SSR 68-4c: SECTION 202(h). -- PARENT'S INSURANCE BENEFITS -- ONE-HALF SUPPORT -- BURDEN OF PROOF
FederalRulings
Ask Donna
How this section applies to your facts.
Social Security Rulings › OASI › Parent's Insurance Benefits › SSR 68-4c
Text
20 CFR 404.350 and 404.720
SSR 68-4c
SANDLIN v. CELEBREZZE , U.S.D.C., E.D. Ky., Civ. Action No.
539 (2-3-67)
[In this case, in a hearing before a hearing examiner of the Social
Security Administration, the claimant presented certain evidence as to
contributions she received toward her support by her deceased son. It was
also established that during the 12-month period preceding her son's death
she lived in her own home, that her household consisted of three members
and that her son lived elsewhere, and that she had cash income of $1,452
from social security and public welfare sources, and used toward her
support her own garden produce and livestock. Because the claimant failed
to present tangible evidence of one-half support by her son, the hearing
examiner affirmed the denial of her application for parent's insurance
benefits.]
H. CHURCH FORD, District Judge:
The plaintiff, Della Sandlin, of Ricetown, Kentucky, filed her "Parents
Certificate of Support" with the Social Security Administration on January
18, 1962, and again on October 24, 1962, on account of her deceased son,
Harlan H. Burns, who died June 31, 1961, seeking that she be determined
entitled to a parent's monthly benefit under the Social Security Act.
The plaintiff exhausted appropriate administrative procedure without
success. The Appeals Council on February 2, 1965, denied review of the
Hearing Examiner's decision of October 22, 1964, and thereby the decision
* * * of October 22, 1964, [by the Hearing Examiner] became the final
decision of the defendant, Secretary of Health, Education and Welfare.
On March 30, 1965, plaintiff filed his civil action pursuant to § 205(g)
of the Social Security Act, 42 U.S.C.A., § 405(g), for Court review and
reversal of the defendant's final decision.
A certified copy of the transcript of record, including the evidence upon
which the findings and decision complained of are based, has been duly
filed.
dant, Secretary of Health, Education and Welfare.
On March 30, 1965, plaintiff filed his civil action pursuant to § 205(g)
of the Social Security Act, 42 U.S.C.A., § 405(g), for Court review and
reversal of the defendant's final decision.
A certified copy of the transcript of record, including the evidence upon
which the findings and decision complained of are based, has been duly
filed.
It appears that there is no dispute as to whether, at the time of his
death, the deceased Harlan H. Burns was an insured individual under the
Social Security Act.
Pursuant to plaintiff's request, a hearing was held at Hazard, Ky., on
August 31, 1964, before [a] Hearing Examiner, * * * at which time
plaintiff, Della Sandlin, and her daughter, Wilma Amis, were present and
testified in her behalf.
On October 22, 1964, the Hearing Examiner rendered his decision and
summarized the testimony of the plaintiff and other evidence presented in
the case with his findings and conclusions as follows:
"Medical expenses ranging from $15 to $25 monthly, with some months as
much as $50, would not permit a conclusion that the average would amount
to more than $40 per month, and the Hearing Examiner so finds. It is
possible that the medical expenses would equal all of the other expenses
of the claimant's support, but not very probable. If the claimant were
able to prove payment by her son, Harlan, of all of the medical expenses,
it would not clearly prove that one-half of the claimant's support was
provided by the wage-earner. The only proof that Mrs. Sandlin received any
amounts for her support during the last year of Harlan's lifetime is
contained in statements of belief and opinions from her children and
others interested in helping the claimant establish a claim for a monthly
social security benefit in excess of what she has been receiving from the
account of a deceased husband.
rovided by the wage-earner. The only proof that Mrs. Sandlin received any
amounts for her support during the last year of Harlan's lifetime is
contained in statements of belief and opinions from her children and
others interested in helping the claimant establish a claim for a monthly
social security benefit in excess of what she has been receiving from the
account of a deceased husband.
"* * * [T]he statement by Wilma Amis, is typical of the 'proof' that is
in the record. Mrs. Amos [sic.] testified that she was no longer at home
with her mother after she became married and that she could not,
therefore, say that the mother's testimony of having received 'checks' was
not correct. The child of the claimant who was actually living with the
wage-earner during his last year was Rosa Lee Sandlin, later Rosalie
English. Rosalie English. Rosalie English's written statement dated May
14, 1964 * * * was that the wage-earner did send hie mother amounts
ranging from $10 to $25 on three or four occasions in a year. The Hearing
Examiner finds that Mrs. English was in a more advantageous position to
know and that statements by her mother and her mother's physician, Dr.
J.R. Aker, to the contrary, that hers is the more credible testimony.
"It is obvious that for years prior to the wage-earner's death, the
claimant and her family were supported by a combination of monthly
benefits and their own efforts. The finding, therefore, is that the
wage-earner was not providing the claimant one-half of her support at the
time of his death. At the time of the wage-earners' [sic.] death, the
economic relationship was one between the claimant and her children living
at home with her. The record shows that rather than being a dependent of
any individual, the claimant actually provided for her own support and
with help from her children and Public Assistance, for the support of her
children.
support at the
time of his death. At the time of the wage-earners' [sic.] death, the
economic relationship was one between the claimant and her children living
at home with her. The record shows that rather than being a dependent of
any individual, the claimant actually provided for her own support and
with help from her children and Public Assistance, for the support of her
children.
"The Hearing Examiner accordingly finds that the claimant was not
receiving one-half of her support from the wage-earner at the time of his
death. It is, therefore, the decision of the Hearing Examiner that the
claimant is not entitled to the Parent's Insurance Benefits for which she
filed application."* * *
Under § 205(g) of the Social Security Act, 42 U.S.C.A., § 405(g), it is
provided: "The findings of the Secretary as to any fact, if supported by
substantial evidence, shall be conclusive." Beshears v. Celebrezze ,
338 F.2d 998, C.A.5 (1964); Domanski v. Celebrezze , 323 F.2d 882,
C.A. 6, certiorari denied 376 U.S. 958 (1964).
[ SSR 64-61c , C.B. 1064, p.
44.]
As the Court has pointed out in Domanski v. Celebrezze , supra, (p.
885), it is clear that "in an action to review the decision of the
Secretary the case is not tried de novo in the District Court. The review
is limited to the record of the proceedings before the Secretary. In
reviewing this record the Court is not authorized to adopt findings of
fact of his own, but must accept the Secretary's findings of fact if they
are supported by substantial evidence. When so supported, they are
conclusive. 42 U.S.C. § 405; Hobby v. Hodges , 215 F.2d 754,
(C.A.4).
We are not at liberty to consider the factual issue de novo, but we
inquire only whether the Secretary's finding was supported by substantial
evidence. King v. Celebrezze , 341 F.2d 108, 109 (CA.6); Thomas
v. Celebrezze , 341 F.2d 541, 543 (C.A.4).
y
are supported by substantial evidence. When so supported, they are
conclusive. 42 U.S.C. § 405; Hobby v. Hodges , 215 F.2d 754,
(C.A.4).
We are not at liberty to consider the factual issue de novo, but we
inquire only whether the Secretary's finding was supported by substantial
evidence. King v. Celebrezze , 341 F.2d 108, 109 (CA.6); Thomas
v. Celebrezze , 341 F.2d 541, 543 (C.A.4).
Thus the Secretary, and not the Court is charged with the duty to weigh
the evidence, to resolve material conflicts in the testimony and to
determine the case accordingly.
The plaintiff did not show by any probative evidence that in fact, within
the immediately preceding year of the death of her deceased son, Harlan H.
Burns, she received at least one-half of her support from him.
Upon consideration of all the evidence in the case, I am of the opinion
that the final decision of the Hearing Examiner is supported by
substantial evidence and is, therefore, conclusive upon the Court and must
be affirmed.
For the reasons indicated, an order will be entered affirming the actio
of the Appeals Council of February 2, 1965, approving the Hearing
Examiner's decision of October 22, 1964 which stands as the final decision
of the defendant, Secretary of Health, Education and Welfare, and ordering
that this action be dismissed.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.