Later courts went against this
Overruled by Leggett v. Northwestern State College, 242 La. 927 (1962)
Brickman was overruled in Leggett v. Northwestern State College, 242 La. 927, 140 So.2d 5 (1962), and the rule was announced that if there is any evidence before the Commission from which a conclusion can be drawn that the employee's conduct is prejudicial to the Service, the Commission's ruling will not be disturbed.
The opinion
PONDER, Justice
(concurring).
In the original opinion handed down in this case we did not consider the sufficiency of the charges made by the appointing authority. On rehearing it has been strenuously urged that the charges were not sufficient to inform the employee of the acts complained of requiring disciplinary action. The written charges preferred by the appointing authority are in effect mere conclusions without stating the. facts upon which they are based. I do not think that the charges herein comply with our Constitution and therefore I concur in the decree. .