holding that Tex. Code Crim.P. Ann. art. 37.07, sec. 4(a) (Vernon Supp.1988) (“the parole statute”), requiring that the trial court instruct the jury on the Texas parole laws, is unconstitutional
How later courts described this case
- holding that Tex. Code Crim.P. Ann. art. 37.07, sec. 4(a) (Vernon Supp.1988) (“the parole statute”), requiring that the trial court instruct the jury on the Texas parole laws, is unconstitutional
- presuming the jury generally follows the trial court's instruction unless appellant presents evidence to rebut presumption
- holding that predecessor statute violated separation of powers and due course of law
- declaring § 4(a) of article 37.07 unconstitutional, on the basis that it violated separation of powers and due course of law clauses
Written by the judges who cited it.
Later courts went against this
Abrogated on other grounds by Karenev v. State, 2009 Tex. Crim. App. LEXIS 961 (2009)
752 S.W.2d 529, 535 (Tex. Crim. App. 1987), abrogated by, Karenev v. State, 281 S.W.3d 428
Limited by Shearer v. State, 1989 Tex. App. LEXIS 1355 (1989)
However, although we agree that the additional instruction discussed in Rose, supra, and Olivarez, supra, is a significant factor in the application of TEX.R.APP.P. 81(b)(2), we disapprove of any suggestion that harmless error is not possible in the absence of such an additional instruction.
The opinion
DUNCAN, Judge,
concurring on Court’s motion for rehearing.
On original submission I joined only that portion of Judge Clinton’s opinion that declared the parole instruction mandated by Art. 37.07, § 4(a) V.A.C.C.P., unconstitutional because it violated the due course of law provision of the Texas Constitution. I also concluded that since submission of the jury instruction was violative of a defendant’s right to due course of law it necessarily followed that a harm analysis as envisioned by Almanza v. State, 686 S.W.2d 157 (Tex.Cr.App.1985) was inappropriate. I continue to adhere to my position that Almanza v. State, id., is inapplicable, but I do agree with Judge Campbell’s position that a harm analysis as required by Rule 81(b)(2) Tex.R.App.Proc. is applicable.
I now also agree with Judge Clinton’s observations that Art. 37.07, § 4(a), V.A.C. C.P., is an unconstitutional legislative intrusion upon the separation of powers doctrine. Therefore, I join completely the opinion of Judge Campbell.
*558 Nevertheless, I feel it is necessary to make these additional comments concerning the legislative activity that resulted in Art. 37.07, § 4(a), supra. It is no secret that Art. 37.07, supra was enacted to pacify a perceived public concern that defendants were being released prematurely from prison. Whether that is a valid thesis is irrelevant. What is relevant, however, is that there was a viable way to respond to the public’s arguable concern.
Assuming that the concern was real and action by the Legislature was necessary, there was a means of doing so without imposing upon the executive and judicial branches of Texas government. Very simply, rather than rely upon the speculation that Art. 37.07, supra, encourages, if the Legislature concluded that prisoners are being released too early all they have to do is alter the standards under which the parole laws are administered. Why the Legislature elected to proceed in the faulty manner that resulted in Art. 37.07, supra, as opposed to confronting the matter in a direct and constitutional way is not readily apparent.
Courts are properly hesitant to declare legislative actions unconstitutional. But when a legislative body acts in a manner that unaccountably usurps the authority and responsibility of another branch of government it is the right and duty of this Court to declare such actions unconstitutional. Art. 37.07, supra was not only an unconstitutional legislative effort, but unnecessary as well.
MILLER, J., joins.