Migratory Bird Hunting; Decision on the Conditional Approval of Bismuth-Tin Shot as Nontoxic for the 1994-95 Season

FederalRegulations

Ask Donna

How this section applies to your facts.

Federal Register › Vol. 60 › 60 FR 61

This text was captured on Sep 30, 2026. It is a snapshot, not a live feed, so check the official code before relying on it.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR

50 CFR Part 20

RIN 1018-AC66

Migratory Bird Hunting; Decision on the Conditional Approval of

Bismuth-Tin Shot as Nontoxic for the 1994-95 Season

AGENCY: Fish and Wildlife Service, Interior.

ACTION: Final rule.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (Service) is publishing

this final rule to notify the public of the interim conditional

approval of the use of bismuth-tin for the remainder of the 1994-1995

migratory bird hunting season. Toxicity studies undertaken by the

Bismuth Cartridge Company and other pertinent materials indicate that

bismuth-tin shot is nontoxic to waterfowl when ingested.

EFFECTIVE DATE: This rule becomes effective January 3, 1995.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Paul R. Schmidt, Chief, or Keith

Morehouse, Staff Specialist, Office of Migratory Bird Management

(MBMO), U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, 634 ARLSQ, 1849 C St. NW,

Washington D.C. 20240 (703/358-1714).

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: The Service published a proposed regulation

in the Federal Register on August 22, 1994 (59 FR 43088) to provide for

conditional approval of bismuth-tin shot (in a mixture of [nominally]

97-3 percents, respectively) as nontoxic for the taking of waterfowl

and coots during the 1994-1995 hunting season. This proposed action was

in response to a petition for rulemaking from the Bismuth Cartridge

Company received June 24, 1994. The petition requested that the Service

modify the provisions of 50 CFR 20.21(j), to legalize the use of

bismuth-tin shot on an interim, conditional basis for both the 1994-95

and the 1995-96 seasons. The petition cited the following reasons in

support of the proposal: (a) bismuth is nontoxic; (b) the proposed rule

is conditional; and (c) the evidence presented in the record, i.e., the

application from the Bismuth Cartridge Company. This petition

acknowledged responsibility by the Bismuth Cartridge Company to

complete all the nontoxic shot approval tests as outlined in 50 CFR

20.134.

The current petition for rulemaking follows two previous

applications to the Service for final approval, one dated October 21,

1993, and the other dated December 30, 1993. The Service replied that

the applications were deficient because the bismuth-based shot material

had not been adequately tested. Preliminary toxicity testing by the

applicants had been with essentially-pure bismuth only. Thus, there was

not adequate scientific data (either available or provided with the

application) covering toxicity of the material to be loaded into

shotshells. The Service pledged in both replies, however, to work with

the applicants to process the applications in as timely a fashion as

possible.

In response to the Bismuth Cartridge Company's petition of June 14,

1994, the Service proposed (59 FR 43088) the interim conditional

approval of bismuth-tin shot based on what was known about the toxicity

of bismuth and on the agreement by the Bismuth Cartridge Company to

conduct and complete the 30-day acute toxicity test as described in 50

CFR 20.134.

For bismuth, there are three especially recent and relevant studies

that support this proposal. The three studies include Sanderson and

Anderson (1994), Ringelman et al. (1992), and Sanderson et al. (1992).

A complete description of these studies can be found in the proposed

rule (59 FR 43088). In addition, test results with tin include those by

Grandy et al. (1968) in which there were no deaths associated with

mallards dosed with tin shot. Positive results from the acute toxicity

test (Sanderson et al. 1994) (just concluded) and the other toxicity

information (cited above) suggest that a temporary conditional approval

for bismuth-tin can be provided without significant risk to migratory

bird resources. The Service believes it has sufficient flexibility in

the regulations to approach approval of shot in a step manner.

The toxicity analysis procedures (50 CFR 20.134) consist of three

tests which represent the three major categories of toxic effects:

short-term periodic exposure, chronic exposure under adverse

environmental conditions, and the impact of chronic exposure on

reproduction. Tests include both steel-shot and lead-shot control

groups and statistical analyses of all data from each test. Test 1 is a

short-term, 30-day acute toxicity study using commercially-

available duck food and including blood tests and organ analysis. Test

2 is a chronic 14-week toxicity test in cold weather using a

nutritionally-deficient diet, and test 3 is a chronic-dosage study that

includes reproductive assessment using a commercially-available duck

food diet. For bismuth-tin shot to achieve interim conditional

approval, results from test 1 (30-day acute toxicity) must show a

finding of nontoxicity to waterfowl. Unconditional final approval will

result when the second and third tests are concluded with a finding of

nontoxicity.

The Bismuth Cartridge Company contracted with Dr. Glen Sanderson,

Center for Wildlife Ecology, Illinois Natural History Survey, to

conduct the 30-day (short-term) acute toxicity study. Results from the

test indicate that bismuth-tin is not toxic when ingested by waterfowl.

As stated in the proposed rule of August 22, 1994 (59 FR 43088), ``. .

. this concluding work will be completed before any final rulemaking .

. .'' Having received these test results and final report, the Service

now issues this final rule providing interim conditional approval to

the use of bismuth-tin shot for the remainder of the 1994-1995

migratory bird hunting season.

Since the mid-1970s, the Service has sought to identify shot that,

when spent, does not pose a significant hazard to migratory birds and

other wildlife. Ingestion of spent lead shot has long been identified

as a source of significant mortality in migratory birds. The Service

first addressed the issue of lead poisoning in waterfowl in a 1976

environmental impact statement (EIS), and later readdressed the issue

in a 1986 supplemental EIS. The latter provided the scientific

justification for the ban on the use of lead shot for hunting waterfowl

and coots that was begun in 1986 and completed in 1991. Currently, only

steel shot has been approved by the Service Director as nontoxic. The

Service believes, however, that there may be other suitable candidate

shot materials that could be approved for use as nontoxic shot.

In summary, this rule provides interim conditional approval for the

use of bismuth-tin shot for waterfowl and coot hunting only for the

1994-1995 hunting season. Further approval will be granted only upon

satisfactory completion of the remaining tests required by the Service

and the regulations at 50 CFR 20.134, and upon availability of a field

detection device to address law enforcement concerns.

Public Comments

The August 22 proposed rule invited comments from interested

parties. Closing date for receipt of all comments was September 21,

1994. During this 30-day comment period, the Service received 351

comments. These comments consisted of 2 from Flyway Councils, 5 from

Federal agencies, 19 from State fish and wildlife agencies, 23 from

other organizations, and 302 from individuals, including a letter

signed by 33 Congressmen. A brief summary of those comments is as

follows:

The Mississippi and Pacific Flyway Councils both opposed the

proposal. The Mississippi Council cited incomplete toxicity testing,

enforcement problems caused by lack of a simple field identification

technique and the timing of the approval. The Pacific Council stated

that ``this expedient action abandons the hard-fought standards set for

waterfowling ammunition, fails to consider impacts on law enforcement

and education programs, and unnecessarily sets a precedent for special

exemptions.''

Four of the Federal agency comments were submitted by law

enforcement personnel and opposed the action, primarily on the basis of

enforcement problems caused by lack of a non-invasive field method to

distinguish bismuth-tin from lead. They suggested further that

approving bismuth-tin will provide an additional opportunity for those

using lead to go undetected. Comments reiterated the need for the

development of a cheap, easy non-invasive field test to distinguish

between bismuth-tin and lead. The Canadian Wildlife Service appeared to

endorse the action with a statement that the conditional approval of

bismuth shot would be consistent with actions taken in Canada. Bismuth

is apparently considered nontoxic in Canada since the comment indicated

that toxic shot is defined as anything containing more than one percent

lead.

Nineteen comments were received that represented 18 States (2

comments from Maryland). Of the 19 comments, 6 endorsed the proposal,

13 opposed it. Opposition came from Arkansas, Colorado, Delaware,

Indiana, Kentucky, Minnesota, Missouri, Montana, Washington, and

Wisconsin. These comments also raised the issue of enforcement

difficulties, incomplete toxicity testing, and concern about timing

(delay approval until 1995-96 hunting season). Support for this action

came from Louisiana, Maryland, Mississippi, Nevada, and New Jersey.

Organizations were represented by 23 comments. Of the 23 comments,

21 endorsed the proposal and 2 (McGraw Wildlife Foundation and National

Wildlife Federation) opposed it. Opposition was based mainly on

concerns that ``shortcuts'' were being taken on testing procedures for

toxicity and that the process was ``moving too fast.'' Support came

from Ontario Federation of Anglers & Hunters, Safari Club

International, Arkansas Wildlife Federation, International Association

of Fish and Wildlife Agencies, Congressional Sportsman Foundation,

National Rifle Association, South Carolina Waterfowl Association, The

Wildlife Legislative Fund of America, Catahoula Lake Conservation Club,

Alabama Waterfowl Association, Inc., California Waterfowl Association,

Sporting Shooters' Association of Australia (Inc.), New Jersey State

Federation of Sportsman's Clubs, Inc., Michigan United Conservation

Clubs, Ducks Unlimited, The American Outdoorsman Hunting Club,

International Joint Commission--Great Lakes, ASARCO, Inc., Smoking

Barrel Duck Club, The Bismuth Cartridge Company, and the Sportsman's

Council of Central California.

Individuals submitted 302 comments with 299 favoring the action and

only 3 opposing it. The comments favoring the approval of bismuth-tin

were, in fact, generally anti-steel, restating opposition to steel shot

due to such factors as crippling loss and gun-barrel damage. The

consensus expressed support of anything that could replace steel.

Response to Comments

Opposition to the regulation focused on 3 major areas: enforcement,

toxicity testing, and timing.

1. Enforcement--Concern was expressed in the comments that there is

no simple procedure to distinguish bismuth-tin shot from lead shot in

the field, creating a burden on law enforcement personnel. The Service

recognizes this difficulty and acknowledges that a prescribed field

testing method (short of exposing the shot through invasive inspection)

to determine shot composition should ideally be in place before

approval. In fact, field methods are currently being developed to

address this concern. Since resistance to steel shot is promoting a

climate for noncompliance, however, it is important to provide an

alternative to steel shot that could give the public greater choice

during this interim period and improve hunter compliance, thereby

reducing the amount of lead shot being used. In addition, increased

hunter use of this alternative shot could benefit upland habitats,

through the diminished use of lead shot in those areas. The

Service believes that by offering alternatives to steel shot, a climate

of compliance will be promoted, not reduced, and that this is a

reasonable approach to take while field testing techniques are being

developed.

2. Toxicity Testing--Comments expressed concern that testing is

incomplete and that testing procedures, clearly defined by regulation

are not being followed. The Service stresses that there have been no

actions relative to this process outside compliance with 50 CFR 20.134.

The Service believes, however, that the regulatory process is

sufficiently flexible to provide the opportunity for interim

conditional approval of alternatives to steel shot. The applicant has

demonstrated a good faith effort to comply with the regulatory

procedures defined for toxicity testing and there appears to be no

information suggesting a hazard to migratory birds. The Service

believes this flexibility can be exercised. The procedures described in

50 CFR 20.134 are in place and interim conditional approval is being

granted only after completion of the 30-day acute toxicity test and an

independent review of the test results. In addition, the Service has

clearly stated that only interim conditional approval has been given

and the Bismuth Cartridge Company must still complete all remaining

toxicity tests before unconditional final approval is granted for the

use of bismuth-tin shot.

3. Timing--Concern was expressed that the hunting season will have

begun if/when bismuth-tin shot is approved.The Service regrets that the

conditional approval of bismuth-tin had to be delayed until after the

start of the 1994-95 hunting season. Although an earlier approval date

would have been preferred, the Service was obligated to wait until the

acute toxicity tests, analysis of data, and review of the results were

completed. The fact that the season has already begun is not considered

an adequate justification to delay approval, especially considering the

effort put forth to complete the testing and review process as quickly

as possible. It was determined that the ``inconvenience'' of approving

the use of bismuth-tin shot after the start of the hunting season was

outweighed by the opportunity for the hunting public to use bismuth-

tin, even if few days remained in the 1994-95 season.

References

Grandy, J.W., L.N. Locke and G.E. Bagley. 1968. Relative toxicity of

lead and five proposed substitute shot types to pen-reared mallards.

J. Wildl. Manage. 32(3):483-488.

Ringelman, J.K., M.W. Miller and W.F. Andelt. 1992. Effects of

ingested tungsten-bismuth-tin shot on mallards. CO Div. Wildl., Fort

Collins, 24 pp.

Sanderson, G.C., W.L. Anderson, G.L. Foley, L.M. Skowron, and J.W.

Seets. 1994. Toxicity and reproductive effects of ingested bismuth

alloy shot and effects of embedded bismuth alloy, lead, and iron

shot on game-farm mallards. Final Report, Ill. Nat. Hist. Surv.,

Champaign, IL. 64 pp. + tables.

Sanderson, G.C. and W.L. Anderson. 1994. Toxicity and reproductive

effects of ingested bismuth alloy shot and effects of embedded

bismuth alloy, lead, and iron shot on game-farm mallards. 3rd Prog.

Rpt., Ill. Nat. Hist. Surv., Champaign, IL. 14 pp. + tables.

Sanderson, G.C., S.G. Wood, G.L. Foley and J.D. Brawn. 1992.

Toxicity of bismuth shot compared with lead and steel shot in game-

farm mallards. Trans. 57th N.A. Wildl. Nat. Res. Conf., 57:526-540.

NEPA Consideration

Pursuant to the requirements of section 102(2)(C) of the National

Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (NEPA) (42 U.S.C. 4332(C)), and the

Council on Environmental Quality's regulation for implementing NEPA (40

CFR 1500-1508), an Environmental Assessment has been prepared and is

available to the public at the Office of Migratory Bird Management at

the address listed above. Based on review and evaluation of the

information contained in the Environmental Assessment, the Service

determined that the proposed action to amend 50 CFR 20.21(j) to allow

interim conditional use of bismuth-tin as nontoxic shot for the 1994-95

waterfowl hunting season would not be a major Federal action that would

significantly affect the quality of the human environment.

Endangered Species Act Considerations

Section 7 of the Endangered Species Act (ESA), as amended (16

U.S.C. 1531-1543; 87 Stat. 884), provides that, ``The Secretary shall

review other programs administered by him and utilize such programs in

furtherance of the purposes of this Act'' (and) shall ``insure that any

action authorized, funded or carried out . . . is not likely to

jeopardize the continued existence of any endangered species or

threatened species or result in the destruction or adverse modification

of (critical) habitat . . .''

Toxicity testing conducted by the Bismuth Cartridge Company

indicates that bismuth-tin is nontoxic to the environment; therefore,

no adverse impact on endangered and threatened species is anticipated.

Pursuant to section 7 of the ESA, MBMO sought review and concurrence

that this action ``is not likely to adversely affect'' threatened,

endangered, proposed, and category 1 species. Based on review and

evaluation of the toxicity testing and other available information, the

Service determined that no adverse impact on endangered and threatened

species would result from the proposed action. The results of this

review may be inspected by the public in, and will be available to the

public from, the Office of Migratory Bird Management, U.S. Fish and

Wildlife Service, Department of the Interior, Washington, DC 20240.

Regulatory Flexibility Act, Executive Order 12866, and the Paperwork

Reduction Act

The Regulatory Flexibility Act of 1980 (5 U.S.C. 601 et seq.)

requires the preparation of flexibility analyses for rules that will

have a significant effect on a substantial number of small entities,

which includes small businesses, organizations and/or governmental

jurisdictions. The Service has determined, however, that this rule will

have no effect on small entities since the shot to be approved will

merely supplement nontoxic shot already in commerce and available

throughout the retail and wholesale distribution systems. No

dislocation or other local effects, with regard to hunters and others,

are apt to be evidenced. This rule was not subject to Office of

Management and Budget (OMB) review under Executive Order 12866. This

rule does not contain any information collection efforts requiring

approval by the OMB under 44 U.S.C. 3504.

Effective Date

This rule reflects the interim approval in the text of 50 CFR

20.21(j), by restricting permission to use bismuth-tin for the 1994-95

season. Because this rule relieves a restriction, and the current

hunting season ends on February 28, 1995, the Service has determined

that there is good cause to establish the effective date of this rule

as the date of publication in the Federal Register, as authorized under

5 U.S.C. 553(d) (1 and 3).

Authorship

The primary author of this final rule is Peter G. Poulos, Office of

Migratory Bird Management.

List of Subjects in 50 CFR Part 20

Exports, Hunting, Imports, Reporting and recordkeeping

requirements, Transportation, Wildlife.

Accordingly, Part 20, Subchapter B, Chapter I of Title 50 of the

Code of Federal Regulations is amended as follows:

PART 20--[AMENDED]

1. The authority citation for Part 20 continues to read as follows:

Authority: Migratory Bird Treaty Act, as amended (16 U.S.C. 703

et seq.)

2. Section 20.21 is amended by revising paragraph (j) to read as

follows:

Sec. 20.21 Hunting methods.

* * * * *

(j) While possessing shot (either in shotshells or as loose shot

for muzzleloading) other than steel shot, bismuth-tin ([nominally] 97-3

percents, respectively) shot or such shot approved as nontoxic by the

Director pursuant to procedures set forth in Section 20.134.

Provided that:

(1) This restriction applies only to the taking of Anatidae (ducks,

geese [including brant] and swans), coots (Fulica americana) and any

species that make up aggregate bag limits during concurrent seasons

with the former in areas described in Section 20.108 as nontoxic shot

zones, and

(2) Bismuth-tin shot is legal as nontoxic shot only during the

1994-95 season.

Dated: December 22, 1994.

George T. Frampton, Jr.,

Assistant Secretary for Fish and Wildlife.

[FR Doc. 94-32214 Filed 12-30-94; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 4310-55-P

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Migratory Bird Hunting; Decision on the Conditional Approval of Bismuth-Tin Shot as Nontoxic for the 1994-95 Season · 60 FR 61 | Frix