TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND
Tribal code
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
WAGANAKISING
ODAWA
TRIBAL CODE of LAW
TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND
EDUCATION
2024.2
WAGANAKISING ODAWA TRIBAL CODE of LAW
TABLE OF CONTENTS
TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS, AND EDUCATION....................................................... 1
Chapter 1. Health Commission................................................................................................... 1
11.101
FINDING ............................................................................................................... 1
11.102
REPEALED ........................................................................................................... 1
11.103
EFFECTIVE DATE.............................................................................................. 1
Chapter 2. Education Appeals Board (Repealed) ..................................................................... 2
11.201
PURPOSE .............................................................................................................. 2
11.202
FINDINGS ............................................................................................................. 2
11.203
REPEAL ................................................................................................................ 2
11.204
EFFECTIVE DATE.............................................................................................. 2
Chapter 3. Michelle Chingwa Education Honorarium Act ..................................................... 4
11.301
PURPOSE .............................................................................................................. 4
11.302
GENERAL WELFARE EXCLUSION ............................................................... 4
11.303
DEFINITIONS ...................................................................................................... 4
11.303
APPLICATION..................................................................................................... 6
11.304
RESTRICTIONS .................................................................................................. 9
11.305
REGULATIONS REQUIRED ............................................................................ 9
11.306
APPROPRIATIONS AUTHORIZED .............................................................. 10
11.307
SEVERABILITY ................................................................................................ 10
11.308
EFFECTIVE DATE............................................................................................ 11
Chapter 4. Aanjigin Honorarium Program Act...................................................................... 12
11.401
11.402
11.403
11.404
11.405
11.406
11.407
11.408
11.409
PURPOSE ............................................................................................................ 12
GENERAL WELFARE EXCLUSION ............................................................. 12
DEFINITIONS .................................................................................................... 12
AANJIGIN HONORARIUM PROGRAM....................................................... 13
ELIGIBLE COST ............................................................................................... 15
RESTRICTIONS ................................................................................................ 15
REGULATIONS REQUIRED .......................................................................... 16
APPROPRIATIONS AUTHORIZED .............................................................. 17
SEVERABILITY ................................................................................................ 17
i
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
11.410
EFFECTIVE DATE............................................................................................ 17
Chapter 5. Reserved.................................................................................................................... 19
Chapter 6. Food Safety Act ....................................................................................................... 20
11.601
PURPOSE ............................................................................................................ 20
11.602
DEFINITIONS .................................................................................................... 20
11.603
APPLICATION................................................................................................... 20
11.604
RESTRICTIONS ................................................................................................ 21
11.605
REGULTIONS REQUIRED ............................................................................. 21
11.606
PROCEDURES REQUIRED ............................................................................ 22
11.607
APPROPRIATIONS AUTHORIZED .............................................................. 22
11.608
EXECUTIVE AUTHORITY ............................................................................. 22
11.609
SEVERABILITY ................................................................................................ 22
11.610
EFFECTIVE DATE............................................................................................ 23
Chapter 7. Shirley Naganashe Oldman Secondary Education Completion Honorarium ......
...................................................................................................................................... 24
11.701
PURPOSE ............................................................................................................ 24
11.702
GENERAL WELFARE EXCLUSION ............................................................. 24
11.703
DEFINITIONS .................................................................................................... 24
11.704
APPLICATION................................................................................................... 25
11.705
REGULATIONS REQUIRED .......................................................................... 25
11.706
APPROPRIATIONS AUTHORIZED .............................................................. 26
11.707
SEVERABILITY ................................................................................................ 26
11.708
EFFECTIVE DATE............................................................................................ 26
Chapter 8. Right to Breastfeed and Civil Offense for Discrimination .................................. 28
11.801
PURPOSE ............................................................................................................ 28
11.802
RIGHT TO BREASTFEED ............................................................................... 28
11.803
SEVERABILITY ................................................................................................ 29
11.804
EFFECTIVE DATE ............................................................................................ 29
Chapter 9. Vulnerable Elder and Adult or Incapacitated Adult Protection, Guardianship
and Conservatorship Statute ......................................................................................... 30
11.901
PURPOSE ............................................................................................................ 30
11.902
DEFINITIONS .................................................................................................... 30
11.903
AUTHORITY ...................................................................................................... 33
11.905
JURISDICTION ................................................................................................. 34
ii
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
11.905
11.906
11.907
11.908
11.909
11.910
11.911
11.912
11.913
11.914
11.915
11.916
11.917
11.918
11.919
11.920
11.921
11.922
11.923
11.924
DUTY TO REPORT ........................................................................................... 35
IMMUNITY FOR REPORTING ...................................................................... 36
CONFIDENTIALITY OF REPORTER and RECORDS .............................. 36
FAILURE TO REPORT; CIVIL PENALTY .................................................. 36
RETALIATION; CIVIL PENALTY ................................................................ 37
FALSE REPORT ................................................................................................ 37
HUMAN SERVICES DEPARTMENT DUTIES, RESPONSIBILITIES and
AUTHORITY ...................................................................................................... 37
LAW ENFORCEMENT DUTIES AND RESPONSIBILITIES .................... 39
PROSECUTOR’S DUTIES AND RESPONSIBILITIES ............................... 40
PETITIONS AND EMERGENCY ORDERS .................................................. 40
EMERGENCY PLACEMENT.......................................................................... 41
PETITIONS AND NON-EMERGENCY PROTECTION ORDER .............. 42
PETITION FOR FINDING OF VULNERABILITY ELDER OR ADULT as
INCAPACITATED and APPOINTMENT OF GUARDIAN OR
CONSERVATOR ............................................................................................... 43
COURT COSTS AND FEES ............................................................................. 49
ADDITIONAL REPORTING REQUIRMENTS OF GUARDIAN AND/OR
CONSERVATOR ............................................................................................... 49
RIGHTS OF VULNERABLE ELDER AND ADULT, OR
INCAPACITATED ADULT .............................................................................. 50
RESTORATION TO CAPACITY PROCEDURES ....................................... 51
TERMINATION OF GUARDIANSHIP AND CONSERVATORSHIP ....... 52
SAVING CLAUSE .............................................................................................. 52
EFFECTIVE DATE ............................................................................................ 52
Chapter 10. Fair Treatment for Benefits and Services .......................................................... 54
11.1001
PURPOSE ............................................................................................................ 54
11.1002
DEFINITIONS .................................................................................................... 54
11.1003
FAIR TREATMENT and DISCRIMINATION .............................................. 55
11.1004
TRIBAL COURT ................................................................................................ 56
11.1005
LIMITED WAIVER OF SOVEREIGN IMMUNITY .................................... 56
11.1006
REMEDIES AND DAMAGES .......................................................................... 56
11.1007
SAVINGS CLAUSE............................................................................................ 57
11.1008
EFFECTIVE DATE............................................................................................ 58
iii
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
Chapter 12. Naawchigedaa Tort Claims.................................................................................. 59
11.1101
SHORT TITLE ................................................................................................... 59
11.1102
PURPOSE ............................................................................................................ 59
11.1103
JURISDICTION ................................................................................................. 59
11.1104
DEFINITIONS .................................................................................................... 59
11.1105
STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS ......................................................................... 61
11.1106
CAUSES OF ACTION ....................................................................................... 61
11.1107
DEFENSES .......................................................................................................... 69
11.1108
REMEDIES ......................................................................................................... 72
11.1109
SAVINGS CLAUSE............................................................................................ 73
11.1110
EFFECTIVE DATE............................................................................................ 73
Chapter 12. General Welfare .................................................................................................... 74
11.1201
SHORT STATUTE ............................................................................................. 74
11.1202
PURPOSE ............................................................................................................ 74
11.1203
DEFINITIONS .................................................................................................... 75
11.1204
RATIFICATION OF PRIOR ACTS; INTENT OF LEGISLATION ........... 78
11.1205
GENERAL WELFARE DOCTRINE AND IRS REVENUE PROCEDURE
2014-35/TRIBAL GENERAL WELFARE EXCLUSION OF 2014 .............. 78
11.1206
NON-RESOURCE DESIGNATION................................................................. 79
11.1207
GOVERNING LAW; SOVEREIGNTY ........................................................... 80
11.1208
FEDERAL TRUST OBLIGATIONS................................................................ 80
11.1209
TRIBAL COUNCIL APPROVED PROGRAMS ............................................ 80
11.1210
PURPOSE OF APPROVED PROGRAMS ...................................................... 81
11.1211
ELIGIBILITY AND APPLICATION PROCEDURES .................................. 81
11.1212
LIMITED USE OF ASSISTANCE PAYMENTS ............................................ 81
11.1213
11.1215
11.1216
11.1217
11.1218
11.1219
11.1220
11.1221
11.1222
PROGRAMS NOT LIMITED TO MEANS TESTING .................................. 82
ANNUAL BUDGETING: UNFUNDED PROGRAM ..................................... 82
FORFEITURE .................................................................................................... 83
ANTI-ALIENATION ......................................................................................... 83
GENERAL ........................................................................................................... 83
PROGRAM POLICIES ..................................................................................... 84
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT TRIBAL ADVISORY COMMITEE .............. 89
SEVERABILITY ................................................................................................ 89
EFFECTIVE DATE............................................................................................ 90
iv
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
11.1223
OTHER RELATED STATUTES ...................................................................... 90
Chapter 13. Waiver of Fees for Military Veterans Statute .................................................... 91
11.1301
PURPOSE ............................................................................................................ 91
11.1302
GENERAL WELFARE EXCLUSION ............................................................. 91
11.1303
DEFINITIONS .................................................................................................... 91
11.1304
WAIVER OF FEES ............................................................................................ 92
11.1305
REPORTING REQUIRED ................................................................................ 92
11.1306
SEVERABILITY ................................................................................................ 93
11.1307
EFFECTIVE DATE............................................................................................ 93
Chapter 14. Medicare Reimbursement Honorarium Act ...................................................... 94
11.1401
PURPOSE ............................................................................................................ 94
11.1402
GENERAL WELFARE EXCLUSION ............................................................. 94
11.1403
DEFINITIONS .................................................................................................... 94
11.1404
MEDICARE REIMBURSEMENT HONORARIUM PROGRAM ............... 95
11.1405
REGULATIONS REQUIRED .......................................................................... 95
11.1406
APPROPRIATIONS AUTHORIZED .............................................................. 96
11.1407
SEVERABILITY ................................................................................................ 96
11.1408
EFFECTIVE DATE............................................................................................ 97
v
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS, AND EDUCATION
Chapter 1. Health Commission
11.101 FINDING
The Duties of the original Commission are no longer applicable as those duties are now the
responsibility of the Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians Health Department funded by
I.H.S. General Funds and Third Party billing. The department’s rules, policies, and regulations
are provided by the I.H.S. funding source.
(Source: WOS 2009-003, January 25, 2009, Section I)
11.102 REPEALED
WAGANAKISING ODAWA STATUTE 1997-004 is hereby repealed in its entirety.
(Source: WOS 2009-003, January 25, 2009, Section II)
11.103 EFFECTIVE DATE
Effective upon the signature of the Executive, or 30 days from Tribal Council approval, or if the
Executive vetoes the legislation, then upon Tribal Council override of the veto.
(Source: WOS 2009-003, January 25, 2009, Section III)
1
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
Chapter 2. Education Appeals Board (Repealed)
11.201 PURPOSE
The purpose of this statute is to repeal the Education Appeals Board Statute, Waganakising
Odawak Statute 2009-011.
(Source: WOS 2023-021, December 1, 2023, Section I)
11.202 FINDINGS
The Education Appeals Board was established to conduct hearings for appeals of programs
administered by the Education Department such as the Higher Education Scholarship Program,
Adult Vocational Training Scholarship Program and Direct Employment Program. Due to the
enactment of the Michelle Chingwa Education Honorarium Act, Waganakising Odawak Statute
2020-003, appeals of Higher Education Scholarship decisions are now heard directly by the
Education Department. The Education Department’s Vocational and Direct Employment
Programs no longer exist in a form involving appeals. As the Education Appeals Board no
longer serves the purposes for which it was established, the Education Appeals Board Statute
should be repealed.
(Source: WOS 2023-021, December 1, 2023, Section II)
11.203 REPEAL
The Education Appeals Board Statute, Waganakising Odawak Statute 2009-011, is hereby
repealed.
(Source: WOS 2023-021, December 1, 2023, Section III)
11.204 EFFECTIVE DATE
Effective upon signature of the Executive or 30 days from Tribal Council approval, whichever
2
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
comes first, or if the Executive vetoes the legislation, then upon Tribal Council override of the
veto.
(Source: WOS 2023-021, December 1, 2023, Section IV)
3
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
Chapter 3. Michelle Chingwa Education Honorarium Act
11.301 PURPOSE
This Michelle Chingwa Education Honorarium Act is hereby enacted to provide a gift to
honor Tribal Citizens that are obtaining post-secondary educational opportunities and repeals and
replaces the original and amended Michelle Chingwa Education Assistance Act including WOS
2007-005, WOS 2014-010 and WOS 2018-010.
(Source: WOS 2020-003, January 28, 2020, Section I)
11.302 GENERAL WELFARE EXCLUSION
As stated by the requirements of the United States Internal Revenue Section 139E, the Michelle
Chingwa Education Honorarium meets the criteria of the United States Public Law 113-168,
Tribal General Welfare Exclusion Act of 2014 and WOS 2017-002 General Welfare Statute.
(Source: WOS 2020-003, January 28, 2020, Section II)
11.303 DEFINITIONS
A.
“Accredited” shall apply to those post-secondary institutions of higher education,
including vocational schools, that are accredited by an agency or organization recognized
by either a domestic or foreign government or another accrediting agency that processes
validations for colleges, universities, and other institutions of higher learning.
B.
“Citizen” shall mean an enrolled member of the Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa
Indians.
4
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
C.
“Department” shall mean the Niigandiwin Education Department that is overseen by the
Executive Branch.
D.
“Executive” shall means the Tribal Chairperson or his/her designee.
E.
“Executive Directive” in accordance with the WOS 2015-19, means a directive issued by
the Tribal Chairperson that establishes basic internal rules of procedure, or guidelines for
the Executive Department and employees and does not impact Tribal Citizens or entities
outside of the Executive Branch.
F.
“GPA” shall mean a student’s Grade Point Average reported by an institution on a
student’s transcript for the academic term.
G.
“LTBB” shall mean The Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians.
H.
“MCEH” shall mean the Michelle Chingwa Education Honorarium Program.
I.
“Release of the Information Form” shall mean a form completed by the student and
provided by the LTBB Education Department that gives permission to the department for
3rd party communication with the institution.
J.
“Student Success Plan” shall mean a plan that is designed for the student by the
Education Department that addresses financial and/or academic goals of the student
ensure student success.
K.
“Student Success Planning Session” shall mean a meeting facilitated by the Higher
Education Specialist, the Academic Services Coordinator, and/or the Education Director
with the student which is intended to develop a plan which addresses financial and/or
academic goals and connect them to the appropriate supports and resources that are
available.
5
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
L.
“Tribe” or “LTBB” shall mean the Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians.
(Source: WOS 2020-003, January 28, 2020, Section II)
11.303 APPLICATION
A.
The program shall be administered by the Education Department.
B.
Honorariums shall be paid directly to the student.
C.
The program shall fund Honorariums to Tribal Citizens attending:
D.
1.
Accredited post-secondary institutions of higher education located within a Tribal
Reservation, the United States or a foreign country;
2.
Tribally controlled colleges that are seeking accreditation;
3.
Other colleges or programs approved by Tribal Resolution.
Honorariums shall be administered in the following manner:
1.
Deadlines are established as follows:
a.
Fall, October 15th
b.
Winter/Spring, February 15th
c.
Summer, June 15th
d.
Deadlines for trimesters, quarters or non-standard terms shall be thirty
(30) days after the beginning of the session. “Non-standard Term” shall
6
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
mean a course term that is not considered to be a semester, trimester or
quarter as defined by the United States Department of Education.
e.
Deadlines for accelerated courses that fall within a standard term but
begin after the term begins shall be thirty (30) days after the beginning of
the session.
2.
The Honorariums shall be granted up to the deadline for each semester, trimester,
quarter, non-standard term, or accelerated course.
3.
Honorarium applications submitted after the deadlines shall be classified as late.
Late applications shall not be funded, but such late applications may be petitioned
to the Education Department for further review.
4.
The Honorariums shall be calculated on a per credit hour basis with five (5)
classifications: (Credits at foreign accredited post-secondary institutions of higher
education, colleges and universities shall be calculated using the appropriate
United States credit equivalency rate).
a.
Classifications:
i.
Class one (1) are prior learning credit courses or courses that are
sponsored by Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians and
provided nearly free or minimal cost to the student.
ii.
Class two (2) are Junior or community college classes.
iii.
Class three (3) are Four-year colleges or four-year degree program
classes.
iv.
Class four (4) are Graduate level courses.
v.
Class five (5) are free courses such as the free online courses.
7
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
b.
E.
The limit and level of each Honorarium classification shall be:
i.
Set by the Executive Directive.
ii.
Credit limits should not exceed eighteen (18) credits per semester
for undergraduate courses (1,2,3, 5) or twelve (12) credits per
semester for graduate courses (class 4).
iii.
Honorarium levels for Class 1 shall assist with the cost of program
expenses plus smaller amount to cover other student expenses (i.e.
$25 per credit hour to cover travel, meals, etc.).
iv.
Honorarium levels for Class 2, 3, 4 respectively shall follow a
general ratio of 2/3/4 (i.e. Class 2, $150, Class 3, $250, Class 4,
$350) and should be raised or lowered to accommodate the budget
but an attemp should be made to keep the levels as consistent as
possible to help students plan from semester to semester.
v.
Honorarium levels for Class 5 shall be limited to a small per credit
hour amount to cover miscellaneous expense (i.e. $15 per credit to
cover books, material, etc.).
vi.
Students enrolled in multiple level of classes, the Honorarium shall
be awarded at the appropriate level for each course or class.
To be eligible for an Honorarium the student must:
1.
Be an enrolled Citizen of the Tribe;
2.
Be enrolled in an educational institution or program as delineated in Section III,
(C).
8
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
3.
Maintain a 2.0 GPA during the course of an academic term (subject to petition).
(Source: WOS 2020-003, January 28, 2020, Section III)
11.304 RESTRICTIONS
A.
If a student withdraws from a course, their next Honorarium shall be reduced by that
equivalent amount, unless otherwise petitioned.
B.
Students will not be funded for a course more than twice unless the student can prove
they need to take the class over to complete a degree requirement but shall be limited to three (3)
times.
(Source: WOS 2020-003, January 28, 2020, Section IV)
11.305 REGULATIONS REQUIRED
A.
The Department shall develop regulations for this statute for Tribal Council approval;
however, the implementation of the statute shall not be delayed by approval of regulations.
B.
The regulations shall define any petition process. Petitions authorized by this statute shall
be heard by the Education Department.
C.
The regulations shall require the following minimum reports to Tribal Council, and upon
request to other Tribal sub-entity:
1.
Three (3) summary reports for each semester’s Honorariums in March, July, and
October and a year-end summary each January for all the previous year’s Honorariums.
9
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
2.
Each report shall contain at a minimum:
a.
A list of names of Honorarium recipients, the type of degree sought or
earned and most recent contact information.
b.
Number of students in each class of Honorariums
c.
Number of semester credits in each class of Honorariums
d.
Total dollar amount of Honorariums for each period and the year
e.
Present Honorarium rates and predicted rates needed to meet budget for
the next cycle
D.
Publication required. The Department shall publish the award levels for the next
Honorarium cycle in November, April, and June of each year.
(Source: WOS 2020-003, January 28, 2020, Section V)
11.306 APPROPRIATIONS AUTHORIZED
This Education Honorarium Act shall be included in the Executive budget and funded
annually with a minimum budget of one million ($1,000,000.00) dollars per fiscal year.
(Source: WOS 2020-003, January 28, 2020, Section VI)
11.307 SEVERABILITY
If any section, subsection, paragraph, sentence, phrase or portion of this Statute is, for any
reason, held invalid or unconstitutional by any court of competent jurisdiction, such portion shall
10
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
be deemed a separate, distinct and independent provision and such holding shall not affect the
validity of the remaining portions thereof.
(Source: WOS 2020-003, January 28, 2020, Section VII)
11.308 EFFECTIVE DATE
Effective upon signature of the Executive or thirty (30) days from Tribal Council approval
whichever comes first or if the Executive vetoes the legislation, then upon Tribal Council
override of the veto.
(Source: WOS 2020-003, January 28, 2020, Section VIII)
11
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
Chapter 4. Aanjigin Honorarium Program Act
11.401 PURPOSE
The Aanjigin (Continuous Growth) Honorarium Program Act is hereby enacted to provide a gift
to honor Tribal Citizens that are pursuing vocational education opportunities.
(Source: WOS 2021-010, July 7, 2021, Section I)
11.402 GENERAL WELFARE EXCLUSION
As stated by the requirements of the United States Internal Revenue Section 139E, the Aanjigin
Honorarium Program meets the criteria of the United States Public Law 113-168, Tribal General
Welfare Exclusion Act of 2014 and WOS 2017-002 General Welfare Statute.
(Source: WOS 2021-010, July 7, 2021, Section II)
11.403 DEFINITIONS
A.
“Citizen” shall mean an enrolled member of the Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa
Indians.
B.
“Department” shall mean the Niigaandiwin Education Department that is overseen by the
Executive Branch.
C.
“Executive” shall means the Tribal Chairperson or his/her designee
D.
“Individualized Employment Plan (IEP)” shall mean a plan that is designed for the
student by the Education Department that addresses financial and/or career goals of the student
ensure student success.
12
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
E.
“Individualized Employment Planning Session” shall mean a meeting facilitated by the
Department with the student which is intended to develop a plan which addresses the following
goals and connect them to the appropriate supports and resources that are available:
1.
Short- & long-term employment/career goals;
2.
Skills needed to achieve employment goals;
3.
Barriers to achieving employment goals;
4.
Action steps to overcome barriers & develop skills needed to achieve employment
goals.
F.
“Industry recognized credentials” means knowledge and skill that are sought or accepted
by employers within the industry or sector.
G.
“LTBB” mean The Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians.
H.
“Program” means the Aanjigin Honorarium Program.
I.
“Release of the Information Form” shall mean a form completed by the student and
provided by the LTBB Education Department that gives permission to the department for 3rd
party communication with the institution.
J.
“Tribe” or “LTBB” mean the Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians.
K.
“Vocational Training” means training that emphasizes skills and knowledge required for
a particular job function or a trade.
(Source: WOS 2021-010, July 7, 2021, Section III)
11.404 AANJIGIN HONORARIUM PROGRAM
A.
The program will be administered by the Niigaandiwin Education Department within the
Executive Branch.
13
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
B.
To be eligible for an Honorarium the student must:
1.
Be an enrolled Citizen of the Tribe;
2.
Be enrolled in an institution that provides Technical and Vocational; Education
and Training (TVET); or participating in a program that provides Industry recognized
credentials;
3.
Attend one or more “Individualized Employment Planning Session”;
4.
Obtain a “Individualized Employment Plan” from the Department;
5.
Make satisfactory progress as determined by the respective institution or program
during the course of the training. (subject to petition).
C.
The Aanjigin Honorarium Program is a funding of last resort, and student must exhaust
other program funding before being eligible for the Aanjigin Honorarium Program funds.
D.
The Honorariums shall be calculated based on a percentage of cost of the Technical and
Vocational Education and Training (TVET) or Industry recognized credentials program.
E.
The Department may establish deadlines for submission of applications, if necessary.
F.
Honorariums may be paid directly to the student, based on the individual student’s
circumstances.
G.
Students that receive funding through the program shall be required to report progress on
their “Individualized Employment Plan” at a frequency determined by the Department, based on
program length and student progress.
H.
The student is required to sign a “Release of the Information Form” in order to receive
program funding.
14
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
(Source: WOS 2021-010, July 7, 2021, Section IV)
11.405 ELIGIBLE COST
A.
The following are allowable cost to be considered in making funding determinations:
1.
Tuition and fees;
2.
Books and supplies for training and all related equipment;
3.
Testing fees including, but not limited to GED, certifications, or other training
related testing fees;
4.
Payment of allowances/stipends for actual classroom and training time including
workshops and seminars related to job readiness, resume writing, job searching, career
development, and skill development;
5.
Mileage reimbursement, gas/transportation vouchers, lodging, and/or per diem to
support travel to training, certification, and job searching;
6.
Utility assistance;
7.
Entrepreneurial licensure, liability insurance and marketing materials;
8.
Childcare assistance;
9.
Clothing and uniforms; eyeglasses and/or prescription safety goggles.
B.
The Department shall determine whether or not any other expense not listed by be
included in the program and eligible for funding.
(Source: WOS 2021-010, July 7, 2021, Section V)
11.406 RESTRICTIONS
A.
A student must successfully complete their “Individualized Employment Plan” in order to
be eligible for future funding, unless they can show a valid reason not completing the plan.
15
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
B.
Students will not be funded for the same or similar Technical and Vocational Education
and Training (TVET) or Industry recognized credentials program more than twice, unless
required in order to maintain employment and/or credentialing.
C.
Honorarium applications submitted after the deadlines shall be classified as late. Late
applications shall not be funded, but such late applications may be petitioned to the Education
Department for further review.
(Source: WOS 2021-010, July 7, 2021, Section VI)
11.407 REGULATIONS REQUIRED
A.
The Department shall develop regulations for this statute for Tribal Council approval;
however, the implementation of the statute shall not be delayed by approval of regulations.
B.
The regulations shall set forth the application process, provide an appeals process,
applicable deadlines, set standards for “satisfactory progress”, and other criteria for eligibility of
the program.
C.
The regulations shall require the following minimum reports to Tribal Council, and upon
request to other tribal sub-entity:
1.
Three (3) summary reports for each semester’s Honorariums in March, July, and
October and a year-end summary each January for all the previous year’s
Honorariums.
2.
Each report shall contain at a minimum:
a.
A list of names of Honorarium recipients, the type of training sought or
earned and most recent contact information;
b.
Number of students that received Honorariums;
16
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
c.
Total dollar amount of Honorariums for each period and the year;
d.
Present Honorarium rates and predicted rates needed to meet budget for
the next cycle.
D.
The Department shall publish the application and any deadlines at least once a year on
the tribe’s website.
(Source: WOS 2021-010, July 7, 2021, Section VII)
11.408 APPROPRIATIONS AUTHORIZED
The Aanjigin Honorarium Program shall be included in the Executive budget and funded
annually.
(Source: WOS 2021-010, July 7, 2021, Section VIII)
11.409 SEVERABILITY
If any section, subsection, paragraph, sentence, phrase or portion of this Statute is, for any reason,
held invalid or unconstitutional by any court of competent jurisdiction, such portion shall be
deemed a separate, distinct and independent provision and such holding shall not affect the validity
of the remaining portions thereof.
(Source: WOS 2021-010, July 7, 2021, Section IX)
11.410 EFFECTIVE DATE
Effective upon signature of the Executive or thirty (30) days from Tribal Council approval
whichever comes first or if the Executive vetoes the legislation, then upon Tribal Council
override of the veto.
17
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
(Source: WOS 2021-010, July 7, 2021, Section X)
18
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
Chapter 5. Reserved
19
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
Chapter 6. Food Safety Act
11.601 PURPOSE
This Statute is hereby enacted to establish a satisfactory level of food service safety within the
Tribe’s jurisdiction with the intent of promoting Tribal entrepreneurs.
(Source: WOS 2006-010, June 28, 2006, Section I)
11.602 DEFINITIONS
A.
“Tribe” shall mean the Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians.
B.
“Enterprise” shall mean any legal form of business recognized by the Tribe or established
by Tribal law.
C.
“Food Service Facility” an establishment where food is served or sold for immediate
consumption such as a deli, takeout, or restaurant.
D.
“Food Preparation Facility” shall mean an establishment where food is prepared for off
site sales such as a cannery or fish packing plant.
E.
“Food Sales Facility” shall mean an establishment where food is sold for consumption off
site such as a grocery store, fish store, or vegetable stand.
(Source: WOS 2006-010, June 28, 2006, Section II)
11.603 APPLICATION
A.
The Tribe shall have the authority to regulate food service, food sales, and food
preparation facilities owned or operated by the Tribe or the Tribe’s enterprises.
B.
The Tribe shall have the authority to regulate food service, food sales, and food
20
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
preparation facilities owned or operated by Tribal Member enterprises that are legal business
enterprises under the Tribe’s business codes and that are within the Tribe’s jurisdiction.
C.
The Tribe shall have the authority to regulate food service, food sales, and food
preparation facilities of temporary nature at community activities such as jiingtamak and feasts.
D.
The Tribe shall have the authority to establish fees that do not exceed $100 per annum for
permanent or $25 per temporary permits. Fees for Head Start, schools, and non profit
corporations shall not exceed $25 per annum or $10 per temporary permit.
E.
The Tribe shall have the authority to inspect facilities that are licensed by this statute and
facilities that are with in Tribal jurisdiction and licensed by other jurisdictions such as portable
kitchens at jiingtamok. Inspections of facilities that are licensed under the other laws shall be in
accordance with those laws or the Tribe’s which ever best serve the Tribe. Facilities that are
open to the public shall be inspected during open hours while all other inspections shall require
reasonable notice.
(Source: WOS 2006-010, June 28, 2006, Section III)
11.604 RESTRICTIONS
A.
All inspection violations shall require reasonable suggested solutions on the same form as
inspection violations are written.
B.
Regulation of entrepreneurial businesses in Tribal homes shall not exceed the
requirements necessary to prevent significant health risks.
C.
Potlucks and traditional feasts shall not be regulated.
(Source: WOS 2006-010, June 28, 2006, Section IV)
11.605 REGULTIONS REQUIRED
21
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
A.
The Tribal Executive shall adopt regulations to implement this statute.
B.
The regulations concerning home businesses and temporary permits shall be those
minimally required for food safety and shall ensure those regulations are available in pamphlet
format to promote a food safety environment in these entrepreneurial facilities. The pamphlets
should include temperatures and time requirements and warnings or reasons for the regulations.
C.
All fines and penalties other than license revocation shall not exceed $50 and should only
be used after warnings are issued.
(Source: WOS 2006-010, June 28, 2006, Section V)
11.606 PROCEDURES REQUIRED
A.
None.
(Source: WOS 2006-010, June 28, 2006, Section VI)
11.607 APPROPRIATIONS AUTHORIZED
A.
The Executive shall present Tribal Council with modifications to the present and future
annual Budgets to include appropriations necessary to implement this statute.
(Source: WOS 2006-010, June 28, 2006, Section VII)
11.608 EXECUTIVE AUTHORITY
A.
The Tribal Executive is hereby mandated to implement this Act and to enforce all
approved Tribal Codes of Regulation.
(Source: WOS 2006-010, June 28, 2006, Section VIII)
11.609 SEVERABILITY
22
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
If any section, subsection, paragraph, sentence, phrase or portion of this Statute is, for any
reason, held invalid or unconstitutional by any court of competent jurisdiction, such portion shall
be deemed a separate, distinct and independent provision and such holding shall not affect the
validity of the remaining portions thereof.
(Source: WOS 2006-010, June 28, 2006, Section IX)
11.610 EFFECTIVE DATE
Effective upon the signature of the Executive, or 30 days from submission to the Executive
branch, or if the Executive vetoes the legislation, then upon Tribal Council override of the veto.
(Source: WOS 2006-010, June 28, 2006, Section X)
23
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
Chapter 7. Shirley Naganashe Oldman Secondary Education Completion Honorarium
11.701 PURPOSE
The Shirley Naganashe Oldman Graduate Honorarium Statute is hereby enacted to provide a gift
to honor Tribal Citizens to encourage them to continue to obtain and complete a secondary
education; and repeals and replaces WOS 2011-016 Shirley Naganashe Oldman Secondary
Education Completion Award Statute. This Statute is named in the honor of Shirley Naganashe
Oldman in recognition of her dedication in assisting Tribal Citizens to obtain their highest level
of educational goals.
(Source: WOS 2018-020, December 5, 2018, Section I)
11.702 GENERAL WELFARE EXCLUSION
As stated by the requirements of the United States Internal Revenue Section 139E, the Shirley
Naganashe Oldman Graduate Honorarium meets the criteria of the United States Public Law
113-168, Tribal General Welfare Exclusion Act of 2014 and WOS 2017-002 General Welfare
Statute.
(Source: WOS 2018-020, December 5, 2018, Section II)
11.703 DEFINITIONS
A.
“Citizen” means an enrolled member of the Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians.
B.
“Department” means the Education Department located within the Executive Branch of
the Tribe.
C.
“Executive Directive” in accordance with the WOS 2015-019, means a directive issued
by the Tribal Chairperson that establishes basic internal rules of procedure, or guidelines for
Executive departments and employees and does not impact Tribal Citizens or entities out-side of
the Executive Branch.
24
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
D.
“Tribe” or “LTBB” means the Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians.
(Source: WOS 2018-020, December 5, 2018, Section III)
11.704 APPLICATION
A.
The program shall be administered by the Department and the Department shall ensure
that students receive only one (1) honorarium from the Tribe for Secondary Education
completion.
B.
The program shall provide honorarium to Tribal Citizens who have obtained a high
school diploma, General Equivalence Diploma (GED) or a certificate of completion for students
in Special Education programs, during the current fiscal year.
C.
Through regulation as approved by Tribal Council, levels shall be an equal amount for
high school diploma, GED or a certificate of completion for students in Special Education
programs.
(Source: WOS 2018-020, December 5, 2018, Section IV)
11.705 REGULATIONS REQUIRED
A.
The Department shall develop regulations for this Statute within one-hundred and eighty
(180) days of enactment of this Statute; however, the implementation of the Statute shall not be
delayed by approval of regulations.
B.
The regulations shall define an appeal process. Appeals authorized by this Statute shall be
heard by the Education Appeals Board until another body is appointed by Statute, regulation, or
appropriate resolution.
C.
The regulations shall require the following minimum reports to Tribal Council that
contains the following information:
25
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
1.
Number of students that received the honorarium.
2.
Total dollar amount of honorarium for each year.
3.
Present honorarium rates and predicted rates needed to meet budget for the next
cycle.
D.
Publication required: The Executive shall set the honorarium levels for the next
honorarium cycle each academic year or more often as needed by the Executive Directive.
(Source: WOS 2018-020, December 5, 2018, Section V)
11.706 APPROPRIATIONS AUTHORIZED
This Award Statute shall be funded by the General Funds, or other funds as available and
appropriate, with a minimum budget of $5,000 per LTBBOI fiscal year.
(Source: WOS 2018-020, December 5, 2018, Section VI)
11.707 SEVERABILITY
If any section, subsection, paragraph, sentence, phrase or portion of this Statute is, for any
reason, held invalid or unconstitutional by any court of competent jurisdiction, such portion shall
be deemed a separate, distinct and independent provision and such holding shall not affect the
validity of the remaining portions thereof.
(Source: WOS 2018-020, December 5, 2018, Section VII)
11.708 EFFECTIVE DATE
Effective upon signature of the Executive or 30 days from Tribal Council approval whichever
comes first or if the Executive vetoes the legislation, then upon Tribal Council override of the
26
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
veto.
(Source: WOS 2018-020, December 5, 2018, Section VIII)
27
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
Chapter 8. Right to Breastfeed and Civil Offense for Discrimination
11.801 PURPOSE
Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians (LTBB) recognizes the importance of
increasing the breastfeeding practice. The Tribe supports and promotes breastfeeding of
children to ensure that children achieve an optimal healthy condition. Breast milk provides a
better nutrition and higher immunity against diseases, is better to digest, and may increase the
children's IQ.
(Source: WOS 2012-013, August 19, 2012, Section I)
11.802 RIGHT TO BREASTFEED
A.
A mother may breastfeed her child on any Tribal property.
B.
Breastfeeding, prohibition of discriminatory practices. Any direct or indirect act of
exclusion, alienation, restriction, segregation, limitation, rejection, or any other act or practice of
differentiation, including denying a person the total enjoyment of goods, services, facilities,
privileges, advantages, and accommodations in any public or private place on Tribal Property
which she attends, whether it is visited by the public or used for recreation, based on the fact that
a mother is breastfeeding her child, shall constitute a discriminatory practice prohibited by this
Statute and may result in a civil infraction.
C.
Breastfeeding Discrimination shall be prohibited on any Tribal property and shall be
deemed a civil offense.
D.
A law officer has the authority to issue a notice of violation citation when:
1.
When the violation is committed in the officer’s presence;
2.
If an officer investigating the violation has reasonable cause to believe that the
alleged violation has occurred.
E.
Breastfeeding is not a violation of the law. A mother breastfeeding her child in any place,
28
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
whether public or private, on Tribal property shall not be deemed as indecent exposure, obscene
act or other punishable action established in the Tribe’s Criminal Code or Sex Offense Statute, or
as may be amended.
(Source: WOS 2012-013, August 19, 2012, Section II)
11.803 SEVERABILITY
If any section, subsection, paragraph, sentence, phrase or portion of this Statute is, for
any reason, held invalid or unconstitutional by any court of competent jurisdiction, such portion
shall be deemed a separate, distinct and independent provision and such holding shall not affect
the validity of the remaining portions thereof.
(Source: WOS 2012-013, August 19, 2012, Section III)
11.804 EFFECTIVE DATE
Effective upon the signature of the Executive, or 30 days from submission to the
Executive Branch, or if the Executive vetoes the legislation, then upon Tribal Council override of
the veto.
(Source: WOS 2012-013, August 19, 2012, Section IV)
29
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
Chapter 9. Vulnerable Elder and Adult or Incapacitated Adult Protection, Guardianship
and Conservatorship Statute
11.901 PURPOSE
The purpose of this Statute is to protect Vulnerable Elders and Adults, or Incapacitated Adults
from abuse, neglect, or exploitation as defined by this Statute; and provide for services and court
action for Vulnerable Elders and Adults, or Incapacitated Adults; and appoint guardianship
and/or conservatorship for Incapacitated Adults, if necessary. This Statute repeals and replaces
any previous Adult Welfare Code, including WOS 2015-012, WOS 2005-07, repeals and
replaces WOS 2015-017 Elder and Adult Conservatorship and Guardian Statute, and repeals and
replaces WOS 2022- XXX Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated Adult, Protection
Statute.
(Source: WOS 2022-005, June 10, 2022, Section I, Repeals and Replaces 2005-07, 2015-012 and
2015-017)
11.902 DEFINITIONS
A.
“Accounting” means a detailed written summary of all financial actions done by the
guardian and/or conservator on behalf of the Incapacitated Adult.
B.
"Abuse" means
1.
An intentional or negligent infliction of bodily injury, unreasonable confinement,
intimidation, emotional abuse or cruel punishment of a Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or
Incapacitated Adult which result in physical pain or mental anguish; or
2.
Sexual abuse is physical contact without consent of a Vulnerable Elder and Adult,
or Incapacitated Adult with the intent to derive sexual gratification by the person making
contact. Consent may not be obtained by threat, coercion, intimidation or fraud.
30
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
C.
“Bond” means an insurance policy or similar instrument that is intended to protect the
Incapacitated Adult’s property should the conservator mismanage the person’s estate.
D.
"Caretaker" means a person who is required by court of competent jurisdiction to provide
services or resources to a Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated Adult.
E.
“Conservator” means a person appointed by a court of competent jurisdiction who is
responsible for the collection, management, preservation, and investment of an Incapacitated
Adult's property.
F.
“Department” means the Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians Department of
Human Services.
G.
“Emergency” means a situation in which a Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated
Adult is immediately at risk of death or injury and is unable to consent to services to remove the
risk.
H.
“Exploitation” means the improper or unauthorized use of a Vulnerable Elder and Adult,
or Incapacitated Adult’s funds, property or other resources or failure to use a Vulnerable Elder
and Adult, or Incapacitated Adult’s funds, property or resources as a Vulnerable Elder and Adult,
or Incapacitated Adult’s desire or for their benefit.
I.
“Family” means any spouse, parent, child, stepparent, stepchild, grandparent,
grandchild, or significant other person or relative with whom a Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or
Incapacitated Adult which has a familial relationship, or who resides with a Vulnerable Elder
and Adult, or Incapacitated Adult.
J.
“Guardian” means a person appointed by a court of competent jurisdiction to exercise the
duty and authority to provide care and control of an Incapacitated Adult’s personal health, safety,
and welfare, under the Tribal Court’s jurisdiction.
K.
"Good Faith" means an honest and reasonable belief or purpose, and the lack of intent to
defraud.
31
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
L.
“Incapacitated Adult” means a Vulnerable Elder or Adult, because of physical or
psychological infirmities, lacks the understanding or capacity to make or communicate informed
decisions or is unable to manage property and business affairs effectively and needs a
guardianship and/or conservatorship.
M.
"Least restrictive alternative" means whenever it is necessary to protect a Vulnerable
Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated Adult, the least restrictive method of intervention shall be used
to protect the freedom and independence of a Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated
Adult; the least restrictive alternative is that environment which is the most like a Vulnerable
Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated Adult’s home setting and which is most capable of supporting
the protected person's physical and mental health; and emotional well-being.
N.
“LTBB” or “Tribe” or “Tribal” means the Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians.
O.
"Neglect" means the failure of someone with fiduciary or legal responsibility to provide
necessary services or resources to maintain the health or safety of a Vulnerable Elder and Adult,
on Incapacitated Adult, or self-neglect caused by the inability of the adult to provide themselves
with basic food, clothing, shelter and medical care due to mental incompetency or physical
disability.
P.
"Party" or "interested party" means the family, caretaker, and any other person that has an
interest in the welfare of a Vulnerable Elder or Adult, or Incapacitated Adult. The Court shall
have the power to determine who is or is not a party or interested party in any court proceeding.
Q.
“Prosecutor” means the Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians Prosecutor.
R.
“Protective placement" means the placement of a Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or
Incapacitated Adult, in a hospital, nursing home, residential care facility, other suitable
placement, or transfer from one facility to another with consent of that person or with appropriate
legal authority.
32
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
S.
"Protective services" means services provided to a Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or
Incapacitated Adult, with consent or by order of appropriate legal authority which includes but is
not limited to: social services, mental and physical health examinations, home and day care, legal
assistance, guardianship, case management and any other services consistent with this Statute.
T.
"Substantiated Report" means when there is probable cause of abuse after an
investigation conducted by the Department. The report is sent to the Tribal Prosecutor for further
steps to be taken.
U.
“Tribe” or “Tribal” means the Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians.
V.
“Tribal Court” means the Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians Tribal Court.
W.
“Vulnerable Elder and Adult” means an Elder who is fifty-five (55) years old or older or
an Adult who is eighteen (18) years old or older and is unable to protect themselves from abuse,
neglect or exploitation due to mental incompetency or physical disability.
X.
“Unsubstantiated Report” means when no probable cause exists after an investigation.
These reports are filed within the Department for reference as needed.
(Source: WOS 2022-005, June 10, 2022, Section II, Repeals and Replaces 2005-07, 2015-012
and 2015-017)
11.903 AUTHORITY
A.
Pursuant to provisions of the Tribal Constitution, including Article I, B, 2. “Promote with
special care the health, educational and economic interests of all the people, especially our
children and Elders, and shall protect them from social injustice and all forms of exploitation;
and 4. “Establish and maintain within the limits of their economic capacity and development,
effect provision for securing the right to work, to education and assistance, in cases of
unemployment, old age, sickness and disablement, and in other cases of need”.
33
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
B.
Pursuant to provisions of the Tribal Constitution, including Article VI., C. “… the
Executive Branch to administer such funds, enforce this Constitution and laws passed
thereunder, and implement policies and procedures enacted by the Tribal Council in accordance
with Article VIII”, Article VII of the Tribal Constitution allows the Legislative Branch to
approve the creation or dissolution of Executive divisions or departments to promote and protect
the peace, health, safety, education and general welfare of Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa
Indians and its members.
(Source: WOS 2022-005, June 10, 2022, Section III, Repeals and Replaces 2005-07, 2015-012
and 2015-017)
11.905 JURISDICTION
A.
The Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians shall have jurisdiction over the
following:
1.
A Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated Adult who is unable to protect
themselves from suspected abuse, neglect or exploitation due to mental incapacity or
physical disability and resides within Tribal Trust Lands;
2.
An Incapacitated Adult, because of physical or psychological infirmities, lacks the
understanding or capacity to make or communicate informed decisions or is unable to
manage property and business affairs effectively and needs a guardianship and/or
conservatorship and resides within Tribal Trust Lands;
3.
A person who is required by a court of competent jurisdiction to or has a
guardianship, conservatorship, fiduciary or legal responsibility to provide services or
resources and is suspected of abuse, neglect or exploitation under this Statute to a Tribal
Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated Adult who resides within Tribal Trust
Lands.
4.
A person appointed by Tribal Court as a Conservator and/or Guardian.
34
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
(Source: WOS 2022-005, June 10, 2022, Section IV, Repeals and Replaces 2005-07, 2015-012
and 2015-017)
11.905 DUTY TO REPORT
A.
Every person has the duty to report to the Department if they suspect that a Vulnerable
Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated Adult is abused or neglected.
B.
It is mandated by this Statute for the following to report to the Department any suspected
abuse, neglect or exploitation of a Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated Adult
immediately or no later than twenty-four (24) hours of obtaining the information:
1.
Persons who either have been court appointed or have a legal responsibility to a
Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated Adult;
2.
Law Enforcement;
3.
Tribal employee(s) who provide services to Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or
Incapacitated Adult, of the following departments:
a.
b.
c.
d.
e.
f.
4.
Education
Elders
Health
Housing
Human Services
Language
Elected or appointed official of the Tribe;
C.
Reports should include a detailed summary of the actions, inactions and/or allegations of
the suspected abuse or neglect.
35
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
D.
Reports of suspected Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated Adult’s abuse are
presumed to be made in good faith.
(Source: WOS 2022-005, June 10, 2022, Section V, Repeals and Replaces 2005-07, 2015-012
and 2015-017)
11.906 IMMUNITY FOR REPORTING
A person who in good faith reports suspected abuse, neglect or exploitation as defined in this
Statute is immune from any civil or criminal statute, even if the report is unsubstantiated.
(Source: WOS 2022-005, June 10, 2022, Section VI, Repeals and Replaces 2005-07, 2015-012
and 2015-017)
11.907 CONFIDENTIALITY OF REPORTER and RECORDS
A.
The identity of the reporter of suspected Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated
Adult’s abuse, neglect or exploitation, under this Statute, is confidential.
B.
Records of investigations concerning suspected Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or
Incapacitated Adult’s abuse, neglect or exploitation shall be confidential.
(Source: WOS 2022-005, June 10, 2022, Section VII, Repeals and Replaces 2005-07, 2015-012
and 2015-017)
11.908 FAILURE TO REPORT; CIVIL PENALTY
If found responsible, after a fair hearing of the Court, that a person mandated by this Statute to
report, and that person fails to report suspected Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated
Adult’s abuse, neglect, or exploitation, may be subject to a civil fine not to exceed five-thousand
($5,000.00) dollars.
(Source: WOS 2022-005, June 10, 2022, Section VIII, Repeals and Replaces 2005-07, 2015-012
36
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
and 2015-017)
11.909 RETALIATION; CIVIL PENALTY
If a person is found to have retaliated against a reporter, they may be subject to a civil fine not to
exceed five-thousand ($5,000.00) dollars. For the purposes of this Statute, "Retaliation" shall
include the following: intimidating or threatening to cause bodily harm, or causing bodily harm,
or causing bodily harm to a reporter or family of a person reporting abuse; causing the reporter
or reporter's family to be terminated, suspended or reprimanded by an employer; causing
property damage to real or personal property belonging to a reporter's family.
(Source: WOS 2022-005, June 10, 2022, Section IX, Repeals and Replaces 2005-07, 2015-012
and 2015-017)
11.910 FALSE REPORT
If found responsible, after a fair hearing of the Court, any person who makes a report of
suspected Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated Adult’s abuse, neglect or exploitation as
defined by this Statute knowing it to be false may be subject to a civil fine not to exceed fivethousand ($5,000.00) dollars.
(Source: WOS 2022-005, June 10, 2022, Section X, Repeals and Replaces 2005-07, 2015-012
and 2015-017)
11.911 HUMAN SERVICES DEPARTMENT DUTIES, RESPONSIBILITIES and
AUTHORITY
A.
of:
The Department shall be responsible to initiate an investigation, upon receiving a report
1.
a Vulnerable Elder and Adult’s abuse, or Incapacitated Adult neglect or
exploitation, or
2.
an Incapacitated Adult in need of a Guardian and/or Conservator.
37
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
B.
The Department shall investigate all reports.
C.
Abuse, Neglect or Exploitation. The Department shall initiate an investigate upon
receipt of the report of abuse, neglect or exploitation within twenty-four (24) hours, meet face to
face with the alleged victim within seventy-two (72) hours and complete the investigation with a
written report within thirty (30) consecutive days based upon:
1.
Personal interviews with the alleged abused, neglected or exploited Vulnerable
Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated Adult, the immediate family and caretaker, suspected
abuser, employees of agencies (if involved), and any other person who may have
pertinent information;
2.
Medical records and other evidence of abuse;
3.
Assessments of a Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated Adult’s living
conditions;
4.
Any other observations, assessments or documents that may aid in completing an
accurate report.
D.
Based on the investigation, if the Department believes that there is evidence of
Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated Adult’s abuse, neglect or exploitation, the
Department will submit the report to the Prosecutor.
E.
Based on the investigation, if the Department believes that there an Incapacitated Adult in
need of a Guardian and/or Conservator, the Department may request the Prosecutor file a petition
with Tribal Court.
F.
The Department shall have the authority to obtain from all Tribal Governmental
Departments, Agencies and Programs information and assistance with the Department’s
investigations of suspected Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated Adult, abuse, neglect or
exploitation; or Incapacitated Adult in need of a Guardian and/or Conservator. This shall include
38
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
information sharing without the need of signed releases, if it is part of an ongoing investigation
for alleged abuse or neglect.
(Source: WOS 2022-005, June 10, 2022, Section XI, Repeals and Replaces 2005-07, 2015-012
and 2015-017)
11.912 LAW ENFORCEMENT DUTIES AND RESPONSIBILITIES
A.
Upon the request of the Department, Law Enforcement shall assist the Department in
conduct of an investigation within twenty-four (24) hours, if one or more of the following
conditions exist:
1.
Abuse or neglect is the suspected cause of death of a Vulnerable Elder and Adult,
or Incapacitated Adult;
2.
A Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated Adult, is the victim of suspected
sexual abuse or sexual exploitation;
3.
Abuse or neglect resulting in severe physical injury to a Vulnerable Elder and
Adult, or Incapacitated Adult, that requires medical treatment or hospitalization. For the
purpose of this subsection, “severe physical injury” means brain damage, skull or bone
fracture, subdural hematoma, dislocation, sprain, internal injuries, poisoning, burns,
scalds, severe cuts, or any other physical injury that seriously impairs the health or
physical well-being of a vulnerable Tribal Elder or Vulnerable Tribal Adult, or
Incapacitated Adult.
4.
Law Enforcement intervention is necessary for the protection of a Vulnerable
Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated Adult, Department staff, or another person involved in
the investigation; or
5.
The alleged perpetrator of abuse, neglect or exploitation of a Vulnerable Elder
and Adult, or Incapacitated Adult, is not a person responsible for the health or welfare of
the Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated Adult.
39
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
B.
Law Enforcement shall be responsible to determine and investigate if any other criminal
acts are alleged and shall forward this information to the Prosecutor.
(Source: WOS 2022-005, June 10, 2022, Section XII, Repeals and Replaces 2005-07, 2015-012
and 2015-017)
11.913 PROSECUTOR’S DUTIES AND RESPONSIBILITIES
The Prosecutor is authorized by this Statute to petition the Court for Emergency Protection
Orders and Non-Emergency Protection Orders for the protection of Vulnerable Elders and
Adults, or Incapacitated Adult from abuse, neglect or exploitation, upon receipt of a
substantiated report of investigation from the Department.
(Source: WOS 2022-005, June 10, 2022, Section XIII, Repeals and Replaces 2005-07, 2015-012
and 2015-017)
11.914 PETITIONS AND EMERGENCY ORDERS
A.
The Department or any concerned or interested party may file a Petition for an
Emergency Protection Order (EPO) directly with the Court of suspected Vulnerable Elder and
Adult, or Incapacitated Adult’s abuse, neglect or exploitation.
B.
Upon filing of a Petition, the Court may issue an EPO authorizing emergency services or
protective placement either ex parte or after a hearing, if there is a showing, upon clear and
convincing evidence that:
1.
A person is a Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated Adult; and
2.
The Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated Adult, is at risk of immediate
abuse, neglect or exploitation.
C.
The EPO, using the least restrictive alternative, may include:
40
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
1.
Specific emergency services to be provided to remediate the emergency;
2.
Protective placement only if the evidence indicates that it is absolutely necessary;
3.
Designation of a person or agency required to implement the order; and
4.
A warrant for forcible entry by Tribal Law Enforcement, if requested and
documented attempts to gain voluntary access have failed.
D.
EPO’s shall not exceed a maximum of seventy-two (72) hours excluding weekends and
holidays, and may only be renewed for an additional seventy-two (72) hours, if there is evidence
of continuing emergency.
E.
The Court shall hold a hearing upon the filing of a Petition for an EPO or if an EPO was
issued ex parte, within seventy-two (72) hours. At the hearing, if the Vulnerable Elder or Adult,
or Incapacitated Adult, is not represented, a Guardian ad Litem shall be appointed at this time, if
it has not already been done so at the time of the filing of the Petition for an EPO.
F.
All parties, including attorneys, are permitted to attend the hearing for an EPO. The
hearing may be done ex parte if the need arises. The sufficiency of the petition will be
determined on a totality of circumstances and goes into effect upon the immediate granting of the
order by the Court.
(Source: WOS 2022-005, June 10, 2022, Section XIV, Repeals and Replaces 2005-07, 2015-012
and 2015-017)
11.915 EMERGENCY PLACEMENT
A.
If there is good cause to believe that an emergency exists and a Vulnerable Elder and
Adult, or Incapacitated Adult is at risk of immediate or irreparable harm upon personal
observation or by the Department’s investigation, the Department or Tribal Law Enforcement
shall immediately take steps to protect the Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated Adult,
41
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
including emergency services or protective placement. A Court Order must be obtained within
twenty-four (24) hours to continue the authorization of emergency services or protective
placement.
B.
Anyone who acts, based on reasonably good faith, pursuant to this section shall be
immune from civil and criminal suit if the suspected abuse or neglect results in an
unsubstantiated report.
(Source: WOS 2022-005, June 10, 2022, Section XV, Repeals and Replaces 2005-07, 2015-012
and 2015-017)
11.916 PETITIONS AND NON-EMERGENCY PROTECTION ORDER
A.
The Department or any concerned or interested party may file a Petition for a NonEmergency Protection Order (NEPO) directly with the Court of suspected Vulnerable Elder and
Adult, or Incapacitated Adult’s abuse, neglect or exploitation.
B.
Upon the filing of a Non-Emergency Protection Order (NEPO) petition, the Court may
issue an NEPO, after a hearing that shall be held within fourteen (14) consecutive days if there is
a showing, upon clear and convincing evidence
1.
A person is a Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated Adult; and
2.
The Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated Adult, is at risk of abuse,
neglect or exploitation.
C.
All parties are entitled to Notice and an opportunity to be heard on the record. All
proceedings shall be open to the public, unless the Court, on its own motion or by motion of a
party, determines that by the nature of the proceedings, the proceedings are to be closed.
D.
Judgments. The Court shall make a written determination or decision within forty-eight
(48) hours of a hearing and use the least restrictive alternative, which may include the following:
42
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
1.
Appointing Guardian ad Litem for the Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or
Incapacitated Adult to enter other orders for the protection of the Vulnerable Elder and
Adult, or Incapacitated Adults.
2.
Order the Department to prepare petitions for Guardianship and/or
Conservatorship if the Vulnerable Elder or Adult is believed to be an Incapacitated Adult;
or order the Department file a request for a termination of the current Guardian and/or
Conservator for an Incapacitated Adult, and prepare petitions for a new appointment;
3.
Removal from the place where the abuse or neglect occur(ed) including the
Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated Adult’s home;
4.
Remove the abuser from the residence to prohibit further abusive acts;
5.
Requiring any party having a fiduciary duty to the Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or
Incapacitated Adult, to account for the Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated
Adult’s funds and/or property.
E.
Protective orders authority shall not exceed 180 days; Guardianship and/or
conservatorship may be temporary or permanent.
(Source: WOS 2022-005, June 10, 2022, Section XVI, Repeals and Replaces 2005-07, 2015-012
and 2015-017)
11.917 PETITION FOR FINDING OF VULNERABILITY ELDER OR ADULT as
INCAPACITATED and APPOINTMENT OF GUARDIAN OR CONSERVATOR
A.
The Department via the Prosecutor, or any concerned or interested party may file a
petition for Finding of a Vulnerable Elder or Adult as an Incapacitated Adult and request an
Order for Appointment of Guardian or an Order for Appointment of a Conservator, or both.
B.
The Petition will include, but not limited to, the name, age, date of birth, gender and
address of the alleged Incapacitated Adult, reasons why the need exists, petitioner’s relationship
43
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
with the alleged Incapacitated Adult, names and addresses of immediate family of the alleged
Incapacitated Adult, the extent of the alleged Incapacitated Adult’s estate, and the names and
addresses of those who can provide testimony that the person needs a guardian or conservator.
C.
The petitioner or Court will mail copies of the petition and notice of the hearing to all
interested persons who include the following people:
1.
The alleged Incapacitated Adult's spouse;
2.
If known, a person named as the alleged Incapacitated Adult's agent in a Durable
Power of Attorney or Patient Advocate Designation, or other medical or legal
representatives;
3.
The alleged Incapacitated Adult's children (or, if the Incapacitated Adult has no
children, the Incapacitated Adult's parents); and
4.
If there is one, the alleged Incapacitated Adult's Guardian or Conservator
appointed by a Court in another jurisdiction.
D.
The Court shall appoint Guardian ad Litem to represent the alleged Incapacitated Adult,
unless the alleged Incapacitated Adult has his or her own attorney. The alleged Incapacitated
Adult and these interested persons are entitled to object to the appointment of a Guardian or
Conservator.
E.
The Court may issue an Order for Appointment of Guardian or Appointment of a
Conservator, or both, after a hearing which shall be held, and there is a showing, upon clear and
convincing evidence based a detailed description of the alleged Incapacitated Adult's physical or
psychological infirmities by a physician or mental health professional and an explanation of how
and to what extent each infirmity interferes with the alleged Incapacitated Adult's ability make
decisions, on the following:
44
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
1.
The person lacks the understanding or capacity to make or communicate informed
decisions, and the appointment of a guardian is necessary to provide for the Incapacitated
Adult's continuing care and supervision;
2.
The person is an adult who is unable to manage property and business affairs
effectively for reasons such as mental illness, mental deficiency, physical illness or
disability, chronic use of drugs, chronic intoxication, confinement, or disappearance, and
the person has property that will be wasted or dissipated unless the Appointment of a
Conservator is provided, or money is needed for the Incapacitated Adult's support, care,
and welfare or for those entitled to the Incapacitated Adult's support, and that the
Appointment of a Conservator is needed to obtain or provide money;
3.
Or both, and an Appointment of a Guardian and Conservator is necessary.
F.
If a medical evaluation is not voluntarily provided to the Court, the Court on its own
Motion may Order a medical evaluation by a physician or mental health professional. The
examination and evaluation report should contain a description of the alleged Incapacitated
Adult’s physical and mental condition, cognitive and functional abilities and limitations,
adaptive behaviors, social skills, educational and developmental potential, prognosis for
improvement and recommendation for treatment or rehabilitation as appropriate. The
professional completing the report must also state his or her opinion as to whether the alleged
Incapacitated Adult is impaired and in need of a guardian or conservator, or both, and whether
the person could meaningfully participate in the proceedings.
G.
The Court may also weigh any of the following as evidence:
1.
Testimony from family or friends familiar with the alleged Incapacitated Adult;
2.
Medical and financial records relevant to the alleged Incapacitated Adult or their
ability to care for themselves;
3.
Any other evidence the Court determines to be relevant.
45
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
4.
Refusal to submit to a Court Order medical evaluation can be used by the Court as
evidence of mental incapacity.
H.
All parties are entitled to Notice and an opportunity to be heard on the record. All
proceedings shall be open to the public, unless the Court, on its own motion or by motion of a
party, determines that by the nature of the proceedings, the proceedings are to be closed. The
hearing shall be conducted in as informal a manner as may be consistent with orderly procedure.
I.
For the Court to Order for Appointment of Guardian or Appointment of a Conservator, or
both, the Court shall make a written determination based on sufficient proof as presented to the
Court.
J.
The Court should consider appointing the alleged Incapacitated Adult's agent in a
Durable Power of Attorney or Patient Advocate Designation, or other medical or legal
representatives of the alleged Incapacitated Adult.
K.
Before the Judge signs an Order of Appointment and issues letters of guardianship or
conservatorship, or both, the Court shall require a written oath reflecting that the Guardian and/or
Conservator will faithfully discharge all duties assigned by the Court. The Guardian and/or
Conservator shall also sign an Acceptance of Appointment.
L.
Appointment of a Guardian. The Court shall grant a Guardian only those powers and
only for that period of time as is necessary to provide for the demonstrated need of the
Incapacitated Adult. The Court shall design the guardianship to encourage the development of
maximum self-reliance and independence in the Incapacitated Adult. A Court Order establishing
a guardianship shall specify any limitations on the Guardian's powers and any time limits on the
guardianship. At any time, the Court may require the guardian to develop and file with the Court
a plan of care of the Incapacitated Adult.
M.
Powers and Duties of a Guardian.
1.
A Full Guardian is responsible for the Incapacitated Adult 's care, custody, and
supervision, including ensuring that the Incapacitated Adult has proper food and clothing,
46
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
the Incapacitated Adult lives in a place that is appropriate for him or her, the
Incapacitated Adult's medical needs are met, and the Incapacitated Adult's property is
safe. A Limited Guardian is responsible for only those duties stated in the Court Order.
2.
In the absence of a valid Patient Advocate Designation, the Guardian will make
the medical decisions.
3.
The Guardian must visit the Incapacitated Adult at least quarterly or as directed
by the Court Order, but no less than once a year, the Guardian must prepare a report on
the condition of the Incapacitated Adult and file the report with the Court. The Guardian
must give copies of the report to the Incapacitated Adult and all interested persons as
defined by the Statute. The Court will review any guardianship plan, prior orders in the
case, and any accountings and previous reports or accountings, including all costs and
fees charged by the guardian.
4.
If a Conservator is not appointed, the Guardian may take control of and manage
the Incapacitated Adult 's funds and property for the benefit of the Incapacitated Adult.
The funds or property are used for the Incapacitated Adult's support, care, and education.
Any amount not used is saved for the Incapacitated Adult's needs.
N.
Appointment of a Conservator. The Court shall grant a Conservator only those powers
and only for that period of time as is necessary to provide for the demonstrated need of the
Incapacitated Adult. The Court shall design the conservatorship to encourage the development of
maximum self-reliance and independence in the Incapacitated Adult. A Court Order establishing
a conservatorship shall specify any limitations on the conservator's powers and any time limits
on the conservatorship.
O.
Powers and Duties of a Conservator.
1.
A Conservator may expend or distribute estate income or principal without court
authorization or confirmation for the support, education, care, or benefit of the
Incapacitated Adult or the Incapacitated Adult 's dependents in accordance with the
following principles:
47
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
a.
the action taken be in the best interest of the Incapacitated Adult,
exercising sound judgment and avoiding conflicts of interest;
b.
the action is reasonably necessary for the support, education, care, or
benefit of the protected Incapacitated Adult or a dependent.
2.
A Conservator shall not sell or otherwise dispose of the protected Incapacitated
Adult's principal dwelling, real property, or interest in real property or mortgage, pledge,
or cause a lien to be placed on any such property without approval of the Court. The
Court shall only approve the sale, disposal, mortgage, or pledge of or lien against the
principal dwelling, real property, or interest in real property if the Court considers
evidence of the value of the property and otherwise determines that the sale, disposal,
mortgage, pledge, or lien is in the protected Incapacitated Adult's best interest.
3.
The Court shall require the Conservator promptly file a fiduciary bond and
provide an inventory of the Incapacitated Adult's property to the Court and deliver copies
to the Incapacitated Adult and other parties as required by the Court.
4.
Conservators shall file at a minimum an annual report to the Court that provides
an update on the condition of the protected Incapacitated Adult and an accounting of
funds collected and funds expended on behalf of the Incapacitated Adult. The reports
shall be available for review by interested parties. The Court will review any
conservatorship plan, prior orders in the case, and any accountings and previous reports
or accountings, including all costs and fees charged by the Conservator.
5.
Conservators shall schedule annual review hearings in conjunction with the filing
of annual reports. Any interested party may request additional hearings.
6.
Conservators do not have power to consent to medical treatment, to choose where
an Incapacitated Adult lives, or to control day-to-day activities.
(Source: WOS 2022-005, June 10, 2022, Section XVII, Repeals and Replaces 2005-07, 2015012 and 2015-017)
48
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
11.918 COURT COSTS AND FEES
A.
The Court may require payment of costs and fees for filing a petition with the Court.
Costs and fees may be waived if a person is unable to pay by reason of indigence. Any costs for
filing of a petition by the Department shall be waived.
B.
Costs and fees may be allowed for the following:
1.
2.
Any professional services ordered performed by the Court.
Counsel for the Incapacitated Adult when counsel is appointed by the Court.
3.
Counsel for the petitioner and any respondent.
4.
Other costs and fees may be allowed and paid as are allowed by law for similar
services in other cases.
C.
The costs shall be taxed to the estate of the Incapacitated Adult, to those bound by law to
support the Incapacitated Adult, to other parties whenever it would be just and equitable to do so.
(Source: WOS 2022-005, June 10, 2022, Section XVIII, Repeals and Replaces 2005-07, 2015012 and 2015-017)
11.919 ADDITIONAL REPORTING REQUIRMENTS OF GUARDIAN AND/OR
CONSERVATOR
A.
The Court may determine whether or not a report or accounting shows reasonable
administration of the guardianship or conservatorship, or both, whether the fiduciary is
performing his or her duties and responsibilities, and whether the fiduciary's powers should be
expanded or limited or any other modifications made.
B.
The Court may then set a hearing on the matter.
49
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
C.
In addition to the usual annual reports and accountings, the Court may order additional
filing of a special report or accounting if specific circumstances require it.
D.
The Court will require a reporting of any of the following:
1.
Change of address of the guardian or conservator.
2.
Change of residence or placement of the Incapacitated Adult.
3.
Significant change in the health or impairment of the Incapacitated Adult.
4.
The acquisition, receipt or accumulation of property or income by the
Incapacitated Adult which would cause the value of the Incapacitated Adult 's estate to
equal or exceed $10,000.
5.
The death of the Incapacitated Adult.
6.
A change in the circumstances of the guardian, or conservator, Incapacitated
Adult that may constitute a conflict of interest.
(Source: WOS 2022-005, June 10, 2022, Section XIX, Repeals and Replaces 2005-07, 2015-012
and 2015-017)
11.920 RIGHTS OF VULNERABLE ELDER AND ADULT, OR INCAPACITATED
ADULT
A.
The alleged Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated Adult shall be informed of any
investigation as it begins, unless an emergency exists and shall have the ability to receive any
investigation reports.
B.
Elders or Adults are presumed to possess capacity until a court of competent jurisdiction
determines otherwise.
50
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
C.
The alleged Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated Adult may refuse to allow
investigators into their home without a warrant for entry.
D.
The alleged Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated Adult has the right to attend all
proceedings pertaining to the suspected abuse, neglect or exploitation, or guardians or
conservatorship unless the Court determines the Elders or adult’s health is at risk in attending
such proceedings based on medical reports and records.
E.
The alleged Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated Adult has the right to receive
any documents presented to the Court at any or all court proceedings pertaining to the suspected
abuse, neglect or exploitation, or guardian or conservatorship.
F.
The alleged Vulnerable Elder and Adult, or Incapacitated Adult has the right to
independent medical, psychological or psychiatric evaluations at their own expense.
(Source: WOS 2022-005, June 10, 2022, Section XX, Repeals and Replaces 2005-07, 2015-012
and 2015-017)
11.921 RESTORATION TO CAPACITY PROCEDURES
A.
An adult in need of a guardian or a conservator, or both, may be restored to capacity.
B.
Upon a petition being filed, the Court must review to determine whether probable cause
exists to warrant further proceedings. If probable cause is found, the Court shall set the petition
for hearing and may appoint an attorney for the alleged Incapacitated Adult. If probable cause
does not exist, the Court may dismiss the petition.
C.
At the conclusion of the hearing, if the Court does not find by clear and convincing
evidence, that the alleged Incapacitated Adult is an Adult with an impairment in need of a
guardian or a conservator, or both, the Court shall order that the Adult is restored to capacity and
shall proceed to terminate the guardianship or conservatorship, or both.
51
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
(Source: WOS 2022-005, June 10, 2022, Section XXI, Repeals and Replaces 2005-07, 2015-012
and 2015-017)
11.922 TERMINATION OF GUARDIANSHIP AND CONSERVATORSHIP
A.
The Court at any time may enter an order summarily terminating a guardianship or a
conservatorship in any of the following circumstances:
1.
The Incapacitated Adult is deceased.
2.
No further need for the guardianship or conservatorship exists.
(Source: WOS 2022-005, June 10, 2022, Section XXII, Repeals and Replaces 2005-07, 2015012 and 2015-017)
11.923 SAVING CLAUSE
In the event that any phrase, provision, part, paragraph, subsection or section of this Statute is
found by a court of competent jurisdiction to violate the Constitution, laws, ordinances or
statutes of the Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians, such phrase, provision, part,
paragraph, subsection or section shall be considered to stand alone and to be deleted from this
Statute, the entirety of the balance of the Statute to remain in full and binding force and effect.
(Source: WOS 2022-005, June 10, 2022, Section XXIII, Repeals and Replaces 2005-07, 2015012 and 2015-017)
11.924 EFFECTIVE DATE
Effective upon signature of the Executive or 30 days from Tribal Council approval whichever
comes first or if the Executive vetoes the legislation, then upon Tribal Council override of the
veto.
52
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
(Source: WOS 2022-005, June 10, 2022, Section XXIV, Repeals and Replaces 2005-07, 2015012 and 2015-017)
53
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
Chapter 10. Fair Treatment for Benefits and Services
11.1001
PURPOSE
The Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians, based on traditional cultural values,
creates this Statute to ensure fair treatment and protection against discrimination in the receipt of
benefits or services offered by the Tribe and the exercise of the enforcement for violations of this
Statute.
(Source: WOS 2013-009, August 4, 2013 by Veto Override, Section I)
11.1002
DEFINITIONS
A.
“Benefits or Services” means participation in, the benefits of, or any service, program,
activity or public accommodation provided by the Tribe.
B.
“Employee” means an individual employed by the Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa
Indians including Tribal Government Administration, commercial entities, sub-entities and the
Odawa Casino Resort and ancillary enterprises and activities beginning on the first day of work
and after the employment process and issuance of a temporary gaming license.
C.
“Malice” means the intent, without just cause or reason, to commit a wrongful act that will
result in harm to another.
D.
“Official" means any person holding an elective or appointed office in any branch, entity,
enterprise, authority, division, department, office, commission, council, board, bureau,
committee, legislative body, agency and any establishment within the Executive, Legislative or
Judiciary branch of the Tribe including Members of the Election Board and Prosecutors.
E.
“Reckless indifference” means conscious or reckless disregard of the consequences of
one's acts or omissions.
54
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
F.
“Territorial Jurisdiction of the Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians” means “areas
referenced in Public Law 103-324, 25 USC Section 1300k-2(b)(2)(A) as the boundaries of the
reservations for the Little Traverse Bay Bands as set out in Article I, paragraphs ‘third and fourth’
of the Treaty of 1855, 11 Stat.621.” Little Traverse Bay Bands Constitution, Article V(A)(1)(a).
G.
"Tribal Council" The Tribal Council of the Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians.
H.
“Tribe” means the Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians and includes any Tribal
entity or sub-entity of the Tribe.
(Source: WOS 2013-009, August 4, 2013 by Veto Override, Section II)
11.1003
FAIR TREATMENT and DISCRIMINATION
A.
Recognizing the traditional Odawak value of equality, mutual respect and respect for
differences, the Tribe determines fair treatment to mean not to discriminate against a person on
the ground of religion, race, color, national origin, ethnicity, age, sex, height, weight, familial
status, marital status, disability, perceived disability, sexual orientation, arrest or detention
records, or other disposition in which a conviction did not result.
B.
Discriminate means to exclude a person from participation in, be denied the benefits of,
or be subjected to discrimination under any service, program, activity or accommodation
provided by the Tribe, unless such benefit or service is limited by the following:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
law
Tribal Constitution
Tribal law
Funding
Limited to Tribal Citizens
Indian Preference in Tribal Employment Statute, WOS 2002-04, and any successor
(Source: WOS 2013-009, August 4, 2013 by Veto Override, Section III)
55
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
11.1004
TRIBAL COURT
The Tribal Court shall have the jurisdiction to hear charges of violations of this Statute based on
fair treatment and discrimination.
(Source: WOS 2013-009, August 4, 2013 by Veto Override, Section IV)
11.1005
LIMITED WAIVER OF SOVEREIGN IMMUNITY
A.
The Tribe clearly and expressly waives its sovereign immunity to the Equitable Remedies
as set forth in this Statute and clearly and expressly waives its sovereign immunity to
Damages as set forth within this Statute for the Tribe, officials and its employers and limits such
waiver to remedies as set forth within this Statute wherein the Tribe, officials or employees who
act beyond the scope of their duties and authority in which the actions include either acting with
malice or with reckless indifference discriminates against a person under this Statute and limits
such waiver to remedies as set forth within this Statute.
B.
The Tribe asserts no sovereign immunity for third-parties; and limits the remedies as set
forth by this Statute.
(Source: WOS 2013-009, August 4, 2013 by Veto Override, Section V)
11.1006
REMEDIES AND DAMAGES
A.
Any charge of violation must be filed with the Tribal Court within one-hundred and eighty
(180) days of the alleged violation.
B.
In any action filed under this Statute, the Tribal Court may grant the remedies set forth:
1.
Equitable Remedies. If the Tribal Court finds that violation of discrimination
occurred, its judgment must specify an appropriate remedy or remedies for that violation.
The remedies may include, but are not limited to:
56
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
a.
b.
An order to cease and desist from the unlawful practices specified in the
order;
Community services or similar penalty.
2.
Damages. If the Tribal Court finds a blatant violation of discrimination, the Tribal
Court may additionally award compensatory, punitive damages or fines as provided in this
subparagraph.
a.
A complainant may recover compensatory damages for future pecuniary
losses, emotional pain, suffering, inconvenience, mental anguish, loss of enjoyment
of life, and other non-pecuniary losses.
b.
A complainant may recover punitive damages if the complainant
demonstrates that the violation of discrimination was done with malice or with
reckless indifference to the rights of an aggrieved individual protected by this
Statute.
3.
The total sum of compensatory, punitive damages and/or fines may not exceed
$10,000.00.
4.
When a discriminatory practice involves the provision of a reasonable
accommodation, damages may not be awarded if demonstrated that good faith efforts were
made or the accommodation would create an undue hardship on the operation of the Tribe.
5.
The Tribal Court may award reasonable attorney fees and costs in its discretion to
the prevailing party.
6.
The Tribal Court may award the opposing party any penalties for frivolous claims
or any other appropriate remedies as the Tribal Court deems.
(Source: WOS 2013-009, August 4, 2013 by Veto Override, Section VI)
11.1007
SAVINGS CLAUSE
57
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
In the event that any phrase, provision, part, paragraph, subsection or section of this
statute is found by a court of competent jurisdiction to violate the Constitution, laws or
ordinances of the Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians, such phrase, provision, part,
paragraph, subsection or section shall be considered to stand alone and to be deleted from this
statute, the entirety of the balance of the statute to remain in full and binding force and effect.
(Source: WOS 2013-009, August 4, 2013 by Veto Override, Section VII)
11.1008
EFFECTIVE DATE
Effective upon signature of the Executive or shall be deemed enacted if not expressly vetoed by
the Executive within thirty (30) days of submission. The Tribal Council may, by an affirmative
vote of seven (7) members of the Tribal Council, override a veto by the Executive.
(Source: WOS 2013-009, August 4, 2013 by Veto Override, Section VIII)
58
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
Chapter 12. Naawchigedaa Tort Claims
11.1101
SHORT TITLE
This Statute may be referred to as the “Torts Statute.”
(Source: WOS 2014-012, October 15, 2014, Section I)
11.1102
PURPOSE
To provide civil remedies to private persons within the jurisdiction of the Little Traverse
Bay Bands of Odawa Indians who are injured by the wrongful acts of others.
(Source: WOS 2014-012, October 15, 2014, Section II)
11.1103
JURISDICTION
The Tribe’s jurisdiction extends to persons who are Indians, tribal citizens, or who live or
work within the territorial jurisdiction of LTBB and who commit a tort or are injured by the
tortious acts of another within the territorial jurisdiction of the Little Traverse Bay Bands of
Odawa Indians, unless such claims fall within the Federal Tort Claims Act. The federal
government currently provides for the resolution of tort, malpractice and injury claims against
federally funded tribal activities under the Federal Tort Claims Act. Any such claim should be
pursued and subject to the provisions and procedures of the Federal Tort Claims Act and are not
within the jurisdiction of the Tribal Court.
(Source: WOS 2014-012, October 15, 2014, Section III)
11.1104
DEFINITIONS
A.
“Actual damages” means the ascertainable loss of money or property sustained as the
result of a tortious act.
59
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
B.
“Award” means money damages that the Tribal Court determines are payable to
compensate for an injury under this Statute.
C.
“Claim” means a petition for an award under this Statute. A claim may be filed with
respect to any injury under this Statute.
D.
“Dangerous condition” means a physical aspect of a facility or the use thereof
constituting an unreasonable risk to human health or safety that is known or should be known to
exist upon the exercise of reasonable care.
1.
For purposes of this subsection, a dangerous condition should be known to exist if
it is established that the condition existed for a period of time and was of a nature that in
the exercises of reasonable care, the condition and its dangerous character should have
been discovered.
2.
A dangerous condition does not exist solely because the design of a facility is
inadequate or because of the mere existence of natural physical conditions such has wind,
water, ice, or temperature.
E.
“Employee” means any person employed by another when acting within the course and
scope of their employment.
F.
“Indian” means any person who is an enrolled member of a federally recognized Indian
tribe.
G.
“Injury” means death, physical or emotional harm to a person, or damage or destruction of
property.
H.
“LTBB” means the Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians.
I.
“Malice” means the intent to commit a wrongful act that will result in harm to another
without just cause.
60
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
J.
“Offensive” means an act by another that a person of ordinary sensitivity would find
inappropriate.
K.
“Person” means any individual, firm, partnership, corporation, or other legally recognized
entity.
L.
“Reckless indifference” means conscious or reckless disregard of the consequences of
one’s acts or omissions.
M.
“Territorial jurisdiction of the Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians” means
“areas referenced in Public Law 103-324, 25 USC Section 1300k-2(b)(2)(A) as the boundaries of
the reservations for the Little Traverse Bay Bands as set out in Article I, paragraphs ‘third and
fourth’ of the Treaty of 1855, 11 Stat. 621.” Little Traverse Bay Bands Constitution, Article
V(A)(1)(a).
N.
“Tribal Court” means the court of the Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians.
O.
“Naawchigedaa” means “to set things straight” in Anishinaabemowin.
(Source: WOS 2014-012, October 15, 2014, Section IV)
11.1105
STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS
A plaintiff seeking relief under this Statute must file his or her claim with the Tribal
Court within three years of the date that the injury occurred or becomes known.
(Source: WOS 2014-012, October 15, 2014, Section V)
11.1106
CAUSES OF ACTION
In order to file a tort claim, the plaintiff must meet all requirements of one or more of the causes
of action as set out below. Plaintiffs may file multiple claims and claims with alternative theories
based on more than one cause of action.
61
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
A.
Intentional Torts.
1.
Assault. An assault occurs when the defendant places the plaintiff in reasonable
apprehension of an immediate battery.
a.
Words alone or threats of physical harm are insufficient for an assault,
unless those words or threats are accompanied by physical conduct or gestures.
b.
In this subsection, apprehension refers to the plaintiff’s knowledge of the
defendant’s apparent ability to commit an immediate battery. It does not mean
fear.
2.
Battery. A battery occurs when the defendant makes a harmful or offensive
contact with the plaintiff’s person.
3.
False Imprisonment. False imprisonment occurs when the defendant commits an
act of restraint that confines the plaintiff in a bounded area.
a.
An act of restraint can be any action, verbal or physical, that causes the
plaintiff to be confined.
b.
A bounded area is one where the plaintiff has no reasonable means of
escape.
4.
Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress (IIED). IIED occurs when the
defendant engages in extreme and outrageous conduct that causes the plaintiff to suffer
severe emotional distress.
a.
IIED can be caused intentionally by the defendant or by the defendant’s
reckless conduct.
b.
Outrageous conduct is conduct without just cause or excuse and exceeds
62
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
all bounds of decency. Such conduct can be proven by a showing of continuous
and repetitive conduct, conduct by a superior or someone in a supervisory
position, conduct directed at young children, the elderly, or a person who has a
medical condition that causes him or her to be particularly sensitive to such
conduct, or any other conduct that a reasonable person would consider to be
outrageous.
5.
Trespass to Land. A trespass to land occurs when the defendant intentionally and
physically invades the land of the plaintiff.
6.
Trespass to Chattels and Conversion.
a.
A trespass to chattels occurs when the defendant interferes with the
personal property of the plaintiff.
b.
A conversion occurs when there is a trespass to chattels that results in
complete destruction or loss of the personal property.
B.
Defamation. Defamation is an act of communication that causes someone to be shamed,
ridiculed, held in contempt, lowered in the estimation of the community, or to lose
employment status or earnings or otherwise suffer a damaged reputation. The Plaintiff
must prove that there was (1) a defamatory statement of fact; (2) concerning the plaintiff;
(3) which was false; (4) which was communicated to a person or persons other than the
plaintiff; (5) with actual knowledge that the statement was false or with reckless
disregard of the statement's truth or falsity or with negligence in failing to ascertain the
truth or falsity; and (6) which caused damage.
1.
Libel. Libel occurs where the defendant makes a defamatory statement
identifying the plaintiff and that statement is published in writing, or otherwise recorded,
that causes harm to the plaintiff’s reputation. A plaintiff’s damages are presumed in
successful libel actions.
2.
Slander. Slander occurs where the defendant makes a defamatory statement
63
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
identifying the plaintiff, that statement is orally made to at least one other person than the
plaintiff, and causes harm to the plaintiff’s reputation.
a.
Damages are presumed only when the plaintiff is successful in proving
slander per se.
b.
Slander per se occurs when the defendant makes a defamatory statement:
regarding the plaintiff’s business; that the plaintiff has committed a serious crime;
that the plaintiff displays occupational or professional incapacity; that the plaintiff
suffers from a loathsome disease; that has an immoral character.
c.
In regular slander actions, the plaintiff must offer evidence of economic
harm suffered or harm to the health . Social harm alone is insufficient evidence of
damages.
3.
Public Officials and Matters of Public Concern. If the plaintiff is a public
official and the statement is one of public concern, he or she must prove that the
defendant made the statement knowing it to be false or with a reckless disregard for its
accuracy in addition to the requirements under Section XI(B)(1) or (2), whichever is
applicable.
C.
Privacy Torts.
1.
Appropriation. An appropriation occurs when the defendant uses the plaintiff’s
name or image for a commercial purpose.
2.
Intrusion. An intrusion occurs when the defendant invades the plaintiff’s
physical seclusion in a way that would be highly offensive to an average person and the
plaintiff is in a place where the plaintiff reasonably expects to be a private place.
3.
False Light. The tort of false light occurs when the defendant’s conduct results in
the widespread dissemination of a major falsehood about the plaintiff that would be
offensive to an average person.
64
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
4.
Disclosure. A disclosure occurs when the defendant’s conduct results in the
widespread dissemination of confidential information about the plaintiff that would be
offensive to an average person.
D.
Business Torts.
1.
Fraud. Fraud occurs when the defendant makes a misrepresentation of a material
fact that the defendant knows or believes to be false with the intent to induce the plaintiff
to act or refrain from acting in reliance on the misrepresentation, the plaintiff justifiably
and actually relies on the misrepresentation, and the plaintiff suffers damages because of
it.
2.
Negligent Misrepresentation. Negligent misrepresentation occurs when the
defendant makes a misrepresentation in a business or professional capacity that breaches
a duty owed to a particular plaintiff that causes the plaintiff’s justifiable reliance and
results in damage to the plaintiff.
3.
Interference with a Business Relationship. Interference with a business
relationship occurs when the plaintiff has a valid contractual relationship with a third
party that the defendant has knowledge of and the defendant intentionally interferes with
that relationship by inducing the third party to breach or terminate the relationship and
such breach or termination causes harm to the plaintiff.
E.
Litigation Torts.
1.
Malicious Prosecution. Malicious Prosecution occurs when the defendant
initiates criminal proceedings against the plaintiff that terminate in favor of the plaintiff
and where the defendant had an improper purpose for initiating criminal proceedings and
lacked any reasonable probable cause.
2.
Abuse of Process. An abuse of process occurs when the defendant maliciously or
65
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
deliberately misuses a regularly issued civil court process that is not justified by the
underlying legal action or the abuser of process is interested only in accomplishing some
improper purpose.
F.
Negligence.
1.
In General. In all negligence actions, the plaintiff must prove that the defendant
owed the plaintiff a duty, the defendant breached that duty, and that the defendant’s
breach was the actual and proximate cause of the plaintiff’s injury.
2.
Ordinary Negligence. Negligence occurs when the defendant fails to exercise the
type of care toward the plaintiff that a reasonably prudent person would exercise under
similar circumstances.
3.
Malpractice. Malpractice occurs when a defendant-professional acts or continues
a course of conduct that does not meet the standard of professional competence in that
particular profession and causes provable damages to the plaintiff.
4.
Premises Liability. Owners and occupiers of land may be liable when his or her
own negligence causes another person to be injured on the occupier’s premises. An
occupier’s liability for another’s injury depends on the type of person entering the land.
a.
Trespassers. Owners and occupiers of land are only liable to known or
anticipated trespassers that are injured because of a highly dangerous and artificial
condition that the owner or occupier knew existed.
b.
Licensees. Owners and occupiers of land are liable to licensees that are
injured because of a hidden condition on the land that the occupier knew existed.
c.
Invitees. Owners and occupiers of land are liable to invitees that are
injured because of a hidden condition on the land that the occupier either knew
existed or could have discovered with reasonable inspection.
66
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
d.
Attractive Nuisance Doctrine. Owners and occupiers of land are subject
to liability for physical harm to children caused by an artificial condition on the
land if the following are met:
i.
the place where the condition exists is one that the owner or
occupier knows or has reason to know that children are likely to trespass;
ii.
the condition is one that the owner or occupier knows or has reason
to know of and realizes or should realize will involve an unreasonable risk
of death or serious bodily harm to children;
iii.
the children, because of their youth, do not discover the condition
or realize the risk involved in intermeddling with it or in coming within
the area made dangerous by it;
iv.
the owner’s or occupier’s utility of maintaining the condition and
the burden of eliminating the danger are slight compared with the risk
involved; and
v.
the owner or occupier fails to exercise reasonable care to eliminate
the danger or otherwise to protect the children.
G.
Strict Liability Torts.
1.
Abnormally Dangerous Activities. A defendant is strictly liable when he or she
is engaged in an abnormally dangerous activity that causes harm to another person. An
activity is considered to be abnormally dangerous when it creates a foreseeable risk of
serious harm even where reasonable care is exercised and that activity is uncommon in
the place where it is conducted.
2.
Wild Animals. A defendant is strictly liable when he or she is the owner of a wild
(undomesticated) animal and that animal causes harm to another person.
67
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
H.
Products Liability.
1.
A defendant is liable for an injury caused to another person when:
a.
the defendant is a merchant who regularly deals in products of the kind
involved;
b.
the product in question is defective;
c.
the defect in the product existed when the product left the defendant’s
place of business; and
d.
2.
the plaintiff was using the product in a foreseeable manner.
A product is deemed defective when any one of the following defects exist:
a.
Manufacturing defects exist when the product differs from all the others
that were produced at the same time in a way that makes it more dangerous than
consumers would expect.
b.
Design defects exist when there is a safer, yet feasible, way that the
product could have been built.
c.
Information defects exist when the product has residual risks that cannot
be designed out and consumers would not be aware of those risks without an
adequate warning.
3.
It is not a defense that the plaintiff misused the product. Such misuse by the
plaintiff is irrelevant if it is foreseeable that consumers may use that product in that way.
I.
Nuisance. A nuisance occurs when the plaintiff’s ability to use and enjoy his or her real
property has been disrupted to an unreasonable degree.
68
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
(Source: WOS 2014-012, October 15, 2014, Section VI)
11.1107
A.
DEFENSES
Affirmative Defenses to Intentional Torts.
1.
Consent. It is a complete defense to all intentional torts when the plaintiff
consents expressly or impliedly.
a.
Express consent occurs when the plaintiff makes a declaration of
permission for the defendant to act. However, express consent is not a defense if
the consent was obtained through fraud or duress.
b.
Implied consent occurs based on custom or based on the defendant’s
reasonable interpretation of the plaintiff’s objective conduct that the plaintiff
consents to such action.
c.
Any consent given by a plaintiff is limited to the scope of the consent
given. Where a defendant exceeds the scope of the plaintiff’s consent, consent is
not a valid defense.
2.
Self-Defense. This defense applies when the defendant is faced with an imminent
threat of force or injury. The defendant may only use an amount of force that is necessary
under the circumstances.
3.
Defense of Others. This defense applies when the defendant witnesses another
person faced with an imminent threat of force or injury. The defendant may only use an
amount of force that is necessary under the circumstances.
4.
Defense of Property. This defense applies when the defendant is faced with an
imminent threat of damage to or loss of property. The defendant may only use an amount
of force that is necessary under the circumstances.
69
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
5.
Necessity. The defense of necessity only applies to torts involving property.
a.
A defense based on public necessity applies when the defendant commits
a property tort in an emergency to protect the community as a whole or to protect
a significant group of people. This is an absolute defense to tort liability.
b.
A defense based on private necessity applies when the defendant commits
a property tort to protect his own interest. This is not an absolute defense,
therefore, the defendant may be liable to the plaintiff for any actual damage done
to plaintiff’s property.
B.
Affirmative Defenses to Defamation.
1.
Consent. It is an affirmative defense to defamation if the plaintiff consents to the
defendant’s making and publishing the statement. See Section VII(A)(1).
2.
Truth. A defendant is not liable for a defamatory statement if the statement made
is true.
3.
Absolute Privileges. A defendant is not liable for a defamatory statement if the
defamatory statement is made to the defendant’s spouse or made by an official in the
course of official functions.
a.
Definition. “Official” means any person who is elected or appointed that
acts on behalf of the Tribe.
b.
Definition. “Official functions” mean any acts taken by an official within
the scope of that official’s position.
4.
Qualified Privileges. A defendant may not be liable for a defamatory statement if
the defendant made the statement in good faith and the statement made was confined to
relevant matters.
70
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
a.
This privilege only applies in situations where there is a public interest in
encouraging candor (e.g., employment references).
b.
Definition. “Good faith” in this subsection means that the defendant had a
reasonable belief that the statement made was accurate.
C.
Affirmative Defenses to Privacy Torts.
1.
Consent. It is an affirmative defense if the plaintiff consents to the invasion. See
Section VII(A)(1).
2.
Defamation Privileges. A defendant is not liable for the torts of false light or
disclosure if either an absolute or qualified privilege applies. See Section VII(B)(3) and
(4).
D.
Affirmative Defense to Negligence Torts – Comparative Negligence. A defendant can
lower his or her liability by proving that the plaintiff failed to exercise proper care for his or her
own safety.
1.
The judge or the jury must allocate a percentage of fault to each party. The
plaintiff’s recovery must be reduced by his or her own percentage of fault.
2.
When the percentage of fault allocated to the plaintiff is more than 50%, and that
fault is due to the plaintiff’s intoxication, the plaintiff may not recover.
E.
Affirmative Defense to Products Liability. A defendant can lower his or liability by
proving that the plaintiff failed to take proper precautions. The rules of comparative negligence
apply; see SECTION VII(D).
F.
Sovereign Immunity.
1.
Tribal Immunity from Suit. LTBB, including all subordinate entities, officials
and employees are immune from suit except to the extent that the Tribal Council clearly and
71
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
expressly waives its sovereign immunity, provided that the Tribe, subordinate entity, official or
employee of the Tribe acting within the scope of their duties or authority. If the Tribe, including
any subordinate entity, official or employee of the Tribe, who acts beyond the scope of their
duties and authority in which the tortious actions include either acting with malice or with
reckless indifference, or both, then the tortious action is not within the sovereign immunity of
the Tribe.
(Source: WOS 2014-012, October 15, 2014, Section VII)
11.1108
REMEDIES
A.
Damages. Damages are available in any tort claim where the plaintiff can prove with
reasonable certainty monetary loss or harm suffered because of the tortious acts of the defendant.
Damages may include the following:
1.
loss of wages;
2.
loss of profits;
3.
medical expenses;
4.
pain and suffering;
5.
loss of consortium;
6.
loss of future earnings; and
7.
market or rental value of destroyed property.
B.
Restitution. Restitution is available where the plaintiff can be restored by putting the
plaintiff in a similar position as he or she was prior to the tortious act. Restitution may include
the following:
72
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
1.
restitution damages calculated by the defendant’s gain;
2.
return of the plaintiff’s property;
3.
ejectment of a trespasser from the plaintiff’s property; and
4.
any other action or remedy as deemed appropriate to make the plaintiff whole.
C.
Injunctions. Where monetary or restitutionary remedies will not make the plaintiff whole
again, the judge may order an injunction to prevent the defendant from continuing or repeating
the tortious behavior in the future.
(Source: WOS 2014-012, October 15, 2014, Section VIII)
11.1109
SAVINGS CLAUSE
In the event that any phrase, provision, part, paragraph, subsection or section of this
statute is found by a court of competent jurisdiction to violate the Constitution, laws or
ordinances of the Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians, such phrase, provision, part,
paragraph, subsection or section shall be considered to stand alone and to be deleted from this
statute, the entirety of the balance of the statute to remain in full and binding force and effect.
(Source: WOS 2014-012, October 15, 2014, Section IX)
11.1110
EFFECTIVE DATE
Effective upon signature of the Executive or shall be deemed enacted if not expressly vetoed by
the Executive within thirty (30) days of submission. The Tribal Council may, by an affirmative
vote of seven (7) members of the Tribal Council, override a veto by the Executive.
(Source: WOS 2014-012, October 15, 2014, Section X)
73
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
Chapter 12. General Welfare
11.1201
SHORT STATUTE
This Statute may be cited as the “General Welfare Statute,” and it repeals and replaces any prior
Statute or Regulation in conflict with this Statute.
(Source: WOS 2017-002, June 2, 2017, Section I)
11.1202
PURPOSE
A.
The Tribe provides Assistance to Applicants and desires to affirm its sovereign right to
do so on a non-taxable basis, pursuant to the General Welfare Doctrine. Both the United States
Congress, through its enactment of the Tribal General Welfare Exclusion Act of 2014, and the
Internal Revenue Service, through its traditional application of the general welfare doctrine and
subsequent guidance, has recognized the sovereign right of Indian tribal governments to provide
financial assistance to its citizens under certain circumstances on a non-taxable basis.
B.
The purpose of this Statute is to set forth the guidelines for programs that are used by
the Tribe to determine what services or programs are needed to promote public health, safety
and other basic need services for the promotion of the general welfare of the Tribe, such as
food, utilities, housing, education assistance and other such functions that support the long
historical and cultural general welfare of the Tribe.
C.
The purpose of this Statute is to establish basic guidelines and procedures for
programs to follow in ensuring compliance with the general welfare doctrine and Internal
Revenue Code Section 139E for 1) Applicants applying for Assistance and 2) Tribal staff
making eligibility determinations for Assistance. Further, it is the intent of the Tribal Council
that all Assistance provided under this Statute:
1.
Is made under an Approved Program;
74
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
2.
Is available to any Applicants who satisfy the program policies, subject to
budgetary restraints;
3.
Is made under an Approved Program that does not discriminate in favor of
members of the Tribal Council;
4.
Is not provided as compensation for goods and/or services; and
5.
Is not lavish or extravagant under the facts and circumstances, as determined by
the Tribal Council.
(Source: WOS 2017-002, June 2, 2017, Section II)
11.1203
DEFINITIONS
A.
“Administrative Entity(s)” means a department or program of the Tribal government that
is authorized and funded, through a Tribal Council approved budget, to administer and provide
Assistance under an Approved Program under this Statute.
B.
“Applicant(s)” means an enrolled Tribal citizen or qualified non-citizen who has applied
for Assistance under this Statute. It also includes an Identified Group, as defined in subsection
M, below;
C.
“Approved Program(s)” means any program or programs approved by the Tribal Council
to provide general welfare assistance to Applicants that is intended to qualify for treatment under
the General Welfare Doctrine, as defined herein. It includes, for example, the payment of
benefits related to housing, education, elder or disabled status, cultural and religious programs or
for other qualifying assistance, such as transportation costs, etc.
D.
“Assistance” means any Program benefits or payments that qualify for tax free
treatment under the General Welfare Exclusion.
E.
“Beneficiary” means any person or persons entitled to receive Assistance in accordance
75
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
with specific Program policies and are exempted under Internal Revenue Code, Section 139E
and may benefit, including: Tribal Citizens, spouses of a Tribal Citizen, and/or dependents of a
Tribal Citizen.
F.
“Citizen” or “Tribal citizen” means an enrolled member of Little Traverse Bay Bands of
Odawa Indians.
G.
“Code” means the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended.
H.
“Compensation” for services should reflect that qualifying Programs are not
disguised employment. However, this shall not prevent the Tribe from structuring Programs
with community service ties so long as such ties are consistent with the General Welfare
Exclusion.
I.
“Constitution” means the Constitution of the Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa
Indians.
J.
“Executive” means the Executive Branch of government under Article VIII of the
Constitution the power of which is vested in the Tribal Chairperson and the Vice-Chairperson.
K.
“General Welfare Exclusion" means any assistance shall be treated as non- taxable
so long as it satisfies the requirements for exclusion under Code Section 139E, it is provided
under a Safe Harbor Program, or it meets the General Test.
L.
“General Test” means any assistance will be treated as meeting the General Test under
the General Welfare Exclusion if the benefits are:
1.
Paid by or on behalf of an Indian tribe;
2.
Under a social benefit program;
3.
Based on either needs of the Indian community itself or upon individual needs
of the recipient (which need not be financial in nature);
76
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
4.
Are not Compensation for services;
5.
Are not gaming per capita payments as referenced in the Indian Gaming
Regulatory Act.
M.
“Identified Group” means Tribal citizens and qualified non-citizens who are members of
an identified group, such as Elders.
N.
"Lavish" or "Extravagant" shall have the meaning determined by the Tribal Council in
its sole discretion based on all facts and circumstances, taking into account needs unique to the
Tribe as well as the social purpose being served by the particular Assistance at hand, except as
otherwise may be required for compliance with final guidance issued under IRS Code Section
139E following consultation between the Tribe and the IRS;
O.
“Indian Gaming Regulatory Act”, “IGRA” means the United States federal law that
establishes the jurisdictional framework that governs Indian gaming, Federal Act (Pub.L. 100–
497, 25 U.S.C. § 2701 et seq.
P.
“Reservation” in accordance with Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians
Constitution, Article III, Section H, means the lands within the boundaries of the reservations
for the Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians as set out in Art I, paragraphs third and
fourth of the Treaty of 1855, 11 Stat. 621, plus any lands set out in Articles Second and Third of
the Treaty of March 28, 1836, 7 Stat. 491, in the event that the 1836 reservation is determined
to include lands which are not included within the 1855 reservation, plus any lands outside of
those boundaries which are now or in the future declared to be Little Traverse Bay Bands of
Odawa Indians reservation by the U.S. Department of Interior.
Q.
"Safe Harbor Program" shall refer to a Program that meets the safe harbor requirements set
forth herein and IRS Revenue Procedure 2014-35, as the same may hereafter be amended. Need
shall be presumed for Assistance provided under a Safe Harbor Program.
R.
"Tribal Council" or "Council" means the Council Members of the Little Traverse
77
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
Bay Bands of Odawa Indians.
(Source: WOS 2017-002, June 2, 2017, Section III)
11.1204
RATIFICATION OF PRIOR ACTS; INTENT OF LEGISLATION
A.
This Statute does not establish a new program or programs. This Statute is intended to
set forth and confirm existing procedures used in the administration of general welfare
assistance programs and services and is not to be construed as the creation of new general
welfare assistance rights that previously did not exist.
B.
Assistance provided prior to the enactment of this Statute is hereby ratified and
confirmed as general welfare assistance pursuant to the authority of the Tribal Constitution.
It is intended to establish a framework to improve the coordination of general welfare
doctrine compliance. Programs and services, referred to herein, are authorized by the
enactment of this statute in conjunction with other applicable laws.
(Source: WOS 2017-002, June 2, 2017, Section IV)
11.1205
GENERAL WELFARE DOCTRINE AND IRS REVENUE PROCEDURE
2014-35/TRIBAL GENERAL WELFARE EXCLUSION OF 2014
A.
The Internal Revenue Service recognizes that Assistance to Applicants under a
legislatively provided Approved Program for the promotion of the general welfare of the Tribe is
excludable from the gross income of those Applicants.
B.
In addition, the Service, in IRS Revenue Procedure 2014-35, provided for safe harbor
programs under which, if approved and in writing, need would be presumed and qualifying
benefits would be excluded.
C.
The Assistance authorized by this Statute is intended to qualify for such favorable tax
treatment under the General Welfare Doctrine to the fullest extent permitted at law. All amounts
78
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
budgeted by the Tribe for Assistance shall remain general assets of the Tribe until such payments
are disbursed.
D.
Assistance authorized by this Statute shall be an unfunded arrangement and shall be
limited to funds appropriated, at the discretion of the Council.
E.
Assistance is not subject to information reporting by the Tribe to the Internal Revenue
Service.
F.
Without limitation, the following benefits shall be treated as non-taxable hereunder:
1.
Benefits that satisfy the requirements for the exemption under Code Section
139E;
2.
Benefits that qualify for exclusion under an IRS Safe Harbor Program;
3.
Benefits that qualify for exclusion under the IRS General Test of General Welfare
exclusion; or
4.
Benefits that meet another express exemption under the Internal Revenues Code,
such as the exemption provided for tribal medical expenses under Internal Revenue Code
Section 139D, or that meet other recognized exemptions including, for example, resource
or land-based exemptions under 25 USC Sections 117a-b, 1407 and 1408.
(Source: WOS 2017-002, June 2, 2017, Section V)
11.1206
NON-RESOURCE DESIGNATION
A.
Assistance to Applicants shall be made from the assets of the Tribal government and all
payments are subject to the availability of budgeted Tribal government funds.
B.
The Tribe does not guarantee Assistance under this Statute. Assistance shall not be
treated as a resource of an Applicant for any purpose.
79
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
(Source: WOS 2017-002, June 2, 2017, Section VI)
11.1207
GOVERNING LAW; SOVEREIGNTY
A.
All the rights and liabilities associated with the enactment of this Statute, or the
Assistance made hereunder, shall be construed and enforced according to the laws of the Tribe
and applicable federal law.
B.
Nothing in this Statute or the related policies or procedures adopted for its
implementation, if any, shall be construed to make applicable to the Tribe any laws or
regulations 1) which are otherwise inapplicable to the Tribe, or 2) from which the Tribe is
entitled to exemption because of its sovereign status.
(Source: WOS 2017-002, June 2, 2017, Section VII)
11.1208
FEDERAL TRUST OBLIGATIONS
A.
The Tribe reserves the right to provide Assistance in circumstances where federal funding
is insufficient to operate federal programs designed to benefit Applicants and when federal
funding is insufficient to adequately and consistently fulfill federal trust obligations.
B.
The Tribe’s adoption of its Approved Programs is not intended to relieve or diminish the
federal government of its funding and trust responsibilities. Nothing herein shall waive the
Tribe’s right to seek funding shortfalls or to enforce the trust rights of the Tribe and its citizens.
The Tribe shall be entitled to government-to-government consultation and coordination rights in
regard to this Statute with the federal government.
(Source: WOS 2017-002, June 2, 2017, Section VIII)
11.1209
TRIBAL COUNCIL APPROVED PROGRAMS
80
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
A.
The Tribal Council shall designate Approved Programs for which funds will be budgeted
each fiscal year, consistent with the purposes of this Statute. Each Approved Program shall be
consistent with the General Welfare Doctrine as to purpose, eligibility, and funding.
B.
Tribal Council reserves the right to cancel, adjust, modify or revoke any Assistance
provided by the Tribe in accordance with the Budget Formulation Statute, including Allocation
of General Fund Balance, Supplemental Funding Process, Budget Modifications, Emergency
budgets/Recessions, and Systematic Reductions of Budgets.
(Source: WOS 2017-002, June 2, 2017, Section IX)
11.1210
PURPOSE OF APPROVED PROGRAMS
Each Approved Program shall be limited to purposes consistent with treatment under the General
Welfare Doctrine. An Approved Program must be established and operated to promote the
general welfare of the Tribe, including programs designed to enhance the promotion of health,
education, self-sufficiency, self-determination, Tribal character and the maintenance of culture
and tradition, entrepreneurship, and employment.
(Source: WOS 2017-002, June 2, 2017, Section X)
11.1211
ELIGIBILITY AND APPLICATION PROCEDURES
Assistance intended to qualify for General Welfare Doctrine treatment shall be limited to
enrolled citizens of the Tribe and qualified non-citizens. Each Approved Program shall set forth
the specific eligibility rules and limitations applied to that program. The Executive shall present
program descriptions and policies, which include eligibility rules and limitations, to the Tribal
Council for approval in accordance with this Statute. Only those descriptions and policies that
are so approved by the Council shall be considered to be in force and effect.
(Source: WOS 2017-002, June 2, 2017, Section XI)
11.1212
LIMITED USE OF ASSISTANCE PAYMENTS
81
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
All Assistance must be used for the purpose stated in the Approved Program description and
policy. In the event that Assistance is used or pledged for a purpose inconsistent with the purpose
set forth in an Approved Program or the Applicant’s application, the payment will be deemed
forfeited. The Administrative Entity responsible for the Approved Program under which the
misused Assistance was made shall secure repayment from the Applicant. The Administrative
Entity is also authorized to offset any other payments owed to such an Applicant, if an offset is
necessary to secure repayment of Assistance under this Statute.
(Source: WOS 2017-002, June 2, 2017, Section XII)
11.1213
PROGRAMS NOT LIMITED TO MEANS TESTING
Programs that qualify under Code Section 139E or the IRS Safe Harbor shall not require a
showing of individual need or means testing in order to achieve non-taxable treatment under the
General Welfare exclusion. The Tribe also reserves the right to provide community-based
Programs and programs based on non-financial needs under the General test so that no individual
means testing is needed. The Tribe recognizes that means testing can distort certain tribal
cultural and community values. However, the Tribe can have some programs which are financial
need based in order to help those most in need of the assistance.
(Source: WOS 2017-002, June 2, 2017, Section XIII)
11.1215
ANNUAL BUDGETING: UNFUNDED PROGRAM
When applicable per program requirements, the Council shall annually designate those funding
sources that are available for Approved Programs as part of the annual budgeting process.
Notwithstanding anything to the contrary, the Assistance authorized hereunder shall be
“unfunded” for tax purposes and no Applicant shall have an interest in or right to any funds
budgeted for or set aside for Approved Programs until paid. Assistance funds shall remain assets
of the Tribe until distributed and the Approved Programs shall be administered at all times to
avoid triggering of the doctrines of “constructive receipt” and/or “economic benefit.”
82
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
(Source: WOS 2017-002, June 2, 2017, Section XV)
11.1216
FORFEITURE
Notwithstanding anything herein to the contrary, the Executive, acting on behalf of the Council,
may forfeit Assistance to any Applicant who is found to have violated the terms of this Statute,
or the policies and procedures for any Approved Program. The Executive may also forfeit
Assistance should said Assistance be treated as a resource detrimental to the Tribe or an
Applicant. In the event of any such forfeiture, all Assistance provided to the Applicant pursuant
to this Statute shall be deemed a loan and shall be enforceable as such. Such loans may be
subject to taxation, including any amount for the forgiveness of a loan.
(Source: WOS 2017-002, June 2, 2017, Section XVI)
11.1217
ANTI-ALIENATION
An Applicant’s right to apply for Assistance is not subject to anticipation, alienation, sale,
transfer, assignment, pledge, encumbrance, attachment or garnishment by creditors of the
Applicant.
(Source: WOS 2017-002, June 2, 2017, Section XVII)
11.1218
GENERAL
Each Approved Program shall be administered by the Administrative Entity. All the powers and
duties conferred on each respective Administrative Entity shall be exercised or performed by it in
the exercise of its discretion regardless of whether the provision conferring such power or
imposing such duty specifically refers to its discretion. All decisions of a given Administrative
Entity regarding an Approved Program, within the scope of its authority, shall be binding and
conclusive upon all Applicants under the Approved Program.
(Source: WOS 2017-002, June 2, 2017, Section XVIII)
83
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
11.1219
PROGRAM POLICIES
A.
Policies for Approved Programs shall be developed by the respective Department staff
responsible for a given Assistance Program, coordinated through the Executive, if applicable,
and approved by the Tribal Council. At a minimum, such policies shall satisfy the requirements
of this Statute including the following:
B.
Indian General Welfare Benefits (Code Section 139E) Programs that meet the following
criteria for exemption under Code Section 139E shall be treated as non-taxable Assistance under
the General Welfare exclusion without the applicant having to demonstrate individual need:
1.
The program is administered under specified policies and does not discriminate in
favor of the members of the Tribal Council;
2.
Program benefits are available to any Tribal citizen who meets such policy
requirements;
3.
Program benefits are for the promotion of the general welfare;
4.
Program benefits are not lavish or extravagant; and
5.
Program benefits are not compensation for services.
C.
Ceremonial Activities: Any items of cultural significance, reimbursement of costs or cash
honorarium for participation in cultural or ceremonial activities for the transmission of tribal
culture shall not be treated as compensation for services.
D.
Safe Harbor programs: Programs that meet the following general criteria for safe harbor
treatment, and provide qualifying safe harbor benefits, shall be treated as non-taxable Assistance
under the General Welfare Exclusion without the applicant having to demonstrate individual
need:
1.
General Criteria for Safe Harbor Treatment:
84
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
a.
The benefit is provided under a specific approved program of the Tribe;
b.
The program has written policies specifying how individuals may qualify
for the benefit;
c.
The benefit is available to any Tribal citizen, identified group of Tribal
citizens, or qualified non-citizen who satisfy the program policies, subject to
budgetary restraints;
d.
The distribution of benefits from the program does not discriminate in
favor of the governing body of the Tribe;
e.
The benefit is not compensation for goods or services; and
f.
The benefit is not lavish or extravagant under the facts and circumstances,
as determined by the Tribal Council.
2.
Specific Safe Harbors: The following benefits may be provided under a Safe
Harbor program. The benefits listed in the parenthetical language herein are illustrative
only, rather than an exhaustive list. Thus, a benefit may qualify for exclusion from gross
income as a Safe Harbor Program even though the benefit is not expressly described in
the parenthetical language herein, provided that it meets all other requirements of the
Internal Revenue Service, and Revenue Procedure 2014-35 (as may be amended):
a.
Housing programs. Programs relating to principal residences and ancillary
structures that are not used in any trade or business, or for investment purposes
that—
i.
Pay mortgage payments, down payments, or rent payments
(including but not limited to security deposits) for principal
residences;
85
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
ii.
iii.
iv.
v.
b.
Enhance habitability of housing, such as by remedying water,
sewage, or sanitation service, safety issues (including, but not
limited to, mold remediation), or heating or cooling issues;
Provide basic housing repairs or rehabilitation (including, but not
limited to, roof repair and replacement);
Pay utility bills and charges (including, but not limited to, water,
electricity, gas, and basic communications services such as phone,
internet, and cable); or
Pay property taxes or make payments in lieu of taxes (PILOTs).
Educational programs. Programs to –
i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
Provide students (including, but not limited to, post-secondary
students) transportation to and from school, tutors, and supplies
(including, but not limited to, clothing, backpacks, laptop
computers, musical instruments, and sports equipment) for use in
school activities and extracurricular activities;
Provide tuition payments for students (including, but not limited
to, allowances for room and board on or off campus for the
student, spouse, domestic partner, and dependents) to attend
preschool, school, college or university, online school, educational
seminars, vocational education, technical education, adult
education, continuing education, or alternative education;
Provide for the care of children away from their homes to help
their parents or other relatives responsible for their care to be
gainfully employed or to pursue education; and
Provide job counseling and programs for which the primary
objective is job placement or training, including, but not limited to,
allowances for expenses for interviewing or training away from
home (including, but not limited to, travel, auto expenses, lodging,
and food); tutoring; and appropriate clothing for a job interview or
training (including, but not limited to, an interview suit or a
uniform required during a period of training).
86
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
c.
Elder and disabled programs. Programs for individuals who have reached
age 55 or are mentally or physically disabled (as defined under applicable law,
including, but not limited to, tribal government disability codes or laws) that
provide –
i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
d.
Meals through home-delivered meal programs or at a community
center or similar facility;
Home care such as assistance with preparing meals or doing
chores, or day care outside the home;
Local transportation assistance; and
Improvements to adapt housing to special needs (including but not
limited to grab bars and ramps).
Cultural and religious programs. Programs to –
i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
v.
Pay expenses (including, but not limited to, admission fees,
transportation, food, and lodging) to attend or participate in an
Indian tribe’s cultural, social, religious, or community activities
such as pow-wows, ceremonies, and traditional dances;
Pay expenses (including, but not limited to, admission fees,
transportation, food, and lodging) to visit sites that are culturally or
historically significant for the Tribe, including, but not limited to,
those on other Indian reservations;
Pay the costs of receiving instruction about an Indian tribe’s
culture, history, and traditions (including, but not limited to,
traditional language, music, and dances);
Pay funeral and burial expenses and expenses of hosting or
attending wakes, funerals, burials, other bereavement events, and
subsequent honoring events; and
Pay transportation costs and admission fees to attend educational,
social, or cultural programs offered or supported by the Tribe or
another tribe.
87
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
e.
Other qualifying assistance programs. Programs to –
i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
v.
vi.
Pay transportation costs such as rental cars, substantiated mileage,
and fares for bus, taxi, and public transportation between an Indian
reservation, service area, or service unit area and facilities that
provide essential services to the public (such as medical facilities
and grocery stores);
Pay for the cost of transportation, temporary meals, and lodging of
a Tribal citizen or Qualified Non-citizen while the individual is
receiving medical care away from home;
Provide assistance to individuals in exigent circumstances
(including, but not limited to, victims of abuse), including, but not
limited to, the costs of food, clothing, shelter, transportation, auto
repair bills, and similar expenses;
Pay costs for temporary relocation and shelter for individuals
displaced from their homes (including, but not limited to,
situations in which a home is destroyed by a fire or natural
disaster);
Provide assistance for transportation emergencies (for example,
when stranded away from home) in the form of transportation
costs, a hotel room, and meals; and
Pay the cost of nonprescription drugs (including but not limited to
traditional Indian tribal medicines).
3.
Compensation Safe Harbor: For Safe Harbor Programs, and subject to
amendments to Revenue Procedure 2014-35 hereafter, the Tribe will presume that
individual need is met for religious leaders or spiritual officials or leaders (including but
not limited to Pipe-carriers, Firekeepers, Traditional Healers, the Drum and Singers,
Flag-carriers, and other cultural or spiritual and religious officiants.)) receiving the
following benefits, and that the benefits do not represent Compensation for services:
benefits provided under an Indian tribal governmental Program that are items of cultural
significance that are not lavish or extravagant under the facts and circumstances, as
88
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
determined by the Tribal Council, or nominal cash honoraria provided to religious or
spiritual officials or leaders (including, but not limited to, Pipe-carriers, Firekeepers,
Traditional Healers, the Drum and Singers, Flag-carriers, and other cultural or spiritual
and religious officiants.) to recognize their participation in cultural, religious, and social
events (including, but not limited to, pow-wows, rite of passage ceremonies, funerals,
wakes, burials, other bereavement events, and subsequent honoring events).
In accordance with 26 U.S. Code § 139E - Indian General Welfare Benefits, “deference
shall be given to Indian tribal governments for the programs administered and authorized
by the tribe to benefit the general welfare of the tribal community.”
Non-Safe Harbor Programs: Nothing in this Statute or the IRS safe harbor guidance shall
limit the Tribe's right to provide Assistance outside of the safe harbor rules.
Any changes to the Safe Harbor programs as a result of the Indian General Welfare
Exclusion Act of 2014 will be immediately incorporated, by reference, into this Statute.
(Source: WOS 2017-002, June 2, 2017, Section XIX)
11.1220
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT TRIBAL ADVISORY COMMITEE
The Tribe may utilize the Treasury Tribal Advisory Committee (TTAC) to assist in making
determinations of criteria for general welfare exclusion. In accordance with the Federal Law,
Tribal General Welfare Exclusion Act of 2014, TTAC members will advise the United States
Department of Treasury Secretary on matters related to the taxation of Indians, the training of
Internal Revenue Service field agents, and the provision of training and technical assistance to
Native American financial officers.
(Source: WOS 2017-002, June 2, 2017, Section XX)
11.1221
SEVERABILITY
If any section, subsection, paragraph, sentence, phrase or portion of this Statute is, for
89
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
any reason, held invalid or unconstitutional by any court of competent jurisdiction, such portion
shall be deemed a separate, distinct and independent provision and such holding shall not affect
the validity of the remaining portions thereof.
(Source: WOS 2017-002, June 2, 2017, Section XXI)
11.1222
EFFECTIVE DATE
Effective upon signature of the Executive or 30 days from Tribal Council approval
whichever comes first or if the Executive vetoes the legislation, then upon Tribal Council
override of the veto.
(Source: WOS 2017-002, June 2, 2017, Section XXII)
11.1223
OTHER RELATED STATUTES
See WOS 2015-016 Tribal Government Budget Formulation and Modification Statute, WOS
#2015-019 Administrative Procedures Statute, or as may be amended.
(Source: WOS 2017-002, June 2, 2017, Section XXIII)
90
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
Chapter 13. Waiver of Fees for Military Veterans Statute
11.1301
PURPOSE
The Waiver of Fees for Military Veterans Statute is hereby enacted to honor our Little Traverse
Bay Bands of Odawa Indians Military Veterans in accordance with the Constitution, Article I, B.
Directive Principles: “Promote with special care the health, educational and economic interests
of all the people, especially our children and elders . . .”.
(Source: WOS 2021-009, July 7, 2021, Section I)
11.1302
GENERAL WELFARE EXCLUSION
As stated by the requirements of the United States Internal Revenue Section 139E, the Waiver of
Fees for Military Veterans meets the criteria of the United States Public Law 113-168, Tribal
General Welfare Exclusion Act of 2014 and WOS 2017-002 General Welfare Statute.
(Source: WOS 2021-009, July 7, 2021, Section II)
11.1303DEFINITIONS
A.
“Citizen” shall mean an enrolled member of the Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa
Indians.
B.
“Executive” shall mean the Tribal Chairperson or his/her designee
C.
“LTBB” means The Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians.
D.
“Military Veteran” means a person who served in the active military, naval, or air
service, and who was discharged or released therefrom under conditions other than
dishonorable this includes United States Army, Navy, Marine Corps, Air Force, Coast
Guard service, and members of the Reserves, Air or Army National Guard.
91
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
E.
“Tribe” or “LTBB” means the Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians.
(Source: WOS 2021-009, July 7, 2021, Section III)
11.1304
WAIVER OF FEES
A.
The Executive has the authority to waive fees collected by the Executive Branch for
Military Veterans.
B.
These fees may include, by not limited to the following:
1.
Hunting and fishing licenses
2.
Enrollment cards
3.
Notarial acts
C.
When the Executive approves a fee to be waived, the Executive shall post a notice to the
tribal website; and publish a list of fees waived annually in the tribal newspaper, or similar
means of communication.
(Source: WOS 2021-009, July 7, 2021, Section IV)
11.1305
A.
B.
REPORTING REQUIRED
The Executive shall report to annually to Tribal Council:
1.
The number of Military Veterans that received a waiver of fees.
2.
The total dollar amount of fees waived.
Tribal Council may request the Executive provide additional information, if necessary.
92
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
(Source: WOS 2021-009, July 7, 2021, Section V)
11.1306
SEVERABILITY
If any section, subsection, paragraph, sentence, phrase or portion of this Statute is, for any reason,
held invalid or unconstitutional by any court of competent jurisdiction, such portion shall be
deemed a separate, distinct and independent provision and such holding shall not affect the validity
of the remaining portions thereof.
(Source: WOS 2021-009, July 7, 2021, Section VI)
11.1307
EFFECTIVE DATE
Effective upon signature of the Executive or thirty (30) days from Tribal Council approval
whichever comes first or if the Executive vetoes the legislation, then upon Tribal Council
override of the veto.
(Source: WOS 2021-009, July 7, 2021, Section VII)
93
WOTCL TITLE XI. HEALTH, WELLNESS AND EDUCATION last codified through March 1, 2024 – See
Register for Details
Version 2024.2
Chapter 14. Medicare Reimbursement Honorarium Act
11.1401
PURPOSE
The Medicare Reimbursement Honorarium Act is hereby enacted to provide a gift to honor our
Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians Elders in accordance with the Constitution, Article
I, B. Directive Principles: “Promote with special care the health, educational and economic
interests of all the people, especially our children and elders . . .”
(Source: WOS 2021-012, July 7, 2021, Section I)
11.1402
GENERAL WELFARE EXCLUSION
As stated by the requirements of the United States Internal Revenue Section 139E, the Medicare
Reimbursement Honorarium meets the criteria of the United State
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.