Petition for Writ of Certiorari — Jorge Robles-Avalos, Petitioner v. United States

Supreme Court briefOct 10, 2018

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

APPENDIX A

United States v. Robles-Avalos,

No. 17-50633 (5th Cir. July 12, 2018)

Case: 17-50633

Document: 00514552895

Page: 1

Date Filed: 07/12/2018

IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE FIFTH CIRCUIT

United States Court of Appeals

Fifth Circuit

No. 17-50633

Lyle W. Cayce

Clerk

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,

Plaintiff–Appellee,

versus

JORGE ROBLES-AVALOS,

Defendant–Appellant.

* * * * * *

No. 17-51037

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,

Plaintiff–Appellee,

versus

FILED

July 12, 2018

ISMAEL GUEVARA-LOPEZ,

Defendant–Appellant.

Appeals from the United States District Court

for the Western District of Texas

Case: 17-50633

Document: 00514552895

Page: 2

Date Filed: 07/12/2018

No. 17-50633

No. 17-51037

Before SMITH, WIENER, and WILLETT, Circuit Judges.

JERRY E. SMITH, Circuit Judge:

In this consolidated action, Jorge Robles-Avalos and Ismael GuevaraLopez appeal their convictions on the sole ground that their traffic stop lacked

reasonable suspicion. We find no error and affirm.

I.

Defendants were passengers in a car stopped by Border Patrol Agent

Barry McLain while he was on roving patrol west of Marfa, Texas. McLain

had been an agent for eight years, all at the Marfa Station. Around midnight,

he saw a Chrysler 300 driving west on U.S. Highway 90. Of the areas he

patrolled, that section of Highway 90 was the most heavily trafficked by

smugglers. The vehicle was driving 45–50 mph in a 75 mph zone, and the

driver tapped the brakes several times as though lost or looking for a place to

pull over.

McLain followed for 15–20 minutes and did not observe any traffic violations or signs of illegal activity. He noted, however, that at that time of night

the road is typically used only by ranchers, there is nothing in the surrounding

area except ranch land, and the Chrysler was not a vehicle he recognized as

belonging to any of the local ranchers.

The vehicle then pulled into Ryan Roadside Park, a small area off the

highway with a couple of picnic tables and a trash can. The park is directly

across from the entrance to the aerostat balloon, a feature of the Tethered

Aerostat Radar System, 1 which is visible from Mexico and has historically been

See Dave Long, CBP’s Eyes in the Sky, U.S. CUSTOMS & BORDER PROTECTION,

https://www.cbp.gov/frontline/frontline-november-aerostats.

1

2

Case: 17-50633

Document: 00514552895

Page: 3

Date Filed: 07/12/2018

No. 17-50633

No. 17-51037

used as a guidepost for those walking illegally across the border. In that area,

there have been multiple apprehensions of those smuggling aliens or controlled

substances. McLain had been involved in three other apprehensions next to

the balloon in the two weeks before the November 17 stop, and other agents in

his office had recently apprehended several additional loads of smugglers.

McLain drove past the parked car at 45–50 mph. He illuminated his

alley light as he passed and saw the female driver standing by the vehicle looking down the highway. He could see through the open driver door and did not

observe any passengers; he likewise did not see anyone else standing near the

car. After passing it, McLain took Farm Road 505 to Highway 166 and parked

to monitor traffic. About a half hour later, he saw the same Chrysler traveling

east on Farm Road 505. It then turned north on Highway 166, which is a scenic

loop and goes to Interstate 10. McLain testified that other than local ranchers,

legitimate traffic never uses this route at night.

When the Chrysler passed McLain’s parked vehicle, his headlights illuminated the interior, and he observed three passengers in the front and several

in the back. McLain thought it strange to see three passengers in the front,

not only because those passengers were not previously with the driver but

because McLain knew the Chrysler 300 had only two bucket seats in the front.

The roadside park is over 100 miles from the border if traveled via public

roads, and McLain did not suspect that the vehicle had originated at the

border. Instead, he surmised that the driver had been waiting for illegal aliens

who had hiked from the border, as the roadside park is only twenty-five miles

from the border as the crow flies. McLain also noted that the driver did not

look his way when she passed him, even though his headlights were on and

shined directly into the vehicle.

3

Case: 17-50633

Document: 00514552895

Page: 4

Date Filed: 07/12/2018

No. 17-50633

No. 17-51037

His suspicion aroused by the sudden appearance of numerous passengers, McLain again began following the Chrysler and ran the plates. The car

was registered to a female in Odessa, Texas, which is a known destination for

illegal aliens and narcotics. McLain testified that the driver was taking an

inconvenient route to Odessa from Marfa. Agents had been able to identify

smugglers because they would pass an officer and then be seen a short time

later coming back after picking up their load. As a result of the high number

of apprehensions, however, smugglers changed their strategy and began picking up the load, going straight, and finding another place to turn. McLain

testified he suspected that might be the case here, based on the driver’s chosen

route to Odessa.

When McLain stopped the car in which defendants were passengers, he

saw backpacks of marihuana on the passengers’ laps. He told the occupants

they were under arrest, and a search of the car revealed 122.42 kilograms of

marihuana between the backpacks and the trunk. A later immigration check

showed that the occupants were illegally in the country.

After being charged, defendants filed a joint motion to suppress. After a

hearing, the magistrate judge issued a recommendation to deny the motion,

which the district court adopted. Defendants conditionally pleaded guilty of

aiding and abetting possession with intent to distribute marihuana under

21 U.S.C. §§ 841(a)(1), (b)(1)(B) and 18 U.S.C. § 2 , reserving an appeal of the

denial of suppression.

II.

For reasonable suspicion to stop a vehicle while on roving patrol, an

agent must be “aware of specific articulable facts, together with rational inferences from those facts, that reasonably warrant suspicion that the vehicle’s

4

Case: 17-50633

Document: 00514552895

Page: 5

Date Filed: 07/12/2018

No. 17-50633

No. 17-51037

occupant is engaged in criminal activity.” 2 The district court found this test

satisfied, as do we.

A.

We review the district court’s findings of fact for clear error and its conclusions of law de novo. United States v. Hernandez-Mandujano, 721 F.3d 345,

348 (5th Cir. 2013). The facts are uncontested and must be viewed in the light

most favorable to the prevailing party, here, the government. United States v.

Ibarra, 493 F.3d 526, 530 (5th Cir. 2007).

B.

In United States v. Brignoni-Ponce, 422 U.S. 873, 884−85 (1975), the

Court outlined factors to consider for reasonable suspicion. This circuit has

distilled from that case several relevant considerations, including

(1) the area’s proximity to the border; (2) the characteristics of the

area; (3) usual traffic patterns; (4) the agents’ experience in detecting illegal activity; (5) the driver’s behavior; (6) the aspects or characteristics of the vehicle; (7) information about recent illegal trafficking of aliens or narcotics in the area; and (8) the number of

passengers and their appearance and behavior.

United States v. Olivares-Pacheco, 633 F.3d 399, 402 (5th Cir. 2011).

Instead of looking at the factors as a checklist, we examine the “totality

of the circumstances” to see whether the agent had a “particularized and objective basis” for his suspicion. 3 He is permitted to “draw on [his] own experience

and specialized training to make inferences from and deductions about the

cumulative information available to [him] that ‘might well elude an untrained

2 United States v. Soto, 649 F.3d 406, 409 (5th Cir. 2011) (quoting United States v.

Jacquinot, 258 F.3d 423, 427 (5th Cir. 2001)).

3 United States v. Arvizu, 534 U.S. 266, 273 (2002) (quoting United States v. Cortez,

449 U.S. 411, 417 (1981)).

5

Case: 17-50633

Document: 00514552895

Page: 6

Date Filed: 07/12/2018

No. 17-50633

No. 17-51037

person.’” Id. (quoting Cortez, 449 U.S. at 418).

The totality of the circumstances supports the denial of the motion to

suppress. When a route is commonly known to be used for smuggling, that

weighs in favor of reasonable suspicion.

United States v. Zapata-Ibarra,

212 F.3d 877, 881 (5th Cir. 2000). McLain testified that, having patrolled the

relevant area for eight years, he knew that the stretch of Highway 90 near the

aerostat balloon is a frequently used pickup spot. He had made three other

arrests there in the previous two weeks and knew of several more by other

officers.

When combined with other factors, it also contributes to the reasonablesuspicion analysis that it was midnight. See United States v. Chavez-Chavez,

205 F.3d 145, 148–49 (5th Cir. 2000). The only usual traffic at that time of

night is local ranch vehicles, and McLain, though admitting he did not know

every local vehicle, did not recognize the Chrysler. And a sedan stood out from

the typical truck or SUV used by ranchers. 4

Further, the driver was going well below the posted speed limit, was tapping the brakes as though lost or searching for something along the road,

pulled over at a known pickup point, and looked into the distance. Then, when

McLain again saw the vehicle a short time later, numerous additional passengers had appeared. The first factor of proximity to the border is not satisfied,

but its absence is outweighed by the presence of other articulable facts that,

together, adequately support reasonable suspicion. See United States v. Inocencio, 40 F.3d 716, 722–23 (5th Cir. 1994). Moreover, as noted, the hiking

distance from the border was only twenty-five miles.

4 See Zapata-Ibarra, 212 F.3d at 883–84 (finding that nonlocal traffic on a secondary

road at an unusual time is suspicious).

6

Case: 17-50633

Document: 00514552895

Page: 7

Date Filed: 07/12/2018

No. 17-50633

No. 17-51037

Although many of the individual factors here may be innocent enough

when seen in isolation, we are satisfied, viewing the totality of the circumstances in the light most favorable to the government, that the stop was supported by reasonable suspicion. 5 The judgment of conviction is AFFIRMED.

Olivares-Pacheco, 633 F.3d at 402 (“Factors that ordinarily constitute innocent

behavior may provide a composite picture sufficient to raise reasonable suspicion in the

minds of experienced officers.”) (quoting United States v. Jacquinot, 258 F.3d 423, 427−28

(5th Cir. 2001)).

5

7

APPENDIX B

Map of the Stop Area

Case:

17-50633

Document:

00514371000

Page:

Case

4:16-cr-00526-DCG

Document

159-1 Filed

03/02/18

7

Page

Filed:

1 of

4

Date

03/02/2018

APPENDIX

17-50633.377

-iii I:

..-:

I.

II 159-1 Filed 03/02/18 .-Page 2 of 4

Case 4:16-cr-00526-DCG

Document

III

I

I

roa

'n

-

*

4

-

Abeline, AmariHo, Austin,

Beaumont, Belton, Brazosport,

Corpus Christi, Dallas, Del Rio,

Denison,Denton,El Paso,

Ft Worth,Galveston, Houston,

Killeen, Laredo, Longview,

ubbock, Lufkin, Marshall

Nacogdoches, Odessa,

Port Arthur, Rio Grande Valley,

San Angelo, Sari Antonio,

Sherman, Temple, Texarkana,

Tyler,Waco & Wichita Falls

L

r

Li

/'

Major Points Of Interest

Mileage Chart

Parks

Rest Areas

Town & City Index

www unlvorsalmdp cool

titoC"u flIV('l cdl nap Corn

17-50633.378

Cas 4:16-cr-00526-DCG

633

DoçnDocument

fl:O

NArLPage:

Case

43.7QQQ

159-1 Filed

03/02/18

Page

3 of

9

Date

Filed:

C 4

H.P

EL PASO

DeUCily,

-2775

is

ASKS

+

2

Cenkat Tune Zone

HALISK!

LOVING

'jar

2

00000UJPS

i26:r:

62

8

I2SIELPAS0IJ

2i

5

$EEAEVE

SalIFIat

iiio

o

'I

I

I

'

HUDSPETH

49

\

Mentong

s

C(JL8ERSON

'1.

no

9rndlo

$

60

'I

58

II

4

BLANCAMTS.

78

1405..,

I

SIERRA

3J

0

joSI

REEVES

..

(ss

SIerr Dlaoca

J-v

p?v<1

2115/

/

Toyah

I

2

p0.

4..

I

.n.

.

;T

\

............. 13-12 treestone ........... S-IS

........ M-4 Felnburg ........... 5.14

Dokn .............. S-iS

Fresno(6603) ....... U-14

HermIeI0h(393) ...... k6

Dooni(14764) ....... P.21

FIIdaC .............. 5.11

CaIne

iooH .............. 5.11

.............. 6-13

)osn

macnile

V 12

HewIICIISSS) ...... 071

Friendiwood ......... 1-14

Ni5

Fda lowe

mona

(1341)

I 4

1

*

S.

Dodsnn 1115)

OBSERVATORY

),I'

DAVIS

MS

K660o5

XnickubOcker

P tO

Kniopa (739)

C.

'....

....... L.II

Valentine

,

(30541

........... 6-6 Fncot337I4) ........ 84 Hidalgo(7322) ...... P-21 Knott ............... J4

........... U-ie ji (22353 ......... J2 HPdoawa5 ............ T8 Knee Cits ........... M-7

lllggms (425) ........ 1.1-2

Konniusko .......... P-15

)ozier ............... L-4

FulbIinhI ............ u6

iøhisiind ......... if.74 Kosse(497) ......... R11

1,0w.

.

J-1

FolsInar(7I6)

.2.14

Highbaok ........... fl-Il

Knwnlve(2115) ...... V-12

InfIwood ........... P13 Puooit(1553) ........

1.17

I6qIiandPark ...... 19-24 Kresn(825) ...........I-S

)nippingSpriogs ..... P.13 F.msloo ............. 14-n

HIlCowityViIiage...B-27

Krom(1979) ......... 0-7

lnisCol(825( ........ Q

601

ISOlate, ............ v-li

Curls., ............. S-li

kydnn ............. I-li

Galoenvila(15539)

HSisborn(1232( ...... 6-9

((p18(5314) ......... P-13

'.6110(3754)

.

P.9

ati......... e-i

Lulls ........ S-Il Li Firla (0115) ...... 0-21

soran (13747) ....... J2

Gaflafin (311)

no HIIIIOP

HiIsSireVila91 ...... F-Se Li GlorIa ........... 020

510001 ............. 1-6

Galveston (6724?).

V-IS

Hindu ............. 0-IS U Orseigu (4478)

-. 5-14

0uncnnlIo .........

Salade (1915)

.

1

.9-8

............. 0-6

............... K-B

andes

non

nQin Inks (3664) -. . .8-14

4015 Pass (22413) . - - 1-16

......... 0.19

srlh(1109) .......... 1-5

esPy (2598)

eotoavnasd(1725),..T-14

,slCnfambia

U 15

tstMnunlain(500)

U-B

oloaly

............ s-it

inHand (3769)

hOn (624)

- --

-o

GII61OCI

GardeoValhay

0aoleodahe

........ .1-8

........ 0-29

Godendile (1197)

........... S-S

.............. 011

50(2561) ........ Mu

201(600)

Wy

..... 8-26

..... S-I

mbufg (48465).....

dgnCliffViIagn

gnwonvi (1348)

monson (123)

Giry(3o3)

,,

Galeavolo)lfIsnn)

os

Goon et

w

Gleolnon

(922)......

614db

siss

Ghfebriso

Shell

0-12

------------

.............. 0-IS

Candelaria

-

MOUNTAINS

......... 0-17

ypi .............. S-IS

soy (420)

0101,5

-

HoneyGroae(1746)

3.9

HOoln(2973) --------- V-I

0-6

......... 0-13

.............

hars(1215( ....... 1-to

rigor ............ 6-14

Howolon (1853631).. .9-14

Ia Ward (200) ....... S16

......... fl.7

lacoslE (1255) ------ 0-15

Hubbard(1586)

...... A-tn

Hodson (3792)

...... U-Il

159168 ------------ P-li

HudsoaQaks

......... a-n

........... 9-13

LagoVs)a(4507) -- ..P-13

Hoffman

laeunaPa

v.

50

iy

Hutlo)1250)

Hye

00

1-10

Gnldllnwan

1092

0084 lO7

.... 0-li

0-16

000dland ------------ HG

5

......... V9

SI

05001(159)

1-8

......N-li

in n(

........

) -------- P-20

..........

......... 13-6

lmporiol)420( ....... H-Il

Ituadale .............. L-8

IndhanGap .......... pie

ldolnu(2157)

Illinois flood

............... SC

.............. 0-13 G7202...... 0.14

1al

026

a-I?

013

Hutchins

Scnrlo

145

-----------212

GOoddal, (243)

(nplhaemha

----------- 5-16

Indosby (3134)

-osi

s u

.......

rs

fWloeide(0388) ----- ((-18

05151011740)

N 13

fl-I

lola

--------------- 0-12

Gorea)32I) ---------- N-i

Ira

................. ((-8

--

(nsa,, 11239)

--------- J-l2

I

,

-

,içl

(!.PE

ST L T

H

-------- 8-7

T8IIIOQU3

--------- 0-10

Indies -------------

.......... 6-24

.

----

1

I

1,111

HunlersCroekfflbog..F-28

CaSa Pledra

Preokflo

Laliapool(881)-------- V-9

Humble (14579)

-

.4.

6

................ Cool .............. 5-13

11.11

'

-

lIkwJsCblnn (26366). U-lB

soils

.......... n-la

Ladosua (067)

1

-.

Shatter

lJVornil(931) ...... P-lS

Livifte ............ 0-SI

pg

-

S 16

take Dales (6100) . - - - 6.7

in (5100)

Mull

1051111

HorizonCity --------- c)))

-

0101 (3168)

-,

.

HuvUoglow (2068).... v-lI

Lii

I

61

Hoiliday (1632)

........ 1-lU 6)Caw .......... Ml-0 Ho.rlsniIIe(35078).. T-I2

Sane ............. 0-25

Hsdwnod ............

51

R

2122------8-15

:

------------ HUI ............. 0-24

orodo(195I)

Ruldosa

17

..... 0-13

Hungerford(645( ..... 1-14

Camps (10945)

07

LiGfiiihi)121l) ..... 0-21

Holland (1102)

bndio(263)

-1,1 (56)

168

)

............... V-13

5500 ................21

Marat)

/Ue.S1A DEL BURR

1

............ p-is LaJoya(3303) ...... P-21

.......... fl-IS Li Marqoe ......... S-21

1l006187 ............ S-li

LiMarque (13682)... 2-14

14-6

...........

Girard (62)

em (322)

I

HoclihOm

HuçtlasSpriogs(1156)

Sihhhiand

AlpIne

20

Hoboes

Howe(2478)

GeOrge Wont (22

a

PIIESIOlO

22

...... 0-12 Ii PoIson (354) ..... 0-21

....... 0-6 La Pane (31880) ..... 0-14

Garland (215768)

n-s

I.iP.yor(1491) ----- 14-16

HollywovdPaiI, ..... C-27

Gonrinsn(844).... i,-to

I.aReIwilni --------- P20

Hondo)7097( ....... N-IS

Garwood

5-14

Gunner (4;99

no (5809)

..... li-IS

\

I

/Marfa

,

............ (.23

Godaod

.0-9

...........

liftcbcock5)306(

/27

i

.

onCanolhi, (36081)

.-'

1031

I

'

\

.

\

..

I

'._..

)ougIas

.

.A

ST PARK

)o..ghe.ly

,

.r1Fort Davis

MOUNTAINS

6

',

N 15

\

NATL.HJST flICALSITE

74

KirvIn122) ......... S-tn

612

32

g

LakuWanlH -------- 4-24

lonit,aitooi(8731)

W-13

Mineola(4550)

LydIa

MI

UI

takevinw ---------- 8-23

lylnod (1913)

0-SI

MInter

Lalaeslvw(152( .....$-7,U4

Lyons

S-13

MlraodoClty

Lakeway (9002) ------ P.13

LyIle(2303(

015

Misoboo (45408)

lakasldo

-

Minan01

MunenaiWeIlnlHol5)

1-8

Iloilon

0-lB

P-I

N*eee

14-10

H10

PISoIcs(112)

6-19.1-4

1-7

Nuaonry

. 6-16

0-19

06011

P-13

P-2I

Cdi RldgeNosth)2991)

1)13

6-16

--------- 0-0

Iyttoo$prings

0-13

Mbno)nnVs0oy

9*1111

P12

Lamb.,

PlO

Mabaok(2l51)

S-9

MussoudCily

.3n

Odibtoest (250)

U12

Lampaaas(67l6(

P11

Mabelle

6-6

Mobeetle(187)

13

Oddand

614

PteeyPubirlVIUa9l

7-29

Redlord(l32(

9-26

I'JoloHso

J2

Mouse

P11

OabvlhIe

P17

P(peCmek

0-14

80500

lunnesa)199S2(

(.31(11110

----------- 115

------------ 0.9

Iaoeolry ------------- J14

lanndn(116576) ----- 6-IS

1108 City

Madl000villa)4159)

11010116

Maguo5a(111)(

..... i-I)

........ 1-13

Mabko(I(2257) ......... 5-9

Malone(278) ---------- 9-19

tidal -----------------

Mainclroster

Lark ----------------

Maoldns

------------ U-S

............... 0-6

Lois. --------------- 7-9 Masor(1204( .......... 0-13

Lalean (372)

Lawn (393) ----------

lawson

Ill u ceil3naal

May18

125

15050456 -------------1114108

------------ 0-15

League City --------- U-Il

U

I

................. H-S

Marothoa)455(

1913

MarbloPelhs)4959( ----- P-IS

Mi,fa(2121) ---------- 7-13

Masasnel

-------------- 14-8

-

Monahans (682t) ------ H-to

0850004)411) --------- 1-10

Pltlsbure(4347). -------- (1-7

---------------- u-n

MontagUe -------------Masealba ------------- 1-18

OlrIeo(132)----------- U-i

plso ---------------- 0-16

Monroe

MonleAtlo (1011)

...... 0-21

Montel) -------------- 14-14

Mo5l68mey (489) ------ 1-12

0-ne

Muwnly)lnnol

140008(644) ----------- 0-15

Monona

................. N-S ptabo5(llSO) ------------ 0-i

00150(2419)

Morgafl)465) ----------Mill ------------

---------- 0-Il

Plain.lrw(22336) --------- J-5

......... I-In PIano2flO3O ------------ 5-7

0*osa(09943(

0Inniull(lOIl) -------- J9

0Isby (458) -------- 0-Il

019

OIl Glnsy -------------- M7

nlmon(310)

115

5-12

Monao(233)------------ 6-9

1401510

0611

OlOnuboen

------------ 6-13

Ma

mon Pails

$-10

---------- e-28

Pleasaoltanrns

----------- I-to

Pleasleiton (8266)

........ 7-18

pe1.j

115

Plum

.................. 8-14

PolIo

19

------ u2

049*4o4(781( ------ $g

polalAbslH(559)

poiios

ROI0GIO(2941)

Pt

---------- Al

........... U1

Roes (24411 ............. 1#Iiinnlaoid ............... 84Shown (551) ............ 0Hicando ................ 0-I

Rice (790) ...............

Reblaw(327)

TI

Balsa do

0lchardson

............ H-2

Abhardson (91802)

17-50633.379

Spdos (350)....

------------------ u-ui

Al

---------- S-Il

RlCblandHhlS ---------- C-S

P.lclvland(291(

AuCkland

0-1

Case 4:16-cr-00526-DCG Document 159-1 Filed 03/02/18 Page 4 of 4

(PARKI

'

4

I

35\ \

1641

22

:j

_,___

'0

CULBERSON

'I

'

I

WARD

4

1

(55

,

REEVES

iMce

010

20

49?/__._/

)

\

'I

oorr

A

TOYOII,

f

4

A

1

1927

3

iç4

19

1219

18

.

42

2

2994

-

1050

..

Ta

stj

IS

6-

"

2424

87

VanH4Th

Verhalen

Ken)

'1 40

,

g

\,-

80

A1573

52

Barstow

I

Mo a

1

1355

:1

son

1218

___._!

2119

I

MDI

WInk18

'Mon(one

w

10

UNTAINS

24

.

/

535053

309-

3075

Im,9)3

'9.

I

212

21

23

Lobo

y,

3832

MCDONA

1

0 OLD FOR

1

74

25

0AVIS

For

/

2037

'

,/

'tortDavs

-j___..___._.__

10

I

RLAND-BUTTERFIELD

STAGE STOP

0

a'

2023

NATLHIST RICAL SITE

DAVIS

MOUNTAINS

ST PARK4

6

248

\/

OBSERVATORY

ValentIne

32

ST. PARK

DAVIS

JEFF

18

£

BALMORHEP.

1

Coyanosa

37

7j!iiroh.l

Toyahva)e

)

8

325

'\

4

87

16

PEE

48

Ir

4.9

PORT

N

LANCASTER

SlIP

1537

1'

-

7

21

PRESIDIO

Mpine

N

26

22

INSPEcONI

2810

STATION

ndeIar)a

/'rADEL8URX

ii

(j

,.

\,

Mart

MOUNTAINS

INSPECTION

l

IS

.

67

M11eota (4550)

:

Mineral W,I1, (10946)

P4

Minter

:::

NovIce 11421

0-18.74

1-7

Nuiouy

8-18

0-19

oa 1011

P.13

p-zt

Odc0idoe 00115(2991)

M55oadCOy

E-30

O48wmt(230)

MobeNie(l87)

L3

Ooldand

.

Mirando City

STATION

I

(Ru)dou

,.

.

-

.::

U 12

)4

PinnyPoIntVlOa99

6-29

.............. P17 PipeCreek. ............. 0-14 RodInai(I32)

80000....

Mitealians (6821)

......... 710 Plltsbuig(4347) .......... U-i

4-10

01100(132)

Monroe

........... M7 Placedit ................ 8-16 Riluglo(2941)

uS

RekIaw (327)

0151 .................

Munlagol

PIalno(1450) ............ H-i

Reono(24411

0155(2499) .......... 017

Moalalb

1-to

PMluuiew(22336) ......... J-5

Rlilnotaind

015189(00943)......... 1-19

Mon1eAI1o(611)

0-21

P1800)222030) ........... 9-7

Rlrome(55i)

MofltII .............. M14 Olotineli(l0t1) ........ J-a Pteanaintiarms ...........

1-19 Ricordo..

001tW (458) ......... 0-lI

UonI5wnety (480) ...... 1-13

Pleonantoin (8265) ........ P-is

RIca (798)

pl

O*vIlte

oocebbdIl7t)

6-14

18

AMARILLO, TX

-

917

-

Mcoily I00l ........... 11

........... o-is

MoOre (644)

.. S-I2

................. 0-OH

O9nio,

N-i

............. 115

0-13

...............................

0-9

(485)

Moirn)233)

Mo'n

...........

s-

llorgnMIII ........

528

-:

°°I2SIj

Plit9er ................

Plum

1-15

.................. 8-14

P45 (792) ..............

.

RIchirdoitn

RICIOOIdSOII (91102)

nIBl00k)55I) ........ 0-12

RIchlnd)291)

Mi

07

039

0-12

Ckltst it

lost

C

...

I

RD

43

WondeL

°

Amii9e01eflI

P011ER

M4o

ST. FRANCIS

_.AV_

tyssaI

H[t/AYil91

'a

BLVD

4

I

C.,

1-14

60 60 o

iaiIiio 18

Ha,

U 15

104oe.

J'CLIFFSIDE

0

CR091

°

S-to

C 24

Alchmond(1108I)

287

09

Ott

7

)1L

3l(iloroo1ee

623

Rlchioo060ts

u.t

87

712

RiChlafldSptIllOS(3501

POAIO

2

ID

I

31.lrleo

'1

S9

Pellok

U-ia

I

O

2

1-6

Podcoorrioct(701) ...... 5-15

P0060r(507)

°:'!

Rictiarda

U-iD

W

I

0

lltnthoo

87 87

II

19Th

Amarillo

LIveeloek

Au4ion

-

II

17-50633.380

-.5

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.