Case law

Opinions from 1658 to today.

Filters1939

10,000+ results

5.73s

  • Williams v. Mayor & City Council

    128 Md. App. 1 · Court of Special Appeals of Maryland · Sep 7, 1999

    The Maryland case law establishes unequivocally that police officers in the course of their public duties are public officials within the contemplation of the qualified immunity law. … We hold that in enacting the immunity provision of Ch. 307 of the Acts of 1979, it clearly was not the legislative intent to diminish or to curtail in any way the qualified immunity otherwise enjoyed by a law enforcement

    Reversed on other grounds by Williams v. Mayor of Baltimore, 359 Md. 101 (2000)Cited 8 timesPublished
  • Peter I. Diamondstone v. Christopher A. MacAluso Leroy Prior, David R. Stanton, A. James Walton, Jr., and State of Vermont

    148 F.3d 113 · Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit · Jun 22, 1998

    Qualified Immunity i. … Even “[w]here a right is clearly established, ‘the defendants may nonetheless establish immunity by showing that reasonable persons in their position would not have understood that their conduct was within the scope of the

    Cited 54 timesPublished
  • Daniel Irish v. Keith McNamara

    108 F.4th 715 · Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit · Jul 18, 2024

    Deputy McNamara moved to dismiss the complaint based on qualified immunity. … During argument on the motion, the district court observed that this was a “highly unfortunate accident,” but it nevertheless denied qualified immunity, reasoning that it was clearly established that a seizure occurred within

    Cited 7 timesPublished
  • Askari Abdullah Muhammad, 017434 v. Louie L. Wainwright, Richard Dugger, Clayton C. Strickland, David Watson, Thomas L. Barton, R.R. Music

    839 F.2d 1422 · Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit · Dec 28, 1987

    Muhammad further argues that because this area of the law was clearly established, defendants should not be permitted to avail themselves of qualified immunity. … Broadly defining “clearly established law” as Muhammad suggests significantly undermines part of the rationale for the qualified immunity defense.

    Cited 66 timesPublished
  • Erika Mabes v. Shannon Thompson

    Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit · Apr 28, 2025

    Both sets of defendants invoked qual- ified immunity, contending that their actions did not violate the Mabeses’ clearly established rights. … Thompson’s en- titlement to qualified immunity naturally follows from the Mabeses’ failure to carry their “burden of demonstrating the violation of a clearly established right.” Forman v.

    Cited 0 timesPublished
  • Michael L. Davis v. John Zirkelbach

    149 F.3d 614 · Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit · Jul 9, 1998

    Ordinarily, because Lenn is entitled to qualified immunity from a suit based on the legal advice he gave to the police officers, we would ask whether his actions violated a clearly established statutory or constitutional … In Harlow , the Supreme Court explained its scope as follows: *620 If the law was clearly established, the immunity defense ordinarily should fail, since a reasonably competent public official should know the law governing

    Cited 74 timesPublished
  • Colston v. Barnhart

    130 F.3d 96 · Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit · Jul 29, 1998

    Disputes over the application of the clearly-established-law prong of the qualified-immunity inquiry are separable from the merits of a controversy because “‘[a]n appellate court reviewing the denial of the defendant … The semantic switch from discussing the typical qualified-immunity issue of “clearly established law” to a hypothetical (in Behrens) issue of “objective legal reasonableness” creates many of the problems that are now plaguing

    Cited 36 timesPublished
  • Darby v. Bratch

    287 F.3d 673 · Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit · Apr 11, 2002

    immunity. … The Family and Medical Leave Act creates clearly established statutory rights, including the right to be free of discrimination or retaliation on account of one's exercise of leave rights granted by the statute. 13 Qualified

    Cited 50 timesPublished
  • Stasher v. City of Jackson, Mississippi

    District Court, S.D. Mississippi · Sep 13, 2022

    Unless the public official’s conduct violated a clearly established constitutional right, he is cloaked with qualified immunity. (citing Anderson v. Creighton, 483 U.S. 635, 640 (1987)). … Lamar County Texas, 717 F.3d 410, 422-24 (5th Cir. 2013) (Qualified immunity extends to public officials “to the extent their conduct is objectively reasonable in light of clearly established law.”).

    Cited 0 timesUnknown
  • Johnson v. Clifton

    74 F.3d 1087 · Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit · Jan 26, 1996

    clearly established law. … of clearly established law.

    Cited 126 timesPublished
  • Roric Gibbs v. Brooke Lomas

    755 F.3d 529 · Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit · Jun 17, 2014

    Gibbs’s constitutional rights and, even if she did, those rights were not clearly established when she acted. Accordingly, she urges, she is entitled to qualified immunity. … Qualified immunity “protects government officials from liability for civil damages insofar as their conduct does not violate clearly established statutory or constitutional rights of which a reasonable person would have known

    Cited 137 timesPublished
  • Behrens v. Pelletier

    516 U.S. 299 · Supreme Court of the United States · Feb 21, 1996

    On the merits of the appeal, the court rejected the argument that petitioner enjoyed qualified immunity because he had not violated any “clearly established right.” … allegations state a claim of violation of clearly established law, a defendant pleading qualified immunity is entitled to dismissal before the commencement of discovery.

    Disagreed with by a later decision, 153 F.3d 591 (1998)Cited 1,950 timesPublished
  • Whiteru v. Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority

    258 F. Supp. 3d 175 · District Court, District of Columbia · Jul 7, 2017

    WMATA’s first argument—that there is no statute, regulation, or policy on point—is clearly unavailing. … rely on “SSOP 46 alone” to establish this standard.

    Cited 26 timesPublished
  • Brautigam v. Fraley

    684 F. Supp. 2d 589 · District Court, M.D. Pennsylvania · Feb 4, 2010

    and official immunity and remain immune from suit except as the General Assembly shall specifically waive the immunity. … The court specifically distinguished the immunity for an employee of the Commonwealth versus the immunity conferred by statute upon the employee of a municipality: We note that the immunity defense provided by the General

    Cited 38 timesPublished
  • Cugini v. City of New York, Palazzola

    941 F.3d 604 · Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit · Oct 25, 2019

    It granted the defendantsʹ motion for summary judgment, however, on the ground that Palazzola was entitled to qualified immunity because his behavior did not constitute a violation of a clearly established constitutional … However, because at the time of the plaintiffʹs arrest Palazzolaʹs actions did not violate clearly established constitutional law, the district court correctly concluded that his actions were protected by qualified immunity

    Cited 112 timesPublished
  • Martha Stringer v. County of Bucks

    141 F.4th 76 · Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit · Jun 18, 2025

    established, as required for qualified immunity. … Stringer’s clearly established constitutional rights.” Opening Br. 25, 28 (emphasis added). But that conflates the two prongs of qualified immunity.

    Cited 31 timesPublished
  • Hollingsworth v. Hill

    110 F.3d 733 · Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit · Apr 4, 1997

    Hollingsworth relies are not clearly established. Ms. Hollingsworth argues that Deputy Hill is not entitled to qualified immunity because a reasonable person in Hill’s position would have known that entry into Ms. … Objective Reasonableness and Extraordinary Circumstances Once the plaintiff has established the inference that the defendant’s conduct violated a clearly established constitutional right, a qualified immunity defense

    Cited 136 timesPublished
  • Sudah v. District of Columbia

    District Court, District of Columbia · Jul 25, 2025

    And if he fails to show that his asserted right was clearly established after a defendant officer asserts qualified immunity, courts properly grant the officer’s motion to dismiss. E.g., Turpin v. Ray, 319 F. … Cir. 2016) (affirming dismissal of a complaint on qualified-im- munity grounds when the plaintiff had not shown that the right at issue was clearly established at the time of the purported violation).

    Cited 0 timesPublished
  • DeBoer v. Pennington

    206 F.3d 857 · Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit · Mar 17, 2000

    If the right is not clearly established, the individual defendants are entitled to qualified immunity. See Thompson v. Souza, 111 F.3d 694, 698 (9th Cir.1997). … Clearly Established Law Having identified the right at issue, we must determine whether it was clearly established before January 31, 1995.

    Vacated on other grounds by City of Bellingham v. DeBoer, 532 U.S. 992 (2001)Cited 24 timesPublished
  • Ajaj v. Federal Bureau of Prisons

    25 F.4th 805 · Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit · Feb 9, 2022

    The defense of qualified immunity is a judicially recognized doctrine that shields government officials “from liability for civil damages insofar as their conduct does not violate clearly established statutory or constitutional … Thus, the same context that supported a RFRA damages remedy also supported the application of qualified-immunity doctrine, which limits individual liability to violations of clearly established law.

    Cited 12 timesPublished

Ask Donna

Ask Donna

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.