Later courts went against this
Overruled by Leggett v. Northwestern State College, 242 La. 927 (1962)
Brickman was overruled in Leggett v. Northwestern State College, 242 La. 927, 140 So.2d 5 (1962), and the rule was announced that if there is any evidence before the Commission from which a conclusion can be drawn that the employee's conduct is prejudicial to the Service, the Commission's ruling will not be disturbed.
The opinion
HAWTHORNE, Justice
(dissenting).
I concur in the reasons given by Justice McCALEB in his dissenting opinion.