Trifluralin; Revocation of Food Additive Regulation

FederalRegulations

Ask Donna

How this section applies to your facts.

Federal Register › Vol. 61 › 61 FR 2446

This text was captured on Sep 30, 2026. It is a snapshot, not a live feed, so check the official code before relying on it.

Text

ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY

40 CFR Part 185

[OPP-300394A; FRL-4983-6]

RIN 2070-AB78

Trifluralin; Revocation of Food Additive Regulation

AGENCY: Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).

ACTION: Final rule.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: EPA is revoking the food additive regulation (FAR) for

residues of the herbicide trifluralin in peppermint oil and spearmint

oil. EPA is taking this action because peppermint oil and spearmint oil

are not ready-to-eat commodities, and residues of trifluralin are not

likely to concentrate in ready-to-eat foods containing peppermint and

spearmint oil. Therefore, this FAR is not required.

EFFECTIVE DATE: This final rule becomes effective January 26, 1996.

ADDRESSES: Written objections, requests for a hearing, and/or requests

of stays identified by the document control number, OPP-300394A, must

be submitted by February 26, 1996, and comments on all of the above

must be submitted by March 11, 1996 to the OPP docket: Public Response

and Program Resources Branch, Field Operations Division (7506C), Office

of Pesticide Programs, Environmental Protection Agency, 401 M St., SW.,

Washington, DC 20460. Hand deliver to: Rm. 1132, CM #2, 1921 Jefferson

Davis Hwy., Arlington, VA.

Information submitted as a filing concerning this document may be

claimed confidential by marking any part or all of that information as

``Confidential Business Information'' (CBI). Information so marked will

not be disclosed except in accordance with procedures set forth in 40

CFR part 2. A copy of the filings that does not contain CBI must be

submitted for inclusion in the public record. Information not marked

confidential may be disclosed publicly by EPA without prior notice. All

written (non-CBI) filings will be available for public inspection in

Rm. 1132 at the address given above, from 8 a.m. to 4:30 p.m., Monday

through Friday, excluding legal holidays.

A copy of objections and hearing requests filed with the Hearing

Clerk may also be submitted electronically by sending electronic mail

(e-mail) to: [email protected]. Copies of objections and

hearing requests must be submitted as an ASCII file avoiding the use of

special characters and any form of encryption. Copies of objections and

hearing requests will also be accepted on disks in WordPerfect in 5.1

file format or ASCII file format. All copies of objections and hearing

requests in electronic form must be identified by the docket number

[OPP-300394A]. No Confidential Business Information (CBI) should be

submitted through e-mail. Electronic copies of objections and hearing

requests on this rule may be filed online at many Federal Depository

Libraries. Additional information on electronic submissions can be

found below in this document.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: By mail: Niloufar Nazmi, Special

Review Branch (7508W), Environmental Protection Agency, 401 M St., SW.,

Washington, DC 20460. Office location and telephone number: Crystal

Mall #2, Rm. 1113, 1921 Jefferson Davis Hwy., Arlington, VA, (703)-308-

8028; e-mail: [email protected].

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

I. Introduction

EPA is revoking the FAR for residues of the herbicide trifluralin

in peppermint oil and spearmint oil (40 CFR 185.5900).

A. Statutory Background

The Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (FFDCA), 21 U.S.C. 301 et

seq., authorizes the establishment by regulation of maximum permissible

levels of pesticides in foods. Such regulations are commonly referred

to as ``tolerances.'' Without such a tolerance or an exemption from the

requirement of a tolerance, a food containing a pesticide residue is

``adulterated'' under section 402 of the Federal Food, Drug, and

Cosmetic Act (FFDCA) and may not be legally moved in interstate

commerce. 21 U.S.C. 331, 342. EPA was authorized to establish pesticide

tolerances under Reorganization Plan No. 3 of 1970. 5 U.S.C. App. at

1343 (1988). Monitoring and enforcement of pesticide tolerances are

carried out by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and the U.S.

Department of Agriculture (USDA). EPA can establish a tolerance in

response to a petition (FFDCA sections 408(d)(1) and 409(b)(1)) or on

its own initiative (FFDCA sections 408(e) and 409(d)).

The FFDCA has separate provisions for tolerances for pesticide

residues on raw agricultural commodities (RACs) and tolerances on

processed food. For pesticide residues in or on RACs, EPA establishes

tolerances, or exemptions from tolerances when appropriate, under

section 408 of the act (21 U.S.C. 346a.) EPA regulates pesticide

residues in processed foods under section 409 of

the act, which pertains to ``food additives'' (21 U.S.C. 348). Maximum

residue regulations established under section 409 of the act are

commonly referred to as food additive regulations (hereafter referred

to as ``FARs''). Section 409 FARs are needed, however, only for certain

pesticide residues in processed food. Under section 402(a)(2) of the

FFDCA, a pesticide residue in processed food generally will not render

the food adulterated if the residue results from application of the

pesticide to a RAC and the residue in the processed food when ready to

eat is below the RAC tolerance. This exemption in section 402(a)(2) is

commonly referred to as the ``flow-through'' provision because it

allows the section 408 raw food tolerance to flow through to the

processed food forms. Thus, a section 409 food additive regulation is

only necessary to prevent foods from being deemed adulterated when the

level of the pesticide residue in a processed food when ready to eat is

greater than the tolerance prescribed for the RAC, or if the processed

food itself is treated or comes in contact with a pesticide.

B. Regulatory Background

In the Federal Register of July 14, 1993 (58 FR 37862) EPA issued a

final order, hereafter referred to as ``1993 Order'', that was subject

to objections and requests for a hearing and that revoked the

trifluralin FAR for peppermint oil and spearmint oil. The 1993 Order

was issued in response to the decision by the U.S. Court of Appeals,

Ninth Circuit, in the case of Les v. Reilly, 968 F.2d 985 (9th Cir.

1992), cert. denied, 113 S.Ct. 1361 (1993). DowElanco, the manufacturer

of trifluralin, filed objections to the revised Order, as well as

requests for a hearing on, and a stay of, the revocation Order. In the

Federal Register of June 30, 1994 (59 FR 33684), EPA issued a final

order (hereafter referred to as ``1994 Order'') denying DowElanco's

objections and requests for a hearing and a stay of the revocation. On

July 14, 1994, DowElanco filed an action in the U.S. Court of Appeals,

D.C. Circuit, for review of EPA's 1993 Order, and moved for summary

reversal or, in the alternative, an emergency stay of the revocation.

E.I. DuPont DeNemours and Co., et al. v. EPA, Civ. Action No. 94-1504

(D.C. Cir.). On August 24, 1994, the Court denied DowElanco's motion

for summary reversal, but issued an emergency stay of the revocation.

In the Federal Register of September 12, 1994 (59 FR 46768), EPA

reinstated the FAR for trifluralin (as well as for benomyl), and they

are currently in effect.

On September 11, 1992, the National Food Processors Association

(NFPA) and other organizations filed a petition with EPA challenging,

among other things, EPA's interpretation of the phrase ``ready to eat''

in the Delaney Clause. (Petition to the Environmental Protection

Agency, Office of Pesticide Programs, Concerning EPA's Pesticide

Concentration Policy (1992)) (hereinafter cited as ``NFPA petition'').

The petition requested that EPA apply the term ``ready to eat'' in the

flow-through provision according to what NFPA asserts is its plain

meaning. EPA sought public comment on the petition (58 FR 7470, Feb. 5,

1993). In the Federal Register of June 14, 1995 (60 FR 31300), EPA

issued a partial response to the NFPA petition, addressing the ``ready

to eat'' policy. In that response, EPA agreed that the term ``ready to

eat'' food has a common-sense meaning of food which is consumed without

further preparation, and stated its intention to apply that

interpretation in future actions.

In the Federal Register of July 28, 1995 (60 FR 38781), EPA issued

a proposed rule to revoke the FAR for trifluralin on peppermint and

spearmint oils. In the same proposed rule, EPA proposed to withdraw its

Order dated July 14, 1993 (58 FR 37862), to the extent that it revoked

the FAR for trifluralin in peppermint oil and spearmint oil. Today's

document contains a final rule revoking the trifluralin FAR and

responds to comments on the July 28, 1995 proposal

II. Revocation of the Food Additive Regulations for Trifluralin in

Peppermint Oil and Spearmint Oil

EPA has determined that no section 409 FAR is necessary for mint

oils because they are not ``ready to eat'' processed foods, and because

``ready to eat'' foods containing mint oils are unlikely to have

trifluralin residues greater than the RAC tolerances for peppermint hay

and spearmint hay. The proposed rule for this action was published in

the Federal Register of July 28, 1995 (60 FR 38781). The Federal

Register document and all the supporting documents are in the OPP

docket number 300394.

As noted above, under FFDCA section 402(a)(2), processed foods

containing pesticide residues are not deemed adulterated if the level

of pesticide residues in the processed food ``when ready to eat is not

greater than the tolerance prescribed for the raw agricultural

commodity.'' EPA believes that the common sense meaning of the term

``ready to eat'' food is food ready for consumption without further

preparation. Mint oils are not consumed ``as is'' but are used as a

flavoring in other foods. As such, peppermint oil and spearmint oil are

not ``ready to eat.''

Mint oils are used as flavoring agents in foods such as beverages,

ice cream, candy, and chewing gum. Chewing gum is a ready-to-eat food

with the highest concentration of peppermint and spearmint oils. The

information available to EPA shows that trifluralin residues are

diluted during manufacturing so that there is no concentration over the

RAC tolerance in the ready-to-eat chewing gum. Thus, no section 409 FAR

is needed for peppermint oil and spearmint oil, and EPA is revoking the

existing FAR. (60 FR 38781)

III. Response to Comments

EPA received comments on the proposed revocation of the trifluralin

FAR. All the commenters support the basis for the revocation of the

referenced FAR. In addition, many of the commenters raise other issues

that EPA believes are not relevant to EPA's conclusion that mint oils

are not ready-to-eat commodities and that as a result, the section 409

FAR covering residues of trifluralin in mint oils are not necessary.

However, the following are brief responses to these comments.

Comment

The National Food Processor's Association (NFPA), the American Crop

Protection Association (ACPA), DowElanco, and Gowan Co. submitted

comments in support of the revocation of the proposed FAR and the

withdrawal of the July 14, 1993 Order. However, NFPA, ACPA, and

DowElanco contend that there are other controlling legal reasons why

the 1993 and 1994 Orders must be withdrawn.

The commenters contend that once it has been determined that

trifluralin residues in mint oil are subject to the section 402 flow-

through provision, the 1993 and 1994 Orders must be withdrawn because

those Orders purported to revoke the FAR on the grounds that the

pesticide ``induces cancer'' within the meaning of the Delaney clause.

The commenters contend that, as a matter of law, EPA is precluded from

revoking a section 409 FAR under the safety standard in section 409(c)

if EPA has determined, as it has here, that the FAR is not needed to

prevent the adulteration of processed food.

According to the commenters, the flow-through provision prohibits

EPA from determining that an agricultural pesticide in a processed food

is ``unsafe,'' notwithstanding the

provisions of section 409, if the pesticide residue has been removed to

the extent possible in good manufacturing practice and the level of the

residue in the processed food when ready to eat is not greater than the

applicable section 408 tolerance. Thus, the commenters reason that

since EPA has decided that trifluralin residues in mint oil are likely

to fall within the protection of the flow-through provision, EPA is

barred from revoking the trifluralin FAR on grounds that the pesticide

``induces cancer'' within the meaning of the Delaney clause in section

409 of the FFDCA. On June 10, 1995, NFPA separately filed a petition

with EPA raising this same issue.

EPA's Response

As will be explained in more detail in EPA's response to the June

10, 1995 NFPA petition, the commenters' argument is without any legal

basis. The commenters misunderstand the relationship between a section

409 FAR and the flow-through provision. As a result of the flow-through

provision, a FAR only has legal effect as to residues of the pesticide

in processed food that exceed the residue levels qualifying under the

flow-through provision. Thus, a finding that a pesticide does not meet

the safety standard under section 409 and a revocation of a FAR based

on such a finding has no effect on residues of the pesticide that are

in compliance with the flow-through provision. Such a lack of safety

finding under section 409(c) does not render pesticide residues in

compliance with the flow-through provision unsafe. If a section 409 FAR

is revoked, residues still retain the same legal safe harbor they

always had under the flow-through provision. Accordingly, the flow-

through provision contains no bar to the revocation of a section 409

FAR on safety grounds.

Comment

DowElanco further requests that the Agency explicitly acknowledge

that DowElanco and other adversely affected parties will not be

precluded from challenging any ``induce cancer'' finding for

trifluralin in any future FFDCA tolerance revocation actions. DowElanco

insists that without such an acknowledgement, today's Notice will not

resolve the underlying controversy in the Dupont and DowElanco v.

Browner litigation. In addition, DowElanco urges that the EPA should

use today's Notice to clarify its position on chemicals classified as

Group C carcinogens with quantification by the Reference Dose approach

(or found not to be quantifiable). DowElanco further argues that by

using the Reference Dose approach for quantifying risk, EPA is

recognizing that the carcinogenic risk is so uncertain that it is

disregarded for evaluating risk.

EPA's Response

EPA believes that there are no additional trifluralin tolerances or

FARs that are likely to be revoked on grounds that trifluralin

``induces cancer.'' The trifluralin Reregistration Eligibility

Document, which will soon be issued by EPA, indicates that there are no

section 409 FARs needed for this chemical. Therefore, EPA does not

foresee a situation that would result in any hearings under the FFDCA

on whether trifluralin ``induces cancer.'' However, as explained below,

EPA will consider future hearing requests raising any evidence relevant

and material to a finding that trifluralin ``induces cancer'' within

the meaning of the Delaney clause when that finding serves as the basis

for an order issued by EPA under the authority of sections 408 and 409

of the FFDCA.

EPA believes that precluding review of issues that could have and

should have been raised in prior proceedings is an appropriate and

essential policy and legal position for the Agency to take in FFDCA

proceedings because it ensures that such Agency decisions are accorded

finality. In the interest of administrative efficiency and economy,

final determinations in such administrative proceedings deserve to be

treated with the same finality as final determinations in judicial

proceedings. Further, under section 409 of the FFDCA, the only way to

prevent EPA from according finality to a section 409(f) order, and the

legal and factual basis for that order, is to file objections within

the time period specified, Nader v. EPA, 859 F.2d 747 (9th Cir. 1988),

cert. denied, 490 U.S. 1931 (1989; and CNI v. Young, 773 F2.d 1356

(1985).

EPA found, in its 1990 and 1991 Orders, that trifluralin ``induces

cancer'' but that because the trifluralin cancer risks were de minimis,

EPA would retain the trifluralin FAR that was the subject of NRDC's

petition. However, because EPA retained the FAR, and because this was

the first proceeding of this nature under section 409 of the FFDCA,

proponents of the FAR and chemicals, including DowElanco, may not have

understood that their failure to raise objections to the cancer finding

at that time could result in that finding being accorded finality by

EPA. Given that such circumstances are not likely to be repeated, EPA

believes it is appropriate to assure DowElanco that EPA will not assert

in future FFDCA proceedings that the issue of whether trifluralin

``induces cancer'' must or will be accorded finality based on EPA's

1990 and 1991 Orders.

Because EPA is providing the assurances requested by commenters,

EPA believes there should be no objections to an EPA final order

withdrawing the 1993 and 1994 Orders.

IV. Procedural Matters

A. Filing of Objections and Requests for Hearings

Any person adversely affected by this final rule may file written

objections to the final rule, and may include with any such objection a

written request for an evidentiary hearing on the objection. Such

objections must be submitted to the Hearing Clerk on or before February

26, 1996. A copy of the objections and hearing requests filed with the

Hearing Clerk shall be submitted to the Office of Pesticide Programs

Docket Room. Regulations applicable to objections and requests for

hearings are set out at 40 CFR parts 178 and 179. Those regulations

require, among other things, that objections specify with particularity

the provisions of the final rule objected to, the basis for the

objections, and the relief sought. Additional requirements as to the

form and manner of the submission of objections are set out at 40 CFR

178.25. The Administrator will respond as set forth in 40 CFR 178.30,

178.35, and/or 178.37 to objections that are not accompanied by a

request for evidentiary hearing.

A person may include with any objection a written request for an

evidentiary hearing on the objection. A hearing request must include a

statement of the factual issues on which a hearing is requested, the

requestor's contentions on each such issue, and a summary of any

evidence relied upon by the requestor. Additional requirements as to

the form and manner of submission of requests for an evidentiary

hearing are set out at 40 CFR 178.27. Under 40 CFR 178.32(c), the

Administrator, where appropriate, will make rulings on any issues

raised by an objection if such issues must be resolved prior to

determining whether a request for an evidentiary hearing should be

granted. The Administrator will respond to requests for evidentiary

hearings as set forth in 40 CFR 178.30, 178.32, 178.35, 178.37, and/or

179.20. Under 40 CFR 178.32(b), a request for an evidentiary hearing on

an objection will be granted if the objection and request have been

properly submitted and if the Administrator determines that the

material submitted show: (1) There is a genuine and substantial issue

of fact for resolution at a hearing; (2) There is a

reasonable possibility that available evidence identified by the

requestor would, if established, resolve one or more of such issues in

favor of the requestor; and (3) Resolution of one or more of the

factual issues in the manner sought by the person requesting the

hearing would be adequate to justify the action requested.

Any person wishing to comment on any objections or requests for a

hearing may submit such comments to the Hearing Clerk on or before

March 11, 1996.

A record has been established for this rulemaking under docket

number [OPP-300394A] (including objections and hearing requests

submitted electronically as described below). A public version of this

record, including printed, paper versions of electronic comments, which

does not include any information claimed as CBI, is available for

inspection from 8 a.m. to 4:30 p.m., Monday through Friday, excluding

legal holidays. The public record is located in Room 1132 of the Public

Response and Program Resources Branch, Field Operations Division

(7506C), Office of Pesticide Programs, Environmental Protection Agency,

Crystal Mall #2, 1921 Jefferson Davis Highway, Arlington, VA.

Written objections and hearing requests, identified by the document

control number [OPP-300394A], may be submitted to the Hearing Clerk

(1900), Environmental Protection Agency, Rm. 3708, 401 M St., SW.,

Washington, DC 20460.

A copy of electronic objections and hearing requests filed with the

Hearing Clerk can be sent directly to EPA at:

opp-D[email protected]

A copy of electronic objections and hearing requests filed with the

Hearing Clerk must be submitted as an ASCII file avoiding the use of

special characters and any form of encryption.

The official record for this rulemaking, as well as the public

version, as described above will be kept in paper form. Accordingly,

EPA will transfer any objections and hearing requests received

electronically into printed, paper form as they are received and will

place the paper copies in the official rulemaking record which will

also include all objections and hearing requests submitted directly in

writing. The official rulemaking record is the paper record maintained

at the address in ``ADDRESSES'' at the beginning of this document.

B. Effective Date

EPA is making this final rule effective January 26, 1996 given the

lack of adverse comments on EPA's proposed action. In addition, if EPA

does not receive objections to this Order, this Order and the factual

and legal basis for this Order become final and are not judicially

reviewable. See section 409(g)(1), 21 U.S.C. 348(g)(1), and Nader v.

EPA: 859 F.2d 747 (9th Cir. 1988), cert. denied, 490 U.S. 1931 (1989).

C. Request for Stays of Effective Date

A person filing objections to this final rule may submit with the

objections a petition to stay the effective date of this final rule.

Such stay petitions must be submitted to the Hearing Clerk on or before

February 26, 1996. A copy of the stay request filed with the Hearing

Clerk shall be submitted to the Office of Pesticide Programs Docket

Room. A stay may be requested for a specific time period or for an

indefinite time period. The stay petition must include a citation to

this final rule, the length of time for which the stay is requested,

and a full statement of the factual and legal grounds upon which the

petitioner relies for the stay. In determining whether to grant a stay,

EPA will consider the criteria set out in the Food and Drug

Administration's regulations regarding stays of administrative

proceedings at 21 CFR 10.35. Under those rules, a stay will be granted

if it is determined that: (1) The petitioner will otherwise suffer

irreparable injury; (2) The petitioner's case is not frivolous and is

being pursued in good faith; (3) The petitioner has demonstrated sound

public policy grounds supporting the stay; and (4) The delay resulting

from the stay is not outweighed by public health or other public

interests.

Under FDA's criteria, EPA may also grant a stay if EPA finds such

action is in the public interest and in the interest of justice.

Any person wishing to comment on any stay request may submit such

comments and objections to a stay request, to the Hearing Clerk, on or

before March 11, 1996. Any subsequent decisions to stay the effect of

this Order, based on a stay request filed, will be published in the

Federal Register, along with EPA's response to comments on the stay

request.

V. Regulatory Requirements

A. Executive Order 12866

Under Executive Order 12866, the Agency must determine whether the

regulatory action is ``significant'' and therefore subject to review by

the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) and the requirements of the

Executive Order. Under the order, a ``significant regulatory action''

is an action that is likely to result in a rule (1) having an annual

effect on the economy of $100 million or more, or adversely and

materially affecting a sector of the economy, productivity,

competition, jobs, and the environment, public health or safety, of

State, local, or tribal governments or communities''; (2) creating

serious inconsistency or otherwise interfering with an action taken or

planned by another agency; (3) materially altering the budgetary

impacts of entitlement, grants, user fees, or loan programs or the

rights and obligations of recipients thereof; or (4) raising novel

legal or policy issues arising out of legal mandates, the President's

priorities, or the principles set forth in the Executive Order. EPA has

determined that this final rule is not a ``significant'' action under

E.O. 12866. EPA is taking this action because it has determined that

the food additive regulation for trifluralin is not needed. Therefore,

the Agency expects that no economic impact will result.

B. Regulatory Flexibility Act

The regulatory action has been reviewed under the Regulatory

Flexibility Act of 1980, and, as stated above, EPA expects that it will

not have any economic impacts, including impacts on small entities.

C. Paperwork Reduction Act

This Order does not contain any information collection requirements

subject to review by the Office of Management and Budget under the

Paperwork Reduction Act of 1980, 44 U.S.C. 3501 et seq.

List of Subjects in 40 CFR Part 185

Environmental protection, Administrative practice and procedures,

Agricultural commodities, Food additives, Pesticides and pests,

Reporting and recordkeeping.

Dated: January 19, 1996.

Lynn R. Goldman,

Assistant Administrator for Prevention, Pesticides and Toxic

Substances.

Therefore, 40 CFR part 185 is amended as follows:

PART 185--[AMENDED]

1. The authority citation for part 185 continues to read as

follows:

Authority: 21 U.S.C. 346a and 348.

Sec. 185.5900 [Removed]

2. By removing Sec. 185.5900 Trifluralin.

[FR Doc. 96-1402 Filed 1-25-96; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 6560-50-F

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.