No-action relief granted to an entity from CPO registration with respect to a commodity pool for which it serves as trustee; provided, that it delegates the CPO responsibilities to a registered CPO, subject to certain...

Summary: No-action relief granted to an entity from CPO registration with respect to a commodity pool for which it serves as trustee; provided, that it delegates the CPO responsibilities to a registered CPO, subject to certain conditions.

Division of Swap Dealer and

Matthew Kulkin

Intermediary Oversight

Director

U.S. COMMODITY FUTURES TRADING COMMISSION

Three Lafayette Centre

1155 21st Street, NW, Washington, DC 20581

Telephone: (202) 418-6700

Facsimile: (202) 418-5528

mkulkin@cftc.gov

CFTC Letter No. 18-16

No-Action

March 30, 2018

Division of Swap Dealer and Intermediary Oversight

RE:

Request for No-Action Relief from the Requirement to Register as a Commodity

Pool Operator under Section 4m(1) of the Commodity Exchange Act

Dear :

This is in response to your letter dated November 22, 2017, to the Division of Swap

Dealer and Intermediary Oversight (“Division”) of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission

(“Commission”). In the letter, you request on behalf of “A” relief from the requirement to

register with the Commission as a commodity pool operator (“CPO”) under section 4m(1) of the

Commodity Exchange Act (“CEA” or “Act”),1 in connection with its role as trustee of the “B”

(the “Pool”). Instead, you state that “A” will delegate certain of its responsibilities as the CPO of

the Pool to “C”, pursuant to the applicable requirements of CFTC Staff Letter No. 14-126

(“Letter 14-126”),2 except for criterion 6 therein.

Background

On May 12, 2014, the Division issued CFTC Staff Letter No. 14-69 (“Letter 14-69”),3

which was in response to numerous requests asking that the Division provide no-action relief for

failure to register as a CPO under section 4m(1) of the Act, if another person would serve as the

registered CPO of the commodity pool at issue in lieu of the requesting CPO

or criterion 6 therein.

Background

On May 12, 2014, the Division issued CFTC Staff Letter No. 14-69 (“Letter 14-69”),3

which was in response to numerous requests asking that the Division provide no-action relief for

failure to register as a CPO under section 4m(1) of the Act, if another person would serve as the

registered CPO of the commodity pool at issue in lieu of the requesting CPO. Letter 14-69

developed a standardized, streamlined approach pursuant to which the Division addressed these

types of relief requests, and set forth certain requirements that were based on prior staff no-action

letters.

1 7 U.S.C. 6m(1). The Act is found at 7 U.S.C. 1 et seq. (2016). It, and the Commission’s regulations, may be

accessed through the Commission’s website, http://www.cftc.gov.

2 CFTC Staff Letter No. 14-126 (Oct. 15, 2014), available at

http://www.cftc.gov/idc/groups/public/%40lrlettergeneral/documents/letter/14-126.pdf (last retrieved Mar. 20,

2018). This and the other Commission staff letters referenced herein are also available on the Commission’s

website, http://www.cftc.gov.

3 CFTC Staff Letter No. 14-69 (May 12, 2014), available at

http://www.cftc.gov/idc/groups/public/@lrlettergeneral/documents/letter/14-69.pdf (last retrieved Mar. 20, 2018).

RE: “A” and “C” Delegation

Page 2

March 30, 2018

2

On October 15, 2014, the Division issued Letter 14-126, which was a further refinement

of the relief addressed in Letter 14-69. Like Letter 14-69, Letter 14-126 provided no-action

relief for failure to register as a CPO under CEA Section 4m(1), if another person would serve as

the registered CPO of the commodity pool at issue in lieu of the requesting CPO. The

circumstances and conditions for relief under Letter 14-126 were, in purpose and effect, the same

as those set forth in Letter 14-69, with the exception of certain added clarifications

r 14-126 provided no-action

relief for failure to register as a CPO under CEA Section 4m(1), if another person would serve as

the registered CPO of the commodity pool at issue in lieu of the requesting CPO. The

circumstances and conditions for relief under Letter 14-126 were, in purpose and effect, the same

as those set forth in Letter 14-69, with the exception of certain added clarifications. One of those

conditions was that, if the Delegating CPO4 and the Designated CPO5 are each a non-natural

person, then one such CPO controls, is controlled by, or is under common control with the other

CPO. The relief provided by letter 14-126 was self-executing, and no notice or claim needed to

be filed, in order to, in part, ease the administrative burdens of Letter 14-69 on the Division. In

issuing Letter 14-126, the Division noted that there may be other CPO delegation situations

involving circumstances in which CPO registration no-action relief may be warranted that are

not addressed by Letter 14-126, and indicated that it intends to continue to evaluate requests

submitted pursuant to Commission Regulation 140.996 for CPO registration no-action relief from

persons who fall outside the scope of Letter 14-126.7

Requested Relief and Legal Analysis

Based on the representations made in your letters and other email and telephone

correspondence (the “Correspondence”), we understand the facts to be as follows. “C”, the

Designated CPO, has its principal place of business in the State of New York, is organized as a

Delaware limited liability company, and is subject to U.S. federal and state regulation. “C” is

registered with the Commission both as a CPO and commodity trading advisor (“CTA”), since

2013 and 2004, respectively, and is also a National Futures Association member in those

capacities

ws. “C”, the

Designated CPO, has its principal place of business in the State of New York, is organized as a

Delaware limited liability company, and is subject to U.S. federal and state regulation. “C” is

registered with the Commission both as a CPO and commodity trading advisor (“CTA”), since

2013 and 2004, respectively, and is also a National Futures Association member in those

capacities. “C” is also registered as an investment adviser with the Securities and Exchange

Commission (“SEC”), pursuant to the Investment Advisers Act of 1940, and is considered a

large advisory firm with approximately US$ regulatory assets under management.8 While the

operations of the Designated CPO, “C”, are largely based in the United States, “C” is an affiliate

of “D” and is part of the global “E”, a large full service global financial institution with total

assets of approximately US$, as of September 30, 2017. Consequently, “C’s” books and records

are maintained in the U.S., as well as the Cayman Islands.

4 This term is defined in Letter 14-126.

5 Id.

6 17 CFR 140.99.

7 Letter 14-126, p. 2. The Division indicated the same following the issuance of Letter 14-69 as well.

8 “C”, Form ADV Filing (Mar. 31, 2017).

RE: “A” and “C” Delegation

Page 3

March 30, 2018

3

The Pool is organized as a Cayman Islands unit trust, and “A”, the Delegating CPO, is a

Cayman Islands exempted company, which, by virtue of its license as a trust company under the

Cayman Islands Trusts Law, serves as the sole trustee to the Pool

ollowing the issuance of Letter 14-69 as well.

8 “C”, Form ADV Filing (Mar. 31, 2017).

RE: “A” and “C” Delegation

Page 3

March 30, 2018

3

The Pool is organized as a Cayman Islands unit trust, and “A”, the Delegating CPO, is a

Cayman Islands exempted company, which, by virtue of its license as a trust company under the

Cayman Islands Trusts Law, serves as the sole trustee to the Pool.

In addition, you state that “A” and “C” satisfy all of the applicable criteria in Letter 14-

126, except for criterion 6 therein, which states that, “[i]f the Delegating CPO and the

Designated CPO are each a non-natural person, then one such CPO controls, is controlled by, or

is under common control with the other CPO.” In particular, you represent the following:

• Pursuant to a legally binding document, “A” has delegated to “C” all of its CPO rights

and obligations with respect to the Pool.

• “A”, including any of its employees or other persons acting on their behalf, does not

participate, and has never participated, in the solicitation of participants for the Pool.

• “A”, including any of their employees or other persons acting on their behalf, does not

manage, and has never managed, any property of the Pool beyond that which is required

for the fulfillment of its role as a trustee to the Pool.

• “A” is not a subject to statutory disqualification under section 8a(2) or 8a(3) of the Act.

• There is a business purpose for “C” being a separate entity from “A” that is not solely to

avoid CPO registration by “A” under the Act and the Commission’s regulations.

• The books and records of “A” with respect to the Pool are maintained by “C” in

accordance with Commission Regulation 1.31.9

• “A” has executed legally binding documents with “C”, whereby each entity undertakes to

be jointly and severally liable for any violation of the Act or the Commission’s

regulations by the other in connection with the operation of the Pool

Commission’s regulations.

• The books and records of “A” with respect to the Pool are maintained by “C” in

accordance with Commission Regulation 1.31.9

• “A” has executed legally binding documents with “C”, whereby each entity undertakes to

be jointly and severally liable for any violation of the Act or the Commission’s

regulations by the other in connection with the operation of the Pool.

As noted above, although “A” and “C” are not under common control and neither “C” nor “A”

controls the other, they will remain jointly and severally liable for any violations of the Act or

Commission regulations related to operating the Pool. Further, the entity to which “A” has

delegated, “C”, has itself been registered as a CPO and CTA for four and thirteen years,

respectively, is an affiliate of “E”, and will maintain all books and records related to the Pool in

accordance with Commission Regulation 1.31. The Division believes that under these

circumstances, granting no-action relief permitting the delegation of CPO duties and

9 17 CFR 1.31.

RE: “A” and “C” Delegation

Page 4

March 30, 2018

4

responsibilities for the Pool to “C” is appropriate, notwithstanding that “A” and “C” do not

qualify for relief under Letter 14-126.

Relief Granted

Based upon the representations made in the Correspondence, the Division will not

recommend that the Commission commence any enforcement action against “A” for failure to

register as a CPO under CEA Section 4m(1) in connection with its role with respect to the Pool.

This position is subject to and taken in reliance on all of the representations you have made in

connection with your relief request.

The relief issued by this letter does not excuse persons relying on it from compliance

with any other applicable requirements contained in the Act or in the Commission regulations

issued thereunder

1) in connection with its role with respect to the Pool.

This position is subject to and taken in reliance on all of the representations you have made in

connection with your relief request.

The relief issued by this letter does not excuse persons relying on it from compliance

with any other applicable requirements contained in the Act or in the Commission regulations

issued thereunder. Further, this letter, the relief contained herein, is based upon the

representations made to the Division. Any different, changed, or omitted material facts or

circumstances might render this letter void. The Division retains the authority to condition

further, modify, suspend, terminate, or otherwise restrict the terms of the relief provided herein

in its discretion. Finally, this letter and the position taken herein represent the views of this

Division only, and do not necessarily represent the views of the Commission or of any other

office or division of the Commission.

If you have any questions regarding this letter, please contact Amanda Olear, Associate

Director, at 202-418-5283 or aolear@cftc.gov, or Elizabeth Groover, Special Counsel, at 202-

418-5985 or egroover@cftc.gov.

Very truly yours,

Matthew Kulkin

Director

Division of Swap Dealer and

Intermediary Oversight

RE: “A” and “C” Delegation

Page 5

March 30, 2018

5

Appendix A: Delegated Commodity Pools

“B” (NFA Pool ID #)