Opinion

City of Shawnee v. Exchange National Co.

  • 185 Okla. 451
  • 94 P.2d 250
  • 1939 OK 331
  • 1939 Okla. LEXIS 374
Court
Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Filed
Sep 26, 1939
Status
Published
Author
Welch
On the bench
Osborn, Bayless, Corn, Gibson, Hurst, Davison, Danner, Welch, Riley
Cited by
4 cases
Authority
More cited than 0.3%

Overruled by Wilson v. City of Hollis, 193 Okla. 241 (1943)

Later courts went against this

  • Overruled by Wilson v. City of Hollis, 193 Okla. 241 (1943)

    Co., 185 Okla. 451, 94 P. 2d 250, are overruled.
    Supreme Court of OklahomaOct 19, 1943Read it
  • Overruled by Board of Ed. v. City of Chickasha Ex Rel. Pool, 195 Okla. 127 (1945)

    Co. 185 Okla. 451, 94 P. 2d 250, are overruled.”
    Supreme Court of OklahomaFeb 6, 1945Read it

The opinion

WELCH, V. C. J.

(dissenting). I think the decision should be otherwise and should follow City of Drumright v. McCormick, 118 Okla. 140 , 247 P. 25 . I think the plaintiff in commencing this action had the right to rely on the rule of the Drumright Case theretofore fixed. That decision has been criticized, but has never been expressly overruled, nor has any decision pointed out the evil or unsoundness of that rule. I think that rule is sound and is preferable to the rule of the majority opinion here, which evidently goes on to the logical conclusion that this plaintiff can, at any time in the future, compel a general fund appropriation and levy to pay his warrants, as was held by majority opinion in Board of Education of Duncan v. Johnston, No. 28313, promulgated June 27, 1939 [pending on rehearing], thus avoiding the principle that general fund appropriations may be made only for the purposes of the current year and may not be made to discharge general fund obligations of long prior years. I am not willing to now join in the substitution of that rule, with its apparent defects and evils, for the plain rule of the Drumright Case that upon timely action, within the limitation period, a judgment may be rendered against the municipality.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.