AZ Circular Letter 1981-03: Reasonableness of Benefits in Relation to Premium Charged

STATE OF ARIZONA

DEPARTMENT OF INSURANCE

JANE DEE HULL

2910 NORTH 44th STREET, SUITE 210

CHARLES R. COHEN

Governor

PHOENIX, ARIZONA 85018-7256

Director of Insurance

602/912-8456 (phone) 602/912-8452 (fax)

Former Director J. Michael Low issued the following Circular Letter on July 24, 1981:

REASONABLENESS OF BENEFITS IN RELATION TO

PREMIUM CHARGED

July 24, 1981

You should be advised that Rule R4-14-607, entitled Reasonableness of Benefits

in Relation to Premium Charged, took effect on July 14, 1981. This regulation, which

establishes anticipated loss ratio standards for individual accident and health insurance

policies, is designed to assist the Department in implementing ARS § 20-1342.02. That

statutory provision provides that “The director may disapprove any disability policy form

if the benefits provided in the policy form are unreasonable in relation to the premium

charged.” id.

Rule R4-14-607 is similar to the NAIC Guidelines for Filing of Rules for Individual

Health Insurance Forms; however, there are some differences in our regulation.

Essentially, every new individual policy and endorsement form must be accompanied by

a rate filing, unless there is no rate charge involved. Every rate filing must include an

actuarial memorandum, including an anticipated loss ratio which must be based upon

the present value of the expected benefit to the present value of the expected premium

over the entire period for which the rates are computed to provide coverage. The rate

filing must also contain a certification by the actuary that the filing is in conformance with

the regulation and that the benefits are reasonable in relation to the premium charged.

Actuarial memorandums should include the following information:

1) A description of the type of policy, benefits, renewability and issue age limits.

2) A description of how rates were determined, including the general description

and source of each assumption used.

3) The estimated average annual premium per policy

regulation and that the benefits are reasonable in relation to the premium charged.

Actuarial memorandums should include the following information:

1) A description of the type of policy, benefits, renewability and issue age limits.

2) A description of how rates were determined, including the general description

and source of each assumption used.

3) The estimated average annual premium per policy. This figure will be used to

determine the minimum anticipated loss ratio presumed reasonable in the rule under the

appropriate type of coverage and renewability features.

July 24, 1981

Page 2

4) The anticipated loss ratio and a description of how it was calculated. For rate

increases applying to existing in force business, the anticipated future loss ratio and the

estimated cumulative loss ratio, past and future would be required. If any loss ratio less

than the minimum anticipated loss ratio, the company would need to file substantial

supporting documentation for the use of the particular rate.

5) The minimum anticipated loss ratio presumed reasonable in the rule for

purposes of the particular type of coverage and renewability features.

It is suggested that the following certification be used by the actuary in submitting

a particular rate filing:

I hereby certify that, to the best of my knowledge and belief, the rate filing

submitted herein is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations

of Arizona, including ACRR R4-14-607; that the anticipated loss ratio

submitted herein is expected to develop over the period for which the

rates are computed to provide coverage; that the benefits of the policy

form affected by the rate filing are reasonable in relation to the premiums

charged.

________________________________

Actuary

For all previously approved forms, any rate revision must also be filed, together

with an appropriate statement describing the anticipated loss ratio for the particular form

and whether the rate will apply only to new business or also to existing policies in force

policy

form affected by the rate filing are reasonable in relation to the premiums

charged.

________________________________

Actuary

For all previously approved forms, any rate revision must also be filed, together

with an appropriate statement describing the anticipated loss ratio for the particular form

and whether the rate will apply only to new business or also to existing policies in force.

Insurers must also maintain adequate records of earned premium and incurred losses

for each policy form written so that credible data from the company’s experience can be

derived.

It should also be noted that, under this regulation, anticipated loss ratio standards

will vary depending on the type of coverage (i.e., either medical expense or loss of

income) and whether the policy falls within a particular renewal category (optionally

renewable, conditionally renewable, guaranteed renewable and non-cancellable).

Although the rule makes provisions for special circumstances that might affect the

anticipated loss ratios projected to develop, the burden is clearly on the insurer to justify

a particular factor which warrants special consideration. Additionally, notwithstanding

the existence of special circumstances, all hospital indemnity and cancer insurance

policies must develop the specific anticipated loss ratio standards prescribed in the rule.

Rule R4-14-607 will apply to all individual accident and health insurance policy

forms, other than Medicare supplement coverages and credit disability insurance, which

must be filed with the Department on and after July 14, 1981. However, it is important

to realize that notwithstanding the scope of this regulation, all individual accident and

health insurance forms are subject to A.R.S. § 20-1342.02. Therefore, the Department

will periodically monitor existing policy forms, regardless of whether a rate change has

been made after July 14, 1981.

insurance, which

must be filed with the Department on and after July 14, 1981. However, it is important

to realize that notwithstanding the scope of this regulation, all individual accident and

health insurance forms are subject to A.R.S. § 20-1342.02. Therefore, the Department

will periodically monitor existing policy forms, regardless of whether a rate change has

been made after July 14, 1981.

July 24, 1981

Page 3

If you would like to receive a copy of this regulation, please write to Margaret

McClelland, Department of Insurance Rules Analyst at 2910 N. 44th Street, Suite 210,

Phoenix, Arizona 85018. Enclose a $2.00 fee to cover the Department’s reproduction

and mailing costs. If you have any questions concerning the rule, ARS § 20-1342.02 or

this circular letter, please contact Alexandra Shafer, Assistant Director of the

Department’s Life and Health Division at (602) 912-8460.

J. Michael Low

DIRECTOR OF INSURANCE