Exchange Visitor Program

FederalRegulations

Ask Donna

How this section applies to your facts.

Federal Register › Vol. 61 › 61 FR 13760

This text was captured on Sep 30, 2026. It is a snapshot, not a live feed, so check the official code before relying on it.

Text

UNITED STATES INFORMATION AGENCY

22 CFR Part 514

Exchange Visitor Program

AGENCY: United States Information Agency.

ACTION: Statement of policy.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: Since August of 1990, the Agency has continued its oversight

of Summer Travel/Work programs, notwithstanding suggestions that the

Agency is in fact without statutory authority to conduct such programs

as currently configured. The Agency hereby announces its acceptance, as

statutorily sound, of four Summer Travel/Work programs. A two year

period of additional review of a fifth program is also hereby announced

and adopted.

EFFECTIVE DATE: This policy statement is effective March 28, 1996.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:

Stanley S. Colvin, Assistant General Counsel, United States Information

Agency, 301 4th Street, S.W., Washington, D.C. 20547; Telephone, (202)

619-6829.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: In February of 1990, the General Accounting

Office (``GAO'') issued its report entitled ``Inappropriate Uses of

Educational and Cultural Exchange Visas.'' This report specifically

identified Summer Travel/Work programs designated by the Agency for the

past twenty-five years as an example of programs operating outside of

the statutory parameters set forth under the Mutual Educational and

Cultural Exchange Act of 1961 (Fulbright-Hays Act.) As currently

configured, Summer Travel/Work programs permit foreign university

students to enter the United States during their summer months for the

purpose of travel and the pursuit of employment opportunities wherever

they may be found. Approximately 16,000 foreign university students to

charges of inappropriate use of the Exchange Visitor Program and

brought about, in March of 1993, the promulgation of new and

comprehensive regulations governing exchange activities. These

regulations, in turn, resulted in changes to the operations of flagship

exchange programs and other programs of long-standing and venerable

reputation. Underlying this policy and regulatory review was the

Agency's identification of the core components of an exchange activity.

These components--selection, screening, orientation, placement,

monitoring, and the promotion of mutual understanding--define what an

exchange is and whether one is actually occurring.

The use of these components in a review of the Summer Travel/Work

programs demonstrates clearly why the Agency has determined that it

lacks sufficient authority to continue the programs as currently

configured. Today, five organizations conduct Summer Travel/Work

programs pursuant to two substantially different program designs. Four

of the five programs arrange all details of the program including

prearranged employment and accommodations. The remaining program,

accounting for approximately 12,000 of all participants, does not make

advance arrangements for employment or accommodations. Participants in

this program are left to their own devices in securing both employment

and accommodation.

Given the design and operation of these four programs and their

selection, screening, orientation, placement, and monitoring of program

participants, the Agency is satisfied that statutory conformity is

possible. Accordingly, the Agency has determined that these four Summer

Travel/Work programs should be allowed to expand both their number of

program participants and the countries from which they are selected.

Program guidelines have been developed and the four programs currently

selecting, screening, orienting, placing, and monitoring their program

enter each year for this purpose.

The 1990 GAO report was the catalyst for what has become a five

year debate regarding the public diplomacy value of Summer Travel/Work

programs and the Agency's legal authority to continue them under the

aegis of the Fulbright-Hays Act. The debate surrounding these programs

occurs entirely along the fault lines that necessarily underlie the

intersection of law and policy. The legal considerations of this debate

are straightforward, while the policy considerations are less so.

Statutory Considerations

The Immigration and Nationality Act, as amended, sets forth at 8

U.S.C.

1101(a)(15)(J) an alien's statutory eligibility for entry into the

United States on a J visa. The J visa was created, as a provision of

the Fulbright-Hays Act, to facilitate educational and cultural exchange

activities. Pursuant to the provisions of 1101(a)(15)(J), an exchange

visitor is defined as:

(J) an alien having a residence in a foreign country which he

has no intention of abandoning who is a bona fide student, scholar,

trainee, teacher, professor, research assistant, specialist, or

leader in a field of specialized knowledge or skill, or other person

of similar description, who is coming temporarily to the United

States as a participant in a program designated by the Director of

the United States Information Agency, for the purpose of teaching,

instructing or lecturing, studying, observing, conducting research,

consulting, demonstrating special skills, or receiving training and

who, if he is coming to the United States to participate in a

program under which he will receive graduate medical education or

training, also meets the requirements of section 212(j), and the

alien spouse and minor children of any such alien if accompanying

him or following to join him:

Given this statutory definition of an exchange participant, the GAO

concluded that persons entering the United States to participate in

Summer Travel/Work programs did not fall within the statutory

parameters of the Fulbright-Hays Act and the Immigration and

Nationality Act. Specifically, the GAO opined that the Summer Travel/

Work programs do not require participants to engage in those activities

set forth in both Acts.

In response to this GAO report, the Agency published a Statement of

Policy and Notice in the Federal Register on August 13, 1990 (55 FR

32906.) This notice advised the public and those organizations

facilitating Summer Travel/Work programs that, in light of the GAO

report, a legal and policy review of the programs would be undertaken.

This notice further advised that upon a favorable determination

regarding the foreign policy value of these programs, the Agency would

consider whether regulations could be drafted to conform the programs

with existing law. The notice also advised that, in the alternative,

the Agency might pursue legislation to specifically authorize the

continuation of the programs.

As the debate regarding statutory authority began, the Agency

received two well-reasoned and thorough legal memoranda suggesting the

Agency did in fact possess adequate legal authority to facilitate

Summer Travel/Work programs. These memoranda proved unpersuasive.

Accordingly, the Agency remained unconvinced that it possessed

sufficient statutory authority to facilitate Summer Travel/Work

programs and so advised the Congress by letter dated June 10, 1991.

Additional support for this Agency determination was subsequently

provided by a GAO Office of General Counsel letter opinion dated July

8, 1992. This letter opinion set forth a review of both the statutory

language and legislative history of the Fulbright-Hays Act. The GAO

affirmed its legal opinion set forth in the 1990 report but suggested

that the Agency may be able to bring Summer Travel/Work programs into

statutory compliance, stating:

Notwithstanding our conclusions, given the broad authority an

agency has in promulgating regulations and implementing an activity

conferred upon it by statute, Powell v. Schweiker, 688 F. 2d 1357,

1360-61 11th Cir. 1982), we think USIA could revise its regulations

to establish trainee, summer student travel/work and international

camp counselor programs that are consistent with the J-visa statute.

We emphasize that any determination about the propriety of these

programs must begin with the J-visa statute. If a program involves

individuals whose status is comprehended by the categories set forth

in the J-visa statute, and the statute authorizes the activity that

such individuals will pursue, then the program would be consistent

with the intent of the J-visa statute. These categories and

activities intend an educational or cultural purpose.

Thus, the Agency laid to rest the question of whether it possessed

sufficient statutory authority to continue Summer Travel/Work programs

as currently configured. Having determined that it did in fact lack

such authority, the Agency turned its attention to an examination of

the policy and public diplomacy aspects underlying these activities.

Policy Considerations

Summer Travel/Work programs have been designated by the Agency for

over twenty five years. When these programs began, a strict reciprocal

element mandated that the number of United States students outbound

from the United States approximate the number of foreign students

inbound. Annual consultations with the program's sponsoring

organizations were held and the number of participants for that year

established. An additional requirement limited participation to foreign

students lacking sufficient funds to enter the United States as

tourists. Periodic reminders of this underlying policy were also

transmitted to sponsoring organizations. The policy underlying these

two requirements attempted to (i) ensure no adverse domestic labor

market impact resulted from the activity; and (2) that only those

persons otherwise financially unable to visit the United States would

benefit from this opportunity.

These original policy objectives have been seriously eroded with

the passage of time. Exchange programs facilitated under the auspices

of the Fulbright-Hays Act must, as a matter of policy and law, have an

underlying educational or cultural programmatic component which

promotes the Act's raison d'etre of mutual understanding. Critics

generally suggest that Summer Travel/Work programs do not possess an

educational or cultural exchange component even when such terms are

given their broadest of interpretations. Conversely, advocates of these

programs suggest that ``experiential'' learning, whereby the

participant gains insight into the American lifestyle and culture

through travel and employment, does in fact fulfill the expected

programmatic educational or cultural component.

The Agency's interpretation of what is an acceptable educational or

cultural programmatic component is often quite broad. However, the

Agency has determined that it is unable to adopt the concept of

``experiential'' learning as sufficient legal justification, in and of

itself, for an exchange activity under the Fulbright-Hays Act. To do

so, would suggest that any time an alien enters the country as a

visitor for business or pleasure or as a temporary worker, an

educational or cultural exchange occurs.

In light of this determination, and pursuant to the discussion set

forth below, the Agency is willing, in general, to accept,

``experiential'' programs that otherwise incorporate those programmatic

components common to all other exchange activities designated by the

Agency.

The Components of Exchange

Since 1990, the Agency has engaged in an on-going review of the

policy and public diplomacy considerations underpinning exchange

activities. This review has proven useful in responding participants

have agreed to abide by these guidelines in the absence of program

specific regulations.

Because the remaining Summer Travel/Work sponsor does not operate

its program in the manner that the Agency has determined would meet all

threshold statutory requirements, the Agency is unable to allow this

program to expand in size or scope. Thus, this sponsor will continue to

be limited to the numerical program size at which it operated when

statutory deficiencies were identified in February of 1990. In similar

fashion, this sponsor will also be

limited to recruitment in only those countries in which it was

operating Summer Travel/Work programs in 1990.

The Agency has agreed to permit the continued operation of this

program under these terms notwithstanding its determination that such a

program design continues to suffer certain statutory deficiencies. As

agreed with the sponsor, the Agency will allow a two year period of

continued study of this matter for the purpose of addressing the policy

considerations arising from possible adverse domestic labor market

impact due to the lack of preplacement. The Agency will seek the advice

and counsel of the U.S. Department of Labor regarding labor market

considerations and will continue this additional period of review until

March 1, 1998.

List of Subjects in 22 CFR Part 514

Cultural exchange programs.

Dated: March 22, 1996.

Les Jin,

General Counsel.

Guidelines for Summer Work/travel Programs

In lieu of specific programmatic regulations governing the

administration of Agency-designated Summer Travel/Work programs, the

guidelines set forth below are hereby adopted by the Agency and

shall be binding upon all newly designated programs and the existing

Summer Travel/Work programs operated by the American Institute for

Foreign Study, YMCA InterExchange, and Camp Counselors USA. These

guidelines may be amended by the Agency at any time and shall remain

in full force and effect until rescinded or Superseded by duly

promulgated regulations.

(a) Introduction. These guidelines shall apply to the above

described program sponsors and their administration of exchange visitor

programs under which foreign university students are afforded the

opportunity to travel and pursue employment in the United States for a

four month period corresponding with their summer vacation.

(b) Participant Selection and Screening. In addition to satisfying

the requirements set forth at Sec. 514.10(a), sponsors shall adequately

screen all program participants and at a minimum:

(1) Conduct an in person interview; and

(2) Ensure that the participant is a bona fide post-secondary

school student is his or her home country; and

(3) Ensure that not more than ten percent of selected participants

have previously participated in a summer travel/work program.

(c) Participant Orientation. Sponsors shall provide participants

prior to their departure from the home country information regarding:

(1) The name and location of their employer; and

(2) Any contractual obligations related to their acceptance of paid

employment in the United States.

(d) Participant Placements. Sponsors shall not facilitate the entry

into the United States of any program participant for whom an

employment position has not been arranged.

(e) Participant Compensation. Sponsors shall ensure that program

participants receive pay and benefits commensurate with those offered

to their American counterparts.

(f) Monitoring. Sponsors shall provide:

(1) All participants with a telephone number which allows 24 hour

immediate contact with the sponsor; and

(2) Appropriate assistance to program participants on an as needed

emergency basis.

(g) Placement report. In lieu of listing the name and address of

the participant's pre-arranged employer on the form IAP-66 sponsors

shall submit to the Agency a report of all participant placements. Such

report shall reflect the participant's name, place of employment, and

the number of times the participant has previously participated in any

summer travel/work program. Such report shall be submitted semi-

annually on January 30th and July 30th of each year and shall reflect

placements made in the preceding six month period.

(h) Unauthorized activities. Placement as domestic employees in

United States households is expressly prohibited.

[FR Doc. 96-7592 Filed 3-27-96; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 8230-01-M

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Exchange Visitor Program · 61 FR 13760 | Frix