Energy Conservation Program for Consumer Products: Decision and Order Granting a Waiver From the Furnace Test Procedure to Trane Company

DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY

[Case No. F-080]

Energy Conservation Program for Consumer Products: Decision and

Order Granting a Waiver From the Furnace Test Procedure to Trane

Company

AGENCY: Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, Department of

Energy.

ACTION: Decision and order.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: Notice is given of the Decision and Order (Case No. F-080)

granting a Waiver to Trane Company (Trane) from the existing Department

of Energy (DOE) test procedure for furnaces. The Department is granting

Trane's Petition for Waiver regarding blower time delay in calculation

of Annual Fuel Utilization Efficiency (AFUE) for its Models TUD-C/AUD-

C, TDD-C/ADD-C, TUD-R/AUD-R, TDD-R/ADD-R, TUD-R-V/AUD-R-V, TDD-R-V/ADD-

R-V, TUY-R-V/AUY-R-V, and TDY-R-V/ADY-R-V central furnaces.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:

Cyrus H. Nasseri, U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Energy

Efficiency and Renewable Energy, Mail Station EE-431, Forrestal

Building, 1000 Independence Avenue SW., Washington, DC 20585, (202)

586-9138

Eugene Margolis, Esq., U.S. Department of Energy, Office of General

Counsel, Mail Station GC-72, Forrestal Building, 1000 Independence

Avenue SW., Washington, DC 20585, (202) 586-9507

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: In accordance with 10 CFR 430.27(g), notice

is hereby given of the issuance of the Decision and Order as set out

below. In the Decision and Order, Trane has been granted a Waiver for

its Models TUD-C/AUD-C, TDD-C/ADD-C, TUD-R/AUD-R, TDD-R/ADD-R, TUD-R-V/

AUD-R-V, TDD-R-V/ADD-R-V, TUY-R-V/AUY-R-V, and TDY-R-V/ADY-R-V central

furnaces, permitting the company to use an alternate test method in

determining AFUE.

Issued in Washington, DC, on November 29, 1995.

Christine A. Ervin,

Assistant Secretary, Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy.

Decision and Order; Department of Energy, Office of Energy Efficiency

and Renewable Energy

In the Matter of: Trane Company.

[Case No. F-080]

Background

The Energy Conservation Program for Consumer Products (other than

automobiles) was established pursuant to the Energy Policy and

Conservation Act (EPCA), Public Law 94-163, 89 Stat. 917, as amended by

the National Energy Conservation Policy Act (NECPA), Public Law 95-619,

92 Stat. 3266, the National Appliance Energy Conservation Act of 1987

(NAECA), Public Law 100-12, the National Appliance Energy Conservation

Amendments of 1988 (NAECA 1988), Public Law 100-357, and the Energy

Policy Act of 1992 (EPAct), Public Law 102-486, 106 Stat. 2776, which

requires DOE to prescribe standardized test procedures to measure the

energy consumption of certain consumer products, including furnaces.

The intent of the test procedures is to provide a comparable measure of

energy consumption that will assist consumers in making purchasing

decisions. These test procedures appear at 10 CFR Part 430, Subpart B.

The Department amended the prescribed test procedures by adding 10

[[Page 62836]]

CFR 430.27 to create a waiver process. 45 FR 64108, September 26, 1980.

Thereafter, DOE further amended its appliance test procedure waiver

process to allow the Assistant Secretary for Energy Efficiency and

Renewable Energy (Assistant Secretary) to grant an Interim Waiver from

test procedure requirements to manufacturers that have petitioned DOE

for a waiver of such prescribed test procedures. 51 FR 42823, November

26, 1986.

The waiver process allows the Assistant Secretary to waive

temporarily test procedures for a particular basic model when a

petitioner shows that the basic model contains one or more design

characteristics which prevent testing according to the prescribed test

procedures or when the prescribed test procedures may evaluate the

basic model in a manner so unrepresentative of its true energy

consumption as to provide materially inaccurate comparative data.

Waivers generally remain in effect until final test procedure

amendments become effective, resolving the problem that is the subject

of the waiver.

The Interim Waiver provisions added by the 1986 amendment allow the

Assistant Secretary to grant an Interim Waiver when it is determined

that the applicant will experience economic hardship if the Application

for Interim Waiver is denied, if it appears likely that the Petition

for Waiver will be granted, and/or the Assistant Secretary determines

that it would be desirable for public policy reasons to grant immediate

relief pending a determination on the Petition for Waiver. An Interim

Waiver remains in effect for a period of 180 days or until DOE issues

its determination on the Petition for Waiver, whichever is sooner, and

may be extended for an additional 180 days, if necessary.

Trane filed a ``Petition for Waiver,'' dated August 11, 1995, in

accordance with section 430.27 of 10 CFR Part 430. The Department

published in the Federal Register on October 13,1995, Trane's Petition

and solicited comments, data and information respecting the Petition.

60 FR 53354, October 13, 1995. Trane also filed an ``Application for

Interim Waiver'' under section 430.27(g), which DOE granted on

September 28, 1995. 60 FR 53354, October 13, 1995.

No comments were received concerning either the ``Petition for

Waiver'' or the ``Application for Interim Waiver.'' The Department

consulted with The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) concerning the Trane

Petition. The FTC did not have any objections to the issuance of the

waiver to Trane.

Assertions and Determinations

Trane's Petition seeks a waiver from the DOE test provisions that

require a 1.5-minute time delay between the ignition of the burner and

the starting of the circulating air blower. Trane requests the

allowance to test using a 45-second blower time delay when testing its

Models TUD-C/AUD-C, TDD-C/ADD-C, TUD-R/AUD-R, TDD-R/ADD-R, TUD-R-V/AUD-

R-V, TDD-R-V/ADD-R-V, TUY-R-V/AUY-R-V, and TDY-R-V/ADY-R-V central

furnaces. Trane states that since the 45-second delay is indicative of

how these models actually operate and since such a delay results in an

overall furnace AFUE improvement of approximately 1.0 percentage point,

the Petition should be granted.

Under specific circumstances, the DOE test procedure contains

exceptions which allow testing with blower delay times of less than the

prescribed 1.5-minute delay. Trane indicates that it is unable to take

advantage of any of these exceptions for its Models TUD-C/AUD-C, TDD-C/

ADD-C, TUD-R/AUD-R, TDD-R/ADD-R, TUD-R-V/AUD-R-V, TDD-R-V/ADD-R-V, TUY-

R-V/AUY-R-V, and TDY-R-V/ADY-R-V central furnaces.

Since the blower controls incorporated on the Trane furnaces are

designed to impose a 45-second blower delay in every instance of start

up, and since the current provisions do not specifically address this

type of control, DOE agrees that a waiver should be granted to allow

the 45-second blower time delay when testing the Trane Models TUD-C/

AUD-C, TDD-C/ADD-C, TUD-R/AUD-R, TDD-R/ADD-R, TUD-R-V/AUD-R-V, TDD-R-V/

ADD-R-V, TUY-R-V/AUY-R-V, and TDY-R-V/ADY-R-V central furnaces.

Accordingly, with regard to testing the Trane Models TUD-C/AUD-C, TDD-

C/ADD-C, TUD-R/AUD-R, TDD-R/ADD-R, TUD-R-V/AUD-R-V, TDD-R-V/ADD-R-V,

TUY-R-V/AUY-R-V, and TDY-R-V/ADY-R-V central furnaces, today's Decision

and Order exempts Trane from the existing provisions regarding blower

controls and allows testing with the 45-second delay.

It is, therefore, ordered That:

(1) The ``Petition for Waiver'' filed by Trane Company. (Case No.

F-080) is hereby granted as set forth in paragraph (2) below, subject

to the provisions of paragraphs (3), (4), and (5).

(2) Notwithstanding any contrary provisions of Appendix N of 10 CFR

Part 430, Subpart B, Trane Company, shall be permitted to test its

Models TUD-C/AUD-C, TDD-C/ADD-C, TUD-R/AUD-R, TDD-R/ADD-R, TUD-R-V/AUD-

R-V, TDD-R-V/ADD-R-V, TUY-R-V/AUY-R-V, and TDY-R-V/ADY-R-V central

furnaces on the basis of the test procedure specified in 10 CFR Part

430, with modifications set forth below:

(i) Section 3.0 of Appendix N is deleted and replaced with the

following paragraph:

3.0 Test Procedure. Testing and measurements shall be as specified

in section 9 in ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 103-82 with the exception of

sections 9.2.2, 9.3.1, and 9.3.2, and the inclusion of the following

additional procedures:

(ii) Add a new paragraph 3.10 to Appendix N as follows:

3.10 Gas- and Oil-Fueled Central Furnaces. The following paragraph

is in lieu of the requirement specified in section 9.3.1 of ANSI/ASHRAE

Standard 103-82. After equilibrium conditions are achieved following

the cool-down test and the required measurements performed, turn on the

furnace and measure the flue gas temperature, using the thermocouple

grid described above, at 0.5 and 2.5 minutes after the main burner(s)

comes on. After the burner start-up, delay the blower start-up by 1.5

minutes (t-), unless: (1) the furnace employs a single motor to drive

the power burner and the indoor air circulating blower, in which case

the burner and blower shall be started together; or (2) the furnace is

designed to operate using an unvarying delay time that is other than

1.5 minutes, in which case the fan control shall be permitted to start

the blower; or (3) the delay time results in the activation of a

temperature safety device which shuts off the burner, in which case the

fan control shall be permitted to start the blower. In the latter case,

if the fan control is adjustable, set it to start the blower at the

highest temperature. If the fan control is permitted to start the

blower, measure time delay, (t-), using a stopwatch. Record the

measured temperatures. During the heat-up test for oil-fueled furnaces,

maintain the draft in the flue pipe within 0.01 inch of

water column of the manufacturer's recommended on-period draft.

(iii) With the exception of the modifications set forth above,

Trane Company shall comply in all respects with the test procedures

specified in Appendix N of 10 CFR Part 430, Subpart B.

(3) The Waiver shall remain in effect from the date of issuance of

this Order until DOE prescribes final test procedures appropriate to

the Models TUD-C/AUD-C, TDD-C/ADD-C, TUD-R/AUD-R, TDD-R/ADD-R, TUD-R-V/

AUD-R-V, TDD-R-V/ADD-R-V, TUY-R-V/AUY-R-V, and TDY-R-V/ADY-R-V

[[Page 62837]]

central furnaces manufactured by Trane Company.

(4) This Waiver is based upon the presumed validity of statements,

allegations, and documentary materials submitted by the petitioner.

This Waiver may be revoked or modified at any time upon a determination

that the factual basis underlying the Petition is incorrect.

(5) Effective November 29, 1995, this Waiver supersedes the Interim

Waiver granted the Trane Company on September 28, 1995. 60 FR 53354,

October 13, 1995 (Case No. F-080).

Issued In Washington, DC, on November 29, 1995.

Christine A. Ervin,

Assistant Secretary, Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy.

[FR Doc. 95-29717 Filed 12-6-95; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 6450-01-P