Opinion

Bivens v. Six Unknown Named Agents of Federal Bureau of Narcotics

  • 403 U.S. 388
  • 91 S. Ct. 1999
  • 29 L. Ed. 2d 619
  • 1971 U.S. LEXIS 23
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Filed
Jun 21, 1971
Status
Published
Author
Blackmun
On the bench
Brennan
Cited by
17,826 cases

Questioned by BARRIOS v. HASKELL COUNTY PUBLIC FACILITIES AUTHORITY FOUTCH v. TURN KEY HEALTH, 2018 OK 90 (2018)

holding that federal officials can be sued personally for money damages for the alleged violation of constitutional rights stemming from official acts. Federal officials can also be subjected to claims against them in their individual capacity for official acts based upon state common law, statutory provisions and professional licensing matters.

How later courts described this case

  • holding that federal officials can be sued personally for money damages for the alleged violation of constitutional rights stemming from official acts. Federal officials can also be subjected to claims against them in their individual capacity for official acts based upon state common law, statutory provisions and professional licensing matters.
  • stating that direct constitutional damage remedy should at least be available “for the most flagrant and patently unjustified sorts of police conduct,” keeping in mind that “the countervailing interests in efficient law enforcement of course argue for a protective zone with respect to many types of Fourth Amendment violations”
  • holding that a remedy is available for a federal agent’s violation of a citizen’s Fourth Amendment right to be free from warrantless searches and Braxton is a prisoner, he must still pay the $350 filing fee for this case in installments as required by the Prison Litigation Reform Act. seizures
  • holding that an individual may bring a private cause of action under the Fourth Amendment, even in the absence of statutory authority, and is entitled to recover money damages for any injuries he has suffered as a result of a federal agent's violation of the Fourth Amendment

Written by the judges who cited it.

Later courts went against this

  • Questioned by BARRIOS v. HASKELL COUNTY PUBLIC FACILITIES AUTHORITY FOUTCH v. TURN KEY HEALTH, 2018 OK 90 (2018)

    More tellingly, the Supreme Court has suggested that the continuing validity of Bivens, Davis, and Carlson turns in part on the lack of congressional disapproval of the decisions.
    Supreme Court of OklahomaDec 4, 2018Read it
  • Declined to follow by Hernandez v. Mesa, 140 S. Ct. 735 (2020)

    Because of the distinctive characteristics of cross-border shooting claims, we refuse to extend Bivens into this new field.
    Supreme Court of the United StatesFeb 25, 2020Read it
  • Declined to follow by Holly v. Scott, 434 F.3d 287 (2006)

    We decline to extend the Bivens cause of action to these circumstances, both because the actions of the private prison employees are not fairly attributable to the federal government and because the inmate has adequate remedies under state law for his alleged injuries.
    Court of Appeals for the Fourth CircuitJan 12, 2006Read it
  • Declined to follow by Spagnola v. Mathis, 859 F.2d 223 (1988)

    While we decline to extend Bivens remedies to Hubbard and Spagnola, we do not suggest that the CSRA precludes the exercise of federal jurisdiction over the constitutional claims of federal employees and job applicants altogether.
    Court of Appeals for the D.C. CircuitSep 30, 1988Read it
  • Declined to follow by Ramon ex rel. Ramon v. Soto, 916 F.2d 1377 (1989)

    In light of the impressive array of cases on point, we decline to follow Professor Davis’s suggestion that Bivens be held to apply to official capacity suits against the United States.
    Court of Appeals for the Ninth CircuitNov 15, 1989Read it
  • Declined to follow by Mirmehdi v. United States, 662 F.3d 1073 (2011)

    Accordingly, we decline to extend Bivens to allow the Mirmehdis to sue federal agents for wrongful detention pending deportation given the extensive remedial procedures available to and invoked by them and the unique foreign policy considerations implicated in the immigration context.
    Court of Appeals for the Ninth CircuitNov 3, 2011Read it

Distinguished

  • Distinguished by Jarita Mesa Livestock Grazing Ass'n v. United States Forest Service, 58 F. Supp. 3d 1191 (2014)

    They argue, primarily, that Bivens’ alternative remedy framework is inapplicable, because Bivens suits involve money damages, and not equitable relief, and, additionally, because there is no basis in the case law to suggest that it should be applied to the APA.
    District Court, D. New MexicoOct 22, 2014Read it
  • Distinguished by Arar v. Ashcroft, 585 F.3d 559 (2009)

    Even so, the authority cited by Judge Calabresi, which suggests deciding whether a claim is stated before doing Bivens analysis, is inapposite.
    Court of Appeals for the Second CircuitNov 2, 2009Read it
  • Distinguished by Jones v. City of Philadelphia, 68 Pa. D. & C.4th 47 (2004)

    The city argues that Bivens is inapplicable here because it involved claims against individual officers, not the federal agency.
    Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Philadelphia CountyJul 30, 2004Read it
  • Distinguished by Turner v. Holbrook, 278 F.3d 754 (2002)

    Turner contends her Bivens claims are distinguishable because postal inspectors, that is, law enforcement officers, interrogated her about possible criminal violations.
    Court of Appeals for the Eighth CircuitFeb 1, 2002Read it

The opinion

Mr. Justice Blackmun,

dissenting.

I, too, dissent. I do so largely for the reasons expressed in Chief Judge Lumbard’s thoughtful and scholarly opinion for the Court of Appeals. But I also feel that the judicial legislation, which the Court by its opinion today concededly is effectuating, opens the door for another avalanche of new federal cases. Whenever a suspect imagines, or chooses to assert, that a Fourth Amendment right has been violated, he will now immediately sue the federal officer in federal court. This will tend to stultify proper law enforcement and to make the day’s labor for the honest and conscientious officer- even more onerous and more critical. Why the Court moves in this direction at this time of our history, I do not know. The Fourth Amendment was adopted in 1791, and in all the intervening years neither the Congress nor the Court has seen fit to take this step. I had thought that for the truly aggrieved person other quite adequate remedies have always been available. If not, ¿t is the Congress and not this Court that should act.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.