Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012 as Passed by the House and Senate
Congressional research reportJul 22, 2016
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in
S. 2012 as Passed by the House and Senate
name redacted
Specialist in Energy Policy
name redacted
Acting Deputy Assistant Director/RSI
July 22, 2016
Congressional Research Service
7-....
www.crs.gov
R44569
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
Summary
Congress most recently enacted major energy legislation in the Energy Independence and
Security Act of 2007 (P.L. 110-140). The 114th Congress is currently considering new legislation
to address broad energy issues. On April 20, 2016, the Senate passed an amended version of S.
2012, the Energy Policy and Modernization Act. On December 3, 2015, the House passed an
amended version of H.R. 8, the North American Energy Security and Infrastructure Act of 2015.
On May 25, 2016, the House passed an amended version of S. 2012 which contains the text of
H.R. 8, as well as the text of several other energy and natural resources-related bills. The
following day, the House moved to insist upon its amendment, and to appoint conferees to resolve
the differences in S. 2012. On July 12, the Senate agreed to the request for a conference, and
appointed conferees.
Both versions of S. 2012 would address a variety of energy topics, including
Energy efficiency in federal buildings, data centers, manufacturing, and schools;
Water conservation/efficiency;
Electric grid cybersecurity;
Nuclear energy and carbon sequestration research and development;
Amendments to hydropower licensing provisions;
Liquefied natural gas exports; and
Energy workforce development.
The House version also contains provisions on
Electric grid physical security;
A North American energy security plan; and
A study of wholesale electricity markets.
The Senate version also includes provisions on
Review of the Strategic Petroleum Reserve;
Geothermal energy development on federal lands;
Vehicle research and development;
Electric grid energy storage;
Renewable energy supply and incentives; and
Loan programs.
Both versions of S. 2012 also contain major non-energy provisions including fish and wildlife
recreation and federal land conveyances. Differences include permanent authorization of the Land
and Water Conservation Fund (LWCF) (Senate); reauthorization of the EPA Brownfields Program
(Senate); National Forest management (House); and drought relief (House).
This report provides a side-by-side table identifying comparable and non-comparable provisions
in the House and Senate-passed versions of S. 2012.
Congressional Research Service
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
Contents
Introduction ..................................................................................................................................... 1
Comparable Provisions.................................................................................................................... 2
Tables
Table 1. Comparable and Non-Comparable Provisions in S. 2012 as Passed by the Senate
and House ..................................................................................................................................... 2
Contacts
Author Contact Information .......................................................................................................... 36
Congressional Research Service
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
Introduction
On September 9, 2015, the Senate Committee on Energy and Natural Resources reported S. 2012,
the Energy Policy Modernization Act, a major energy bill with provisions addressing energy
efficiency, critical infrastructure, energy supplies (fossil, renewable, and nuclear), energy
financing and markets, and critical minerals, among other topics.1 The Senate passed S. 2012 on
April 20, 2016.
On May 25, 2016, the House passed an amended version of S. 2012 which contains the text of
H.R. 8,2 as well as the text of several other energy and natural resources-related bills. The
following day, the House moved to insist upon its amendment, and to appoint conferees to resolve
the differences in S. 2012. On July 12, the Senate agreed to the request for a conference, and
appointed conferees.
In addition to energy policy provisions, both versions of S. 2012 contain many natural resources
and environmental provisions including provisions on fish and wildlife recreation and federal
land conveyances. The Senate version includes permanent reauthorization of the Land and Water
Conservation Fund and reauthorization of EPA’s Brownfields Program, while the House version
includes provisions on National Forest management and drought relief.
The House-passed bill would have eliminated restrictions on the export of U.S.-produced crude
oil. However, this provision was included in the FY2016 Consolidated Appropriations Act (P.L.
114-113).3
The House-passed bill also includes provisions on the physical security of the electric grid. Two
of these provisions—on critical electric infrastructure security and a strategic transformer
reserve—were included in the Fixing America’s Surface Transportation (FAST) Act (P.L. 11494).4
This report provides a side-by-side table identifying comparable and non-comparable provisions
in the House and Senate-passed versions of S. 2012, provisions that may be addressed in
conference.5 The first part of the table lists the provisions in the Senate version of S. 2012 in
section order in the left column, with any comparable House provisions in the right column. The
second part of the table (beginning on page 16) lists the provisions from the House version in
section order in the right column, with any comparable Senate provisions in the left column.
For a discussion of key energy and natural resources topics in the two bills, see CRS Report
R44291, Energy Legislation: Comparison of Selected Provisions in H.R. 8 and S. 2012.
1
U.S. Congress, Senate Committee on Energy and Natural Resources, Energy Policy and Modernization Act of 2015,
114th Cong., 1st sess., September 9, 2015, S.Rept. 114-138 (Washington: GPO, 2015).
2
The North American Energy Security and Infrastructure Act of 2015, which passed the House on December 3, 2015.
3
For more information, see CRS Insight IN10472, U.S. Crude Oil Exports to International Destinations, by (name re
dacted).
4
For more information on these provisions, see CRS Insight IN10425, Electric Grid Physical Security: Recent
Legislation, by (name redacted) .
5
For more information on conference committees, see CRS Report 96-708, Conference Committee and Related
Procedures: An Introduction, by (name redacted) .
Congressional Research Service
1
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
Comparable Provisions
Table 1. Comparable and Non-Comparable Provisions in S. 2012 as Passed by the
Senate and House
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
Engrossed in Senate
Sec. 1. Short title; table of contents.
Sec. 1. Short title; table of contents.
Sec. 2. Definitions.
No comparable provision
TITLE I—EFFICIENCY
Subtitle A—Buildings
Sec. 1001. Greater energy efficiency in building codes.
Division A - Sec. 3141. Greater energy efficiency in
building codes.
Sec. 1002. Budget-neutral demonstration program for
energy and water conservation improvements at
multifamily residential units.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1003. Coordination of energy retrofitting assistance
for schools.
Division A - Sec. 3131. Coordination of energy
retrofitting assistance for schools.
Sec. 1004. Energy efficiency materials pilot program.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1005. Utility energy service contracts.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1006. Use of energy and water efficiency measures
in Federal buildings.
Division A - Sec. 3113. Report on energy and water
savings potential from thermal insulation.
Sec. 1007. Building training and assessment centers.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1008. Career skills training.
No comparable provision (related provisions in Senate
Sec. 3601 and House Division A - Secs. 9001-9003)
Sec. 1009. Energy-efficient and energy-saving information
technologies.
Division A - Sec. 3111. Energy-efficient and energy-saving
information technologies.
Sec. 1010. Availability of funds for design updates.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1011. Energy efficient data centers.
Division A - Sec. 3112. Energy efficient data centers.
Sec. 1012. Weatherization Assistance Program.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1013. Reauthorization of State energy program.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1014. Smart building acceleration.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1015. Repeal of fossil phase-out.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1016. Federal building energy efficiency performance
standards.
Division A - Sec. 3117. Federal building energy efficiency
performance standards; certification system and level for
Federal buildings.
Sec. 1017. Codification of Executive Order.
Division A - Sec. 3116. Energy performance requirement
for Federal buildings.
Sec. 1018. Certification for green buildings.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1019. High performance green federal buildings.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1020. Evaluation of potentially duplicative green
building programs.
No comparable provision
Congressional Research Service
2
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
Sec. 1021. Study and report on energy savings benefits of
operational efficiency programs and services.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1022. Use of Federal disaster relief and emergency
assistance for energy-efficient products and structures.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1023. Watersense.
Division A - Sec. 3162. WaterSense.
Subtitle B—Appliances
Sec. 1101. Extended product system rebate program.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1102. Energy efficient transformer rebate program.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1103. Standards for certain furnaces.
Division A - Sec. 3123. Facilitating consensus furnace
standards.
Sec. 1104. Third-party certification under Energy Star
program.
Division A - Sec. 3124. No warranty for certain certified
Energy Star products.
Sec. 1105. Energy conservation standards for commercial
refrigeration equipment.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1106. Voluntary verification programs for air
conditioning, furnace, boiler, heat pump, and water
heater products.
Division A - Sec. 3122. Voluntary verification programs
for air conditioning, furnace, boiler, heat pump, and
water heater products.
Sec. 1107. Application of energy conservation standards
to certain external power supplies.
Division A - Sec. 3128. Definition of external power
supply; Sec. 3129. Standards for power supply circuits
connected to LEDs or OLEDs.
Subtitle C—Manufacturing
Sec. 1201. Manufacturing energy efficiency.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1202. Leveraging existing Federal agency programs
to assist small and medium manufacturers.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1203. Leveraging smart manufacturing infrastructure
at National Laboratories.
No comparable provision
Subtitle D—Vehicles
Sec. 1301. Short title.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1302. Objectives.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1303. Coordination and nonduplication.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1304. Authorization of appropriations.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1305. Reporting.
No comparable provision
PART I—Vehicle Research and Development
Sec. 1306. Program.
No comparable provision (related provision in Division
D - Sec. 641)
Sec. 1307. Manufacturing.
No comparable provision
PART II—Medium- and Heavy-Duty Commercial
and Transit Vehicles
Sec. 1308. Program.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1309. Class 8 truck and trailer systems
demonstration.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1310. Technology testing and metrics.
No comparable provision
Congressional Research Service
3
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
Sec. 1311. Nonroad systems pilot program.
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
No comparable provision
PART III—Administration
Sec. 1312. Repeal of existing authorities.
No comparable provision (related provisions in Senate
Sec. 1306 and House Division D - Sec. 641)
Sec. 1313. Reauthorization of diesel emissions reduction
program.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1314. Gaseous fuel dual fueled automobiles.
No comparable provision
Subtitle E—Short Title
Sec. 1401. Short title.
No comparable provision
Subtitle F—Housing
Sec. 1501. Definitions.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1502. Enhanced energy efficiency underwriting
criteria.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1503. Enhanced energy efficiency underwriting
valuation guidelines.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1504. Monitoring.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1505. Rulemaking.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1506. Additional study.
No comparable provision
TITLE II—INFRASTRUCTURE
Subtitle A—Cybersecurity
Sec. 2001. Cybersecurity threats.
No comparable provision
Sec. 2002. Enhanced grid security.
Division A - Sec. 1106. Cyber Sense.
Subtitle B—Strategic Petroleum Reserve
Sec. 2101. Strategic Petroleum Reserve modernization.
No comparable provision
Sec. 2102. Strategic petroleum reserve drawdown and
sale.
No comparable provision
Subtitle C—Trade
Sec. 2201. Action on applications to export liquefied
natural gas.
Division A - Sec. 2005. Authorization to export natural
gas.
Sec. 2202. Public disclosure of liquefied natural gas
export
destinations.
Division A - Sec. 2005. Authorization to export natural
gas. (c)
Sec. 2203. Energy data collaboration.
Division A - Sec. 2003. North American energy security
plan.
Subtitle D—Electricity and Energy Storage
Sec. 2301. Grid storage program.
No comparable provision
Sec. 2302. Electric system grid architecture, scenario
development, and modeling.
No comparable provision
Sec. 2303. Hybrid micro-grid systems for isolated and
resilient communities.
No comparable provision
Sec. 2304. Voluntary model pathways.
No comparable provision
Congressional Research Service
4
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
Sec. 2305. Performance metrics for electricity
infrastructure providers.
No comparable provision
Sec. 2306. State and regional electricity distribution
planning.
No comparable provision
Sec. 2307. Authorization of appropriations.
No comparable provision
Sec. 2308. Electric transmission infrastructure permitting.
No comparable provision
Sec. 2309. Report by transmission organizations on
distributed energy resources and micro-grid systems.
No comparable provision
Sec. 2310. Net metering study guidance.
No comparable provision
Sec. 2311. [Sec. 2312 in text] Model guidance for
combined heat and power systems and waste heat to
power systems.
No comparable provision
Subtitle E—Computing
Sec. 2401. Exascale computer research program.
Division D - Sec. 503. Advanced scientific computing
research.
TITLE III—SUPPLY
Subtitle A—Renewables
PART I—Hydroelectric
Sec. 3001. Hydropower regulatory improvements.
Division A - Sec. 3115. Federal purchase requirement;
Sec. 1203. Hydropower licensing and process
improvements; Sec. 1205. Licensing study improvements;
Sec. 1206. Closed-loop pumped storage projects.
Sec. 3002. Hydroelectric production incentives and
efficiency improvements.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3003. Extension of time for a Federal Energy
Regulatory Commission project involving Clark Canyon
Dam.
Division A - Sec. 8001. Extension of time for Federal
Energy Regulatory Commission project involving Clark
Canyon Dam.
Sec. 3004. Extension of time for a Federal Energy
Regulatory Commission project involving Gibson Dam.
Division A - Sec. 8002. Extension of time for Federal
Energy Regulatory Commission project involving Gibson
Dam.
PART II—Geothermal
subpart a—Geothermal Energy
Sec. 3005. National goals for production and site
identification.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3006. Priority areas for development on Federal
land.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3007. Facilitation of coproduction of geothermal
energy on oil and gas leases.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3008. Noncompetitive leasing of adjoining areas for
development of geothermal resources.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3009. Report to Congress.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3010. Authorization of appropriations.
No comparable provision
subpart b—Development of Geothermal, Solar,
and Wind Energy On Public Land.
Congressional Research Service
5
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
Sec. 3011. Definitions.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3011A. Land use planning; supplements to
programmatic environmental impact statements.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3011B. Environmental review on covered land.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3011C. Program to improve renewable energy
project permit coordination.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3011D. Savings clause.
No comparable provision
subpart c—Geothermal Exploration
Sec. 3012. Geothermal exploration test projects.
No comparable provision
PART III—Marine Hydrokinetic
Sec. 3013. Definition of marine and hydrokinetic
renewable energy.
Division A - Sec. 7001. Definition of marine and
hydrokinetic renewable energy.
Sec. 3014. Marine and hydrokinetic renewable energy
research and development.
Division A - Sec. 7002. Marine and hydrokinetic
renewable energy research and development.
Sec. 3015. National Marine Renewable Energy Research,
Development, and Demonstration Centers.
Division A - Sec. 7003. National Marine Renewable
Energy Research, Development, and Demonstration
Centers.
Sec. 3016. Authorization of appropriations.
Division A - Sec. 7004. Authorization of appropriations.
PART IV—Biomass
Sec. 3017. Policies relating to biomass energy.
No comparable provision
Subtitle B—Oil and Gas
Sec. 3101. Amendments to the Methane Hydrate
Research and Development Act of 2000.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3102. Liquefied natural gas study.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3103. FERC process coordination with respect to
regulatory approval of gas projects.
Division A - Sec. 1101. FERC process coordination.
Sec. 3104. Pilot program.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3105. GAO review and report.
Division A - Sec. 4004. Studies.
Sec. 3106. Ethane storage study.
Division A - Sec. 1111. Ethane storage study.
Sec. 3107. Aliso Canyon natural gas leak task force.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3108. Report on incorporating Internet-based lease
sales.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3109. Denali National Park and Preserve natural gas
pipeline.
No comparable provision
Subtitle C—Helium
Sec. 3201. Rights to helium.
No comparable provision
Subtitle D—Critical Minerals
Title III—National Strategic and Critical Minerals
Act
Sec. 3301. Definitions.
Division C - Sec. 3003. Definitions.
Sec. 3302. Policy.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3303. Critical mineral designations.
No comparable provision
Congressional Research Service
6
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
Sec. 3304. Resource assessment.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3305. Permitting.
Division C - Sec. 3012. Responsibilities of the lead
agency.
Sec. 3306. Federal Register process.
Division C - Sec. 3014. Federal register process for
mineral exploration and mining projects.
Sec. 3307. Recycling, efficiency, and alternatives.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3308. Analysis and forecasting.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3309. Education and workforce.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3310. National geological and geophysical data
preservation program.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3311. Administration.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3312. Authorization of appropriations.
No comparable provision
Subtitle E—Coal
Sec. 3401. Sense of the Senate on carbon capture, use,
and storage development and deployment.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3402. Fossil energy.
Division D - Sec. 661. Fossil energy.
Sec. 3403. Establishment of coal technology program.
Division D - Sec. 662. Coal research, development,
demonstration, and commercial application programs.
Sec. 3404. Report on price stabilization support.
No comparable provision
Subtitle F—Nuclear
Sec. 3501. Nuclear energy innovation capabilities.
Division D - Title VI, Subtitle C—Nuclear Energy
Research and Development - Secs. 621-628; Sec. 714.
Nuclear energy innovation; and TITLE XXXIII—
NUCLEAR ENERGY INNOVATION CAPABILITIES Secs. 3301-3311.
Sec. 3502. Next generation nuclear plant project.
No comparable provision
Subtitle G—Workforce Development
Title IX. Energy and Manufacturing Workforce
Development
Sec. 3601. 21st Century Energy Workforce Advisory
Board. (Related provision in Senate Sec. 1008)
Division A - Sec. 9001. Energy and manufacturing
workforce development; Sec. 9002. Report.
Sec. 3602. Energy workforce pilot grant program.
Sec. 9002. Report; Sec. 9003. Use of existing funds.
Subtitle H—Recycling
Sec. 3701. Recycled carbon fiber.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3702. Energy generation and regulatory relief study
regarding recovery and conversion of nonrecycled mixed
plastics.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3703. Eligible projects.
No comparable provision (related provision in House
Division A - Sec. 3115(b))
Sec. 3704. Promoting use of reclaimed refrigerants in
Federal facilities.
No comparable provision
Subtitle I—Thermal Energy
Sec. 3801. Modifying the definition of renewable energy
to include thermal energy.
Congressional Research Service
Division A - Sec. 3115. Federal purchase requirement. (a)
7
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
TITLE IV—ACCOUNTABILITY
Subtitle A—Loan Programs
Sec. 4001. Terms and conditions for incentives for
innovative technologies.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4002. State loan eligibility.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4003. GAO Study on fossil loan guarantee incentive
program.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4004. Program eligibility for vessels.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4005. Additional reforms.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4006. Department of Energy Indian energy education
planning and management assistance program.
No comparable provision
Subtitle B—Energy-Water Nexus
Sec. 4101. Nexus of energy and water for sustainability.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4102. Smart energy and water efficiency pilot
program.
Division A - Sec. 3161. Smart energy and water efficiency
pilot program.
Subtitle C—Innovation
Sec. 4201. America COMPETES programs.
Division D - Sec. 510. Authorization of appropriations;
Sec. 671. ARPA–E amendments; Sec. 681. Authorization
of appropriations.
Sec. 4202. Inclusion of early stage technology
demonstration in authorized technology transfer
activities.
Division D - Sec. 723. Inclusion of early-stage technology
demonstration in authorized technology transfer
activities.
Sec. 4203. Supporting access of small business concerns
to National Laboratories.
Division D - Sec. 713. Sense of Congress.
Sec. 4204. Microlab technology commercialization.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4205. Sense of the Senate on accelerating energy
innovation.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4206. Restoration of Laboratory Directed Research
and Development Program.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4207. National Science and Technology Council
coordinating subcommittee for high-energy physics.
Division D - Sec. 504. High energy physics.
Subtitle D—Grid Reliability
Sec. 4301. Bulk-power system reliability impact
statement.
Division A - Sec. 1108. Reliability analysis for certain
rules that affect electric generating facilities.
Sec. 4302. Report by transmission organizations on
diversity of supply.
Division A - Sec. 1110. Reliability and performance
assurance in Regional Transmission Organizations.
Subtitle E—Management
Sec. 4401. Federal land management.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4402. Quadrennial Energy Review.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4403. State oversight of oil and gas programs.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4404. Under Secretary for Science and Energy.
Division D - Sec. 501. Mission.
Congressional Research Service
8
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
Sec. 4405. Western Area Power Administration pilot
project.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4406. Research grants database.
Division D - Sec. 628. Available facilities database.
Sec. 4407. Review of economic impact of BSEE rule on
small entities.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4408. Energy emergency response efforts of the
Department.
Division A - Sec. 1103. Emergency preparedness for
energy supply disruptions.
Sec. 4409. GAO report on Bureau of Safety and
Environmental Enforcement statutory and regulatory
authority for the procurement of helicopter fuel.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4410. Conveyance of federal land within the Swan
Lake hydroelectric project boundary.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4411. Study of waivers of certain cost-sharing
requirements.
Division D - Sec. 724. Funding competitiveness for
institutions of higher education and other nonprofit
institutions.
Sec. 4412. National park centennial.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4413. Program to reduce the potential impacts of
solar energy facilities on certain species.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4414. Wild horses in and around the Currituck
National Wildlife Refuge
No comparable provision
Subtitle F—Markets
Sec. 4501. Enhanced information on critical energy
supplies.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4502. Working Group on Energy Markets.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4503. Study of regulatory framework for energy
markets.
No comparable provision
Subtitle G—Affordability
Sec. 4601. E-prize competition pilot program.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4602. Carbon dioxide capture technology prize.
No comparable provision
Subtitle H—Code Maintenance
Sec. 4701. Repeal of off-highway motor vehicles study.
Division A - Sec. 3231. Repeal of off-highway motor
vehicles study.
Sec. 4702. Repeal of methanol study.
Division A - Sec. 3232. Repeal of methanol study.
Sec. 4703. Repeal of authorization of appropriations
provision.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4704. Repeal of residential energy efficiency
standards study.
Division A - Sec. 3233. Repeal of residential energy
efficiency standards study.
Sec. 4705. Repeal of weatherization study.
Division A - Sec. 3234. Repeal of weatherization study.
Sec. 4706. Repeal of report to Congress.
Division A - Sec. 3235. Repeal of report to Congress.
Sec. 4707. Repeal of report by General Services
Administration.
Division A - Sec. 3236. Repeal of report by General
Services Administration.
Sec. 4708. Repeal of intergovernmental energy
management planning and coordination workshops.
Division A - Sec. 3237. Repeal of intergovernmental
energy management planning and coordination
workshops.
Congressional Research Service
9
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
Sec. 4709. Repeal of Inspector General audit survey and
President's Council on Integrity and Efficiency report
to Congress.
Division A - Sec. 3238. Repeal of Inspector General audit
survey and President’s Council on Integrity and Efficiency
report to Congress.
Sec. 4710. Repeal of procurement and identification of
energy efficient products program.
Division A - Sec. 3239. Repeal of procurement and
identification of energy efficient products program.
Sec. 4711. Repeal of national action plan for demand
response.
Division A - Sec. 3240. Repeal of national action plan for
demand response.
Sec. 4712. Repeal of national coal policy study.
Division A - Sec. 3241. Repeal of national coal policy
study.
Sec. 4713. Repeal of study on compliance problem of
small electric utility systems.
Division A - Sec. 3242. Repeal of study on compliance
problem of small electric utility systems.
Sec. 4714. Repeal of study of socioeconomic impacts of
increased coal production and other energy
development.
Division A - Sec. 3243. Repeal of study of socioeconomic
impacts of increased coal production and other energy
development.
Sec. 4715. Repeal of study of the use of petroleum and
natural gas in combustors.
Division A - Sec. 3244. Repeal of study of the use of
petroleum and natural gas in combustors.
Sec. 4716. Repeal of submission of reports.
Division A - Sec. 3245. Repeal of submission of reports.
Sec. 4717. Repeal of electric utility conservation plan.
Division A - Sec. 3246. Repeal of electric utility
conservation plan.
Sec. 4718. Emergency Energy Conservation repeals.
Division A - Sec. 3248. Emergency energy conservation
repeals.
Sec. 4719. Energy Security Act repeals.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4720. Nuclear Safety Research, Development, and
Demonstration Act of 1980 repeals.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4721. Elimination and consolidation of certain
America COMPETES programs.
Division D - Sec. 3305. University nuclear science and
engineering support.
Sec. 4722. Repeal of state utility regulatory assistance.
Division A - Sec. 3249. Repeal of State utility regulatory
assistance.
Sec. 4723. Repeal of survey of energy saving potential.
Division A - Sec. 3250. Repeal of survey of energy saving
potential.
Sec. 4724. Repeal of photovoltaic energy program.
Division A - Sec. 3251. Repeal of photovoltaic energy
program.
Sec. 4725. Repeal of energy auditor training and
certification.
Division A - Sec. 3252. Repeal of energy auditor training
and certification.
Sec. 4726. Repeal of authorization of appropriations.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4727. Repeal of Renewable Energy and Energy
Efficiency Technology Competitiveness Act of 1989.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4728. Repeal of hydrogen research, development,
and demonstration program.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4729. Repeal of study on alternative fuel use in
nonroad vehicles and engines.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4730. Repeal of low interest loan program for small
business fleet purchases.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4731. Repeal of technical and policy analysis for
replacement fuel demand and supply information.
No comparable provision
Congressional Research Service
10
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
Sec. 4732. Repeal of 1992 Report on Climate Change.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4733. Repeal of Director of Climate Protector
establishment.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4734. Repeal of 1994 report on global climate
change emissions.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4735. Repeal of telecommuting study.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4736. Repeal of advanced buildings for 2005
program.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4737. Repeal of Energy Research, Development,
Demonstration, and Commercial Application Advisory
Board.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4738. Repeal of study on use of energy futures for
fuel purchase.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4739. Repeal of energy subsidy study.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4740. Modernization of terms relating to minorities.
Division A - Sec. 5012. Modernization of terms relating
to minorities.
TITLE V—CONSERVATION
REAUTHORIZATION
Sec. 5001. National Park Service Maintenance and
Revitalization Conservation Fund.
No comparable provision
Sec. 5002. Land and Water Conservation Fund.
No comparable provision
Sec. 5003. Historic Preservation Fund.
No comparable provision
Sec. 5004. Conservation incentives landowner education
program.
No comparable provision
TITLE VI—INDIAN TRIBAL ENERGY
DEVELOPMENT AND SELF-DETERMINATION
Sec. 6001. Short title.
Division C - Sec. 4001. Short title.
Subtitle A—Indian Tribal Energy Development
and Self-determination Act Amendments
Sec. 6011. Indian tribal energy resource development.
No comparable provision
Sec. 6012. Indian tribal energy resource regulation.
No comparable provision
Sec. 6013. Tribal energy resource agreements.
No comparable provision
Sec. 6014. Technical assistance for Indian tribal
governments.
No comparable provision
Sec. 6015. Conforming amendments.
No comparable provision
Sec. 6016. Report.
No comparable provision
Subtitle B—Miscellaneous Amendments
Sec. 6201. Issuance of preliminary permits or licenses.
No comparable provision
Sec. 6202. Tribal biomass demonstration project.
Division C - Sec. 4006. Tribal biomass demonstration
project.
Sec. 6203. Weatherization program.
No comparable provision
Sec. 6204. Appraisals.
Division C - Sec. 4002. Appraisals.
Congressional Research Service
11
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
Sec. 6205. Leases of restricted lands for Navajo Nation.
Division C - Sec. 4008. Leases of restricted lands for the
Navajo Nation.
Sec. 6206. Extension of tribal lease period for the Crow
Tribe of Montana.
No comparable provision
Sec. 6207. Trust status of lease payments.
No comparable provision
TITLE VII—BROWNFIELDS
REAUTHORIZATION
Sec. 7001. Short title.
No comparable provision
Sec. 7002. Expanded eligibility for nonprofit
organizations.
No comparable provision
Sec. 7003. Multipurpose brownfields grants.
No comparable provision
Sec. 7004. Treatment of certain publicly owned
brownfield sites.
No comparable provision
Sec. 7005. Increased funding for remediation grants.
No comparable provision
Sec. 7006. Allowing administrative costs for grant
recipients.
No comparable provision
Sec. 7007. Small community technical assistance grants.
No comparable provision
Sec. 7008. Waterfront brownfields grants.
No comparable provision
Sec. 7009. Clean energy brownfields grants.
No comparable provision
Sec. 7010. Targeted funding for States.
No comparable provision
Sec. 7011. Authorization of appropriations.
No comparable provision
TITLE VIII—MISCELLANEOUS
Sec. 8001. Removal of use restriction.
Division C - Sec. 16001. Removal of use restriction.
TITLE IX—MISCELLANEOUS
Sec. 9001. Interagency transfer of land along George
Washington Memorial Parkway.
No comparable provision
TITLE X—NATURAL RESOURCES
Subtitle A—Land Conveyances and Related
Matters
Sec. 10001. Arapaho National Forest boundary
adjustment.
Division C - TITLE XI—ARAPAHO NATIONAL
FOREST BOUNDARY ADJUSTMENT ACT; Sec. 11001.
Short title; Sec. 11002. Arapaho National Forest
boundary adjustment.
Sec. 10002. Land conveyance, Elkhorn Ranch and White
River National Forest, Colorado.
Division C - TITLE XIII—ELKHORN RANCH AND
WHITE RIVER NATIONAL FOREST CONVEYANCE
ACT; Sec. 13001. Short title; Sec. 13002. Land
conveyance, Elkhorn Ranch and White River National
Forest, Colorado.
Sec. 10003. Land exchange in Crags, Colorado.
Division C - TITLE XV—CRAGS, COLORADO LAND
EXCHANGE ACT; Sec. 15001. Short title; Sec. 15002.
Purposes; Sec. 15003. Definitions; Sec. 15004. Land
exchange; Sec. 15005. Equal value exchange and
appraisals; Sec. 15006. Miscellaneous provisions.
Congressional Research Service
12
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
Sec. 10004. Cerro del Yuta and Rio San Antonio
Wilderness Areas.
No comparable provision
Sec. 10005. Clarification relating to a certain land
description under the Northern Arizona Land Exchange
and Verde River Basin Partnership Act of 2005.
No comparable provision
Sec. 10006. Cooper Spur land exchange clarification
amendments.
No comparable provision
Sec. 10007. Expedited access to certain Federal land.
Division C - Subtitle Q—Good Samaritan Search and
Recovery; Sec. 2181. Short title; Sec. 2182. Expedited
access to certain Federal land.
Sec. 10008. Black Hills National Cemetery boundary
modification.
No comparable provision
Subtitle B—National Park Management, Studies,
and Related Matters
Sec. 10101. Refund of funds used by States to operate
national parks during shutdown.
No comparable provision
Sec. 10102. Lower Farmington and Salmon Brook
recreational rivers.
No comparable provision
Sec. 10103. Special resource study of President Street
Station.
No comparable provision
Sec. 10104. Special resource study of Thurgood
Marshall's elementary school.
No comparable provision
Sec. 10105. Special resource study of James K. Polk
presidential home.
No comparable provision
Sec. 10106. North Country National Scenic Trail route
adjustment.
No comparable provision
Sec. 10107. Designation of Jay S. Hammond Wilderness
Area.
No comparable provision
Sec. 10108. Advisory Council on Historic Preservation.
No comparable provision
Sec. 10109. Establishment of a visitor services facility on
the Arlington Ridge tract.
No comparable provision
Subtitle C—Sportsmen's Access and Land
Management Issues
Division C - Title II, Subtitle F
PART I—National Policy
Division C - Title II, Subtitle F
Sec. 10201. Congressional declaration of national policy.
Division C - Sec. 2062. Findings.
PART II—Sportsmen's Access to Federal Land
Subtitle F—MISCELLANEOUS
Sec. 10211. Definitions.
Division C - Sec. 2063. Fishing, hunting, and recreational
shooting.(a)
Sec. 10212. Federal land open to hunting, fishing, and
recreational shooting.
Division C - Sec. 2063. Fishing, hunting, and recreational
shooting.(b)-(d); (f)-(j)
Sec. 10213. Closure of Federal land to hunting, fishing,
and recreational shooting
Division C - Sec. 2063. Fishing, hunting, and recreational
shooting.(e)(1)
Sec. 10214. Shooting ranges.
Division C - Sec. 2063. Fishing, hunting, and recreational
shooting.(e)(2)
Congressional Research Service
13
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
Sec. 10215. Federal action transparency.
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
Division C - Sec. 2161. Short title; Sec. 2162.
Modification of equal access to justice provisions.
PART III—Filming on Federal Land Management
Agency Land
Sec. 10221. Commercial filming.
No comparable provision
PART IV—Bows, Wildlife Management, and
Access Opportunities for Recreation, Hunting,
and Fishing
Division C - Subtitle H—Transporting Bows
Across National Park Service Lands
Sec. 10231. Bows in parks.
Division C - Sec. 2081-2082(a)
Sec. 10232. Wildlife management in parks.
Division C - Sec. 2064; Subtitle N—Grand Canyon Bison
Management Act - Sec. 2151-2153
Sec. 10233. Identifying opportunities for recreation,
hunting, and fishing on Federal land.
No comparable provision
PART V—Federal Land Transaction Facilitation
Act
Division C - Subtitle I—Federal Land Transaction
Facilitation Act Reauthorization (FLTFA)
Sec. 10241. Federal Land Transaction Facilitation Act.
Division C - Sec. 2091. Short title; Sec. 2092. Federal
Land Transaction Facilitation Act.
PART VI—Fish and Wildlife Conservation
Sec. 10251. Amendments to Pittman-Robertson Wildlife
Restoration Act.
Division C - Subtitle B—Target Practice and
Marksmanship Training Support Act - Secs. 2022-2024,
2026
Sec. 10252. North American Wetlands Conservation
Act.
No comparable provision
Sec. 10253. National fish habitat conservation.
No comparable provision
Sec. 10254. Gulf States Marine Fisheries Commission
report on Gulf of Mexico outer Continental Shelf State
boundary extension.
No comparable provision
Sec. 10255. GAO report on Gulf of Mexico outer
Continental Shelf State boundary extension.
No comparable provision
PART VII—Miscellaneous
Sec. 10261. Respect for treaties and rights.
Division C - Sec. 2111. Respect for treaties and rights.
Sec. 10262. No priority.
Division C - Sec. 2063. Fishing, hunting, and recreational
shooting. (g)
Subtitle D—Water Infrastructure and Related
Matters
PART I—Fontenelle Reservoir
Sec. 10301. Authority to make entire active capacity of
Fontenelle Reservoir available for use.
No comparable provision
Sec. 10302. Savings provisions.
No comparable provision
PART II—Bureau of Reclamation Transparency
Sec. 10311. Definitions.
No comparable provision
Sec. 10312. Asset management report enhancements for
reserved works.
No comparable provision
Congressional Research Service
14
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
Sec. 10313. Asset management report enhancements for
transferred works.
No comparable provision
Sec. 10314. Offset.
No comparable provision
PART III—Basin Water Management
subpart a—Yakima River Basin Water
Enhancement
Sec. 10321. Short title.
No comparable provision
Sec. 10322. Modification of terms, purposes, and
definitions.
No comparable provision
Sec. 10323. Yakima River Basin Water Conservation
Program.
No comparable provision
Sec. 10324. Yakima Basin water projects, operations, and
authorizations.
No comparable provision
Sec. 10325. Authorization of Phase III of Yakima River
Basin Water Enhancement Project.
No comparable provision
subpart b—Klamath Project Water and Power
Sec. 10329. Klamath Project.
No comparable provision
PART IV—Reservoir Operation Improvement
Sec. 10331. Reservoir operation improvement.
No comparable provision
PART V—Hydroelectric Projects
Sec. 10341. Terror Lake Hydroelectric Project Upper
Hidden Basin Diversion authorization.
No comparable provision
Sec. 10342. Stay and Reinstatement of FERC License No.
11393 for the Mahoney Lake Hydroelectric Project.
No comparable provision
Sec. 10343. Extension of deadline for hydroelectric
project.
Division A - Sec. 1202. Extension of time for FERC
project involving W. Kerr Scott Dam.
Sec. 10344. Extension of deadline for certain other
hydroelectric projects.
Division A - Sec. 8005. Extension of time for Federal
Energy Regulatory Commission project involving
Gathright Dam; Sec. 8006. Extension of time for Federal
Energy Regulatory Commission project involving
Flannagan Dam.
Sec. 10345. Equus Beds Division extension.
No comparable provision
Sec. 10346. Extension of time for a Federal Energy
Regulatory Commission project involving Cannonsville
Dam.
Division A - Sec. 8004. Extension of time for Federal
Energy Regulatory Commission project involving
Cannonsville Dam.
PART VI—Pumped Storage Hydropower
Compensation
Sec. 10351. Pumped storage hydropower compensation.
No comparable provision
Engrossed House Amendment
Sec. 1. Short title; table of contents.
Congressional Research Service
Sec. 1. Short title; table of contents.
15
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
TITLE I—MODERNIZING AND PROTECTING
INFRASTRUCTURE
Subtitle A—Energy Delivery, Reliability, and
Security
Sec. 3103. FERC process coordination with respect to
regulatory approval of gas projects.
Sec. 1101. FERC process coordination.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1102. Resolving environmental and grid reliability
conflicts.
Sec. 4408. Energy emergency response efforts of the
Department.
Sec. 1103. Emergency preparedness for energy supply
disruptions.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1104. Critical electric infrastructure security.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1105. Strategic Transformer Reserve.
Sec. 2002. Enhanced grid security.
Sec. 1106. Cyber Sense.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1107. State coverage and consideration of PURPA
standards for electric utilities.
Sec. 4301. Bulk-power system reliability impact
statement.
Sec. 1108. Reliability analysis for certain rules that affect
electric generating facilities.
No comparable provision (Related provisions in Senate
Sections 3401-3404)
Sec. 1109. Increased accountability with respect to
carbon capture, utilization, and sequestration projects.
Sec. 4302. Report by transmission organizations on
diversity of supply.
Sec. 1110. Reliability and performance assurance in
Regional Transmission Organizations.
Sec. 3106. Ethane storage study.
Sec. 1111. Ethane storage study.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1112. Statement of policy on grid modernization.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1113. Grid resilience report.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1114. GAO report on improving National Response
Center.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1115. Designation of National Energy Security
Corridors on Federal lands.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1116. Vegetation management, facility inspection,
and operation and maintenance on Federal lands
containing electric transmission and distribution facilities.
Subtitle B—Hydropower Regulatory
Modernization
No comparable provision
Sec. 1201. Protection of private property rights in
hydropower licensing.
Sec. 10343. Extension of deadline for hydroelectric
project.
Sec. 1202. Extension of time for FERC project involving
W. Kerr Scott Dam.
Sec. 3001. Hydropower regulatory improvements.
Sec. 1203. Hydropower licensing and process
improvements.
No comparable provision (related provisions in Senate
Sec. 3001 and House Division A – Secs. 1203, 1205, and
1206)
Sec. 1204. Judicial review of delayed Federal
authorizations.
Sec. 3001. Hydropower regulatory improvements.
Sec. 1205. Licensing study improvements.
Sec. 3001. Hydropower regulatory improvements.
Sec. 1206. Closed-loop pumped storage projects.
Congressional Research Service
16
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
No comparable provision
Sec. 1207. License amendment improvements.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1208. Promoting hydropower development at
existing nonpowered dams.
TITLE II—ENERGY SECURITY AND
DIPLOMACY
No comparable provision
Sec. 2001. Sense of Congress.
No comparable provision
Sec. 2002. Energy security valuation.
Sec. 2203. Energy data collaboration.
Sec. 2003. North American energy security plan.
No comparable provision
Sec. 2004. Collective energy security.
Sec. 2201. Action on applications to export liquefied
natural gas; Sec. 2202. Public disclosure of liquefied
natural gas export destinations.
Sec. 2005. Authorization to export natural gas.
No comparable provision
Sec. 2006. Environmental review for energy export
facilities.
No comparable provision
Sec. 2007. Authorization of cross-border infrastructure
projects.
No comparable provision
Sec. 2008. Report on smart meter security concerns.
TITLE III—ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND
ACCOUNTABILITY
Subtitle A—Energy Efficiency
CHAPTER 1—FEDERAL AGENCY ENERGY
EFFICIENCY
Sec. 1009. Energy-efficient and energy-saving information
technologies.
Sec. 3111. Energy-efficient and energy-saving information
technologies.
Sec. 1011. Energy efficient data centers.
Sec. 3112. Energy efficient data centers.
Sec. 1006. Use of energy and water efficiency measures
in Federal buildings
Sec. 3113. Report on energy and water savings potential
from thermal insulation.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3114. Battery storage report.
Sec. 3001. Hydropower regulatory improvements; Sec.
3801. Modifying the definition of renewable energy to
include thermal energy.
Sec. 3115. Federal purchase requirement.
Sec. 1017. Codification of Executive Order.
Sec. 3116. Energy performance requirement for Federal
buildings.
Sec. 1016. Federal building energy efficiency performance
standards.
Sec. 3117. Federal building energy efficiency performance
standards; certification system and level for Federal
buildings.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3118. Operation of battery recharging stations in
parking areas used by Federal employees.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3119. Report on energy savings and greenhouse gas
emissions reduction from conversion of captured
methane to energy.
CHAPTER 2—ENERGY EFFICIENT
TECHNOLOGY AND MANUFACTURING
Congressional Research Service
17
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
No comparable provision
Sec. 3121. Inclusion of Smart Grid capability on Energy
Guide labels.
Sec. 1106. Voluntary verification programs for air
conditioning, furnace, boiler, heat pump, and water
heater products.
Sec. 3122. Voluntary verification programs for air
conditioning, furnace, boiler, heat pump, and water
heater products.
Sec. 1103. Standards for certain furnaces.
Sec. 3123. Facilitating consensus furnace standards.
Sec. 1104. Third-party certification under Energy Star
program.
Sec. 3124. No warranty for certain certified Energy Star
products.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3125. Clarification to effective date for regional
standards.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3126. Internet of Things report.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3127. Energy savings from lubricating oil.
Sec. 1107. Application of energy conservation standards
to certain external power supplies.
Sec. 3128. Definition of external power supply.
Sec. 1107. Application of energy conservation standards
to certain external power supplies.
Sec. 3129. Standards for power supply circuits connected
to LEDs or OLEDs.
CHAPTER 3—SCHOOL BUILDINGS
Sec. 1003. Coordination of energy retrofitting assistance
for schools.
Sec. 3131. Coordination of energy retrofitting assistance
for schools.
CHAPTER 4—BUILDING ENERGY CODES
Sec. 1001. Greater energy efficiency in building codes.
Sec. 3141. Greater energy efficiency in building codes.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3142. Voluntary nature of building asset rating
program.
CHAPTER 5—EPCA TECHNICAL
CORRECTIONS AND CLARIFICATIONS
No comparable provision
Sec. 3151. Modifying product definitions.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3152. Clarifying rulemaking procedures.
CHAPTER 6—ENERGY AND WATER
EFFICIENCY
Sec. 4102. Smart energy and water efficiency pilot
program.
Sec. 3161. Smart energy and water efficiency pilot
program.
Sec. 1023. Watersense.
Sec. 3162. WaterSense.
Subtitle B—Accountability
CHAPTER 1—MARKET MANIPULATION,
ENFORCEMENT, AND COMPLIANCE
No comparable provision
Sec. 3211. FERC Office of Compliance Assistance and
Public Participation.
CHAPTER 2—MARKET REFORMS
No comparable provision
Sec. 3221. GAO study on wholesale electricity markets.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3222. Clarification of facility merger authorization.
CHAPTER 3—CODE MAINTENANCE
Sec. 4701. Repeal of off-highway motor vehicles study.
Congressional Research Service
Sec. 3231. Repeal of off-highway motor vehicles study.
18
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
Sec. 4702. Repeal of methanol study.
Sec. 3232. Repeal of methanol study.
Sec. 4704. Repeal of residential energy efficiency
standards study.
Sec. 3233. Repeal of residential energy efficiency
standards study.
Sec. 4705. Repeal of weatherization study.
Sec. 3234. Repeal of weatherization study.
Sec. 4706. Repeal of report to Congress.
Sec. 3235. Repeal of report to Congress.
Sec. 4707. Repeal of report by General Services
Administration.
Sec. 3236. Repeal of report by General Services
Administration.
Sec. 4708. Repeal of intergovernmental energy
management planning and coordination workshops.
Sec. 3237. Repeal of intergovernmental energy
management planning and coordination workshops.
Sec. 4709. Repeal of Inspector General audit survey and
President's Council on Integrity and Efficiency report to
Congress.
Sec. 3238. Repeal of Inspector General audit survey and
President’s Council on Integrity and Efficiency report to
Congress.
Sec. 4710. Repeal of procurement and identification of
energy efficient products program.
Sec. 3239. Repeal of procurement and identification of
energy efficient products program.
Sec. 4711. Repeal of national action plan for demand
response.
Sec. 3240. Repeal of national action plan for demand
response.
Sec. 4712. Repeal of national coal policy study.
Sec. 3241. Repeal of national coal policy study.
Sec. 4713. Repeal of study on compliance problem of
small electric utility systems.
Sec. 3242. Repeal of study on compliance problem of
small electric utility systems.
Sec. 4714. Repeal of study of socioeconomic impacts of
increased coal production and other energy
development.
Sec. 3243. Repeal of study of socioeconomic impacts of
increased coal production and other energy
development.
Sec. 4715. Repeal of study of the use of petroleum and
natural gas in combustors.
Sec. 3244. Repeal of study of the use of petroleum and
natural gas in combustors.
Sec. 4716. Repeal of submission of reports.
Sec. 3245. Repeal of submission of reports.
Sec. 4717. Repeal of electric utility conservation plan.
Sec. 3246. Repeal of electric utility conservation plan.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3247. Technical amendment to Powerplant and
Industrial Fuel Use Act of 1978.
Sec. 4718. Emergency Energy Conservation repeals.
Sec. 3248. Emergency energy conservation repeals.
Sec. 4722. Repeal of state utility regulatory assistance.
Sec. 3249. Repeal of State utility regulatory assistance.
Sec. 4723. Repeal of survey of energy saving potential.
Sec. 3250. Repeal of survey of energy saving potential.
Sec. 4724. Repeal of photovoltaic energy program.
Sec. 3251. Repeal of photovoltaic energy program.
Sec. 4725. Repeal of energy auditor training and
certification.
Sec. 3252. Repeal of energy auditor training and
certification.
CHAPTER 4—AUTHORIZATION
No comparable provision
Sec. 3261 Authorization.
TITLE IV—CHANGING CRUDE OIL MARKET
CONDITIONS
No comparable provision
Sec. 4001. Findings.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4002. Repeal.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4003. National policy on oil export restrictions.
Sec. 3105. GAO review and report.
Sec. 4004. Studies.
Congressional Research Service
19
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
No comparable provision
Sec. 4005. Savings clause.
No comparable provision (related provisions in Senate
Sec. 3601 and House Division A - Secs. 9001-9003)
Sec. 4006. Partnerships with minority serving institutions.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4007. Report.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4008. Report to Congress.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4009. Prohibition on exports of crude oil, refined
petroleum products, and petrochemical products to the
Islamic Republic of Iran.
TITLE V—OTHER MATTERS
No comparable provision
Sec. 5001. Assessment of regulatory requirements.
No comparable provision
Sec. 5002. Definitions.
No comparable provision
Sec. 5003. Exclusive venue for certain civil actions
relating to covered energy projects.
No comparable provision
Sec. 5004. Timely filing.
No comparable provision
Sec. 5005. Expedition in hearing and determining the
action.
No comparable provision
Sec. 5006. Limitation on injunction and prospective relief.
No comparable provision
Sec. 5007. Legal standing.
No comparable provision
Sec. 5008. Study to identify legal and regulatory barriers
that delay, prohibit, or impede the export of natural
energy resources.
No comparable provision
Sec. 5009. Study of volatility of crude oil.
No comparable provision
Sec. 5010. Smart meter privacy rights.
No comparable provision
Sec. 5011. Youth energy enterprise competition.
Sec. 4740. Modernization of terms relating to minorities.
Sec. 5012. Modernization of terms relating to minorities.
No comparable provision
Sec. 5013. Voluntary vegetation management outside
rights-of-way.
No comparable provision
Sec. 5014. Repeal of rule for new residential wood
heaters.
TITLE VI—PROMOTING RENEWABLE
ENERGY WITH SHARED SOLAR
No comparable provision
Sec. 6001. Short title.
No comparable provision
Sec. 6002. Provision of interconnection service and net
billing service for community solar facilities.
TITLE VII—MARINE HYDROKINETIC
Sec. 3013. Definition of marine and hydrokinetic
renewable energy.
Sec. 7001. Definition of marine and hydrokinetic
renewable energy.
Sec. 3014. Marine and hydrokinetic renewable energy
research and development.
Sec. 7002. Marine and hydrokinetic renewable energy
research and development.
Sec. 3015. National Marine Renewable Energy Research,
Development, and Demonstration Centers.
Sec. 7003. National Marine Renewable Energy Research,
Development, and Demonstration Centers.
Sec. 3016. Authorization of appropriations.
Sec. 7004. Authorization of appropriations.
Congressional Research Service
20
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
TITLE VIII—EXTENSIONS OF TIME FOR
VARIOUS FEDERAL ENERGY REGULATORY
COMMISSION PROJECTS
Sec. 3003. Extension of time for a Federal Energy
Regulatory Commission project involving Clark Canyon
Dam.
Sec. 8001. Extension of time for Federal Energy
Regulatory Commission project involving Clark Canyon
Dam.
Sec. 3004. Extension of time for a Federal Energy
Regulatory Commission project involving Gibson Dam.
Sec. 8002. Extension of time for Federal Energy
Regulatory Commission project involving Gibson Dam.
No comparable provision
Sec. 8003. Extension of time for Federal Energy
Regulatory Commission project involving Jennings
Randolph Dam.
Sec. 10346. Extension of time for a Federal Energy
Regulatory Commission project involving Cannonsville
Dam.
Sec. 8004. Extension of time for Federal Energy
Regulatory Commission project involving Cannonsville
Dam.
Sec. 10344. Extension of deadline for certain other
hydroelectric projects.
Sec. 8005. Extension of time for Federal Energy
Regulatory Commission project involving Gathright Dam.
Sec. 10344. Extension of deadline for certain other
hydroelectric projects.
Sec. 8006. Extension of time for Federal Energy
Regulatory Commission project involving Flannagan Dam.
TITLE IX—ENERGY AND MANUFACTURING
WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT
Sec. 3601. 21st Century Energy Workforce Advisory
Board.
Sec. 9001. Energy and manufacturing workforce
development.
Sec. 3601. 21st Century Energy Workforce Advisory
Board.; Sec. 3602. Energy workforce pilot grant program.
Sec. 9002. Report.
Sec. 3602. Energy workforce pilot grant program.
Sec. 9003. Use of existing funds.
DIVISION B—RESILIENT FEDERAL FORESTS
No comparable provision
Sec. 1. Short title.
No comparable provision
Sec. 2. Definitions.
TITLE I—EXPEDITED ENVIRONMENTAL
ANALYSIS AND AVAILABILITY OF
CATEGORICAL EXCLUSIONS TO EXPEDITE
FOREST MANAGEMENT ACTIVITIES
No comparable provision
Sec. 101. Analysis of only two alternatives (action versus
no action) in proposed collaborative forest management
activities.
No comparable provision
Sec. 102. Categorical exclusion to expedite certain
critical response actions.
No comparable provision
Sec. 103. Categorical exclusion to expedite salvage
operations in response to catastrophic events.
No comparable provision
Sec. 104. Categorical exclusion to meet forest plan goals
for early successional forests.
No comparable provision
Sec. 105. Clarification of existing categorical exclusion
authority related to insect and disease infestation.
No comparable provision
Sec. 106. Categorical exclusion to improve, restore, and
reduce the risk of wildfire.
No comparable provision
Sec. 107. Compliance with forest plan.
Congressional Research Service
21
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
TITLE II—SALVAGE AND REFORESTATION IN
RESPONSE TO CATASTROPHIC EVENTS
No comparable provision
Sec. 201. Expedited salvage operations and reforestation
activities following large-scale catastrophic events.
No comparable provision
Sec. 202. Compliance with forest plan.
No comparable provision
Sec. 203. Prohibition on restraining orders, preliminary
injunctions, and injunctions pending appeal.
No comparable provision
Sec. 204. Exclusion of certain lands.
TITLE III—COLLABORATIVE PROJECT
LITIGATION REQUIREMENT
No comparable provision
Sec. 301. Definitions.
No comparable provision
Sec. 302. Bond requirement as part of legal challenge of
certain forest management activities.
TITLE IV—SECURE RURAL SCHOOLS AND
COMMUNITY SELF-DETERMINATION ACT
AMENDMENTS
No comparable provision
Sec. 401. Use of reserved funds for title II projects on
Federal land and certain non-Federal land.
No comparable provision
Sec. 402. Resource advisory committees.
No comparable provision
Sec. 403. Program for title II self-sustaining resource
advisory committee projects.
No comparable provision
Sec. 404. Additional authorized use of reserved funds for
title III county projects.
No comparable provision
Sec. 405. Treatment as supplemental funding.
TITLE V—STEWARDSHIP END RESULT
CONTRACTING
No comparable provision
Sec. 501. Cancellation ceilings for stewardship end result
contracting projects.
No comparable provision
Sec. 502. Excess offset value.
No comparable provision
Sec. 503. Payment of portion of stewardship project
revenues to county in which stewardship project occurs.
No comparable provision
Sec. 504. Submission of existing annual report.
No comparable provision
Sec. 505. Fire liability provision.
TITLE VI—ADDITIONAL FUNDING SOURCES
FOR FOREST MANAGEMENT ACTIVITIES
No comparable provision
Sec. 601. Definitions.
No comparable provision
Sec. 602. Availability of stewardship project revenues and
Collaborative Forest Landscape Restoration Fund to
cover forest management activity planning costs.
No comparable provision
Sec. 603. State-supported planning of forest management
activities.
TITLE VII—TRIBAL FORESTRY
PARTICIPATION AND PROTECTION
Congressional Research Service
22
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
No comparable provision
Sec. 701. Protection of tribal forest assets through use of
stewardship end result contracting and other authorities.
No comparable provision
Sec. 702. Management of Indian forest land authorized to
include related National Forest System lands and public
lands.
No comparable provision
Sec. 703. Tribal forest management demonstration
project.
TITLE VIII—MISCELLANEOUS FOREST
MANAGEMENT PROVISIONS
No comparable provision
Sec. 801. Balancing short- and long-term effects of forest
management activities in considering injunctive relief.
No comparable provision
Sec. 802. Conditions on Forest Service road
decommissioning.
No comparable provision
Sec. 803. Prohibition on application of Eastside Screens
requirements on National Forest System lands.
No comparable provision
Sec. 804. Use of site-specific forest plan amendments for
certain projects and activities.
No comparable provision
Sec. 805. Knutson-Vandenberg Act modifications.
No comparable provision
Sec. 806. Exclusion of certain National Forest System
lands and public lands.
No comparable provision
Sec. 807. Application of Northwest Forest Plan Survey
and Manage Mitigation Measure Standard and Guidelines.
No comparable provision
Sec. 808. Management of Bureau of Land Management
lands in western Oregon.
No comparable provision
Sec. 809. Bureau of Land Management resource
management plans.
No comparable provision
Sec. 810. Landscape-scale forest restoration project.
TITLE IX—MAJOR DISASTER FOR WILDFIRE
ON FEDERAL LAND
No comparable provision
Sec. 901. Wildfire on Federal lands.
No comparable provision
Sec. 902. Declaration of a major disaster for wildfire on
Federal lands.
No comparable provision
Sec. 903. Prohibition on transfers.
DIVISION C—NATURAL RESOURCES
TITLE I—WESTERN WATER AND AMERICAN
FOOD SECURITY ACT
No comparable provision
Sec. 1001. Short title.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1002. Findings.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1003. Definitions.
Subtitle A—ADJUSTING DELTA SMELT
MANAGEMENT BASED ON INCREASED REALTIME MONITORING AND UPDATED SCIENCE
No comparable provision
Congressional Research Service
Sec. 1011. Definitions.
23
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
No comparable provision
Sec. 1012. Revise incidental take level calculation for
delta smelt to reflect new science.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1013. Factoring increased real-time monitoring and
updated science into Delta smelt management.
Subtitle B—ENSURING SALMONID
MANAGEMENT IS RESPONSIVE TO NEW
SCIENCE
No comparable provision
Sec. 1021. Definitions.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1022. Process for ensuring salmonid management is
responsive to new science.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1023. Non-Federal program to protect native
anadromous fish in the Stanislaus River.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1024. Pilot projects to implement CALFED invasive
species program.
Subtitle C—OPERATIONAL FLEXIBILITY AND
DROUGHT RELIEF
No comparable provision
Sec. 1031. Definitions.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1032. Operational flexibility in times of drought.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1033. Operation of cross-channel gates.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1034. Flexibility for export/inflow ratio.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1035. Emergency environmental reviews.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1036. Increased flexibility for regular project
operations.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1037. Temporary operational flexibility for first few
storms of the water year.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1038. Expediting water transfers.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1039. Additional emergency consultation.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1040. Additional storage at New Melones.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1041. Regarding the operation of Folsom Reservoir.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1042. Applicants.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1043. San Joaquin River settlement.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1044. Program for water rescheduling.
Subtitle D—CALFED STORAGE FEASIBILITY
STUDIES
No comparable provision
Sec. 1051. Studies.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1052. Temperance Flat.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1053. CALFED storage accountability.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1054. Water storage project construction.
Subtitle E—WATER RIGHTS PROTECTIONS
No comparable provision
Sec. 1061. Offset for State Water Project.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1062. Area of origin protections.
Congressional Research Service
24
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
No comparable provision
Sec. 1063. No redirected adverse impacts.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1064. Allocations for Sacramento Valley contractors.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1065. Effect on existing obligations.
Subtitle F—MISCELLANEOUS
No comparable provision
Sec. 1071. Authorized service area.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1072. Oversight board for Restoration Fund.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1073. Water supply accounting.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1074. Implementation of water replacement plan.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1075. Natural and artificially spawned species.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1076. Transfer the New Melones Unit, Central
Valley Project to interested providers.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1077. Basin studies.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1078. Operations of the Trinity River Division.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1079. Amendment to purposes.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1080. Amendment to definition.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1081. Report on results of water usage.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1082. Klamath project consultation applicants.
Subtitle G—Water Supply Permitting Act
No comparable provision
Sec. 1091. Short title.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1092. Definitions.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1093. Establishment of lead agency and cooperating
agencies.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1094. Bureau responsibilities.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1095. Cooperating agency responsibilities.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1096. Funding to process permits.
Subtitle H—Bureau of Reclamation Project
Streamlining
No comparable provision
Sec. 1101. Short title.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1102. Definitions.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1103. Acceleration of studies.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1104. Expedited completion of reports.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1105. Project acceleration.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1106. Annual report to Congress.
Subtitle I—Accelerated Revenue, Repayment,
and Surface Water Storage Enhancement
No comparable provision
Sec. 1111. Short title.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1112. Prepayment of certain repayment contracts
between the United States and contractors of federally
developed water supplies.
Congressional Research Service
25
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
Subtitle J—Safety of Dams
No comparable provision
Sec. 1121. Authorization of additional project benefits.
Subtitle K—Water Rights Protection
No comparable provision
Sec. 1131. Short title.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1132. Definition of water right.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1133. Treatment of water rights.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1134. Recognition of State authority.
No comparable provision
Sec. 1135. Effect of title.
TITLE II—SPORTSMEN’S HERITAGE AND
RECREATIONAL ENHANCEMENT ACT
No comparable provision
Sec. 2001. Short title.
No comparable provision
Sec. 2002. Report on economic impact.
Subtitle A—Hunting, Fishing and Recreational
Shooting Protection Act
No comparable provision
Sec. 2011. Short title.
No comparable provision
Sec. 2012. Modification of definition.
No comparable provision
Sec. 2013. Limitation on authority to regulate
ammunition and fishing tackle.
Sec. 10251. Amendments to Pittman-Robertson Wildlife
Restoration Act.
Subtitle B—Target Practice and Marksmanship
Training Support Act
No comparable provision
Sec. 2021. Short title.
Sec. 10251. Amendments to Pittman-Robertson Wildlife
Restoration Act.
Sec. 2022. Findings; purpose.
Sec. 10251. Amendments to Pittman-Robertson Wildlife
Restoration Act. (b)
Sec. 2023. Definition of public target range.
Sec. 10251. Amendments to Pittman-Robertson Wildlife
Restoration Act.
Sec. 2024. Amendments to Pittman-Robertson Wildlife
Restoration Act.
No comparable provision
Sec. 2025. Limits on liability.
Sec. 10251. Amendments to Pittman-Robertson Wildlife
Restoration Act. (d)
Sec. 2026. Sense of Congress regarding cooperation.
Subtitle C—Polar Bear Conservation and
Fairness Act
No comparable provision
Sec. 2031. Short title.
No comparable provision
Sec. 2032. Permits for importation of polar bear
trophies taken in sport hunts in Canada.
Subtitle D—Recreational Lands Self-Defense Act
No comparable provision
Sec. 2041. Short title.
No comparable provision
Sec. 2042. Protecting Americans from violent crime.
Subtitle E—Wildlife and Hunting Heritage
Conservation Council Advisory Committee
Congressional Research Service
26
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
No comparable provision
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
Sec. 2051. Wildlife and Hunting Heritage Conservation
Council Advisory Committee.
Subtitle F—Recreational Fishing and Hunting
Heritage Opportunities Act
No comparable provision
Sec. 2061. Short title.
Sec. 10201. Congressional declaration of national policy.
Sec. 2062. Findings.
Sec. 10211. Definitions; Sec. 10212. Federal land open to
hunting, fishing, and recreational shooting; Sec. 10213.
Closure of Federal land to hunting, fishing, and
recreational shooting; Sec. 10214. Shooting ranges; Sec.
10262. No priority.
Sec. 2063. Fishing, hunting, and recreational shooting.
Sec. 10213. Closure of Federal land to hunting, fishing,
and recreational shooting; Sec. 10232. Wildlife
management in parks.
Sec. 2064. Volunteer Hunters; Reports; Closures and
Restrictions.
No comparable provision
Subtitle G—Farmer and Hunter Protection Act
No comparable provision
Sec. 2071. Short title.
No comparable provision
Sec. 2072. Baiting of migratory game birds.
Sec. 10231. Bows in parks.
Subtitle H—Transporting Bows Across National
Park Service Lands
Sec. 10231. Bows in parks.
Sec. 2081. Short title.
Sec. 10231. Bows in parks.
Sec. 2082. Bowhunting opportunity and wildlife
stewardship.
Sec. 10241. Federal Land Transaction Facilitation
Act.
Subtitle I—Federal Land Transaction Facilitation
Act Reauthorization (FLTFA)
Sec. 10241. Federal Land Transaction Facilitation Act.
Sec. 2091. Short title.
Sec. 10241. Federal Land Transaction Facilitation Act.
Sec. 2092. Federal Land Transaction Facilitation Act.
Subtitle J—African Elephant Conservation and
Legal Ivory Possession Act
No comparable provision
Sec. 2101. Short title.
No comparable provision
Sec. 2102. References.
No comparable provision
Sec. 2103. Placement of United States Fish and Wildlife
Service law enforcement officers in each African elephant
range country.
No comparable provision
Sec. 2104. Treatment of elephant ivory.
No comparable provision
Sec. 2105. African Elephant Conservation Act financial
assistance priority and reauthorization.
No comparable provision
Sec. 2106. Government Accountability Office study.
PART VII—Miscellaneous
Subtitle K—Respect for Treaties and Rights
Sec. 10261. Respect for treaties and rights.
Sec. 2111. Respect for Treaties and Rights.
Subtitle L—State Approval of Fishing Restriction
No comparable provision
Congressional Research Service
Sec. 2131. State or Territorial Approval of Restriction of
Recreational or Commercial Fishing Access to Certain
State or Territorial Waters.
27
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
No comparable provision
Subtitle M—Hunting and Recreational Fishing
Within Certain National Forests
No comparable provision
Sec. 2141. Definitions.
No comparable provision
Sec. 2142. Hunting and recreational fishing within the
national forest system.
No comparable provision
Sec. 2143. Publication of Closure of Roads in Forests.
Sec. 10232. Wildlife management in parks.
Subtitle N—Grand Canyon Bison Management
Act
Sec. 10232. Wildlife management in parks.
Sec. 2151. Short title.
Sec. 10232. Wildlife management in parks.
Sec. 2152. Definitions.
Sec. 10232. Wildlife management in parks.
Sec. 2153. Bison management plan for Grand Canyon
National Park.
Sec. 10215. Federal action transparency.
Subtitle O—Open Book on Equal Access to
Justice
Sec. 10215. Federal action transparency.
Sec. 2161. Short title.
Sec. 10215. Federal action transparency.
Sec. 2162. Modification of equal access to justice
provisions.
Subtitle P—Utility terrain vehicles
No comparable provision
Sec. 2171. Utility terrain vehicles in Kisatchie National
Forest.
Sec. 10007. Expedited access to certain Federal land.
Subtitle Q—Good Samaritan Search and
Recovery
Sec. 10007. Expedited access to certain Federal land.
Sec. 2181. Short title.
Sec. 10007. Expedited access to certain Federal land.
Sec. 2182. Expedited access to certain Federal land.
Subtitle R—Interstate Transportation of
Firearms or Ammunition
No comparable provision
Sec. 2191. Interstate transportation of firearms or
ammunition.
Subtitle S—Gray Wolves
No comparable provision
Sec. 2201. Reissuance of final rule regarding gray wolves
in the Western Great Lakes.
No comparable provision
Sec. 2202. Reissuance of final rule regarding gray wolves
in Wyoming.
Subtitle T—Miscellaneous provisions
No comparable provision
Sec. 2211. Prohibition on issuance of final rule.
No comparable provision
Sec. 2212. Withdrawal of existing rule regarding hunting
and trapping in Alaska.
Subtitle D - Critical Minerals
TITLE III—NATIONAL STRATEGIC AND
CRITICAL MINERALS PRODUCTION ACT
No comparable provision
Sec. 3001. Short title.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3002. Findings.
Sec. 3301. Definitions.
Sec. 3003. Definitions.
Congressional Research Service
28
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
Subtitle A—Development of Domestic Sources of
Strategic and Critical Minerals
No comparable provision
Sec. 3011. Improving development of strategic and
critical minerals.
Sec. 3305. Permitting.
Sec. 3012. Responsibilities of the lead agency.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3013. Conservation of the resource.
Sec. 3306. Federal Register process.
Sec. 3014. Federal register process for mineral
exploration and mining projects.
Subtitle B—Judicial review of agency actions
relating to Exploration and Mine Permits
No comparable provision
Sec. 3021. Definitions for title.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3022. Timely filings.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3023. Right to intervene.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3024. Expedition in hearing and determining the
action.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3025. Limitation on prospective relief.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3026. Limitation on attorneys’ fees.
No comparable provision
Subtitle C—Miscellaneous provisions
Sec. 3031. Secretarial order not affected.
TITLE VI—INDIAN TRIBAL ENERGY
DEVELOPMENT AND SELF-DETERMINATION
TITLE IV—NATIVE AMERICAN ENERGY ACT
Sec. 6001. Short title.
Sec. 4001. Short title.
Sec. 6204. Appraisals.
Sec. 4002. Appraisals.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4003. Standardization.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4004. Environmental reviews of major Federal
actions on Indian lands.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4005. Judicial review.
Sec. 6202. Tribal biomass demonstration project.
Sec. 4006. Tribal biomass demonstration project.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4007. Tribal resource management plans.
Sec. 6205. Leases of restricted lands for Navajo Nation.
Sec. 4008. Leases of restricted lands for the Navajo
Nation.
No comparable provision
Sec. 4009. Nonapplicability of certain rules.
TITLE V—NORTHPORT IRRIGATION EARLY
REPAYMENT
No comparable provision
Sec. 5001. Early repayment of construction costs.
TITLE VI—OCMULGEE MOUNDS NATIONAL
HISTORICAL PARK BOUNDARY REVISION
ACT
No comparable provision
Sec. 6001. Short title.
No comparable provision
Sec. 6002. Definitions.
No comparable provision
Sec. 6003. Ocmulgee Mounds National Historical Park.
Congressional Research Service
29
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
No comparable provision
Sec. 6004. Boundary adjustment.
No comparable provision
Sec. 6005. Land acquisition; no buffer zones.
No comparable provision
Sec. 6006. Administration.
No comparable provision
Sec. 6007. Ocmulgee River corridor special resource
study.
TITLE VII—MEDGAR EVERS HOUSE STUDY
ACT
No comparable provision
Sec. 7001. Short title.
No comparable provision
Sec. 7002. Special resource study.
TITLE VIII—SKY POINT MOUNTAIN
DESIGNATION
No comparable provision
Sec. 8001. Findings.
No comparable provision
Sec. 8002. Sky Point.
TITLE IX—CHIEF STANDING BEAR TRAIL
STUDY
No comparable provision
Sec. 9001. Chief Standing Bear national historic trail
feasibility study.
TITLE X—JOHN MUIR NATIONAL HISTORIC
SITE EXPANSION ACT
No comparable provision
Sec. 10001. Short title.
No comparable provision
Sec. 10002. John Muir National Historic Site land
acquisition.
Sec. 10001. Arapaho National Forest boundary
adjustment.
TITLE XI—ARAPAHO NATIONAL FOREST
BOUNDARY ADJUSTMENT ACT
Sec. 10001. Arapaho National Forest boundary
adjustment.
Sec. 11001. Short title.
Sec. 10001. Arapaho National Forest boundary
adjustment.
Sec. 11002. Arapaho National Forest boundary
adjustment.
TITLE XII—PRESERVATION RESEARCH AT
INSTITUTIONS SERVING MINORITIES ACT
No comparable provision
Sec. 12001. Short title.
No comparable provision
Sec. 12002. Eligibility of Hispanic-serving institutions and
Asian American and Native American Pacific Islanderserving institutions for assistance for preservation
education and training programs.
Sec. 10002. Land conveyance, Elkhorn Ranch and White
River National
TITLE XIII—ELKHORN RANCH AND WHITE
RIVER NATIONAL FOREST CONVEYANCE
ACT
Sec. 10002. Land conveyance, Elkhorn Ranch and White
River National
Sec. 13001. Short title.
Sec. 10002. Land conveyance, Elkhorn Ranch and White
River National
Sec. 13002. Land conveyance, Elkhorn Ranch and White
River National Forest, Colorado.
TITLE XIV—NATIONAL LIBERTY MEMORIAL
CLARIFICATION ACT
Congressional Research Service
30
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
No comparable provision
Sec. 14001. Short title.
No comparable provision
Sec. 14002. Compliance with certain standards for
commemorative works in establishment of National
Liberty Memorial.
TITLE XV—CRAGS, COLORADO LAND
EXCHANGE ACT
Sec. 10003. Land exchange in Crags, Colorado.
Sec. 15001. Short title.
Sec. 10003. Land exchange in Crags, Colorado.
Sec. 15002. Purposes.
Sec. 10003. Land exchange in Crags, Colorado.
Sec. 15003. Definitions.
Sec. 10003. Land exchange in Crags, Colorado.
Sec. 15004. Land exchange.
Sec. 10003. Land exchange in Crags, Colorado.
Sec. 15005. Equal value exchange and appraisals.
Sec. 10003. Land exchange in Crags, Colorado.
Sec. 15006. Miscellaneous provisions.
TITLE XVI—REMOVE REVERSIONARY
INTEREST IN ROCKINGHAM COUNTY LAND
No comparable provision
Sec. 16001. Removal of use restriction.
TITLE XVII—COLTSVILLE NATIONAL
HISTORICAL PARK
No comparable provision
Sec. 17001. Amendment to Coltsville National Historical
Park donation site.
TITLE XVIII—MARTIN LUTHER KING, JR.
NATIONAL HISTORICAL PARK ACT
No comparable provision
Sec. 18001. Short title.
No comparable provision
Sec. 18002. Martin Luther King, Jr. National Historical
Park.
No comparable provision
Sec. 18003. References.
TITLE XIX—EXTENSION OF THE
AUTHORIZATION FOR THE
GULLAH/GEECHEE CULTURAL HERITAGE
CORRIDOR COMMISSION
No comparable provision
Sec. 19001. Extension of the authorization for the
Gullah/Geechee Cultural Heritage Corridor
Commission.
TITLE XX—9/11 MEMORIAL ACT
No comparable provision
Sec. 20001. Short title.
No comparable provision
Sec. 20002. Definitions.
No comparable provision
Sec. 20003. Designation of memorial.
No comparable provision
Sec. 20004. Competitive grants for certain memorials.
TITLE XXI—KENNESAW MOUNTAIN
NATIONAL BATTLEFIELD PARK BOUNDARY
ADJUSTMENT ACT
No comparable provision
Sec. 21001. Short title.
No comparable provision
Sec. 21002. Findings.
Congressional Research Service
31
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
No comparable provision
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
Sec. 21003. Boundary adjustment; land acquisition;
administration.
TITLE XXII—VEHICLE ACCESS AT
DELAWARE WATER GAP NATIONAL
RECREATION AREA
No comparable provision
Sec. 22001. Vehicular access and fees.
No comparable provision
Sec. 22002. Definitions.
No comparable provision
Sec. 22003. Conforming amendment.
TITLE XXIII—GULF ISLANDS NATIONAL
SEASHORE LAND EXCHANGE ACT
No comparable provision
Sec. 23001. Short title.
No comparable provision
Sec. 23002. Land exchange, Gulf Islands National
Seashore, Jackson County, Mississippi.
TITLE XXIV—KOREAN WAR VETERANS
MEMORIAL WALL OF REMEMBRANCE ACT
No comparable provision
Sec. 24001. Short title.
No comparable provision
Sec. 24002. Wall of Remembrance.
TITLE XXV—NATIONAL FOREST SMALL
TRACTS ACT AMENDMENTS ACT
No comparable provision
Sec. 25001. Short title.
No comparable provision
Sec. 25002. Additional authority for sale or exchange of
small parcels of National Forest System land.
TITLE XXVI—WESTERN OREGON TRIBAL
FAIRNESS ACT
No comparable provision
Sec. 26001. Short title.
Subtitle A—Cow Creek Umpqua Land
Conveyance
No comparable provision
Sec. 26011. Short title.
No comparable provision
Sec. 26012. Definitions.
No comparable provision
Sec. 26013. Conveyance.
No comparable provision
Sec. 26014. Map and legal description.
No comparable provision
Sec. 26015. Administration.
No comparable provision
Sec. 26016. Land reclassification.
Subtitle B—Coquille Forest Fairness
No comparable provision
Sec. 26021. Short title.
No comparable provision
Sec. 26022. Amendments to Coquille Restoration Act.
Subtitle C—Oregon Coastal Lands
No comparable provision
Sec. 26031. Short title.
No comparable provision
Sec. 26032. Definitions.
No comparable provision
Sec. 26033. Conveyance.
No comparable provision
Sec. 26034. Map and legal description.
Congressional Research Service
32
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
No comparable provision
Sec. 26035. Administration.
No comparable provision
Sec. 26036. Land reclassification.
DIVISION D—SCIENCE
TITLE V—DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY
SCIENCE
Sec. 4404. Under Secretary for Science and Energy.
Sec. 501. Mission.
No comparable provision
Sec. 502. Basic energy sciences.
Sec. 2401. Exascale computer research program.
Sec. 503. Advanced scientific computing research.
Sec. 4207. National Science and Technology Council
coordinating subcommittee for high-energy physics.
Sec. 504. High energy physics.
No comparable provision
Sec. 505. Biological and environmental research.
No comparable provision
Sec. 506. Fusion energy.
No comparable provision
Sec. 507. Nuclear physics.
No comparable provision
Sec. 508. Science laboratories infrastructure program.
No comparable provision
Sec. 509. Domestic manufacturing.
Sec. 4201(a). America COMPETES programs.
Sec. 510. Authorization of appropriations.
No comparable provision
Sec. 511. Definitions.
TITLE VI—DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY
APPLIED RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT
Subtitle A—Crosscutting Research and
Development
No comparable provision
Sec. 601. Crosscutting research and development.
No comparable provision
Sec. 602. Strategic research portfolio analysis and
coordination plan.
No comparable provision
Sec. 603. Strategy for facilities and infrastructure.
No comparable provision
Sec. 604. Energy Innovation Hubs.
Subtitle B—Electricity Delivery and Energy
Reliability Research and Development
No comparable provision
Sec. 611. Distributed energy and electric energy systems.
No comparable provision
Sec. 612. Electric transmission and distribution research
and development.
Title III - Subtitle F—Nuclear
Subtitle C—Nuclear Energy Research and
Development (See also House Division D - Sec.
714; and TITLE XXXIII—NUCLEAR ENERGY
INNOVATION CAPABILITIES - Secs. 3301-3311)
Sec. 3501. Nuclear energy innovation capabilities.
Sec. 621. Objectives.
No comparable provision
Sec. 622. Program objectives study.
Sec. 3501. Nuclear energy innovation capabilities.
Sec. 623. Nuclear energy research and development
programs.
No comparable provision
Sec. 624. Small modular reactor program.
Sec. 3501. Nuclear energy innovation capabilities.
Sec. 625. Fuel cycle research and development.
Congressional Research Service
33
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
Sec. 3501. Nuclear energy innovation capabilities.
Sec. 626. Nuclear energy enabling technologies program.
No comparable provision
Sec. 627. Technical standards collaboration.
Sec. 4406. Research grants database.
Division D - Sec. 628. Available facilities database.
Subtitle D—Energy Efficiency and Renewable
Energy Research and Development
No comparable provision (related provision in Senate
Sec. 1306)
Sec. 641. Energy efficiency.
No comparable provision
Sec. 642. Next Generation Lighting Initiative.
No comparable provision
Sec. 643. Building standards.
No comparable provision
Sec. 644. Secondary electric vehicle battery use program.
No comparable provision
Sec. 645. Network for Manufacturing Innovation
Program.
No comparable provision
Sec. 646. Advanced Energy Technology Transfer Centers.
No comparable provision
Sec. 647. Renewable energy.
No comparable provision
Sec. 648. Bioenergy program.
No comparable provision
Sec. 649. Concentrating solar power research program.
No comparable provision
Sec. 650. Renewable energy in public buildings.
Subtitle E—Fossil Energy Research and
Development
Sec. 3402. Fossil energy.
Sec. 661. Fossil energy.
Sec. 3403. Establishment of coal technology program.
Sec. 662. Coal research, development, demonstration,
and commercial application programs.
No comparable provision
Sec. 663. High efficiency gas turbines research and
development.
Subtitle F—Advanced Research Projects Agency–
Energy
SEC. 4201(b). America COMPETES programs.
Sec. 671. ARPA–E amendments.
Subtitle G—Authorization of appropriations
SEC. 4201(a). America COMPETES programs.
Sec. 681. Authorization of appropriations.
Subtitle H—Definitions
No comparable provision
Sec. 691. Definitions.
TITLE VII—DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY
TECHNOLOGY TRANSFER
Subtitle A—In General
No comparable provision
Sec. 701. Definitions.
No comparable provision
Sec. 702. Savings clause.
Subtitle B—Innovation Management at
Department of Energy
No comparable provision
Sec. 712. Technology transfer and transitions assessment.
Sec. 4203. Supporting access of small business concerns
to National Laboratories.
Sec. 713. Sense of Congress.
Congressional Research Service
34
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
S. 2012 (Engrossed in Senate)
Sec. 3501. Nuclear energy innovation capabilities.
S. 2012 (Engrossed House Amendment)
Sec. 714. Nuclear energy innovation. (See also House
Division D - Title VI, Subtitle C—Nuclear Energy
Research and Development - Secs. 621-628; and TITLE
XXXIII—NUCLEAR ENERGY INNOVATION
CAPABILITIES - Secs. 3301-3311)
Subtitle C—Cross-Sector Partnerships and Grant
Competitiveness
No comparable provision
Sec. 721. Agreements for Commercializing Technology
pilot program.
No comparable provision
Sec. 722. Public-private partnerships for
commercialization.
Sec. 4202. Inclusion of early stage technology
demonstration in authorized technology transfer
activities.
Sec. 723. Inclusion of early-stage technology
demonstration in authorized technology transfer
activities.
Sec. 4411. Study of waivers of certain cost-sharing
requirements.
Sec. 724. Funding competitiveness for institutions of
higher education and other nonprofit institutions.
No comparable provision
Sec. 725. Participation in the Innovation Corps program.
Subtitle D—Assessment of Impact
No comparable provision
Sec. 731. Report by Government Accountability Office.
TITLE XXXIII—NUCLEAR ENERGY
INNOVATION CAPABILITIES (See also House
Division D - Title VI, Subtitle C—Nuclear Energy
Research and Development - Secs. 621-628; and
Sec. 714.)
No comparable provision
Sec. 3301. Short title.
Sec. 3501. Nuclear energy innovation capabilities.
Sec. 3302. Nuclear energy.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3303. Nuclear energy research programs.
No comparable provision
Sec. 3304. Advanced fuel cycle initiative.
Sec. 4721. Elimination and consolidation of certain
America COMPETES programs.
Division D - Sec. 3305. University nuclear science and
engineering support.
Sec. 3501. Nuclear energy innovation capabilities.
Sec. 3306. Department of Energy civilian nuclear
infrastructure and facilities.
Sec. 3501. Nuclear energy innovation capabilities.
Sec. 3307. Security of nuclear facilities.
Sec. 3501. Nuclear energy innovation capabilities.
Sec. 3308. High-performance computation and
supportive research.
Sec. 3501. Nuclear energy innovation capabilities.
Sec. 3309. Enabling nuclear energy innovation.
Sec. 3501. Nuclear energy innovation capabilities.
Sec. 3310. Budget plan.
Sec. 3501. Nuclear energy innovation capabilities.
Sec. 3311. Conforming amendments.
Source: CRS analysis.
Congressional Research Service
35
Energy Legislation: Comparable Provisions in S. 2012
Author Contact Information
(name redacted)
Specialist in Energy Policy
r[ edacted/@crs.loc.gov
, 7-....
(name redacted)
Acting Deputy Assistant Director/RSI
[redacted/@crs.loc.gov , 7-....
Key Policy Staff
Area of Expertise
Name
Phone
Automotive Industry
(name redacted)
7-....
[redacted]@crs.loc.gov
Carbon Capture and Sequestration
(name redacted)
7-....
[redacted]@crs.loc.gov
Electric Power
(name redacted)
7-....
[redacted]@crs.loc.gov
Energy Development on Federal Lands,
Critical Minerals, Helium
(name redacted)
7-....
[redacted]@crs.loc.gov
Energy Efficiency, Renewable Energy
(name redacted)
7-....3
[redacted]@crs.loc.gov
Energy Efficiency, Renewable Energy
(name redacted)
7-....
[redacted]@crs.loc.gov
Energy Policy
(name redacted)
7-....
[redacted]@crs.loc.gov
EPA Brownfields Program
(name redacted)
7-....
[redacted]@crs.loc.gov
Equal Access to Justice Act
(name redacted)
7-....
[redacted]@crs.loc.gov
Federal Lands
(name redacted)
7-....
[redacted]@crs.loc.gov
Fish and Wildlife Recreation
(name redacted)
7-....
[redacted]@crs.loc.gov
Forest Management
(name redacted)
7-....
[redacted]@crs.loc.gov
Infrastructure Security, Pipelines
(name redacted)
7-....
[redacted]@crs.loc.gov
National Park Service
(name redacted)
7-....
[redacted]@crs.loc.gov
Natural Gas, Quadrennial Energy
Review
(name redacted)
7-....
[redacted]@crs.loc.gov
Nuclear Energy
(name redacted)
7-....
[redacted]@crs.loc.gov
Oil Export Policy
( name redacted)
7-....
[redacted]@crs.loc.gov
Strategic Petroleum Reserve
(name redacted)
7-....
[redacted]@crs.loc.gov
Water Resources, Drought Response
(name redacted)
7-....
[redacted]@crs.loc.gov
Congressional Research Service
36
EveryCRSReport.com
The Congressional Research Service (CRS) is a federal legislative branch agency, housed inside the
Library of Congress, charged with providing the United States Congress non-partisan advice on
issues that may come before Congress.
EveryCRSReport.com republishes CRS reports that are available to all Congressional staff. The
reports are not classified, and Members of Congress routinely make individual reports available to
the public.
Prior to our republication, we redacted names, phone numbers and email addresses of analysts
who produced the reports. We also added this page to the report. We have not intentionally made
any other changes to any report published on EveryCRSReport.com.
CRS reports, as a work of the United States government, are not subject to copyright protection in
the United States. Any CRS report may be reproduced and distributed in its entirety without
permission from CRS. However, as a CRS report may include copyrighted images or material from a
third party, you may need to obtain permission of the copyright holder if you wish to copy or
otherwise use copyrighted material.
Information in a CRS report should not be relied upon for purposes other than public
understanding of information that has been provided by CRS to members of Congress in
connection with CRS' institutional role.
EveryCRSReport.com is not a government website and is not affiliated with CRS. We do not claim
copyright on any CRS report we have republished.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.