Fisheries of the Caribbean, Gulf of Mexico, and South Atlantic; Coastal Migratory Pelagic Resources of the Gulf of Mexico and South Atlantic; Changes in Catch Limits

FederalRegulations

Ask Donna

How this section applies to your facts.

Federal Register › Vol. 61 › 61 FR 48848

This text was captured on Sep 30, 2026. It is a snapshot, not a live feed, so check the official code before relying on it.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE

National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration

50 CFR Part 622

[Docket No. 950725189-6245-04 ; I.D. 060696A]

RIN 0648-AI92

Fisheries of the Caribbean, Gulf of Mexico, and South Atlantic;

Coastal Migratory Pelagic Resources of the Gulf of Mexico and South

Atlantic; Changes in Catch Limits

AGENCY: National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS), National Oceanic and

Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), Commerce.

ACTION: Final rule.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: In accordance with the framework procedure for adjusting

management measures of the Fishery Management Plan for the Coastal

Migratory Pelagic Resources of the Gulf of Mexico and South Atlantic

(FMP), NMFS implements commercial vessel trip limits for the Atlantic

migratory group of king mackerel. The intended effects of this rule are

to preclude an early closure of the commercial fishery, protect king

mackerel from overfishing, and maintain healthy stocks while still

allowing catches by important commercial fisheries.

EFFECTIVE DATE: September 23, 1996.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Mark F. Godcharles, 813-570-5305.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: The fisheries for coastal migratory pelagic

resources are managed under the FMP. The FMP was prepared by the Gulf

of Mexico and South Atlantic Fishery Management Councils and is

implemented by regulations at 50 CFR part 622 under the authority of

the Magnuson Fishery Conservation and Management Act (Magnuson Act).

In accordance with the framework rulemaking procedures of the FMP,

the South Atlantic Council (Council) recommended, and NMFS published, a

proposed rule to establish commercial vessel trip limits for the

Atlantic migratory group of king mackerel (61 FR 34785, July 3, 1996).

That proposed rule described the FMP framework procedures through which

the Council recommended the trip limits and explained the need and

rationale for

them. Those descriptions are not repeated here.

Comments and Responses

Three letters were received during the comment period. One from the

Council supported the proposed trip limits and requested approval and

expedient implementation to forestall a possible closure during the

1996-97 season. The other two--from a gillnet fisherman and a

commercial fishermen's organization--opposed the trip limits. Similar

comments were addressed in the final rule implementing the partially

approved 1995-96 mackerel catch specifications (60 FR 57686; November

17, 1995) and in the proposed rule announcing this action (61 FR 34785;

July 3, 1996).

National Standard 1

Comment: One commenter stated that trip limits for Atlantic group

king mackerel are unnecessary and inconsistent with maintaining optimum

yield (OY) and maximizing benefits to everyone. He further commented

that such proposals designed to decrease efficiency and prevent quota

overruns are not justifiable considering that the annual commercial

quota has not been harvested since the 1988-89 season and that the

resource is not considered overfished.

Response: National Standard 1 requires conservation and management

measures to prevent overfishing while achieving, on a continuing basis,

the OY from each fishery. NMFS believes the trip limits will not

preclude harvest of the commercial quota or achievement of OY. Rather,

in consideration of newly available stock assessment information and

the Council's recent actions to reduce total allowable catch (TAC) and

quotas, NMFS has determined that the trip limits are necessary to

achieve the objectives of the FMP and those specified for this action.

Specifically, the trip limits should: Prevent user groups from

exceeding their traditional portion of the quota; reduce the likelihood

of a closure that would negatively impact commercial fisheries north of

Florida; limit harvest during the spawning period, and, thus protect

the stock from recruitment overfishing and help in rebuilding it to the

level capable of meeting the long-term OY target of the FMP; and

minimize gear and user group conflicts resulting from possible effort

shifts by fishermen displaced from other fisheries.

This year's stock assessment for Atlantic group king mackerel

provided much lower estimates of the spawning potential ratio (SPR) and

the acceptable biological catch (ABC) range than in previous years.

Levels of SPR form the basis of the FMP definitions for ``overfished,''

``overfishing,'' and ``OY.'' The recommended ABC range establishes the

boundaries for the Council's selection of the annual TAC. The 1996 SPR

estimate, which declined to 32 percent from last year's estimate of 55

percent, is above the 20 percent SPR level delineating overfished

stocks but is below the 40 percent SPR level required to meet the long-

term, target level OY proposed by the Council in FMP Amendment 8. The

estimated 1996 range of ABC decreased to 4.4 - 6.8 million lb (1,996 -

3,084 mt) from the 1995 estimate of 7.3 - 15.5 million lb (3,311 -

7,031 mt). Accordingly, the Council recommended that the 1996-97 TAC be

decreased from 7.3 to 6.8 million lb (3,311 to 3,048 mt).

If the Council's recommended TAC is approved, the resulting 1996-97

commercial quota of 2.52 million lb (1,143 mt) will be somewhat above

levels harvested during the past 4 fishing years, which ranged from

about 2.0 - 2.2 million lb (907 - 998 mt). Moreover, this resulting

quota will be similar to catch levels during the preceding 3-year

period (1989-90 through 1991-92 fishing years), which ranged from 2.5 -

2.7 million lb (1,134 - 1,225 mt). Therefore, at the expected

commercial quota level of 2.52 million lb, implementation of vessel

trip limits is necessary to avoid an early closure of the fishery and

help ensure equitable distribution of the commercial quota among

traditional fisheries.

As discussed in detail in the preamble to the proposed rule (60 FR

34785; July 3, 1996), the Council also proposed the trip limits to

prevent excessive harvest of pre-spawning and spawning fish and, thus,

to avoid recruitment overfishing of both Atlantic and Gulf groups of

king mackerel. The trip limits should prevent excessive catches of the

Atlantic group king mackerel throughout the spring/summer spawning

season and of the Gulf group king mackerel during April. King mackerel

harvest in April, unrestricted by daily vessel trip limits, could

result in the unintentional taking of large quantities of Gulf group

king mackerel when such fish are still located within the boundaries of

the Atlantic group. The Council considers such catches ``double-

dipping,'' (i.e., overrunning of Gulf group quotas that have already

been harvested during the south Florida winter fishing season). Such

overruns contribute to exceeding TAC, or the yearly OY target, and

increase the risk of recruitment overfishing and of not achieving OY.

According to the Council's impact analyses, the trip limits would

alter or reduce the efficiency of operations for some fishermen. For

some years and areas, particularly south Florida, the trip limits would

have substantially reduced some individual vessel's landings as well as

the area's total catch. Nevertheless, given the estimated reduced stock

size and the lower commercial quota for the 1996-97 fishing year,

implementation of trip limits is necessary to prevent recruitment

overfishing, to avoid disproportionate and inequitable harvest of the

available quota by one user group compared to another, and to minimize

the possibility of an early closure of the commercial fishery.

Avoidance of such problems is consistent with National Standards 1, 3,

and 4 (as discussed herein) and with the objectives of the FMP (e.g.,

stabilize fishery yields at maximum sustainable yield (MSY) and

minimize gear and user group conflicts). For these reasons, NMFS

believes that the trip limits strike a reasonable balance between

achieving efficient resource utilization and promoting stability of the

socioeconomic and biological characteristics of the fishery.

National Standard 2

Comment: A commenter stated that the trip limits, particularly the

1,250-lb (567-kg) commercial trip limit proposed for off Monroe County

(Florida Keys), are not supported by the best available scientific

information. He submitted an annotated bibliography suggesting that the

trip limits are not designed to provide maximum protection for spawning

king mackerel. For example, the largest trip limit is proposed for an

area off the South Atlantic Bight, which he contends is a major

spawning area. However, the most restrictive trip limits are proposed

for south Florida in areas where the commenter suggests the

contribution of spawning fish is not important. He also states that off

North Carolina, king mackerel have a prolonged spawning season which

peaks June through August. Therefore, he infers that few, if any, king

mackerel spawn in the Florida Keys area. Finally, the commenter

speculates that the proposals were not reviewed by the Council's

Scientific and Statistical Committee (SSC).

Response: National Standard 2 requires conservation and management

measures to be based upon the best scientific information available.

The Director of NMFS' Southeast Fisheries Science Center has certified

that the trip limits are based on the best available scientific

information and appear risk-averse in maintaining the stock at a size

level not posing risks of recruitment

overfishing. Furthermore, the trip limit proposals have been reviewed

by the SSCs of both the South Atlantic and Gulf of Mexico Fishery

Management Councils.

The lower trip limits are designed to prevent excessive catches and

overfishing off south Florida where about half to two-thirds of the

commercial quotas for the Atlantic and Gulf groups of king mackerel are

taken annually. The trip limits off south Florida should protect

against double-dipping of quotas already taken during the winter season

and allow greater escapement for overwintering fish to migrate to

summer spawning grounds. They also would preclude excessive harvest

during summer spawning months.

Although larval collection surveys have provided some information

on the location of king mackerel spawning grounds, the findings of the

surveys are not considered conclusive because the patchy occurrence of

larvae in oceanic waters has made biological sampling difficult.

Therefore, information yielded from sparse larval data collections off

south Florida is unlikely to be representative or an accurate indicator

of the actual spawning contribution of this area. Presently,

determination of this type of information is confounded by seasonal

migrations, protracted spawning seasons, and inconclusive findings of

stock identification genetics studies. Until further scientific

information becomes available, protection of spawners by trip limits,

even in areas considered as minor spawning grounds, is a conservative

approach in a risk-averse management program that prevents overfishing

and rebuilds stocks to long-term OY target levels. As indicated by the

1996 stock assessment, both groups of king mackerel are below SPR

target levels representing the long-term OY.

National Standard 3

Comment: One commenter stated that the different trip limits do not

provide uniform management for the stock throughout its range. He

reasoned that if Atlantic group king mackerel is in jeopardy, fishing

mortality from commercial fishing should be reduced uniformly

throughout its range.

Response: National Standard 3 requires that an individual stock of

fish, to the extent practicable, be managed as a unit throughout its

range, and that interrelated stocks of fish be managed as a unit or in

close coordination. The goal of National Standard 3 is not to manage

stocks with identical measures but to manage a given stock as a unit

throughout its range. Indeed, National Standard 6 requires conservation

and management measures to take into account and allow for variations

among, and contingencies in, fisheries, fishery resources, and catches.

The comments received in opposition to the proposed rule were

considered to be rigid interpretations of the national standards that

do not reflect accurately the flexibility described in the Guidelines

for Fishery Management Plans and the legislative history of the

Magnuson Act. Consequently, NMFS has determined that the trip limits

are an important part of a risk-adverse program to protect against

overfishing, distribute the annual commercial quota equitably among

resource users throughout the management area, preclude in-season

closure and resultant negative socioeconomic impacts, rebuild the stock

to long-term OY target levels, and, thus, provide the socioeconomic and

conservation benefits intended by the Council.

National Standard 4

Comment: One commenter believed that the trip limit proposals were

not fair and equitable to the commercial fishermen of Monroe County. He

did not believe that, compared to the lower trip limits proposed for

Florida's southeast and Florida Keys fisheries, the higher trip limit

proposed for the northern area logically follows from the Council's

projection of an additional effort shift from nearby fishermen

displaced from New England fishery closures. He stated, ``Ideally, all

users should bear the burden of resource conservation.''

Another commenter indicated that the trip limit proposals were

unjust and unfair to Florida east coast net fishermen. He believed that

the proposed trip limits would eliminate nets in favor of hook-and-line

fishermen. Net fishermen, he stated, should have a share of the east

coast subzone quota similar to that provided by the gillnet quota for

the Florida west coast subzone.

Response: National Standard 4 requires conservation and management

measures to not discriminate between residents of different states; the

allocation or assignment of fishing privileges among U.S. fishermen

must be fair and equitable to all affected fishermen, reasonably

designed to promote conservation, and implemented in a way so as to

prevent any particular individual, corporation, or other entity from

acquiring an excessive share of such privileges.

NMFS believes the trip limits are consistent with National Standard

4. From the perspective of assigning fishing privileges, they would be

fair and equitable, reasonably calculated to promote conservation, and

carried out in such a manner that no particular entity acquires an

excessive share of such privileges. Although there will be some

disadvantage to more efficient fishermen (e.g., high liners or net gear

users), the trip limits are necessary to achieve long-term OY targets

and to maximize overall benefits from the fishery to participants

throughout the management area.

In response to previous comments received, the Council increased

the trip limit proposed for the Florida Keys from 50 fish to 1,250-lb

(567-kg) (about 125 fish) per day. The higher limit was proposed to

help offset costs of producing Atlantic group king mackerel from more

distant fishing grounds and, thus, allow a more efficient and

profitable operation of vessels in that area. The different trip limits

in different areas of the coast may disadvantage some mackerel

fishermen over others. However, the overall benefits to the entire

community of resource users should offset any adverse impacts on

specific fishermen. The 1,250-lb (567-kg) trip limit for the Florida

Keys and the 500-lb (227-kg) trip limit for the Florida east coast

should provide fair access while preventing excessive catches, early

closures, and quota overruns. For these reasons, NMFS believes that the

trip limits satisfy the requirements of National Standard 4 regarding

fairness and equity to all fishery participants throughout the

management area, while providing a rational management approach to

achieve OY.

Concern about the possibilities of effort increasing from displaced

fishermen entering the fishery was only one of several factors

supporting the implementation of trip limits. Some protection from

potential effort shifts will be provided by all the trip limits.

The comment suggesting a separate gillnet quota for Florida

southeast coast fishermen is not within the scope of this action,

therefore, no response is provided.

Other Comments

Comment: The Council chairman stated that, after reviewing the 1996

stock assessment and the decreased SPR estimate, the Council remains

concerned about the status of Atlantic group king mackerel. In

addition, he expressed concern that the TAC reduction recommended by

the Council in response to the lower 1996 ABC range would result in an

early closure of the 1996-97 fishing season, thereby negatively

impacting states north of Florida. To avoid this potential

situation, he expressed the Council's support and request to implement

the trip limits as soon as possible.

Response: During agency review of the proposed action, NMFS

carefully considered these and other comments before approving the

Council's regulatory amendment and issuing this implementing final

rule. NMFS issued this final rule in as timely a manner as practicable

consistent with the Council's stated objectives and concerns about the

effects of an early fishery closure.

Changes from the Proposed Rule

Since the proposed rule was published, NMFS has consolidated most

of its fishery regulations for the Southeast Region into one set of

regulations at 50 CFR part 622 (61 FR 34930, July 3, 1996).

Accordingly, this final rule amends the regulations for coastal

migratory pelagic resources in 50 CFR part 622 in lieu of an amendment

to similar regulations previously contained in part 642. Minor changes

in language have been made to conform to the standards in part 622.

Further, the addition, in logical order, of commercial trip limits for

Atlantic group king mackerel, as contained in this final rule, requires

redesignation of existing paragraphs in Sec. 622.44(a). For convenience

and ease of understanding, this final rule redesignates and reprints

the existing commercial trip limits for Gulf group king mackerel

contained in that paragraph without substantive change.

Classification

This final rule has been determined to be not significant for

purposes of E.O. 12866.

The Assistant General Counsel for Legislation and Regulation of the

Department of Commerce certified to the Chief Counsel for Advocacy of

the Small Business Administration that the proposed rule, if adopted,

would not have a significant economic impact on a substantial number of

small entities. The reasons for this certification were published in

the preamble to the proposed rule (61 FR 34966, July 3, 1996) and are

not repeated here. No comments were received in response to the

proposed rule that required a change in that assessment. As a result, a

regulatory flexibility analysis was not prepared.

To avoid early closure of the commercial Atlantic group king

mackerel fishery and disproportionate harvest of the quota by certain

user groups, it is essential that the trip limits for commercial

vessels that harvest Atlantic group king mackerel from New York through

southwest Florida be implemented as soon as possible. The Assistant

Administrator for Fisheries, NOAA, therefore, finds that good cause

exists, under 5 U.S.C. 553(d)(3), to establish an effective date of

less than 30 days after the date of publication of this final rule. To

provide sufficient notification of the trip limits, particularly to

vessels that may be at sea, NMFS makes the final rule effective

September 23, 1996.

List of Subjects in 50 CFR Part 622

Fisheries, Fishing, Puerto Rico. Reporting and recordkeeping

requirements, Virgin Islands.

Dated: September 11, 1996.

Nancy Foster,

Deputy Assistant Administrator for Fisheries, National Marine Fisheries

Service.

For the reasons set out in the preamble, 50 CFR part 622 is amended

as follows:

PART 622--FISHERIES OF THE CARIBBEAN, GULF, AND SOUTH ATLANTIC

1. The authority citation for part 622 continues to read as

follows:

Authority: 16 U.S.C. 1801 et seq.

2. In Sec. 622.44, paragraph (a) is revised to read as follows:

Sec. 622.44 Commercial trip limits.

* * * * *

(a) King mackerel--(1) Atlantic group. (i) North of 29 deg.25' N.

lat., which is a line directly east from the Flagler/Volusia County,

FL, boundary, king mackerel in or from the EEZ may not be possessed on

board or landed from a vessel in a day in amounts exceeding 3,500 lb

(1,588 kg).

(ii) In the area between 29 deg.25' N. lat. and 28 deg.47.8' N.

lat., which is a line directly east from the Volusia/Brevard County, FL

boundary, king mackerel in or from the EEZ may not be possessed on

board or landed from a vessel in a day in amounts exceeding 3,500 lb

(1,588 kg) from April 1 through October 31.

(iii) In the area between 28 deg.47.8' N. lat. and 25 deg.20.4' N.

lat., which is a line directly east from the Dade/Monroe County, FL

boundary, king mackerel in or from the EEZ may not be possessed on

board or landed from a vessel in a day in amounts exceeding 500 lb (227

kg) from April 1 through October 31.

(iv) In the area between 25 deg.20.4' N. lat. and 25 deg.48' N.

lat., which is a line directly west from the Monroe/Collier County, FL

boundary, king mackerel in or from the EEZ may not be possessed on

board or landed from a vessel in a day in amounts exceeding 1,250 lb

(567 kg) from April 1 through October 31.

(2) Gulf group. Commercial trip limits are established in the

eastern zone as follows. (See Sec. 622.42(c)(1)(i) for specification of

the eastern zone and Sec. 622.42(c)(1)(i)(A)(3) for specifications of

the subzones in the eastern zone.)

(i) Florida east coast subzone. In the Florida east coast subzone,

king mackerel in or from the EEZ may be possessed on board or landed

from a vessel for which a commercial permit for king and Spanish

mackerel has been issued, as required under Sec. 622.4(a)(2)(iv)--

(A) From November 1, each fishing year, until 75 percent of the

subzone's fishing year quota of king mackerel has been harvested--in

amounts not exceeding 50 king mackerel per day.

(B) From the date that 75 percent of the subzone's fishing year

quota of king mackerel has been harvested until a closure of the

Florida east coast subzone has been effected under Sec. 622.43(a)--in

amounts not exceeding 25 king mackerel per day. However, if 75 percent

of the subzone's quota has not been harvested by March 1, the vessel

limit remains at 50 king mackerel per day until the subzone's quota is

filled or until March 31, whichever occurs first.

(ii) Florida west coast subzone--(A) Gillnet gear. (1) In the

Florida west coast subzone, king mackerel in or from the EEZ may be

possessed on board or landed from a vessel for which a commercial

permit with a gillnet endorsement has been issued, as required under

Sec. 622.4(a)(2)(ii), from July 1, each fishing year, until a closure

of the Florida west coast subzone's fishery for vessels fishing with

run-around gillnets has been effected under Sec. 622.43(a)--in amounts

not exceeding 25,000 lb (11,340 kg) per day.

(2) In the Florida west coast subzone:

(i) King mackerel in or from the EEZ may be possessed on board or

landed from a vessel that uses or has on board a run-around gillnet on

a trip only when such vessel has on board a commercial permit for king

and Spanish mackerel with a gillnet endorsement.

(ii) King mackerel from the west coast subzone landed by a vessel

for which such commercial permit with endorsement has been issued will

be counted against the run-around gillnet quota of

Sec. 622.42(c)(1)(i)(A)(2)(ii).

(iii) King mackerel in or from the EEZ harvested with gear other

than run-around gillnet may not be retained on board a vessel for which

such commercial permit with endorsement has been issued.

(B) Hook-and-line gear. In the Florida west coast subzone, king

mackerel in or

from the EEZ may be possessed on board or landed from a vessel with a

commercial permit for king and Spanish mackerel, as required by

Sec. 622.4(a)(2)(iv), and operating under the hook-and-line gear quota

in Sec. 622.42(c)(1)(i)(A)(2)(i):

(1) From July 1, each fishing year, until 75 percent of the

subzone's hook-and-line gear quota has been harvested--in amounts not

exceeding 125 king mackerel per day.

(2) From the date that 75 percent of the subzone's hook-and-line

gear quota has been harvested until a closure of the west coast

subzone's hook-and-line fishery has been effected under

Sec. 622.43(a)--in amounts not exceeding 50 king mackerel per day.

(iii) Notice of trip limit changes. The Assistant Administrator, by

filing a notification of trip limit change with the Office of the

Federal Register, will effect the trip limit changes specified in

paragraphs (a)(2)(i) and (a)(2)(ii)(B) of this section when the

requisite harvest level has been reached or is projected to be reached.

* * * * *

[FR Doc. 96-23769 Filed 9-16-96; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 3510-22-F

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Fisheries of the Caribbean, Gulf of Mexico, and South Atlantic; Coastal Migratory Pelagic Resources of the Gulf of Mexico and South Atlantic; Changes in Catch Limits · 61 FR 48848 | Frix