Opinion

Peter Clayton McClendon v. City of Columbia, City of Columbia James R. Carney

  • 305 F.3d 314
  • 2002 U.S. App. LEXIS 18318
  • 2002 WL 2027329
Court
Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit
Filed
Sep 5, 2002
Status
Published
Author
Jolly
On the bench
King, Jolly, Higginbotham, Davis, Jones, Smith, Wiener, Barksdale, Garza, -Demoss, Benavides, Stewart, Parker, Dennis, Clement
Cited by
558 cases
Authority
More cited than 26.1%

concluding that the adoption of the state-created-danger doctrine in six circuits was insufficient to create a robust consensus because the circuits were not unanimous in defining the doctrine’s its “contours” or applying it “to a factual context similar to that of the instant case”

How later courts described this case

  • concluding that the adoption of the state-created-danger doctrine in six circuits was insufficient to create a robust consensus because the circuits were not unanimous in defining the doctrine’s its “contours” or applying it “to a factual context similar to that of the instant case”
  • holding that a right may be clearly established based on controlling authority — Supreme Court or Fifth Circuit case law — or " ‘a consensus of cases of persuasive authority' " in other circuits (quoting Wilson v. Layne, 526 U.S. 603, 617, 119 S.Ct. 1692, 143 L.Ed.2d 818 (1999))
  • holding that “neither this court nor the Supreme Court has yet determined whether a citizen has a constitutional right to be free from state-created dangers” and because the plaintiff failed to establish the necessary elements of the theory it would not apply even if available
  • concluding that, although three other circuits recognized constitutional right, their differing "mental state" requirements did not fairly warn government official of what conduct would contravene that right

Written by the judges who cited it.

The opinion

E. GRADY JOLLY, Circuit Judge,

concurring:

The majority has followed a plausible approach in deciding the qualified immunity issue in this case and I concur in the analysis and result reached. However, I agree with Judge Parker’s very convincing dissent to the effect that the most judicially responsible course for this en banc court to follow would be to decide the specific contours of the “state created danger” cause of action under the Due Process Clause. I regret that the majority of the court has chosen to pretermit the resolution of this question once again, leaving the bench and bar in doubt as to whether and to what extent such a cause of action exists in this circuit.

EDITH H. JONES, Circuit Judge,

joined by RHESA HAWKINS BARKSDALE, Circuit Judge, concurring:

I concur in the majority opinion but would emphasize two points. First, it is unnecessary for the court to reach any broad pronouncement on the state-created danger theory of § 1983 liability because, at the level of generality represented by the facts before us, no such theory would be viable. This is why it is imperative for courts carefully to address the first question in qualified immunity analysis: whether, under existing law, the plaintiff states a claim for violation of a clearly established federal right

Second, the panel seriously erred by disregarding ten years’ precedents of this court refusing to adopt the theory and instead holding that theory “clearly established” by other circuits’ decisions as of 1993. No matter what was clearly established elsewhere, that theory certainly was not and is not established in this court. Fidelity to circuit precedent demands granting qualified immunity whenever the law in this circuit has remained in flux before and after the events that give rise to a particular claim. Compare Butera v. District of Columbia, 235 F.3d 637 (D.C.Cir.2001).

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.