Appendix — Ex parte Phillips
Supreme Court brief1943
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
eel .+30
APR 20 1943 |
LES ELMSEE CRBPI.
“OLERK
B
Supreme Gourt af the United States
OCTOBER TERM, 1942
945-946 &989
FORD MOTOR COMPANY,
Petitioner,
vs.
THE GORDON FORM LATHE COMPANY,
Respondent.
Transcript of Record
On Petition for Writ of Certiorari to the United States Circuit
Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit
VOLUME IV.
Plaintiff's Exhibits, Defendant’s Exhibits
and Main Record Exhibits.
I. Joszrn Farwey,
1664 National Bank Bldg.,
Detroit, Michigan,
Coorzr, Kerr & Dunnam,
“Woolworth Bldg., 233 Broadway,
New York, New York,
Attorneys for Petitioner.
Lecuer, MicnarLt, Wuyte & Spoun,
110 East Wisconsin Ave., Milwaukee, Wisconsin,
Ricuey & Watts,
Union Commerce Bldg., Cleveland, Ohio,
7 Swan, Frye & Harpesty,
Ford Bldg., Detroit, Michigan,
Attorneys for Respondent.
Eee
United States Circuit Court of Appeals
FOR THE SIXTH CIRCUIT.
THE GORDON FORM LATHE COMPANY,
Plaintiff-Appellant and Cross-Appellee,
vs.
FORD MOTOR COMPANY,
Defendant-Appellee and Cross-Appellant.
Equity No. 4564.
AppEAL F'RoMm
Tue District Court or THE UniTEp States,
Eastern District or MIcHIGAN,
SovuTHERN Division.
TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD.
VOLUME IV.
Plaintiff’s Exhibits, Defendant’s Exhibits
and Main Record Exhibits.
LecHer, MicnaEL, Wuyte & Spoun,
110 East Wisconsin Ave., Milwaukee, Wisconsin,
Ricney & Warts,
Union Commerce Bldg., Cleveland, Ohio,
Swan, Frye & Harpesty,
Ford Bldg., Detroit, Michigan,
Attorneys for Plaintiff-Appellant and
Cross-Appellee.
Bopman, Lonciey, Bociz, Mippteton & Far ey,
1400 Buhl Bldg., Detroit, Michigan,
Cooprr, Kerr & DunHam,
Woolworth Bldg., 233 Broadway,
New York, New York,
Attorneys for Defendant-Appellee and
Cross-Appellant.
a
al i clas lle in cams
Caption
INDEX.
VOLUME I.
Trial Papers, Plaintiff’s Record and Part of
Defendant’s Record.
coor eoeoeeeo eee eee eeeeeeeeereeeeeereereeeeeeeeeeee eee
DS ON ES. oo n.n cd 000 800 50etuenweesesuesees¢esea
Report of Special Master...........: see cece eeeeeeeeeees
i.
IL.
III.
IV.
Nature of Invention and History of Litigation and
of Defendant’s Use of Machinery...............+.-
Cr Or ee a pesecesensecesteutess
Accounting Period, and Produciion of Shafts on In-
fringing Machines: Question of Notice............
A. Dagheting CF PestOE. cc ccscccccccsccesccecses
B. Production of Camshafts and End of Accounting
PUNE sc ccvnccccececevevecsvsestceveveseeces
A. Profits from Infringement...............-..+.
1. Standard of Comparison...... peésnenivesne
a. Standard for Model A Shaft............
(1) Pioch and Modified Walcott Machines
(2) Westinghouse Lathe ...............
Gap PONS Ce BE. oc cccccccsccesere
b. Standard for Tractor Shaft.............
e. Effect of Choice of Incorrect Standard...
2. Savings from Use of Infringing Machines...
a. Savings or Loss in Other Operations:
PE. co bcacacdcusuduassecures
b. Savings in Cam-Roughing Operation.....
(1) Direct Labor Savings...............
I
a —
(a) Speeds of Production on Model T
GE ccc vccvessvucvekaqitedens
(b) Speeds of Production on Model A
GOES icc vcusdcesreesvavcecees
(c) Speeds of Production on Tractor
GOES cccaccesvisecousedereses
(2) Other Savings: Overhead or Burden
(3) Offset of Loss from Scrapping Shap-
GD ccccesscevesvoreevesseedeerecns
3. Apportionment of Profits.........--+++++++
V. Damages: Reasonable Royalty.........++++++++++
A. Conditions to Assessment of Reasonable Royalty
B. Amount of Royalty...........seeeeeeeeeeeeee
VI. Questions of Clean Hands and of Increase of Re-
COVETY occccccccecvecccccccesecvcesssouccsesvess
A, Chonm Hlamdls 2c ccccccccecccccvcceccesccceness
B. Increase of Recovery.........2.:+eeeeeeeeeees
,3) = rr errr ry rey TT terse
Schedule A. Production of Camshafts on Infringing Ma-
GMOS cccccccevncesccesveccasadvecdevesesceensves
Schedule B. Proration of Production on Camshafts be-
tween Pioch and Walcott Machines, May 14, 1930 to
March 15, 1931, inclusive. ............::seecereceess
Schedule C. Comparative Costs on Cam-Roughing Op-
eration with Walcott Lathes and Standards of Com-
BOOEGOM, 6 oo cc ccccvscerveneDeiretecstreocdavvisyes:
Clerk’s Notice of the Filing of the Master’s Report........
Plaintiff’s Objections to Master’s Report............-+++
Exceptions of Defendant to the Report of the Special Master
Motion for Action Upon Master’s Report and Objections
TeTetO oc ccccvccvcvcvceseveccccsescevseccesesovess
AGidavit of Todid La, MekeO. oc cccccccccccccecssvescess
43
44
46
47
103
111
111
oS ee
¥
t
‘
Bahatialla FT nc ccccvcccccesecvcccossesesescsovccosess
Rdleodlln TE noc cccccccccscvcessccvecssesessusseseses
Sahaliatn TEE a vcccccvcccscccesevesesrescssssvesesees
Galetiatin TY ccccccccccccovesvevesecrecsevececceeses
Notice of Motion for Action Upon Master’s Report........
Opinion of the Hon. Arthur J. Tuttle, District Judge, on the
Objections to the Master’s Report..........-+-++++++
Master’s Order for Statement of Account, dated July 6, 1937
Exhibit A—Defendant’s Statement of Account, filed Septem-
2 Ae Me PPrrrerrrrr: TTT TrITTITTTrTti ieee
Exhibit 7. Operation Sheet No. 1.-..........-++0000-
Operation Sheet No. 2.........:eeeeeeeees
Operation Sheet No. 3...........-e ee eens
Operation Sheet No. 4............20ee00e
Operation Sheet No. 5.........--eeeeeeeee
Exhibit 10. Material Price Card No. 1...........++..-
Material Price Card No. 2...........--0-
Exhibit 11. Computation of Certain Items of Cost of
Gordon Lathe Operation on Tractor Cam-
GED svcccsuccrssescuveccecectocceeeses
Exhibit 12. Computation of Certain Costs Invoived in
Rough Grinding Operation on Tractor Cam-
shafts by Landis 10 x 36 Grinders during
Period July 1, 1925 to January 1, 1928.....
Exhibit B—Amendment to Defendant’s Statement of Ac-
count, verified December 31, 1937............2000seeee
Ptf. Rec. Vol. III beginning line 18, page 29 of Type-
written Transcript (Mr. Spohn)..............+.+:
Master’s Order for Statement of Account, dated October 29,
OEE who cbdknceuedees) ede inetacdtedeentesensenceees
Exhibit C—Defendant’s Further Statement of Account,
RG TRUONG Gh, DOE 006 koveveccccevcdcvonesvesees
Ptf. Rec. Vol. III from page 34, line 26 to page 37, line 3
inclusive of Typewritten Transcript (Mr. Spohn)..
Ilr
161
166
169
193
TRANSCRIPT OF TESTIMONY
(Designated by both Plaintiff and Defendant).
Appearances ......eeeeeeeeeereesressnsessesseser esses:
PLAINTIFF’S RECORD.
Frep M. Hovis (Defendant’s Witness) :
Cross Examination by Mr. Spohn......--+++++s++es+:
Cross Examination by Mr. Farley......-++++++++++++*
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Spohn......--+++++++++5
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Farley.....---++++++++:
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Spohn......--+++++++++:
Harotp M. Woeurte (Defendant’s Witness) :
Cross Examination by Mr. Spohn......--+++++++e+ee:
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Spohn......--++++++++++
Cross Examination by Mr. Spohn.....--..++-+++eeeees
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley.......+++++++++:
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Spohn........++-++++++:
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley......+-++++++++>
Frep M. Hovis (Recalled) :
Cross Examination by Mr. Spohn......--+++++eeereees
Harotp M. Woeurze (Recalled) :
Cross Examination by Mr. Spohn.......--+-++eeeeeees
Cross Examination by Mr. Farley
eoeoeceeveeveeeeveeev eee e @
Norman R. Scovity (Defendant’s Witness) :
Direct Examination by Mr. Farley
Cross Examination by Mr. Spohn
eeovoeeveovoeveeevoeeeoe oo eee?
Topp L. Morse (Plaintiff’s Witness) :
- Direct Examination by Mr. Spohn
“Cross Examination by Mr. Farley........-+++++++++++
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Spohn
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Farley
IV
«Linh LI 2,2: AE OI OE
To as
ff,
%
Cuar.es Gorpon (Plaintiff’s Witness) :
Direct Examination by Mr. Spohn............-++++++5 275
Cross Examination by Mr. Farley........-+-++++++++ 280
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Spohn...........--+++ 282
Cross Examination by Mr. Farley............+++++++5 283
Lyze E. Broventon (Plaintiff’s Witness) :
Direct* Examination by Mr. Spohn...........+++++++5 291
Howarp Jongs (Plaintiff’s Witness) :
Direct Examination by Mr. Spohn..............e+++55 296
Cross Examination by Mr. Farley.........++++++++++5 300
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Spohn............+++++ 302
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Farley...........+++++: 303
Muues G. Stonixer (Plaintiff’s Witness) :
Direct Examination by Mr. Spohn............+eeeee+5 304
Cross Examination by Mr. Farley...........++++se++ 308
DEFENDANT’S RECORD.
Cares Gorpon (Plaintiff’s Witness) :
Cross Examination by Mr. Farley............s++eeee 312
Topp L. Morse (Recalled) (Plaintiff’s Witness) :
Cross Examination by Mr. Farley..........-..++eeees 423
* The Examination of Lyle E. Broughton by Mr. Spohn, appearing on
page 291, was incorrectly stated in the Typewritten Transcript. It should
be ‘‘Direct’’ instead of ‘‘Cross.’’
VOLUME II.
Defendant’s Record (Continued).
Morris E. Suawxey (Defendant’s Witness) :
Direct Examination by Mr. Farley.......---+++++++++:
Spencer W. Lipsy (Defendant’s Witness) :
Direct Examination by Mr. Farley........-++++++++++:
Cross Examination by Mr. Spohn.........--++++++0++5
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley........-+++++++:
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Spohn.........++++++++>
Morris E. Suawkey (Recalled) (Defendant’s Witness) :
Direct Examination by Mr. Farley........-++++++++++5
Mixes Kuopsic (Defendant’s Witness) :
Direct Examination by Mr. Farley.........++++++++++5
Rautpu T. Myers (Defendant’s Witness) :
Direct Examination by Mr. Farley..........++++++++++
Victor F. Marentette (Defendant’s Witness) :
Direct Examination by Mr. Farley.........-+++++++++5
Cross Examination by Mr. Spohn.........-.+++++++++
A. M. Wiset (Defendant’s Witness) :
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley...........+-++++
Cuarzes Gorpon (Plaintiff’s Witness) :
Cross Examination by Mr. Farley
TrroporE R. Dau (Defendant’s Witness) :
Direct Examination by Mr. Farley
Grorce W. Smiru, Jr. (Defendant’s Witness) :
Direct Examination by Mr. Farley
Apert Aprekar (Defendant’s Witness) :
Direct Examination by Mr. Farley............+++0++0+
Cross Examination by Mr. Michael.................--
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley
eee eee eee ewe eeene
VI
i oR err tease eT
Sse
sian
é
:
i
j
i
;
Wiuiam D. Hunt (Defendant’s Witness) :
Direct Examination by Mr. Farley.........---+++++++>
Cross Examination by Mr. Spohn........-+--++++++++5
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley.........+-+-+++++
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Spohn..........-+++++++
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley..........-++++++
Henry G. Pruincer (Defendant’s Witness) :
Direct Examination by Mr. Farley.........+++++++++++
Cross Examination by Mr. Spohn............+++++0+55
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley.........+..+++++
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Spohn............+.++++
Joun L. Scumint (Defendant’s Witness) :
Direct Examination by Mr. Farley..........6+++00+45+
Cross Examination by Mr. Spohn............0+++++0+5
Rupy Exruarp Herxtorz (Defendant’s Witness) :
Direct Examination by Mr. Farley............65-00e
Wu F. Piocn (Defendant’s Witness) :
Direct Examination by Mr. Farley............-+.0005:
Cross Examination by Mr. Michael..................+
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley..............-.
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Michael................
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley............+.+++
Nrets Borsen (Defendant’s Witness) :
Direct Examination by Mr. Farley...............++++:
Auanson P. Brusu (Defendant’s Witness) :
Direct Examination by Mr. Farley.............-.0-++:
Cross Examination by Mr. Michael.................--
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Michael
eee ee eee eweeeeaee
VII
Ervin Franky (Defendant’s Witness) :
Direct Examination by Mr. Farley......-+-++se++seees 825
Cross Examination by Mr. Spohn.......-++++eeereeees 843
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley......---++++++++ 846
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Spohn......----s++++++5 846
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley.....--+++++++++: 846
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Spohn......---++++++++5 847
Josep Henry Acuten (Defendant’s Witness) :
Direct Examination by Mr. Farley........+-+++++eee++ 847
Cross Examination by Mr. Michael.........+++++++0+> 856
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley.......+-+++++++5 859
Frep Hovis (Recalled) (Defendant’s Witness) :
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley.......-++++++++: 863
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Spohn........-++++++++5 869
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley.......+-+-+++++5 874
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Spohn.......-+++++++++5 877
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley........+++++++++ 881
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Spohn.........++++++++5 882
VIII
VOLUME III.
Defendant’s Record (Continued),
Appendix to Record and Appeal Papers.
Harotp W. Hoceian (Defendant’s Witness) :
j
3 Direct Examination by Mr. Farley...-.--+++++++0+++*: 883
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley.....-+-++++++++> 889
' Pierce Atpert Weyt (Defendant’s Witness) :
: Direct Examination by Mr. Farley.....----+++++ses+00° 891
Cross Examination by Mr. Michael......-.-+++++++++: 911
i Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley.....---++++++++* 913
; Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Michael......---++++++> 918
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley.....--+-++++++++ 920
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Michael.......-+++++++> 924
James McEvoy (Defendant’s Witness) :
Direct Examination by Mr. Farley...-..+-+++e++++eee* 925
R Cross Examination by Mr. Michael.......--+++++++++5 932
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley....-.--++++++++* 935
Axpert Aprekar (Recalled) (Defendant’s Witness) :
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley.....--+--+++++++> 936
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Spohn......---+++s+++% 939
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Michael.....--..++++++> 940
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley......---+++++++> 942
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Michael......--.+++++++ 943
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley......--++++++++: 945
I. Joseru Fartey (Defendant’s Witness) :
Direct Testimony ......--:ee cee eeeere reece eerreeees 951
Cross Examination by Mr. Michael.........--++++++++: 956
Joun W. Micuaet (Plaintiff’s Witness) :
Direct Testimony .......-:eeeeee creer eee eeeeeeees 962
Cross Examination by Mr. Farley..........+-+++++++5 965
Norman R. Scovitzt (Defendant’s Witness) :
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley........-++++++++ 971
Ix
cee le ;
Harotp M. Woeurte (Defendant’s Witness) :
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley.....---+-+++++*: 980
Wituia F. Proc (Defendant’s Witness) :
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley.....-.--++-++++: 1051
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Michael........--+++++> 1055
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley...-..--++++++++> 1059
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley.....-.-++++++++: 1060
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Michael.......-.--+-+++- 1061
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley......--++++++++> 1063
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Michael...-..-..-+++++- 1063
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley.....----++++++++ 1063
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Michael......-.--.++++: 1064
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley.....----++++++++ 1064
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Michael......-.-+--+++> 1065
Harotp M. Wornrue (Defendant’s Witness) :
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley......---+++++++: 1065
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Spohn......---++++++++: 1071
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley.......-----+++++ 1080
Donatp M. Russevt (Defendant’s Witness) :
Direct Examination by Mr. Farley.......-----+++++++: 1082
Harotp M. Worurwe (Defendant’s Witness) :
Examination by the Master........----++eeeeeeeeeees 1094
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley.........+++++++: 1095
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Spohn.........-+++++++- 1096
ALEXANDER OBERHOFFKEN (Defendant’s Witness) :
Direct Examination by Mr. Farley........-+--+++++++: 1097
Cross Examination by Mr. Michael...........++++++++ 1114
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley........-.--+++++ 1122
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Michael.............--- 1124
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley...........--+++: 1126
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Michael............-+-- 1127
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley..........-+++++: 1129
x
Henwine Ourn (Defendant’s Witness) :
Direct Examination by Mr. Farley........-+--+++++++:
Cross Examination by Mr. Michael..........--++-+++++
Re-)irect Examination by Mr. Farley........---+++++:
Cuar.es Hasovicu (Defendant’s Witness) :
Direct Examination by Mr. Farley..........-+-+++++55
Cross Examination by Mr. Michael...........++++++++
Aupert Kipta (Defendant’s Witness) :
Direct Examination by Mr. Farley......-..-..+++++++5
Cross Examination by Mr. Michael............-.++5++
Wuuiam D. Hunt (Recalled) (Defendant’s Witness) :
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley............+++:
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Michael............+++-
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Farley.............+.+:
Cuar.es Gorvon (Recalled) (Plaintiff’s Witness) :
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Michael.............+++
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Farley............06++:
Topp L. Morse (Recalled) (Plaintiff’s Witness) :
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Spohn
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Farley
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Spohn
eeeereeeeereseeeteee
eee eee ee ee eeeenne
eeoeereereeeeeeeeere
xI
APPENDIX
TO TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD
Designated Portion of the Testimony of the Witnesses
Otto H. Schultz, Frank Steinke, Bert Weisel, William
Cunningham, and Charles Gordon from Plaintiff’s Exhibit
14—Patent Office Record, Interference No. 47,200—Her-
man W. Melling vs. Charles Gordon and Alfred Redlin.
Orto H. Scuvuttz:
Q. 1, page 132, to and including Q. 22 and Answer, page
136:
Direct Examination by Mr. Earl.......-++++e0ees 1261
Q. 45, page 140, to and including Q. 72 and Answer 145:
Direct Examination by Mr. Earl......---+++eeeees 1264
Bert WEISEL:
Q. 1, page 190, to and including Q. 55 and Answer, page
Direct Examination by Mr. Earl......-++++++e+e+* 1268
XQ. 84 and Answer, page 203 :
Cross Examination by Mr. Dennett........++++++: 1274
XQ. 100, page 205, to and including XQ. 102 and Answer,
page 206:
Cross Examination by Mr. Dennett........++-++++ 1274
XQs. 115 and 116 and Answers, page 210:
Cross Examination by Mr. Dennett........-+++++-
XQ. 121, page 211, to and including RDQ. 150 and An-
swer, page 219:
Cross Examination by Mr. Dennett........+++++++
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Earl.....-.--+++++>
RDQs. 153 and 154 and Answers, page 220:
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Earl.....-.-.-.+--
RDQ. 166, page 222, to and including RDQ. 177 and An-
swer, page 224: _
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Earl......--++-++++
xi
RDQ. 183, page 224 to and including RXQ. 193 and An-
swer, page 226:
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Earl...........++- 1284
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Dennett.........--- 1284
RRDQ. 207 and Answer, page 229:
Re-Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Earl........... 1285
Frank STEInKE:
Q. 1, page 230, to and including RDQ. 66 and Answer,
page 238:
Direct Examination by Mr. Earl..........+.+++5+ 1286
Cross Examination by Mr. Dennett..........++++- 1289
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Earl..........+++- 1291
WittiM CunNINGHAM:
Q. 1, page 288, to and including Q. 16 and Answer, page
293 :
Direct Examination by Mr. EFarl.........+.++++06+ 1292
XQ. 19, page 293, to and including XQ. 43 and Answer,
page 298:
Cross Examination by Mr. Dennett............... 1295
RDQ. 44 and Answer, page 299:
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Earl............+.+- 1299
Cuar_Les Gorpon :
Q. 56, page 402, to and including Q. 57 and Answer, page
403 :
Direct Examination by Mr. Dennett............... 1300
Q. 66, page 405, to and including Q. 74 and Answer, page
409:
Direct Examination by Mr. Dennett.............. 1300
XQ. 188, page 441, to and including XQ. 190 and Answer,
page 442:
Cross Examination by Mr. Earl.................. 1303
XIII
inner
Master’s Report in National Tube Company v. Mark et al.,
Equity No. 4360.......:0eeeeeeeerereceereesreesees 1305
Proceedings in Court........-eeeeeeeeeeeeeereeereees 1305
Proceedings Before the Master.......++++++eserrrrrrs 1306
Conceded Facts ........ceeeceeeeeeeereeceerereeeess 1307
The 1909 Order........ccceeeeeeeeeereeeeeeeetereees 1308
Answers to Questions Referred......-.-+++++e+eeeees 1309
Gains and Profits.........-eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeereeeees 1310
Savings .....cecceccccccccvccccceescecssecceessees 1312
Advantages Derived by Defendant From and Through
Said Infringement .......-.eeeeeereeeeeeeeereees 1315
License ..cccccccccccccccccccccsccccccesesececeecees 1319
Special Damages ......-seeceeeeeeeeeeersseeeeeeeees 1321
Damages .....scceeeeececrcncreeerenenererseceseess 1322
Interest on the Award........-:ceeeee rere eeeeeeeeees 1325
Judge Sater’s Opinion on Exceptions to Master’s Report in
National Tube Company v. Mark et al., Equity No. 4360 1326
Special Master’s Report, on Accounting of Profits, Opinion
and Order, and Opinion and Order on Standard of Com-
parison in O’Neal v. San Jose Canning Co., Equity No.
TEED Lcocccccovcouseveccescescoseecusescosesesesses 1333
Special Master’s Report on Accounting of Profits...... 1333
Master’s Opinion and Order.....--.--+++eereerrreees 1336
Special Master’s Opinion and Order on Standard of
Comparison .......-.eeeeeeeeeeceeeeeeeeeereeees 1340
Opinion of the Cireuit Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit
in Gordon Form Lathe Co. v. Walcott Machine Co., No.
5511, Decided April 12, 1929, 32 Fed. (2d) SB... ccccces 1344
Opinion of the Cireuit Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit
in Gordon Form Lathe Co. v. Ford Motor Co., Nos. 7363,
7364, Decided January 12, 1937, 87 Fed. (2d) 390....... 1358
XIV
Final Judgment .......6:0: cece cece eee e eee ener ee seeees 1365
Notice of Appeal of Plaintiff... ......-6-eeeeeeee reer reese 1369
Bond on Appeal of Plaintiff. ........6-++eeeeeeeee re eeeees 1370
Plaintiff’s Statement of Points To Be Urged on Appeal.... 1371
Notice of Appeal of Defendant........---eeeeeeeeeeeeeees 1373
Bond on Appeal of Defendant..........-+see cere ereeeeees 1375
Defendant’s Statement of Points To Be Relied On Upon
Appeal under Rule 75(d) of Rules of Civil Procedure... 1376
Stipulation Re Waiver of Supersedeas Bowd. .ccccveseccees 1379
Stipulation Concerning Number of Copies of Record to be
Filed on Appeal.........ceceee ee eeeereeeeeenenneees 1379
Stipulation Re Exhibits and Transcript of Record on Appeal
in Gordon v. Ford, Nos. T363-4...... 0660 e eee e eee eens 1380
Order Re Exhibits and Transcript of Record on Appeal in
Gordon v. Ford, Nos. T363-4.....6 00 ce eee ee eneeeeene 1381
Stipulated Designation of Contents of Plaintiff-Defendant
Composite Record on Appeal. ........eeeeeeeeeeeenees 1382
Stipulation Extending Time to July 29, 1941........0.00es 1399
Order Extending Time to July 29, 1941. .... 6.600 e cece eeees 1399
Stipulation (filed July 21, 1941) Extending Time to Septem-
ber 27, 1941, and Approval of U. S. Cireuit Court of Ap-
Peas ....ccccceeeecereeeeeeeeeeeeeereeneeeeenesees 1400
Stipulation (filed September 24, 1941) Extending Time to
October 27, 1941.......ccceecee eee eeeereeeweneeeeees 1401
Stipulation Extending Time to November 26, 1941, and
Approval of U. 8. Cireuit Court of Appeals............ 140°
Certificate of Clerk. ......cccccscccccccccccccccessccseees 1403
XV
EXHIBIT
E-1.
VOLUME IV.
Plaintiff’s Exhibits, Defendant’s Exhibits
and Main Record Exhibits.
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBITS.
PaGE
Cost Summary Card for A-6250 Camshaft covering
January and March 1930 and September and Oc-
dohaw BOED co ccccccecevescsevescecvesssasencores 1404-5
Cost Summary Card for A-6250 Camshaft covering
May, August and October 1930 and March 1931. .. . 1406-7
Cost Summary Card for A-6250 Camshaft covering
March, May and July 1929. (Same as Exhibit 6 in
Exhibit A) .........ceeeeee cece rene eeeeeeenees 1408-9
Cost Summary Card for T-410 Camshaft covering
January to June 1923.........e eee cece reer eeees 1410
Cost Summary Card for T-410 Camshaft covering
July to November 1923......-++.+eeeeeeeeereeees 1411
Cost Summary Card for T-410 Camshaft covering
January to June 1924.........02 cece cere reer eres 1412
Cost Summary Card for T-410 Camshaft covering
July to November 1924.......---+++eeeeeerereeee 1413
Cost Summary Card for T-410 Camshaft covering
April to September 1925.....-.-++-+eesereerereee 1414
Cost Summary Card for T-410 Camshaft covering
October to November 1925.........---eeeeeeeeees 1415
Cost Summary Card for T-410 Camshaft covering
January 1926 to October 1929.........--+++++++ 1416-17
Cost Summary Card for T-410 Camshaft covering
November 1928 ......--cccecccccceccecscccvccers 1418
Cost Summary Card for T-410 Camshaft covering
Gatahn TGS oo cccccucuccvccscsescesvcccsusesess 1419
Cost Summary Card for A-6250 Camshaft covering
August 1928 to January 1929........---++++e+es 1420-21
XVII
ExHIBIT PaGE
F-10. Cost Summary Card for A-6250 Camshaft covering
December 1927 to June 1928....---+++eererrreee 1422-23
F-11. Cost Summary Card for F-446 Camshaft covering
April to September WE. oo covccsedooverssucussane 1424
F-12. Cost Summary Card for F-446 Camshaft covering
October to November 1925....--.+++errreeerrrces 1425
F-13. Cost Summary Card for F-446 Camshaft covering
January 1926 to March 1928.....-+--++eerrerees 1426-27
H-1. Production Cost Record for T-410 Camshaft cover-
ing November 1927....-..-+sseerrsrreeerertesee® 1428
L-1 to L-3. Pages from note book kept by witness Spencer
We LIBBY cccccccccercvcvcvcesevrsonsecesoeses 1429-31
M. Operation Sheet compiled from notations appearing
in Exhibit L. (Same as Exhibit 13 attached to Ex-
Bilt C) .cccccccvccccccccsccesececsocvecceress 1432-33
N. Operation Sheet for T-410 Camshaft dated 10-8-24.
(Same as Exhibit 14 attached to Exhibit C)..... 1434-35
O. Correspondence between Ford Motor Company and
Jackson Shaper Company....---+++ererrrereees 1436-63
P-1 to P-14. Ford Work Orders for Repairs to Melling
Tales ovcccccccvevcavcvecvesseuseseesouseuees 1464-70
Q. Inventory card covering Ford Camshaft Shaper
HIOTOG 20. cee ccrecccccccccccencccccccccssreeess 1471
R. Inventory card covering Ford Camshaft Shaper
HIIGDB 2. cccccceccccccccececorsccrecscescerres 1472
Ss. Inventory card covering Ford Camshaft Shaper
BIBMGS on cccccccccccvccccvccsecsccvcccosssoress 1473
W-1 to W-14. Study of operation of Melling Lathes... .1474-87
X-1. Productive Labor and Overhead for Department 410
BEEN. on cccdiavesadtdadenseeel Eeesneeeesaenenus 1488
X-2, Same—continued to 2-28-31 ....-.+-eeeeereeereees 1489
X-3. Productive Labor and Overhead for F-446 Camshaft
Machining 6-1-25 to 3-31-28 ....----seereeeeereeee 1490
XVIII
EXHIBIT PaGE
Y-1. Inventory Card covering Melling Cam Turning
I Lathe Ford #36592 .........sssceeeeeeenerees 1491-92
: Z-3. Plaintiff’s statement of account.............+. 1493-1513
6
2 7-4. Plaintiff’s schedule showing computation of depre-
i ciation on Model T type cam shapers and Melling
fi Cams LOURGS ccccccccccscccccccceseccceccescens 1514-16
; Z-5. Plaintiff’s compilation of depreciation cost on Model
t T Cam Shapers and Melling Cam Lathes......... 1517-18
} Z-6. Plaintiff’s computation of Maintenance and Over-
t haul Expense ........-ccccccccsecccsssccsscees 1519-22
Z-7. Pilaintiff’s computation of Cost of Tools......... 1523-24
CC. Telegram dated 11-18-30 addressed to Ford Motor
COMBPAMY cccccccccccccccccccvcerccerecscesevers 1525
DD. Telegram dated 11-18-30 ........::scee cece eeeees 1526
GG. Release to White Motor Company from infringe-
ment of Gordon patent. (Included in Exhibit RR). 1540
HH. Letter of White Motor Company to Mr. John W.
Michael dated 12-24-29. (Included in Exhibit RR). 1532
RR. Gordon Form Lathe Company agreement file..... 1527-57
DEFENDANT'S EXHIBITS.
209. Copy of U. S. Patent No. 1,655,655 of January 10,
1928 to Herman W. Melling.............+-0005: 1558-66
217 to 222. Ford Purchase Orders for Melling Cam Turn-
ing Lathes ......ccccccccccccessccccccccsscees 1567-73
232. White Motor Company Departmental Correspond-
ene Gated TE aitbe cs vcccescassvsecveccvisvesoes 1574
233. Same—dated 1-29-30 ........ccccccccccvccccceres 1575
254. Ford Motor Company print dated 11-17-13 showing
front view of construction of original Ford Cam
Shaper with attachment superimposed in yellow.... 15
7
nh i i came pas edRe eddie ne eden ee 1577
ExHIBIT PaGE
957. Ford assembly print showing attachment for use in
shaping Model A Camshafts......---+eeeeeerereee 1578
958. Same—sub-assembly ....-----+srerrrrrrerrt 1579
259. Same—showing removal of tools numbers 1 and 5.. 1580
263. Sketch drawn by witness Piodhh. .ccccccccceeseece 1581
964. Letter of Mr. Pioch to Mr. Farley dated 11-2-38.... 1582
266. Computation by witness Pioch.....ccccccsecsccres 1583
968. Print Camshaft Shaping Machine Oberhoffken de-
sign—layout showing ‘‘tools to cut in both direc-
tions—speeds being equal’’....------s++errrrrrt* 1584
269. Same—Layout to show individual relief of tools on
weturn StTOKe ....cccccccccvcccscccscsesesrseer® 1585
972, Sketch by witness Brush showing cutting action of
Shaper Tool ......e-eecercercscressrrseserree® 1586
973. Same—showing cutting action of Melling Tool..... 1587
976. Brush sketch of two way cuts...-.-+-+++rrrrerees 1588
981. Operation Sheet for 1-410 Camshaft dated 12-21-27.
(Same as Exhibit 15 in Exhibit C).....-...+++-- 1589-90
289 (1 to 10). Engineering Record of T-410 Camshaft,
Forging Size ......--.e+eeeceerseeecrestees 1591-95
290 (1 to 13). Same—Finished Size ....-----+-+++> 1596-1602
291 (1 to 3). Engineering Record for A-6250 Camshaft,
Forging Size ......--eeseeeceeeereereeeresrees 1602-03
292 (1 to 4). Same—Finished Size .....--+++++e++: 1604-05
993. Ford print 9-Z-32, Shaper WOE. ccncsnecestusweese 1606
294, Ford print 9-Z-215, Melling Wad. cccccocesdsesees 1607
995. Letter of witness Pioch dated 2-1-39 re: Surface
Speeds of Shaper Tools .....--+-+++++++++r0+' 1608-09
296. Sample Ford Purchase Qwer 2. cccccccccsceccees 1610
997. Print of Ford Camshaft A-6250-Al......-----+++- 1611
Se AON RS + AES
EXHIBIT PaGE
298 (1 to 6). Engineering Record Fordson Tractor Cam-
shaft, Forging and Finished Size..........--.-. 1612-14
299. Summary of Ford Tractor Production............ 1615
301. Defendant’s substitute pages for plaintiff’s state-
ment of account Exhibit Z-3 making 3 changes. . . .1616-22
302. Same—6 changes .......--.eeeeeeeceeereceeees 1623-29
304. Pages from Ford Parts Price List, effective 2-1-31
cde recasecevesssveuscedddavasseneeveuseees ss 1630-33
305. Defendant’s computation of Comparative Direct
Labor Costs on F-446 Tractor Camshafts........ 1634-35
306. International Harvester Company Requisition for
Gordon Lathe dated 11-20-19...........--.eeeeee 1636
307. International Harvester Company order for Gordon
Lathe dated 11-24-19 .........ccceeccccecceeceees 1637
308. International Harvester Company installation of
machinery card covering ‘‘Gordon Std. Cam Turn-
ing Machine”? ..........eeeeceeceeeeseereceeeess 1638
309. International Harvester Company disposition of
machinery card covering same ... .....--+ee+00+: 1639
312. Copy U. S. Patent No. 1,512,995 of 10-28-24 to Her-
man W. Melling ........-.scccecccccsesccccces 1640-47
313. Copy U.S. Patent No. 1,634,550 of 7-5-27 to Herman
W. ME ccc ccccccceccccccescscesensessceees 1648-52
314. Print #C-2129 of Walcott Machine Company—
‘‘ Assembly of New Style Parallel Type Tool Head’’ 1653
315. Print #KT-530-A of Walcott Machine Company—
‘‘Assembly of Tool Head’’ ...........--eeeeeeees 1654
MAIN RECORD EXHIBITS.
EXHIBIT PAGE
2. Copy of U. S. Patent No. 1,542,803 of 6-16-25 to
Chas. Gordon et al. ...c.ccececccereeeccceerees 1655-69
5. Amended Final Decree in Walcott case........ 1670-72
40. Notice of Infringement dated 7-1-25...........++::. 1673
41. Cuts only of Walcott Machine Company advertising
pamphlet ........ ce eeee ee eer ee ee eee ceeeeeeenes 1674-75
42. Mailing List ...........ccecccscccccccccecccses 1676-83
48. 1929 Notice of Infringement.............++++0+: 1684-86
52. Photograph of Ford Shaper %4 front view......... 1687
53. Same—front view .........ccceececccreceveveees 1688
53-b. Illustrated chart of Ford Shaper tool movements
OM ACHONS oo cccccccecccvvedccccsccescecosecess 1689
55. Record re: delivery of Gordon machine to Ford.... 1690
56. Copy of Ford order for Gordon machine......... 1691-92
61. Affidavit of I. W. Kindall re: Ford Camshaft Shaper 1693
62. Ford Motor Company Print dated 5-18-15 showing
Ford Camshaft Shaper, front view.............+.- 1694
63. etc GIO po ccccccrdecdcobicdesdveseceeves 1695
64. Waleott letter to Ford 7-30-29. ........ceccecceees 1696
71. Copy of General Motors-Gordon Company Agree-
ment. (Included in Exhibit RR)................ 1552-57
154-a, b, c, d. Records produced by Ford in response to
Court GOES coccccseccvcecccescccensctsovase 1697-1700
XXII
t
(7 “ON LIGIHX2 S.JSILNIVId
= _
| Ziz 32AMBE—HONVUE C4 1800 WAL || SL55% SAMBO ——+1DeVEE OL 1869 Wild
a r os 7 ama | | ONIANIVe || FZ Sy . 642. SHNAIEY -
— FT EE \| Tre: | reg
cS | jP / 98 E5| C+
a ee HONVES O14 14609 BAY || “« 2505 . HONVéS O14 1800 “BAV
; ¥ | s2auia || £445 =, | s0Rea
HONVES O1 ANV1d “OANW || HONVEe OL INVi San
LA 12798 CSCS ME . | eres, wo 4 [-—~"Sannaxa ontaaies
ae, | Shes Teegtes OT FFST7 - 780d ANVIa “Danes
Taree Bd oy £8F z
ieee, Fee Oe YL FO CTo0| baer"
CHM Hb $8 |: ISE9S1\ bE. ‘fp | o9| 4. ,
~tteoa [OF 00|_57090 HEIST | 75/47. ’ 637 7 rz Oo
Fark (ETF E!.I/ZO ab RAT 5748 WS FT iAZ eal 7A 7
004¢ | fp200|2F00 of \2es787| E7 | & , oo? ee ExiTA o
wisi ___= 1 — — n.cous | evuos| ‘s430 || ae SSisod ima w.Goue | avuos| ‘adzo
‘H “WW ONY “184 “ON! “BAY “WR “iua “BAV . “HW ONY “Ltd “ONI BAV “W2 “Aud “BAY
|
o2z9-Lsvzrl6| £-SV £ ee fe ro. easy
‘ie | =
aive "2810 INA Zoiwa | Adlunvno | iva | usawo || iva ama] ‘D810 uNA a
aus od} SISVHOUNG WIMBLVN ius EBSVHOUNG TIMELY
TEA By. HINOW -—* HLNOM
er a: wa KZ... Aaiere... sestiec *
oeseeceeeose OV a WTTTTTTITTTTT TT Pl ° ° QVEENVD BNUN Luvd
To 6=—llC Wl 8®lll””:”~:~:~;~;«é‘C eel, Bll jj | Ee ae BINAIIN ys
IH vees-r “GSAS AUVAWNS worn seme
| 3D1Am3S—HINVES OL 1809 Wao. \ } | | BHAMES +#ONVEe O1 480) Wicd
|
' - | ONIANIVe | | ] | Ow LNiva
| | ot Sees eee pee
| {
' ‘
! ‘ 4 '
HONWHA OL 1SO9 3AV ’ ‘ ~MONWNO OL 1509 aay
DUST ATETT 23997) «Zee iDawa “
Asia :
ts rr
=.*° 2.
40210
HONWHH OL ANY Ia DANY
T° Rh Sat 2 3/A07 7h be ha’ t FP FATEs onaains
» to €&o0ce stoo Shs hl oe ose. 44 . hy KS
TF 00 Troe S84C) way pod YHST a. sae Goan) ee, te
FIOF\ZOOO| F000) SAIAL wewyssae Free $725 ZS33 135245 ty Ly
torr 7 A lS se _ _ SESRL 1904 OT fr me "FIA OE 09 1295451558 07%
SY é g2er 9EAV LoVe? (250S$/ 2 bod
Te soe Te CNSR FILE sO E SET Zs 9C KISO TES ILS bin FS"
S3Zt|ZF00|F R00 | fhgie Fs99s/ BH s/ geo? 3900 F500 via o J9LEE) sg/. 7 tT
Wi0. | N@Ualie | »oev) VAIN i tbwacs NiCaoe eO8wt tawny
— N.GO! 4 aVNOS “4a30 - — - ~ O0ne avew y a0
SASOD LINN ‘ S450.) 1tnn zi =i a6
‘"- “HW ONY “184 ONI ‘BAY ‘wa 444 BAW <a CO. 4 WUNYW i164 ONT BAV va ims BAY
™ BVRLO tH 09°7
--+ ..Je
| Re / Horr? ov) 3 7 e °
PREYS. ——— 79Ee £ 31 BAD WIE TO OameksWSFats/
nl A ae ee 2 OG f. x enn
Litcsts] paw : res re
Aare aus) “os10 | "IND | aDIue AAILNYNO = uva u30NO aavM ima sta aINO aime Oe oe errr
“aus oc/ }! (rr? S3SVHOUNd Witaivw UC” sua of) S25 i SASVHOMNG Wines ven iP get
-19n HINOW y HINOW
ee eer Oiu Vive teaavew
2 a Tine ais
rent tee 4/ **"HenOM LiV HSNVD BN WL ae we
ps Ge aguyoemas AUVWWNS LSOD acnec creer aniinmiid
‘GOEL St mE meg
~ 7 ‘ON LISIHXG SddLLNIVId _ —
a 19 Ee : B21AUTS—HOWVER O4 4809 Wicd | |
| 44 5 tte @ | ONILNIVe |
Ela | l
? St Gra
| HONVWES O14 1805 “BAV
) SRE BLA | 493m10
] | HONVUS O41 ANVI1d ‘OANW
BSN3dX 3 ONidd IHS “
tT] Usic4 $fA9 | tess 41S09 INV Id ‘oann || Ls biel “bei
4 | | eS: ssolavacs || $eto
TTELoOlEF00| ~ |_STPIG PMI FOG || WET /O
19 roals/oo| LS7S ILO $5 FAz Ree | Zr 00
Use TElISF#A STS IL a OF || Rxobhi| FZES
Filszzew|Z 74 OLLI oF CECE St/_ F/ IP: both 6¢E£
SII OOlIEPIC|- 17 £ leroe es 7 | -<Rtt |S soolt FOO|D Ae |Z %e se AST
| Neuen | wOoevT Taivw : viod Nacene ive 1.aeud qvuse 3430
$3805 nen N.GOud | evs | 4430 | S05 TINA
‘Zz « HW ONY “183 ON! BAY | ‘w3 1ts “BAY H| ISTO “WweONY “Laid “ON! “BAY “v2 iad BAV
| | ] il i |
] | | i
] | | fl ic
“wae | | ae ] SF Lsero- a7 Ie| €-S7|
a?" | EFS \O8LEE)) 37 | 4 77; | | [Pazo. 02949 |€7
*4| 3810 ain | aDtee =| AdIANWNO. | Bava | B30NO || 3Ave aus | = “DSIC | sina aDiud AsLNWNO | Bava | wz0NO
l S3ISVHOWNG IWINaiwh || sara of ]| S3ISVHOWNd IWIB3siVAW
bs MY “iNOW | a Uke. wu HLNOW
° me —_— ORLILNWNO yo ONI™
**"#O°TT ee cccccces Honow { wv) 4 eee TT TT eT TT ek ek bd hak hobs hdebcdd yarn suved
-Gé25 ¥ aia “WSN AS Pe AYUVANWNS LSOOD 5 64666466 06SE SES SESE UEEENS a7naaHos
sic oe-stS— WO! sess Bod
a tw
ZB . « wt
vas Y of pnt >
Manufacturers «( \utomobdes Trucks and Tracters é
Detroit.U.S.A. Jeruary 7 1924.
a%° 97S oth *Y Se,
Jae tos { « s
er Ve ewe
? :
1 RE PLTme BErKe FO F-69 |
AL. S7A7E Emre OF AE RERmE RTS CONTAIRS m TES LETTE® O96 COUTROEET Om STRESS AEGOEETS OMNES: on
COST@RC TS 208 SuBeECT FO APEROWR OF Tut an OF Owe err ces we toe eo
we ere crel-sire, herewith, revised bise:
#lbeLeS sort +9 Fet* rn “L" charged - to be used «
rith cnr crder L-43c97. 3 aS
Kindly h ve the shove order come Koswepa Ss
letest revised pri-t, © vising ue of ery edit
«ip ae. :
Ple«se a «<r’-l°dge receipt of t
infer™ing us the matt r
Komatocemrers of ae
Dewoi..sa. Jemuery 7 Tig
“scrson Sherer Co-,
Jee <8°F.,« iene
Gert Llemen:
19 EPL VIDS DETER TO .} *. f. #
pad ee mp - — = res mom we et ee a
ge are erci-sire, herewith, revisec dlue print 4
#1BeZe? gheete #62 1¢*- 223 chenged, to be used in commen .. ,
“aS
eur order L-48027- mm
*2:
Kindl: heve the sovve order come forveré per ag
letert revired prirt, e*vising ‘ne eriter of sry sdéiti-ne "
Flea ¢ sccronledee receipt of this revised ve:
irforrirg us tne setter is heving your ettention. ,
? ay, 7
* ror
2
: eg nist ‘
1442
January iC, 1934.
Ford Motor Sompany
Purchasing Cept.
Detroit, Michigan.
Gentlemen; Attention J. R. ~tewart.
We acknowledge your letter of Janay fe
with revised print #16-7-5 snset #9.
We will ha-> thie machine cow forwer’ per
thie revised pri: © and there wiii ce no aidition-~
al cost.
Yours very truly,
Jackson Shaper Toman.
LER/ MJ General Mararcer.
1443
January 10, 1924.
te
47
a7 "~
Pord Motor Company
Purchasing Dept.
Detroit, Michigan.
Gentlemen; attention J. &. Stewart.
Be hereby acknowledge Letter of Jenuesy
7th with revised treat bie--5 sheet $62, deteil
#223 changed. eo.
ve have had this detail whic is e gear, bored -
and turned comlete, ready to out teeth, so it will
be necessary for us to make them up egeia.
The labor performed on thie detail amovate to
$13.20 per machine. It will also be necessary to
furnish us sufficient AAA steel for ten of these
details $225.
Fill youaleo p.ese9 eend us two additional
revised orints #6-2-3 sheet #62.
Yours very truly,
Jeckson Shaper “Comany.
General wsnager.
f /, Ml A 5- t f fs — NA IS AL / = +
t/ + ( sv” y , a 7
} 6 OM Te pr oa pees & pear ra 4 2n—
1444
) A eter Cimpuny,, |
Manufacturers of \utomubiles Trucks and Tractors
Detroit.U.S.A. January | 12 1924,
Jackson ohaper Co.,
Jackson, Micr. -
Gent leren;: a ES ae
os ME PLvins maven ve
Ac. S7Ave maNTS On 6m . ari STrES Aas COnrwaRe? O% BTHRES Ac: Oem
CONTACTS N86 SuRCEET TO APOROWA. Gr Ime orrces oF Vier
Be are enclosing, herewitn, |
#18-Z2-35 complete - (See change colum) sheets
be used in connection with our order ar <i,
Kindly heve tre. above
leteat revised print, jAnforming us of
. Pleese: acknowledge recet
‘ y int ring us bs saller: is heving- your.
A eh ee
A Es ae SR |
*
1445
January 14, 19.4,
Feri motcr Tompany
Pirchaeing Dept.
Metzoit, Michigen,
centlemen; Attention J. R. Stewart.
Ve acknowledge receipt of your letter of
January 12t). enclosing revised print 18-£-3
detail #20, sheet $29.
Inasmuch as this detail hasn®et been. plac-
ed in work, there will be no additional charge.
Yours very truly,
Jackeon Sheper Somany.
LFR/uJ General Manager.
Jamary 18, 1924.
Ford ctor “omany - anaes
Purchceing Sept.
Detroit, Wickigan.
Gentleren; Attertion J. R. Stewart.
Ve hereby epi your letter of Jamary
icth enclosing revisei blue prints 13-85 sheets
1-3-3-6-11..18,
Ye tad some of this work etartei and fro
conversation w*ich re ‘ai with vour tool desiga
department lest Tuesday, ve will be able to bring
this work through without any e4ditional cost.
Yours very truly,
Jackson Shaper Sompiny.
LYR/ uJ General Manager.
Purchase Order No. D 48697
Dest © 1-16-24
DELIVERY REQUIRED
2 moattes efter rece'rt
of petterns ©
2 from Jackson Prepaie
86 RO prox oF net 60 Mays
@oisl uechine for Shaping (6) cans
at one time T-410 e2 ch 2 6,500.00
j Hs
We ne
*%, “
Pirst
Py | o
Pe Pes oR ob BS 5 is-s3-25-85-03-73-23-
oe 38-03 -£3-138-38-Y2-X2-V2-72-T2-UL-32-
vs R2-22-PS-QS-U2-I3-J2-L2-L2-Ne2-72-
2-DR-E8-32-C02-2-1 2-X-Y -V-"-T-U-2-8-G-N-P-
Lt -K-H-3-3-F.
First perty "es furnish (no cherge)
Det. 287 ree © ascemble
6) of Dets. 178-176 to assembdle
Be cares at lan altered ar crmtimg, tears ow GrMCPRER wimimee vated Seer
“44 suochaned ave aubject to Dann Pasta’ teapartion and agprovel end W ccjertad, Wil be hid ot Greend Party's rid and retumahte at
A. ae taramaaa atari aceite acai
By
ig Mote came Pe Ne ame
Purchase Order No.D 48607
z : a
a HIGHLAND PARK, MICH.
eee eens ith whe a A rm no ee SORE + ts ESS.
page No. 2 Continued from Page No. 1
Ordered From Jeckson Sheper 20: rany
——— ——_ =. SST SSS SS Ses eS
is DENCRIPTION OF MATERIAL
in 8 2 ES EES SS a ee “TITS
(Continued = irst rarty vill ‘:rrish (no charge) ):
(5) 19 & 6) Cil boxee sith of] -sv-es.
(40) 19 2 25 Tet. 6
5) p:e 3611 Dieroné cable Chein 76” long
6) ree £/* witch 1/4" wide,Zoller Chein Die
of roller .400
Necessory ete] for (6) dets. 1-25-26-41-43-66-129-
132- 33-228
(40) of lets. £%-61-62-64
(1 } of (eta. 58) 79-206-222
(20) of retr. 97-95
al"o vill shin pottorn 19 2 2-73
All petterns cre pleced with the second party strictly at the
second party's risk, fob second narty's plant charges fully
prepeid. On conplesice of orders, return patterne fod first
party's plant, charges fully prepaid. In case of éeetruotion
by fire or othervi:e, replaco:ent nust be nade at second
arty's exvense. The first t i t um t
Por fetterhs Wile in the sesone neste Ecosse On ep Onetb Al ity
y'e roceecs
Pov jour quotetion 12-11-23, our inguir: } 42664
Confirnine *clephone order to ::r. Broughton 12-18-23
dark mé Cénsizn: HISSDAND Pak PLANT
/Ore jwotor Co
"sr oréec D 48697)
Jie 83 Detroit iich
3 72884
¥1-19
70 X-59530
Xeqe 416362
1448
ic ee « a”
wrk ~ |
et thea ts
oon om NEWCOUR CONLTON eoeenens BEOOCGE WF BTHINS Fae VICE OREO DENT | Somes capen'ine of o yen ;
ace iven at
272 X 12 1 EXTRA
FO DETROIT MICH 1035A JAN 21 1926
JACKSON SHARER CO VW
JACKSON MICH
OK MAKE EIGHTEEN Z THREE DETAIL FIFTY TW) OF TOOL STEEL
FORO MOTUR CO STEWART
O4TA
_—
-
Sa fl iA
Sird ieter Temftuny ,
eo
Manufacturers of \itomolules Inieks and frretors
Detrant.t SX.
Jackson Shujer Co., "ah du 196%
Jacks on
Kichi gan ATCITTL * © Fe Brow ter
Gentlemen: sarevacerems Feh2
Res BOT e MENTS OF BE MER ERTS COmTamE SHS HTT Em Ame a7 Ee Om Sm eee a
COmPRa. *s 208 BuUBVEL* TO APOR. we. & THES ewe
This will co:firr our telegrir t¢ :cu toda, authorizing ou
to make 16-Z-S detsil vc of tovl steel. “ec te.-eve it wiii work oO. “Cc
better adv.ntage maxing tuis part of tocl steel tau, cf tri;le """ sicei
a8 Specifies cn cur orcer. You wil) rove:.er tails is tue part that you
telkec over with our toolmaker when last =u: cur ci:ice, with reference to
tue hardmess on the encs Where the wee: wou.u Cccre.
flown eden aegt
im? Departinent
IRS: 3T3
%
Detroit.U.S.A. an : -
ie
Jeckson Sherer Company <7
Jac -ron,“ichican.
fer*lerens
+= AEM LvINS BErER TO P-69
De 7
*, i
mae Ter® LETTER ame COUT NESE Gm STORES acerDeuTs cRBSER [
COnreec’s an8 Suevec’ ou orr-gne or
ee
00 aseabuns ov tom Common ora
£8 ee
We ere erelcsirg, nererith, revised Lest
HLCez-Z sheet 44° j; ott. M3 changed, ty be used 2
“ur o' der 568697. : és
We ere elso enclesing revised blue
sheet #£& *n he usté tn correction with order B
Kiraly wve the eo0ve order come form
laces’ pevleed «révt, acvisire c-e writer of ,
Fréenre acorowie ce weretpt of these |
ivfor-teg oS te matter ts hevire your etter
( 4: Di OR
sapeeeetinthanss Contractor's Material Order PB oti,
"THE FORD MOTOR COMPANY «4 Highland Park Michigan
Sellet, agrees. to x’!
And Jerscrcn Sheore cc.,
* Jeaskeon, 130.
ee re ie nwt
SHIP VIA “xp
TERMS 30 Days Net from Date of Shipment
of..0. B.Com, Rairwad, Point of Delivery
QUANTITY | S¥MBou |
6 16-2-3 Cea Sneprr Jashine
for 186-2-3 .steil 96
fet riel -
} Letor -
!
|
g28 FD | |
PHO 8 9465 |
Te be Revered by ( om tear te
Order No. RR uh 28s
ef‘)
D ; 26
1-25-24.
Rater to Ford Meter Co.
L-46697
ee eee Lh cements
Puce
- AAA Ste21 “oraings
et sost
Jur tr 1.26
_. Tiabe and right to possession of said material shall be and remain im Seller until paid fer in
LAB cach materia! where tithe amd right te pesscanee bavt aot paamed te Buyer shell be held at Buyers ret ond shel SET ORGRER be imeured ot Buyer's onpenee in ap
memoent and wumepany awed by the Seder
‘sithe ated onged te prceconice aaoe mat pane = Bouya oui ne wacheost legmd ara ome
| ot B aay be rally heed
te came the Seller tall deme ited imeocsers mm chimney parte: ance of thes cambrect < oney termmanets anmnr without moire amd retake pemeatio ~ ch amterml, where
prwecsnmte n> te Bary to agreed chet Buyer ull soap cael saatersa) mparets and pert eerted “Poor od Ford Meeker Company.”
. S Rethntins slr adan tecmdtantantgnednaratantadndltneammtantitediiiane
© acount of soch material, oo hapt caperate and apart, where tithe snd right te passe” ove sot pamed to —T oe
SO Oe ce cmesas ies calcd dation end Wntan of enh satel 0s wo eng ott eaten cl fr aaunagen
¥ SNREEER om Samet See
rl aroma es at va enpes, och owmtwsed wd Bhar ronerde ered
oy nih, bee
pend etna sores my oon thesk be es oe ca etn ae sh eat
Manadiacturers of Mate
Detroit. MA,
Jackson
aioh
. f
Gent lemon: ee
Oo. OF ROME RETR m8 Le eee Oe Ame Cee Sete Of Creme ‘
ee
We «ish to call your attention te the .
140697 b-40678. ae
Inqgemeh as we are is urgent &
thet you do all in your pover
dates specified om the above erderd,
An expression from you comseraing |
FORD MOROR
ns i
JTe°Mm.
Deda SIM «3 ty
, at Aa
Dowoi. USA. ai, |
ge m ‘
Jackson Shaper Ce Pobreary 8
Jackson
Mich
Gentlemen: Me ak Wived »
1 REPLv ne BEPEE TO
Sa Scand cONNED SE CEnonaW a Orte As DENTS CORED OR Ame Comte ee Oe
" APPROCe & me SOMATUNE OF ACULY AETHORE® CreCUTN’ +h Fe UF ee Lemrene Cosette seater
s F .. ‘
Kindly give us, wlll, cempietes, for record gurpeeees
net weight of the special Machine for Game on camshaft, c
by oir omer D48697, our Requisiticn
FORD MOTOR Wd hy : $
e Buineering Dept
ciaernoengeers nye arencsomsagenipepmmcneeeeie: 60 ThE
1452
Pebruary 12, i924.
VPord Wotor Comaery
Parchasing fept.
Detroit, Michizan.
Gentlemen; Attention J. R. Stewart.
Be have just received one pattern and core
box marked 16-£-5 - HB and we cannot find any
Dlue print covering this piece, neither can we
find 1% on the assembly drawing.
Will you please look into this and send us
Dlue print showing this pattern.
Yours very truly,
Jackeor Shaper Company.
"General Manager.
1453
e.
Manufacturers of Automobiles Trucks and Tractors
Co" = / Cf/
Strid Hoh MK Y-
Log Se, (or CetYLney »
Detroa,U.SA.
Jecksw@ shaper Company Feorusry 19 1984
Jeckscn
Lichigan
ee we themes ok ate atte eo ome pearationg pet oes _Prken2 2 ams CT nt (s. 908 CL YOND Gut CONTE, On8 tas
omt@e "Seer t oe +> ePeec ves O 2) ee . Pee eee eee ee weaney Cte «, C8088 Suestcr ve comeeeHeD
Referrirg to purchase vrcer D-4€67 coverirg 5 only 16-2-3
corplete special machires for sbaping € Cems on Camshaft at ome time.
hindly expedite the vatter of udtcining your Castings from cet
patterns l€-<-3F 2, o1¢ l€-s-% 2 which sere delivem to you om éviivery
order #$0$12 .n Fed 4tk, l$Ze.
. it is necessary that se bave these patterns at the earliest
possible torent in order ttt we ray obteln castizgs for the repeirs
om machines shich ere dca at the present time.
hirdly chip tosse patterus vy express, acire:sed for the
attention of -r. .odges, Casti:g utuch, highland ¢:: rk plart.
1455
‘ta oh 4, 1924,
Fuori Mctcr Tompany
Pi4 Bi ctar cet.
¢ fie users ie
Jert een; A’°srticn J. &. ctewart.
We have hed rine hours pattern work, atount
$11.55 on your orics #14-f-3, a3 “cu no Boubt ree
rerv.ver some of the patte:ns sece sert to us in a
orcker. condition.
Willyou please aivise us that it will be sll
right tc adi this amount to your order #D-48697.
Yours very truly,
Jackson Shaper Company.
UPF/J General Manager.
Firat feter Company.
reeO— eee eee eee eee
PI CHANGE NOTICE Date.. B= BBA ............-
fase o
thangy Bn. re agd Pps Made the foll — :
ae. Oe one eed Firm Jaakaon Shaper. .0a.............-.-------2---eeeeeeseeeees
mdly corre J
k «t ’
en ri oo mene i isacecctesncevinttewncescaes NS cccccoccsececneseenent
Mia
PO. _D-48627...... aS) oie Symbol.J4.2.8............
ee
RES ONE NE er Ca aac ae Re ATE Oe I NE FI. csuninnensvcoseemieneimeanhnns
NSE ARS SEE 15 RIN OAC NE AOE POTN TE ES SH ENE OREN TE AE NON
Specifications —from . eee RAS RP eal ESE RECN AIM TA OE RMS *
REASON . 90st of repairing patteras furnished by Ford Hotes fe.
Change Item
RECRIVING DEPT.—If in order make change indicated.
-~ = a - or
| Case No.
= ——- —— —_ =
“ 1456
Meroh 25,1924.
Pord Motor Company,
Detroit, Mich.
Geatlemen: Atteation Mr. J.R.S8téwart
Complying with your reduest of yesterday,
we oubait ewith cost figures om Mechine 18 2% $3
your erdes D46697. Work om this order has bees
held up, awaiting your further iastrustions,
Youre very truly,
JACKSON SHAPER COMPARY
LEB/L General Manager
Mareh 24,1934,
Time end material om “am Mac¥ine 18 £3 to date.
Rroase ° 2,374 ¢ 712.62
Iron Castings 26,260 ¢ 1,575.83
Steel Castings 8,390 ¢ 566.35
Steel Porgings 606.75
C.R. & Mach Steel 237.87
Tool Steel 88775
Screws & Bute 14.73
Orill Rea 3.87
Pattern Vork 37.37
Geer Outti 186.355
Special Tools 118.07
a. 6.16
Heat Treating 50.50
eekete 17.00
eel lasasous 275.96
Tetal Material 4276.16
Pius 10% 427.61
Pr eight 194.00
Leder, 10,217) hours OF7:80__ 15806 .28_
ee Sa ee
change FL. indicated purchase order Peiiinesdcenere ...98¢ "ae
correct records accordingly ;
coun te Geka aa Rec. Memo. Dae
gt po....D- 49697 pa.
MATERIAL Mechine for shaping camse
Cost of dian BS pes. det. f 10 pes.
REASON . frm Joh ataah 0.200) 8k00) = DOR WT Lf
we
“ » Se L_ Prom
MBCRIVING DEPT.—if in order make change indicated.
iiichvciianete signed........2Rs 9M P69
ie Cnange sm piome.
Manufacturers of Automobiles Trucks and Tractors °
Detroit,U.S.A.
Jacacson Shuper vompary Larch 24 1924.
Jackson ee
sich ini
Gentlemen: w anevyne waren rc P-82-1.
4 5 ae ey ge Poa : ¢* 6 @ O@6 29% HOES C8 S°O HES @. Prat Be ee ca. 808 Ot rORS Ove CONTE. AND aR
ite ek le ARTO PED ORE LT OFF Om OF Te 8 Seman OM Ce. COMCOS Se Owec® “2 COMMECNOR
ne te
Kinuly expeaite the miter of obtaining your castings
fron pattern i8-Z-3 $2, which we delivered to you under date of
Lecexber 17th, 1923, on our D.0. 66811, to be used in connection
with purchase orcer b-46697.
1t is necessary that we have these patt eras at the
euriiest posysiole moment in oruer that we my obtain castings for
the ropeirs of m.chines which are cown at the present time.
Hindl, ship this pattern vie exvress aduressed for
the attenticn cf Lr. .coges, vestings Jtock, Highland Park Plent,
acvising the sritur the wate shipment lesves your plant.
ALR ONY aby.
Ae <* ,,
be ae ofr ch. sii beartmest.
1458
Warch c€, 1924,
Pord Motor Tormpany
Purchasing Det.
Detroit, Michtcan.
Gentlemen: “pitention M. A. Feiknap.
We acknowleire your letter of March 24th ard
will return this pattern to you within the next
few days.
Yours very truly,
Jackson Shaper “ompany.
LEP: uJ Genernl Manager.
March 80, 1924.
Ford Motor “orp:
Purchasing Set.
Detroit, Michi can/
OGontis-en; Attention J. 8. Sterart.
Ve have rate up the fol cwin- pert’ ont the
18—f8 rachine which *ere changed “rom triple "a®*
steel to tocol steel;
6 ~ Detail #1.
10 - ® 179.
40 - ® 52.
210 lbs. tocl steel . $57.75
139-1/4 hes. Labor @ $1.°5.- 174,06 |
Totrl 31.61
Total to apply against your or ter # D-45697,
Yours ver truly,
Jack30n Shaper Tcmpany.
LPR/ud Sarera. Marcrfe:.
AL. S787 E RWIS OF COREEME WTS CONTAEED & Tere LETTER O08
Jacason shaper 0
Jackson
Mich
Gertlene ns: nen
“NT GA TR BOP Sw Oekd* 16 AORROWR. & Tre S tig o 6
Ps Pa}
sutitor of Oiebur senente.
Detroit, Wich cen, Py. ig
wher
Gentiexen; Attention 8,
Yo sckmowleige with.
Aprt« 5th ecnlosing
on ac*cunt.
LFP: us
Por4 Motor “ompany
Puschaa‘ne fe *.
fetroit, Mick’sar.
Attenticn J. R. Stewart.
vour orier #D-48697 covering
shafts.
Sentlenen;
Please refer tc
five machines 16-%-3 ‘or cachining cam
It ie now four weeks since you had us stop
4-
work on ‘his order and we would very much apprec
ate a word from vou as to the disposition of the
order or material on han1.
Yours wery truly,
Jackson Shaper 7*.~mpany.
LFR/d GQ«neral Manager.
Mamafacturers of \utomobiles Trucks and Tractors
Destroit. USA.
Juokson Shaper Comp .ny
Jackson april 24 1926
Mieh
Attn. Mr. Broughton
Gentlemen;
(© MEPL VIG METER TO p69
Aad OTATE MENTS OF AGRE EE mts COmTAIED 1m THIS LETTE® ARE CONTINGENT OF STR MED ACC OTNTS TIMER UM AMY HEM & SER MET oe
CONTRACTS O96 BUDE’ 10 APPROWA, BY THT G:OmATURE OF 4 UL AUTHOMITED EHEC UTIVE OFFICER OF TH & (Ommaney 0@. 6. 608 a4s.0-8 ane
Aoxnouledging ,our letter of April ‘thuith reference to
erder §D-46697 for 6 mohines 168-35 are pleased to inform yo. that
Mr. Duffy bas thie matter up with our 3upq@intendent’s cffice ant
expecte to be able to give you disposition of this material sometime
within the nat seek.
Thanking you for dravin thie to our attention, ue are
IRS: AO Purchasin Department
saad 1461
Se, 4 fh LA,
irdeto Company»
‘antic trees of \atomobiles dinehs and Tractors
DetraomU sn,
Jackeon Shaper Com any
Jacxseon avril 24 1924
Mich
Attn. Mr. Broughton
Gentle mens Tee Pe P-69
_ SAME OM AEE ME ES COmT AED OS Pe SOFTEE 88 CORT EST OR STM ES OCC OR TS Freee Om ame TE. OBES BEFORE OCR COMTRO, OD Mis
ae TS ame” Bek FD OPOm we. Oe het Some mF fF a + auto ce. Ft et et OFF Oe OF Tes COmmams Ce Ca, COR OS SH Bwtr th hv emECr OS
The writer .s surprised to learn that you still have in your
possession all of the patterns for machine 168-412. These mohines
you built for us you delivered along the later part of Mbruary am
the patterns should have been returned at tit time or prior the reto.
Right now we are very anxiously in need of pasterns X and W so wired
yo: today to return by electric freight all of the patterns for this
job, murking the eame for Castiu,s stock Department and sending them
to our Highland Park plant.
Along the line of patterns you my use this as your authority
to return to us the patterns for machine 16%+3, these patters may be
boxed and returned to our Rouge plant, B Building. Please see that
this is properly taken oare of. A
Pra Bia
/
y, PURCHASING DEPARTMENT
(7
JK sA0
April 2€, 1924,
For’ Motor Tompany
Purchasing fept.
Petroit, Wichi an,
Gentieren; Attention J. h. Stewart,
We acknowledre vour letter of April c4th
confirming your telegram rerarding patterne
18-%-412,
These went forward on the 24th and the
1h-7—2 patterns will ‘te shipped sither toiny or
Mon ‘av,
"e reprat that the 16-%-412 patterns were
not returned sooner and will keep a closer tab
cn the return of patterns in the future.
Yours very truly,
Jackeon Shaper “Tomury.
1462
Gerd Ke rh cmfiun Y>
o
Moridastarersof \utetmotates: fine hs ame Ppa tops
Drertrertt ENN A: ril ~8, 19:4
Jackson Shaper Company,
Jackson,
Michigan
Attention - “*r. Le <=. Brow..ton
‘entlemen;
16
We are authorising our Disbursement De;artment to honor
your Invcice for $0,414.02 to ccver Mi.terial, Frei, ht ond Labor
to time of cancellation of our Order D-46697 ccvering 5 (um Ghapers
as per blueprint 16 - Z - 3. we are. licwover, also instructing tre
above Department to deduct from your account §.1:.52: This snount
being the salvage and freight you advised you would allew : reviding
we left the material at Jackson, and arrived at as follcws:
Bronze 1000 libs. « eld 51%.00
ns 336 —=Ci*” ar 8) 101.40
Cast Iron <2c0O |” 201 £20.00
" Steel 2000 ” -005 10.00
Steel Shafletc.2000 ” 001 20.00
POG ccccccccscey 461.40
Plus Sllowunce for Frei nt escossee Ld.IS
“ . ” 4 } e
Ete TOthlescccveccceevosescoossosy BV eve
Kindly advise by r.turn mail if this is in a@ccorda:ce with
your understanding.
Purchssing ve artment '
1463
April 29, 1924.
Perd Motcr Somany
Purchasing Nept.
Detroit, Michigan.
Gentlemen; Attention H. A. DOurfey.
We acknowledge your letter of April 26th
cogarding your order $D-48697 cowering five Cam
Shapers 16-7-8.
The disposition of material by us and dé
duction of $619.52 from our account is in acocsd-
ance with our previous conversation with your Mr.
Stexurt when he was here and checked up the job.
Yours very truly,
Jackson Shaper Sompany.
General Manager.
eo
eq N2 H79276 ACCOUNT NO OPT. CHG. PACTORY WORK ORDER WO ry
2 ewme: 4 - ¢
— ” . , , & é }
: o79Z16 \ 2! and Sf ( ain L : re ; Ay
ASSIGNED | CAST IRON | STEEL | NI CHROME | @RONZE AL BRONZE ALUMINU ™ | erass
Zz NUMBER DETAIL PART NO P RN NUMBER Pa
N ee e. wl ot 256
te aw. melii mbm e S5£472 from n-7 botor value
= 18 {éssirier to 6 6266) 5 Feb FO. tye
eo:
“7h. =
er: @l .or o i On -—6200 CAs Bite
ron
\ eulsae
4lerita
orown
hyerbe 3
Fa REASON @ o a Orbe
f3 6.7 .25 | Soler: iots = 1 me 41° ht plore
§
” nate RFQUESTED &v OF DEPT LOCATION FOR DEPT. |LOCATIONOF JOB suPT oO. &
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT NO, od
. ~|, N2 144431
=
BO. WANTEO | KIND OF METAL
| MO. WANTED ZOR S NUMBER [| _ceran | atrern | roraina | s.P.
s ' ' \
filuaee snore Can La Ltet $4592.
K-7 Br W-71/-C a A
) Fee
OD ns | sees ol ea A ALE
: ieee
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT NO_-2
oe
jm A 577 |e FEZ F271.
ASSIGNED CAST IRON | sree. NI CHROME BRONZE AL BRONZE ALUMINUM BRASS
Z-NUMBER DETAIL PART NO. PATTERN NUMBER ATT. LETTER,
B.T. 36926 Overhaul for 4-6250.
5.711.060
5-309 Move Milling Cam Lathe 5.7. 36928 from 4-8 Lotor bli’.
Bo316 (Assigned to 46250) to 5-58 Fréry.
5-700
& cc Overhanl for Opr. #133 Turm Cam on A-6259 Canshaft. i
2107,
Rs SEP 1
:
ii B-Ble. | 410 Motor wai
i DATE REQUESTED BY : or oxrr.| vocation. | ron pert.. |LocaTionor sos SUPT. ©. K.
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT NO_A-Z
vsei15 “IN aol Y/0 1. CEYM7 £\ &
oc
Overhaml for opre #15; tum cams on £nb250 Coma fte
Kellog
4. mith
Myers.
Hill
. B,T. 366L2
Ne711.0 Move Mclling Car: Lathe 3,7, 36562 from I-7 Kotor
ee )
Boihé6 Slé@. (assigne: to 46250} to 5-58 Parye
Re Herxlots | a:
REQUESTED BY
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT No. °-#
1466
VRE | LY
@rnass
PATTERN NUMBER PATTY. LeTTER
A
fleas Pves-e a ad ff sence” pt lFru-~
pre facing Exe fa Ma COP GLACE
<a ~ me from K-7
LAY 910 te 8- 535°-N-7ue
yea fa 0 CL. ae 4 A EAM Arfat-9
fie Me 1a Betek« we tte: Opie
| SFO. te a
REASON aad fr Jugs
gear = tele aah aeEZ DM nn
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT NO._-35
Move Melling Cem Turning Lethe 3,7. 80008 fron x?
Motor Hldre (assigned to 46280) to 3-58 Farge APR 1 01939
Overhaul fer opre $13: ture came on 4-625 Camshaft,
AX
SoM —7-1-20
. | LOCATIONOCE -ourT. o. K.
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT NO. P-6
‘ 967317 Ca WEVA Wo $52 les
ASSIGNED CAST IRON | sree | NI CHROME | gronze | AL eronze | aLuMiuM enass
Bf. BOOS
N? 14087 es ae dies enees an. '
ee Ae |
assioneoD CAST IRON | ever | ———— | ” noes —— —— Sl
on Rove MNelling Cae Turning Lathe B2-37867
Ke ¥ 14g to A-6280)
{i .. from F-7 Motor 314g. (assigned
00 ‘ to B58 Pry.
Ke llogs } Overhenl for opr. $13: Bough turn case on
8.Hhl | ~ 44-6860 Camshaft.
APRs 1930
- PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT NO;_7-7
TB 4" | Zib|a7e CE TESTS.
ay A SS oe i anni
beg tees eR)
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT NO; A
SIRO T ot) oe i oteatal "Oo.
od Oo
: S544 if os 3 oa i 7 pa
” ennai
rer . ae GETAn. PROT oer PATTEM wus EER PATTY. LATTER
os Ae amen
‘
— ro | meee Lye 2
ite
Ousheml fev Cpr. $28, Tum comme of 1-425) Comsbaft.
AALe eto ive Dina Aron OW 74
36 ehe bt K-P-_ 76250 7db~ 4/2
at aly = ry" (IVA,
| pre Feu,
N78 he st er Maat:
fr Mapping Conws tr —
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT NO._ 7-70
po | PGi elo =P
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT NO. 7-H
ERT Tee Oa | gen |
¥ #
+
&
rs “ “er.
cag wat vm « rm a aLeameues
PART PO.
. Sela Sve rhaml, ve yal MeRiing Com Tarming Lathe 51-37502
. rcbaves ot Bes Fary for opr. $13: Exper inental
thre 0.3. Of com om 4-€990 Censheft. |
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIRIT NO, S72
“a N°? :
uO. WANTEO
foo? Pure
; Ne Pa on N71 C+ Ja /, wii
: ¥* & (fa
WINE "4 a sek, 7 [wey fer", (wt.
1929,
eh OE he / z
ity 7
ooo pow Ny
~
} Te sage
4 Ot Ate
cafe Caan ? ig ¥ Stpu™ S Mfe fucia if
By REASON 4g |
V2 | pM | LZ. |am. Tt: 3
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT NO.
~ |, N2184099 mourn | wrens |
i LEGOQUD : Hole
TTuwaSE SPACE ._m-
KINO OF METAL
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT NO "2-14.
© “ON LIGIHX] S.dSILNIVId
avy y . ‘ y /° U/ , “Ss” |
n. Az %2 TH Of “AIA N4uFi-i cot 9 |
= L —s* 5-4 ree 5, € tte ry hak hee ™ |
— FS VT ney 1s Beebe ene am SS |
L tons Poe | SS yee ae ae ee eRe ee eee
Pos? ts FERS | “yell syij tae ) !
FOOT CANT“ 9beeeta TTY ST70t/a) oS | rs
suuynay Bava | wousas | ave | wools
GQaddV 4S
BB40¥d BMIHIVE WO ONIL13E 40 1809 asl
asseans 79/8 canmmenrne | Fgh ' 3 x
9 $ zoqer ° 3800 \* OO Gadavars
we BAVG BSIOANI a _ SIC
*38 436 F0°9d <B0 dezy mano zo 4ueTI IMO
‘6°04 |
A@ G3UNLDVINNYR ;
"Op WOxTOD mqzzv + —LNAd-ano ty
mows OISVHOUNG | OMNVHUaNS SNIHOUW Sue t swouveaity
set
i, | eae
*sz030m 4deoxe certs ‘76%
300U8‘ L499 % 99¢-SOeF STTSZeD BuTgdeoxe ‘egsetdmoo g-zet a/q zed eB
@UT4 OUO 48 OIF] 4738S WeD uo sueOo g Butdeyse zoxy eutyoum Tetoedg aan
“= JTCT usawnn twiuas AuOLovs : €-7gl Y3GWNN SYSUNLOVINNVA
GAddvadS
STOOL SNIHOVW 2° ANQLNSANI LNANVWY3d p
7 "ON LISIHX9 S.SdELNIVId
east | AD
N . = e.
- (- EAM \LE- =
= 5p WS Het e ,
27 art-i-! 4 1- o-
oo jaan ie
> xP oc -06-8 -Wil-g, S/~3-al
= Pave tect, EN ea |
=F AYIT4 FRR ee |
. suuvans nae | mousse ave aoe
SuouUvEsitV
ANBNdINOD IWIIBdS
°gz030m gdecxe oste ‘76f
\ geome’ 49g % 99G-99eF STTEgep FuTgdeocxe ‘ogeTdmoo g-ZeT ¢/d 20d SB
) emg owe $8 OTP-z S30US WeO WO Sweo g BuydeyS z0z euTYoUN Teyoeds =...
UIGWON SUIUNLIVINNVA
— 2291l 3GNNN TWIU3S AYOLIV4 7 ON
———————S—
F001 INIHOVW 2° RADINGAN INSNVWEAd ,
COPY BOUND VERTICALLY
= ‘ON LIGIHX] S.dJILNIVId
1473
ae oe eee FEB Se “Te y
eee = ne TT PNT ;
: rerseasia i
a4 es % —s od .
SuOUVESIIV
nh invid uno wi CTTNYHUIAD
ANBNGINOD TWIIBes
*ezogom gdecxe oste ‘264
goeqs* 498 © 99G-G9RF STTEgep FuTgdecxe ‘o a/a zed ee
CEES CWO EE OTL *F4IS WED WO GuTO CG FP zoz Tejoeds
—gezzt HIGNNN TWRIas AUOLDVS 1 Gezgt USGNNN SUaUNLOVINNVA
$1001 SNIHOVW 4° AYPLNAANI INAINVWUSd f
COPY BOUND VERTICALLY
1474
J -M ‘ON Lisinxa S.dSILNIVId
~
Le
——
ain me
, i
| e 7
ae :
Le pad rs
Laing k RSs b
} | qe et | 2
€ | ;
| | i - 7 " is 3. ’ J
‘ —
+ 3
} 4
ee Lectie & = 1 _
reat Bias
. Ds Ae eo)
: -2 oe
j 4’
|
4 ; i
e"
as
COPY BOUND VERTICALLY
1475
6-16-™%
Houre Lost Due to
Ho. Ere Moh No Ho Yo
B. Te Hoe | Pieces Run Trouble Toole Stook Oper. REMARKS
35472 f°) 0 120. Setting up Machine
3o5es #171 66.75 3.50 19.50 7.25
36451 3035 64.50 16.76 11.60 7.85
36496 2074 77. 41. 2.
S4682 2645 69.25 12.25 36.60 2.
36592 2019 64.75 5. 62. 6.25
B6ADMS 2096 66.75 13. 18. 29. 3.25
34928 13500 35. 85. Broken Tool Holder
57601 3721 103.75 5. 1.60 11.75
37657 578 16 8 67. 9.
ST732 3425 99.75 il. 7. 2.25
37764 505 7.76 76.25 24. 12. Broken Tool Holder
37844 2152 62.50 6. 49. +50
37667 3602 96.50 ll. 7.50 4.
38006 3761 4. 3.50 18.50 4.
38080 2500 66. | 44. 10.
H
Total 37,054 1106. 75 422.25 18. 394. 65.50
Doe el. 089 19.¢ 33
} Payne
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT NO. W=2
Hours Lost Due to
Moh fool Ho Bo Ho
Trouble frbl Tools Steck Opere
Setting up Machine
fail Stock Trouble
Cam & Tool Holder - out
of order
Slide out of order
fool Holder eut of order
Master Cam worn out
Repair Slides
979.76 671.28 8.50 5.
1.4 2%
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT NO._W-s¥
1477
Pa!
OG
Mr 4M Wibel 11-04
Fo. Ere. Mab Teel |= Wo
BS Bo.| Pi Run | Trouble) freabl¢ feels Oper. BL a FI
SOAR o| 0. 112. Setting Up
somes | 2005 | 79. 29. 1. 2. 1. Rep fail Stock
seami | 2970 | 62. 26.50 2.60 | 1. » 8 " & Slide
36406 | 4156 | 111. i.
36562 | 2975 | 78.50 | 32. 60 i. Broken Drive ‘Gear
36508 | 1650 | 37.25 | 64.25 10.80 Rep Tool Heléer
sete | 1555 | 36.25 | 61.25 | 14.80 8. Rep Slide & whange cam
36928 oj} 0. 112. Rep. Slide & Tail Stock
87801 | 1210 | s2.60 | 70.50 % Rep. Slide, Cam & Drive Gear
37657 0 | 0. 112. Rep. Slide & Tail Stoox
sv7sz | 644 | 15.75 | 75.25 5. 16. Overhauling Slides
Sv764 | 1290 31. 61. - s
87044 | S777 | 104. 250 1. 5.50
ses? | 3515 | 98. 12. 1. 1.
$8005 | 4012 | 108. Re 2.
38080 | 3500 | 97. 7.50 | 7.50
Total 33,736 | 910.25 | 795.75 | 17. 5. [16.50 | 54.50
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT NO. W/-#
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT NO. Ww-3
—_
Firs. Moh Tool No Ko No
Run Troubl@ Trouble; Tools| Stock| Oper. REMARKS
i]
0. 96. Setting Up
93.50 50 & 1.
93. | et ) le
53.50 | 30. ete ee
2. M4. | Rep Tool Holder
33. | 39% | | | 2h " Mester Cam & Clutch
14.50 46.50 | | 6. 3. | 16. Tools out of line
19% | 76. | | | 1. Tool Holder ous of order
17.50 76.50 2. Rep Drive Gear
66. 26. 2.
41.50 11.50 4. 23. —_—* Overhauling slides
48.50 46.50 |
16. 9, il.
| 37-75 $8.25 | Overhauling slides
| 82.50 50 | 13.
| 58.50 | 25.50 | | 5. Tool Roldnr & Tail Stock
| | Trowle
|
Totel 27,092 | ves.t0 | 639.75 5. | 29. | 3.| 104.80
49% 42%, 2s %
HE PaYxe ENG] MERRI WG
1479
Mr AM Wibel Engineering Pb -M
M02 Ok ELLAND CAM SHAPER - WER OF MRT OTK TO LACK AOS
Hours Lost Due to
No. ire. Mob. Teol No Bo Wo
sr ho. Pieces Bun Trouble Trouble Toole Steck Oper. ks
seats 126. Not assembled
wd 2301 74.25 39.25 5.60 5. Cam out of line
30452 3829 = 106. 50 5.50 16.
So4%0 eve “4.59 85. 50 Slides & Tool Holder Out
35620271200 73.80 = 59 15.60 Seses @ & Broken my
36592 715 19. 77. 32. Tool Holder out of order
$6546 2350 61.50 39. 27.50
$6923 106. 22. Tool Holder oat of @éer
37501 2785 75.25 16.75 50 35.50 Cluteh owt of order ‘
37657 3645 97.75 14.25 1. 15. Tail Stk ows of order
37732 208 5.50 19. 64. 39.50 Master Cam Trouble
37754 3645 105.75 12.50 0 50 10.75 Tail Steck Trouble
Tool Holder out of @éer
37644 2627 71. 35.50 50 21.
37867 1945 62.50 59. 16.50 Overhauling Slides
38005 4295 115.50 60 1. ll.
36080 4145 0=—111.50 50 0 15.50
Total 37,656 1011.60 630.265 3. 103. 13.8 262.75
4 49.45 30.90 +14 5.035 +66 15.62
aS pares ENG] NEERI WO
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT NO. WwW -€
1480
ur aM Wide) Engineering 9-26-24
- 7 . - '
Pieces. Heures Mach Hot fool He ve Lt) ,
wn. mde Run = PL | Asso, rb) Toole Steak — Opers REMARKS
|
mr | | 1“
wees | 1297 a ee | 35.50 a1. Cae Treble
wisi | 1000 | 87.80 | TR 6. 57.60 Steady Rest and Tail Stosk
mass | 2960 | 68,50 27,80 8. as, geal Belden out of order
sassz | 1920 | 52.25 4s. 28.75 Rep. Feed Gear
moon | 4675 125. Ve | 12. feel Holder Trouble
wee | 3000 | 108.50 80 | 6. M4.
ems | 8728 | 100, | 1% | 29. Clateh out of arder
#501 | 1976 65.25 | 8B. | 66.75 | Cam worn out
sr7sa oa 1b. 104, | Out of Time
sss | 6076 | 141.60) 1. 1. 60
gress | 1719 | 9 45678 | 69.60 28.75 | Rep. Tail Steck
sre? | 2606 | 45. | 41. 10, 89 Drive Chain Broke
seo0s | 4402 | 181, | —
mono | 4407 | 188.80, 80 a | 460
must | oa09 | 168. | a) -60
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT NO, W/4-.7
mr 4K Vibe)
Pisces| Reare | mach
Be Be| Mate | Bun tre}
eare
ets 128. eae ree
a ee | re
Beate 14 | we le
maen| 4055 125.75 1.38 le
sss | 5067 200.80 26. | 2.80 | Dew Slides
wees 1796 | 44.00 : 29. | 1%80/ sl.
setes | acs | 1ns80) | 1.80
smo 408 10.80; 64. | “. 15.80 | Installing Bow Beate
sust sess 03.75) 9.28 | | 23. | 1% | feel Bolder trade
sr7az | 1100 | 6080! 37680 | a | a 16. m. Pin out ef Peed Gear
7M | 1108 eS | | |
wrote | soso 10%.80' .80 | 16. %
S106? | 4045 106.80 13. 8.80
30008 | 1480 | 3. 8 =| 78. | | | 13. 6. Installing Bow Reade
seco | B40 10, 124,80 | | | 4.80
| | |
fetal suze 1008. ss. 128. | 2. _ 198. | 120.80
ee ee oe Se
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT NO._ Y/- F
1482
mr AM Wibdel Engineering 10-10-24
QAM SHAFER REPORT - WERK OF MEPT 89TH 70 OCT OTK 9M4
seve Tag M* BAT Toten Sat feels Steck Oper. mere)
qaate 128.
ord 128. Cem Trobe
wm ms 8608.80 iS 85.60
mans RO %.00 17. 14.60 200] Holder Troable
ee ed 4.60 20.580
wom 64000108, 15. 1. 4. General Trouble
geese «(1%86 0 = 44. s. 36. 38.50
PT ee 12.60 280 2001 Holder Prouble
Pe 90.80 29.50 6. Broken Chain
Pe ee 16. 8.60
we 2.7% 4. Ss. 68.76 8. 6.
ora Ss Sats “15 4.8 le 1
Foe RE 1.8 55.8 1.
yest B88 ww. 17. ube 6.
as 060 OU & 118% 8.
ates.
ont gente 1008.75 656. 188-5080 16,78 161080 OB
“$
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT no. W-%
ur 4 M Wide} Engi nee ring 10-16
Pieces Hours Mach Hot Tool Ho Ko ¥o
tO Made Run Trdl assem fTrb) Tools Stock Oper RAS
36472 128.
36306 «(1855 = 56 27. 13. 32. Head stock out of order,
Clutch Trouble
36451 555 «16. 104. 8. Overhauling & heads
36496 «= 4045 «114. 9. 5.
36552 S850 110.75 2. 2. 4. 9.26
36592 «695965 112. 7. 9.
846 «633850=— 92.50 39 35 BO 1. 1. Generel Trouble
369868 ©6400 ~=121. 7.
$701 165 5. 107. 8. Repeiring Beads
37667 3460 100. 11.50 12.80 4. Broken Tool Holder
37732 755 821. 96. 1. 10. Preparing for shipment to
377564360. S«108 le 6s a
37044 2755 75. 29. 18. General Trouble
$7667 2765 75.50 14.50 18. 20. Moving to Rouge
38005 126. B-160 Gen Overhauling
3e0e0 3080S 89. 32. 7. Slide out of order
Total 36456 1004.75 706.50 128. 4. 17. 120.50 65.24
e HE PaYxe EBNGINEERL 3S
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT NO._W/-/0
Mr a bi iibel Encineering 10-27-24
GAM SiaPoR SPORT - WEEK OF OCTOBER 5TH 70 2978
Pieces Hows Mach Sot Tool Wo Ho Ho
BT 500 Maude Run fTrdl assem Trbdl Tools Stock Oper. REMARKS
36472 1550 46.50 6050 862. 1. 9. 3. Shipped to River Rouge
$6386 46©=—«: 3105 96. 10. 3. 5. 3. 4.
36451 765 20.50 250 3.
36496 3905 lll. 10. 2.50
36552 4295 122, 5.50 2.50
36592 2240 63.50 56. 9.50 Clutch Trouble
36926 3180 94. 32. 50 1.50 Slide out of order
37667 3650 114.50 250 1. 8.50 3.50 Broken Too] Holder
$7644 2510 72.50 27. 8.50 >.
39005 1070 28.50 250 3. Shipped to River Rouge
38080 2585 79. 18. 2. 10. 4. 7. Clutch Trouble
Totel 26615 648. 163.50 62. 5. 17. 39.50 43.50
RE Pave ENG IXEERING
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT NO. _W/ -//
1485
Engineering 11-86-24
Hours Lost Due To
Ho. Ere. Moh. Tool Bo Bo Ho
BT Ho. Pieces Ran Trouble Trouble Toole Stock Oper. REMARKS
35472 3605 103,50 16. 7.50 Clutch Trouble
WA6 4220 1235.50 1.50 3.
36552 4165 121. 4. S.
36692 3950 111.50 13. 2.50 le Clutch Trouble
36848 aA 14. 6. 41. 3. Motor Disconnected
36928 3600 99. 26. le Installing New Slides
37657 4035 215.50 6.50 5.
37844 1800 51.50 2.50 1. 1. Going tw River Rouge
38060 — 54. 2. bad ° ad
Total 25695 639.50 71.80 9.50 102.50 1. 16.
4
a EH PAYNE ENGINEERING
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT NO. WAZ2
1486
Mr AM Wibel Engineering eckente
BEPORT Of MELLING CaM SHAPERS - WEEK OF OCTOBER 27TH 70 NOV LOT.
Hours Lost Due to
Ho. ire. Moh. Tool Ho Ho Ho
BT No. Pieces Run froubls Trouble Toole Stock Oper. REMARKS
36472 4160 «128. 16.50 0 4. om Repair Chain
34496 4125 120. 16.80 6.60 fa ke Cam Trouble
36552 “AS5 = 120. 6. 5.50 6.60 Slide Trowle
36592 2696 “4.50 DW. ll. 10,80
36848 ---- 112. Motor Disconnected
36928 2736 77. 36. Slides & Tail Stock out
of order
37657 4606 «124.50 9.60 4. 6. Hew Master
fael 228665 649. 115.50 112. 50 xO. 23.
4
a H PAYEE ENGINEER DG
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT NO. WwW-/7
1487
Rr Au Vidbel ~
AW
(\
£
—
.
va
>.
GEZEEEEEE EE
z§ § =
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT NO, W- A
CARE att Bie %, Lae Sey ° 2
n LE PT 1 ts ab
# aa Host
_——
1482
EXHIBIT X1.
FORD MOTOR COMPANY
PRODUCTIVE LABOR AND OVERHEAD
FOR DEPARTMENT T 410
For the period from June 1, 1925 to February 28, 1931.
Productive
Months Labor Overhead
June to December, inclusive, 1925 .......... ° bd
January, 1926 ....ccccccccccsvcccvccsccvces $ 62,909.88 $ 84,008.13
PeWruary ..ccccccccccvesccsssccesesccsocses 59,306.94 68,945.28
[POT Cer TET Eo TTR CRE ee 69,146.55 84,292.23
BT cccccccstnscddyssrcvcessscccsressenes :
MAY ccccccccccccccceccissocccccccsvecsces sf be
pO CT ORT ere CPO Ler CL 48,696.46 69,397.49
July to October, inclusive ........+++.++eee- 2 .
WAUOIEE beter desidectccevacsecunpecededs 65,574.68 97,369.91
TCOUINOE scccccsdacdeccdwodecssscenvegesas ad i
January, 1927 ....cccccccvecvcccccsssccess 58,283.20 82,996.62
WOWPURTY ccc cicccvevcccsssecnccsocccrves 53,310.77 77,531.01
WOM pcccesecendanededadvecdeedertorasees 68,320.05 92,290.50
April .ccccccsccccccsssesccssccsccccsvvess 54,351.92 85,119.67
MAG vsvcccccdcvcecssdsccsrccrencsseneesee 249,710.42 358,460.04
June, 1927 to February, 1928, inclusive ..... ¥ .
MAGE, SOUND cerdccdavcveccnssctecoreseress 383,979.89 447,558.00
BN oicccccdcdscvusssrsscesccosccoccssese 426,026.67 475,148.94
MAY ..ccccccccccccccrccccccccccccccsesees 161,354.00 156,416.84
BT POP POT POLO rT eee eL ETE Tt Ca 165,423.64 171,631.19
» REPO OCOTOOC UU OULU 165,843.40 167,469.92
BURGE ccccccccccccsccscccesesccrcosoccos 184,494.69 168,764.90
September ......--cecccscccccscccseccccees 160,847.08 159,116.76
Ce PET ET CET OCC COU 190,366.59 195,530.67
MONOMNOE cecedisdecncecaverencdiecden tens 180,039.79 195,001.14
WOGOINOE cc dcccceccdevosssesssuedstmyeess # Wg
January, 1929 .......cccccccscssccsccvcccee 215,922.85 202,037.18
February ....ccccccccccccccccscccscccvcres 193,657.89 197,642.17
MED idecc cde veecesskdesse Faagdeeeseenses 196,301.27 200,855.86
BOND ceccccacnboteteccerisevecdecseresedee 175,020.71 190,257.42
OT. sabes ccsaidedetureew er ehtsednsasaviee 190,031.69 195,126.59
PRPC OTTE CET ee Cet Cl Ce a, 180,264.14 203,087.58
DUET cccsavosdaccuscscvedvsbereedunsiesress 193,567.51 220,448.28
De PPE COPe Ore COLO OO Ce. 200,442.07 224,977.43
September ........ccccccccsccvccccccccvecs 153,922.47 195,200.30
le Serer err rr errr ire aay eee, 169,232.65 219,447.29
WOVOMIBET ccc ccccdcccsrvedeccessceiveseens 103,309.90 163,800.36
WUCONNOE scccdddbciandescadeadoneseetsaseers 64,214.22 139,747.94
* Not available.
ee Te Se, ee, ee ee
_—_ :
EXHIBIT X2.
FORD MOTOR COMPANY
PRODUCTIVE LABOR AND OVERHEAD
FOR DEPARTMENT T 410
For the period from June 1, 1925 to February 28, 1931.
(Continued)
Productive
Months Labor
January, 1980 ....ccccccssvcccvsscvsseccces $ 87,939.83
FODVGRTY oc cccccccecccrccecvsvcsescvessees 119,236.45
TE. cc acccverievecvokdvedenseeseeuevedens 149,514.16
BOT cicceccccvesvendnsseseonedvenvonveses 177,954.06
sebcccctnirnedasnseedrer ness eres ees 182,309.84
POND nice cerccedhesecvedsensseraceeseeveune 176,010.73
FO cctvpessncsventasaestecasauseseorsseee 60,658.66
MUBUSH .ccccccccccecvecesesccsevcsvesceces 111,339.13
September .......-.ccecccccccccsecsscvence 103,715.10
CIE: gereenscrecesersncis cuswreseinereeers 86,511.22
DN dsc cv ercckededatdvctuceiavere ces 78,540.83
DRE acivcceenc ccecucuceenyseousdvede 58,743.22
January, 19G1 ..cccsccccccvscccseversessses 59,624.21
DOGES ces crisccvnccsetseseceseueseceses 83,081.80
i... AONE RSL ROE IIRL ET RE ESSE Ne ORR A ES RM RL BR EN
SAAS OK
Overhead
$145,167.10
195,618.32
216,167.92
223,733.42
246,599.45
241,648.41
114,603.09
178,899.35
171,956.69
149,475.42
147,837.62
135,272.64
120,931.88
147,409.48
sii tae!
pe a ae
aver
SLAC NTEBR LLIN PETE ER OTH LEI EN SIE TNS
1499
EXHIBIT X3.
FORD MOTOR COMPANY
PRODUCTIVE LABOR AND OVERHEAD FOR F 446
CAMSHAFT MACHINING
For the period from June 1, 1925 to March 31, 1928.
Productive Overhead
Months Labor Overhead Percentages
possesion
Department 105:
June to December, inelusive,
Per rrrr rrr cee rere ” .
January, 1926 ..........06- $105,857.33 $178,937.71 169.037
VPODTUGTY cc scccccrseseccces 138,974.51 234,512.23 168.745
MAUD sebsvaseandescereeees 124,779.76 234,215.80 187.703 (Used 150 pet.)
April ....ee cere ere eeeeeee * is
MAY .ccccccscccccccccceces id *
DED necapecresieersscasses 98,673.30 193,146.33 195.743
July to October, inclusive .. ) #
MOVOMDET cccsccsccesevess 22,200.11 149,677.33 674.219
December, 1926 to March,
1928, inclusive .......... ba >
Departments 102, 105 and 106
combined:
June, 1925 to December,
1926, inclusive .........- bd *
January, 1927 ..........6- 133,935.24 324,142.77 242.01
February .....-eseessceeees 236,317.99 373,399.23 158.007
Departments 102, 105, and 106
combined:
March, 1927 .........seee- 335,789.35 447,867.90 133.378
April ...ce cece cece eeeeeees 9 *
MAG 6 nkccccsessecssecevesesc 207,504.98 398,269.68 191.933
June, 1927 to March, 1928,
IMEIGSIVE cc ccccccesecsers id +
Department 102:
June, 1925 to October, 1927,
GMEWUGIVE 2c cccccsdbiesiices ? .
WOVE co ccdacecccsscces 232,425.83 399,546.41 171.903
December, 1927 to February,
1928, inclusive ........... id 7
rrr rrr rr 103,137.11 218,493.79 211.85 (Used 176 pet.)
* Not available.
ececagaconieg tetera
SPO ee ee ye
7-A ON usiaxa S.J dILNIVId
anaes — —— —
; |
Tata dlam nme emaia ies ee Seat
|
, % at! 7
‘ a |
~
bead {
wn “wag =0s0 S-oCy, | FCs OVAL ies
eqecets Vert ame menenananamimas is 7 : |
LHOTEA 0.1.99 1.04 om ‘Soa’ G0 49 5<-T- Ty
ne : = “a i —
‘eq pemaepownt 197 = {/ i wre y | pe-92-b yrud
ee re epi B® “STIuw he
tg fe Sse avec @sPOU ND. eg AAT OFT dai ?
ao Ont & . pha ee ie ih
{[t-4% Séter-“7 ro oa? a ggese fo 4 2g
fr -tr-e 220 9¢ 4B
mw Pg perys e ewe quo ct puw zogou Ayadns oa ea *paerd
rere lh eye e@vdisi& wa CE Basis 204) APTTO 20g pesurizy est
-. cote dt 6 @§ OF B,ACKAMWS™ FEZ" - reg *|Qcago perszede pueg eary 03
Bex 702087697 0 MS : : a fg gat BaeB lg the me by Deters €Q 03 PUB Moy
en ° , - 3020 Tse se gg Der wUBaerh “agevesen QrH<y,
Omydeq ‘jue 3 oe oat Brita é 2
’ J F qd et erm ee oreo. our eETUy Be. aE as coe OLY Suyuray ue Bujllen
Oo 3 pansy :vad ;
3532. SSaNN TVhtas AMOLOVE Lil <aa0NnN Semaniovanuvn
pte |
S1001 ANIHOVWW AO AYNOLNSAANI LINSNVWWUSd
hooray sn Page :
SRE AN LETIET RTM ROOT
SALI OOS
AIRE IONE I AE GEL IONE SEINE
TR ee A
"1430 asybvs Ag 0.134
VATVS
a
Ganesi ‘0°
——,
EXHIBIT Z-3.
SAVINGS EFFECTED BY FORD MOTOR COMPANY
THROUGH USE OF MELLING CAM LATHES POR ROUGH
TURNING CAMS OF CAMSHAFTS T-410, A-6250 AND F-446
FROM JUNE 16, 1925 TO DATE USE OF THESE MACHINES
WAS ABANDONED.
MINIMUM SAVINGS from June 16, 1925 to Febru-
ary 3, 1931, based upon production shown upon
Exhibit D, pages 14, 15 and 16 of this report,
per Exhibit A, Page 2 of this report ........-- $895,793.95
ADDITIONAL SAVINGS based upon rejection of
claims made by defendant, but not substanti-
ated by records supplied :
Item one of Exhibit H—Page 21 of this
FEPOTt ...-cceeccccccceecccererceess 32,629.23
Item two of Exhibit H—Page 21 of this
yO 9 28,917.18
WOVPAL: .cccccccscccrevevcovsceeeseereseusrsser? $957 340.36
>... EATON) RL RPUL EPA UPAR ARES SILI AAI ISEDY Ey
seinen ay Dear lps so ae mean erane
SL tS Nee Be a A Ta Soa
Ea is
1493
LILO EMSS OTEK A AT ROTH
ee cake a,
fa Sa
1494
“yaodaa sty} JO G “A—SIFBYS JO 83809 JUN OF Ff q1qIyxg 9g *230N
-yaodoa sty} JO OT OF FL “dd “A WALUXA 8, BV OS «
66° S6L‘C68 69'°08S°FE3S rope Oel'T 6288162 *** SYdAL TIV—STIVLOL GNVUD
Ce Les‘L9 660891 FL'9FO'FS #99°CLS seececececcccessceces OFT BBIOL
COOLS 89986 ee" e89'F £00660" e10Sés’ GL8‘S1 veseseeeeees gz@y ‘yosuyy ‘Aavnaqog ‘Arvnuee
16'696'F6 OF 329 Le'SIs‘1e 186190" £6608" cOL‘ool Se PEER E SS SET ee
OS ELU'SS Ge e6s'9 GG OOF TE 86rE90° S8bLIE’ 1L1‘66 ubiebivbeensanceee ene.
6o°LFe' el 96'9E¢'E co'F89'9L 1F9Sco" 10c8L3° €L6°6¢ seseeseeeeoes Oger ‘Tg saquieded 0} ‘gt oun
:9FF-I—AOPOCLL
soqze'y WED si0pupifp soqzeT wep sieputip
Sule sypue'y Suen spue'y
99°9E8°C8L Lg'sse'sel €9°S33'816 666'Gco F seeeeeeereceeeseress QCgg-V ‘BBIOL
69° 1SS°6 oI'609'1 1s'O9L‘TL C6FSEO ChLEGS 998'LE seveceseseees Tet ‘g Arunaqeg 0} [ Arunuese
Le'S69'e0e clveg‘ts SE BER ESE FEELEo" SEE8ES Li¥‘ole'l PP CREE RESEDA RAP Ce
LZ 86‘ OFE glele'l¢ er 1Lis’L6s 212630" 809603" €16'196'L HEV ECR O ESTEE EN ASRS ee
Bo FES‘OSL L3°366'13 6r'9ES'SSL 40930" L¥SO8T Och Ets Soeh RAIA 8261
IL'2t8'l LVILE ass goseeo 86E3ES" 183'6 seeseeeeeeres pogy ‘soquiavog puv 1oquIoAON
:0929-WV—V TePOnM
souzeyT meD siopurly soqye'y wep siepurip
SUTTON sypue'y Sure sypuey
F661 L‘SF €E's8e'Ss LE BOU'8sl 99L‘Oat'e seeeeeeereeeeesereess OTF ‘S[BIOL
Ife 18°93 Gs OF LE6130" F16ZE0" ool veeeeeeeeeseeeeessees 626, ‘CT 09 [ Aiunuvr
re 09E'T I¢'sIL‘s G8'8L0'F 016330" F98EE0" StF OZT PEARED SERS SEO SE? SSS eee
LU's99‘L $2'02E'ST 1P°S86'SS ZLZ0E0" SLFSFO 980°90¢ LSERSAEEEERES TOES OO ST eee
69°F93'33 SF 00S FF LUS9L‘99 681920" 660° 602'669'T FNANEENE SS SENSORY AES ee
Ee VIF'IL $ 62° 918'ss $ sosEes be $ 128020" $ FIElEo $ G02‘60'L seeeeeeeeeees® Ozer ‘Te saquisveg 0} OT cuny
:01FL—L lePon
soyye'yT wep seqye'y wep siedeqg seuyey wep siodeyg ,UoTyONpolg
BUTI J° 88D. Suttle weD p10T Suton wep pior
qsno143 SupAtg
4809 TeIOL 4geqg red 4809
-qaodox sr JO ST 04 OT SeSea ‘ NaTUxa Aq uUmoyg fe INoH Jog UOHONPord uO PosvE
‘Te6t ‘¢ Areniqeg
04 GZ6T ‘9T Sung Wor SOIT] WH Sure JO esQ Ysnom4} fueduog 1040
piog 4q Suaeg umuypuyg pues ueudmby erqerreay 19430 qu pus soqieyT
ure SUITOW UM syszeysueD prog uodn sulEH Zurpurip 10 Zururqovyl JO 3809
-y LIGIHXS 8.4a1LNIVId ‘
(% 23ea ‘e-Z WarTaxa) Bi
«aa ea nema ammammmmmamr aie a a
,
L
OF.
?
14
F8°S0EL8E OL F8S‘sOl #6°688'68F
+6 1S8EZ 20°E96'S 961862
LY LSE'T 8E°6EE ¢8°969‘L
68°292'6 12°St¢'s 9¢°8lS‘1T
ao Lee's 0g 480° ZS 12F‘OL
OF F68'F €9°ese'T €0'°SIl'9
soqzey me siopurlp
SuTTIov sypue'y
8S°LIL FFE €0°EL6'LS 19°060°Z0F
Il'g9te‘e #9°8S¢ CLEL8‘E
€6°908°8IT 6° F10°02 L8°128‘8el
IU'1Z8°ZS1 99°88S‘92 LL'60FF81
60°91#'E9 12°¢89‘0I 0£°660'°FL
PE LSL 8S L131 3688
sone ue sIopuyip
SuTTlo sypueT
se'9ee'6l CO'8t9'8E LE’ F86'LS
£69 c8'El 8102
82°099 6S°02E'T LE'186'T
6L°hL' #S°182'9 €'Fst'6
29°88S'6 ee'S9l6L C6°ESL‘8
ose6's ¢ FL998'IL ¢ FE SOs'LI $
seqzey WED seqye'y wep siedeqg
SuyTleW 50 os Suto wep p10z
Ysno01g3 szupaeg
OgeT eaponpolg 4800 s0qeT
eayjonpolg TeOL
8LETZO
[66330
0£0130°
£04030"
soqyeT WED
Sule
€SLPlo
CO9FTO"
3SSElo"
999610"
8ELelo
soqzyeT eH
Suton
Eeello
496010
SlFS10"
6L3110
ccsolo’ $
soqyeT wep
Sure
*yzodaa sty} JO ¢ “q—#7ZBYS JO 83809 4yUN 40Z | IGIYXM cag :070N
88s90T
CL6OFIT
ostsor
€LOsor™
siopuyip
sypuey
83Es0T
662101
36660"
6S8280"
983560"
s1epupip
sypuey
FOOLTO
OSF9TO"
339810
336910"
98Z910° $
siodeyqg
mep p10z
aseqg sod 4800
ZogeT eAponporg
"yaodoz sty} JO OT 07 FT “dd ‘CG WATUXA 8, BUC 8 »
628‘816'L
#99°CLZ
C18‘SI
¢0z‘00T
TL1‘66
€L6'°6S
666 ‘Goce F
998°LE
Li¥‘0le't
€16'196'T
OCt‘ehs
183'6
991 ‘Oats
Zoe T
StF‘OZI
980°90¢
602'669'T
G02‘ E60'T
stoFpOnpolg
*** SEdAL TIV ‘STVLOL GNV4D
eeeewee
tereeeeeeeses O55. 7—STBIOL
nod idenssiuanianiaaecen ae
9261
SZ6I ‘Te 4equiedeq 0} gT eune
:9FF-I—10poeIL
ee
0S29-V ‘SIBIOL
*++s+* Teg ‘g Areniqag 03 [ Arvnuee
be teeseeeeeereeees QogT
set eeeeeeeeeeeeees ger
Gale ene Rane reese ger
tr pee, ‘sequiadeg puB JEqUIZAON
:0929-V—V Topo
CSCW SERS S SSS eC ‘s[BqOL
ee ee eeee 6261 ‘cL 0} I Arenuee
pei siniensnek ae
tinsassntenctions EE
serene ‘ 9261
Sel ‘Ie 1equieveq 07 9T oune
OTF L—L Pon
-‘,10deq STq} JO ST 03 OT 8eSeg ‘O NaTyxa Aq uMONg se MoH Jed UOMONpoIg UO peseg
souye] ureQ Surpeme JO 98M ySnomm, Aueduog 10j0m piog Aq Zuavg I0qeT
uMuUUT pus 4uoudmby oqueay 1010 WM pus seyyey] UreD Suro WIM
SyVysUIVH piog uodn survQ Zurpurip 10 Suyuyyouw JO 480H JoquyT eayonpoig
Ce e3ea ‘e-Z WaIGxG)
‘Teel ‘¢ Areniqeg 04 GZ6T ‘9T ung wor;
‘TVW LIGIHXa 8S. dadLLNIVId
1496
09° F8F0FD
SL LES‘ FS
8h'986'S
cLeso‘6l
£0°SF0'LS
2S°99S‘OL
si0pupi‘
srpue lt
BO FEL‘VIS
90°982'L
69°9E0'9TS
99 LOL'E1s
6ULEF'SL
9S SL3'L
siopuyip
sypUeT
06 LIT‘OL
tF'6I
St L60°
so 19s‘eL
Zs L108
89'8zPr‘9l ¢
siodeyqg
wep pi0z
4809 ueping 1%30L
IT'88F'80¢ 6F'966' TST
TF'oge'et Le'9Fs‘Ol
S1'68e's 0€°L6¢
90°202‘ST 69°926'E
86'ces‘9L 60°603'F
61 ESt's eee’
seqze'y mep
Sule
80°61 LIFE PS'SIP EL
go°S¢s'9 sr 0S0'L
PP S88' FSI 13 StL' Le
OU LLE's8I 0S F3L‘0E
€U'8sl'L9 90°60€'1L
LL°680'T 69°81
seqze'y mep
Sure
29" E8E'Es 82 FSL‘9F
8r9 96°31
9S°669 26° L6E'L
8e'oos'F 02°8£0'6
L0°929‘31 GlSee'ss
El'6lrs $ GS'6FE OL $
seouje'y MeO soqyeyT ep
Suylew 0 SuTTIen
esp qsno014q3
Zuyaeg weping
6288162
$99°CL3
GZ9LE0° GZI88l° CLS
Z668E0" e96F6L GOL‘00L
89bZF0" Sess 111‘66
8EzSe0" S8I9ZL° €16'6¢
soqze'T WED s10puyi‘)
SUTTON sypue'y
666'Zco F
ZPLLZO" LItZ6L 998‘Le
621220" €FOLST Lir‘oze'l
099ST0 919801" €16'196'L
80FELO 66260" Oct ets
89L610" SLILEU 182'6
seqzey WED siopurip
SUTTON sTpuey
99L‘Ost's
F09010" O16SI0" Bee l
909T 10" FIFLIO’ StF OSL
098Z10° 961920" 980°90¢
OL6F10 0LE330" 602'669'L
910010" $ 8Z0SI0° $ G02'E60'L
seqze'T WED siodeyg mep suoppONpoldg
Suton p10z
seus 10d
480g ueping
*yzo0daa sty} JO G "d—#IFBYS JO 8}809 FUN 10} | JIQIUXY 2FG—9}ON
-yaodos sty} JO ‘gt 03 $1 “dd— HANA 8, PUUIBId 8 «
“"'* SAGAL TIV ‘S'TIVLOL GNVUD
eee ercerseeeseeeeseses OPF-A ‘STBIOL
.
** 261 “4
teneeeeees peer
seeeeeeeeeees O2eT
auvp ‘Asvniqey ‘Aivnuee
"** GZ6L ‘Le 4equies0q 0} gt eune
eeeee
Le6l ‘¢ Avenaqag 0} | Arvnuee
seeeeeeees Q76T ‘eT O11 Arenuese
LZ6T ‘Aoquiavag Pu s9quUIOAON
:9FF I —10708LL
** 9¢z9-V ‘SIBIOL
reese OSET
eee QZ6T
testes Q2eT
:09%9-V—V TePOW
eee
eeeeeee
eee
“''* OLFL ‘Si8IOL
tees QReT
veseee p26T
ve eeeeeeeeeere® Q2eT
*** 6Z6L ‘Te Jequieveq 0} OT eunL
-s10dey S14 JO ST 04 OT SeS8q—O WaTyx” 4q UMOGS se InOH sod uorjonpoig a0 peseg
souyeyT WeD JutoW
UNUTUT pus 4
UWA sIyVysUIED ps0
Qe e3ea ‘e-Z VaATGxXG)
‘Teer ‘¢ Arenigeg 04 GzeT ‘9T CuUNL MOI
yo esQ qSnomqy Auvdui0p 10j0q Plog 4q 2uueg uepimg
dinbg erqereay 20MO WHA pus seme] ueD FuNIeW
q uodn survg Surpupip 10 Zuyurpoem, JO WOH uepang
‘SV LIAIHXG 8. 44LLNIVId
01FL—L Pon
COPY BOUND VERTICALLY
(Exhibit Z-3, Page 6)
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT B-1.
DETERMINATION OF BURDEN RATIO TO PRODUCTIVE LABOR.
Qn June 1, 1938, at cross examination, defendant presented three sheets showing total productive labor
and total overhead as follows: Pltfs. Exs. — X-1 — X-2 — X-3 —
for Department 410: For Department 105 or for Departments 102, 105 and 106 combined:
5 Months of 1926 5 Months of 1926
5 sé ae 1927 5 “e oe 1927
9 * ‘¢ 1928 1 ie ‘¢ 1928
@ * ¢¢ 1929
ye ¢* *¢ 1930
a 4 ‘€ 1931
The data thus supplied has been used, as shown below, for periods subsequent to December 31, 1925. For
the period beginning June 15, 1925 and ended December 31, 1925, the data has been obtained from cost summary
wards furnished by defendant at earlier dates:
Department 410: Unit Costs Total Amounts
Months Production Labor Burden Labor Burden
From Cost Summary Cards:
June 16 to 30, 1925 (% of June) ..... 100,575 3066 .2894 30,836.30 29,106.40
July © > icuueaseseenetens 172,650 .2960 3271 51,104.40 56,473.82
August TTT TTCTI TTT Tire. 92,700 3235 .2955 29,988.45 27,392.85
September HF ptéaweseueseveeses 119,500 .3106 .2837 37,116.70 33,902.15
October MH yeescadunecredere 222,950 3195 .2793 71,232.53 62,269.93
November e- cccckensunavaeweee 212,950 3084 .2570 65,673.78 54,728.15
te cuneseteceevncasteucduee 921,325 285,952.16 263,873.30
Weighted average burden percent-
age (Used for 1925) .......-.++ 92.27
Productive Burden
Labor Overhead Percentage
From Data Supplied June 1, 1938 by Defendant
(Exs, X-1, X-2 and X-3):
January OE cheer cee eeeeetcsueeeedsutcrteesevecenessreds 62,909.88 84,008.13 133.54
February WF Le gach ekeckser PEREVEEVE STR CEERDI EE ThEKeeKESs 59,306.94 68,945.28 116.25
March Fc cecundeee ns beceOeeseteuversesertuseveccess 69,146.55 84,292.23 121.90
June PE ces edS eR KENENSENTPEESENONY EPOREN SELES ORG 48,696.46 69,397.49 142.51
Cee gcse veer ever ersetasreseeriovceneveeeurtene 65,574.68 97,369.91 148.49
Totals, and average percentage (Used for 1926) .........--- 305,634.51 404,013.04 132.19
January SE on Fiicckasuccceevateee ees heceuderssestsixse¢ 58,283.20 82,996.62 142.40
February FF peeved nen reneere CenevenreewEneerediesi 53,310.77 77,531.01 145.43
March We ceuyaderdvececencedeereseceuseuhets Caseess 68,320.05 92,290.50 135.09
April oT acececkecteceserecusvexerreccanssessecerts 54,351.92 85,119.67 156.61
May Oe cecév unt UXadstUe nee CES ee RP cneeess resets 249,710.42 358,460.04 143.55
Totals, and average percentage (Used for BOBT) .nccccceces 483,976.36 696,397.84 143.89
~~ nedeis 4 ee eT ee, es ea i a a
Department 410 (continued)
Totals, and average percentage (Used for 1930)
January 1931
February ¥
Totals, and average percentage (Used for 1931)
eoeeeeeeeeereseeseerereeeereeeee
Months
March PPP r Perr rrr rrr Tet rrr rrr it
April CG _ fee OOOOH ESOC HR ORO HOCH HOCK THC CCH FERC CTCF FEE
May errr rrr rrerrfyT rel iA ed
June PrP rrrrrrrre eee eet
July . PPPTTTITIITITITITI
Aagust —«- «wv ccercecceccrvereveccesesccsesvccssesersees
September Cosh enwsavadtwereceeerereerererecererrrnerere
October ee Payee rrr rrr errr rrr rer Tria tt. tril re.
November rr errr rr rer rrr eee rere t ee
Totals, and average percentage (Used for 1928) .........-++-
January SD ccveusneviseeveeereveverecveverecrereneerOns
February eee Pr rrrrrrr rr rrr rT eri tee ee
Mareh CO locereeecerveververserererereererrEerTeTere tes
April re errr rrr rrr rrr ret Tier Teter eh,
May OE Lc aveser ser ee ereeceekeerTeeeeno er CCLOT eS
June ew de ovate eee hecen es eeRRe reverses ¥Ces es
July 4 sevestrurernencvareseeutruerrocrrerer ener es
August 6 CcveeeereeuvedersvererrsnverrrsterveCrereeTs
September 6 eevee eecercecceeusereeceesrseessssssereeees
October oe lpworecectrereecerereserervescevereavesererse
November , WL Leosercnsstensreéreeveeseevevereovetevererre
December a nn rrr rrr rrr rer iY Trt rt tree ok
January SOOO ccccveecdrccvereececereroveroeroverocereeres
February f sccchoctecdtveraverureterrvcererereveeresres
March He scapeereterrerreedetederseerierertenes
April He pcceuseensevtersrerecedesovenerrerereererues
May errr rrrrrrrrrrrr rity titi eee
June Fn cooked eee CEO ERTERSUR IS ET OT ECTENES CEES
July TF pcceeperest eesti Cerrer eet eerecesrederererss
August Ho . cegadodereverueeceererrecerecisoeeroeruertrs
September {6 sea eceeerccecercerensussesersarsusesseeseses
October He clecccdaneeeraveereceehedverceveceereserters
November M8 is ccevenvernerereestraseereerererentses
December Hn oe pecriwrseeesereverseurterersrrerieagene
re
een
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT B-1.
DETERMINATION OF BURDEN RATIO TO PRODUCTIVE LABOR.
149°
(Exhibit Z-3, Page 7)
Productive Burden
Labor Overhead Percentage
383,979.89 447,558.00 116.56
426,026.67 475,148.94 111.53
161,354.00 156,416.84 96.94
165,423.64 171,631.19 103.75
165,843.40 167,469.92 100.98
184,494.69 168,764.90 91.47
160,847.08 159,116.76 98.92
190,366.59 195,530.67 102.71
180,039.79 195,001.14 108.31
2,018,375.75 2,136,638.36 105.86
215,922.85 202,037.18 93.57
193,657.89 197,642.17 102.06
196,301.27 200,855.86 102.32
175,020.71 190,257.42 108.71
190,031.69 195,126.59 102.68
180,264.14 203,087.58 112.66
193,567.51 220,448.28 113.89
200,442.07 224,977.43 112.24
153,922.47 195,200.30 126.82
169,232.65 219,447.29 129.67
103,309.90 163,800.36 158.55
64,214.22 139,747.94 217.63
2,035,887.37 2,352,628.40 115.56
87,939.83 145,167.10 165.07
119,236.45 195,618.32 164.06
149,514.16 216,167.92 144.58
177,954.06 223,733.42 125.72
182,309.84 246,599.45 135.26
176,010.73 241,648.41 137.29
60,658.66 114,603.09 188.93
111,339.13 178,899.35 160.68
103,715.10 171,956.69 165.80
86,511.32 149,475.42 172.78
78,540.83 147,837.62 188.23
58,743.22 135,272.64 230.28
1,392,473.33 2,166,979.43 155.62
59,624.21 120,931.88 202.82
83,081.80 147,409.48 177.43
142,706.01 268,341.36 188.04
DELANO REDE P ARENAS L RL AEST TIEN EPS EE Sedat iS tal a i
1§"0
(Exhibit Z-3, Page 8)
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT B-1.
DETERMINATION OF BURDEN RATIO TO PRODUCTIVE LABOR.
vepartment 105, or 102, 105 and 106 combined:
Unit Costs Total Amounts
Production Labor Burden Labor Burden
From Cost Summary Cards:
June 16 to 30, 1925 (% of June).. 5,242 .8006 1.2520 4,196.74 6,562.99
July SF peeeeoueseceer 9,681 .8140 1.4303 7,880.33 13,846.74
August i seaasevausauey 9,245 .7525 1.2479 6,956.86 11,536.84
September OT iedewusecsuns 8,745 .7356 1.2410 6,432.82 10,852.55
October Oe Leceseueteeres 9,363 .7486 1.2642 7,009.14 11,836.71
November Oe Lacecewneeenes 8,825 .6757 1.3316 5,963.05 11,751.37
Totals ...cccccccccscervccces 51,101 38,438.94 66,387.20
Weighted average burden per- 172.71
centage (Used for 1925)....
Productive Burden
Labor Overhead Percentage
From data supplied June 1, 1938 by defendant
(Exs, X-1, X-2 and X-3):
January Dp caceen GWEC ERUSEEUCUVEREESNSVERS UOCENE SERS Es 105,857.33 178,937.71 169.04
February reer TT TT errr TTT Ti ToT Tt ttt tha 138,974.51 234,512.23 168.74
Mareh fee ceudereSeSUS SECC CEVEUEREO RCH EODS SET E ND ERKOT 124,779.76 234,215.80 187.70
June Wh. dasensesasieusbarassucuneuseués 98,673.30 193,146.33 195.74
November Oe coves peveSUSETEESEROUEECCRERESCCE SO RGR ET ERTS 22,200.11 149,677.33 674.22
Totals, and average percentage (Used for 1926) .........++. 490,485.01 990,489.40 201.94
January OE Cc cccndcuvrceseeeevediaseesvecuvecrceevensnees 133,935.24 324,142.77 242.01
February MTT ePeTTroTTTIeTiTT Tritt 236,317.99 373,399.23 158.01
March ror rr eT Trey rT Terr rT TTT its ita hil as 335,789.35 447,867.90 133,38
May ee eT eC O TOTO UTT TTC et 207,504.98 398,269.68 191.93
Wovember §! — ncccvecccvccccccccevceveccccccccrernveceeese 232,425.83 399,546.41 171.90
Totals, and average percentage (Used for 1927) .....+.+++++ 1,145,973.39 1,943,225.99 169.57
March DC cconccvedvecesweeedcndvedshesieeteercreeeexe 103,137.11 218,493.79 211.85
Not used. Instead have accepted the suggesced percentage. . 176,00
LIRA, BOTS AMPLE UB NRL ANEMIA MIAN EYEE TEI TMI OE IIH GR BEM ON SE NE LE TIO
Cn So
(Exhibit Z-3, Page 10)
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT C.
Production Per Hour by Various Types of Machines of
Each Type of Camshaft, as Used in this Report.
T-410 Shaft.
By Cam Shaper: 25 per machine hour, 50 per man
hour.
Based on production admitted by defendant’s wit-
nesses (pp. 205, 212, 222 of Printed Record of Appeal).
Same production per hour as used by defendant in its ac-
counting.
By Melling Cam Lathe: —37!4 per machine hour, 75
per man hour.
Based on production admitted by defendant’s wit-
nesses (pp. 212-223 of Printed Record of Appeal). Sup-
ported by operation sheet of 10-8-24. Made at Highland
Park. (Defendant’s Exhibit 14). Modified by testimony
of Mr. Schmidt, who was in charge of maintenance of De-
partment 410 at Highland Park and Rouge. On page 1016
of the typewritten record of the hearing beginning January
16, 1939, Schmidt testified that the Melling lathes came
in March, 1924; that slides were changed from cast iron to
steel and that many other changes were made in the ma-
chines; that it was five or six months after the machines
were received before they started to get anywhere near the
production they ought to get; that after they made changes
in the machines the production kept increasing and that
this increase continued after the lathes were moved to the
Rouge plant.
This operation sheet showed .86 of a minute for turning
the cams, which is equivalent to about 35 per hour. The
increase from 35 per hour to 371% per hour, supported as
it is by Mr. Wibel’s sheet (Exhibit 247) is, we believe, ex-
ceedingly conservative.
15%2
A-6250 Shaft.
By Landis Grinders: —9.4297 per machine and man
hour.
Calculated upon page 13 of this report. In this calcula-
tion, non-grinding time within the operation cycle is ob-
tained from the White Motor Company’s motion time study
(Plaintiff’s Exhibit A a). Unloading and loading time, as
shown by this time study, has been eliminated from the non-
grinding time because of the use of conveyors by defendant
and consequent probable faster handling. Only the non-
grinding time necessary because cams were ground one at a
time, is retained. The remaining, or actual grinding time,
is calculated upon the basis of the relative periphery of the
cams upon A-6250 and F-446 shafts. Defendant’s Exhibit
12 showed a production of eight F-446 shafts per hour and
this production is the basis used for the calculation of the
actual grinding time.
By Melling Cam Lathe: 32.711 Per Mach. Hour. 65.422
per Man Hour.
No time study covering the turning of the cams upon
this shaft on the Melling lathes during the infringing pe-
riod, is available, excepting Defendant’s Exhibit 16, made
at the very beginning of the production of the A-6250 shaft,
and disregarded, for this reason, in defendant’s account-
ing. A different type of operation sheet (Exhibit 214) pre-
pared for Autostroy, has been presented by defendant, but
this is clearly not an exact copy of a time study, because
the production thereon is shown in even numbers per hour.
At best, it is an approximation and time study speed
showing anything between 30 and 35 per hour were prob-
ably changed to the nearest ‘‘gafe”’ figure,—in this case
30. This sheet was prepared for use in Russia under the
supervision of an employee of defendant, and presumably
to indicate production which might be attained by work-
men of a nation relatively inexperienced in mechanical
operations or mass production. It would naturally state
expected production conservatively. It cannot, therefore,
be accepted as definitely and accurately proving production
of defendant.
1593
164
In the absence of an actual record, production has been
calculated (See Page 13 of this report). In view of the
evidence presented at the hearing beginning January 16,
1939, the use of non-turning time within an operation, as
shown by the White Motor Company’s time study of the
Melling lathe, has been eliminated,—this because loading
and unloading time has been shown by evidence at the
hearing beginning January 16, 1939 to be materially less
at the defendant’s plant than at the White Motor Com-
pany’s plant, and, unlike the grinding operation, in which
each cam is separately ground, the non-turning time, other
than loading and unloading, amounts to so little as to be a
negligible factor in the determination of production per
hour.
Evidence at the hearing beginning January 16, 1939
shows that the shaft revolution on Melling lathes is based
upon motor revolutions per minute and on gearing which
cannot be changed by operators and which was not
changed. Therefore, theoretically, the production per hour
of A-6250 shafts should be the same as that of T-410 shafts.
However, evidence at this hearing indicated that even with
shunt wound motors a heavier and longer cut would slight-
ly reduce the motor speed. As the periphery of the A-6250
cams is greater than that of the T-410 cams and as the for-
mer are produced from 40 carbon steel as compared with
35 carbon steel for the latter, the production of the A-6250
shafts would have been slightly lower than the production
of the T-410 shafts.
In recognition of this fact, production of the A-6250
shaft has been reduced from that of the T-410 shaft (37.5
per hour) in proportion to the relative area of the cams
upon the two shafts. The reduction in speed, so deter-
mined, should be ample to give effect to the slight reduction
in motor speed and to the slightly harder steel.
F-446 Shaft.
By Landis Grinders: Based on production of 8 shafts
per machine and man hour, from Defendant’s Exhibit 12.
By Melling Cam Lathes: 20 Per Machine and Man
Hour.
Mr. Herklotz testified (page 256 of printed record of
appeal) that production was 29 per machine hour, 50 per
man hour. However, Mr. Worley (page 1872 of the type-
written record of the hearing beginning January 16, 1939)
stated that the recollection of various men in the plant
of the production of these cams, ranged all the way from 15
to 20 per Hour and some even said 25. A calculation based
on 37.5 per hour of the T-410 shafts and recognizing the
greater area of the F-446 shaft, shows 20.2389 per hour.
(37.5 divided by 1.85287) for the F'-446 shaft.
Defendant’s Exhibit 215, an operation sheet prepared
from an English time study, is not conclusive for the rea-
son that there is no information as to the motor speed, or
as to the handling methods in the English plant, and for
the further reason that it is generally recognized that
English workmen’s output is much lower than that of
American workmen. Also, English production of motor
ears and tractors has not been in sufficient quantities to
necessitate the mass production methods used in the United
States.
In view of the above, it is believed that 20 per machine
hour is the most reasonable estimate of production obtain-
able for the F-446 shaft.
For the Period from June 16, 1925 to February 3, 1931.
Month
June 16 to 30, 19250 wee eeeee
July 660 geeevere
August 66 peeeeene
September $6 peeeenes
October se ogesuvers
November 60 geeevere
December Ht . openness
Totals, June 16 to Dee, Sl,
ey Sr
January 1026 .ccccres
February $6 poeecere
March $6 cevecess
April 66 = =seereree
May $60 geeueees
June 6 tp eoeeues
July eo ceevente
August $6 tp evecers
September ‘io poeneeee
October 6 sasveers
November te Gecccose
December + eeveewes
Totals, 1986 .nccoees
January errr
February $€ geturunus
March $6 saeeuane
April ¢ soeusees
May 0 seenenee
June ¢ neeneeon
July seeerere
August te peansere
September of eeennens
October tt gn auenes
November $e geuseees
December ct “seeuenes
Totals, WET cccecoer
January 1928 ...ceces
February oe onwenves
March tt ctaneeee
April $6 steeenve
May + guanvnds
June $6 paneteun
July et cseneuse
August $6 seceenes
September $6 soveeees
October 66 peevveee
November 66 geeveees
December 6 gontedes
Totals, 19028 ...cceee
(Exhibit Z-3, Page 14)
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT D.
Production of Camshafts.
Model T Model A Tractor
T-410 A-6250 P-446
100,575 a 6,242 a*
172,650 9,681 a*
92,700 a 9,245 a*
119,500 a 8,745 a*
292 V50 ua 9,363 a*
212,950 a 4,825 a*
171,880 b 4,872 b
1,093,205 59,973
157,400 a 11,995 a*
154,000 a 12,195 a*
178,200 a 15,092 a*
170,375 b 10,124 b
155,139 b %,823 b
149,069 b 9,645 a*
141,877 b 6,554 b
151,676 b 6,766 b
141,814 b 6,552 b
145,830 b 4,914 b
110,418 a 4,830 a*
43,407 b 1,621 b
1,699,205 99,111
83,909 b 4,636 b
68,810 b 7,932 b
93,781 b 13,510 a*
80,555 b 9,704 b
83,520 b 6,944 b
13,109 b 7,398 b
12,711 b 6,531 b
14,837 b 9,977 b
18,703 b 9,737 b
16,625 b 9,606 b
12,285 « 2,553 ¢ 16,380 ¢
7,241 ¢ 6,734 ¢ 5,250 ¢
506,086 9,287 100,705
9,191 «¢ 13,509 ¢ 7,795 ¢
7,844 ¢ 19,512 ¢ 5,360 ¢
8,041 d 32,295 d 2,720 a®
8,435 ¢ 44,503 ¢
12,508 ¢ 55,306 ¢
14,878 ¢ 67,866 ¢
13,712 ¢ 69,537 ¢
13,491 ¢ 96,098 ¢
11,760 ¢ 89,353 ¢
9,445 ¢ 117,348 ¢
3,444 © 118,145 ¢
5,699 « 119,984 ¢
120,448 843,456 15,875
1597
(Exhibit Z-3, Page 15)
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT D.
Production of Camshafts.
For the Period from June 16, 1925 to February 3, 1931.
Model T Model A Tractor
Month T-410 A-6250 F-446
January WD cicccoes 1,222 (ce) 165,184 (¢)
February 66 = seeeeves 160,960 (¢)
March et eeeneee? 175,960 (¢)
April geeeeves 180,249 (¢)
May OO ewevewes 194,724 (¢)
June ee lpeeereus 186,277 (¢)
July 1 ogtetiany 198,713 (¢)
August WTI T Tr 198,044 (¢)
September OF ebcesees 154,561 (¢)
October ee seeeuwes 174,545 (¢)
November 7 syeeneve 109,155 (¢)
December OF peeeeeus 63,601 (¢)
Totals, SD ccccnere 1,222 1,961,973
January SOOO cevesvis 90,529 (e)
February Fp weneete 114,714 (¢)
March oe peceueus 156,386 (¢c)
April Ff weseneee 192,275 (¢)
May f) seueeses 186,961 (e)
June OF pheuavun 169,489 (e)
July 7 wtxeeees 56,702 (e)
August oO - teesvers 103,200 (e)
September cre rrr. 94,616 (e)
October der rrrcer 79,907 (e)
November 6. Levceete 73,022 (e)
December Oe peveeues 52,616 (e)
Totals, | ere rer 1,370,417
January, errr ree 32,700 (e)
February OF cowceees 5,166 (e)
Totals Se weceecey 37,866
GoanG Tetale .ccccccvevss 3,420,166 4,222,999 275,664
a. Quantities obtained from cost summary cards, Form 3566.
b. Quantities arrived at by adding motors produced and camshaft service
sales.
Quantities obtained from minute cost summaries, Form 2202B.
Quantities obtained from Productive Labor Reports, Form 3567.
Quantities obtained from minute cost summaries, Form 2202B and pro-
rated between camshafts produced on Melling cam lathes and Ford Cam
mills,
gas
Note: All of the above quantities and notes (excepting for those marked
‘*a’’) are taken from Defendant’s Exhibit No. 4 Amended. Those marked
‘‘a*’? are taken from cost summary cards discovered and supplied subse-
quent to preparation of Defendant’s amended accounting and have been
accepted in Defendant ’s accounting presented at hearing beginning January
16, 1939. These corrections, covering 13 months, considerably increase the
production shown by Defendant for each month corrected, the total addi-
tions totaling more than 21 percent of the production previously reported
for the months corrected.
Quantities obtained by method ‘‘b’’ do not recognize variations in in-
ventories and are therefore estimates.
Quantities obtained by method ‘‘e’’ are likewise estimates, being the
balance of production after assigning to Pioch machines production obtained
by multiplying total hours operated by hourly production of these machines
as shown by a time study dated July 1 of the following year.
No separate record was kept, or at least none was presented, of the
respective production by Melling and Pioch machines during the period when
both types were available.
7-410:
January
February
March
April
May
June
July
August
September
October
November
January
February
March
April
May
June
July
August
September
October
November
April
May
June
July
August
September
October
November
January
February
March
April(?)
June
November
Inventory
March
August
November
April,
October
October,
Cost Summary Cards
ae
November,
‘é
12/31/26
1928
‘se
sé
1929
sé
1928
1930
7 4
se
sé
sé
oe
sé
F-1
ee
“e
ce
F-2
ae
‘6
“6
‘“
“6
F-3
‘6
“c
“
‘6
F-4
sé
se
sé
sé
sé
F-5
‘6
F-6
sé
“e
sé
sé
sé
sé
sé
sé
sé
sé
sé
F-7 (Revised)
F-8
Production
146,400
158,100
184,100
178,450
188,150
185,000
180,750
191,450
168,900
193,500
180,900
226,850
216,450
218,250
208,050
176,800
142,700
142,450
148,900
155,050
152,950
107,050
197,000
187,240
201,150
172,650
92,700
119,500
222,950
212,950
157,400
154,000
178,200
173,700(?)
eeneee
oeeeee
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT E.
Tabulation of Cost Summary Cards.
Sheet 1 of 2
159
(Exhibit Z-3, Page 17)
Cost per Camshaft
Labor
3269
3014
2902
.2997
3023
.3162
3135
3220
3485
3393
.3280
3299
3201
3180
3330
3337
3239
3163
.3088
.2974
3295
3300
3002
2995
.3066
-2960
3235
3106
3195
-3084
3051
-2934
3011
.2773
2831
2802
4926
4318
7143
7143
Burden
3171
2924
.2467
.2298
2267
2055
2195
2737
.3137
.3393
.3280
3299
3201
3085
3230
3237
3239
3479
3551
3331
3625
3630
3302
-2646
.2894
3271
2955
2837
2793
2570
3356
3521
3613
3952
4204
4078
HTA2
3950
7737
7737
Total
6440
5938
5369
5395
5290
5217
5330
5957
6622
.6786
6560
6598
6402
6265
.6560
6574
6478
-6642
6639
6305
-6920
.6930
6304
5641
5960
6231
6190
5943
5988
5654
6407
6455
6624
6725
7035
6880
1,0668
8268
1.4880
1.4880
ial 1810
(Exhibit 2-3, Page 18)
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT E.
Tabulation of Cost Summary Cards.
Cost per Camshaft
cost Summary Cards: Production Labor Burden Total
————— eee
A-6250
Inventory 12/31/27 (Estimate) Ex. F-10 .6362 .6534 1.2896
Special 2/20/28 = 1173 4277 5450
March 1928 7 8 32,295 1.1165 1.3014 2.4179
Jone 1-25“ ee 6o8 38,664 1.0003 1.1203 2.1206
August ‘6 oc FY 96,098 8625 .7890 1.6515
October 66 vig ii 117,348 .7769 .7980 1.5749
November ‘‘ ee #9 118,145 .7455 .8075 1.5530
January 1929 en 165,184 .7920 .7524 1.5444
March $6 ‘6 E-1 175,960 7251 .7396 1.4647
May 66 ace 194,724 .6880 .7086 1.3966
July 66 Oe 198,713 6246 .7120 1.3366
September ‘* "¢ 6D} 154,561 .6036 .7666 1.3702
October 66 ally 174,545 .5743 .7466 1.3209
January 1930 "eee 90,529 5519 .9106 1.4625
March e6 li 156,386 5895 .8548 1.4443
May 66 ae 197,713 5668 .7652 1.3320
August 66 e 119,328 5705 9185 1.4890
October 66 se 646 93,179 5636 .8398 1.4034
March 1931 = = 96,815 5486 9271 1.4757
F446:
May 1925 Ex. F-11 12,716 .7266 1.0563 1.7829
June sé es 10,485 .8006 1.2520 2.0526
July ¥e s 6 9,681 .8140 1.4303 2.2443
August sh 6 9,245 7525 1.2479 2.0004
September ‘ . e 8,745 -7356 1.2410 1.9766
October ii ‘6 6 F-12 9,363 .7486 1.2642 2.0128
November ‘‘ es 8,825 .6757 1.3316 2.0073
January 1926 ‘6 P13 11,995 .6789 1.0184 1.6973
February si ald 12,195 .6428 .8678 1.5106
March sh “ 15,092 .6594 9891 1.6485
June ag iad 9,645 .7601 1.4898 2.2499
November ‘‘ sills 4,830 .6642 2.5833 3.2475
December(?) ‘‘ oe (?) .7122 2.0366 2.7488
Inventory 12/31/26 eo 14,475 .7281 1.8547 2.5828
March 1927 s 13,510 .6268 .8360 1.4628
November e ?- (?) .6563 1.0043 1.6606
March 1928 ee 2,720 .7642 1.3450 2.1092
Blank ¢ @ + i eeeev
|
:
bes ed Tere)
—
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT F.
Defendant’s Proration of Production Between Melling and Pioch Machines.
Machines Available
Production Assigned
1513
(Exhibit Z-3, Page 19)
Melling Pioch Shifts Melling Pioch Total
1930 to Feb. 3, 1931:
190 (last half) ...-+++-eeeee 21 1 32 (used) 186,961 10,752 197,713
MW sesnnceeneaeeneceeeeroes 21 1 62 169,489 20,832 190,321
vt ETE 21 1 22 56,702 7,392 64,094
et! sesneneeneeneneeeeeaeees 21 1 48 103,200 16,128 119,328
Sh ceseessaceeuenersesseres 21 1 47 94,616 15,792 110,408
Tee 21 1 39.5 79,907 13,272 93,179
Mh ceuasteenbennarenerneess 21 1 36 73,022 12,096 85,118
FR ceeevadeneunecrrerssress 21 1 26.5 52,616 8,904 61,520
bili cuseceesevesesucereesseses 313 816,513 105,168 921,681
no, 1931 (first half) ...-.-+++++++ 21 2 9 6,048
me (last 88) ceeeeeeeeeeee 21 4 18 24,192
GAM e aicabeutiineviveesess 27 32,700 30,240 62,940
Ss aaah B WED cvcecssccrcecesens 21 4 5 5,166 6,720 11,886
Totals, 5-16-30 to 2-3-31 ......... 345 854,379 142,128 996,507
re. 4 to March 15, 1931:
eT ME vvscssyerevecrerss 13 6 me, “seante 75,572 75,572
MMe: FF ccsciveseccerryses 13 6 iS ee 39,065 39,065
Sats 04 te FIRES o0 ccc cc reece ee ee 114,637 114,637
Record of Shifts Operated from May 1, 1930 to March 31, 1931 and of
Defendant’s Claimed Production with Pioch Machines.
Days operated
Sshifts 2shifts 1 shift Total
AMUN yc cserisreserevestresseressriecesssseessersreeees 9 2 2 33
by 16 00 $0, 1000 co.cc cecccccececevevecersesessccseseooseeneaeess 4 2 3 31
4 5 64 (a)
5 4 62
1 2 22
4 4 48
5 4 47
4 5 39.5 (b)
4 4 36
3 3 26.5 (b)
3 27
2 37
0
41
EEE — ST a ete |
1512
(Exhibit Z-3, Page 20)
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT G.
Evidence of Abandonment of the Use of Melling Cam Lathes for
Rough Turning the Cams upon Camshafts.
From Photostatic Copies of Defendant’s Permanent Inventory of
Machine Tools—Exhibits Y-1 to Y-24.
Manufac-
turer’s Date sent to Date
Number Track 297 Salvaged Other Data
111 2- 5-31 6-18-31
114 2- 5-31 6-18-31
113 2- 5-31 6-18-31
115 2- 5-31 6-18-31
229 9-13-32 4-11-30 (a) (Still at Highland Park)
122 11- 9-28—Sold to Cork, Ireland
225 11-22-34 10- 7-31 (b) Believed used to turn pump
eccentric
214 11-22-34
226 11-22-34
110 3-16-31 6-18-31
109 3-16-31 6-18-31
112 2- 5-31 6-18-31
106 3-16-31 6-18-31
116 2- 5-31 6-18-31
118 3-16-31 6-18-31
119 2- 5-31 6-18-31
2- 4-29 Sold to Continental Motors Corpn.
121 6- 8-36 4-23-31 Repurchased—Sent to Highland
Park
Y-18 (a) 215 6- 8-36 12- 5-834 Made available at Highland Park
10- 7-31 (e)
Y-19 (b) 227 9-13-32 11-22-34 5- 5-30 (d)
108 3-16-31 6-18-31
107 3-16-31 6-18-31
117 3-16-31 6-18-31 ‘*Replaced by a Pioch Machine’’
120 2- 5-31 6-18-31 ‘*Replaced by a Pioch Machine’’
105 11- 9-28 Sold to Cork, Ireland
' (a) Moved 4-11-30 from J-8 in motor building to K-8 in motor building.
(b) “ee 10- 7-31 é sé se sé sé sé sé se sé oe
(¢) “ce sé “oe oe “e “é ae se sé sé “ce
(d) “ce 5- 5-30 sé oe sé “eé oe e ce “é ae “e
K is stated to be a machining or operating department, but information was not available as to
whether or not a part of Dept. 410.
Melling Lathes that may have been available from February 4 to March 15, 1931.
Machines marked (a) above 11
Machines marked (b) above 2 13
— machines could readily have produced the output of camshafts from February 4 to March 15,
me as wr Pag TF RAY ee PR es Sn oh
1972
PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT H.
Additional Savings Based upon Failure of Defendant to Substantiate Claims
of Production by Pioch Machines During Periods When Both Melling and
Pioch Machines Were or May Have Been Available.
12-31-30—105,168 (a) A-6250 camshafts
316 to
at (Productive Labor saving per camshaft) ............- $.086694 (b) $ 9,117.43
at (Burden "= Te bevvestuduene .134914 (b) 14,188.64
at (Total ic " " } vcesvcsrveese .221608 (b) $23,306.07
LI to 9.3-31—36,960 (a) A-6250 camshafts
at (Productive Labor saving per camshaft) ..........--- $.087575 (b) $ 3,236.77
at (Burden wii - " ) cecedsuseeese .164675 (b) 6,086.39
at (Total sb sa - D sevevvesveccess .252250 (b) 9,323.16
Total from 5-16-30 to 2-3-31 11... eee e cece reece eeeeees (Item one) $32,629.23
Xo reeords were furnished by defendant, and apparently none
vere kept, showing actual respective production of shafts on
The Melling Lathes and The Pioch Machines. Since there were
11 to 13 Melling Machines available (see Ex. G of this report)
for turning all production from Feb. 3-1931 to March 15-1931,
the defendants claimed production in Pioch Machines during
this time is not substantiated.
24 to 3:15-31—114,637 (a) A-6250 camshafts
at (Productive Labor saving per camshaft) .......sece0. $.087575 (c) $10,039.33
at (Burden ” " “ ) vesccoveeeess 164675 (c¢) 18,877.85
at (Total - “ sod ) svervovernves .252250 (¢) (Item two) $28,917.18
a) See Exhibit F in this report.
b) See Exhibit B in this report
¢) Same saving per shaft used as during the period from 1-1
to 2-3-31.
Note: The inclusion of the saving shown upon this sheet depends:
In Part upon the lack of sufficient actual records kept by defendant.
In Part upon acceptance of March 15, 1931 as the date upon which the use of the Melling lathes
was abandoned.
ee OD US ee } RE BOs
0 li aes wre e CEES SE De pat b 5 ii a Saad *
1517
EXHIBIT Z-5.
DEPRECIATION COST OF FORD CAM SHAPERS OF MODEL T TYPE
) AND OF MELLING CAM LATHES—FROM JUNE 16, 1925 TO FEBRUARY
| 3, 1931 AND FROM FEBRUARY 4, 1931 TO MARCH 15, 1931.
ford Shapers—Model T Type:
Depre- Amounts for Periods
ciation Total for Y% To % To
Rates Periods T-410 A-6250 T-410 A-6250
5.16.25 to 12-31-25 (6% months)... 9.5% 6,436.56 100.00 6,436.56
Year 1926 .--ccececrccccccrserre® 9.5% 12,160.63 100.00 12,160.63
11.97 to 10-31-27 (10 months) .... 10.5% 11,656.28 100,00 11,656.28
November, 1987 -ccccccccseceeeeee 10.5% 1,165.63 82.79 17.21 965.03 200.60
December, 1927 vncececcrerccceees 10.5% 1,165.63 51.81 48.19 603.91 561.72
Fear 1998 accccccecocerccccrrerss 10.5% 16,614.74 12.50 87.50 2,076.84 14,537.90
1.1.29 to 1-15-29 (% month) ....-- 10.5% 824.42 1.66 98.34 13.69 810.73
1.15.29 to 1-31-29 (% month)....... 10.5% 824.42 100.00 824.42
1.99 to 12-31-29 (11 months)..... 10.5% 18,137.28 100.00 18,137.28
Fear 1980 ..cccccccccccccscseres® 10.5% 23,664.57 109.00 23,664.57
11.31 to 2-3-31 (1-1/10 months).... 9.0% 1,859.36 100.00 1,859.36
94,509.52 33,912.94 60,596.58
»4.31 to 3-15-31 (1-4/10 months)... 9.0% 2,366.46 100.00 2,366.46
96,875.98 33,912.94 62,963.04
Melling Cam Lathes: eo.
6-16-25 to 12-31-25 (6% months)... 9.5% 3,365.57 100.00 3,365.57 we
Year 1926 ....csccecceccererccces 9.5% 6,208.35 100.00 6,208.35
| 1.197 to 10-31-27 (10 months)..... 10.5% 5,718.21 100.00 5,718.21
" November, 1927 ...---++eeeereerrs 10.5% 571.82 82.79 17.21 473.41 98.41
~ December, 1927 ...----+eeeerrrere 10.5% 571.82 51.81 48.19 296.26 275.56
E Year 1928 ....ccccceeccccseescree 10.5% 6,861.85 12.50 87.50 857.73 6,004.12
* 1.1.29 to 1-15-29 (4% month).....-- 10.5% 354.17 1.66 98.34 5.88 348.29
1-15-29 to 1-31-29 (4% month).....- 10.5% 354.17 100.00 354.17
2.1.29 to 12-31-29 (11 months).....- 10.5% 7,791.84 100.00 7,791.84
Year 1930 ....cccccccccccccerceses 10.5% 10,138.51 100.00 10,138.51
1-1-31 to 2-3-31 (1-1/10 months).... 9.0% 796.60 100.00 796.60
42,732.91 16,925.41 25,807.50
2.4-31 to 3-15-31 (1-4/10 months)... 9.0% 1,013.85 100.00 1,013.85
43,746.76 16,925.41 26,821.35
- 1518
DEPRECIATION OF T-410 CAM SHAPERS AND OF MELLING CAM
LATHES REQUIRED FOR PRODUCTION OF F-446 SHAFT.
From June 16, 1925 to March 31, 1928.
Shapers:
Assuming that 114 times as many shapers as Mell-
ing Lathes would have been required (same pro-
portion as for T-410).
No. of shaperS ...--ccccccccccecceceerecseeeees 3
Cost of shapers 3 x $6,000.00 ......--eeeereeeee 18,000.00
Percent
Depreciation: ——
6-15-25 to 12-31-25 ..ccecececcccccccccecens 5.15 927.00
GO cic dc Cede EFECEPEETOTEEAEFOEEED IP EEHEES 9.50 1,710.00
pT POOP PURE PTET TTT CUA 10.50 1,890.00
Ist quarter of 1928—10.5 + 4 ueeeeeererrere 2.625 472.50
4,999.50
:
! Melling Cam Lathes:
Brass
Tag No.
; 32067 Cost 2- 9-24 ..ccceccccvccees 4,121.57
) 37001 $6 F-29024 wcccccccscvecres 3,973.19 8,094.76
| Percent
; Depreciation:
4 6-15-25 to 12-31-25 ...-.eeeccccvccsceeevcces 5.15 416.88
j | Pr errr ee 9.50 769.00
2 NOE cb ke ERERE OEE EA OEELCESEOEEEOOEEOS 10.50 849.95
Ist quarter of 192B—10.5 —<— 4 wnccccccccccees 2.625 212.49
ssaeererpentepepraernnesse sen Lee AE &
9 Ss oi a
“
a Ay
a4
Bet:
one
£4
Ke
we
4
aed
ak
&
*4
EXHIBIT Z-6.
MAINTENANCE—T-410 SHAFT.
For Period from June 16, 1925 to May 31, 1927.
Ford Cam Shapers:
Proportional
Number Average increase
Number of men in Direct Amount for9 Amount
shift of hours maintenance Labor (for13 additional (for 22
Numbers worked crew Rates shapers) shapers shapers)
a, 1922 1 .8587 1,650.42 1,142.60 2,793.01
2. 1922 2 .8587 3,300.84 2,285.20 5,586.04
3 1922 2 8587 3,300.84 2,285.20 5,586.04
5766 8,252.10 5,713.00 13,965.09
Melling Cam Lathes:
Foundry
Tool Room
(a)
» e 1922 1 .8587 1,650.42 ......- 1,650.42
2. 1922 4 .8587 6,601.69 3,300.84 9,902.53
3. 1922 4 8587 6,601.69 3,300.84 9,902.53
5766 14,853.80 6,601.68 21,455.48
(a) There were 2 men in Foundry tool room on each of two shifts, who repaired
slides. The proportion of their time so occupied was not stated. Above includes
all of their time.
ALL overhauling of Melling cam lathes was performed in production depart-
ment and by the above maintenance crew. Therefore overhaul expense is in-
cluded in above total for Melling lathes.
Each shaper was removed from the production department once a year, taken
to the MAIN tool room and completely overhauled by an entirely different set
of men.
Proportion of this overhaul chargeable to T-410 (P. 4) ....+--+++++ 29,000.00
Recapitulation :
Shapers—Maintenance ......----+seeeereereesereeseseee 13,965.09
Overhaul (p. 4) ..--eeeeeecereeeeseeesrererees 29,000.00 42,965.09
Melling Lathes—Maintenance .....-..+--+++eererreerees 21,455.48
Overhaul (included in Maintenance) .... ----+-+- 21,455.48
wail
.D
——— eC
MAINTENANCE—A-6250 SHAFT.
For the Period from November 1, 1927 to February 3, 1931.
Ford Cam Shapers:
Number Proportional
of hours Number of Average increase
Number at eight men in Direct Amounts for 14 Amount
shift of hours hours Maintenance Labor (for13 additional (for 27
Number worked per shift crew Rates shapers) shapers shapers)
prcitaceenianel
1 648 5,184 1 8951 4,640.20 4,997.14 9,637.34
2 730 5,840 2 8951 10,454.77 11,258.98 21,713.75
3 708 5,664 2 (8951 10,139.69 10,919.66 21,059.35
16,688 25,234.66 27,175.78 52,410.44
Melling Cam Lathes:
Foundry
Tool Room
(a)
1 648 5,184 1 8951 4,640.20 oe 4,640.20
2 730 5,840 4 .8951 20,909.54 10,454.77 31,364.31
3 708 5,664 4 ‘8951 20,279.38 10,139.69 30,419.07
16,688 45,829.12 20,594.46 66,423.58
(a) There were 2 men in Foundry tool room on each of two shifts who repaired slides. The
proportion of their time so oceupied was not stated.
Above includes ALL of their time.
ALL overhauling of Melling cam lathes was performed in production department and by
the above maintenance crew. Therefore overhead expense is included in above total for
Melling lathes.
Each shaper was removed from the production department once a year, taken to MAIN
tool room and completely overhauled by an entirely difference set of men.
Proportion of this overhead chargeable to A-6250 (P. 4) .-.-eeeeeeeeeeeereres 40,000.00
Recapitulation :
Shapers—Maintenance ....--eeeeeeeeeerecceccesecssresseesesee ees 52,410.44
QE ic once Rens URS EC OENESECREN ER TET OUR ETE TSH O% 40,000.00 92,410.44
Melling Lathes—Maintenance ......--.ssrerecrsreserseeseseeeeses 66,423.58
Overhaul (included in Maintenance) ......-+-++++- _— 66,423.58
Note: The hours worked appear excessive in this sheet. This because full maintenance crew
is assumed out every shift. If production per shift was 2913 in April, 1930 and only
1541 per shift in September, 1928, a considerably smaller number of machines would
have been required during the latter month and the whole maintenance crew would not
have been required.
aS |
ELLE AOE L LLL LINE LESION LLM ED BNE LISLE LORIE LOI VEY NE LEE TEEN I
-_
1521
MAINTENANCE—F-446 SHAFT.
For the Period from June 15, 1925 to March 31, 1928.
If 22 shapers would have been required for T-410 shafts
and 3 for F-446 shafts, during the same period of time,
the maintenance can be estimated for F-446 as 3/22 of
that for T shafts or 13.64%.
As the production period for T shafts selected for main-
tenance calculation was from 6-16-25 to 5-31-27, 23%
months, and the production period for F-446 shafts was
from 6-16-25 to 3-31-28, a period of 33% months, the
time for F-446 should be increased proportionally or by
43.55%.
1364 x 1.4355 — 19.58 — percentage of T-410 main-
tenance cost used for F-446.
Shapers—Maintenance—$13,965.09 x AGS ccccccsvesrs 2,734.36
Melling Lathes—Maintenance and Tool Men,
$21,455.48 xX 1958 2... cece cece eee ence eee e reer eeeees 4,200.98
Recapitulation:
Shapers—Maintenance .......-+++eeeeeeereeererercees 2,734.36
Overhaul (P. 4) ....-eeeeeee secre eeeeereeees 4,250.00 6,984.36
Melling Lathes—Maintenance ........-.+++e+reeereres
Overhaul (included in Maintenance) .. 4,200.98
‘
——
ID 95, AMER ICEE RMON BLES LONI HOEY LILI LEAN LEER BOLI ED ILLE GN POE LEI ELE TOE IE OT
- 1522
OVERHAUL EXPENSE.
Overhauling of Melling cam lathes was done by maintenance crew in Dept.
410, Therefore cost of overhauling is included in maintenance cost.
In the case of the Ford Shapers, however, each machine was removed bodily
from Department 410 once each year, taken to the main tool room and
completely overhauled by men not connected with Dept. 410.
No cost of those overhauls has been supplied, but a complete overhaul of
expensive machines such as the shapers may well have averaged $1,000.
It would hardly be less than $500. If in the absence of information, the
average overhaul cost is estimated at $500, the following additional cost
would be chargeable to the shapers:
Number of Shaper Overhauls Cost of Overhauling
Period T-410 A-6250 F-446 T-410 A-6250 P-446 Total
6/15 to 12/31/25. 12(a) —0--- 1.5 6,000.00 -—-— 750.00 6,750.00
eee 22 Ie 3 11,000.00 I 1,500.00 12,500.00
WET .ccccccevcese 21 1 3 10,500.00 500.00 1,500.00 12,500.00
TD ceevteveveres 3 19 1(b) 1,500.00 9,500.000 500.00 11,500.00
Oe eccveccresers 0 30 =~ — 0— 15,000.00 ---—- 15,000.00
TS ccveveeveceve 0 30 —0— —0—- 15,000.00 == 15,000.00
, oo) eee 29,000.00 40,000.00 4,250.00 73,250.00
(a)—6%4/12 of 22.
(b)—3 months.
No overhauling shown for 1931 as machines were abandoned by March 15.
i a LR a P OMON Neee
Na cable bol
ee)
EXHIBIT Z.-7.
COST OF TOOLS—INCLUDING GRINDING
FORD SHAPERS OF T-410 TYPE AND MELLING
CAM LATHES.
Cost per Shaft Total Cost
Shafts Ford Melling Ford Melling
Type Produced Shapers Lathes Shapers Cam Lathes
F-410 ..cccccce 3,420,166 .00300 .00087 10,260.50 2,975.54
A-G250 .nccccee 4,222,999 .00344 .00100 14,527.12 4,223.00
P-446 wcccceee 275,664 .00556 .00161 1,532.69 443.82
26,320.31 7,642.36
See page 2 for details.
COST OF TOOLS, INCLUDING GRINDING.
Ford Cam Snapers:
Ex. 9(g) of Defendant’s Statement of Account gives
tool cost per T-410 camshaft (based on record for
1922 and 1923) AS .....--eeeeereseeeeereeescees .00270
Grinding Cost—P. 1765 of typewritten record of
hearing beginning January 16, 1939, states that
grinding 12 tools requires 15 man minutes—15
minutes at 90¢ per hour ......---++seeeeeeeere $ .225
Grinding cost of 8 tools—2/3 Of 225 OF wccccccesce $ 15
Assuming 500 shafts per set of 8 tools, grinding
cost of tools per each T-410 shaft ($.15 + 500)... .00030 .00300
Total tool cost per T-410 shaft ........++eeeeeereees
Had it been possible to use T-410 shapers for the
large bearing shafts, cost would probably been
proportional to areas of cams
A-6250 — 1.14640 x T-410 22... cc cece reer eens .00344
F-446 — 1.85287 x T-410 2... cece eee eeeeee .00556
Melling Lathes:
Cost of 8 tools (per Ex. 8(h) of Defend-
ant’s Statement of Account) ......- $2.00
Hours of life (per do.) ....--+++++0+: 200
Production per machine hour—T-410 .. 37.5
T-410 camshafts per tool life—37.5 x 200, or 7500
Cost per T-410 camshaft $2.00 — 7500........----. .00027
Grinding Cost. P. 1765 of typewritten record of
hearing beginning January 16, 1939, states that
grinding 12 tools requires 30 man minutes.
30 minutes at 90¢ per hour ......---+eeeeeeeeeers $ .45
Grinding cost of 8 tools—2/3 of .45 or .......++++- $ .30
Assuming 500 shafts per set of 8 tools, grinding cost
of tools per each T-410 shaft ($.30 — 500) ...... .00060
Total cost per T-410 shaft .....----seeeeeeeeeees .00087
A-6250 — 1.14640 x T-410 ....... cece cece eee eeeees .00100
F-446 — 1.85287 x T-410 20... cece e cece eee eeeees .00161
Cc}
ae |
“A> ‘ON LIGIHX] SSSILNIVI
SBOVAOVd GNV SZLON gO AMZAITAG AHL 40d WIGVIVAVY BZAV SUAONASSAW NOINN NAAZLSaM
re WHOAWL «O ALZALTICC GuOdai «salon
ej WAGNSS OHO
TEVHOIN ONV VHUVAVHON HSHOST TIVNCAH WILLS
HINGLENIN sOXMONOL ATHY LOadKE TIwus dOls
AMVGROO MNCK HSI" LM WIWLAS AO SAILITIAISsOd SSAC I~ CL SKEWHCLAV MOK
HLTH SONTETS C7 AGSCACHA SINS wLIL OLICMONd Tdedad LNG OVITIG Cou AC Yau
Suldvd dOls ANVAMOO UNOA LSNIVOV LINE FIIs Of GHLONVLSAT NBs FAVA del
* THA Ns UO ROMEO TL GAY GBYd UCL STINVANOO TTIAONCLAY U.HLO ANY SHO ox
QVMESS HOIs. LNIMATLLSS ONAN TONCO GYH WENMC LNGLVd ANVENCO FLY Mog
WOMMOS STVSddV JO LUNCS LINOWIO HIXIS C= VOICAPCY CNY SBHIVT Live. Ve CZ
ONLLYT2U NUWHL JHONVN LHOIS O8L uNCs BATA INO VEANAN LNadVt xccio
NYDIHCI” J IOULS”
THO. RYN NOTIN DL
KNVINOD UOLS CHCS
SE tN,
GEE Oc6l ST MEGMZAON NISNOOSIN FILIVATIN
paw oy poesBe Aqasay 210 yonyen ‘foasy 3209 wo musa} 2y) 4 Profgne “aBoesous Bupno]]of *Y) PUPS
AMBOISBUE-ED1A 18U14 “MBAR TUM DS 2 4M2G1SBUE “NOLIBYS BHOOMEN ONeounuwOD
Mery) F 6s porriweTes
- ao}Aso8 40 S8B]9 9909 Pinoys eudsIe
a31l4 3WiL 31137 e3u37
ON3 ¥33™ LHOIN
' PESTER) 3OvVSS3IW
376v) LHOIN
: BHD ’ 03443430 34137 AWD
| | NY “A S “A Bava W143 wvso3734
.
94d uO HSvD]| “ON S sussas=
Ww sect .
§SBO 3I1ABIS 40 SEV?
pe
APE OGM D LIL ELE BEA
MEE RLS WL ILLES ORES LE PORI NS SIRS REG NEA
eee
WO ON LISIHXI SdILLNIVE
VIAv) "%O HAVUDATAL Ad SI AANOW GNAS OL AVM LSHIVS GNV Lets fein > WHEL
SpObRMKaG SL SSA
=Wd OZ BMIM BLWALYHd BIAO G38Zh1 134 95 sOL0% Tdds sMOA
=n3s IT o UNInsvV
siete, =15VHOIW F VEWAWRON Banos) Wendin ahllos
HP d9S_ Sb HIN LIGgL35G=LISTWI xi FobtV
OF sim ‘commer “SPIg TVET “VEN “PIA Ftd Ie P2A1oI0H
GEL, CEVCNV 195 ‘stem gs 60 mney = SeRSERND 3 ipees jp Sum on POR Some Sup PR SuPRCBUNm evRrR) Sw SRP Ou WR HY TL PONE PAL _
r—_ ti pene ses NOLEN? SROIM EN | . XN
soupre aya Fut
NOINS2} ett
apyrans © AQ Poeoip
“ull sagnesey> poss 33
“op sat ssayun wes
“Qe 20 Wests]
, NUALSAM boc
.3 GLI DMINWEONOO RULLSZDONS GNV WSIDLLIUD AG ANVdWOD JHL MOAV4A OL GALSAIONGU AUV SNOULYd
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT RR
———_—__—-
THE GORDON FORM LATHE Co.
AGREEMENT FILE
MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT made and en-
tered into by and between GORDON FORM LATHE
COMPANY, an Ohio Corporation, hereinafter called
“GORDON”, and CHRYSLER CORPORATION, a Dela-
ware corporation, hereinafter called ‘‘CHRYSLER’’.
WITNESSETH
Wuereas, Gordon is the owner of the entire right, title
and interest ir and to Letters Patent of the United States
No. 1,542,803, dated June 16, 1925, covering an improved
Lathe; and
Wuereas, in an action entitled ‘‘Gordon Form Lathe
Company versus Walcott Machine Company”’, decided
by the United States Cireuit Court of Appeals for the
Sixth Cireuit on April 12, 1929, said patent as to certain
of its claims was held valid and infringed by certain cam
turning and crank shaft contour lathes heretofore manu-
factured and sold by the Walcott Machine Company of
Jackson, Michigan; and
Wuereas, Chrysler Corporation has heretofore pur-
chased and used, and is now using certain of said in-
fringing lathes manufactured by the said Walcott Ma-
chine Company and now desires to free and release said
lathes for the future from infringement of said Letters
Patent.
Now, Tuenerore, for and in consideration of One Dol-
lar ($1.00) by each of the parties to the other in hand
paid, receipt whereof is hereby acknowledged, and other
valuable considerations, each of the parties to the other
moving, the said parties have covenanted and agreed as
follows :
First: Gordon hereby releases and frees from in-
fringement of said Letters Patent of the United States
No. 1,542,803, the hereinafter identified cam _ turning
lathes, now in the possession of said Chrysler Corpora-
tion, said release to take effect as of April 12, 1929, and
to continue throughout the life of said lathes; the lathes
so released being the following :
(CurysLter NUMBER Maxker’s Serta, NuMBER
C. M. 3553 127
C. M. 3016 101
C. M. 5805 182
H. 837 200
H. 838 202
H. 2841 213
E. 3155 53
E. 4564 136
9860 65
9920 57
10141 55
10150 54
11635 89
13035 126
17079 161
17112 162
Seconp: Gordon agrees that it will issue a similar li-
ecense unto Chrysler for such other and further machines
as Chrysler may acquire and request a license for upon
payment by Chrysler to Gordon of the sum of Three
Thousand Dollars ($3,000) for each such machine; pro-
vided, however, that if any such machine shall be in-
tended for use upon shafts for less than six cylinder
machines, the payment required shall be only Two Thou-
sand Dollars ($2,000) per machine.
Tup: In consideration of the foregoing release, the
said Chrysler Corporation agrees to pay Gordon, upon
execution of this agreement, the sum of Forty Six Thou-
sand Dollars ($46,000), such payment being at the rate
of Three Thousand Dollars ($3,000) per lathe, except as
to machine numbers 9860 and 9920, which are intended
for use in turning cam shafts for four cylinder engines,
the rate for such machines being Two Thousand Dollars
($2,000) each, and in addition to grant Gordon a non-
exclusive, non-assignable license under Letters Patent of
the United States No. 1,246,191, dated November 13, 1917.
Fourtu: it is distinctly understood and agreed that
the release under clause First hereof applies only to the
use of said lathes subsequent to the effective date of said
release, viz:—April 12, 1929; Gordon expressly reserving
unto itself, its suecessors and assigns, any and all claims
it now has, or may hereafter acquire, for, or arising out
or by reason of the infringement of its said patent by the
said Chrysler Corporation through the use of said lathes
or any other infringing lathes at or during any time prior
to April 13, 1929.
Firtn: It is further agreed that in the event of litiga-
tion directed to a recovery for infringement of said pat-
ent No. 1,542,803 prior to April 13, 1929, neither party
hereto shall in any wise use this agreement as affecting
the measure of damages for such infringement.
Sixt: It is further agreed that Gordon, or its duly
appointed representative or attorney, shall have access
to the manufacturing plants of Chrysler following the
execution of this agreement for the purpose of verifying
the number of infringing lathes in use or in the posses-
sion of said Chrysler Corporation and the identifying
markings thereon, as set forth under clause First hereof.
Seventu: The said Chrysler Corporation acknowledges
and acquiesces in the validity of said Letters Patent No.
1,542,803, but only as to those claims sustained in said
litigation, and covenants and agrees that it will not in
any proceeding, either in equity or at law, directly or
indirectly, deny or contest its validity or assert its in-
validity.
1929
Ercutx: Gordon further agrees that it will not grant
a similar license or release to any other person, firm or
corporation for a sum of money less than that herein
agreed upon per machine; it being understood and agreed
that if this undertaking shall be violated, then Chrysler
shall be entitled to a similar rate both as to machines
herein enumerated and as to any other machines which
it may hereafter request license for.
Nintu: It is mutually understood and agreed by and
between the parties that in the event said patent No.
1,542,803 shall be sold or otherwise disposed of to any
person, firm or corporation for the benefit or in consid-
eration of money furnished by any group of automotive
manufacturers, Chrysler shall be given an opportunity to
join with said group of automotive manufacturers, and
to apply any moneys paid to Gordon under the terms
of this agreement toward the purchase price of said
patent; it being understood, however, that in the event
Chrysler shall elect to so join with such group of manv-
facturers and have said moneys applied to said purchase
price, then the license and release herein granted shall
be void and of no effect.
Tentu: This agreement shall be binding upon and
inure to the benefit of the respective successors and as-
signs of the parties hereto.
Signed, sealed and delivered this 17th day of July,
1929.
GORDON FORM LATHE COMPANY
Attest: By Cxas, Gorpon,
~caancemaransansesnronernTisre0e” President.
Secretary.
CHRYSLER CORPORATION
Attest: By K. T. Kewzer,
—_ Morrison, Vice President.
Secretary.
Copy December 16, 1929
The White Motor Company,
842 E. 79th Street,
Cleveland, Ohio.
Attention—Mr. Cooper
RE: Gordon Cam Lathe Patent
Dear Mr. Cooper:
I have been expecting to hear from you on the matter
of settlement which we discussed in Mr. Richey’s office
some few weeks ago. We have now instituted some suits
and are preparing to extend our activities in that direc-
tion and would like to have a definite expression from
you as to what The White Company proposes to do in
the matter.
Very truly yours,
BOTTUM HUDNALL LECHER
MeNAMARA & MICHAEL
By
JWM HH
7s 9
#HH
LJB
7/19/38
Copy
THE WHITE MOTOR COMPANY
Manufacturers of
WHITE TRUCKS AND BUSSES
Warrer ©. Waite, President
Grorce H. Ketty, Treasurer
T. R. Dan, Secretary
Cleveland, Ohio
December 24, 1929.
Mr. J. W. Michael,
Bottum, Hudnall, Lecher, McNamara & Michael
Trust Company Building,
Milwaukee, Wis.
Re: Gordon Cam Lathe Patent
Dear Sir:
Your letter of December 16, 1929, has been received.
We would like to effect a settlement both for the past
and the future, and are herewith submitting the data
which you requested during our discussion of this sub-
ject in Mr. Richey’s office.
Number of crankshaft contour machines
owned by the White Motor Company...
Number of cam cutting machines owned
by the White Motor Company... 2
(Both of the 4-cylinder camshaft type)
Number of cams cut prior to July 1, 1925 0
Number of cams cut from July 1, 1925, to
June 12, 1929 (37,919 camshafts)..........803,352
Number of cams cut from June 12, 1929,
to Dec. 21, 1929 (3,013 camshafts ).......++ 24,104
We do not believe that we were given proper and ade-
quate notice of infringement prior to June 12, 1929, but
in order to effect an early and complete settlement of
this matter we are willing to pay the Gordon Form Lathe
Company the sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5,000),
the same to cover both past damages and the future re-
lease of our two machines.
Please let us have an early reply.
Yours very truly,
THE WHITE MOTOR COMPANY
/s/ R. M. Cooper
Patent Engineer.
R. M. Cooper
RMC:hb
Copy
December 27, 1929
The White Motor Company,
842 E. 79th Street,
Cleveland, Ohio.
Attention—Mr. R. N. Cooper, Patent Engineer
Dear Mr. Cooper:
In view of agreements, both executed and pending, we
are not in a position to release your infringing machines
for less than the sum of $2,000.00 per each 4-cylinder
cam shaft type nor, in respect of the past, are we in a
position to accept less than *%ths of a cent per cam.
Your present offer of $5,000.00, as embodied in your
letter of December 24th, covers the $2,000.00 release for
each of the two machines you report but only leaves
$1,000.00 to apply on the past, which figures about 1/3
of a cent per cam. At %4ths of a cent per cam, the total
amount, including the release of each machine and the
past, would, on the statement you have submitted, amount
to $6,455.92.
We are agreeable to settling the matter with you on
this basis to cover both the past and the release of the
machines for the future or, if you prefer, are agreeable
to releasing your two machines on the basis of $2,000.00
per machine and reserving the past for future determina.
tion.
We have every reason to believe that %4ths of a cent
per cam is but a very small percentage of the actual
savings resulting from the use of the Gordon invention.
Please let us hear from you promptly.
Very truly yours,
BOTTUM HUDNALL LECHER
MceNAMARA & MICHAEL
By
JWM HH
c. c. to Mr. Richey and
Mr. Gordon
1535
Copy
THE WHITE MOTOR COMPANY
Manufacturers of
WHITE TRUCKS AND BUSSES
Water C. Waite, President
Greorck H. Ke.iy, Treasurer
T. R. Danw, Secretary
Cleveland, Ohio
January 16, 1930.
Mr. J. W. Michael
Bottum, Hudnall, Lecher, McNamara & Michael
Milwankee, Wisconsin.
Re: Gordon Cam Lathe Patents
Dear Sir:
We have decided, in case we can secure a satisfactory
agreement, to accept your offer to release our two ma-
chines on the basis of Two Thousand Dollars ($2,000)
per machine, leaving the matter of past infringement for
future determination. We, therefore, request that you
submit to us an agreement covering such release.
An agreement similar to the one which the Gordon
Form Lathe Company executed with the Chrysler Cor-
poration will be acceptable to us, with the addition of a
clause which will permit us upon payment of an addi-
tional One Thousand Dollars ($1,000) per machine to
convert either or both of our machines into machines
for use upon shafts for six or more cylinder engines.
Yours very truly,
THE WHITE MOTOR COMPANY
/s/ BR. M. Cooper
R. M. Cooper
RMC:hb Patent Engineer.
ec—Messrs. Church
Dahl
36
(Copy)
January 18th,
1930
The White Motor Company
Cleveland
Ohio
Attention—R. M. Cooper, Patent Engineer.
Gentlemen :
Replying to your letter of January 16th, we have
prepared and enclose an agreement covering the re-
lease of your two machines.
While we are quite willing, as stated in one of our
previous letters, to leave the matter of past infringe-
ment for future determination, we feel that you should
know that we will be unwilling to settle with you for
the past on the 3/4ths of a cent basis if we are forced
to file suit. In such event, we shall insist upon and en-
deavor to collect all that the law allows, which, accord-
ing to our calculations, is substantially greater than the
rate of 3/4ths of a cent per cam.
Please execute both copies of the agreement and
return to us with your check for Four Thousand ($4,-
000.00) Dollars. We shall then have the agreement
executed by the Gordon Form Lathe Company and
one copy returned to you.
Very truly yours,
BOTTUM HUDNALL LECHER
McNAMARA & MICHAEL
By:
JWM HH
encls.
THE WHITE MOTOR COMPANY
Manufacturers of
WHITE TRUCKS AND BUSSES
Watter C. Wuire, President
Georcek H. Ketiy, Treasurer
T, R. Daut, Secretary
Cleveland, Ohio
February 4, 1930.
Mr. J. W. Michael
Bottum, Hudnall, Lecher, McNamara & Michael
Milwaukee, Wisconsin.
Dear Sir:
Please find herewith, duly executed by us, two copies
of an agreement for the future release of our two cam
turning machines.
Please also find enclosed two copies of an agree-
ment releasing us from all claims and demands for past
infringement.
The enclosed agreements are identical with the agree-
ments submitted to us, except that the agreement for
the future release of our two machines has been amended,
for the purpose of eliminating an intervening period
between the effective dates of the two agreements, to
become effective on the same date as the agreement
releasing us from past infringement, viz., December 21,
1929.
We believe that the above amendment will meet with
your approval, and are enclosing herewith our check
for Six Thousand Four Hundred Fifty-five Dollars and
1537
ninety-two cents ($6,455.92), the sum of the amounts
set forth in the two agreements.
Yours very truly,
THE WHITE MOTOR COMPANY
/s/ RR. M. Cooper
R. M. Cooper
Patent Engineer.
RMC :hb
Enes.
(Copy)
February 8th, 1930.
Tue Waite Motor Company
Cleveland
Ohio
Attention—Mr. Cooper, Patent Engineer
re: Gordon Patent
Gentlemen:
Your letter of February 4th, enclosing signed agree-
ments and check in the above matter, was duly re-
ceived.
The agreement and the release for the past have
now been executed by The Gordon Form Lathe Com-
pany and the originals thereof are enclosed to you
herewith. The executed duplicates are retained for
onr files.
The Secretary of The Gordon Company is located
in Cincinnati and we have not deemed it necessary to
forward the papers to him for signature, but will do
so if you insist. The Secretary’s signature has not
appeared on previous agreements of the same char-
acter and, of course, is not necessary.
Thanking you for your cooperation in this matter,
we remain,
Very truly yours,
BOTTUM HUDNALL LECHER
MeNAMARA & MICHAEL
JWM HH By:
Encl.
(Copy)
THE WHITE MOTOR COMPANY
Manufacturers of
WHITE TRUCKS AND BUSSES
Warter C. Wuire, President
Georce H. Ketiy, Treasurer
T. R. Dant, Secretary
Cleveland, Ohio
February 12, 1930,
Mr. J. W. Michael
Bottum, Hudnall, Lecher, McNamara & Michael
Milwaukee, Wisconsin.
Re: Past and future infringement of the
Gordon Patent 1,542,803
Dear Sir:
This will acknowledge the receipt of your letter of
February 8th, enclosing executed copies of the Agree-
ment and Release in the above matter.
Yours very truly,
THE WHITE MOTOR COMPANY
/s/ R. M. Cooper
R. M. Cooper
RMC :hb Patent Engineer.
#4G
LJB
7/19/38
FOR AND IN CONSIDERATION of Twenty-four
Hundred Fifty-five Dollars and Ninety-two Cents
($2,455.92), the undersigned, GORDON FORM LATHE
COMPANY, an Ohio Corporation, owner of the entire
right, title and interest in and to Letters Patent of the
United States No. 1,542,803, dated June 16th, 1925, cov-
ering au improved Lathe, hereby releases and forever
discharges THE WHITE MOTOR COMPANY, an Ohio
Corporation of Cleveland, Ohio, from all claims and de-
mands for past infringement of said patent No. 1,542,803,
by reason of its use and the Two (2) 4-cylinder cam
shaft type infringing lathes identified in Agreement of
even date herewith, releasing said machines for future
use.
Datep this 21st day of December, 1929.
GORDON FORM LATHE COMPANY
By Cxas. Gorpon,
President.
MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT made and en-
tered into by and between GORDON FORM LATHE
COMPANY, an Ohio Corporation, hereinafter called
“GORDON”, and THE WHITE MOTOR COMPANY,
an Ohio Corporation, hereinafter called ‘‘WHITE”’.
WITNESSETH
Wuereas, Gordon is the owner of the entire right,
title and interest in and to Letters Patent of the United
States No. 1,542,803, dated June 16, 1925, covering an
improved lathe; and
Wuenreas, in an action entitled ‘‘Gordon Form Lathe
Company versus Walcott Machine Company’’, decided
by the United States Cireuit Court of Appeals for the
Sixth Cireuit on April 12, 1929, said patent as to cer-
tain of its claims was held valid and infringed by certain
cam turning and crank shaft contour lathes heretofore
manufactured and sold by the Walcott Machine Com-
pany of Jackson, Michigan; and
Wuereas, White has heretofore purchased and used,
and is now using certain of said infringing lathes manu-
factured by the said Walcott Machine Company and now
desires to free and release said lathes for the future
from infringement of said Letters Patent.
Now, Tuererore, for and in consideration of One
Dollar ($1.00) by each of the parties to the other in
hand paid, receipt whereof is hereby acknowledged, and
other valuable considerations, each of the parties to the
other moving, the said parties have covenanted and
agreed as follows:
First: Upon the representation of White that the in-
fringing lathes it desires to free and release are for
use only upon cam shafts for less than 6-cylinder en-
gines, Gordon hereby releases and frees from infringe-
ment of said Letters Patent of the United States No.
1,542,803 at the rate hereinafter specified, the following
identified cam turning lathes now in the possession of
White, said release to take effect as of December 21,
1929, and to continue throughout the life of said lathes:
Wurite NumBEr Maker’s SerraL NUMBER
2582 134
1912 157
Seconp: Gordon agrees that it will issue a similar li-
cense unto White for such other and further machines as
White may acquire and request a license for upon pay-
ment by White to Gordon of the sum of Three Thousand
($3,000.00) Dollars for each such machine for use upon
cam shafts for six (6) or more cylinder engines and
Two Thousand ($2,000.00) Dollars for each such machine
for use upon cam shafts for less than 6-cylinder engines.
1541
Tutrp: In consideration of the foregoing release, White
agrees to pay Gordon, upon execution of this agreement,
the sum of Four Thousand ($4,000.00) Dollars, such pay-
ment being at the rate of Two Thousand ($2,000.00) Dol-
lars per lathe. It is agreed that White may convert
either or both of said machines into machines for use
upon cam shafts for six (6) or more cylinder engines
upon payment of an additional One Thousand ($1,000.00)
Dollars per machine and White agrees that in the event
of conversion, it will make such additional payment unto
Gordon within Twenty (20) days following the conver-
sion.
Fourtu: It is distinctly understood and agreed that
the release under Clause First hereof applies only to the
use of said lathes subsequent to the date of execution
hereof; Gordon expressly reserving unto itself, its suc-
cessors and assigns any and all claims it now has or may
hereafter acquire, for, or arising out or by reason of the
infringement of its patent by White through the use of
said lathes or any other infringing lathes at or during
any time prior to the date hereof.
Fier: It is further agreed that in the event of litiga-
tion directed to a recovery for infringement of said
patent No. 1,542,803 prior to the date hereof, neither
party hereto shall in any wise use this agreement as
affecting the measure of damages for such infringement.
Sixtu: It is further agreed that Gordon, or its duly
appointed representative or attorney, shall have access
to the manufacturing plants of White, following the exe-
cution of this agreement, for the purpose of verifying
the number of infringing lathes in use or in the posses-
sion of White and the identifying markings thereon as
set forth under Clause First hereof.
SeventH: White acknowledges and acquiesces in the
validity of said Letters Patent No. 1,542,803, but only as
to those claims sustained in said litigation, and coven-
ants and agrees that it will not in any proceeding, either
in equity or at law, directly or indirectly, deny or con-
test its validity or assert its invalidity.
EicutH: Gordon further agrees that it will not grant
a similar license or release to any other person, firm or
corporation for a sum of money less than that herein
agreed upon per machine; it being understood and agreed
that if this undertaking shall be violated, then White
shall be entitled to a similar rate, b.th as to machines
herein enumerated and as to any other machines which
it may hereafter request license for.
Nisto: It is mutually understood and agreed by and
between the parties that in the event said patent No.
1,542,803 shall be sold or otherwise disposed of to any
person, firm or corporation for the benefit or in consid-
. eration of money furnished by any group of automotive
manufacturers, White shall be given an opportunity to
join with said group of automotive manufacturers, and
to apply any moneys paid to Gordon under the terms of
this agreement toward the purchase price of said pat-
ent; it being understood, however, that in the event
White shall elect to so join such group of manufactur-
ers and have said moneys applied to said put hase price,
then the license and release herein granted shall be void
and of no effect.
TentH: This agreement shall be binding upon and
inure to the benefit of the respective successors and as-
signs of the parties hereto.
Signed, sealed and delivered this 6th day of February,
1930.
GORDON FORM LATHE COMPANY
Attest:
tina abdieteesiinennesneni By Cuas. Gorpon,
Secretary. President.
Attest: THE WHITE MOTOR COMPANY
est:
T. R. Daun, By Saunpers Jongs,
Secretary. Vice President.
1543
MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT made and en.
tered into by and between GORDON FORM LATHE
COMPANY, an Ohio Corporation, hereinafter called
‘“GORDON”’, and J. I. CASE COMPANY, a Wisconsin
Corporation, hereinafter called ‘‘CASEH”’.
WITNESSETH
Wuereas, Gordon is the owner of the entire right,
title and interest in and to Letters Patent of the United
States No. 1,542,803, dated June 16, 1925, covering an
improved lathe; and
Wuereas, in an action entitled ‘‘Gordon Form Lathe
Company versus Walcott Machine Company’’, decided by
the United States Cireuit Court of Appeals for the Sixth
Cireuit on April 12, 1929, said patent as to certain of its
claims was held valid and infringed by certain cam turn-
ing and crank shaft contour lathes heretofore manufac-
tured and sold by the Walcott Machine Company of
Jackson, Michigan; and
Wuereas, Case has heretofore purchased and used, and
is now using certain of said infringing lathes manufac-
tured by the said Walcott Machine Company and now
desires to free and release said lathes for the future from
infringement of said Letters Patent.
Now, Trererore, for and in consideration of One Dol-
lar ($1.00) by each of the parties to the other in hand
paid, receipt whereof is hereby acknowledged, and other
valuable considerations, each of the parties to the other
moving, the said parties have covenanted and agreed as
follows:
First: Upon the representation of Case that the in-
fringing lathes it desires to free and release are for use
only upon cam shafts for less than 6-cylinder engines,
Gordon hereby releases and frees from infringement of
said Letters Patent of the United States No. 1,542,803
at the rate hereinafter specified, the following identified
cam turning lathes now in the possession of Case, said
release to take effect as of February 18th, 1930, and to
continue throughout the life of said lathes:
Case NuMBER Maker’s Serta, NuMBER
SW 5081 209
SW 5227 221
Seconp: Gordon agrees that it will issue a similar
license unto Case for such other and further machines as
Case may acquire and request a license for upon payment
by Case to Gordon of the sum of Three Thousand
($3,000.00) Dollars for each such machine for use upon
cam shafts for six (6) or more cylinder engines and
Two Thousand ($2,000.00) Dollars for each such machine
for use upon cam shafts for less than 6-cylinder engines.
Tump: In consideration of the foregoing release, Case
agrees to pay Gordon, upon execution of this agreement,
the sum of Four Thousand ($4,000.00) Dollars, such pay-
ment being at the rate of Two Thousand ($2,000.00) Dol-
lars per lathe. It is agreed that Case may convert either
or both of said machines into machines for use upon
cam shafts for six (6) or more cylinder engines upon
payment of an additional One Thousand ($1,000.00) Dol-
lars per machine and Case agrees that in the event of
conversion, it will make such additional payment unto
Gordon within Twenty (20) days following the conver-
sion.
Fourtu: It is distinctly understood and agreed that
the release under Clause Fist hereof applies only to the
use of said lathes subsequent to the date of execution
hereof; Gordon expressly reserving unto itself, its suc-
cessors and assigns any and all claims it now has or may
hereafter acquire, for, or arising out or by reason of the
infringement of its patent by Case through the use of
said lathes or any other infringing lathes at or during
any time prior to the date hereof.
Firra: It is further agreed that in the event of liti-
gation directed to a recovery for infringement of said
patent No. 1,542,803 prior to the date hereof, neither
party hereto shall in any wise use this agreement as
affecting the measure of damages for such infringement.
Sixtu: It is further agreed that Gordon, or its duly
appointed representative or attorney, shall have access
to the manufacturing plants of Case, following the execu-
tion of this agreement, for the purpose of verifying the
number of infringing lathes in use or in the possession
of Case and the identifying markings thereon as set forth
under Clause Finst hereof.
SeventH: Case acknowledges and acquiesces in the
validity of said Letters Patent No. 1,542,803, but only as
to those claims sustained in said litigation, and coven-
ants and agrees that it will not in any proceeding, either
in equity or at law, directly or indirectly, deny or con-
test its validity or assert its invalidity.
Kicuta: Gordon further agrees that it will not grant
a similar license or release to any other person, firm or
corporation for a sum of money less than that herein
agreed upon per machine; it being understood and agreed
that if this undertaking shall be violated, then Case shall
be entitled to a similar rate, both as to machines herein
enumerated and as to any other machines which it may
hereafter request license for.
Nixta: It is mutually understood and agreed by and
between the parties that in the event said patent No.
1,542,803 shall be sold or otherwise disposed of to any
person, firm or corporation for the benefit or in con-
sideration of money furnished by any group of automo-
tive manufacturers, Case shall be given an opportunity
to join with said group of automotive manufacturers,
and to apply any moneys paid to Gordon under the terms
of this agreement toward the purchase price of said
patent; it being understood, however, that in the event
Case shall elect to so join with such group of manufae-
turers and have said moneys applied to said purchase
price, then the license and release herein granted shall
be void and of no effect.
Tento: This agreement shall be binding upon and
inure to the benefit of the respective successors and as-
signs of the parties hereto.
Signed, sealed and delivered this 18th day of Febru-
ary, 1930.
GORDON FORM LATHE COMPANY
By Cuas. Gorpon,
President.
Attest: J. I. CASE COMPANY
TuEo. JOHNSON, By Jos. Bieoert,
Secretary. Vice President.
Also introduced as
Ex. FF
LJB
7/19/38
For anp 1x Constveration of Ten Hundred Fifty-five
Dollars and Twenty-eight Cents ($1,055.28), figuied at
the rate of *4ths of a cent per cam on a total production
of 140,704 cams turned on infringing machines interven-
ing between November 22nd, 1928, the date of the first
installation, and February 18th, 1930, the date of this
release, the undersigned, The Gordon Form Lathe Com-
pany, an Ohio Corporation, owner of the entire right,
title and interest in and to Letters Patent of the United
States No. 1,542,803, dated June 16th, 1925, covering an
improved lathe, hereby releases and forever discharges
the J. I. Case Company, a Wisconsin Corporation of Ra-
cine, Wisconsin, from all claims and demands for past
infringement of said patent by reason of its use of the
Sa
18
Two (2) four-cylinder cam shaft type infringing lathes
identified in an agreement of even date herewith, re.
leasing said machines for future use.
Datep this 18th day of February, 1930.
GORDON FORM LATHE COMPANY
By Cuas. Gorpon,
President.
MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT made and en.
tered into by and between GORDON FORM LATHE
COMPANY, an Ohio corporation, hereinafter called
‘““GORDON’”’, and THE NASH MOTORS COMPANY, a
Maryland corporation, hereinafter called ‘‘NASH’’,
WITNESSETH :
Wuenreas, Gordon is the owner of the entire right, title
and interest in and to Letters Patent of the United States
No. 1,542,803, dated June 16, 1925, covering an improved
Lathe; and
Whereas, in an action entitled ‘‘Gordon Form Lathe
Company versus Walcott Machine Company’’, decided by
the United States Cireuit Court of Appeals for the Sixth
Cireuit on April 12, 1929, said patent as to certain of its
claims was held valid and infringed by certain cam turn-
ing and crank shaft contour lathes heretofore manufac-
tured and sold by the Waleott Machine Company of
Jackson, Michigan; and
Wuereas, Nash has heretofore purchasec and used and
is now using certain Lathes manufactured by the said
Walcott Machine Company employing the construction
referred to in the decision above described and now de-
sires to free and release said Lathes for the future from
any claim of infringement of said Letters Patent.
Now, THEREFORE, for and in consideration of One
Dollar ($1.00) by each of the parties to t
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.