Case law
Opinions from 1658 to today.
10,000+ results
1.89s
Gloria Bustillos v. El Paso County Hospital Dist
891 F.3d 214 · Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit · May 23, 2018
The district court held those allegations cannot overcome the Doctors’ and Nurses’ qualified immunity because the right at issue was not clearly-established. We agree and affirm on that ground. … Granting of qualified immunity on the “clearly-established” prong is not the same as holding that no constitutional violation occurred. That would conflate the two prongs of qualified immunity.
Cited 45 timesPublishedMcClelland v. Katy Indep Sch Dist
63 F.4th 996 · Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit · Mar 31, 2023
Whether McClelland’s free speech rights were clearly established “A Government official’s conduct violates clearly established law when, at the time of the challenged conduct, ‘[t]he contours … established so as to defeat qualified immunity for Hull. 2.
Cited 57 timesPublished63 F.4th 971 · Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit · Mar 30, 2023
conduct is clearly established.”22 It just isn’t enough to identify a right as “a broad general proposition.”23 The district court did not address qualified immunity’s second step. … Griffin27 supports that Jarrett and Bridges violated clearly established law.
Cited 32 timesPublishedPeter Clayton McClendon v. City of Columbia, City of Columbia James R. Carney
305 F.3d 314 · Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit · Sep 5, 2002
established law, and that he was not entitled to qualified immunity. … entitled to qualified immunity, finding that “the law on third-party entry into homes was [not] clearly established in April 1992.”
Cited 558 timesPublished51 F.4th 125 · Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit · Oct 12, 2022
But unpublished opinions “do not establish any binding law for the circuit,” so “they cannot be the source of clearly established law for the qualified immunity analysis.” Marks v. … This court denied the officer qualified immunity.
Cited 64 timesPublished54 F.4th 307 · Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit · Nov 30, 2022
But Carswell says this was “the opposite of a refusal or failure to rule” because the “district court clearly indicated it would timely address Individual Defendants’ qualified immunity defense.” … No. 21-10171 established law, a defendant pleading qualified immunity is entitled to dismissal before the commencement of discovery.”
Cited 138 timesPublished585 F.3d 839 · Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit · Oct 16, 2009
Alternatively, even if Zemlik used excessive force, he is nonetheless entitled to qualified immunity because his conduct was not objectively unreasonable in light of the clearly established law at the time of his actions … Therefore, Zemlik’s actions were objectively reasonable under clearly established law, and he is entitled to qualified immunity.
Cited 219 timesPublished26 F.4th 270 · Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit · Feb 11, 2022
“Once a defendant raises a qualified-immunity defense, the burden shifts to the plaintiff to show that (1) the official violated a statutory or constitutional right, and (2) the right was ‘clearly established’ at the … Whatever one might think about qualified immunity, I think we’re duty bound to say the law is not clearly established when it takes a full-page flow chart to hold otherwise.
Cited 59 timesPublishedKenneth Ratliff v. Aransas County, Texas
948 F.3d 281 · Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit · Jan 15, 2020
He offered the testimony because of a failing memory and to rebut the deputies’ qualified immunity defense in this § 1983 case. … The second “asks whether the right in question was ‘clearly established’ at the time of the violation.” Id. at 656.
Cited 156 timesPublished123 F.4th 736 · Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit · Dec 13, 2024
Forsyth, 472 U.S. 511, 528–30 (1985) (qualified immunity based on a lack of clearly established law); Plumhoff v. … established to strip an official of qualified immunity.
Cited 17 timesPublished560 F.3d 404 · Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit · Feb 25, 2009
The Clearly Established Right At the second step of the qualified immunity inquiry, we ask whether the violated constitutional right was clearly established at the time of the violation. … The right in question was therefore clearly established on February 28, 2006, and this is sufficient to affirmatively answer the qualified immunity question of our inquiry.
Abrogated on other grounds by Mullenix v. Luna, 136 S. Ct. 305 (2015)Cited 290 timesPublishedSonia Garcia v. Wesley Blevins
957 F.3d 596 · Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit · Apr 30, 2020
We therefore hold Blevins is entitled to qualified immunity because he did not violate clearly established law. IV. … The Garcias also assert that, if we conclude the law was not clearly established, we should reconsider our approach to qualified immunity.
Cited 80 timesPublishedPeggy Shumpert v. City of Tupelo, Mississip
905 F.3d 310 · Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit · Sep 24, 2018
The resolution of this case turns primarily on whether these rights were clearly established, so we will begin with that step of the qualified immunity analysis. … established law. 60 He is therefore entitled to qualified immunity on this claim. 61 C.
Cited 125 timesPublishedJerry Lynn Young v. Neil B. Biggers, Jr., J.W. Collins
938 F.2d 565 · Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit · Jul 26, 1991
Public officers “are shielded from liability for civil damages insofar as their conduct does not violate clearly established statutory or constitutional rights of which a reasonable person would have known.” Lynch v. … Herring is entitled to a qualified immunity as Sheriff.
Cited 85 timesPublishedCreech Poole v. City of Shreveport
13 F.4th 420 · Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit · Sep 10, 2021
Qualified immunity shields officers from liability unless their conduct violates a clearly established federal right of which a reasonable person would have known. Kisela v. Hughes, 138 S. … of clearly established law.
Cited 65 timesPublished21 F.3d 597 · Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit · Jun 28, 1994
Qualified immunity protects a police officer from liability if a reasonable competent law enforcement officer would not have known that his actions violated clearly established law. Anderson v. … The examination of a claim of qualified immunity is a two-step process. The first inquiry is whether the plaintiff has alleged a violation of a clearly established constitutional' right. Siegert v.
Cited 127 timesPublishedDel A. v. Edwin Edwards, Individually and as Governor of the State of Louisiana
855 F.2d 1148 · Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit · Sep 28, 1988
The district court denied the motion, holding that because the alleged illegal actions violated clearly established statutory and federal constitutional rights, qualified immunity was not available. … Id. *1151 Thus, the concept of “clearly established” had to be defined narrowly to serve the goals of qualified immunity.
Cited 21 timesPublishedCarlos Gonzalez v. Able Huerta
826 F.3d 854 · Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit · Jun 23, 2016
Because we find no violation of clearly established law, we AFFIRM. I. … Huerta asserted qualified immunity and moved for summary judgment.
Cited 17 timesPublished73 F.4th 400 · Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit · Jul 17, 2023
Qualified immunity involves answering two questions: (1) “whether the officer violated a constitutional right,” and (2) “whether the ‘right at issue was “clearly established” at the time of [the] alleged misconduct. … Unlike the plaintiffs in Joseph, Parker identified cases in his district court briefing, as well as in his briefing to this court, that addressed the clearly-established-law prong of the qualified immunity analysis
Cited 17 timesPublishedDonald Gagne, Etc. v. City of Galveston, and Mike Putnal
805 F.2d 558 · Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit · Dec 9, 1986
qualified immunity from damages for his death. … But until then, the defense of qualified immunity remains available.
Cited 87 timesPublished
Ask Donna