing weight limits of the weight

and balance manual.

1. Inverted Container Test. FedEx states that it has conducted an

inverted container test that demonstrates that its existing sidelocks

are effective in carrying 35 to 40 percent of the container load. The

test report is contained in Appendix 9 (Report 97-048, Revision I/R,

dated May 5, 1997) of FedEx's comments to the NPRM (Rules Docket No.

97-NM-09-AD) during the initial comment period. FedEx also states that

these results show that the FAA's estimation that the sidelocks carry

20 percent of the container load is far too conservative.

The FAA infers that FedEx considers that the FAA's estimation that

20 percent of the total container load is carried by all sidelocks (10

percent per side) is conservatively low since this results in 80

percent of the total load being carried by the locks attached to the

main deck floor beams. Because FedEx's inverted container test showed

that 35 to 40 percent of the container

load was carried by the sidelocks (approximately 20 percent per side),

60 to 65 percent of the total load would be carried by the locks

attached to the main deck floor beams.

FedEx states that this test indicates that the floor structure of

the existing main cargo deck is in compliance with CAR part 4b when

supporting existing weight limits. The FAA does not concur that FedEx's

testing has shown that sidelocks are 35 to 40 percent effective because

the testing does not address all container types, cg shifts, and all

container positions on the airplane. The FAA estimated that the

sidelocks are 20 percent effective based on current industry methods,

as used in TC and STC programs. To date, industry, with the exception

of this test by FedEx, has little or no data showing the exact

distributions of actual sidelock load percentages. Therefore,

enveloping assumptions and/or conservative analytical methodologies

have been consistently used by various manufacturers to show compliance

with CAR sections 4b.200(c), 4b.210, and 4b.359, to which these STC's

also were certified. This approach has previously obviated the need to

determine the exact load distributions to each lock for the various

container types used by operators.

Several commenters point out that there is a vast array of

different types of containers and other ULD's used by the affected

operators. This includes a wide range of construction, shapes, and

materials. Some ULD's look like boxes; others look like flat pallets or

``cookie sheets.'' These differences significantly affect the

distribution of loads to all locks when subjected to ``up'' loads on

the container. Although FedEx's airplanes that have been modified in

accordance with the affected STC's predominantly haul the full-size or

``SAA'' container, and the half-size or ``Demi'' container, FedEx

reported at the September 19 meeting with the FAA that its modified

727's haul other kinds of containers, such as flat pallets, when

necessary.

For these reasons, the FAA's analysis used to determine the maximum

safe payload limits for operations must conservatively account for any

of the currently permitted container types.

CAR section 4b.359 requires that ``each cargo and baggage

compartment be designed for the placarded maximum weight of contents

and the critical load at the appropriate maximum load factors

corresponding to all specified flight * * * conditions * * *.'' CAR

section 4b.210 requires that ``flight load requirements shall be

complied with * * * at all weights from the design minimum weight to

the maximum weight appropriate to each particular flight condition,

with any practicable distribution of disposable load (mass load) within

the prescribed operating limitations stated in the Airplane Flight

Manual.'' CAR section 4b.200(c) requires that ``all loads [force loads]

shall be distributed in a manner closely approximating, or

conservatively representing actual conditions.''

Therefore, in order to show compliance with the applicable

regulations, either the distribution of the container loads to latches

used to analyze the floor beam structure must be accurately determined

for all container types used, or conservative assumptions must be used

considering all practicable distribution of cargo loads. Finally, the

floor structure must be strong enough to carry the maximum weight at

the critical cargo load distribution at the appropriate maximum applied

loads.

As stated previously, the FAA's analysis in the NPRM's identifies

one of several possible critical load cases--that of a large gust

pushing the airplane down, which causes ``up'' loads on two adjacent

containers. On all of the affected STC's, adjacent containers share the

same set of container locks at the forward and aft edges, and these

locks are attached to the floor structure. This condition results in

the loads for both containers being concentrated on isolated floor

beam(s) at the location of the locks.

A ``typical'' full-size (88-by 125-inch) container is an enclosed

box with two sides curved to match the rounded contour of the airplane

fuselage, a fully or partially removable front side (i.e., a door), and

a fixed or rigid back wall. Because of the design of a typical

container, the back wall tends to carry the majority of the load (the

curved sides and removable front are not as effective in supporting an

``up'' load as the rigid back wall). A different type of ULD, a flat

pallet, with netting to restrain the cargo, distributes the loads to

the container locks very differently than the 88- by 125-inch

container. The net tends to distribute the load more uniformly around

the pallet edges.

The rational basis for the FAA's analysis is illustrated by the

following two examples of container/ULD arrangements that result in

load distributions to the floor beams which approach or exceed the 80

percent estimate used by the FAA (i.e., the converse of the estimate

that 20 percent of the load is carried by the sidelocks). These two

examples assume maximum allowable ULD payloads of 8,000 lbs. using

configurations that are permitted for all of these STC's.

Example 1: Back-to-Back Containers. Based on the data from

FedEx's inverted container test with an ``SAA'' container facing

(door side) forward, 43 percent of the total load was carried by the

locks on the back side of the container. If two containers of equal

weight are placed back to back, the equivalent of 86 percent of the

total load of one container would be placed on the floor beam(s) at

the interface (43 percent plus 43 percent).

Example 2: Container and Flat Pallet. Using the test data for

the inverted container test, 43 percent of the load would be carried

by the back wall. A flat pallet (``cookie sheet'') placed just aft

of this container in a cargo position, which has four sidelocks on

each side, will place approximately 28 percent of the total load on

the front side of the ``cookie sheet'' [as discussed previously, the

net on the flat pallet tends to distribute the load equally to all

sides of the sheet, and since there are five locks each on the floor

beam(s) supporting the front and back side of the sheet, and four on

each side, 5/18 (or 28 percent of the total load) will be on the

front side]. This results in a total of 71 percent (43 percent plus

28 percent) of the maximum ULD payload, being placed on the floor

beam(s) between these two ULD's.

These two examples of the many possible loading configurations

illustrate the reasonableness of the FAA's estimation that 80 percent

of the maximum allowable container payload could be concentrated on the

floor beam(s) at the interface between two adjacent containers.

In addition, the FAA has other concerns with FedEx's inverted

container test. First, the effects of a critical cg shift within the

container were not tested. As tested by FedEx, the back wall of the

container carried 43 percent of the load with a zero percent cg shift

(i.e., the cg of the container was at its geometric center). As

discussed previously, this is impractical to achieve in actual

operations. If the cg had been shifted towards the back wall of the

container, the load at the back wall of the container would have been

higher than the 43 percent noted previously.

It should be noted that the FedEx test plan submitted to the FAA in

May 1997 (Appendix 4 of FedEx's comment to Rules Docket No. 97-NM-09-AD

submitted during the initial comment period; Document 97-034, dated May

6, 1997) listed aft cg shift load cases on page 9 of that plan.

However, these critical load cases were not tested because the actual

test (described in Appendix 9) had taken place in accordance with an

earlier test plan, Document 97-023 (which is referenced in Appendix 9).

This was confirmed by FedEx at the September 19 meeting.

A second concern with the FedEx inverted container test is that the

container was tested in a fixture in

which the lock locations were representative of only one cargo position

on the airplane. There are typically a maximum of 8 to 12 containers

that may be carried on the main deck, depending on the configuration of

the airplane. Sidelocks are evenly spaced along the fuselage, and

different cargo container positions result in either four or five

sidelocks along the container side edges. For these reasons, a variety

of locations should be tested to determine the critical load case for

the floor beams.

A third concern is that FedEx tested cargo position 5 on the 727-

200 with the door of the container on the aft side of the cargo

position. This orientation is opposite of how FedEx reports that the

``SAA'' containers are usually placed in its airplanes. This

orientation of the container in the test fixture resulted in a sidelock

being within 4 inches of the back wall of the container. The distance

from the front wall of the container to the nearest sidelock was 23.5

inches. Due to this large distance, or ``overhang,'' and the

flexibility of the ``SAA'' container, the nearest sidelock to the front

wall on each side of the container together carried 32 percent of the

total test load. If the container had been placed in the fixture with

the door on the front side of the cargo position, such that the back

wall of the container had a 23.5-inch ``overhang,'' or was in one of

the several other cargo positions possible which have greater than a 4-

inch ``overhang'' to the backwall of the container, the loads on the

container back wall (which are carried by the floor beams) would have

been significantly higher.

Finally, it is important to note that FedEx has provided no

analysis of the floor beam structure showing that the large negative

margins of safety are resolved based on its assertion that 35 to 40

percent of the container load is distributed to the sidelocks. The load

distribution is only part of the answer; the load distribution must be

used in a stress analysis to develop data identifying stresses in the

structural members.

The FAA concurs that, in principal, testing of containers using a

fixture such as that used by FedEx, if it represents the most adverse

case of ``overhang'' for the back wall for all applicable cargo

positions, and if it shifts the container cg to the most adverse

position, will produce conservative results for the latches common to

the floor beams, for the container type tested. The results will be

conservative because of the flexibility of the floor beams, relative to

the stiff behavior of the test fixture. The degree of conservatism is

unknown to the FAA and has not been demonstrated by FedEx.

FedEx, in its test, did not consider all practicable load

distributions nor establish the critical case considering an adverse

aft cg shift and sidelock location. FedEx tested only those containers

or ULD's that it predominantly uses, but not all the types that it

actually uses in service; therefore, it is impossible to draw broad

conclusions about the behavior of many different container types,

applicable to all cargo positions, or the degree of conservatism

introduced by floor beam flexibility from its limited testing.

Therefore, the FAA concludes that the 35 to 40 percent distribution

of the ``up'' load to the sidelocks used by FedEx is artificially high.

The FAA does not concur that the data ``Container Test,'' documented in

Appendix 9, demonstrate that the commenter's existing sidelocks, in

general, are effective in reacting 35 to 40 percent of the container

load, or that the tests ``indicate that the floor structure of the

existing main cargo deck is in compliance with the requirements of CAR

part 4b when supporting existing weight limits.'' The test also does

not demonstrate that the FAA's finding of unsafe condition is

incorrect.

2. Single ``I'' Beam Test. FedEx states that it performed a floor

beam test on a conservative representation of an unmodified passenger

floor beam. This test is documented in Appendix 8 of FedEx's submittal

to Rules Docket No. 97-NM-09-AD (FedEx Engineering Report 97-049,

Revision I/R, dated August 15, 1997), and the additional data is

contained in Appendices 10 (FedEx Floor Beam Test, Wyle Lab) and 11

(FedEx Floor Beam Test Videotapes).

FedEx also states that this test showed a lower floor beam chord

compression allowable in excess of 60 ksi (60,000 lbs. per square inch)

just prior to failure of the floor beam. FedEx states that this value

controverts the FAA's calculation of 40.6 ksi in the FAA's analysis. In

addition, FedEx states that the floor beam was tested in a fixture

designed to replicate the airplane floor support structure, and that

the test results are conservative due to the interaction of other floor

beams, seat tracks, and floor panels in the airplane; the benefits of

which were not addressed during this test. FedEx states that this test

indicates that the floor structure of the existing main cargo deck is

in compliance with CAR part 4b when supporting existing weight limits.

The FAA does not concur that FedEx's measurement of 60 ksi

compressive stress is relevant to the actual strength of the floor

beam. In the FedEx test, the 60 ksi measurement was taken just before

the floor beam fractured in tension (i.e., stretching of the floor beam

to the point of failure). The FAA considers that the critical failure

mode (i.e., the failure mode that would cause collapse of the floor

structure in actual operation) is buckling of the floor beam. Buckling

occurs when the floor beam warps or twists under applied loads. As

discussed below, the test data indicate that the actual compressive

stress at which the floor beam buckled was approximately 18 ksi.

Although the floor beam buckled during the test, the floor beam did

not collapse, in part because the test fixture substantially and

artificially limited the amount of warping of the beam. The test

fixture used a rigid ``I'' beam to support the ends of the floor beam.

This kept the ends of the floor beam from moving inward during the

test. In contrast, on an actual airplane, the ends of the floor beam

can move inward because they are attached to the fuselage frames, which

are much more flexible than the rigid ``I'' beam used in the test

fixture. The result of this artificial restraint was that the floor

beam buckled and began to deflect. Instead of collapsing, as would be

expected on an airplane, the floor beam behaved more like a cable,

suspended from two rigid ends, with very little bending strength, but

significant axial strength. This behavior was ultimately demonstrated

by the catastrophic failure of the beam in tension, similar to a cable

failure. If the beam had been supported as it is in the airplane, it is

likely that the floor beam would have collapsed at the onset of

buckling.

For example, if a horizontal beam is supported at each end, and

vertical loads are placed on the beam, as the beam deflects the ends

will pull inward. Restraining the beam ends will limit the bending

deflection and stiffen the beam, preventing collapse of the beam as it

buckles. This artificial restraint does not affect the buckling

capability of the beam, but it causes the beam to appear to have higher

load carrying capability than it actually has. FedEx acknowledged the

effect of this axial restraint in a November 4, 1997, letter to the

FAA. FedEx stated that ``It is conceivable that the bending deformation

of the beam * * * would be influenced by restraining the ends of the

floor beam from translating * * *.''

As stated previously, the critical compression buckling stress of

the floor beam tested was approximately 18 ksi. (This occurred at the

load step entitled ``0.6g.'') At this point the beam buckled as a

column in the forward/aft direction.

Beyond this load factor, at the spanwise location left buttock line

(LBL) 11, the beam began bending in the forward and aft direction, as

evidenced by the detailed test data for load case number 5, 2.8 g (2.8

times the force exerted by gravity at sea level) ``up'' load in

Appendix 8. Forward and aft bending of the beam clearly indicates that

the beam has buckled, and can be seen by observing the FedEx videotapes

contained in Appendix 11. This buckling failure occurred prior to 40.6

ksi as predicted by the FAA, and before the 49.1 ksi value predicted

analytically by FedEx in Appendix 1.

The occurrence of buckling at 18 ksi rather than approximately 40

ksi can be explained by the ineffectiveness of the stability straps in

the test fixture. Over most of the airplane, the floor beams extend

from one side of the airplane to the other. A stability strap is a

long, thin strip of metal, running perpendicular to the floor beam, and

attached to the lower surface of several beams, at intervals ranging

from 17 to 24.75 inches along the lower surface of the floor beam. The

purpose of the stability straps is to support or stabilize the lower

chord to strengthen the floor beam. This is accomplished by reducing

the ``effective length'' of the lower chord of the beam from one long

column (the entire length) by splitting it into a series of shorter,

stiffer columns that are equal in length to the distance between the

stability straps. The stability straps in the test model were

ineffective because the portion of the test fixture to which the straps

were attached was not stiff enough to allow the straps to fully

stabilize the floor beam. (This is exactly the opposite problem from

that described above with respect to the excessive rigidity of the test

fixture where the floor beam ends were attached.)

By graphing the results obtained from the test, the FAA determined

that the stability straps were not fully effective at the location

where the beam buckled. This graphing demonstrated that the ``effective

length'' of the floor beam lower chord at the point of buckling was

40.4 inches [between LBL 32.6 and right buttock line (RBL) 7.8], rather

than the ``effective length'' of 24.75 inches used in the analyses

conducted by FedEx and the FAA. Since the ``effective length'' was

longer for the tested beam due to the ineffectiveness of the stability

straps, the resulting column was weaker and buckled at a lower stress

than would occur on the affected airplanes.

The FAA subsequently used the same analytical techniques used in

its previous analysis to confirm that the buckling strength of the beam

is approximately 20 ksi based on the effective column length of 40.4

inches demonstrated by the FedEx tests. This correlates well with the

stress at buckling of 18 ksi measured in the tests and confirms the

validity of the FAA's analysis.

During the September 19, 1997, meeting, and at the February 18,

1998, public meeting, FedEx concurred with the FAA that the stability

straps buckled during the test, and were largely ineffective, as the

straps could not provide stability to the lower chord.

At the public meeting on February 18, 1998, two FedEx consultants

made presentations regarding this test. Both consultants agreed that,

although the test was properly performed in accordance with the test

protocol, the test fixture was not representative of the airplane. As a

result, one of the consultants (Dr. Foster of Auburn University) stated

that it would be inappropriate to draw conclusions from this test for

the airplane floor beam.

Based on the discussion above, the FAA concludes that FedEx's

``Single I Beam Test'' does not demonstrate a lower chord stress

capability greater than that calculated by the FAA, or that the

existing main cargo deck is in compliance with the requirements of CAR

part 4b when supporting existing weight limits. The test also does not

demonstrate that the FAA's finding of unsafe condition is incorrect.

3. ``On-Aircraft'' Test. FedEx states that an ``on-aircraft'' test

was conducted (Appendix 12, Report 97-052, Revision I/R, dated August

27, 1997), and that this test demonstrated that the container/airplane

combination withstood an applied ``up'' load of approximately 20,000

lbs. FedEx states that this test indicates that the floor structure of

the existing main cargo deck is in compliance with the requirements of

CAR part 4b when supporting existing weight limits. FedEx also states

in Section 6 of Report 97-051, also in Appendix 12, that a margin of

safety of 2.1 was demonstrated with a 10,700-lb. container.

The FAA does not concur that this test demonstrates that the

airplane is safe and in compliance with CAR part 4b. The test also does

not demonstrate that the FAA's finding of unsafe condition is

incorrect. The ``on-aircraft'' test consisted of FedEx's ``SAA'' or

full-size container, situated on the main cargo deck of a 727,

restrained vertically by the forward and aft pallet locks (attached to

the floor beams), and side vertical restraints (sidelocks). The

container was modified to place four ``I'' shaped beams running

lengthwise through the container. Four hydraulic jacks were positioned

underneath the ``I'' beams on either side of the container and attached

to jacking platforms on the main deck floor. The jacks were used to

apply ``up'' loads to the container, as is shown in Figure 2.1 of

FedEx's Report 97-051 (Appendix 12 of FedEx's submittal to Rules Docket

No. 97-NM-09-AD). To transmit the loads applied to the ``I'' beams to

the container, a rigid structure made of seventy-two 4- by 4-inch thick

wood beam spacers, and thirty-eight \3/4\-inch thick plywood sheet

formers curved at the edges to match the contour of the container, were

fastened with screws to the 0.063-inch thick aluminum skin of the

container. This structure, weighing approximately 1,400 lbs., provided

a rigid platform for the ``I'' beams to lift the container (details of

the plywood structure and its estimated weight are provided in Figure

2.3 of Report 97-051, Appendix 12).

The FAA has determined that the ``I'' beams and rigid structure

used to introduce ``up'' load into the container artificially limited

the distortion of the container under load and forced most of the

applied load to the sidelocks and away from the floor beams. This is

unconservative for the floor beams because it results in the test not

representing how an actual loaded container or other ULD would affect

the loads on the floor beams.

During the September 19 meeting, FedEx agreed that in the ``up''

load case, if the container is loaded and not restrained by the rigid

structure, it attempts to deform to a catenary (arched) shape at the

front of the container where the door is located. This effect is

demonstrated by FedEx's inverted container test described in Appendix

9. FedEx also stated, however, that this would have no effect on the

test results, although it was considering the use of airbags or

hydraulic bags instead of the rigid structure to allow the ``SAA''

container to behave as it did in the test documented in Appendix 9.

FedEx also stated in the meeting that it believed that testing to 2.5

g's, or 20,000 lbs. of ``up'' load, helps to account for the load being

``beamed'' or forced to the sidelocks.

The test results indicated that over 80 percent of the load was

directed to the sidewalls of the container and, therefore, to the

sidelocks rather than the floor beams. The FAA finds that this effect

results from the rigid structure used to introduce the load into the

container, and that this renders the test unrepresentative of the

actual loading of the floor beam and significantly unconservative.

Even though the FAA determined that the results of the inverted

container test (Appendix 9 of FedEx's comment) were unconservative, it

showed that the percentage of the load carried by the back wall of the

container was approximately three times greater than that determined by

the ``on-aircraft'' test. The loads carried by the rigid back wall are

largely carried by floor beam(s) locks, not the sidelocks. These

results also contradict FedEx's conclusion that the ``on-aircraft''

test demonstrates that the floor structure is safe. The ``on-aircraft''

test provides confidence in the strength of FedEx's sidelocks. However,

because of the artificial shifting of the loads from the floor beams to

the sidelocks, the test fails to demonstrate that the floor structure

is safe. Further, the ``on-aircraft'' testing to 2.5 g's did not result

in the application of significant loading to the floor beams.

Therefore, the results of the testing to 2.5 g's is of little

significance when addressing the unsafe condition of the floor beams.

In Appendix 1 of FedEx's April 30, 1998, submission to Rules Docket

No. 97-NM-09-AD during the reopened comment period, FedEx appears to

now recognize the effect of the rigid plywood formers in forcing the

load to the sidelocks and away from the floor beams. In this Appendix,

on page 2 of the FedEx Engineering Report 98-026, Revision A, FedEx

states ``Measured loads for the container perimeter latch locations

indicate that 40% of the applied load was reacted on each side by the

side latches (see Reference 3). This is due to the fact that the rigid

formers did not allow the top of the container to deform as it would

during actual conditions and thereby forced more load outboard than

what would be typically encountered during flight.''

In summary, based on the previous discussion, the FAA does not

concur that this test demonstrates that the airplane is safe and in

compliance with CAR part 4b. The test also does not demonstrate that

the FAA's finding of unsafe condition is incorrect. One commenter

states that he participated in FedEx's ``on-aircraft'' test. He states

that the data from the latch load cells were inconclusive for the

tests, and although he considered the test to be a reasonable

representation of airplane conditions, he suggests that FedEx improve

the latch load cell installation and data acquisition system and

investigate whether the plywood formers used to apply the test load to

the container roof could influence the latch load distribution. As

discussed previously, the FAA does not concur that the ``on-aircraft''

test was representative of the airplane, but concurs that the plywood

formers influenced the load distribution.

First Container Facing Aft

Two commenters state that positioning the first container aft of

the 9g cargo barrier with the door facing forward is not optimum from a

crashworthiness perspective and request that the AD specify that this

container be facing aft instead. The FAA concurs. Paragraphs (a) and

(b) of the final rule have been revised to allow the first container

aft of the bulkhead to face aft, with all other containers facing

forward.

Increased Running Load

One commenter states that the following statement in the NPRM is

factually inaccurate: ``This running load of 90 pounds per inch is a

safety concern, as it is approximately 2.6 times higher than the

maximum running load of 34.5 pounds per inch allowed on these same

floor beams when the airplane was in a passenger configuration.'' The

commenter states that in a negative gust (``up'' load) situation the

passenger floor beams must act to restrain upper deck loads and lower

deck cargo loads simultaneously and, as a result, must react 81.0-lbs.

per inch, not just the 34.5 figure as the NPRM indicates. The commenter

maintains that if reduced loads are necessary to maintain the safety of

cargo airplanes, then passenger airplanes should be similarly

restricted.

The FAA does not concur that the passenger and cargo airplanes

present similar safety concerns. The NPRM statement quoted by the

commenter appeared in the section of the NPRM that described the FAA's

reasons for undertaking the detailed design review which led to the

conclusion that there is an unsafe condition. The statement in the NPRM

is factually accurate for the running loads and the ``down'' load case

and contributed to the FAA's concern with the strength of an

unreinforced cargo floor.

The FAA subsequently determined that the ``up'' load case is the

most likely critical case. The FAA agrees that, for the ``up'' load

case, the running load figures identified in the comment are accurate.

However, the passenger compartment is designed to uniformly distribute

passenger loads such that every floor beam is active in carrying these

loads. In contrast, the freighter floor loads are applied differently.

Instead of the main deck loads being applied uniformly, each 88-inch

deep container spans several floor beams. As discussed previously, the

result of this is that only floor beams located at the edges of

containers are active in carrying the ``up'' loads. Hence, as the FAA

determined in its detailed design review, the effect on the airplane is

that the 90 lbs. per inch cargo container loading is much more critical

than the uniformly applied upper and lower deck loads of the passenger

configuration and is, in fact, a safety concern.

One commenter states that the interim weight reduction is too

restrictive considering that the passenger 727 can carry in excess of

6,800 lbs. in the same zone. The 3,000-lb. limitation imposed in the

NPRM is unjustified. The FAA does not concur. As discussed previously,

the loading on the floor is significantly different depending on

whether it is loaded by the carriage of passengers or containers. The

3,000-lb. limitation specified for the carriage of cargo in the NPRM is

justified by the FAA's analysis provided in the Rules Dockets.

Netted Lower Lobe Cargo

One commenter states that if the lower lobe cargo is assumed to be

netted (restrained), it would not have any relevance in a down gust

situation. The FAA infers that the commenter believes that, as the

cargo would be restrained to the belly of the airplane, it would not

load the underside of the floor beams in a negative ``g'' environment

due to a down gust.

Another commenter states that the NPRM should be changed to allow

lower lobe weights to be subtracted from the main deck limits if the

load is properly tied down. The FAA concurs partially. If the lower

lobe cargo is properly tied down, it will be restrained by the

structure differently than represented in the FAA analysis. While the

FAA is not currently aware of configurations that restrain lower lobe

cargo, paragraphs (f) and (g) of this AD allow for approval of this

type of configuration as an alternative method of compliance with the

final rule.

Airplane Weight Increases

One commenter states that the FAA should reconsider the present

policy of withholding approval of maximum take-off weight (MTOW) and

maximum landing weight (MLW) increases for 727 freighter modified

airplanes. The rationale for this is that the resulting higher weights

would allow greater fuel loads for remote region operators, and also

would increase the safety margin of the airplane's modified fuselage

structure, which is the FAA's prime concern addressed by the NPRM's.

The FAA infers that the commenter believes

that the proposed AD should be changed to reflect this.

The FAA concurs partially. The FAA concurs that maintaining a

minimum in-flight weight reduces the loads resulting from vertical

gusts, unless this additional weight is carried in body fuel tanks that

are suspended from floor beams. Additional loads to the floor beams

exacerbate the unsafe condition. This issue is addressed appropriately

in the context of type certification and is not addressed in this AD.

Therefore, the FAA has determined that no change to the final rule is

necessary.

Operators' Ability To Determine Container CG's

One commenter states that there is no means to measure or comply

with the requirement that the container cg's be within +/- 10 percent

of the geometric center of the container. Two commenters state that the

wording in the proposed AD should be changed to allow those operators

having a loading procedure that maintains the container cg within +/-

10 percent to be considered compliant with this requirement. The FAA

does not concur that the cg of the container cannot be determined, or

that the requirement to maintain the cg within 10 percent of the

horizontal cg cannot be complied with. For example, FedEx has recently

acquired equipment for this purpose. Because the cg location within the

container has a major effect on the loads imposed on the floor beams,

the FAA considers that this limitation is necessary to address the

unsafe condition. It should be noted that the vast majority of cargo

containers are certificated to TSO C90c, which specifies a maximum cg

shift of 10 percent. Therefore, operators should always have been

ensuring that the cg shift did not exceed this limitation in the TSO.

One commenter submitted data to the Rules Dockets that the

commenter states will allow an operator with a properly designed or

modified scale to accurately determine, display, and record the

container cg. The FAA did not evaluate the technical accuracy of the

submission, as no change to the proposed AD was requested by the

commenter.

Airplanes With Apparent Increased Floor Capability

One commenter states that one of its 727-200 airplanes has a

greater running load allowable than its other two airplanes (37.5 lbs.

per running inch versus 34 lbs. per running inch) and asks why this

airplane is limited by the same restriction.

The FAA infers that the commenter believes that its airplane should

have higher allowable container loads, based on this apparent increased

capability, and that the AD should be changed to reflect this. The FAA

does not concur. From its analysis, the design review team determined

that the 727 main cargo decks are capable of supporting a maximum

payload of approximately 3,000 lbs. per container. Paragraphs (f) and

(g) of the AD allow for an applicant to propose new payloads along with

substantiating data and analysis. No change to the final rule is

necessary.

Inconsistent Limitations

One commenter states that the FAA's determination that these

airplanes are capable of supporting only 3,000 lbs. per container is

entirely inconsistent with the FAA's interim proposal, which would

allow an 8,000-lb. pallet in any position where the entire load would

be carried by one set of container locks. The commenter does not see

any rational or consistent approach in the NPRM's. The FAA does not

concur. The analysis that resulted in the 3,000 lb. per container limit

was based on the current operational limits of the airplane. As

discussed in the NPRM, the FAA determined that, if more restrictive

operational limits are imposed, a higher payload could be allowed on an

interim basis. The FAA has estimated that the airplane gust loads will

be reduced with limitations on in-flight weight and maximum operating

airspeed to the extent that the 3,000-lb. limit per container can be

raised to 4,000 lbs. for the interim period.

For the ``up'' load case, two 4,000-lb. containers placed back-to-

back, without side vertical restraints, impose approximately the same

amount of load on the floor structure as a single 8,000-lb. container

with the adjacent cargo positions carrying no payload. Because of this,

for the interim period, the operator would have the flexibility to

carry an 8,000-lb. container, provided the containers on either side

are empty.

If side vertical restraints acceptable to the FAA are installed,

then the interim payload is not to exceed a total weight of 9,600 lbs.

for any two adjacent containers. In this case, as stated in paragraph

(b) of the AD, the 8,000-lb. limit per container would still apply.

Many of the different containers and flat pallets or ``cookie sheets''

used by operators require side vertical restraints, as specified in TSO

C90c.

Irrelevancy of Model 747 Problems

One commenter states that the FAA only proposed payload reduction

because of the incidents occurring on 747's, but the FAA has no reason

to believe the problems found on the 747's will occur on the 727's. The

FAA does not concur. The FAA did, in fact, look into the 727

conversions because those conversions had been performed by some of the

same companies and with similar procedures and design methods as some

747's which had been found to be unsafe. The unsafe condition that is

the subject of this AD, however, is specific to the 727 and has been

documented in the Rules Dockets.

Applicability of 14 CFR 25.1529

One commenter states that the NPRM statement indicating that STC

holders are required to issue Instructions for Continued Airworthiness

in accordance with 14 CFR 25.1529 does not apply to its STC's because

the applicable airworthiness standards for the 727 are CAR part 4b,

rather than 14 CFR part 25. The FAA does not concur. Since January 28,

1981, 14 CFR 21.50(b) has required that the holder of an STC for which

application was made after that date shall furnish the Instructions for

Continued Airworthiness prepared in accordance with 14 CFR 25.1529.

This requirement is effective regardless of the specific certification

basis of the airplane.

Fatigue Cracks as Evidence of Unsafe Condition

FedEx states that, if the FAA's report of huge negative margins of

safety at ultimate load are true, then the ``typical daily operating

conditions would still impose substantial loads on the structure,'' and

result in wear and cracking of the floor structure. FedEx's review of

the FAA service difficulty report data generated only two reports of

cracks on the converted 727 freighters, and no other damage was found

that could be attributed to the 727 cargo conversion modification.

The FAA does not concur that a low number of in-service difficulty

reports indicates that the FAA's finding of unsafe condition is

unfounded. FedEx has reported that its average cargo load density is

approximately 7.5 lbs. per cubic foot, which equates to an average

cargo payload of approximately 3,300 lbs. per container. This results

in stress levels that on average would be similar to those of a

passenger 727. Therefore, it is not expected that fatigue cracks would

develop in only 11,008 total flight cycles, which is the highest number

of cycles accumulated (as of August 27, 1998) by any FedEx 727 airplane

since conversion to a freighter configuration. As discussed previously,

the unsafe condition addressed in these AD's is not a result of

fatigue, but is the

result of the existing floor structure not being able to support the

allowable payloads and distributions for the critical gust conditions.

Data Showing Floors To Be Safe

FedEx states that the NPRM is inaccurate in stating that the FAA

design review team was unable to find any data which showed that the

floors were safe for the heavier (than passenger loading) freight

payloads. FedEx states that the FAA has received and accepted data

verifying the safety of the floor structure. FedEx also states that the

FAA has failed to provide ``reasoned explanation'' for not approving

various documents.

The FAA does not concur. In performing its own analysis, the FAA

was careful to use only methodologies that were commonly employed in

industry. One of the ways that the reasonableness of the FAA analysis

contained in the Rules Dockets was checked was to compare the results

with results of the STC holders' analyses, where possible. In this

case, several analysis documents (Dee Howard Reports R90-2, R90-4, and

R90-6) were used by FedEx to analyze the main deck floor beams in

support of its STC for half-size containers (SA7447SW). However, these

documents do not ``verify that the unreinforced floor structure of the

main cargo deck can safely support the heavier freighter payloads.''

Also, they do not address all of the critical load cases or

configurations, nor do they address the effect of cg shifts.

Recognizing these limitations, the FAA used FedEx's methodology to

verify that the FAA analysis yielded similar results for a similar load

case. In doing this, the FAA used the load case which placed ``down''

loads on the containers, as provided in FedEx's analysis, as its

analysis did not contain an ``up'' load case (as required by CAR part

4b standards). Using the applied loads from FedEx's ``down'' load case,

the FAA calculated the margins of safety for the floor beams using the

FAA's documented methodology. The results for the mid-span of the floor

beam matched very closely to those documented in FedEx's STC analysis

for the half-size containers, which verifies that the FAA's and FedEx's

analytical methodologies were quite similar for the same load case.

However, because FedEx's (Dee Howard) documents do not address all

the critical load cases, locations on the floor beam, or

configurations, nor do they address the effects of cg shifts, they do

not ``verify the safety of the floor structure.''

In addition, of the ten documents related to the floor beam

analysis testing that FedEx submitted in its comments, three documents

(Appendices 1, 2, and 3) describe analytical methodologies and do not

(and are not intended to) ``show the floor structure can safely support

the heavier payloads.'' Regarding the decompression methodology

document submitted in Appendix 3, FedEx acknowledged at the September

19, 1997, meeting that it had not yet revised the document following

comments received from the FAA at a meeting held between FedEx and the

FAA on July 24, 1997.

Three other documents (Appendices 4, 8, and 9) are test plans or

results that have been discussed previously and also do not ``show the

floor structure can safely support the heavier payloads.''

The two external loads documents (Appendices 5 and 6) have been

approved by the FAA prior to FedEx's comment submittal (FAA letter 97-

120S-534, dated August 21, 1997) and are considered appropriate as a

starting point for an analysis of the floor structure. However, these

documents by themselves do not ``verify the safety of the floor

structure.''

Appendix 12 includes a document containing an incomplete analysis

of one floor beam, a test report which was discussed previously, and

two videotapes of that test, none of which ``verify the safety of the

floor structure.'' Finally, FedEx's Document ER 97-035 I/R, dated July

20, 1997 (Appendix 7), which was approved by FedEx on August 13, 1997,

had not been submitted to the FAA prior to its inclusion in FedEx's

comment submittal. In reviewing this document, the FAA has determined

that because the area addressed is shorter than an 88-inch container,

this document alone does not substantiate higher container loads. The

floor under the rest of the container also would need to be

substantiated to warrant a change to the AD limits.

The FAA does not concur that it has received and accepted data

verifying the safety of the floor structure, or that the FAA design

review team was in possession of any data which showed that the floors

were safe for the heavier (than passenger loading) freight payloads.

Finally, the FAA does not concur that it has failed to provide FedEx

with a ``reasoned explanation'' for not approving various documents.

FedEx is aware of the current status of all the above mentioned

documents.

FedEx also states that a Boeing letter (Appendix 41) indicated that

the floor beams were safe for a passenger to freighter airplane

conversion at (container) weights of 8,000 lbs. The FAA does not

concur. The referenced letter was part of an initial budget quote for a

zero fuel weight increase that estimated potential weight increases

that might be applicable to airplanes converted from passenger to

freighter configurations. Simplifying assumptions were used by Boeing

in order to allow FedEx to quickly establish, as a rough approximation,

the financial feasibility of converting an airplane. Any necessary

changes to the floor beams in estimating the weight of the airplane

following conversion were not addressed.

FedEx's Finite Element Model

FedEx states that the FAA misused FedEx's finite element model

(contained in Engineering Report 8504), which identifies negative

margins of safety in the fuselage monocoque, to substantiate its

finding of unsafe condition. FedEx also states that the NPRM was

inaccurate in stating that the report was used for certification. The

FAA does not concur. The FAA did not use FedEx's Engineering Report

8504 to validate its analysis. Rather, as discussed previously, the FAA

used the floor beam analysis documents submitted as part of the

substantiation for FedEx's STC for half-size containers (SA7447SW) to

validate its analysis. The NPRM did state that the original STC

certification data contained documented negative margins of safety. The

FAA does not concur that this statement is incorrect. At the meeting

held September 19, 1997, FedEx stated that the document was used to

support original STC issuance, and that no other document was

submitted.

Critical Loading on Floor Beams

FedEx states that, contrary to a statement in the NPRM, the FAA has

not established that floor beams at the forward and aft edges of the

container are more critically loaded. In its August 28, 1997, submittal

to Rules Docket No. 97-NM-09-AD, FedEx cited its ``on-aircraft'' test

as proof that the sidelocks are more critically loaded. FedEx appears

to have mistakenly inferred that this statement addresses the

effectiveness of FedEx's sidelocks. This inference is incorrect. In

context, this statement simply points out that, for the ``up'' load

case, ``the floor beams at the forward or aft edges of the containers

would be more critically loaded'' than the floor beams under the center

of the container. The reason for this is that a full-size container is

restrained against vertical movement by the container locks attached to

the floor beams at container edges and there are no

container locks in the center of the container.

Communications With FAA

FedEx's comments included a number of disagreements with

documentation of various communications prepared by the FAA and placed

in Rules Docket No. 97-NM-09-AD. Because these comments do not relate

to the merits of this AD, they are not addressed in this final rule.

However, the FAA has provided a response to these comments in that

Rules Docket.

Interim Limitations Already Observed

One commenter states that the interim operating limitations are not

necessary because the commenter does not know of a 727 freighter STC

that allows operation higher than 350 knots indicated airspeed (KIAS)

and, for practical reasons, 727-200 airplanes almost never operate at

weights below 100,000 lbs. The FAA does not concur. While many of the

affected airplanes are subject to a maximum operational speed

limitation of approximately 350 KIAS, other affected airplanes are not

subject to such limitations and do operate at higher speeds. In

addition, while operation at weights below 100,000 lbs. is not likely

for most 727-200 converted freighters, such operation is permitted and

may occur. Such operation is even more likely for the lighter weight

727-100, which also is subject to this AD.

Alternatives to Limitations in the AD

Several commenters asked about alternatives to the proposed rule

and suggested increased inspections, such as those in other AD's. The

FAA does not concur. The unsafe condition identified in the AD is not

based on loads imposed on the floor structure on an average flight

(i.e., fatigue-type loading). The unsafe condition is caused by loads

experienced on the airplane due to a large gust while carrying certain

cargo payloads and distributions. In this case, a floor beam failure or

excessive deflection would likely result in the loss of the airplane.

Because such a failure would not necessarily be preceded by cracking,

inspections of the airplane would not prevent the failure. The only

means for preventing a catastrophic event is to limit the flight

operation of the airplane and/or the container payloads.

One commenter proposes a statistical approach to study the unsafe

condition by requiring certain inspections over the next year while

imposing certain operational limitations. The FAA does not concur.

Because the unsafe condition is a collapse of the floor caused by large

gusts, increased inspections in the areas of concern will not serve to

lessen the likelihood of loss of the airplane.

One commenter proposes that the FAA revise the proposed AD to

further limit the maximum operational speed to 280 KIAS as an

alternative to payload limitations. The FAA does not concur with the

commenter's proposal to reduce the maximum operational speed to 280

KIAS. Reducing the maximum operational speed levels below 350 KIAS does

reduce the gust loads on the airplane. However, speed restrictions

below 350 KIAS that permit safe operation of the airplane do not affect

the maneuver loads, which at these speeds become more critical than the

gust loads.

``Mode B''

One commenter requests that, for the interim limitations, the FAA

also allows operation at ``Mode B'' [350 knots equivalent airspeed

(KEAS)] for the maximum operating airspeed (Vmo). The commenter states

that operations at ``Mode B'' would be more convenient than the 350

KIAS limitation specified in the proposed AD. The FAA concurs. The FAA

has revised the interim limitations of the final rule accordingly.

Release of Proprietary Data

Several commenters state that the FAA must divulge all data used to

make its finding of an unsafe condition; the commenters cited various

legal cases.

The FAA infers that commenters are insisting that the FAA release

relevant proprietary data that was considered by the FAA during this

rulemaking. The FAA does not concur for two reasons. First, the Trade

Secret Act (18 U.S.C. 1905) prohibits the disclosure of such data, and

this prohibition is not overridden by the requirements of the

Administrative Procedure Act (APA). The cases cited by the commenters,

while generally stating that agencies must release all information on

which they rely during rulemaking, do not address the prohibition

against the release of trade secret data.

Because AD's address unsafe conditions associated with aeronautical

products, the FAA routinely evaluates proprietary design data in

determining whether AD's are necessary. In determining whether such

material should be placed in the Rules Docket, the FAA applies the

standards developed under the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA; 5

U.S.C. 552) in the application of Exemption 4 [Sec. 552(B)(4)], which

protects ``trade secrets and commercial or financial information

obtained from a person and privileged or confidential.'' If data are

determined to meet those standards, they are not placed in the Rules

Docket, but are retained in separate files that are not released to the

public. Apart from violation of the Trade Secret Act, if the FAA were

to release such data, it would be much more difficult for the FAA to

obtain the data on which its findings of unsafe conditions are

necessarily based.

Second, the APA generally has been interpreted as requiring that

agencies provide the public with a meaningful opportunity to comment on

proposed rules. In this rulemaking, the FAA has fully complied with

this requirement, even without releasing trade secret data. In

developing the NPRM, the FAA used proprietary Boeing loads data in its

analysis, from which the FAA identified the existence of the unsafe

condition. Although Boeing has not consented to releasing these data,

FedEx has submitted comparable loads data (discussed previously under

the heading, ``Extension of Interim Operational Period'') which, when

used in the FAA analysis (which has been placed in the Rules Dockets),

also demonstrate the existence of the unsafe condition. FedEx did

consent to the release of these data. In fact, at the first public

meeting on February 18, 1998, the FAA used these data in its

presentation explaining its analysis. The analysis and the presentation

are fully documented in the Rules Dockets, and have been available for

review by commenters. The FAA also has referenced other proprietary

data, which have been submitted by applicants seeking approval for

modifications to correct the unsafe condition, as confirming the FAA's

analysis. Although these data are relevant to the rulemaking, they do

not provide the basis for the FAA's action, and their release would not

significantly increase the meaningfulness of the public's opportunity

to comment on the FAA's proposal.

One commenter requests copies of three recently updated Boeing

computer programs which it believes were utilized by the FAA in

determining the container payload limits specified in the NPRM. The

commenter states that those programs are entitled: (1) ``Vertical Gust

Load Factors 'Gs;'' (2) ``727 Movement (sic) of Inertia Model;'' and

(3) ``Operating Empty Weight Plus Payload Distribution.'' The FAA is

not aware of the referenced programs, does not have them, and did not

use them in its analysis.

Economic Analysis

Several commenters state that the FAA underestimated the cost to

modify the airplane floor structure into

compliance to CAR part 4b, citing a Pemco estimate of $400,000, as

opposed to the $100,000 estimate contained in the NPRM. Several

commenters also state that the FAA had underestimated (1) the loss in

revenue due to the reduced allowable payloads, and (2) the amount of

time necessary to get all airplanes modified due to the short 120-day

interim period, a lack of FAA-approved fixes, and the limited

availability of facilities to install the modifications within the 120-

day period proposed by the NPRM.

The FAA concurs. The FAA used data supplied by industry to conduct

its cost and regulatory flexibility analysis used in the NPRM and has

considered the data supplied by commenters during the comment period to

conduct the cost and regulatory flexibility analysis used for the final

rule.

Cost-Benefit Analysis

One commenter states that the FAA must undertake a thorough cost-

benefit analysis and economic impact assessment in conjunction with its

consideration of the remedial actions at issue in this rulemaking. The

commenter states that the FAA has thus far failed to conduct an

adequate cost-benefit analysis. The commenter states that a cost-

benefit analysis and economic impact assessment are required by the

provisions of the Regulatory Flexibility Act.

The FAA does not concur. As discussed below under the heading

``Regulatory Evaluation Summary,'' the FAA has performed an extensive

analysis of the costs and benefits of this AD and has fulfilled the

requirements of the Regulatory Flexibility Act.

Combi Airplanes

One commenter states that the NPRM has not considered those

operators that operate airplanes in a combi mode (a combi airplane has

provisions for passengers and cargo on the main deck in separate

compartments). The commenter also states that it assumes that the load

restrictions would not apply to the floor structure which is used to

carry passengers and that the original manufacturer's limitations are

applicable. The FAA concurs. Although the commenter is correct with

respect to floor structure carrying passengers, combi airplanes

transporting containers on the main deck must be in compliance with the

limitations specified in this AD.

Applicability of Proposal

FedEx points out that the wording of the applicability in the AD

could easily be misconstrued as also applying to airplanes manufactured

as freighters by the original equipment manufacturer. The FAA concurs

and has revised the applicability of the final rule to read ``Model 727

series airplanes that have been converted from a passenger to a cargo-

carrying (``freighter'') configuration in accordance with Supplemental

Type Certificate ST00015AT; certificated in any category.''

Other Cargo Lock Devices

One commenter requests that the proposed AD be revised to add a

paragraph discussing a ``special load-alleviating cargo container

lock'' for which the commenter has applied for an STC at the FAA, Los

Angeles ACO. The commenter reports that this lock will allow for the

carriage of 16,000 lbs. rather than 8,000 lbs. in two adjacent

containers, as specified in the proposed AD, but to be conservative,

the commenter requests that the rule allow 12,000 lbs. for two adjacent

containers for the interim period. During the reopened comment period,

this commenter submitted additional information in support of its

original comment.

The FAA does not concur. The information submitted is not

sufficient to substantiate the safety of the airplane with the locks

installed. This lock is the subject of an STC application and is not

currently FAA-approved. Paragraphs (f) and (g) of the AD provide for

approval of alternative methods of compliance to address potentially

alleviating devices for the unsafe condition. The commenter may obtain

such an approval upon submission of data substantiating that the

referenced device provides an acceptable level of safety. Therefore, no

change to the final rule is necessary.

``Fine Tune'' the AD

The CAA and others request that the AD should be ``fine tuned''

after issuance, as new data become available. The FAA does not concur

that ``fine tuning'' of the AD is necessary. Paragraphs (f) and (g) of

the AD allow for approval of alternative methods of addressing the

unsafe condition when substantiated properly. As with any AD, if new

information indicates that changes to the AD itself are needed, the FAA

has the authority to revise or supersede this AD.

Request for Clarification

One commenter requests clarification of the procedures that will be

used to obtain future FAA approvals with respect to this rulemaking and

to inform the public of those approvals.

As stated in the final rule, all submissions should be made to the

Atlanta ACO. The Transport Airplane Directorate has established a team

consisting of members from several ACO's to review all requests in

accordance with paragraphs (e) and (f) of this AD. In all other

respects, the process for approvals under this AD will be similar to

that followed for all AD's. For example, in order to protect

applicants' proprietary data, the FAA will notify only the applicant

for an approval of the FAA's decision; while the FAA will disclose

whether approvals have been granted, requests for approved data would

be handled under normal FOIA procedures.

Other Safety Improvements

One commenter states that, because this AD will necessitate large

expenditures and does not address an unsafe condition, requiring

compliance with it will prevent the affected airlines from adopting

other less costly and more effective safety enhancements, such as

updating flight deck equipment. The FAA does not concur. As discussed

previously, this AD addresses a serious unsafe condition. Although

correcting this condition may be expensive, the FAA has determined that

it must be corrected to ensure an acceptable level of safety.

Petitions for Reconsideration

In addition to their comments, several commenters also filed

``Petitions for Reconsideration'' in accordance with 14 CFR 11.93.

Because these petitions were filed prematurely, the FAA considered them

as comments to the Rules Docket. However, because the substance of the

petitions is repetitious of the more extensive comments submitted by

FedEx and others discussed above, the petitions are not discussed

separately in this final rule.

Explanation of Change of Aircraft Certification Office Contact

The FAA has changed the point of contact for obtaining further

information, for obtaining FAA approval of certain actions, and for

submitting substantiating data and analyses in accordance with the

provisions of this AD, due to relocation of certain STC holders.

Conclusion

After careful review of the available data, including the comments

noted above, the FAA has determined that air safety and the public

interest require the adoption of the rule with the changes previously

described. The FAA has determined that these changes will

neither increase the economic burden on any operator nor increase the

scope of the AD.

Participation at the Public Meeting on the Final Rule

Requests from persons who wish to present oral statements at the

public meeting should be received by the FAA no later than 5 days prior

to the meeting. Such requests should be submitted to Mike Zielinski as

listed in the section titled FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT above, and

should include a written summary of oral remarks to be presented, and

an estimate of time needed for the presentation. Requests received

after the date specified above will be scheduled if there is time

available during the meeting; however, the names of those individuals

may not appear on the written agenda. The FAA will prepare an agenda of

speakers that will be available at the meeting. To accommodate as many

speakers as possible, the amount of time allocated to each speaker may

be less than the amount of time requested. Those persons desiring to

have available audiovisual equipment should notify the FAA when

requesting to be placed on the agenda.

Purpose of Public Meeting

Because of the high degree of public interest in this AD, the FAA

has scheduled a public meeting to discuss its content and issues

relating to compliance. The FAA's objective is to ensure that all

affected operators and design approval holders have a full

understanding of the issues addressed in the AD and of the actions

necessary to comply with it. The FAA anticipates that, following this

meeting, there will continue to be extensive discussions between the

affected parties and the FAA for the purpose of identifying and

implementing the most timely and cost-effective means to eliminate the

unsafe condition addressed in this AD.

Public Meeting Procedures

Persons who plan to attend the public meeting should be aware of

the following procedures that have been established for this meeting:

1. There will be no admission fee or other charge to attend or to

participate in the public meeting. The meeting will be open to all

persons who have requested in advance to present statements, or who

register on the day of the meeting (between 8:30 a.m. and 9:00 a.m.)

subject to availability of space in the meeting room.

2. Representatives from the FAA will conduct the public meeting. A

technical panel of FAA experts will be established to discuss

information presented by participants.

3. The FAA will try to accommodate all speakers; therefore, it may

be necessary to limit the time available for an individual or group. If

necessary, the public meeting may be extended to evenings or additional

days. If practicable, the meeting may be accelerated to enable

adjournment in less than the time scheduled.

4. Sign and oral interpretation can be made available at the public

meeting, as well assistive listening device, if requested 5 calendar

days before the meeting.

5. The public meeting will be recorded by a court reporter. Any

person who is interested in purchasing a copy of the transcript should

contact the court reporter directly. This information will be available

at the meeting.

6. The FAA requests that persons participating in the public

meeting provide 10 copies of all materials to be presented for

distribution to the panel members; other copies may be provided to the

audience at the discretion of the participant.

Regulatory Evaluation Summary

The regulations adopted herein will not have substantial direct

effects on the States, on the relationship between the national

government and the States, or on the distribution of power and

responsibilities among the various levels of government. Therefore, in

accordance with Executive Order 12612, it is determined that this final

rule does not have sufficient federalism implications to warrant the

preparation of a Federalism Assessment.

The FAA conducted a Cost Analysis and Final Regulatory Flexibility

Analysis to determine the regulatory impacts of this and three other

AD's to operators of all 244 U.S.-registered Boeing Model 727 passenger

airplanes that have been converted to cargo-carrying configurations

under 10 STC's held by four companies. This analysis is included in the

Rules Docket for each AD. The FAA has determined that approximately

four 727-200's operated by one carrier were converted under Pemco

STC's. This carrier also operates nine converted 727's affected by

other STC's. [There were 15 727's for which the FAA could not identify

the STC holder. It is possible that these airplanes were also converted

under a Kitty Hawk STC (STC previously held by ATAZ, Inc.) Their costs

are not included here.]

Assuming that the operator of affected airplanes converted under

Kitty Hawk STC's will comply with the restricted interim operating

conditions set forth in the AD, the FAA estimates that this operator

will not lose revenues during the 28-month interim period after the

effective date of the AD. During the interim period, these airplanes

will be limited to a total of 8,000 lbs. per pair of adjacent

containers (a total of 36,000 to 48,000 lbs., depending on the number

of pallets) because none of the Kitty Hawk-converted 727's have

approved side restraints. Assuming typical payloads ranging from 34,835

lbs. for a 727-100 with nine pallets to 47,820 lbs. for a 727-200 with

12 pallets, none of the operators of Kitty Hawk-converted airplanes

will lose revenues during this interim period.

The Cost Analysis and Final Regulatory Flexibility Analysis,

completed by the FAA and included in the Rules Dockets, estimates that

affected airplanes can be modified at a cost of $385,000 per airplane

to carry the maximum payloads currently allowed, or a total of $1.5

million for the four Kitty Hawk 727's. The FAA expects that the

operator will modify its airplanes during the 28-month interim period,

scheduling the modifications to coincide with periodic maintenance. A

modification will require that the airplane be removed from service for

a period of 17 days; the FAA conservatively estimates that scheduling a

modification during periodic maintenance will reduce the net time out

of service by two days. The FAA estimates the lost revenue during this

15-day period will be $14,829 per day, per 727-100, and $23,405 per

day, per 727-200. The total down-time lost revenue for the operator

will be $1.4 million. This estimate conservatively assumes that cargo

is not shifted from airplanes being modified to other airplanes. Such

cargo shifting is typical industry practice and would reduce the costs

attributable to lost revenues. Incremental fuel costs to carry the

additional weight of the floor modification will be $17,000 over the

28-month period, as airplanes are modified. When all affected Kitty

Hawk 727's are modified, additional fuel costs will be about $1,100 per

month.

The total cost, therefore, to modify the fleet of affected 727's

that were originally modified to the Kitty Hawk STC's, including lost

revenues while the airplanes are out of service and modification costs,

is $3.0 million, or $2.7 million discounted at seven percent.

The Regulatory Flexibility Act of 1980 (RFA), as amended by the

Small Business Regulatory Enforcement Fairness Act of 1996 (SBREFA),

was enacted by Congress to ensure that small

entities are not unnecessarily or disproportionately burdened by

government regulations. The RFA requires a Regulatory Flexibility

Analysis if a rule would have a significant economic impact, either

detrimental or beneficial, on a substantial number of small entities.

The purpose of this analysis is to ensure that the agency has

considered all reasonable regulatory alternatives that will minimize

the rule's economic burdens for affected small entities, while

achieving its safety objectives. Under section 63(b) of the RFA, the

analysis must address:

1. Reasons Why the Agency Is Promulgating the Rule

2. The objectives and legal basis for the rule;

3. The kind and number of small entities to which the rule will

apply;

4. The projected reporting, recordkeeping, and other compliance

requirements of the rule; and

5. All federal rules that may duplicate, overlap, or conflict with

the rule. These elements of the RFA are addressed below.

A. Reasons Why the Agency Is Promulgating the Rule

The FAA has determined that the unreinforced floor structure of the

main cargo deck of converted 727's is not strong enough to enable the

airplane to safely carry the maximum payload that is currently allowed

in this area. The actions specified in this AD are intended to prevent

failure of the floor structure, which could lead to loss of the

airplane.

B. Statement of Objective and Legal Basis

Under the United States Code (U.S.C.), the FAA Administrator is

required to consider the following matter, among others, as being in

the public interest: assigning, maintaining, and enhancing safety and

security as the highest priorities in air commerce. [See 49 U.S.C.

44101(d).] Accordingly, this AD amends Title 14 of the CFR's to require

operators of Boeing 727 airplanes that have been converted from a

passenger to a cargo-carrying (``freighter'') configuration to comply

with certain payload limitations, substantiate data showing other

acceptable limits, or show an alternative method of compliance (AMOC).

C. Regulatory Flexibility Determination

Under the RFA, the FAA must determine whether or not a rule

significantly affects a substantial number of small entities. This

determination is typically based on small entity size and cost

thresholds that vary depending on the affected industry. The entity

affected by this rule operates four U.S.-registered converted Boeing

727 airplanes that have been converted under Kitty Hawk STC's as well

as nine other affected airplanes converted under other STC's. The FAA

has prepared an analysis of cost impacts and has examined possible

regulatory alternatives.

D. Projected Reporting, Recordkeeping, and Other Compliance

Requirements

With two minor exceptions, the rule will not mandate additional

reporting or recordkeeping. First, there will be a negligible one-time

cost to operators to revise their AFM's and Supplements. Second,

operators will be required to keep records of the modifications to

their airplanes. This requirement is common to all maintenance,

preventive maintenance, and alterations under Sec. 91.417, Maintenance

records.

E. Overlapping, Duplicative, or Conflicting Federal Rules

The rule will not overlap, duplicate, or conflict with existing

Federal rules.

F. Analysis of Alternatives

This AD will impose a financial requirement on small entities that

operate 727's that were converted under Kitty Hawk STC's. The FAA

examined potential alternatives to the AD's requirements to minimize

the rule's economic burden for small entities while achieving its

safety objectives. The alternatives are:

Exclude small entities;

Extend the compliance deadline for small entities; and

Establish higher payload limits for small entities.

The FAA has determined that the option to exclude small entities

from the requirements of the rule is not justified. The unsafe

condition that exists on an affected 727 operated by a small entity is

as potentially catastrophic as that on an affected 727 operated by a

large entity. In fact, the average payloads carried by small entities

may exceed the average payloads carried by large operators, resulting

in a higher probability of a catastrophic event.

The FAA also considered options to extend the compliance period for

small operators. The proposed rule established a final compliance date

of 120 days after the effective date of the rule. During this 120-day

period, operators could comply with interim operating conditions that

would enable them to carry higher payloads than those permitted after

that interim period. When the proposed rule was published, the FAA had

information that indicated that a portion of engineering data from an

FAA-approved STC for a floor modification that could be used as an AMOC

would be available within a few months of the proposed rule's

publication. In addition, the FAA estimated that operators would be

able to modify their airplanes within the 120-day interim period.

Hamilton Aviation has received letters of approval for work towards

obtaining an STC for strengthening the floor beams aft of Station 700

and expects to be able to submit additional data in the Fall of 1998

that will provide the basis for an STC for the entire floor. Pemco

World Air Services expects to be able to use Hamilton's engineering

data to modify the floors of the 727's it has converted. The FAA is

confident, therefore, that there will be AMOC's for operators of all

affected airplanes when this final rule is published.

Several commenters to the Rules Dockets for the proposed AD's

rejected the FAA's claim that their airplanes could be modified within

the 120-day interim period. Their arguments were based on the

unavailability of an approved STC that could be used as an AMOC (or, at

that time, even letters of approval toward an STC). Operators also

stated that modification of all 244 U.S.-registered airplanes would be

impossible within a 120-day time frame.

The FAA agrees 120 days is unrealistic and would have severe

economic consequences as operators would be required to reduce their

payloads substantially at the end of the interim period. In the final

rule, therefore, the FAA extends the interim period to 28 months. This

will permit operators to modify their airplanes during regularly

scheduled maintenance, minimizing down time and associated lost

revenues. This change will be especially beneficial to small entities

that may find it difficult to find alternative means of carrying cargo.

Finally, the FAA rejects the compliance alternative that would

reduce payloads from those currently required but would establish

higher payload limits than those for larger entities. This alternative

is unacceptable because the unsafe condition is dependent on the size

of the payload, not the size of the entity. The FAA cannot permit a

small entity to operate under an unsafe condition.

Title II of the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of 1995 (the Act),

enacted as Pub. L. 104-4 on March 22, 1995, requires each Federal

agency, to the extent permitted by law, to prepare a written assessment

of the effects of any

Federal mandate in a proposed or final agency rule that may result in

the expenditure by State, local, and tribal governments, in the

aggregate, or by the private sector, of $100 million or more (adjusted

annually for inflation) in any one year. Section 204(a) of the Act, 2

U.S.C. 1534(a), requires the Federal agency to develop an effective

process to permit timely input by elected officers (or their designees)

of State, local, and tribal governments on a proposed ``significant

intergovernmental mandate.'' A ``significant intergovernmental

mandate'' under the Act is any provision in a Federal agency regulation

that would impose an enforceable duty upon State, local, and tribal

governments, in the aggregate, of $100 million (adjusted annually for

inflation) in any one year. Section 203 of the Act, 2 U.S.C. 1533,

which supplements section 204(a), provides that before establishing any

regulatory requirements that might significantly or uniquely affect

small governments, the agency shall have developed a plan that, among

other things, provides for notice to potentially affected small

governments, if any, and for a meaningful and timely opportunity to

provide input in the development of regulatory proposals.

This AD does not contain any Federal intergovernmental or private

sector mandate. Therefore, the requirements of Title II of the Unfunded

Mandates Reform Act of 1995 do not apply.

List of Subjects in 14 CFR Part 39

Air transportation, Aircraft, Aviation safety, Safety.

Adoption of the Amendment

Accordingly, pursuant to the authority delegated to me by the

Administrator, the Federal Aviation Administration amends part 39 of

the Federal Aviation Regulations (14 CFR part 39) as follows:

PART 39--AIRWORTHINESS DIRECTIVES

1. The authority citation for part 39 continues to read as follows:

Authority: 49 U.S.C. 106(g), 40113, 44701.

Sec. 39.13 [Amended]

2. Section 39.13 is amended by adding the following new

airworthiness directive:

98-26-20 Boeing: Amendment 39-10963. Docket 97-NM-80-AD.

Applicability: Model 727 series airplanes that have been

converted from a passenger to a cargo-carrying (``freighter'')

configuration in accordance with Supplemental Type Certificate

ST00015AT; certificated in any category.

Note 1: This AD applies to each airplane identified in the

preceding applicability provision, regardless of whether it has been

otherwise modified, altered, or repaired in the area subject to the

requirements of this AD. For airplanes that have been modified,

altered, or repaired so that the performance of the requirements of

this AD is affected, the owner/operator must request approval for an

alternative method of compliance in accordance with paragraph (g) of

this AD. The request should include an assessment of the effect of

the modification, alteration, or repair on the unsafe condition

addressed by this AD; and, if the unsafe condition has not been

eliminated, the request should include specific proposed actions to

address it.

Compliance: Required as indicated, unless accomplished

previously.

Note 2: The payload limitations specified in this AD are in

addition to payload limitations that are otherwise applicable and do

not allow for increases in payloads beyond those specified in such

limitations.

To prevent structural failure of the floor beams of the main cargo

deck, which could lead to loss of the airplane, accomplish the

following:

(a) Except as provided in paragraphs (b) and (c) of this AD, within

90 days after the effective date of this AD, accomplish the

requirements of paragraph (a)(1) or (a)(2) of this AD, as applicable.

(1) For airplanes that transport containers or pallets that have

been manufactured in accordance with National Aerospace Standard

(NAS) 3610 Size Codes ``A,'' ``B,'' ``C,'' ``D,'' or ``E,''

containers: Revise the Limitations Section of all FAA-approved

Airplane Flight Manuals (AFM) and AFM Supplements, and the

Limitations Section of all FAA-approved Airplane Weight and Balance

Supplements to include the following information. This may be

accomplished by inserting a copy of this AD in all AFM's, AFM

Supplements, and Weight and Balance Supplements.

``LIMITATIONS

All containers with one door must be oriented with the door side

of the container facing forward, except the door of the first

container aft of the cargo barrier may face aft.

The location of the horizontal center of gravity for the total

payload within each container or pallet shall not vary more than 10

percent (8.8 inches) from the geometric center of the base of the

container or pallet for the forward and aft direction, and 10

percent of the width from the geometric center of the base of the

container or pallet for the left or right direction.''

``PAYLOAD LIMITATIONS

For containers or pallets that have been manufactured in

accordance with National Aerospace Standard (NAS) 3610 Size Code

``A'' (88 by 125 inches), ``B'' (88 by 108 inches), or ``C'' (88 by

118 inches):

Do not exceed a total weight of 3,000 pounds per container or

pallet on the main cargo deck, except in the area adjacent to the

side cargo door. In the side cargo door area, for all containers or

pallets completely or partially located between Body Station 440 and

Body Station 660, those containers or pallets are restricted to a

maximum payload of 2,700 pounds per container or pallet. The 3,000

and 2,700 pound payload limits include the payload in the lower lobe

cargo compartments and any other load applied to the bottom of the

floor beams of the main cargo deck for the same body station

location as the container or pallet on the main cargo deck.

For containers or pallets that have been manufactured in

accordance with NAS 3610 Size Code ``D'' (88 by 54 inches) or ``E''

(88 by 53 inches) containers:

Do not exceed a total weight of 1,500 pounds per container or

pallet on the main cargo deck, except in the area adjacent to the

side cargo door. In the side cargo door area, for all containers or

pallets completely or partially located between Body Station 440 and

Body Station 660, those containers or pallets are restricted to a

maximum payload of 1,350 pounds per container or pallet. The 1,500

and 1,350 pound payload limits include the payload in the lower lobe

cargo compartments and any other load applied to the bottom of the

floor beams of the main cargo deck for the same body station

location as the container or pallet on the main cargo deck.''

(2) For airplanes on which any other containers or pallets are

transported: Revise the Limitations Section of all FAA-approved

AFM's and AFM Supplements, and the Limitations Section of all FAA-

approved Airplane Weight and Balance Supplements, in accordance with

a method approved by the Manager, Standardization Branch, ANM-113,

FAA, Transport Airplane Directorate.

Note 3: The weight restrictions to be approved under paragraph

(a)(2) will be consistent with the limitations specified in

paragraph (a)(1) of this AD.

(b) For airplanes that ARE equipped with side vertical cargo

container restraints that have been approved by the Manager,

Standardization Branch, ANM-113: As an op

This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.