Review of Cap Increases; Response Plans for Marine Transportation-Related (MTR) Facilities and Tank Vessels

FederalRegulations

Ask Donna

How this section applies to your facts.

Federal Register › Vol. 65 › 65 FR 710

This text was captured on Sep 30, 2026. It is a snapshot, not a live feed, so check the official code before relying on it.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

Coast Guard

33 CFR Parts 154 and 155

[USCG-1998-3350]

Review of Cap Increases; Response Plans for Marine

Transportation-Related (MTR) Facilities and Tank Vessels

AGENCY: Coast Guard, DOT.

ACTION: Notice of decision.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: Coast Guard response plan regulations contain requirements for

on-water oil recovery capacity (referred to as caps). These caps were

scheduled to increase by 25 percent on February 18, 1998, provided the

Coast Guard completed a review of the cap increases. The Coast Guard

has completed its review and the 25 percent increase for on-water

mechanical recovery will take effect 90 days from the date of this

notice. The Coast Guard will consider a 2003 cap for mechanical on-

water removal capability and requirements for other removal

technologies in a subsequent notice of proposed rulemaking.

DATES: The scheduled cap increase for on-water mechanical recovery

requirements will take effect on April 5, 2000.

ADDRESSES: The Docket Management Facility maintains the public docket

for this notice (USCG-1998-3350). The Response Plan Equipment Cap

Review (Cap Review) is part of the docket and is available for

inspection or copying at room PL-401 on the Plaza level of the Nassif

Building, 400 Seventh Street SW., Washington, DC 20590-0001, between 9

a.m. and 5 p.m., Monday through Friday, except Federal holidays. You

may also find this docket on the Internet at http://dms.dot.gov. The

Cap Review is also available for examination on the Vessel Response

Plan Internet site at http://www.uscg.mil/vrp.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: For questions on this notice, call

Lieutenant Commander John Caplis, Office of Response (G-MOR), Coast

Guard, telephone 202-267-6922 or by e-mail at JC[email protected].

For questions on viewing materials in the docket, call Dorothy Walker,

Chief, Dockets, Department of Transportation, telephone 202-366-9329.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

Regulatory History

In 1996, the Coast Guard published two final rules entitled

``Vessel Response Plans'' (61 FR 1052, January 12, 1996) and ``Response

Plans for Marine Transportation-Related Facilities'' (61 FR 7890,

February 29, 1996). Those rules finalized the 1993 interim rules (58 FR

7330, February 5, 1993, and 58 FR 7376, February 5, 1993, for Marine

Transportation-Related Facilities and Vessels, respectively) and are

located in the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) in 33 CFR parts 154

and 155. 33 CFR 154.1045(m) and 155.1050(o) contain requirements for

on-water oil recovery capacity (referred to as caps) that an owner or

operator must ensure is available, through contract or other approved

means, in planning for a worst case discharge. These caps were

established taking into account 1993 technology, deployment capability,

and availability of response resources.

The 1993 and 1996 rules established a 1998 cap, a 25 percent

increase from the 1993 levels, as a target for increasing response

capabilities. This increase was endorsed by the Vessel Response Plan

Negotiated Rulemaking Committee as an incentive to expand response

capabilities within the United States to an obtainable and desirable

level by 1998. The Coast Guard concurred with the recommendation from

the Committee, adopted for both vessel and facility rules, to review

the proposed cap increase before the increase would be implemented to

determine if it remains practicable.

On January 27, 1998, we published a ``Request for Comment'' notice

(63 FR 3861) with regard to the Cap Review and stated that the 1993

caps would remain in effect pending the results of that review and that

the cap increases as originally scheduled would not be implemented

until the review was complete.

On June 24, 1998, we published a Notice of Meetings (63 FR 34500)

that announced three public workshops to solicit comments on the

potential changes to the equipment requirements within the response

plan regulations (33 CFR parts 154 and 155) for mechanical recovery,

dispersants, and other spill removal technologies. These workshops were

held in Oakland, CA, on July 24, 1998, with 55 attendees; in Houston,

TX, on August 19, 1998, with 71 attendees; and in Washington, DC, on

September 16, 1998, with 49 attendees. We completed the Response Plan

Equipment Cap Review (Cap Review) in May 1999, placed it in the docket

and made it available on-line on July 26, 1999. The Cap Review can be

viewed on the Internet at the sites listed in the ADDRESSES section.

Discussion of Comments

The Coast Guard received 25 written comments in response to a

``Request for Comment'' published in the Federal Register on January

27, 1998 (63 FR 3861). In addition, we recorded 41 verbal comments

regarding mechanical recovery caps in the summaries for three public

workshops which were conducted in the summer of 1998. We received 37

letters in response to the workshops. These letters were placed in the

public docket. In general, public comment regarding an increase in the

mechanical recovery equipment is divided, with numerous comments

received both for and against such an increase.

Current Equipment Inventories

Five comments stated that the cap increase is practicable since

equipment inventories already exceed the increased cap requirements. We

agree that equipment inventories are sufficient throughout the nation

to support an increase in the equipment required to be ensured

available by any individual planholder. The Cap Review indicates that

only a few port areas do not have aggregate equipment stockpiles

significantly in excess of the increased cap requirements, and that

from an availability standpoint, the caps are practicable.

Five comments suggested that the cap increase was not necessary

because the additional mechanical recovery equipment already exists and

is sufficient to respond to most anticipated spills. We disagree that

the mere existence of surplus equipment in the regional response

inventories negates the need for an increase in an individual

planholder's equipment requirements. The Oil Pollution Act of 1990

(Pub. L. 101-380) (OPA 90) directed that response plans should prepare

for, to the maximum extent possible, a response to a worst case

discharge. Scheduled increases in recovery capability were intended and

remain necessary to close the gap between the equipment required to be

ensured available by a planholder and that amount which would be

necessary to respond to a worst case discharge. The equipment

requirements, however, should not be elevated to the entire worst case

discharge amount simply because aggregate regional inventories are now

available at those levels. This is because the capped amounts also

attempt to discount for operational considerations, such as limitations

regarding the effective deployment of equipment during the first 72

hours of the response. Total availability within regional equipment

inventories is only one of many factors that must be considered in

determining what is a practicable equipment cap.

Two comments stated that the cap increases are not necessary

because free market forces have generated the large equipment

inventories as a result of competition between the oil spill removal

organizations (OSROs). We agree that competition between OSROs, who

have individually acquired enough resources each to meet the cap

requirements, has resulted in the accumulation of large aggregate

equipment inventories in each regional and port area. We determined

that these accumulations are suitable and necessary, as the caps rely

on these excess stockpiles to come into play in the event of a

catastrophic spill, such as a worst case discharge from a large

tankship. The cap requirements reflect the limitations of a

planholder's ability to deploy and effectively manage equipment during

the initial phase of a response. As such, the capped equipment tiers

are designed to ensure an increasing availability of equipment during

that first 72 hours of a response. If a worst case discharge were to

occur from a large tank vessel or facility, however, the equipment

needed to respond past that initial 72-hour period is likely to exceed

the cap levels. As spill management team and incident command systems

are firmly established, their ability to effectively deploy and manage

equipment should also surpass the capped levels. The response will need

to draw upon those aggregate inventories in excess of the caps to

ensure the response can continue to expand in scope beyond that initial

72-hour period.

Five comments supported the cap increase, stating that the

equipment has already been obtained in anticipation of the scheduled

increase, and that a failure to implement the new requirements will

result in additional equipment being sold off or put out of service. We

agree that a failure to implement a cap increase may result in

declining equipment inventories. If the equipment caps are not

increased, economic pressures may force a sell-off of un-mandated

equipment which may result in a lessening of our overall response

capability.

Three comments stated that the evaluation of equipment stockpiles

must account for the fact that tiered response requirements allow

equipment to be brought in from other regions and that this

``cascading'' of equipment may strip the providing area of critical

response capability. This was cited as a major concern where ports and

stockpiles are separated by hundreds of miles. We acknowledge that the

cascading of equipment out of a region may impact the ability of a

particular OSRO or planholder to respond in that port. This possibility

reinforces the need to maintain aggregate levels of response equipment

within a port area that significantly exceed the cap requirements.

These surplus inventories will ensure that a viable response capability

is retained within one region when some of its resources are cascaded

into another region in response to a discharge.

Four comments stated that the equipment required under the current

cap has been sufficient to respond to all spills since the passage of

OPA 90 and is also sufficient to respond to the current risk of spills.

Two comments stated the Cap Review should evaluate responses to actual

incidents in order to determine whether more response equipment is

necessary or not. The Coast Guard has the responsibility for issuing

regulations that require a

planholder to respond, to the maximum extent possible, a worst case

discharge. The fact that a worst case discharge from a large tank

vessel (such as an ultra-large crude carrier) or large tank facility

has not occurred in the United States since the passage of OPA 90 does

not mean that such a discharge could not happen. Nor does it change the

intent of Congress that industry develop response plans that prepare

for, to the maximum extent possible, a worst case discharge. While

spill tendencies since the passage of OPA 90 do show a decline in large

oil spill events, the risk of future spills still includes the

contingency of a worst case discharge. Evaluating the cap increase with

regard to the smaller incidents that have occurred since the passage of

the OPA 90 does not satisfy the intent of Congress in preparing for a

worst case discharge.

One comment stated that the cap increase must be based upon a

determination that the resources currently required are not sufficient

to remove a worst case discharge. One comment stated the caps should be

increased because the current cap levels represent a very small

percentage of the overall capability required to respond to a worst

case discharge from a large tankship. The Cap Review evaluated the

scheduled increase to determine if it required resources that exceeded

the amount necessary to respond to a worst case discharge. This

evaluation was based on the planning assumptions and calculations

contained within 33 CFR part 154, Appendix C and 33 CFR part 155,

Appendix B, and compared the increased caps against the worst case

discharge volumes found within the Area Contingency Plans throughout

the country. The comparison revealed that the increase is still far

below the levels of equipment that would be necessary to respond to a

worst case discharge (see Cap Review Tables 3-9, A-C for more

information).

Regional, State, and Local Issues

Two comments stated that the caps should be consistent with State

requirements. One comment stated that California has already mandated a

25 percent increase in State equipment caps. The State of California

Office of Spill Prevention and Response (OSPR) commented that a 25

percent increase in the planning standards for on-water oil recovery

volumes was both feasible and necessary to meet the best achievable

protection of the California coast. The State of Alaska Department of

Environmental Conservation (ADEC) has also commented that their State

requirements exceed the existing cap requirements and that the Federal

caps should increase in order to strengthen and stabilize equipment

inventories. Another comment stated that the U.S. Environmental

Protection Agency (EPA) has already implemented the 25 percent increase

in the caps for the OPA 90 response plans required under their

regulations. We agree that response requirements should be as

consistent as possible across Federal agency and State requirements.

Increasing the national response standards for caps will promote

consistency between EPA, Coast Guard, and State cap requirements. The

State of California OSPR, Alaska ADEC and the EPA have all commented

that the caps should increase, both for reasons of ensuring

consistency, as well as for ensuring an adequate level of national

preparedness. We will continue to work with the Federal and State

agencies to ensure consistency and as much harmony between requirements

as possible.

Three comments recommended that the mechanical recovery equipment

caps should be flexible to accommodate local priorities and concerns

and should be developed regionally. Another comment stated that the cap

increases should not be applicable in areas shown to have lower levels

of risk. We disagree. The equipment caps were designed to establish on

a national level a minimum baseline for response equipment that would

be ensured available for any given location. Similarly, the cap

increase was designed to raise the baseline to provide consistency on a

national basis. The use of a national standard does not impede the

development of response inventories that are reflective of regional and

local needs or risks. Market forces will shape a region's response

equipment inventory irrespective of the regulatory baseline. The Gulf

Coast region is an example where market forces have built a

substantially larger stock of equipment than most other regions of the

country. This larger equipment stockpile is also reflective of the

higher regional risk of an oil spill. Conversely, the response plan

rules allow for situations where market forces dictate that the

sustainable level of response equipment in an area falls below the

national baseline. Under these circumstances, planholders may request

an alternative planning criteria from the Coast Guard.

One comment suggested that Area Committees should establish the

equipment requirements for each region. We disagree. The National

Contingency Plan charges Area Committees with many responsibilities as

outlined in the Section 311(j)(4) of the Federal Water Pollution

Control Act (Pub. L. 92-500). These responsibilities include, but are

not limited to, developing an area contingency plan, response

strategies and procedures, joint contingency plans, agency

responsibilities, and the identification of sensitive resources. Area

Committee's do not have the responsibility for establishing response

plan equipment requirements, nor have they been delegated that

authority by the President under the Federal Water Pollution Control

Act.

One comment stated that the Coast Guard should evaluate the net

environmental benefit in each regional area to determine if any

equipment increases are necessary. Before the adoption of the vessel

and facility response plan requirements, we conducted a regulatory

assessment that determined an acceptable level of benefits would result

from an increase in the equipment caps as a national planning standard.

In addition, the response plan rules charge the Coast Guard with

conducting a review to determine whether an equipment cap increase is

practicable. Our determination of practicability has included an

evaluation of technological, operational, and economic feasibility. Net

environmental benefit studies are better suited for evaluating area

specific response strategies and are beyond the scope of the analysis

needed to evaluate the cap increase as a national planning standard.

One comment stated that the Coast Guard should use the Preparedness

for Response Exercise Program (PREP) as an evaluation tool in assessing

the need for increased equipment caps at local and regional levels

throughout the United States. We disagree. PREP was developed as a

workable, voluntary program that would facilitate the planholders'

compliance with the exercise requirements of OPA 90. PREP was designed

to test preparedness of the Area, vessel, or facility level, but was

not designed to establish regional or national equipment requirements.

While government-led exercises do occasionally test an area contingency

plan's worst case discharge scenario, the resultant tabletop exercise

is not suitable for determining the baseline of equipment that should

be ensured available by all planholders. A PREP exercise cannot test

the adequacy of a national equipment cap in the isolation of a single

simulated response. Nor would a series of such exercises held around

the country be suitable for evaluating the sufficiency of an increased

national planning standard.

High-rate Removal Technology

The Texas General Land Office stated that the addition of high-rate

removal technologies is preferred to an increase in mechanical recovery

systems, indicating that the surplus of mechanical equipment stationed

on the Gulf Coast already exceeds the scheduled increase. We agree that

mechanical stockpiles on the Gulf Coast already exceed the cap

increase. However, the cap increase is necessary to raise the

individual planholder's level of preparedness. The increase will raise

the amount of equipment ensured available by an individual planholder,

but will not necessarily raise the level of overall equipment located

on the Gulf Coast. The Coast Guard acknowledges that high-rate removal

technologies, such as dispersants, are valuable response options that

should complement the existing mechanical recovery capabilities on the

Gulf Coast. We are considering the addition of such technologies to the

response plan requirements in a separate rulemaking.

Many comments suggested that high-rate removal technologies are

more cost-effective and capacity-enhancing than additional mechanical

recovery and advocated the inclusion of these high-rate removal

technologies, rather than the addition of more mechanical recovery.

Other comments suggested that the high-rate removal technologies should

be included, but not at the expense of mechanical recovery

capabilities. We disagree that the scheduled increases in mechanical

recovery should be replaced by requirements for high-rate removal

technologies. Each response technology is unique and the situations

where these technologies provide an environmental benefit may vary

considerably, dependant upon the circumstances of each response. The

Coast Guard determined that high-rate removal technologies should

augment and not necessarily replace required mechanical recovery

capacities. We will consider requirements for high-rate removal

technologies in a separate response cap rulemaking. A credit provision

currently exists within the vessel and facility regulations for

ensuring the availability of a dispersant capability (high-rate removal

technology), which may be applied toward the total required recovery

capacity a planholder must ensure available. Planholders may take

advantage of this existing credit, as appropriate, to meet the

scheduled cap increase. However, planholders should be aware that we

are considering the removal of this credit from the regulations as part

of a separate rulemaking.

Recovery System Components

One comment suggested the caps review should take a ``systems''

approach to evaluating the need for an equipment cap increase. We

agree. The Cap Review, in making its determination of the

practicability of an increase, reviewed each of the components of a

mechanical recovery system, including containment booms, skimming

mechanisms, pumps, storage devices, and oil-water separators. The

review revealed that improvements to the overall technology and

operability of mechanical recovery systems support the practicability

of an equipment increase.

One comment stated that the proposed increases should apply to all

components of a mechanical recovery system, not just boom, skimmers,

and storage devices. We agree. The cap increase as set out in 33 CFR

154.1045(m) and 33 CFR 155.1050(o) specifically addresses the

requirements in 33 CFR part 154, Table 5 of Appendix C and 33 CFR part

155, Table 6 of Appendix B. These tables establish increased amounts

for effective daily recovery capacity (EDRC) that must be ensured

available. While EDRC is used to determine the required number of oil

recovery devices (through calculations outlined in 33 CFR part 154,

paragraph 6 of Appendix C and 33 CFR part 155, paragraph 6 of Appendix

B), the increased EDRC values are also indirectly applied to the

``system'' of resources necessary to sustain those recovery devices.

Title 33 CFR part 154, paragraph 9.2 of Appendix C, and 33 CFR part

155, paragraph 9.2 of Appendix B, both require that temporary storage

for the recovered oil be ensured available in amounts equivalent to

twice that of EDRC. Since the regulations establish a direct proportion

between EDRC and temporary storage, an increase in EDRC requires that

temporary storage amounts also increase by 25 percent. Title 33 CFR

part 154, paragraph 9.1 of Appendix C, and 33 CFR part 155, paragraph

9.1 of Appendix B, also require that sufficient numbers of ancillary

equipment (such as trained personnel, boats, spotting aircraft,

sorbents, booms and other resources as necessary to support the oil

recovery devices employed), are ensured available to achieve the

required EDRC values. While specific amounts of such ancillary

equipment are not required to be listed in the response plans, the

levels of ancillary equipment should increase as necessary to support

the 25 percent increase in EDRC. It is the planholder's responsibility

to ensure and certify that ancillary response resources are available

to support the cap increase. We may amend the OSRO classification

guidelines to include more detailed guidance concerning ancillary

equipment necessary to support the cap increase in an effort to assist

planholders and reviewers.

One comment stated that the cap increase should not be required for

containment boom. We disagree. Title 33 CFR 154.1045(e)(3) and 33 CFR

part 154, paragraph 5.6 of Appendix C (for facilities), and 33 CFR

155.1050(f)(3) and 33 CFR part 155, paragraph 5.6 of Appendix B (for

vessels) indicate that sufficient amounts of containment and collection

boom must be ensured available to recover the required EDRC volumes. If

EDRC values increase as a result of the cap increase, then it is

reasonable to assume that the amounts of containment and collection

boom must increase proportionately. While specific amounts of

containment and collection boom are not required to be listed in the

response plans, the levels of boom ensured available should increase as

necessary to support the increase in EDRC. We may amend the OSRO

classification guidelines to include more detailed guidance concerning

amounts of collection and containment boom necessary to support the cap

increase.

Two comments stated that the cap increase should increase the

amount of shoreline protection boom that must be ensured available. One

comment stated that the cap increases should not apply to shoreline

protection boom requirements. The cap increase, as set out in 33 CFR

154.1045(m) and 33 CFR 155.1050(o), applies specifically to the

equipment requirements contained in 33 CFR part 154, Table 5 of

Appendix C and 33 CFR part 155, Table 6 of Appendix B. Tables 5 and 6

do not contain any requirements to increase shoreline protection boom

amounts. Therefore, the cap increase will not affect the amount of

shoreline protection boom required to be ensured available. The

regulatory requirements for shoreline protection boom will not increase

and will remain as originally outlined in 1993 (see 33 CFR 155.1050(m)

and 33 CFR part 155, Appendix B, Table 2 for vessel response plans, and

by 33 CFR 154.1045(k) and 33 CFR part 154, Appendix C, paragraph 5.6

for facility response plans).

Deployment Ability

One comment stated that the Cap Review should consider the ability

to deploy equipment when determining whether a cap increase is

practicable. We agree. The cap requirements were originally designed in

part to reflect the limitations of a planholder's ability to deploy and

effectively manage equipment during the initial phase of a response.

The Cap Review, in making its determination for practicability,

evaluated the technological and operational feasibility of deploying

increased amounts of equipment. Improvements in equipment technology

and availability, as well as advances in the ability to track, deploy,

and manage resources were all factors that indicate an increase is

practicable.

One comment stated that training and exercising of response

personnel and equipment has improved greatly since 1993 and has

resulted in a far greater capability to operate and deploy such

equipment effectively. We agree that personnel training and response

exercises have improved the ability of today's responders to deploy and

operate response equipment effectively. The improvements to personnel

training and response exercises support the determination that it is

practicable to increase the cap for mechanical recovery systems.

OSRO Classification

One comment stated that the 25 percent cap increase appears

reasonable and should carry over to OSRO classification standards. We

agree and the OSRO guidelines will be adjusted to reflect the increases

in equipment required by the cap increase.

Seven comments stated the Cap Review should focus on the quality of

equipment, rather than increasing the quantity. We agree that quality

is a relevant issue, but one that will be addressed outside of the Cap

Review process. Standards or guidelines that address the quality of

response equipment would be better addressed as revisions to the OSRO

classification guidelines. We will review the OSRO guidelines and

consider the question of equipment quality during that process.

Two comments stated that the Coast Guard must revise the OSRO

classification program before any cap increases are implemented. We

disagree. Potential changes to the OSRO classification program are best

addressed separately from the cap increase. Most OSRO-related issues of

recent concern do not directly involve the cap increase and do not need

to be addressed before the implementation of the increase. The Coast

Guard will be addressing the OSRO-related issues in workshops that are

planned during the next year. The Coast Guard will announce the

schedule and agenda for these workshops in a separate Federal Register

document.

Response Database

One comment suggested that the government should capture

information on personnel, vessels, and response equipment and store

that information in a database that is universally available and

frequently updated. We agree. Currently this information is maintained

in the Response Resource Inventory (RRI). However, it is not

universally available at this time. We are considering methods to

improve or increase public accessibility to this database.

Costs

Two comments stated that the economic costs and benefits of all OPA

90 requirements should be considered when determining whether to

increase the response caps. Four comments stated that a cap increase

must consider the cost and benefits of such an increase, and is not

practicable because the caps will increase costs without providing any

benefits to the preparedness of a planholder to respond. And, an

additional comment stated that OPA 90 prevention measures have lowered

the risk of spills substantially, and the need for a cap increase

should look at current risk rather than pre-OPA 90 risk.

We agree. The Coast Guard has determined that the treatment of

equipment caps increases presented in the regulatory impact analysis

for vessel response plans that was published in January of 1993 is

legally sufficient to support actions enumerated in this notice of

decision. We also agree that consideration of the economic costs and

benefits of all the OPA 90 requirements, and therefore, consideration

of current risk rather than pre-OPA 90 risk, is a valid approach.

Accordingly, a risk analysis based on post-OPA 90 experience will be

completed as part of a new economic analysis. The new economic analysis

will in turn be used as a principal program decision tool for equipment

caps decisions scheduled for the year 2003.

One comment stated that the Cap Review should consider the economic

impacts of additional equipment requirements on OSROs. It stated that

there are fewer OSROs today resulting in a reduction of the number of

qualified and trained personnel available for a major response.

Additional cost burdens on the OSROs may result in OSROs going out of

business. OPA 90 and resulting vessel response plan rules that were

mandated by OPA 90, established a demand for response products and

services as it established a captive market for them. Market-driven

adjustments, such as ``shakeouts'' among providers that result from

cost pressures, are a natural occurrence which we would expect. A

threat to the availability of qualified and trained personnel does not

necessarily follow. The federally established demand remains and prices

are expected to be the incentive that results in a balance with the

supply of qualified and trained personnel available for a major

response.

One comment stated that the cap increase will force OSROs to

purchase new equipment, which will reduce the amount of funds spent on

training and exercises in the future. We disagree. The Cap Review has

found by examination of public comment and independent research that

most OSROs have already purchased the required equipment in

anticipation of the scheduled increase. The majority of OSROs will not

have to purchase new equipment to meet this cap increase. The Coast

Guard has no evidence to suggest that funding normally spent on

personnel training and response exercises will decrease as a result of

equipment purchases driven by this cap increase.

Review Standard for Increase

Two comments stated that the Cap Review must show a scientific and

economic justification for an increase. One comment stated that the Cap

Review must prove that a net environmental benefit would result from an

increase. Section 4202(a) of the OPA 90 states that response plans

shall ensure the availability of private personnel and equipment

necessary to remove, to the maximum extent practicable, a worst case

discharge. The Cap Review evaluated the scheduled increase against the

standard of practicability, as required by the statute. This evaluation

included an assessment of the technological, operational, and economic

feasibility, and found the increase to be practicable.

Public Resources

One comment stated that the equipment ensured available by industry

should not increase, but should be augmented with public resources in

order to meet the demands of a worst case discharge. We disagree.

Section 4202(a) of OPA 90 states that response

plans must ensure, by contract or other means approved by the

President, the availability of private personnel and equipment

necessary to remove, to the maximum extent practicable, a worst case

discharge. OPA 90 clearly states that the capability to respond to a

worst case discharge should be provided by the private sector, to the

maximum extent practicable. The Cap Review evaluated the scheduled

increase against the standard of practicability and found that it is

practicable for the private sector to provide the increase.

Discussion of Decision

In accordance with 33 CFR 154.1045(n) and 155.1050(p), we have

completed our review of the 25 percent cap increase for on-water

mechanical recovery capacity, and have determined that the increase, as

originally scheduled for February 18, 1998, is practicable. This notice

announces the results of the Cap Review and sets an implementation date

for the scheduled increase listed in Table 1. The increase was

originally scheduled for vessel response plans in 33 CFR part 155,

Appendix B, Table 6, and for facility response plans in 33 CFR part

154, Appendix C, Table 5, to take effect on February 18, 1998.

Table 1.--1993 and Scheduled Increases to Capability Limits on Mechanical Recovery Equipment for Vessels and Facilities

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1993 Caps (BPD) Scheduled Increase (BPD)

Geographic area -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Tier I Tier II Tier III Tier I Tier II Tier III

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

All except rivers and canals and Great Lakes............ 10,000 20,000 40,000 12,500 25,000 50,000

Great Lakes............................................. 5,000 10,000 20,000 6,250 12,500 25,000

Rivers and canals....................................... 1,500 3,000 6,000 1,875 3,750 7,500

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Note: BPD, barrels per day. Table 1 corrects previously published typographical errors in Great Lakes Tier I and Tier II increases.

A team of policy and technical professionals prepared the Cap

Review for the Coast Guard. This team had extensive experience in oil

spill preparedness and response, USCG policy and regulatory

development, and technical, operational, and policy considerations

affecting mechanical recovery, dispersant, and in situ burn equipment

and its use. The team examined peer-reviewed, scientific, and technical

papers as well as government documents, including Federal Register

documents, government reports, the USCG spill database (Marine Safety

Information System (MSIS)), and comments to the docket regarding the

proposed cap increase.

This Cap Review focused on the open-water removal of Groups I

through IV oils as defined in 33 CFR 155.1020. Although the recovery of

Group V oils has become a topic of interest in recent years, the

recovery techniques and equipment for these oils are not well

developed, and equipment caps have not been established for such oils

under the current regulations (per 33 CFR 154.1047 and 33 CFR

155.1052).

In order to assess the practicability of the scheduled 25 percent

increase in mechanical recovery equipment, the review evaluated the

planholders' current capability to implement the oil recovery process

as compared with that which existed in 1993. In doing so throughout the

United States for each generic operating environment (oceans, inland,

Great Lakes, rivers, and canals), primarily three important elements

were considered: technological capability, commercial or market

availability, and the availability of existing equipment stocks to

respond within the prescribed time limitations (Tiers I, II, and III

response times).

Technological capability was assessed by reviewing advances in

systems and equipment design, which have occurred over the past 5

years. This assessment evaluated improvements in oil spill tracking

systems, booms and skimming devices, oil/water separation and emulsion-

breaking systems, and modular, easily transported, temporary storage

devices. The original caps were limited, in part, due to the

difficulties in effectively tracking multiple response operations

simultaneously. Visual observation by aircraft and the use of remote

sensing systems enhance oil recovery by allowing more precise direction

of oil removal response resources to the thickest portions of the

spilled oil. Advances in aerial surveillance and other oil tracking

systems have improved and, when used in conjunction with improved

command and control systems, support the deployment of increased levels

of response equipment effectively. Improvements in command and control,

such as the increased use of an incident command system (ICS), and the

establishment of a network of qualified individuals (QIs), and spill

management teams (SMTs) also support the effective deployment and

tracking of a greater number of response resources during the initial

phases of a spill than was possible in 1993.

Conventional on-water mechanical recovery equipment, however, has

not improved significantly since 1993 in terms of design efficiency or

effectiveness. While improved storage units are more readily available

to support skimming units, actual recovery rates are still limited by

skimmer mechanics and pump rates. Therefore, the increases in daily

recovery capacity require that additional recovery equipment is ensured

available. As the efficiency of most skimming devices has not improved

significantly, increases in recovery capacity continue to require an

additional increase in storage at the existing storage to EDRC ratio of

two to one (2:1). While there has been some improvement in oil/water

separation systems, this type of technology has not been widely

procured and is not generally available in most recovery systems. In

situations where large recovery units, such as large seagoing oil spill

response vessels (OSRVs), have demonstrated that installed separation

systems have improved their ability to store and recover oil,

allowances have been granted through the OSRO classification program.

Situations such as these, however, do not support a generic credit or

offset for separator systems with respect EDRC or storage requirements.

Commercial or market availability was assessed by reviewing

equipment currently on the market in terms of representative models and

their intended applications as compared with that which was available 5

years ago. The primary references for this assessment were the fourth

and sixth editions of the World Catalog of Oil Spill Response Products

(Schulze, 1993, 1997). The assessment revealed that the number of

models available for each of the components of an on-water recovery

system has increased. Equipment is

widely available for purchase, and a healthy level of competition

exists among manufacturers capable of maintaining a current and

adequate stock of response equipment at increased levels. The overall

availability of new oil spill response equipment in the commercial

market has improved since 1993.

The availability of existing equipment stocks for deployment to

spills was assessed by reviewing nationwide inventories of major items

such as booms, skimmers, skimming vessels, and temporary storage

devices. Primary data was compiled using the Coast Guard National

Strike Force Coordination Center's (NSFCC) Response Resource Inventory

(RRI). The resulting equipment distribution and the daily recovery

capacity it represented were examined for each geographic region and

operating environment. The comparison of the scheduled cap increase

with the existing equipment stocks available to planholders clearly

indicated that planning for a response is not equipment limited. The

scheduled 25 percent cap increase can easily be accommodated with the

existing stocks of equipment available to planholders for each

geographical region and operating environment.

The assessments of technological capability, market availability,

and regional availability of existing stocks, support the determination

that the scheduled increase in caps is practicable. For a more detailed

explanation of these findings, the Cap Review can be viewed on the

Internet at the sites listed in the ADDRESSES section.

Other removal technologies. The Cap Review also evaluated the

following topics:

a. Additional proposed increases for on-water mechanical removal

capacity in 2003.

b. Advances in oil tracking technology.

c. Improvements in high-rate removal technologies such as

dispersants or in situ burning.

The conclusions and recommendations of the Cap Review concerning

these topics are contained within the Response Plan Equipment Cap

Review document. This notice does not address these topics and makes no

changes to existing regulations or policy. However, we intend to

address any additional cap increases for mechanical recovery or other

removal technologies in a subsequent rulemaking. The Cap Review

recommendations regarding these other removal technologies should be

viewed as information only. We will consider them along with previously

received public comments when formulating any subsequent rulemakings.

Dated: December 28, 1999.

Joseph J. Angelo,

Acting Assistant Commandant for Marine Safety and Environmental

Protection.

[FR Doc. 00-31 Filed 1-5-00; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 4910-15-U

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.