explaining that the intent requirement in a claim for tortious interference—which requires that a “defendant must have engaged in intentionally wrongful acts designed to disrupt the plaintiff's relationship” is designed to limit “both the potential number of plaintiffs that may bring a claim under this tort and the remoteness of these plaintiffs to a defendant's wrongful Page 17 of 23 conduct”
How later courts described this case
- explaining that the intent requirement in a claim for tortious interference—which requires that a “defendant must have engaged in intentionally wrongful acts designed to disrupt the plaintiff's relationship” is designed to limit “both the potential number of plaintiffs that may bring a claim under this tort and the remoteness of these plaintiffs to a defendant's wrongful Page 17 of 23 conduct”
- holding that “disgorgement of profits allegedly obtained by means of an unfair business practice” is not “an authorized remedy under the UCL where the profits are neither money taken from a plaintiff nor funds in which the plaintiff has an ownership interest”
- explaining that restitution involves the return of money "to those persons in interest from whom the property was taken," while disgorgement, though it may include restitution, is not limited to the return of monies actually taken (emphasis supplied)
- explaining that penalty provisions, like § 226, cannot be enforced through § 17200, which permits a violation of another law to be actionable as an “unfair competitive practice” only if the remedy sought is equitable in nature
Written by the judges who cited it.
The opinion
WERDEGAR, J., Concurring.
I agree with the majority that a plaintiff, in order to state a claim for interference with prospective economic advantage, need not plead that a defendant acted with the specific intent to interfere with the plaintiffs business expectancy, and with the reasoning leading to that conclusion. (Maj. opn., ante, at pp. 1141, 1153-1166.) Under compulsion of Kraus v. Trinity Management Services, Inc. (2000) 23 Cal.4th 116 [ 96 Cal.Rptr.2d 485 , 999 P.2d 718 ], from which I dissented, I further agree that nonrestitutionary disgorgement of profits is not an available remedy in an individual action under the unfair competition law, Business and Professions Code section 17200 et seq. (Maj. opn., ante, at p. 1152.) Accordingly, I concur in the judgment.