Protection of Historic Properties

FederalRegulations

Ask Donna

How this section applies to your facts.

Federal Register › Vol. 64 › 64 FR 27044

This text was captured on Sep 30, 2026. It is a snapshot, not a live feed, so check the official code before relying on it.

Text

Part II

Advisory Council on

Historic Preservation

_______________________________________________________________________

36 CFR Part 800

Protection of Historic Properties; Recommended Approach for

Consultation on Recovery of Significant Information From Archaeological

Sites; Final Rule and Notice

and Regulations

ADVISORY COUNCIL ON HISTORIC PRESERVATION

36 CFR Part 800

RIN 3010-AA04

Protection of Historic Properties

AGENCY: Advisory Council on Historic Preservation.

ACTION: Final rule; revision of current regulations.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: The Advisory Council on Historic Preservation is publishing

its final rule, replacing the previous regulations in order to

implement the 1992 amendments to the National Historic Preservation Act

(NHPA) and to improve and streamline the regulations in accordance with

the Administration's reinventing government initiatives and public

comment. The final rule modifies the process by which Federal agencies

consider the effects of their undertakings on historic properties and

provide the Council with a reasonable opportunity to comment with

regard to such undertakings, as required by section 106 of the NHPA.

The Council has sought to better balance the interests and concerns of

various users of the Section 106 process, including Federal agencies,

State Historic Preservation Officers (SHPOs), Tribal Historic

Preservation Officer (THPOs), Native Americans and Native Hawaiians,

industry and the public. After engaging in extensive consultation

through more than four years, the Council has developed this final

rule.

DATES: This final rule is effective June 17, 1999.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: If you have questions about the

regulations, please call Frances Gilmore or Paulette Washington at the

regulations hotline (202) 606-8508, or e-mail us at [email protected]. When

calling or sending e-mail, please state your name, affiliation and

nature of your question, so your call or e-mail can then be routed to

the correct staff person. Information materials about the new

regulations will be posted on our web site (http://www.achp.gov) as

they are developed.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: The information that follows has been

divided into eight sections. The first one provides background

information introducing the agency and summarizing the history of the

rulemaking process. The second section provides a general summary of

the comments received in response to the September 1996 notice of

proposed rulemaking. The third section summarizes consultations that

took place with Native Americans. Such summary is included in the

preamble of these regulations to reflect the fact that regulations

incorporate the 1992 amendments to the NHPA which had a large impact on

the role of Native Americans on the section 106 process.

The September 1996 notice of proposed rulemaking highlighted six

issues on which the Council particularly wanted to received comments.

The fourth section summarizes those comments, and generally reflects

the Council reaction to them. The fifth section relates, section by

section, the Council's response in these new regulations to the

comments received. The sixth section highlights the major changes to

the section 106 process that these new regulations implement. The

seventh section provides a description of the meaning and intent behind

specific sections of the new regulations. Finally, the eight section

provides the impact analysis section, which addresses various legal

requirements, including the Regulatory Flexibility Act, the Paperwork

Reduction Act, the National Environmental Policy Act, the Unfunded

Mandates Act, the Congressional Review Act and various relevant

Executive Orders.

I. Background

The Advisory Council on Historic Preservation (Council) is the

major policy advisor to the Government in the field of historic

preservation. Twenty members make up the Council. The President

appoints four members of the general public, one Native American or

Native Hawaiian, four historic preservation experts, and one governor

and one mayor. The Secretary of the Interior and the Secretary of

Agriculture, four other Federal agency heads designated by the

President, the Architect of the Capitol, the chairman of the National

Trust for Historic Preservation and the president of the National

Conference of State Historic Preservation Officers complete the

membership. The diverse make-up of the Council provided a broad base of

experience and viewpoints from which the Council drew in developing

these regulations.

These sections set forth the revised section 106 process. Section

106 of the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966, as amended, 16

U.S.C. 470f (NHPA), requires Federal agencies to take into account the

effect of their undertakings on properties included in or eligible for

inclusion in the National Register of Historic Places and to afford the

Council a reasonable opportunity to comment on such undertakings.

In October, 1992, Pub. L. 102-575 amended the NHPA and affected the

way section 106 review is carried out. The Council thereafter began its

efforts to amend its regulations accordingly. Additionally, as part of

the Administration's National Performance Review and overall

streamlining efforts, the Council undertook a review of its regulatory

process to identify potential changes that could improve the operation

of the section 106 process an conform it to the principles of the

Administration. The Council commenced an information-gathering effort

to assess the existing section 106 process and to identify desirable

changes.

As a part of these efforts, the Council sent a questionnaire to

1,200 users of the Section 106 process, including Federal agencies,

State Historic Preservation Officers (SHPOs), State and local

governments, applicants for Federal assistance, Indian tribes,

preservation groups, contractors involved in the process, and members

of the public. The questionnaires sought opinions on the existing

regulatory process and ideas for enhancing the process. The Council

received over 400 responses. After analyzing the responses and holding

several meetings with Federal Preservation Officers and SHPOs, the

Council staff presented its preliminary findings to a special Task

Force comprised of Council members representing the Department of

Transportation, the National Conference of State Historic Preservation

Officers, the National Trust of Historic Preservation, the Council's

Native American representative, an expert member and the chairman. The

Council member representing the Department of the Interior was later

added to the Task Force. This diverse, special Council member Task

Force worked closely with the Council staff, reviewing comments and

numerous drafts of the regulations.

The Task Force adopted the following principles and attempted to

craft regulations to reflect them: (1) Federal agencies and SHPOs

should be given greater authority to conclude Section 106 review; (2)

the Council should spend more time monitoring program trends and

overall performance of Federal agencies and SHPOs, and less time

reviewing individual cases or participating in case-specific

consultation; (3) Section 106 review requirements should be integrated

with environmental reviews required by other statutes; (4) Section 106

enforcement efforts should be increased, and specific remedies should

be provided for failure to comply; and (5) the public should be granted

expanded

opportunities for involvement in the Section 106 process. These

principles have guided the regulatory reform effort.

The Council drafted proposed regulations, seeking to meet the

stated findings and objectives adopted by the Task Force. On October 3,

1994, the Council published those draft proposed regulations on the

Federal Register and sought public comment, on a notice of proposed

rulemaking (59 FR 50396). The notice provided for a 60 day public

comment period, and a 30 day extension of that period for Indian tribes

who requested it. The Council received approximately 370 comments on

the October 1994 proposal. Generally, commenters supported the overall

goals and direction adopted by the Task Force, but found that the

proposed regulations failed to implement the stated goals.

Particularly, many commenters disagreed with the role of the Council as

arbiter of disputes over application of the regulations, the public

appeals process, and provisions dealing with enforcement.

At a Council membership meeting in February, 1995, the Council

decided to continue its dialogue with major user groups of the section

106 process in an effort to resolve these concerns. The Council

membership also reaffirmed the objective of reducing regulatory burdens

on Federal agencies and SHPOs and focusing the review process on

important historic preservation issues. The Council solicited the views

of users of the Section 106 process once again by convening separate

focus groups with local governments, industry representatives, Native

Americans and Federal agency officials in early 1995. As a result of

these meetings, and after considering the views of commenters, the

Council drafted a substantially revised proposal and circulated the

draft informally in July, 1995 to those who had commented on the

October, 1994, notice of proposed rulemaking. The Council received

approximately 80 comments on the informally distributed draft.

Generally, the commenters found the July, 1995, draft to be an

improvement on the October, 1994, proposal. Again, however, Federal

agencies noted that the Council did not go far enough in removing

itself from routine cases and in bringing finality to the process.

Federal agencies also remained concerned that the public participation

provisions were too open-ended and inadequately defined the roles and

rights of participants in the process. Federal agencies also considered

the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) integration section to be

a step forward, but submitted that its substitution provisions should

be extended to environmental assessments as well as environmental

impact statements and, overall, could provide better integration of

NHPA and NEPA. In contrast, the majority of SHPOs did not want the

Council to remove itself further from the Section 106 process and did

not want the NEPA integration section to be extended to environmental

assessments. The National Conference of State Historic Preservation

Officers, as well as many of its member SHPOs, supported the public

participation process as set forth in the July, 1995, draft, but sought

clarification on the roles and responsibilities of Federal agencies

under section 106. Although industry commenters deemed the July, 1995,

draft a vast improvement over the 1994 proposal, they remained

concerned with the appeals procedures and found the process too

burdensome. Industry also remained concerned about the public

participation provisions.

In accordance with the general approach described above, after

reviewing the comments on the October, 1994, proposal, and in response

to agency downsizing and restructuring, the Council substantially

changed its proposal. The new proposed regulations were published on

the Federal Register on a second notice of proposed rulemaking on

September 13, 1996 (61 FR 48580). Again, the notice provided for a 60

day public comment period, and a 30 day extension of that period for

Indian tribes who requested it. The notice highlighted six specific

issues to focus commenters' review on what the Council believed to be

the most critical issues of concern. The six issues were: public

participation, local government involvement, Council review of agency

findings, time frames, and alternate procedures. The Council received

221 comments. Most commenters focused on the six issues listed above. A

summary of the comment received in response to the September, 1996,

notice is presented below, under its own section (See Section II of the

preamble, below).

On November 12, 1996, reauthorization legislation for the Council

was signed into law. It directed the Council, within 18 months, to

submit a report to Congress containing an analysis of alternatives for

modifying the regulatory process under Section 106 and section 110(f)

of the NHPA, and ``alternatives for future promulgation and oversight

of regulations for implementation of Section 106 of the (NHPA).'' The

report was submitted to Congress in May, 1998. In summary, the report

concluded that the basic implementation of the Section 106 process was

sound, though it certainly merited continuing improvement. It also

stated that some improvements sought in the rulemaking process should

result in more thoughtful and efficient decisionmaking and better

protection of significant historic properties. It noted that only a

small number of the thousands of projects and programs considered under

the Section 106 process each year were problematic or controversial,

and that those should continue to receive an appropriate level of

attention and public debate even while the Council worked to improve

the planning and review process to forestall or minimize potential

disputes of this nature that could arise in the future. The Council

also reaffirmed its commitment to ensuring that it would continue to

develop program and operational enhancements that promote the

effectiveness, consistency, and coordination of other public policies

and programs with the purposes Congress articulated in the NHPA.

Through the process of considering public comments, the Council

formulated a draft regulation on June 5, 1997. During August and

September of 1997, the Council conducted consultations with Indian

tribes regarding the June, 1997, draft regulations. These special

consultations were held to respond to tribal concerns about prior

insufficient consultation, to meet Administration directives regarding

government-to-government consultation with Indian tribes and to

recognize the special role given Indian tribes in the 1991 NHPA

amendments. A summary of these consultations is provided under Section

II, below.

After further, careful consideration of all public comments and the

results of its tribal consultations, the Council revised the June,

1997, draft regulations. On October 24, 1997, the Council membership

approved this draft of the regulations. On November 20, 1997, the

Council submitted its draft regulations to the OMB Office of

Information and Regulatory Affairs for their required review. This

review involved numerous interagency meetings over the course of 15

months and resulted in certain changes in the October, 1997, draft to

meet agency concerns.

At its business meeting on February 12, 1999, the Council formally

adopted the draft of the regulations resulting from the OMB review

process. Previously, the Council Chairman and the Regulations Task

Force, in response to concerns raised by certain commenters, carefully

considered whether the final regulation should be published once more

for public comment. They determined that the changes made in response

to public

comment and interagency review did not make substantial changes in the

section 106 process as presented for public comment in September, 1996,

and were rather the Council's reasonable response to and incorporation

of suggested refinements that emerged from the public review process.

After the Council's Regulations Task Force adopted final technical

and editorial changes to the regulations, and the preamble was

finalized, this preamble and regulation were submitted to the OMB for

final review, and then to the Federal Register for publication.

II. General Summary of Comments From the September, 1996, Notice of

Proposed Rulemaking

Following is a summary of the major issues raised in the comments

received in response to the notice of proposed rulemaking in September

1996. These comments led to the drafting of the proposed regulations

that were then handed to the OMB Office of Information and Regulatory

Affairs for their required review. Note that the terms ``most'' or ``a

majority'' or other like phrases on the particular issue discussed.

Please refer to Section V of this preamble for a discussion on the

Council's response to the comments received.

A. Federal Agencies (35 Comments, Including Those From Field Offices

and Regions)

General

A majority of agencies found that the regulations proposed on the

September 1996 notice of proposed rulemaking (``September 1996 draft'')

either streamlined the existing regulatory process or were an

improvement over the proposal on the October 1994 notice of proposed

rulemaking (``October 1995 draft''). Nevertheless, almost all suggested

further changes.

Council Role

Most agencies were pleased with the general approach of deferring

to Federal agency-SHPO decision making. Some felt that the Council did

not go far enough in removing itself from the process. Others did not

see the value in filing Memoranda of Agreement (MOAs) with the Council.

One agency expressed its concern that the deference to agency-SHPO

decision making would create inconsistencies and delays and would leave

SHPOs subject to political pressure.

In addressing the Council's role in the 106 process, some agencies

recognized and supported the Council's right to intervene in a case on

its own initiative, while others opposed this provision. Specifically,

some agencies expressed problems with the Council's right to intervene

when projects involve tribal lands and whenever the SHPO fails to

respond to an agency. On the Council's role in agencies' alternate

procedures, most agencies opined that the Council approval should not

be required for such procedures, although one agency found this role

for the Council to be appropriate. Related to the Council's role, a

number of agencies objected to the appeals process as set forth in the

provision relating to the Council review of section 106 compliance,

finding that it was too open-ended and inappropriately allowed the

Council to enter the process after decisions had been made. Other

agencies liked that appeals process, while one agency found it too

restrictive. A few agencies viewed the Council as exceeding its

authority in general in the regulations.

Public Involvement

The issue of public involvement was one of concern to agencies.

Most agencies found that there were too many opportunities for the

public to become involved. Specifically, agencies were concerned that

the public could protest late in the process. Some agencies believed

that existing agency procedures could better address public

involvement, that guidelines on the goal of public involvement would be

more appropriate than regulations, and that public involvement

requirements should be lessened for minor projects. Agencies also

expressed concern about the description of various participants in the

process and their corresponding rights and responsibilities. Several

agencies also took issue with the requirement that agencies consult

with traditional cultural authorities because of the difficulty in

identifying them.

NEPA Coordination

Several agencies found the goal of NEPA coordination beneficial,

but did not find that the NEPA coordination section achieved its goal.

Agencies found the section inconsistent with NEPA, particularly where

agencies prepare an Environmental Assessment (EA), because of the

public involvement and documentation requirements in the Council's

regulations. Some agencies found the section helpful.

Time Frames

The issue of time frames for the different steps of the 106 process

was also raised by agencies, with some suggesting that additional time

frames were needed to make the process more efficient. Other agencies

found the time frames appropriate as proposed. One agency objected to

the suspension of the process where the Council or SHPO determines

there is inadequate documentation.

Other Issues

Agencies favorably noted the new provisions on phased compliance

and consideration of the magnitude of the undertaking and nature of

property and effects. Agencies also liked the section on alternative

means of satisfying 106, but some noted that the same result could be

achieved through Programmatic Agreements (PAs). Agencies also expressed

concern over the requirements that agency heads document decisions

involving terminations, finding it inappropriate to elevate such

decisions.

B. SHPOs (45 Comments, Including Those From Deputies and Staff)

General

Overall, the majority of SHPOs were satisfied with the direction of

the proposed regulations or believed that the Council had made

substantial progress in achieving streamlined regulations.

Council Role

An overwhelming concern of SHPOs was the proposal that the

Secretary of the Interior decide disputes over consistency of agency

procedures with section 106. Almost all SHPOs found that the Council

should determine consistency. The majority of the SHPOs found that

Council's role and criteria for involvement appropriate, although many

noted that the regulations should clarify that the SHPO could directly

seek the Council's involvement in a case. Some noted that the Council

should be required to participate when asked by a SHPO.

Public Involvement

Most SHPOs supported the public participation provision, although

some were still concerned that the public would be precluded from the

process and would not have a real opportunity to provide input. The

delineation of the roles and rights of participants was also viewed as

somewhat confusing, according to several SHPOs. Some SHPOs found that

the proposal could preclude the public from meaningful participation in

the process. Several SHPOs also noted that Federal agencies should be

required to consult with SHPOs when identifying interested parties.

With respect to the public's right to appeal agency decisions under the

provision regarding Council review

of Section 106 compliance, a number of SHPOs commented that appeals

should not be restricted to members of the public who participated in

the process. Further, several SHPOs found that the public appeal

section set too high of a standard on the public in making a case for

an appeal.

Alternative Procedures

With regard to program alternatives, SHPOs were supportive of the

proposal, but many suggested that the National Conference of State

Historic Preservation Officers (NCSHPO), individual SHPOs, and the

public participate in the development of standard treatments,

alternative agency procedures and categorical exemptions. SHPOs also

overwhelmingly expressed the opinion that NCSHPO be given the right to

terminate nationwide Programmatic Agreements. A number of SHPOs

commented that they found the bridge replacement standard treatment as

proposed in Section 800.5 of the September 1996 version to be

inappropriate.

Time Frames

The most common concern of almost all SHPOs was the 15-day deadline

for a finding of no historic properties affected. SHPOs believed this

was an unreasonable short turn-around time for them to make a proper

determination. With the exception of the 15-day deadline, most SHPOs

found the time frames appropriate. Some noted that the different time

periods were confusing and suggested adding time frames wherever the

regulations referred to the phrase ``timely manner.''

C. Industry (24 Comments)

General

The majority of industry commenters stated that the September 1996

draft was substantially improved over either the existing regulations

or the October 1994 draft. However, all commenters offered suggestions

for further amending the regulations. Several other commenters,

primarily associated with the mining industry, noted that while the

September 1996 draft was an improvement, changes were still necessary

to make the proposal acceptable. The question of the Council

overstepping its authority was the primary concern of industry.

Council Role

The mining industry and several other commenters were concerned

that the Council had overstepped its statutory mandate in the existing

regulations and those proposed. They found that the regulations allowed

the Council to ``second guess'' Federal agency decisions, particularly

in the appeals section regarding Council review of section 106

compliance. Some commenters recognized that the proposed regulations

provided a more limited role for the Council and, therefore, supported

this change. Most industry commenters found that the Federal agency,

not the Council, should decide whether agency procedure were consistent

with section 106.

Public Involvement

The role of participants in the process, particularly the public

and applicants was a major issue of concern for the industry.

Generally, many commenters found the roles poorly defined and

confusing. Several commenters suggested the regulations delineate and

limit participants entitled to partly status and those entitled to

notice status. Many commenters liked the enhanced role of applicants,

but some suggested that applicants deserved equal status with principal

parties. On the role of the public in appeals of agency decisions (in

the provision regarding Council review of section 106 compliance), some

commenters noted approvingly that appeals were limited to parties who

had participated in the process. However, most commenters on the issue

wanted the appeals process further limited to parties that met legal

standing requirements. Industry commenters, primarily from the mining

industry, viewed public participation as too open-ended and lacking

finality.

NEPA Coordination

Industry commenters approved of the concept of NEPA coordination,

but found that the proposed regulations would not reduce burdens

because the NEPA documents still have to meet the Council's criteria.

Alternative Procedures

Almost all industry commenters approved of the concept of standard

treatments, categorical exemptions, PAs, and alternate procedures.

Time Frames

On the issue of time frames, commenters suggested inserting

deadlines at each step in the process, including consultation, and

found references to the words ``timely'' or ``before'' too vague and

unworkable.

Other Issues

Several industry commenters viewed the requirement to consult with

traditional cultural authorities as burdensome. Generally, industry

found that the regulations provided too much ``special treatment'' for

Native Americans. Industry commenters were also interested in having

the regulations address the question of agency jurisdiction on non-

Federal lands.

D. Indian Tribes (28 Comments)

General

Tribes overall were dissatisfied with the direction of the

regulations.

Council Role

Tribes were troubled by the Council's removal from routine case

review and found that the proposed regulations did not provide a

balanced process. However, several tribes stated that the Council

should participate on projects on tribal lands only if requested by the

tribe.

Public Involvement

Tribes found the public appeals provision in the section regarding

Council review of section 106 compliance to be too restrictive. They

also suggested that the regulations clarify that Federal agencies must

solicit the views of Indian tribes as members of the public, as well as

consult on a government-to-government basis.

NEPA Coordination

Tribes viewed the NEPA coordination provision as troublesome

because sensitive tribal information gathered in fulfilling the

Council's criteria would be included in an Environmental Impact

Statement (EIS) and thus available for public distribution.

Alternative Procedures

Tribes wanted to be included in the development of standard

treatments, categorical exemptions, PAs and alternate agency

procedures. Tribes were most concerned about the standard treatment for

archaeology as proposed in Sec. 800.5 of the September 1996 version,

finding it discouraged consideration of the broader values of a site.

Other Issues

Tribes were most concerned with the identification and evaluation

of historic properties, including properties to which they attach

religious and cultural significance. They were concerned that Federal

agencies' identification efforts would be incomplete and that agencies

would make ``no historic properties affected'' determinations without

prior consultation with the tribes. They also found that the standard

treatment provision covering data recovery for archaeological sites a

proposed in Sec. 800.5 of the September 1996 version, encouraged

evaluation of sites only for

criterion D of the National Register and discouraged consideration of

the broader range of values of the site. The relationship between

tribal and SHPO responsibilities was also of concern to tribes. When

undertakings were on tribal lands, tribes did not want SHPO

involvement. When undertakings were on non-tribal lands, but affected

properties to which they attach religious and cultural significance or

other historic properties of tribal concern, then tribes wanted equal

status with SHPOs and NCSHPO in the process. Tribes also suggested that

the regulations require determinations of eligibility from the Keeper

where tribes disputed an agency decision on eligibility.

E. Local Governments (11 Comments)

General

Local governments were supportive of the concept of allowing

agencies and SHPOs to conclude the 106 process without Council review.

Council Role

Local government commenters overall found the proposed role of the

Council appropriate, but expressed concern about the loss of the

Council as a balancing force in the process.

Public Involvement

The public participation requirements were viewed as redundant with

NEPA. The National Association for County Community and Economic

Development opposed the requirement to consult with tribes on non-

tribal lands.

Alternative Procedures

Local governments supported the use of standard treatments, but

wanted more flexible application of the Secretary's Standards for

Rehabilitation. Some were concerned about the standard treatment for

bridge replacements as proposed in Sec. 800.5 of the September 1996

version.

F. Preservation Organizations (21 Comments)

General

Presevation organizations were most concerned about the diminished

role of the Council as set forth in the general framework of the

proposed regulations. They also viewed the public participation

provisions as preventing meaningful public involvement.

Council Role

Preservation organizations opposed the decreased role of the

Council in the 106 process, finding that it displaced the check and

balance system of the process in place at the time. They also

considered the proposal as placing too many constraints on the

Council's ability to review agency findings. The Council's withdrawal

from commenting on standard treatments under the section on the

assessment of adverse effects was also of great concern to

preservationists. On the issue of the Council's role in determining

consistency of agency procedures, the few groups that commented found

that the Council should make the determination.

Public Involvement

The public's role in the process as proposed was of great concern

to preservation organizations. They found the public participation

provisions confusing, complicated, and circumscribed, leaving the

public with no meaningful role in the 106 process. The proposal,

according to preservation organizations, would increase litigation,

last minute appeals and Council foreclosures.

NEPA Coordination

Preservation organizations supported the concept of compliance

coordination with NEPA, but found that the September 1996 draft did not

go far enough to protect preservation interests.

Alternative Procedures

Commenters were supportive of the concept of alternative

procedures, but wanted provisions to explicitly ensure that the public

participate in their development and implementation.

Time Frames

Commenters strongly opposed the 15-day deadline for SHPO review of

a ``no historic properties affected'' finding, as not giving SHPOs

adequate time to conduct such review.

Other Issues

Preservation organizations were opposed to the standard treatments

as proposed in Sec. 800.5 of the September 1996 draft, finding that the

public, tribes and Council would have little or no role in projects

involving bridges or archeology. The Sec. 800.5 standard treatment for

archeology, according to the commenters, would encourage agencies only

to consider criterion D and, thus, to not properly consider other

values.

G. General Public (14 Comments)

General

There were no significant trends in the comments from the general

public. Individuals raised particular concerns based on their own

interests and experience. Several commenters noted that, overall, the

regulations appeared to be too complex. Three commenters expressed

concern that the regulations could affect their rights as private

landowners.

Council Role

A few commenters found that the removal of the Council from routine

cases would create too much pressure and work for SHPOs.

Public Involvement

Several comments found that the proposed public participation

provision failed to provide sufficient opportunities for public

involvement.

Alternate Procedures

A few commenters expressed concern about the standard treatment for

bridge replacements and archaeological sites as proposed in Sec. 800.5

of the September 1996 version.

H. Experts/Consultants (33 Comments)

Council Role

Most commenters found that the proposal did not provide enough

opportunities for Council involvement in the process. Commenters

expressed concern that the proposal did not set forth an adequate check

and balance system, leaving SHPOs subject to political pressure.

Several experts suggested that the regulations focus more on

substantive outcomes and less on removing the Council from the process.

Public Involvement

Experts and consultants found that the terms and procedures in the

proposal were too complicated and vague and would, thus, discourage

meaningful public involvement. Commenters found the delineation of

participants too confusing. Overall, commenters noted that the proposal

provided few opportunities for public participation and gave the

Federal agencies to much control over public involvement.

NEPA Coordination

Experts and consultants found the NEPA coordination section to be

inadequate, since they believed it did not go far enough in allowing

use of NEPA for 106 purposes.

Alternative Procedures

Experts and consultants expressed concern about the standard

treatment for archaeology as proposed in Sec. 800.5 of the September

1996 version, finding it would encourage sites to be evaluated as

significant only for the data they contain. A few commenters found the

proposed bridge replacement standard treatment problematic.

III. Summary of Native American Consultations

As stated before, these regulations seek, among other things, to

incorporate the 1992 amendments to the NHPA. Such amendments include

important changes that significantly alter the role of Indian tribes in

the 106 process. The Council members decided that before submitting a

draft proposed regulation to the OMB for the mandatory review,

additional input should be sought from Native Americans. The meetings

focused on obtaining comments on the June 5, 1997 draft of the revised

regulations (See Section I of the preamble, above). Each meeting of the

four meetings was two days long. A total of eight days were spent

discussing various aspects and concerns with tribal representatives.

The tenor of each meeting varied but all of the meetings proved

productive. The attendees in Seattle were few but, as a result, the

discussion was detailed. At Leech Lake Reservation, where the land base

is shared by both the Forest Service and the Leech Lake Tribe,

discussion focused on land jurisdictions and authorities. The meeting

in Albuquerque solicited highly constructive suggestion due to the

participants' extensive Section 106 experience. The Washington, DC

meeting had the greatest number of participants from tribes and legal

firms representing tribes.

The format of each meeting was consistent for all four meetings.

The Executive Director briefed the group on the administrative

structure of the Council, the existing steps of the regulation revision

process and the proposed changes. The floor was then opened for

discussion and recommendations. Some participants handed in written

comments as well. The Native American/Native Hawaiian Council Member,

Mr. Raynard Soon, attended the Seattle meeting and had the opportunity

to convey his interest and listen to other Native American concerns.

This summary is presented in three sections of primary concerns

that were stated at every meeting. The primary issues clearly became

the focus points of the discussions as almost every participant

reiterated in similar form the same concerns. They are presented in the

following manner: (1) General overall comments and observations, (2)

comments on sections pertaining to the Section 106 process on tribal

lands, and (3) comments pertaining to the section 106 process off

tribal lands.

General Comments

General observations in all of the meetings included the concern

that the Council did not give the Native Americans adequate time to

consult with them on the proposed regulations. The time constraint of

potential adoption of the revised regulations at the October, 1997,

Council meeting, before submission to OMB for review, was consistently

questioned by many participants. The overriding sentiment was that the

time frame was not adequate. Many tribal representatives explained that

they had to take the information back to their Tribal Councils to

receive directions and comments.

The proposed June 5, 1997 draft of the regulations was perceived by

tribes as being heavily weighted toward the SHPO interest. Requests

were made to take the state-oriented bias out of the draft. At every

meeting, suggestions were made to change the ``SHPO'' citation to

``SHPO/THPO'' (Tribal Historic Preservation Office) or simply HPO

(Historic Preservation Officer). There was consistency in the

recommendation that even if tribes have not assumed SHPO duties, as

delegated by the National Park Service (NPS) in accord with section

101(d)(2) of the NHPA, that the tribe or Native Hawaiian Organization

should still be consulted if places of religious and cultural

significance would be affected by a federal undertaking.

It became apparent that the word ``consultation'' is interpreted

differently by Indians and non-Indians. In general, American Indian

participants believed that the word implies a ``give-and-take''

dialogue, not just listening or recording their concerns. From the

tribal perspective, consultation is more closely aligned with the

process of negotiation. The tribes described that consultation means

working toward a consensus. For non-Indians, consultation has another

meaning: if the tribe had been contacted, attended the meetings, and

had the opportunity to discuss its views with the agency, then the

tribes had been consulted regardless of the outcome. For the majority

of the American Indian participants, this kind of exchange did not

represent adequate or effective consultation.

Where the proposed regulatory process addressed the requirements of

Federal involvement regarding the places of religious and cultural

significance to Native Americans, participants were adamant that they

be involved in the process of decision making for an acceptable

outcome. Requests were repeated to insert clear procedures within the

regulations regarding `'adequate consultation.'' The stated preference

of the American Indian participants was a clear definition in the

regulations so that all parties in the section 106 process would

perform what the tribes saw as adequate consultation.

On-Tribal Lands

The issues consistently raised for tribal lands reflected the

underlying issue of a tribal nation's sovereignty. The primary concern

was the ability of a SHPO to make or agree to a decision by a federal

agency on tribal lands when there was no THPO. Tribal representatives

explained why this was a problem for tribal governments and why the

regulatory process under the June, 1997, draft regulations that enabled

a State to have overriding decision-making authority on tribal lands,

questioned their sovereign status. By delegating the authority vested

in the Council by the NHPA for commenting on Determinations of No

Adverse Effect and Adverse Effect, the proposed regulations effectively

shifted the authority from a federal agency (the Council) to a State on

tribal lands when there was no THPO. This shift of delegation from

Federal to State clearly presented legal jurisdiction issues from the

tribes' perspectives. Participants in the meetings maintained that,

regardless of whether the tribe had formally assumed SHPO duties, the

State did not have the jurisdictional authority to have final oversight

for a federal undertaking on tribal lands.

Off-Tribal Lands

There are several issues that were raised in each meeting for those

Federal undertakings that would affect religious and culturally

significant places located off tribal lands. Much of the time was spent

discussing American Indian involvement in the process on ancestral

lands, ceded lands, fee lands and other types of land titles. A

consensus of tribal representatives maintained that sovereignty, treaty

rights, trust responsibility and government-to-government status

entitled the tribes to a role in the process that was greater than the

other ``consulting parties'' or general public as defined in the draft

proposal.

The discussion surrounding the identification, evaluation

determination of effect and potential mitigation proposals for

properties to which the tribes attach religious and cultural

significance resulted in recommendations that tribes should be involved

early in the process and required signatories to a Memorandum

of Agreement, or at least have the ability to concur or object to the

part of a project or plan that will affect an area of tribal or Native

American interest.

IV. Summary of Comments Received Regarding the Six Issues Specially

Raised in the September 1996 Notice of Proposed Rulemaking

On the preamble of the proposed regulations published for public

comment on the Federal Register on September 1996, the Council

presented six issues that it believed, based on comments received,

deserved special attention from the commenters. What follows is a

discussion of the commenters' response to these six issues and the

Council's general reaction to them. For a discussion on the Council's

response to comments, please refer to Section V of the preamble.

Finally, please note that these issues are stated in the same

language as presented in the published preamble to the September 1996

draft.

1. Public Participation

The goal of the regulatory requirement that Federal agencies

inform and involve the public in the section 106 process is to

ensure that the public has a reasonable opportunity to provide its

views on a project. The Council has attempted to give the public an

adequate chance to voice its concerns to Federal decisionmakers

while recognizing legitimate concerns about avoiding unnecessary

procedural burdens and delays and protecting the privacy of non-

governmental parties involved in the section 106 process. How can

the regulations be enhanced to provide for meaningful public

involvement in a timely and effective fashion?

Summary of comments: Federal agencies were still concerned about

the role of the public in the process. Agencies believed that the roles

and responsibilities of various participants were unclear. They still

found that the public could delay a project by using the 106 process.

Most SHPOs supported the public participation provision, although some

still found the role of the public as set forth on the September 1996

draft to be unclear. Several SHPOs found the public appeals provision

too restrictive. Local governments found the public participation

provisions excessive and duplicative of NEPA, noting that the public

involvement requirements would discourage local governments from

seeking Federal monies for projects. Tribes found the public appeals

provisions to be too restrictive. In addition, they wanted the

regulations to clarify that agencies must consult with the general

populace of tribes as members of the public. The role of the public was

a major concern of the industry. Their comments viewed the public

participation provisions as unclear and excessive. They wanted to

further limit the public's right to appeal agency decisions. Many

specific comments were received from all categories of commenters that

were critical of the clarity and timing of public participation

provisions.

Council general reaction: The public participation provisions

needed a thorough overhaul with the objective of making them clearer,

achieving earlier effective public involvement and providing better

public access to the Council when it was not involved in a case. The

Council thought that the provisions should be redrafted to achieve

these goals, while honoring the Council's original policy of

encouraging the use of agency public participation procedures, reducing

duplication of effort and having clear points of involvement and points

of closure for the Section 106 process. The Council believed that the

question of public participation could be effectively addressed by

careful examination of the provisions, following the preceding

principles, rather than adopting some significant departure from the

Council's original objectives in this area.

2. Local Governments

Several agencies see an enhanced role for certified local

governments in the section 106 process and find that the regulations

do not go far enough in providing for their involvement. The

definition of ``Head of the agency'' provides that the head of a

local government shall be considered the head of the agency where it

has been delegated responsibility for section 106 compliance. How

can we better incorporate local governments into the process without

confusing the regulations?

Summary of comments: Federal agencies were not concerned with this

issue overall, but those that commented found the local government role

appropriate as proposed. HUD wanted the regulations to set forth an

enhanced role for local governments. Some SHPOs felt that Certified

Local Governments (CLGs) should be given recognition in the procedures,

although others found the role appropriate as set forth in the proposed

regulations. Some SHPOs noted that increased CLG involvement would

bring a lack of consistency to the regulations, others noted CLGs may

not be equipped to handle compliance. Local governments did not

question their role in the process as set forth in the regulations,

although they expressed general concern about SHPOs having too much

power in the process. Tribes were not concerned about this issue.

Industry was for the most part not concerned about this issue, although

those that did comment found the level of local government involvement

appropriate as drafted.

Council general reaction: Based on these comments, the Council

believed that no major changes should be made in the role of local

government. We suggested continuing to work with HUD to determine if

there are specific amendments that could be made to advance their

interest in enhancing the role of local governments while remaining

consistent with overall direction of the regulations and avoiding

further complicating the regulations. It is intended to pursue this in

the development of local government program alternatives (Sec. 800.15),

which as been reserved for future issuance.

3. Council Involvement

In this proposal, the Council has removed itself from review of

no adverse effect determinations and routine Memoranda of Agreement

with the intent of deferring to agency-SHPO decisionmaking as a

general rule. At the same time, as the Federal agency assigned to

review the policies and programs of Federal agencies on historic

preservation matters, the Council has retained the right to enter

the consultative process on its own motion or when requested by the

Agency Official. The regulations set forth in 800.6 several criteria

which indicate when an Agency Official must invite the Council to

become involved in the consultation. They also set a general

standard for when the Council will enter the process without a

request. The Council intends on exercising its right to enter the

process sparingly. Are the criteria set forth in Sec. 800.6(a)(1)(i)

workable? Can the regulations better define when the Council will

intervene on its own initiative?

Summary of comments: Federal agencies like the general approach of

deference to agency-SHPO decisionmaking, although some found that the

Council did not go far enough in removing itself from the process or

did not see the value in filing MOAs with the Council. Most agencies

recognized the Council's right to intervene in a case on its own

initiative, although some opposed this provision. SHPOs were satisfied

overall with the Council's role in the process, although many SHPOs

noted that they should have the right to go directly to the Council to

seek Council intervention in a case. Local governments were concerned

that the level of Council involvement may be too low and believed the

SHPO would gain too much control under this proposal. Tribes were

greatly concerned about the Council's removal from routine case review

and found that the September 1996 draft failed to achieve a balance of

power in the section 106 process.

Industry suggested the direction of removal of the Council from routine

cases, but still found the Council had too must authority in the

process to intervene and second-guess agency decisions. Preservation

consultants expressed concern over possible abuses by agencies and

SHPOs without adequate checks and balances.

Council general reaction: This was a critical point of the

regulations and one that raised a lot of concern from a variety of

sources. We believed that the basic principle of deferring to Federal

agency-SHPO decisions was valid, but that the draft needed to better

define when and how the Council would get involved. The Council did not

believe in a policy change, but rather a refinement of the published

provisions to clarify the Council's role and how parties invoked our

involvement, responding to the specific comments. In particular, the

involvement of the Council when undertakings affected Indian tribes and

their interests needed to be expanded, as did the SHPO's right to

directly request Council involvement. Changes made to address this

issue had to be closely coordinated with those dealing with Council

review of agency findings.

4. Council Review of Agency Findings

Section 800.9 provides for Council review of agency findings

where the Council has not participated in the consultative process

pursuant to Sec. 800.6. The Council's right to review agency

findings is limited to whether the agency followed the appropriate

procedures when making an eligibility determination under

Sec. 800.4(c)(2), a no historic properties present or affected

finding under Sec. 800.4(d), or a no adverse effect finding or

resolution by standard treatment under Sec. 800.5(c). The right to

review is also limited by the requirement that the request be made

prior to the agency approval of the expenditure of funds or the

issuance of a license, permit or other approval. The Council has 10

days to decide if the request warrants Council review and 30 days to

decide the merits of the case. The Council finds that the above

review process strikes a balance between allowing review of

procedurally deficient agency decisions and limiting review to

situations that could not have been corrected earlier in the

process. Some Federal agencies find that the review process in

Sec. 800.9 provides the Council too much authority to second guess

agency decisions and promotes a lack of finality to the process. How

can the regulations accommodate the Council's concerns and those of

other Federal agencies?

Summary of comments: Federal Agencies were divided in commenting on

the appeals provision in the proposal. Some found that the September

1996 draft provisions were too open-ended and allowed the Council to

enter the process after decisions had been made. Others liked the

appeal procedures. SHPOS found the appeals provision satisfactory with

respect to the Council's role. Local governments did not express

concern over the Council's role in appeals over agency decisions.

Tribes found the appeals provision too restrictive in general. Industry

still was dissatisfied with the appeals section, finding it would

create delays and allow review of agency decisions too late in a

project's development. Industry maintained that the Council was

overstepping its authority in this section by reviewing agency

decisions. Comments from individuals and preservation organizations

expressed concern that the appeals provisions were too restrictive and

needed to be expanded.

Council general reaction: The Council believed that ready access to

the Council was an essential counterbalance to the removal of the

Council from routine case involvement. This access must be effective

for a broad range of parties in the Section 106 process while

maintaining a system that has definite points of closure for agencies

and applicants. The September 1996 draft formulation was too

restrictive and the regulation should be revised to provide a wider

range of parties with more time to bring issues to the Council.

However, this process must continue to have effective protections

against groundless claims and potential for process abuse.

5. Time Frames

Throughout the regulations, time frames are set for reviews

conducted by SHPOs and the Council. Generally, they allow thirty

days for responding to agency requests, although some are shorter.

These have been established in an effort to balance the need for an

expeditious process for Federal agencies and applicants with the

recognition of the need for adequate time to evaluate submissions

(as well as the limits on resources available in SHPO offices and at

the Council to respond within the specified time). Do the time

frames achieve this balance or should specific ones be increased or

decreased?

Summary of comments: All groups of commenters noted that vague

references to ``timely'' or ``before'' should be replaced with specific

time frames. Federal agencies suggested adding time frames for each

step in the process. SHPOs overwhelmingly expressed concern about the

15-day deadline for a ``no historic properties affected''

determination, finding the period of time too short. SHPOs also noted

that the different time periods listed in the September 1996 draft

would foster confusion. Local governments stated that the overall

process was too time consuming. Tribes did not express concern about

the issue. Industry is most concerned about time frames, finding the

different time frames too confusing. They find the 45 days for Council

comment, 30 days for review of an EA and 15 days for SHPO review of a

``no historic properties affected'' finding to be too long. Overall,

they found the process could be tightened up and made more predictable

by adding more time frames. Preservation organizations expressed

concern about time frames being too short, particularly the 15-day

provision.

Council general reaction: The concern for the 15-day limit on SHPO

responses was valid and that to fail to address it would pace an

unreasonable burden on SHPOs. It was decided that the entire assemblage

of specified time frames should be carefully examined for clarity,

specificity and consistency. The 15-day limit in question was changed

to 30 days, which is the general standard for review in the entire

regulation.

6. Alternate Procedures

The proposed regulations allow Federal agencies to substitute

their own procedures for those contained in subpart B. Section

110(a)(2)(E) of the Act requires that procedures implementing

section 106, including these substitute procedures, be consistent

with the Council's regulations. The proposed regulations charge the

Secretary [of the Interior] with making final determinations on

consistency. This is based on the Secretary's primary responsibility

for implementing section 110. Alternatively, the Council, as the

agency charged to section 211 of the Act with issuing the

regulations to guide the implementation of section 106, could make

such a determination. A third option is allowing the Federal agency

itself to make a determination of consistency. Is the proposed

approach the best solution?

Summary of comments: Almost all Federal agencies found that they

should make the determination on consistency of agency procedures with

section 106. All SHPOs found that the Council should make the

determination as to consistency and viewed the Secretary of Interior's

role as final arbiter to be inappropriate. Local governments did not

express concern on this issue. Tribes view the Council as a protector

of their interests and view the Council as a check against agency

decisionmaking. Industry overwhelmingly finds that the Federal agency

should determine consistency of agency procedures. Preservation

organizations were generally silent on this point.

Council general reaction: The Council believed that the proper

entity to determine consistency was the Council membership and changed

the regulation accordingly. Among other things, the Council has the

statutory responsibility

to oversee the section 106 process, the internal experience and

expertise to make such evaluations, and the diversity of membership to

ensure that a balanced perspective is brought to final determinations

regarding consistency.

V. Response to Comments

This section of the preamble relates, section by section, how the

Council responded to comments from the public regarding these

regulations.

Section 800.1

There were few comments on Sec. 800.1. One comment stated that the

goal of consultation was inappropriately described in the September

1996 notice of proposed rulemaking draft (``September 1996 draft'') as

avoiding or minimizing adverse effect on historic properties. The

comment found this language to be inconsistent with the procedural

nature of section 106 of the NHPA. The Council agreed and therefore

modified the Sec. 800.1(a) of the regulation in response to this

comment by adding that the goal is to ``seek ways to avoid, minimize or

mitigate any adverse effects on historic properties.''

Another comment expressed concern about the reference in the

September 1996 draft to other guidelines, policies and procedures

issued by other agencies. The Council and the OMB were acutely aware of

such concerns and carefully crafted the language in Sec. 800.1(b) to

make it clear that such references in these regulations do not

implement those policies, procedures or guidelines as regulations.

Section 800.1(c) of the September 1996 draft explained the

different methods of complying with these regulations. One comment

found that, rather than showing the flexibility of the regulations,

this subsection gave the impression that the regulations were

inflexible. The Council decided to delete this subsection as redundant,

unnecessary, and confusing.

The ``Timing'' section of the September 1996 draft is now in

Sec. 800.1(c). One comment noted that while this section allows

nondestructive project planning activities before completing compliance

with section 106, it would be nonsensical to include the proviso that

such actions cannot restrict subsequent consideration of alternatives

to avoid, minimize or mitigate adverse effects. The Council, however,

decided that this provision should remain since the Council believes

that the section 106 process should not be circumvented by the early

foreclosure of mitigating options.

Several other comments noted that including field investigations as

nondestructive planning activities could open the door to actions that

could actually alter the character of historic properties, thereby

circumscribing the 106 process. The Council deleted the reference to

field investigations in the final regulation. The Council believes that

such investigations could sometimes, depending on the particular

project, constitute non-destructive planning. However, for the reasons

stated above, the Council believed that the blanket statement in the

September 1996 draft should be deleted.

Another comment suggested that a Federal agency notify the SHPO if

phased compliance is anticipated. However, the Council believed this

could only be a marginally beneficial practice, and did not want to

further lengthen the process by adding another notification requirement

to its regulations.

Section 800.2

The September 1996 draft created various categories of participants

in the Section 106 process: Principal parties, consulting parties,

affected parties, the public and the interested public. Many comments

stated that the proposed ``classes'' of parties were confusing and

inappropriate, and that they unfairly designated status to certain

parties while excluding others. In response to these comments, the

final regulation eliminates these categories of parties. Instead, the

final regulation creates one group of parties, known as ``consulting

parties'' which includes the SHPO/THPO, certain Indian tribes and

Native Hawaiian organizations, local governments, applicants, and

additional consulting parties with a demonstrated legal or economic

relationship to the undertaking or affected properties, or concern with

the undertaking's effects on historic properties. The rights and

responsibilities of the Federal agency, the Council and the public are

identified separately throughout the regulation and are not placed in a

group or category. The Council believes this eliminates confusion and

clarifies the roles of the different parties.

Section 800.2(a)(2) of the final regulation sets forth the concept

of a lead Federal agency. One comment stated that Federal agencies

should be required to select a lead agency where multiple Federal

agencies are involved in a project. The Council rejected this

suggestion as it deemed it appropriate for Federal agencies to maintain

sole discretion in deciding whether to select a lead agency to

represent multiple agencies throughout the section 106 process. The

Council believes Federal agencies are in a better position to determine

whether selecting a lead agency would facilitate the 106 process on a

particular undertaking.

Section 800.2(a)(4) was added to respond to concerns raised about

the nature of consultation in the section 106 process. It incorporates

provisions taken from other sections of the regulations.

Responding to concerns that there were no limitations in the

Council's decision to enter the 106 process, with the possibility of

added delays, the Council added Sec. 800.2(b)(1) defining the

circumstances under which it would enter the Section 106 process.

Specific criteria guiding Council decisions to enter are found in a new

Appendix A.

Section 800.2(c)(6) provides for ``additional consulting parties''

to be added to the consultation process. Some comments sought more

detail in the regulation on the nature and extent of such parties' role

in the process and how such parties are designated as consulting

parties. The Council decided to provide such information in guidance

material rather than in the regulation. The Council also points out

that Sec. 800.3(f) provides some detail on how additional consulting

parties may be added.

Other comments expressed concern, believing that consulting party

status should be given only to those individuals or entities with a

``real'' interest in the undertaking. Among other things, the concern

was that, without somehow limiting this group of participants, the 106

process would be severely slowed down, increasing the economic and time

costs of compliance without adequate justification. The Council

responded to this concern by adding language stating that those with a

``demonstrated interest in the undertaking may participate * * * due to

the nature of their legal or economic relation to the undertaking or

affected properties, or their concern with the undertaking's effects on

historic properties.'' The involvement of private property owners is

contemplated by this language. In response to several comments, the

Council deleted the language in the September 1996 draft which allowed

Agency Officials to limit participation of owners of real property to

organizations representing such owners. The Council agreed that the

limitation could unfairly restrain property owner participation by

virtually requiring they organize before being allowed to participate

in the 106 process.

Section 800.3

This section changed minimally from the September 1996 draft. The

Council simplified the language in subsection (a). One comment noted

that the regulation provided no guidance as to how a Federal agency

determines if an undertaking ``has the potential to affect historic

properties.'' The comment acknowledged that the existing regulations

also did not provide specific criteria for such a determination. The

Council decided that due to the broad differences among undertakings

which would make such guidance too lengthy, this issue will be more

appropriately addressed in supplementary guidance material to Federal

agencies.

With regard to subsection (b), several comments stated that the

Council exceeded its authority by requiring coordination of the section

106 process with reviews under other authorities. The Council maintains

that coordination with other environmental reviews is extremely

beneficial in achieving the best outcome under section 106. In response

to comments questioning the Council's authority to mandate

coordination, however, the Council made such coordination

discretionary.

Subsection (c) in the September 1996 draft was moved to subsection

(e) of the final rule. It was also amended to remove superfluous

language in response to comments. It now requires the Agency Official

to consult with the SHPO/THPO in planning for public involvement, in

recognition of the inherent, specialized knowledge that such local

entities possess regarding local parties which could have an interest

on historic properties.

Subsection (c) of the final rule pertains to identification of the

appropriate SHPO/THPO. It also includes general rules regarding

consultation with the SHPO/THPO. The substance of this subsection was

formally contained in subsection (d) of the September 1996 draft,

although it has been amended to respond to comments. During the

consultation meetings with Indian tribes, and as reflected in Indian

tribe written comments, tribes expressed the concern that the role of

tribal historic preservation officers who had assumed the role of state

historic preservation officers under section 101 (d) (2) of the NHPA

was not adequately addressed in the regulations. Because THPOs that

have formally assumed SHPO duties on tribal lands act in lieu of SHPOs,

many tribal comments suggested referencing ``SHPO/THPO.'' By using this

reference, Federal agencies will be reminded that they must not only

determine if their actions are on or will affect historic properties on

tribal land, but they also must determine whether or not the tribe's

THPO has formally assumed the role of SHPO. This change is a

clarification of the language in Sec. 800.12(B) of the September 1996

draft which set forth the rights of Indian tribes when undertakings are

on tribal lands. That subsection addressed what would happen if an

Indian tribe did not formally assume the responsibilities of the SHPO,

but did not explain the role of the THPO vis-a-vis the SHPO where

formal assumption did occur under 101(d)(2) of the NHPA.

With regard to the role of the THPO that has formally assumed the

SHPO's role on tribal land, and responding to concerns that certain

rights of property owners given by the NHPA could be overlooked or

disregarded, the Council added a reference to the statutory language in

section 101(d)(2)(D)(iii) of the NHPA, which authorizes certain

property owners on tribal lands to request SHPO participation.

The September 1996 draft included in its subsection (d)(1),

language directing Federal agencies to consult with the Council ``if

the State Historic Preservation Officer declines in writing to

participate in the Section 106 process * * *.'' This language was

deleted from the final rule in response to comments made, particularly

during the OMB inter-agency review, that such language in the

regulation appeared to condone SHPO refusal to participate in the 106

process as long as it was done in writing. Language referring to SHPO

failure to respond was retained, but amended in response to comments.

Many comments disapproved of the language ``in a timely manner,'' as

vague and confusing. The Council intended this language to refer back

to the periods of time specified in the regulation for SHPO response.

However, to avoid confusion and to also respond to other comments

requesting definite time periods, the Council deleted the language and

specified a 30 day response time. Additionally, in response to Federal

agency comments asking for certainty and finality to the process, the

Council included language on the regulation stating that the Federal

agency could either proceed to the next step in the process or consult

with the Council if the SHPO fails to respond. In response to SHPO

concerns of being permanently left out of the rest of the 106, process,

the Council allowed for SHPO re-entry into the process. However, in

response to concerns about the need to cut down on delays and providing

for timing certainty in the process, the final regulations do not

provide for reconsideration of previous findings or determinations that

the SHPO failed to review.

Subsection (d) of the final rule contains language similar to that

of Sec. 800.12(b) of the September 1996 draft. However, the intent of

the language has been clarified in response to tribal comments that the

Council must make it clear that the Indian tribe's consent is necessary

when on tribal lands, whether or not the THPO has formally assumed the

SHPO's responsibilities.

Subsections (e) and (f) of the final rule contain similar language

to that of subsection (c) and (e) in the September 1996 draft. In

response to various comments that asked for clarity regarding

participation and showed concern that participants could be left out of

the process, the Council made it clear, under Secs. 800.2(c)(5) and

800.3(f)(1), that applicants must be invited to be consulting parties.

The September 1996 draft stated that Agency Officials ``shall

identify'' Indian tribes or Native Hawaiian organizations that might

attach religious and cultural significance to historic properties in

the area of potential effects. The language was changed so that Agency

Officials ``shall make a reasonable and good faith effort'' to identify

such tribes. This change was strongly requested by Federal agencies

during the OMB review process, on the basis that there would be an

inherent, extreme difficulty in identifying all such tribes when there

is no clear guidance or list showing such tribes for each property in

the entire United States that could be affected by an undertaking.

After discussions with OMB, the Council acceded to the change,

believing it strikes an adequate balance, consistent with the statute,

between the need to consult such tribes and the practical concerns of

identifying them. The Council, however, notes its understanding that a

Federal agency is not making ``a reasonable and good faith effort'' to

identify Indian tribes under this subsection if it possesses knowledge,

through communication from Indian tribes or otherwise, that a

particular Indian tribe attaches religious and cultural significance to

a property to be affected by an undertaking, but still fails to

identify such tribe in the 106 process. Such a lack of a reasonable and

good faith effort would be contrary to the requirements of the NHPA.

Subsection (g) of the final rule contains language that was

formally in subsection (d)(3). It was moved as a separate subsection to

highlight the opportunity for expediting consultation. Language was

added to clarify when

multiple steps in the process could be condensed, further streamlining

the 106 process.

Section 800.4

The substance of Sec. 800.4(a) changed minimally from the September

1996 draft. The first sentence in subsection (a) was deleted as it was

determined to be redundant with the coordination subsection in

Sec. 800.3. The Federal agency responsibilities during the scoping of

identification efforts also remained largely unchanged, except that

reference to the documentation requirement for area of potential

effects was added here. The duty to document the area of potential

effects was listed in Sec. 800.12 in the September 1996 draft and was

added in Sec. 800.3 to emphasize the significance of this step. The

Council plans to provide further guidance on development of the area of

potential effect to address comments seeking assistance in defining the

area of potential effect. Some comments questioned the duty to consult

with the SHPO/THPO during the determination of the area of potential

effect. Consultation with the SHPO/THPO at this critical decision

making point has always been viewed as an important part of the

process. The Council decided to retain the duty to consult with the

SHPO/THPO since the Council believes that SHPO/THPOs have special

expertise as to the historic areas in their jurisdiction and the

idiosyncracies of such areas, and can greatly assist the Agency

Official, using such expertise, in determining an accurate area of

potential effects. Nevertheless, it is noted that the Federal agency is

ultimately responsible for making the final determination about the

area of potential effect (i.e., the concurrence of the SHPO/THPO in

such determination is not required).

One comment noted that, under the existing regulations, the public

was not involved early in the identification efforts. Section

800.4(a)(3) requires that Federal agencies seek information from

individuals or organizations likely to have knowledge of or concerns

with historic properties in the area. This is an avenue for early

public involvement.

Subsection (b) sets the standards for a Federal agency's

identification of historic properties. This subsection was modified

minimally to address several comments. In response to tribal concerns,

the requirement to consult with Indian tribes and Native Hawaiian

organizations that attach religious and cultural significance to

properties was moved to this part of the regulations. The substantive

requirement had been set forth under Sec. 800.12(c)(1) of the September

1996 draft. In response to tribal concerns regarding the need for

adequate safeguards for sensitive information, the Council added a

sentence requiring Federal agencies to consider ``confidentiality

concerns'' of Indian tribes and Native Hawaiian organizations.

The final rule also tied the ``reasonable and good faith effort''

standard to examples listed in subsection (b)(1). Council guidance will

be developed to elaborate on the use of the various methods of

identification depending on the facts of each undertaking to respond to

those comments seeking clarification. One comment noted that the

regulations should provide a mechanism for disputes over what

constitutes a ``reasonable and good faith effort.'' Section 800.2(b)(2)

of the final rule sets forth that the Council can provide advice and

assistance in resolution of disputes during the process.

The concept of ``phased identification'' was well received in the

comments. The final rule, under Sec. 800.4(b)(2), clarifies the

applicability of phased identification. It also expands the notion of

phasing to the evaluation step in the process, as suggested by several

comments.

Section 800.4(b)(3) of the September 1996 draft, regarding the use

of contractors by Agency Officials, was moved to Sec. 800.2(a)(3) of

the final rule.

With regard to the evaluation of historic properties, one comment

stated the importance of allowing consensus determinations on

eligibility whereby Federal agencies assume eligibility for the

National Register without conducting a full evaluation, thus expediting

the section 106 process. The Council provided for consensus

determinations in subsection (c)(2) of the final rule and in the

September 1996 draft in (c)(2).

In response to tribal comments about the importance of

Sec. 800.12(c)(1) of the September 1996 draft regarding determinations

of eligibility, the Council incorporated language from that section

into Sec. 800.4(c)(2) of the final rule. In response to strong tribal

concerns about the treatment of properties to which they attach

religious and cultural significance and concerns that they would not be

properly evaluated by those that do not attach such significance to the

properties, the Council amended the regulatory language to provide an

avenue for tribes that disagree with eligibility determinations

regarding such properties to ask the Council to request the Federal

agency to obtain a determination of eligibility.

Many SHPO comments strongly expressed concern about the 15-day

review period in subsection (d) of the September 1996 draft, finding it

too short for an adequate review of a determination of ``no historic

properties affected.'' In light of the sometimes limited resources and

workloads of the SHPOs and the fact that the complexity of some

determinations require more time for an adequate review, the Council

agreed and extended the time for SHPO response to 30 days. The Council

believes that the need for proper evaluation of this determination and

the danger that an improper evaluation could result in damage to

historic properties outweighs the interests of expediting the process

by 15 days.

Section 800.5

Subsection (a)(1) changed only in that it incorporated the duty to

consult with Indian tribes and Native Hawaiian organizations, that was

found in Sec. 800.12(c)(1) of the September 1996 draft. Other minor

wording changes were made in response to comments to clarify that there

is no new notice and comment requirement at this step. Thus, the words

``which have been'' were added to the last sentence. References to the

term ``interested public'' were deleted, as such a category of

participants was dropped, as described above.

With regard to subsection (a)(1), some comments took issue with the

last sentence which contains the concept of indirect effects as not

being included in the regulations to be superseded. The Council has

always considered that ``effect'' as contained in the statutory

language of Section 106 includes both direct and indirect effects.

Therefore, it specified that in regulatory language, thereby retaining

the requirement that indirect effects be considered by Federal agencies

during section 106 process, as it similarly is during the NEPA process.

The wording of some of the examples of adverse effects in

subsection (a)(2) was modified from the September 1996 draft to clarify

the intent and application in response to comments.

Subsection (a)(3) was eliminated in the final rule, but the concept

of avoidance as justifying a no adverse effect determination is

incorporated into subsection (b). The subsection (a)(3) of the final

rule expands upon the phasing of identification and evaluation efforts

to include phasing of the application of adverse effect criteria under

certain circumstances. Comments observed that such flexibility at this

step in the process was essential if a Federal agency opted for phasing

at the earlier identification and evaluation stages.

Subsection (a)(4), the standard treatment provision, in the

September 1996 draft was completely removed from this section in the

regulation. The standard treatment option is still contained generally

in Sec. 800.14(d) of the final rule. The Council removed the Standard

Treatments on subsection (a)(4) because it believes that all such

treatments should be arrived at through specific consultation about

them, as provided under the final rule's Sec. 800.14(d). This does not

change their availability as a streamlining device under the

regulations.

With regard to review of ``no adverse effect'' determinations, the

final rule was amended to acknowledge that, although the Council will

not review ``no adverse effect'' determinations as a routine matter,

there may be certain circumstances where the Council will intervene and

review the finding, even where there is SHPO/THPO agreement with the

Federal agency. This would likely happen when a consulting party

disagrees with the Agency Official's determination or when the Council,

guided by the criteria in appendix A, decides that it should review the

determination. Subsection (c)(1) of the final rule acknowledges this by

adding the language ``Unless the Council is reviewing the finding

pursuant to Sec. 800.5(c)(3) * * *.'' This was added in response to

comments made by Indian tribes and preservation organizations that

articulated the importance of the Council retaining its authority to

overturn no adverse effect determinations.

Subsection (c)(2) of the final rule also amended the language,

formerly in subsection (b)(2), that provided for disagreements between

the SHPO and the Federal agency. The Council deleted the language

requiring Federal agencies to ``consider the effect adverse'' if the

SHPO/THPO disagreed with a no adverse effect finding. In the last

sentence of (c)(2), the Council also changed the word ``may'' in the

September 1996 draft to ``shall'' in the final rule, in response to

several comments. Federal agency comments and others suggested giving

the Federal agency the option of going back to the SHPO/THPO to resolve

the disagreement or requesting Council review. Most Federal agencies,

however, did not want the Council's position to be binding on the

Federal agency, but merely advisory. The Council considered this

concern, but rejected it as the Council maintains it has the right to

interpret the correct application of its regulations. If an agency

incorrectly applied the criteria of adverse effect, the Council viewed

this as a misapplication of its procedures. In response to comments

which found it problematic that there was no time limit for Council

review of no adverse effect determinations, the Council set a 15 day

review period for such reviews in subsection (c)(3) and added language

stating that the Agency Official could assume Council concurrence with

the finding if the Council had not responded within that time frame.

Subsection (d) of Sec. 800.5 of the final rule contains the

language that was formerly in subsection (c) of the September 1996

draft. The first sentence of (d)(1) has been modified to remove

notification requirements, but to make information available upon

request. The notification requirement was moved to subsection (c) of

the final rule. This was done in response to comments about the

importance of early involvement of consulting parties.

Section 800.6

Subsection (a)(1) was modified to clarify that whenever an adverse

effect determination was made, the Council was to receive notification,

whether or not its participation was being requested. Several comments

noted that this was not clear in the language of the September 1996

draft. The criteria for requesting Council involvement was also

modified by moving (a)(1)(i)(D) to (a)(1)(ii) so that the parties

listed in the provision could directly request Council involvement

rather than going through the Federal agency. This was suggested by

several comments as a more efficient, streamlined method to request

Council intervention. The Council deleted the reference to its right to

enter the process on its own initiative as was mentioned in the

September 1996 draft at subsection (a)(1)(ii). Nevertheless, the

Council maintains that right in the final rule pursuant to

Sec. 800.2(b)(1) and the Criteria in Appendix A.

Subsection (a)(2) of the final rule sets forth the duty to involve

and invite, as appropriate, other individuals or entities to be

consulting parties. This subsection changed minimally from the

September 1996 draft, except that the sentence allowing the Council to

serve as arbiter of disputes over consulting party status was removed

in response to negative comments from Federal agencies that believed

such Council involvement was inconsistent with its authority.

Subsection (a)(3) of the final rule was amended by adding the

proviso that disclosure of information was subject to the

confidentiality provision in the regulation. This was added in response

to Federal agency concerns about disclosure of proprietary information

regarding private property owners and archeological sites, as well as

Indian tribe concerns about disclosure of sensitive information

regarding properties of traditional religious and cultural importance.

Subsection (a)(4) of the final rule was also amended by adding

language on confidentiality for the reasons stated above.

Language was also added, in response to Federal agency comments, to

elaborate on the factors that Federal agencies should consider when

determining the appropriate way to involve members of the public.

Additionally, in response to Federal agency comments concerned with

duplicate efforts, particularly during the inter-agency review, the

Council added a new sentence to acknowledge that earlier public

involvement conducted by Federal agencies may, in certain circumstances

affect the level of public notice and involvement at the resolution of

adverse effect stage. For example, if all relevant information is

provided at earlier stages in the process in such a way that a wide

audience is reached, and no new information is available at that stage

in the process that would assist in the resolution of adverse effects,

then a new public notice may not be warranted.

Reference to section 304 of the NHPA was added in the final rule,

under subsection (a)(5), in response to strong concerns expressed by

Indian tribes regarding disclosure of sensitive information.

The subsection on resolution without the Council, Sec. 800.6(b)(1),

was amended in response to several comments questioning the meaning of

the term ``file'' as used in the September 1996 draft. The term

``file'' was changed to ``submit,'' and the documentation requirement

was added to ensure that the Council had the information that it needed

if it were to review the Memorandum of Agreement, as suggested by some

comments. Language was added in Sec. 800.6(b)(1)(iii) that the Council

would notify the head of an agency when the Council decided to enter

the section 106 process. This was in response to comments in the

interagency review process and was intended to ensure that policy-level

officials in the agency were aware of cases that warranted Council

involvement. The last sentence in Sec. 800.6(b)(1)(v) was added to

explain the outcome if the Council decides not to join the consultation

despite the request to do so.

Subsection (b)(2) was changed so that the phrase ``avoid or

minimize the adverse effects'' was changed to ``seek

ways to avoid, minimize or mitigate the adverse effects.'' This change

was made in response to comments, in order to more appropriately

reflect the essence of consultation behind the 106 process.

The final rule clarifies the status and rights of parties involved

in the development of a Memorandum of Agreement as set forth in

subsection (c). Many comments had found the treatment of these issues

section in the September 1996 draft to be confusing. The Council

redrafted the subsection by first moving the provision describing the

legal effect of a Memorandum of Agreement to the beginning of the

subsection. This was formerly in subsection (c)(5) of the September

1996 draft. Under Sec. 800.6(c)(1) of the final rule, the Council also

separated out the various signatories for different kind of agreements,

adding a reference to the fact that the Council and the Federal agency

can enter into a Memorandum of Agreement under Sec. 800.7(a)(2). The

final rule adds a new category of parties that may or should be invited

to become signatories to the agreement as listed in subsections

(c)(2)(i) and (ii); these parties will have the rights of signatories

if they choose to sign the agreement after being invited. Subsection

(c)(2)(iii) clarifies the outcome of such parties' refusal to sign the

agreement. Another category of parties, different from signatories or

those invited to become signatories, is concurring parties as set forth

in subsection (c)(3). The remaining subsection on Memoranda of

Agreement remained essentially the same except that, in response to

comments, subsections (6) and (9) regarding subsequent discoveries were

added.

Section 800.7

There were few comments on Sec. 800.7. The Council made minimal

changes to this section. In subsection (a), the Council added a

sentence requiring the party terminating consultation to notify the

consulting parties and to state in writing the reasons for terminating.

This was done to ensure that termination was grounded in sound reasons

and that other parties had full understanding of the basis for

termination. The requirement that the head of the agency or an

Assistant Secretary or other officer with major department-wide or

agency- wide responsibility request Council comment when the Federal

agency terminates was criticized in several comments that believed it

was burdensome, unnecessary or beyond the authority of the Council. The

Council retained the requirement for several reasons. First, section

110(1) of the NHPA, which was added in the 1992 amendments to require

this. That section requires that the head of such agency ``shall

document any decision made pursuant to section 106'' where the Federal

agency has not entered into a Memorandum of Agreement regarding

undertakings which adversely affect historic properties. Second, as a

matter of protocol, since the Council members, many of whom are

Presidential appointees and include the heads of six Federal agencies,

are responsible for commenting on a termination, the Council determined

that it was appropriate for the request to be made at that level.

Subsection (a)(3) was added in response to tribe comment and in

recognition of an Indian tribe's sovereign status with regard to its

tribal lands. The requirement that a tribe must be a signatory to any

agreement negotiated pursuant to Sec. 800.6 was contained in the last

sentence of Sec. 800.12(b)(3) of the September 1996 draft.

Subsection (a)(4) was amended by giving the Council the option to

avoid termination by going to the Federal agency Federal Preservation

Officer to attempt resolution of issues. This option was suggested by

several Federal agencies.

Subsection (b) was added to allow the Council to provide advisory

comments even when a Memorandum of Agreement has been signed. This

provision will give the Council the flexibility to agree to certain

Memoranda of Agreement, but to supplement its signature with additional

comments. This was suggested in one comment, and was determined by the

Council to be a valuable vehicle for issuing advisory opinions to

assist Federal agencies in their 106 compliance efforts.

In subsection (c)(3) the Council added the Federal Preservation

Officer (FPO) as a recipient of a copy of the Council comments. This

should assist the FPO in his/her agency-wide management of section 106

compliance.

Subsection (c)(4) pertaining to Federal agency response to Council

comments was changed by adding the requirement that the agency head

prepare a summary of the decision. This was added to ensure that the

decision received adequate consideration by the agency head and,

therefore, was properly documented, as required by section 110(1).

Section 800.8

This section of the regulations responds to the desire to

streamline the 106 process and to coordinate it with the National

Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) process. As stated before, most

commenters approved of the concept of NEPA coordination. However, many

believed it did not streamline the process enough. The Council believes

it has streamlined coordination with the NEPA process to the largest

extent possible without unduly sacrificing the key components of the

section 106 process. The standards by which NEPA coordination must be

conducted reflect our understanding of such key components that could

not be sacrificed without failing the letter and spirit of Section 106.

In response to a concern that a finding of adverse effect could

incorrectly be thought as automatically triggering a requirement to

produce an Environmental Impact Statement (EIS), the Council added the

last sentence of Sec. 800.8(a)(1) of the final regulation to make it

clear that adverse effects on historic properties do not, by

themselves, necessarily trigger an EIS requirement. However, they may

be of such magnitude or combine with other environmental impacts to

warrant preparation of an EIS. This is determined by the Federal agency

in accordance with its NEPA procedures and applicable NEPA case law.

Tribal comments showed a concern that sensitive information would

be published on the Environmental Impact Statement (EIS), and therefore

be available for public distribution. The Council notes that

Sec. 800.8(c)(1)(iii) states that tribes must be consulted in the

preparation of NEPA documents. The Council believes that the

confidentiality concerns of the tribes could be addressed in these

consultations. Moreover, Sec. 800.8(c)(1)(ii) states that

identification and effects determinations must be consistent with

Secs. 800.4 and 800.5, and that such sections address confidentiality

concerns. Tribes could object to a NEPA coordination that is not

consistent with this and other standards.

Certain comments cited a concern that Sec. 800.8 could allow too

many inappropriate reasons to prolong or repeat consultation. The

Council has limited objections to the NEPA coordination on two bases:

(a) That it does not meet the standards listed under subsection (c)(1),

or (b) that substantive treatment of effects on historic properties on

the NEPA documents are inadequate. The Council will review such

objections within 30 days.

Comments from Federal agencies indicated that subsection (c)(5)

inappropriately implied that the Agency Official would retain

responsibility for measures in a Record of Decision (ROD) or Finding of

No Significant Impact (FONSI) when another party may

actually carry those out. The Council therefore agreed to change the

language to: ``if the Agency Official fails to ensure that the measures

* * * are carried out * * *'' (the language used to state that the

Agency Official ``fails to carry out the measure * * *'').

Section 800.9

Many comments found the review procedures set forth in

Sec. 800.9(a) of the September 1996 draft to be problematic. Comments

found this subsection to be a backdoor, and unauthorized, appeals

process that created a lack of finality to the 106 process. Comments

also noted that the right to appeal to the Council was too limited, as

only certain individuals who had participated in the process could make

an appeal under subsection (a). Based on the strong adverse sentiment

to this provision, the Council completely redrafted this subsection.

The new subsection (a) succinctly and simply states that the Council

can render its advisory opinion at any time in the 106 process

regarding any compliance matters. Federal agencies are required to

consider the Council's advisory opinion in reaching a decision on the

matter. With this change, the Council believes it is responding to the

concerns expressed in the comments about an elaborate appeals process.

The change also addresses the concern that the Council was exceeding

its authority as an advisory body, since the final rule acknowledges

that the Council will issue advisory opinions.

Subsection (b) was changed in response to a comment which

questioned the provision in the September 1996 draft that required the

Council chairman to send a foreclosure finding to the head of an

agency. The wording implied that the foreclosure decision was that of

the Chairman, rather than the Council at large. It was always the

intention that the decision was that of the Council at large so as to,

among other things, reflect the diversity of the whole Council. The

final rule merely deletes the reference to the Chairman.

Several comments sought more direction with regard to intentional

adverse effects of applicants in subsection (c). The final rule, like

the notice of proposed rulemaking, tracks the language in section

110(k) of the NHPA. Additionally, in response to comments, the Council

set forth a procedure describing how it would consult with Federal

agencies that make a preliminary determination that circumstances may

justify granting assistance to the applicant. The section 110

Guidelines provide substantive guidance on this subject.

Subsection (d) provides for periodic reviews of how participants

fulfill their responsibilities under section 106. Some comments

questioned the Council's authority for such reviews, even in light of

section 203 of the NHPA. The Council maintains the position that

sections 202 and 203 of the NHPA clearly provide for the collection of

information from Federal agencies regarding the section 106 process and

for the Council to make recommendations to Federal agencies on

improving compliance. In response to comments, nevertheless, the

Council removed the reference to Council ``oversight'' from the final

rule in subsection (d)(1).

Subsection (d)(2) of the September 1996 draft was deleted as

unnecessary and confusing in that it introduced the concept of

``professional peer review'' without explanation. The Council

determined that reference to this term was hot appropriate or

beneficial. The final rule's subsection (d)(2) contains the provision

on improving the operation of section 106. This subsection remained

largely unchanged, except that the last sentence was added to

acknowledge the Council's authority under section 202(a)(6) of the NHPA

to review Federal agency preservation programs and to make

recommendations to improve their effectiveness.

Section 800.10

This section received few comments. One comment questioned the use

of the phrase ``directly and adversely'' in subsection (a), finding it

implied that indirect effects were hot considered under this

subsection. The Council retained the ``directly and adversely''

language of the September 1996 draft because it tracks the statutory

language in the NHPA.

Another comment noted that it would be more appropriate to mandate

that the National Park Service, instead of the Council, be involved in

consultation over National Historic Landmarks. The regulations include

a requirement that the Secretary of the Interior receive notice and an

invitation to participate in such consultations and, thus, the Council

has provided for involvement of the Secretary of the Interior whenever

the Secretary wants to enter the consultation. The Council chose not to

mandate the Secretary's participation.

The final rule contains a few other minor changes to rephrase

headings and wording of subsections.

Section 800.11

The type of documents required to be submitted at various stages in

the 106 process remained, for the most part, the same as presented in

the September 1996 draft. Subsection (a) on adequacy of documentation

and subsection (c) on confidentiality, were changed to respond to

comments.

With regard to subsection (a), one comment questioned the use of

the term ``factual and logical'' basis in the first sentence. The

Council deleted this language as unnecessary. Also in response to a

comment, the Council added language requiring the Council or SHPO/THPO

to notify the Federal agency with the specific information needs to

meet the documentation standards. This should expedite the process and

assist the Federal agency in fulfilling its documentation requirements.

The Council had added specific language giving it the authority to

resolve disputes over whether documentation standards are met. Some

comments disagreed with the language in the September 1996 draft giving

the Council or the SHPO/THPO the authority to determine the adequacy of

documentation. Comments suggested requiring the Federal agency to

consider the Council or SHPO views and supplement the record as the

Agency Official determined it as necessary. The Council disagreed with

these comments because it viewed the adequacy of documentation as an

essential function for which the Council is able to provide its

expertise. Council resolution of disputes over documentation would

maintain consistency of documentation among Federal agencies.

Additionally, the authority of the SHPO/THPO to notify Federal agencies

that documentation is insufficient is necessary so that SHPOs/THPOs

have the information hat they need to respond to Federal agency

determinations. Nevertheless, in light of strong opposition from

commenters who were worried that, as written in the September 1996

draft, subsection (a) would cause unending delays in the section 106

process, the Council acceded to eliminating the language suspending

relevant time periods until specified information was submitted. In

addition, the Council relegated its role to one of ``reviewing,'' as

opposed to ``resolving,'' document disputes.

Comments questioned the language under Sec. 800.11(a) suspending

the time periods when inadequate documentation is submitted, arguing

that such provision would result in long delays. Another comment

questioned

the meaning of ``suspended'', querying whether the SHPO/THPO would

receive an additional 30 days after receipt of adequate documentation,

or merely the remaining days left from when the SHPO/THPO notified the

Federal agency that the documentation was inadequate. In order to

alleviate concerns of delays in the process, the Council acceded to

removing the suspension of time language. Nevertheless, Federal

agencies must note that this does not lessen their obligation to meet

applicable documentation standards, and that, not meeting such

obligations could ultimately result in foreclosure or otherwise open

their Section 106 compliance to challenge.

Subsection (c) containing the confidentiality provision, was

modified by tracking the statutory language, almost verbatim, from

section 304 of the NHPA rather than paraphrasing the main portion of

the provision as was done in the September 1996 draft. This was done to

more accurately describe the Federal agency responsibilities. At the

end of subsection (c)(2), the Council added two sentences describing

how it would consult with the Secretary on the withholding and release

of information. This was added in response to various comments,

particularly those of tribes who are concerned about the release of

information of sacred sites. Subsection (c)(3) was added in response to

comments made by Federal agencies and others about privacy concerns of

applicants. It acknowledges that other laws or agency program

requirements may limit access to information.

Minor additions and changes to enhance the clarity of the

documentation requirements are made. Additionally, subsections (e) and

(f) of the September 1996 draft were consolidated as they contained

essentially the same material. In subsections (f) and (g)(4), the

Council added ``any substantive revisions or additions to the

documentation provided the Council pursuant to Sec. 800.6(a)(1)'' in

order to facilitate and expedite the review of information.

Section 800.12

As discussed above, former Sec. 800.12 of the September 1996 draft

contained the consultation requirements regarding Indian tribes and

Native Hawaiian organizations. The provisions in that past section have

been interspersed and incorporated into the relevant sections and

subsections of the final rule for ease of reference to those reading

the regulations, eliminating the need to flip back and forth between

other sections of the regulations and this one. This reorganization was

also done in response to tribal concerns that the separate section did

not facilitate integration of Indian tribes and Native Hawaiian

organizations into the routine process. For the most part, the

incorporation of those provisions into the other sections used existing

language. Changes that were made in response to comments are noted at

the specific section.

Section 800.12 of the final rule contains the provisions on

emergency situations, formerly under Sec. 800.13 of the September 1996

draft. The final rule incorporates several changes suggested by the

comments. First, the Council deleted the reference to an ``Agency

Official'' declaring a disaster or emergency, since it was pointed out

that Agency Officials, as defined by the Council's regulations, do not

have such authority, nor was it appropriate for the Council to grant

them such authority. Second, in subsection (b), language was also added

that had erroneously been left out, to acknowledge that the provision

extended to other ``immediate threat(s) to life or property.'' Third,

the duty to consult with Indian tribes and Native Hawaiian

organizations has been incorporated in response to tribal comments

holding that this is mandated by the 1992 amendments to the NHPA.

One comment stated that demolition and repair operations should be

exempt from section 106 when the following principles are at stake:

Protection of lives, compliance with building codes, protection for

property, maintenance of public health and safety, restoration of vital

community services, or evaluation of post disaster engineering reports.

The Council recognized many of these principles but believes it has

struck the proper balance between the need to carry out the section 106

process and the need for expediency created by emergency situations.

The last sentence of Sec. 800.12 provides an exemption from section 106

compliance for immediate rescue and salvage operations conducted to

preserve life or property, since the Council believed that emergency

expediency in those situations outweighed section 106 process to such

an extend that an exemption was warranted.

Section 800.13

This section, formerly found under Sec. 800.14 of the September

1996 draft, was revised by the Council to simplify its provisions and

to respond to various comments. Subsection (a)(1) was added in the

final rule to highlight the benefit of planning for subsequent

discoveries in Programmatic Agreements. Subsection (a)(2) contains

language that was in the September 1996 draft, except that mention of

standard treatments containing provisions for subsequent discoveries

was deleted as it was deemed inappropriate to include treatment for

subsequent discoveries in standard treatments.

Subsection (b) was also changed by adding ``or if construction on

an approved undertaking has not commenced,'' as the Council realized

that such a circumstance would also provide the opportunity for

consultation. Subsection (b)(2) was amended in response to comments

that indicated it was not clear, as drafted in the September 1996

draft, that the SHPO/THPO or the Indian tribe or Native Hawaiian

organization that attaches religious and cultural significance to the

affected property have to agree that the property is of value solely

for its scientific, prehistoric, history or archaeological data before

the Archaeological and Historic Preservation Act could be used in lieu

of Section 106. Subsection (b)(3) was changed minimally to clarify the

intent that the SHPO/THPO, the Indian tribe or Native Hawaiian

organization and the Council have 48 hours in which to respond to a

notification of an inadvertent discovery.

Subsection (d) was added as a result of comments made during the

tribal consultation meetings and in deference to tribal sovereignty

with regard to actions on tribal lands.

Section 800.14

This section was formerly found under Sec. 800.15 of the September

1996 draft. It provides for new options for agencies to pursue in

streamlining their section 106 compliance activities and incorporates

the practice, under the regulations activities and incorporates the

practice, under the regulations to be superseded, of developing

Programmatic Agreements to facilitate coordination between Section 106

and an agency's particular program.

Regarding subsection (a), most of the Federal agency and industry

commenters believed that the Federal agencies should be the ones

determining the procedural consistency of program alternatives with

Council regulations. Most SHPOs and Indian tribes believed the Council

should make such consistency determinations. In the end, the Council

opted to make the consistency determinations. The Council believes it

has the internal experience and expertise to make such evaluations.

Also, the diversity of its membership ensures that a balanced

perspective is brought to final determinations regarding consistency.

Section 211 of the NHPA states that the Council ``is authorized to

promulgate such rules and regulations as it deems necessary to govern

implementation of section 106 * * * in its entirety.'' Section

110(a)(2) of the NHPA states that the ``(Federal agency historic

preservation) program(s) shall ensure * * * that the agency's

procedures for compliance with section 106 * * * are consistent with

regulations issued by the Council * * *'' (emphasis added). It must be

understood, among other things and upon closer examination, that

section 110 of the NHPA does not specifically provide for Federal

agencies to substitute their programs for the Section 106 regulations

promulgated by the Council. Through Sec. 800.14(a) of the new

regulations, the Council is allowing for such substitution, believing

this may help agencies in their section 106 compliance. However, the

Council will not allow such substitution if the agency procedures are

inconsistent with the Council's 106 regulations. The Council, in its

expertise, holds that its regulations correctly implement section 106,

and that it would therefore be inimical to its mandate and contrary to

the spirit and letter of section 100(a)(2)(E) of the NHPA, for the

Council to allow inconsistent procedures to substitute the Council's

section 106 regulations.

The last sentence under subsection (a)(4) was added during the OMB

review process to allay concerns that 101(d)(5) agreements would be

entered into without the knowledge and opportunity to comment of

Federal agencies.

Subsection (b) is intended to retain the concept of Programmatic

Agreements as in the superseded regulations, but with more clarity

regarding required signatures, termination, and public participation.

Programmatic Agreements should facilitate and streamline the Section

106 process regarding complex project situations or multiple

undertakings.

Subsection (c) sets forth the process for exempting certain

programs or categories of undertakings from the section 106 process.

This is based on section 214 of the NHPA.

Subsection (f) was added in response to tribal comments that there

needed to be specific requirements for Federal agencies to consult with

Indian tribes during the preparation of program alternatives. The

content follows the policies that have guided tribal consultation

throughout the revisions of the regulation.

Section 800.15

This section was formerly under Sec. 800.16 of the September 1996

draft. It is presently reserved for future use. The Council will

proceed with the review of tribal applications for substitution of

tribal regulations for the Council's section 106 regulations on tribal

lands, pursuant to section 101(d)(5) of the Act, on the basis of

informal procedures. With regard to State agreements, the Council will

keep in effect any currently valid State agreements until revised

procedures for State agreements take effect or until the agreement is

otherwise terminated.

Section 800.16

Few comments were received on the definitions and no substantial

changes were made. There were some comments on the definition of

``undertaking,'' requesting clarification of its scope. That has been

done in the Section-by Section analysis (Section VII).

VI. Summary of Major Changes From the Regulations Being Superseded

The revised section 106 regulations will significantly modify the

process under the regulations to be superseded, introducing new

streamlining while incorporating statutory changes mandated by the 1992

amendments to the NHPA. This section of the preamble highlights the

major revisions in the process. Although there are many other

refinements and improvements that cumulatively improve the operation of

the section 106 process, they are not detailed here.

Major Changes

Greater deference to Federal agency-SHPO \1\ decisionmaking. The

Council will no longer review routine decisions agreed to by the

Federal agency and the SHPO/THPO (adverse effect findings and most

Memoranda of Agreement), recognizing that the capability of these

parties to do effective preservation planning has grown substantially

since the process was last revised in 1986.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\1\ The revised regulations extend to Tribal Historic

Preservation Officers (THPO) the same role on tribal lands as the

SHPO has in the section 106 process. Accordingly, this summary of

changes refers to ``SHPO/THPO'' when the responsibilities for the

SHPO and the THPO (with regard to tribal lands) are the same.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

More focused Council involvement. The Council will focus its

attention on those situations where its expertise and national

perspective can enhance the consideration of historic preservation

issues. Criteria accompanying the regulation specify that the Council

may enter the section 106 process when an undertaking has substantial

impacts on important historic properties, presents important questions

of policy or interpretation, has the potential for presenting

compliance problems, or presents issues of concern to Indian tribes or

Native Hawaiian organizations.

Better definition of participants' roles. The primary

responsibility of the Federal agency for section 106 decisions is

emphasized, while the advisory roles of the Council and the SHPO/THPO

are clarified. The roles of other participants are more clearly

defined, particularly Indian tribes, local governments and applicants,

who may participate as ``consulting parties.'' Certain individuals and

organizations may also be entitled to be consulting parties, based on

the nature of their relation to an undertaking and its effects on

historic properties. Others may request to be involved. The exclusive

role of the Federal agency to make the ultimate decision on the

undertaking is stressed and the advisory roles of the other parties is

clearly stated.

Native American roles defined and strengthened. The 1992 NHPA

amendments placed major emphasis on the role of Indian tribes and other

Native Americans. The revisions incorporate specific provisions for

involving tribes when actions occur on tribal lands and for consulting

with Indian tribes and Native Hawaiian organizations, as required by

the NHPA, throughout the process. The revisions embody the principle

that Indian tribes should have the same extent of involvement when

actions occur on tribal lands as the SHPO does for actions within the

States; this includes the ability to agree to decisions regarding

significance of historic properties, effects to them and treatment of

those effects, including signing Memoranda of Agreement. Off tribal

lands, Federal agencies must consult the appropriate tribe or Native

Hawaiian organization. The provisions recognize Federal agency

obligations to consider properties to which the tribes attach religious

and cultural significance in project planning. Provision is also made

for the involvement of the Tribal Historic Preservation Officer in lieu

of the SHPO for undertaking on tribal lands when that official has

assumed the responsibilities of the SHPO in accordance with section

101(d) (2) of the NHPA.

Role of applicants recognized. The revisions acknowledge the direct

interests of applicants for Federal assistance or approval and specify

greater opportunities for active participation in the section 106

process as consulting parties. Applicants are permitted to initiate and

pursue the steps of the process, while the Federal agency remains

responsible for final decisions regarding historic properties.

Early compliance encouraged. Provisions have been added to

encourage agencies to initiate compliance with the Section 106 process

early in project planning and to begin consultation with the SHPO/THPO

and others at that early stage. This should promote early agency

consideration of historic properties in project planning and prevent

late recognition of an agency's legal responsibilities that often cause

delay or compliance problems.

Coordination with other reviews advanced. Agencies are encouraged

to integrate Section 106 review with that required under the National

Environmental Policy Act and related laws. Specific provisions that

make identification and evaluation, public participation and

documentation requirements more flexible facilitate this and will

streamline reviews, allowing agencies to use information and analyses

prepared for one law to be used to meet the requirements of another.

Use of NEPA compliance to meet Section 106 requirements authorized.

Agencies are authorized to use the preparation of Environmental Impact

Statements and Environmental Assessments under the National

Environmental Policy Act to meet section 106 needs in lieu of following

the specified Council process. This is expected to be a major

opportunity for agencies with well-developed NEPA processes to simplify

concurrent reviews, reduce costs to applicants and avoid redundant

paperwork.

New techniques introduced to deal with marginal or routine cases.

Federal agencies may seek exemptions from Section 106 or advisory

comments on an entire program. Also, the Council may establish standard

methods of treating recurring situations. This will allow agencies to

save both time and resources that would otherwise be committed to

legally-mandated reviews.

Public participation clarified. Opportunities for public

involvement in the section 106 process are simplified and more clearly

defined, with encouragement for Federal agencies to use their

established public involvement procedures where appropriate.

Clarification in this area will reduce controversy over the adequacy of

an agency's efforts to involve the public.

Alternate Federal agency procedures flexed. The provisions allowing

Federal agencies to substitute their internal procedures for the

Council's section 106 regulations no longer require that the agency

procedures be formal rules or regulations. This will make it easier for

agencies to tailor the section 106 process to their needs. Approval of

such substitute procedures is linked to requirements of section

110(a)(2)(E) of the NHPA.

Procedural Streamlining

The following section details changes in the basic Section 106

process. It demonstrates the technical alteration to the process to

carry out the changes described previously.

``No effect'' step simplified. To ``no historic properties'' and

``no effect'' determinations of the regulations being superseded are

combined into a single ``no historic properties affected'' finding. The

separate ``effect'' determination of the regulations being superseded

is dropped and the agency moves directly to assessing adverse effects

when it appears historic properties may be affected.

Identification and evaluation of historic properties made more

flexible. The revised regulation introduces the concepts of phased

identification and relating the level of identification to the nature

of the undertaking and its likely impacts on historic properties. These

concepts are important to effective NEPA coordination and will

encourage more cost-effective approaches to survey and identification,

as agencies will be able to make preliminary decisions on alternative

locations or alignments without having to conduct the more intensive

identification efforts necessary to deal with the final design and

siting of a project.

Adverse effect criteria and exceptions revamped. The criteria are

revised to better define when projects have adverse effects on historic

properties. The ``exceptions'' to the criteria concerning

rehabilitation of historic properties meeting the Secretary's Standards

and transfer of Federal properties with preservation restrictions have

been incorporated into the adverse effect criteria of the new

regulations and expanded. Previously, much archaeological data recovery

qualified for No Adverse Effect treatment when appropriate data

recovery was undertaken. Such cases now will be treated as adverse

effects (as the destruction of other historic properties), but other

changes to the process will speed completion of the section 106

process.

Council review of No Adverse Effect determinations eliminated. The

requirement that the Council review all No Adverse Effect

determinations is replaced by SHPO/THPO review and concurrence.

Consulting parties are authorized to ask the Council to review such a

determination if the request is made in a timely manner.

Failure of Federal agency-SHPO/THPO consultation leads to Council

involvement. If an agency and the SHPO/THPO failed to reach a solution

to deal with adverse effects, the process required the Federal agency

to seek the formal comments of the Council. The revised process

requires the agency to invite the Council to join the consultation and

help the parties reach resolution. Termination and comment would follow

only if further consultation was not successful. This should result in

more negotiated solutions, which are more efficient and usually provide

better results.

Council comment provision reflects 1992 NHPA amendments. Council

comments must be considered by the head of the Federal agency receiving

them, as required by section 110(1) of NHPA.

Review of agency findings clarified. Recognizing that the Council's

views on Federal agency actions to comply with section 106 are only

advisory, a new provision allows anyone at anytime to seek the

Council's opinion on agency findings and decisions under section 106.

There is no obligation to delay agency action while the council

conducts this review.

Emergency and post-review discoveries situations revised. Greater

emphasis is placed on planning for unanticipated events and more

flexible responses are allowed.

Council monitoring of overall Section 106 performance enhanced. The

new regulations will shift the emphasis of Council review from

individual cases to assessments of the overall quality of a Federal

agency's or SHPO/THPO's performance in the section 106 process. The

obligation of section 203 of the NHPA for agencies to provide project

information to the Council is included. Also, provisions are made for

closer Council review of cases where a participant has been found to

have shortcomings in complying with section 106.

VII. Description of Meaning and Intent of Specific Sections

The following information clarifies the meaning and intent behind

particular sections of the regulations.

Subpart A--Purposes and Participants

Section 800.1(b)

This sections makes clear that references in the section 106

regulations are not intended to give any additional authority to

implementing guidelines, policies or procedures issued by any other

Federal agency. Where such provisions are cited, they are simply to

assist users in finding related guidance, which is non-binding, or

requirements of related laws, which may be mandatory depending on the

particular law itself.

Section 800.1(c)

The purpose of this section is to emphasize the flexibility an

Agency Official has in carrying out the steps of the section 106

process, while acknowledging that early initiation of the process is

essential and that actions taken to meet the procedural requirements

must not restrict the effective consideration of alternatives related

to historic preservation issues in later stages of the process.

Section 800.2(a)

The term ``Agency Official'' is intended to include those Federal

officials who have the effective decision making authority for an

undertaking. This means the ability to agree to such actions as may be

necessary to comply with section 106 and to ensure that any commitments

made as a result of the section 106 process are indeed carried out.

This authority and the legal responsibilities under section 106 may be

assumed by non-federal officials only when there is clear authority for

such an arrangement under Federal law, such as under certain programs

administered by the Department of Housing and Urban Development. This

subsection indicates that the Federal Agency must ensure that the

Agency Official ``takes * * * financial responsibility for section 106

compliance * * *.'' This phrase is not to be construed as prohibiting

Federal agencies from passing certain section 106 compliance costs to

applicants. Such a construction of the regulation would contravene

section 110(g) of the NHPA and 16 U.S.C. 469c-2. The intent behind the

reference to ``financial responsibility'' in the regulation is, as

stated above, to ensure that the Agency Official has the effective

decision making authority for an undertaking.

Section 800.2(a)(1)

This reference to the Secretary's professional standards is

intended to remind Federal agencies that this independent but related

provision of the Act may affect their compliance with section 106.

Section 800.2(a)(2)

This provision allows, but does not require, Federal agencies to

designate a lead agency for section 106 compliance purposes. The lead

agency carries out the duties of the Agency Official for all aspects of

the undertaking. The other Federal agencies may assist the lead agency

as they mutually agree. When compliance is completed, the other Federal

agencies may use the outcome to document their own compliance with

section 106 and must implement any provisions that apply to them. This

provision does not prohibit an agency to independently pursue

compliance with section 106 for its obligations under section 106,

although this should be carefully coordinated with the lead agency. A

lead agency can sign the Memorandum of Agreement for other agencies, so

long as that is part of the agreement among the agencies for creating

the lead agency arrangement. It should also be clear in the Memorandum

of Agreement.

Section 800.2(a)(3)

While a Federal agency may rely on applicants or contractors to

prepare necessary materials and assessments for section 106 purposes,

the Agency Official must personally and independently make the findings

and determinations required under these regulations. This includes

assuming the responsibility for ensuring that work done by others meets

applicable Federal requirements.

Section 800.2(a)(4)

This section sets forth the general concepts of consultation. It

identifies the duty of Federal agencies to consult with other parties

at various steps in the section 106 process and acknowledges that

consultation varies depending on a variety of factors. It also

encourages agencies to coordinate section 106 consultation with that

required under other Federal laws and to use existing agency processes

to promote efficiency.

Section 800.2(b)

The Council will generally not review the determinations and

decisions reached in accordance with these regulations by the Agency

Official and appropriate consulting parties and not participate in the

review of most section 106 cases. However, because the statutory

obligation of the Federal agency is to afford the Council a reasonable

opportunity to comment on its undertaking's effects upon historic

properties, the Council will oversee the section 106 process and

formally become a party in individual consultations when it determines

there are sufficient grounds to do so. These are set forth in appendix

A. The Council also will provide participants in the section 106

process with its advice and guidance in order to facilitate completion

of the section 106 review. Except as specifically noted in these

regulations, this advice and guidance is non-binding.

Section 800.2(c)

This section sets a standard for involving various consulting

parties. The objective is to provide parties with an effective

opportunity to participate in the section 106 process, relative to the

interest they have to the historic preservation issues at hand.

Section 800.2(c)(1)

This section recognizes the central role of the SHPO in working

with the Agency Official on section 106 compliance in most cases. It

also delineates the manner in which the SHPO may get involved in the

section 106 process when a THPO has assumed SHPO functions on tribal

lands.

Section 800.2(c)(2)

The role of THPO was created in the 1992 amendments to the Act.

This section tracks the statutory provision relating to THPO assumption

of the SHPO's section 106 role on tribal lands. In such circumstances,

the THPO substitutes for the SHPO and the SHPO participates in the

section 106 process only as specified in Sec. 800.2(c)(1) or as a

member of the public. This section also specifies that in those

instances where an undertaking occurs on or affects properties on

tribal land and a THPO has not officially assumed the SHPO's section

106 responsibilities on those lands, the Agency Official still consults

with the SHPO, but also consults with a representative designated by

the Indian tribe. Such designation is made in accordance with tribal

law and procedures. However, if the tribe has not designated such a

representative, the Agency Official would consult with the tribe's

chief elected official, such as the tribal chairman. For ease of

reference in the regulation and because such designated tribal

representative has the same rights and responsibilities under these

regulations as a THPO that has assumed the SHPO's responsibilities, the

term ``THPO'' has been defined as including the designated tribal

representative.

Section 800.2(c)(3)

This section embodies the statutory requirement for Federal

agencies to consult with Indian tribes and Native Hawaiian

organizations throughout the section 106 process when they attach

religious and cultural significance to historic properties that may be

affected by an undertaking. It is intended to promote continuing and

effective consultation with those parties throughout the section 106

process.

Such consultation is intended to be conducted in a manner that is fully

cognizant of the legal rights of Indian tribes and that is sensitive to

their cultural traditions and practices.

Section 800.2(c)(3)(i)

This subsection has two main purposes. First, it emphasizes the

importance of involving Indian tribes and Native Hawaiian organizations

early and fully at all stages of the section 106 process. Second,

Federal agencies should solicit tribal views in a manner that is

sensitive to the governmental structures of the tribes, recognizing

that confidentiality and communication issues may require Federal

agencies to allow more time for the exchange of information. Also, this

section states that the Agency Official must make a ``reasonable and

good faith effort'' to identify interested tribes and Native Hawaiian

organizations. This means that the Agency Official may have to look

beyond reservations and tribal lands in the project's vicinity to seek

information on tribes that had been historically located in the area,

but are no longer there.

Section 800.2(c)(3)(ii)

This subsection was added to make clear that nothing in these

regulations can, or is intended to, modify any rights that Indian

tribes maintain through treaties, sovereign status, or other legal

bases.

Section 800.2(c)(3)(iii)

This subsection emphasizes the need to consult with Indian tribes

on a government-to-government basis. The Agency Official must consult

with the appropriate tribal representative, who must be selected or

designated by the tribe to speak on behalf of the tribe. Matters of

protocol are important to Indian tribes. Indian tribes and Native

Hawaiian organizations may be reluctant to share information about

properties to which they attach religious and cultural significance.

Federal agencies must recognize this and be willing to identify

historic properties without compromising concerns about

confidentiality. The Agency Official should also be sensitive to the

internal workings of a tribe and allow the time necessary for the

tribal decision making process to operate.

Section 800.2(c)(3)(iv)

This subsection reminds Federal agencies of the statutory duty to

consult with Indian tribes and Native Hawaiian organizations whether or

not the undertaking or its effects occur on tribal land. Agencies

should be particularly sensitive to identifying areas of traditional

association with tribes or a Native Hawaiian organization, where

properties to which they attach religious and cultural significance may

be found.

Section 800.2(c)(3)(v)

Some Federal agencies have or may want to develop special working

relationships with Indian tribes or Native Hawaiian organizations to

provide specific arrangements for how they will adhere to the steps in

the section 106 process and enhance the participation of tribes and

Native Hawaiian organizations. Such agreements are not mandatory; they

may be negotiated at the discretion of Federal agencies. The agreements

cannot diminish the rights set forth in the regulations for other

parties, such as the SHPO, without that party's express consent.

Section 800.2(c)(3)(vi)

The signature of tribes is required where a Memorandum of Agreement

concerns tribal lands. However, if a tribe has not formally assumed the

SHPO's responsibilities under section 101(d)(2) the tribe may waive its

signature rights at its discretion. This will allow tribes the

flexibility of allowing agreements to go forward regarding tribal land,

but without condoning the agreement with their signature.

Section 800.2(c)(4)

Affected local governments must be given consulting party status if

they so request. Under Sec. 800.3(f)(1), Agency Officials are required

to invite such local governments to be consulting parties. This

subsection provides for that status and also reminds Federal agencies

that some local governments may act as the Agency Official when they

have assumed section 106 legal responsibilities, such as under certain

programs administered by the Department of Housing and Urban

Development.

Section 800.2(c)(5)

Applicants for Federal assistance or for a Federal permit, license

or other approval are entitled to be consulting parties. Under section

800.3(f)(1), Agency Officials are required to invite them to be

consulting parties. Also, Federal agencies have the legal

responsibility to comply with section 106 of the NHPA. In fulfilling

their responsibilities, Federal agencies sometimes choose to rely on

applicants for permits, approvals or assistance to begin the section

106 process. The intent was to allow applicants to contact SHPOs and

other consulting parties, but agencies must be mindful of their

government-to-government consultation responsibilities when dealing

with Indian tribes. If a Federal agency implements its section 106

responsibilities in this way, the Federal agency remains legally

responsible for the determinations. Applicants that may assume

responsibilities under a Memorandum of Agreement must be consulting

parties in the process leading to the agreement.

Section 800.2(c)(6)

This section allows for the possibility that other individuals or

entities may have a demonstrated special interest in an undertaking and

that Federal agencies and SHPO/THPOs should consider the involvement of

such individuals or entities as consulting parties. This might include

property owners directly affected by the undertaking, non-profit

organizations with a direct interest in the issues or affected

businesses. Under Sec. 800.3(f)(3), upon written request and in

consultation with the SHPO/THPO and any Indian tribe upon whose tribal

lands an undertaking occurs or affects historic properties, an Agency

Official may allow certain individuals under Sec. 800.2(c)(6) to become

consulting parties.

Section 800.2(d)(1)

Public involvement is a critical aspect of the 106 process. This

section is intended to set forth a standard that Federal agencies must

adhere to as they go through the Section 106 process. The type of

public involvement will depend upon various factors, including but not

limited to, the nature of the undertaking, the potential impact, the

historic property, and the likely interest of the public.

Confidentiality concerns include those specified in section 304 of the

Act and legitimate concerns about proprietary information, business

plans and privacy of property owners.

Section 800.2(d)(2)

This subsection is intended to set the notice standard. Notice,

with sufficient information to allow meaningful comments, must be

provided to the public so that the public can express its views during

the various stages and decision making points of the process.

Section 800.2(d)(3)

It is intended that Federal agencies have flexibility in how they

involve the public, including the use of NEPA and other agency planning

processes, as long as opportunities for such public involvement are

adequate and

consistent with subpart A of the regulations.

Subpart B--The Section 106 Process

Section 800.3

This new section is intended to encourage Federal agencies to

integrate the section 106 process into agency planning at its earliest

stages.

Section 800.3(a)

The determination of whether or not an undertaking exists is the

Agency Official's determination. The Council may render advice on the

existence of an undertaking, but ultimately this remains a Federal

agency decision.

Section 800.3(a)(1)

This section explains that if there is an undertaking, but there is

no potential that the undertaking will have an effect on an historic

property, then the agency is finished with its section 106 obligations.

There is no consultation requirement for this decision.

Section 800.2(a) (2)

This is a reminder to Federal agencies that adherence to the

standard 106 process in subpart B is inappropriate where the

undertaking is governed by a program alternative established pursuant

to Sec. 800.14.

Section 800.3(b)

This section does not impose a mandatory requirement on Federal

agencies. It emphasizes the benefit of coordinating compliance with

related statutes so as to enhance efficiency and avoid duplication of

efforts, but the decision is up to the Agency Official. Agencies are

encouraged to use the information gathered for these other processes to

meet section 106 needs, but the information must meet the standards in

these regulations.

Section 800.3(c)

This sets forth the responsibility to properly identify the

appropriate SHPO or THPO that must be consulted. If the undertaking is

on or affects historic properties on tribal lands, then the agency must

determine what tribe is involved and whether the tribe has assumed the

SHPO's responsibilities for section 106 under section 101(d) (2) of the

Act. A list of such tribes is available from the National Park Service.

Section 800.3(c) (1)

This section reiterates that the THPO may assume the role of the

SHPO on tribal land and tracks the language of the Act in specifying

how certain owners of property on tribal lands can request SHPO

involvement in a Section 106 case in addition to the THPO.

Section 800.3(c) (2)

This section is the State counterpart to Federal lead agencies and

has the same effect. It allows a group of SHPOs to agree to delegate

their authority under these regulations for a specific undertaking to

one SHPO.

Section 800.3(c) (3)

This section reinforces the notion that the conduct of consultation

may vary depending on the agency's planning process, the nature of the

undertaking and the nature of its effects.

Section 800.3(c) (4)

This section makes it clear that failure of an SHPO/THPO to respond

within the time frames set by the regulation permit the agency to

assume concurrence with the finding or to consult about the finding or

determination with the Council in the SHPO/THPO's absence. It also

makes clear that subsequent involvement by the SHPO/THPO is not

precluded, but the SHPO/THPO cannot reopen a finding or determination

that it failed to respond to earlier.

Section 800.3(d)

This section specifies that, on tribal lands, the Agency Official

consults with both the Indian tribe and the SHPO when the tribe has not

formally assumed the responsibilities of the SHPO under section 101(d)

(2) of the Act. It also allows the section 106 process to be completed

even when the SHPO has decided not to participate in the process, and

for the SHPO and an Indian tribe to develop tailored agreements for

SHPO participation in reviewing undertaking on the tribe's lands.

Section 800.3(e)

This section requires the Agency Official to decide early how and

when to involve the public in the section 106 process. It does not

require a formal ``plan,'' although that might be appropriate depending

upon the scale of the undertaking and the magnitude of its effects on

historic properties.

Section 800.3(f)

This is a particularly important section, as it requires the Agency

Official at an early stage of the section 106 process to consult with

the SHPO/THPO to identify those organizations and individuals that will

have the right to be consulting parties under the terms of the

regulations. These include local government, Indian tribes and Native

Hawaiian organizations and applicants for Federal assistance or

permits, especially those who may assume a responsibility under a

Memorandum of Agreement (see Sec. 800.6(c)(2)(ii)). Others may request

to be consulting parties, but that decision is up to the Agency

Official.

Section 800.3(g)

This section makes it clear that an Agency Official can combine

individual steps in the section 106 process with the consent of the

SHPO/THPO. Doing so must protect the opportunity of the public and

consulting parties to participate fully in the Section 106 process as

envisioned in Section 800.2.

Section 800.4(a)

This section sets forth the consultative requirements involved in

the scoping efforts at the beginning stages of the identification

process. The Agency Official must consult with the SHPO/THPO in

fulfilling the steps in subsections (1) through (4). This section

emphasizes the need to consult with the SHPO/THPO at all steps in the

scoping process It also highlights the need to seek information from

Indian tribes and Native Hawaiian organizations with regard to

properties to which they attach religious and cultural significance,

while being sensitive to confidentiality concerns. Where Federal

agencies are engaged in an action that is on or may affect ancestral,

aboriginal or ceded lands, Federal agencies must consult with Indian

tribes and Native Hawaiian organizations with regard to properties of

traditional religious and cultural significance on such lands.

Section 800.4(b)

This section sets out the steps an Agency Official must follow to

identify historic properties. It is close to the section 106 process

under the regulations to be superseded, with increased flexibility of

timing and greater involvement of Indian tribes and Native Hawaiian

organizations in accordance with the 1992 amendments to the Act.

Section 800.4(b)(1)

This section on level of effort required during the identification

processes has been added to allow for flexibility. It sets the standard

of a reasonable and good faith effort on behalf of the agency to

identify properties and provides that the level of effort in the

identification process depends on numerous factors including, among

others listed, the nature of the undertaking and its corresponding

potential effects on historic properties.

Section 800.4(b)(2)

This new section is also intended to provide Federal agencies with

flexibility when several alternatives are under consideration and the

nature of the undertaking and its potential scope and effect has

therefore not yet been completely defined. The section also allows for

deferral of final identification and evaluation if provided for in an

agreement with the SHPO/THPO or other circumstances. Under this phased

alternative, Agency Officials are required to follow up with full

identification and evaluation once project alternatives have been

refined or access has been gained to previously restricted areas. Any

further deferral of final identification would complicate the process

and jeopardize an adequate assessment of effects and resolution of

adverse effects.

Section 800.4(c)

This section sets out the process for determining the National

Register eligibility of properties not previously evaluated for

historic significance. It follows closely the regulations to be

superseded.

Section 800.4(c)(1)

This section sets out the process for eligibility determinations in

much the same way as the regulations to be superseded, but requires

Federal agencies to acknowledge the special expertise of Indian tribes

and Native Hawaiian organizations when assessing the eligibility of a

property to which they attach religious and cultural significance. If

either objects to a determination of eligibility, they may seek the

Council to have the matter referred to the Keeper. The Council retains

discretion on whether or not to submit such referral.

Section 800.4(c)(2)

This section remains largely unchanged from the regulations to be

superseded except that it provides that if an Indian tribe or Native

Hawaiian organization disagrees with a determination of eligibility

involving a property to which it attaches religious and cultural

significance, then the tribe can ask the Council to request that the

Agency Official obtain a determination of eligibility. The Council

retains the discretion as to whether or not it should make the request

of the Agency Official. This section was intended to provide a way to

ensure appropriate determinations regarding properties, located off

tribal lands, to which tribes attach religious and cultural

significance.

Section 800.4(d)

This section now combines the ``No Historic Properties'' and ``No

Effect'' findings of the regulations to be superseded.

Section 800.4(d)(1)

This section describes the closure point in the Section 106 process

where no historic properties are found or no effects on historic

properties are found. Consulting parties must be specifically notified

of the determination, but members of the public need not receive direct

notification; the Federal agency must place its documentation in a

public file prior to approving the undertaking, and provide access to

the information when requested by the public. Once the consulting

parties are notified, the SHPO/THPO has 30 days to object to the

determination. The Council may also object on its own initiative within

the time period. Lack of such objection within the 30 day period means

that the agency need not take further steps in the section 106 process.

Section 800.4(d)(2)

This section requires that the Federal agency proceed to the

adverse effect determination step where it finds that historic

properties may be affected or the SHPO/THPO or Council objects to a no

historic properties affected finding. The agency must notify all

consulting parties.

Section 800.5

This section is similar to the provisions for assessing adverse

affects under the regulations to be superseded, but the role of the

Council is significantly altered and a role is provided for Indian

tribes, Native Hawaiian organizations and other consulting parties.

Section 800.5(a)

This section has been minimally changed except that it provides for

Indian tribe and Native Hawaiian organization consultation where

properties to which they attach religious and cultural significance are

involved. This section also requires the Agency Official to consider

the views of consulting parties and the public that have already been

provided to the Federal agency.

Section 800.5(a)(1)

This section has important changes from the regulations to be

superseded. It combines the effect criteria and adverse effect criteria

as defined in the regulation to be superseded. This section has also

been modified to codify the practice of the Council in considering both

direct and indirect effects in making an adverse effect determination.

This section allows for consideration of effects on the qualifying

characteristics of a historic property that may not have been part of

the property's original eligibility evaluation. The last sentence in

this section is intended to amplify the indirect effects concept,

similar to the NEPA regulations, which calls for consideration of such

effects when they are reasonably foreseeable effects.

Section 800.5(a)(2)(i)

This section contains the minor change of deleting the word

``alteration''. The alteration adverse effect concept is retained in

the next subsection.

Section 800.5(a)(2)(ii)

The list of examples of adverse effects has been modified by

eliminating the exceptions to the adverse effect criteria. However, if

a property is restored, rehabilitated, repaired, maintained,

stabilized, remediated or otherwise changed in accordance with the

Secretary's standards, then it will not be considered an adverse

effect.

Section 800.5(a)(2)(iii)

This subsection, along with Sec. 800.5(a)(2)(I), would encompass

recovery of archeological data as an adverse effect, even if conducted

in accordance with the Secretary's standards. This change from the

regulations to be superseded acknowledges the reality that destruction

of a site and recovery of its information and artifacts is adverse. It

is intended that by eliminating data recovery as an exception to the

adverse effect criteria, Federal agencies will be more inclined to

pursue other forms of mitigation, including avoidance and preservation

in place, to protect archeological sites. The Council is publishing for

comment concurrent with this regulation a proposal to deal with

recovery of archeological data as a standard treatment in accordance

with Sec. 800.14. It is the Council's intent to retain an expedited

format for resolution and reaching agreements where values other than

scientific research are not involved.

Section 800.5(a)(2)(iv)

This section was changed to more closely track the National

Register criteria regarding the relation of alterations to a property's

use or setting to the significance of the property.

Section 800.5(a)(2)(v)

This section was changed to more closely track the language of the

National Register criteria as it pertains to the property's integrity.

Section 800.5(a)(2)(vi)

This section was modified to acknowledge that where properties of

religious and cultural significance to Indian tribes or Native Hawaiian

organizations are involved, neglect and deterioration may be recognized

as qualities of those properties and thus may not necessarily

constitute an adverse effect.

Section 800.5(a)(2)(vii)

If a property is transferred leased or sold out of Federal

ownership with proper preservation restrictions, then it will not be

considered an adverse effect as in the regulations to be superseded.

Transfer between Federal agencies is not an adverse effect per se; the

purpose of the transfer should be evaluated for potential adverse

effects, so that they can be considered before the transfer takes

place.

Section 800.5(a)(3)

This section is intended to allow flexibility in Federal agency

decision making processes and to recognize that phasing of adverse

effect determinations, like identification and evaluation, is

appropriate in certain planning and approval circumstances, such as the

development of linear projects where major corridors are first assessed

and then specific route alignment decisions are made subsequently.

Section 800.5(b)

This section has been modified to allow SHPO/THPO's the ability to

suggest changes in a project or impose conditions so that adverse

effects can be avoided and thus result in a no adverse effect

determination. It is also written to emphasize that a finding of no

adverse effect is only a proposal when the Agency Official submits it

to the SHPO/THPO for review. This provision also acknowledges that the

practice of ``conditional No Adverse Effect determinations'' is

acceptable.

Section 800.5(c)

The Council will cease reviewing no adverse effect determinations

on a routine basis. The Council will intervene and review no adverse

effect determinations if it deems it appropriate based on the criteria

listed in appendix A or if the SHPO/THPO or another consulting party

and the Federal agency disagree on the finding and the agency cannot

resolve the disagreement. The SHPO/THPO and any consulting party

wishing to disagree to the finding must do so within the 30-day review

period. If Indian tribes or Native Hawaiian organizations disagree with

the finding, they can request the Council's review directly, but this

must be done within the 30 day review period. If a SHPO/THPO fails to

respond to an Agency Official finding within the 30 day review period,

then the Agency Official can consider that to be SHPO/THPO agreement

with the finding. When a finding is submitted to the Council, it will

have 15 days for review; if it fails to respond within the 15 days,

then the Agency Official may assume Council concurrence with the

finding. When it reviews no adverse effect determinations, the Council

will limit its review to whether or not the criteria have been

correctly applied. The Council's determination is binding.

Section 800.5(d)

Agencies must retain records of their findings of no adverse effect

and make them available to the public. This means that the public

should be given access to the information, subject to FOIA and other

statutory limits on disclosure such as section 304 of the NHPA, when

they so request. Failure of the agency to carry out the undertaking in

accordance with the finding requires the Agency Official to reopen the

Section 106 process and determine whether the altered course of action

constitutes an adverse effect. A finding of adverse effect requires

further consultation on ways to resolve it.

Section 800.6

The process for resolving adverse effects has been changed to

reflect the altered role of the Council and the consulting parties.

Section 800.6(a)(1)

When adverse effects are found, the consultation must continue

among the Federal agency, SHPO/THPO and consulting parties to attempt

to resolve them. The Agency Official must notify the Council when

adverse effects are found and should invite the Council to participate

in the consultation when the circumstances in Sec. 800.6(a)(1)(I) (A)-

(C) exist. A consulting party may also request the Council to join the

consultation. The Council will decide on its participation within 15

days of receipt of a request, basing its decision on the criteria set

forth in appendix A. Whenever the Council decides to join the

consultation, it must notify the Agency Official and the consulting

parties. It must also advise the head of the Federal agency of its

decision to participate. This is intended to keep the policy level of

the Federal agency apprised of those cases that the Council has

determined present issues significant enough to warrant its

involvement.

Section 800.6(a)(2)

This section allows for the entry of new consulting parties if the

agency and the SHPO/THPO (and the Council, if participating) agree. If

they do not agree, it is desirable for them to seek the Council's

opinion on the involvement of the consulting party. Any party,

including applicants, licensees or permittees, that may have

responsibilities under a Memorandum of Agreement must be invited to

participate as consulting parties in reaching the agreement.

Section 800.6(a)(3)

This section specifies the Agency Official's obligation to provide

project documentation to all consulting parties at the beginning of the

consultation to resolve adverse effects. Particular note should be made

of the reference to the confidentiality provisions.

Section 800.6(a)(4)

The Federal agency must provide an opportunity for members of the

public to express their views on an undertaking. The provision embodies

the principles of flexibility, relating the agency effort to various

aspects of the undertaking and its effects upon historic properties.

The Federal agency must provide them with notice such that the public

has enough time and information to meaningfully comment. If all

relevant information was provided at earlier stages in the process in

such a way that a wide audience was reached, and no new information is

available at this stage in the process that would assist in the

resolution of adverse effects, then a new public notice may not be

warranted. However, this presumes that the public had the opportunity

to make its views known on ways to resolve the adverse effects.

Section 800.6(a)(5)

Although it is in the interest of the public to have as much

information as possible in order to provide meaningful comments, this

section acknowledges that information may be withheld in accordance

with Section 304 of the NHPA. Particular attention is given to the

conf

This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Protection of Historic Properties · 64 FR 27044 | Frix