SSR 76-5c: SECTIONS 401, 402, and 411 (30 U.S.C. 901, 902 and 921) -- FEDERAL COAL MINE HEALTH AND SAFETY ACT OF 1969, AS AMENDED -- BLACK LUNG BENEFITS -- DISABILITY
FederalRulings
Ask Donna
How this section applies to your facts.
Social Security Rulings › DI › Black Lung Benefits › SSR 76-5c
Text
20 CFR 410.400ff
SSR 76-5c
Long v. Weinberger, USDC, Pa., Civil Action No. 74-970 (3/25/75)
WEBER, District Judge
I. Recommendation
It is recommended that defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment be granted
and that the decision of the Secretary of the Department of Health,
Education and Welfare, denying plaintiff's application for benefits under
the Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety Act of 1969, as amended by the
Black Lung Benefits Act of 1972, be affirmed.
II. Report
Plaintiff's complaint was filed on October 11, 1974, appealing the
Secretary's denial of his application for black lung benefits.
The plaintiff has been receiving Social Security disability benefits
under the Social Security Act [1] for a disability beginning on July 6, 1969, and there is no question that
he is totally disabled. The critical question in the present action is
whether plaintiff is totally disabled due to pneumoconiosis which he
acquired as a result of his employment as a miner in the coal mines of the
nation. [2] While both the Social
Security Act [3] and the Federal
Coal Mine Health and Safety Act of 1969, as amended by the Black Lung
Benefits Act of 1972, [4] award
benefits for disabled workers, the standards for determining disability
under the two acts are quite different. Basically, the question in cases
brought under the Social Security Act is whether the person is unable to
engage in " any substantial gainful activity by reason of any medically determinable physical or mental impairment which can be expected
to result in death or which has lasted or can be expected to last for a
continuous period of not less than 12
months." [5] The critical
question in actions brought under the Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety
Act is whether the miner is prevented from continuing his gainful mining
employment because of pneumoconiosis which arose out of, or in connection
with, his work in a coal
mine
to result in death or which has lasted or can be expected to last for a
continuous period of not less than 12
months." [5] The critical
question in actions brought under the Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety
Act is whether the miner is prevented from continuing his gainful mining
employment because of pneumoconiosis which arose out of, or in connection
with, his work in a coal
mine. [6] The Senate
report [7] discusses the fact
that the nation's miners suffered from several handicaps in sustaining
their burden of proving their disabilities under the Social Security Act.
The Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety Act of 1969 was intended to remedy
this. However, just a few years after enactment of that law, Congress
found that miners who were in fact disabled were still being denied
benefits because of their unique problems in producing medical evidence in
support of their physical impairments resulting from pneumoconiosis. One
of these problems was that the chest x-ray or roentgenogram was an
imperfect means of ascertaining the existence of
pneumoconiosis. [8] A negative
x-ray was not positive proof of the absence of pneumoconiosis. Autopsies
performed after chest x-rays had been read negative for pneumoconiosis
indicated an error of 25 percent in
diagnosis. [9] There was strong
evidence that emphysema could cloud an x-ray to such an extent that the
x-ray showed no concentrations of coal
dust. [10] Further, the simple
breathing test which measures only ventilatory capacity did not always
adequately detect disabling respiratory or pulmonary
impairment. [11] Miners had
difficulties securing complete medical records and other evidence of their
disability, [12] and they also
encountered special problems in obtaining gainful employment outside of
coal mining in Appalachia. [13] Therefore, the Act as amended gives miners the benefit of certain
presumptions as follow:
lways
adequately detect disabling respiratory or pulmonary
impairment. [11] Miners had
difficulties securing complete medical records and other evidence of their
disability, [12] and they also
encountered special problems in obtaining gainful employment outside of
coal mining in Appalachia. [13] Therefore, the Act as amended gives miners the benefit of certain
presumptions as follow:
The question in the present case is not whether plaintiff can work -- he
clearly cannot. The question is whether he suffers from a respiratory or
pulmonary impairment which, without consideration of his other
impairments, would prevent him from returning to his former work in the
mines.
The plaintiff was unable to come to his first hearing on May 4, 1972,
because of his physical
condition [28] but his
attorney, Thomas A. Swope, was present and his wife, Sarah Long, and two
of his former co-workers, Clarence Ritchey and Fred Stombaugh, testified
in his behalf before Hearing Examiner Russell J. Blumenthal.
Mrs. Long testified that the plaintiff was born in 1907 and would be 65
on August 11, 1972 (Tr. 37). She did not know how far he had gone in
school, although she knew he had not graduated (Tr. 38). He had worked as
an underground coal miner and had also worked in the machine shop (Tr.
39). She thought he had worked underground about 15 or 16 years. She
thought he had last worked underground around 1938 and had stopped working
completely in 1969 because he was always short-winded and taking spells
and he had a stroke (Tr. 40). When he came out of the mines because "he
couldn't take it anymore" they sent him to school in Altoona for nine
months so that he could work in the machine shop as a welder (Tr. 41).
Toward the end of his work in the machine shop he had noticed that he was
short-winded and could not even walk the length of the room. He could not
go down the cellar steps without having to sit down on the steps and rest.
Sometimes he couldn't make it to the garage (Tr
ore" they sent him to school in Altoona for nine
months so that he could work in the machine shop as a welder (Tr. 41).
Toward the end of his work in the machine shop he had noticed that he was
short-winded and could not even walk the length of the room. He could not
go down the cellar steps without having to sit down on the steps and rest.
Sometimes he couldn't make it to the garage (Tr. 42). He coughed and
choked and spit up phlegm all the time. It was "white-looking" and he had
not noticed any blood in it (Tr. 43). At night he had to sleep propped up
with several pillows. During the time when he was working, before he had
the stroke, he had on one occasion slumped at his machine. The only
problem she had noticed before his stroke was his trouble with his lungs.
They had moved from a two-story house to one floor, on the recommendation
of Dr. Perkins, who was deceased at the time of the hearing (Tr. 44). The
plaintiff had taken medication for his heart but she was not sure whether
he had taken any for his breathing. He once had to be given oxygen (Tr.
45).
When the plaintiff was working in the machine shop he was sent home
sometimes because he would start to pass out (Tr. 46). He would gag and
choke and be unable to get his breath.
The plaintiff was hospitalized at Conemaugh Valley Hospital on four
occasions, he was in the Weaver Hospital twice in 1960, and he was
transferred from the Mercy Hospital in Pittsburgh to St. Mary's Hospital
in Pittsburgh.
She testified that the plaintiff was unable to talk and that he coughs
and chokes during the night. However, he could understand her sometimes
(Tr. 48).
his breath.
The plaintiff was hospitalized at Conemaugh Valley Hospital on four
occasions, he was in the Weaver Hospital twice in 1960, and he was
transferred from the Mercy Hospital in Pittsburgh to St. Mary's Hospital
in Pittsburgh.
She testified that the plaintiff was unable to talk and that he coughs
and chokes during the night. However, he could understand her sometimes
(Tr. 48).
Another of plaintiff's witnesses was Clarence Ritchey, who testified he
and the plaintiff had both worked in the C.A. Hughes Coal Company mine
number two for six or eight years (Tr. 49). He did not know how long the
plaintiff had continued to work there after he left in 1932. One of the
plaintiff's jobs had been to take care of the generators. It was a very
dusty job (Tr. 50).
Plaintiff's last witness was Fred Stombaugh, who testified he had known
the plaintiff when he had worked in both the coal mines and the machine
shop (Tr. 51). He thought plaintiff had worked in the coal mines for 16
years or more. They had worked together in the machine shop for a year or
more in 1959 or 1960. He had noticed that the plaintiff was short of
breath and short-winded (Tr. 52). "He was in awful bad shape." He
frequently had fainting spells. Sometimes they would take him home from
work.
A second hearing was held on March 27, 1974, before Administrative Law
Judge Michael W. Ganzhorn. Plaintiff was again unable to attend because he
was paralyzed from a stroke and was unable to speak (Tr. 56). Plaintiff
was again represented by his attorney, Mr. Swope, and his wife; a former
neighbor, Virginia Ritchie, and Fred Stombaugh testified in his behalf.
d take him home from
work.
A second hearing was held on March 27, 1974, before Administrative Law
Judge Michael W. Ganzhorn. Plaintiff was again unable to attend because he
was paralyzed from a stroke and was unable to speak (Tr. 56). Plaintiff
was again represented by his attorney, Mr. Swope, and his wife; a former
neighbor, Virginia Ritchie, and Fred Stombaugh testified in his behalf.
Plaintiff's wife, Mrs. Sarah Long, stated that plaintiff's paralysis
resulted from a stroke he had undergone on the operating table in Mercy
Hospital, Pittsburgh, in 1969 (Tr. 56). She testified that a man from the
union had said plaintiff had worked underground in the mines from 1927
until sometime past 1938 (Tr. 59). When he was working in the mine he
loaded dust, dug coal, and worked on the generators inside the mines.
However, he had to come out of the mines because he was choking all the
time and couldn't breathe (Tr. 60). He then went to school for nine months
where he learned electric welding. After completing the schooling he got a
job working at a machine company in Portage, where he worked from 1940 up
to 1969. She testified that he was sick and was in and out of the hospital
through all those years. She testified that Dr.
Grokely [29] had treated the
plaintiff for emphysema (Tr. 61). In 1962 he suffered a heart attack,
followed by a stroke (Tr. 61-62). He went to the Rehabilitation Hospital
for therapy but had to leave because he would get short of breath (Tr.
63). There was one occasion when the fire company had to bring oxygen into
the home because of plaintiff's breathing. Mrs. Long testified that even
when the plaintiff was working at Leeman Machine Shop she had noticed that
when he would come home from work he would have to sit down on the porch
before he could get in the house. Sometimes he would try to go down the
cellar and she would have to bring him back (Tr. 64). Exhibit 9 (Tr. 85)
was offered into evidence
he home because of plaintiff's breathing. Mrs. Long testified that even
when the plaintiff was working at Leeman Machine Shop she had noticed that
when he would come home from work he would have to sit down on the porch
before he could get in the house. Sometimes he would try to go down the
cellar and she would have to bring him back (Tr. 64). Exhibit 9 (Tr. 85)
was offered into evidence. It was a certificate by the Secretary of Local
Union 935, dated September 4, 1970, and certified that Lester Long had
worked in the mine as a coal loader from December 13, 1926, until the end
of 1936, when he left the mines on account of poor health.
Under questioning by the Administrative Law Judge, Mrs. Long testified
the plaintiff had smoked during the period he was working in the mines
(Tr. 65). He had stopped working in the mines on December 31, 1936,
because he was in poor health. He was working in the mines before they
were married in 1931 or 1933 (Tr. 65).
Plaintiff's former neighbor, Mrs. Virginia Ritchie, testified that she
lived about four blocks from the plaintiff and when she was at his house
visiting she heard him coughing, choking, and spitting quite often (Tr.
68-69). She had been friends with plaintiff's daughter and she would
frequently be at his house when he would come home from work. He would sit
on the porch before coming into the house. After he came out of the mines
he was very sickly. Mr. Fred Stombaugh testified that he had known
plaintiff when he worked as a welder in the Leeman machine shop (Tr. 70).
He had noticed that the plaintiff was short of breath and there were times
when they would have to take him home. He thought that had occurred around
1956 and 1957. He had noticed that the plaintiff was short of breath and
that it affected his work.
he was very sickly. Mr. Fred Stombaugh testified that he had known
plaintiff when he worked as a welder in the Leeman machine shop (Tr. 70).
He had noticed that the plaintiff was short of breath and there were times
when they would have to take him home. He thought that had occurred around
1956 and 1957. He had noticed that the plaintiff was short of breath and
that it affected his work.
The review of the medical records in the present case is difficult
because portions of some of them are illegible, although they are stamped
"BEST COPY OBTAINABLE". The earliest record appears to be an x-ray from
the Conemaugh Valley Memorial Hospital dated July 19,
1962. [30] (Tr.111) This report
concludes:
The next report is dated January 12, 1967, and gives the following
conclusion from the chest x-ray (Tr. 110):
The discharge summary, apparently from Conemaugh Valley Memorial Hospital
concerning plaintiff's stay from July 6, 1969, to July 17, 1969, gives the
following final diagnosis (Tr. 89):
A chest x-ray on July 8, 1969, resulted in the following conclusion (Tr.
86):
The medical records from St. Francis General Hospital concerning
plaintiff's stay from August 30, 1969, to September 16, 1969, are mostly
illegible (Tr. 92) but the report of Dr. Zimmerman includes no reference
to any pulmonary impairments (Tr. 93).
The record includes two reports from Dr. Burkett, dated April 11, 1969,
(Tr. 98) and November 7, 1969 (Tr. 96). The latter report stated that
plaintiff required constant management by either his wife or the community
nurse because of a stroke he suffered on July 6, 1969. His condition since
discharge from St. Francis Hospital had been downhill. His condition was
poor and his prognosis was unfavorable. However, the report makes no
reference to any pulmonary impairments.
A chest x-ray taken on December 9, 1970, resulted in the following
conclusion (Tr. 101):
agement by either his wife or the community
nurse because of a stroke he suffered on July 6, 1969. His condition since
discharge from St. Francis Hospital had been downhill. His condition was
poor and his prognosis was unfavorable. However, the report makes no
reference to any pulmonary impairments.
A chest x-ray taken on December 9, 1970, resulted in the following
conclusion (Tr. 101):
It is observed that under the regulations, Section 410.428(a)(1), the
classification O is not accepted as evidence of pneumoconiosis.
A report of Dr. Plummer discloses that he saw the plaintiff in the
Conemaugh Valley Memorial Hospital on January 23, 1971, after a fall at
home with a fracture of the eighth rib. "Treatment consisted of pain
medication and no strapping due to poor respiratory function." (Tr.
107)
Another x-ray report, dated August 12, 1972, resulted in a report
identical to the one of December 9, 1970, except that the classification O
was not mentioned (Tr. 112).
Plaintiff was readmitted to Conemaugh Valley Memorial Hospital on August
11, 1972, while complaints of right-sided weakness, nausea, vomiting, and
headache (Tr. 131) and stayed until August 26, 1972 (Tr. 126). Dr.
Bastow's impressions at the time of admission were (Tr. 128):
On February 27, 1973, plaintiff underwent ventilatory function tests (Tr.
116). However, the examiner reported that plaintiff did not understand the
directions and failed to cooperate in performing the test. (Tr. 120) The
evaluation of Dr. Harold I. Passes discloses that the studies depend in
part on the cooperation and effort by the individual undergoing the tests
and that at least three tests are required with no more than a 2 percent
disagreement between the values from each test (Tr. 135). Since plaintiff
had only one test, and since he was unable to understand the directions
and to cooperate with the examiner, the test cannot be considered.
ses that the studies depend in
part on the cooperation and effort by the individual undergoing the tests
and that at least three tests are required with no more than a 2 percent
disagreement between the values from each test (Tr. 135). Since plaintiff
had only one test, and since he was unable to understand the directions
and to cooperate with the examiner, the test cannot be considered.
The report of Dr. Plummer, dated April 24, 1973, stated that his office
had never treated plaintiff for respiratory impairment (Tr. 121).
A review of the evidence discloses that plaintiff worked in the
underground coal mines in excess of ten years and that during the last few
years of his work in the mines he had difficulty breathing, was
short-winded, coughed and choked and spit up phlegm, had to sleep propped
up with several pillows, and had fainting spells. The x-rays show that he
suffered from mild interstitial fibrosis and pulmonary emphysema. He has
not shown that he is entitled to any of the presumptions set forth in the
Act and the regulations. While the record does indicate that he suffers
from a pulmonary impairment, it cannot be said that it establishes that his pulmonary impairment prevents him from continuing his gainful
mining employment. His severe impairment at the present time is his
paralysis resulting from a stroke, for which he is receiving benefits
under the Social Security Act.
A review of the evidence discloses there is substantial evidence to
support the findings of the Secretary. Therefore, it is recommended that
defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment be granted and that the decision
of the Secretary, denying plaintiff's application for benefits under the
Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety Act of 1969, as amended by the Black
Lung Benefits Act of 1972, be affirmed.
of the evidence discloses there is substantial evidence to
support the findings of the Secretary. Therefore, it is recommended that
defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment be granted and that the decision
of the Secretary, denying plaintiff's application for benefits under the
Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety Act of 1969, as amended by the Black
Lung Benefits Act of 1972, be affirmed.
AND NOW March 25, 1975 the above matter having been referred to
the Magistrate for a report and recommendation, and the report and
recommendation of the Magistrate having been filed on March 12, 1975, and
no exception to said report and recommendation having been received, the
recommendation of the Magistrate is hereby approved and adopted by this
court and the motion of the defendant for summary judgment is hereby
GRANTED, and the decision of the Secretary of Health, Education and
Welfare be and is hereby, AFFIRMED and the plaintiff's complaint be and
hereby is DISMISSED.
[1] 42 U.S.C. Sections 423 and
416(i).
[2] 30 U.S.C. Section 921
[3] 42 U.S.C. Section 423.
[4] 30 U.S.C. Section 921.
[5] 42 U.S.C. Section
423(d)(1)(A); 42 U.S.C. Section 416(i)(1)(A) (Emphasis added).
[6] See generally Senate Report,
1972 U.S. Code Cong. and Adm. News, 2305; and 30 U.S.C. Section 902(f).
[7] Id .
[8] Id . at 2313.
[9] Id . at 2314, 2316.
[10] Id . at 2316.
[11] Id . at 2313,
2310.
[12] Id . at 2318.
[13] Id . at 2313.
[14] 30 U.S.C. Section
921(c)(1).
[15] 20 C.F.R. Section
410.414(a)(1).
[16] Id . at (2).
[17] 410.414(c).
[*] Section 413(b) of the Act
provides that claims under Part B of the Act shall not be denied solely on
the basis of a negative chest X-ray. The general ending date for Part B
claims is December 31, 1973. However, under section 414 of the Act,
certain claims filed after December 31, 1973, are still claims under Part
B. Thus, X-ray evidence in such claims is also subject to the limitation.
[ED.]
[18] Id .
[19] 30 U.S.C. Section
921(c)(4).
Part B of the Act shall not be denied solely on
the basis of a negative chest X-ray. The general ending date for Part B
claims is December 31, 1973. However, under section 414 of the Act,
certain claims filed after December 31, 1973, are still claims under Part
B. Thus, X-ray evidence in such claims is also subject to the limitation.
[ED.]
[18] Id .
[19] 30 U.S.C. Section
921(c)(4).
[20] C.F.R. Section
410.414(b).
[21] The appendix following 20
C.F.R. 410.490 is incorporated in 20 C.F.R. 410.414(b) through Sections
410.422(c) and 410.424(a).
[22] 20 C.F.R. 410.424(b).
[23] 20 C.F.R. 410.426(b).
[24] 20 C.F.R. 410.426(c).
[25] 20 C.F.R. 410.414(c).
[26] 20 C.F.R. Section
410.490.
[27] 20 C.F.R. Section
410.490(b)(3).
[28] His wife testified he was
paralyzed from a stroke (Tr. 43).
[29] The doctor's name is
spelled phonetically in the transcript of the hearing and the record does
not include any reports by him.
[30] Although the date and
name of the hospital are illegible on the copy of the report, it appears
to be one of the reports mentioned in Mr. Swope's letter of May 23, 1972,
to Judge Blumenthal (Tr. 109).
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.