UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

Agency decision

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

Before the

SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION

ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDING

File No. 3-13199

In the Matter of

CORNERSTONE CAPITAL

MANAGEMENT, INC., and

LAURA JEAN KENT,

PROPOSED PLAN OF DISTRIBUTION

Respondents.

Background

This Plan of Distribution (the “Distribution Plan”) proposes a methodology for distributing

the disgorgement paid by Cornerstone Capital Management, Inc. (“Cornerstone Capital”) and Laura

Jean Kent (“Kent”) (collectively “Respondents”), in settlement of the administrative proceeding

captioned above.

On March 20, 2009, the Respondents consented to the entry of an Order Making Findings

and Imposing Remedial Sanctions and a Cease and Desist Order Pursuant to Sections 203(e),

203(f), and 203(k) of the Investment Advisers Act of 1940 (“Order”). In the Matter of Cornerstone

Capital Management, Inc., and Laura Jean Kent, Investment Advisers Act Rel. No. 2855, Admin.

Proc. File No. 3-13199 (Mar. 20, 2009). The Order found that from 1997 to 2004, Kent and her

investment advisory firm, Cornerstone Capital, invested approximately $15 million of client funds

in five investments. Over time, Respondents became aware of substantial evidence demonstrating

that the value of each of the investments was severely impaired. Despite this knowledge,

Respondents continued to issue periodic client account statements in which they listed the “market

price” and “total market value” of these investments as remaining unchanged from their original

cost. These statements were mailed to the investors in the impaired programs (the “Harmed

Investors”).

Respondents also made numerous material misrepresentations and omissions about the

status of the investments, including the fact that some of the promoters were subsequently convicted

of fraud. The Order found that the values of the investments were impaired, yet they continued to

charge a 1%-assets-under-management fee based on the initial cost of the investments, collecting

hundreds of thousands of dollars more than they would have had the investments been properly

valued. The Order found that, by failing to properly value impaired investments, and by

misrepresenting and failing to disclose material facts about the investments, Respondents willfully

violated Sections 206(1) and 206(2) of the Advisers Act. Respondents consented to the entry of the

Order without admitting or denying the Order’s findings.

As required by the Order, Respondents are to pay to the Securities and Exchange

Commission (the “Commission”) disgorgement, jointly and severally, in the amount of $335,758.00

(“Settlement Amount”). Pursuant to the Order, Respondents will make thirteen quarterly payments

beginning 30 days from the entry of the Order. These payments will be made to the Commission,

deposited at the U.S. Treasury Bureau of Public Debt for investment in government obligations (the

“Distribution Fund”), and will be distributed to the Harmed Investors in three annual payments.

Pursuant to the Order, Respondents undertook to develop a Distribution Plan for the

distribution of the Settlement Amount in consultation with the staff of the Commission assigned

to this matter (the “Staff”) and subject to the approval of the Commission. Upon Commission

approval of the Distribution Plan and appointment of a Plan Administrator, as provided in Rule

1104 of the Commission’s Rules on Fair Fund and Disgorgement Plans, Respondents will assist the

Commission-appointed Plan Administrator in the distribution of the disgorgement to the affected

investors. The assets of the Distribution Fund are subject to the continuing jurisdiction and control

of the Commission. The Distribution Plan is subject to approval by the Commission, and the

Commission retains jurisdiction over the implementation of the Plan.

Administration of the Distribution Plan

1.

Purpose. The Distribution Plan has been developed pursuant to the Order and the

SEC Rules on Fair Fund and Disgorgement Plans, 17 C.F.R. § 201.1100, et seq. (the “Rules”).

The purpose of the Distribution Plan is to distribute the disgorgement paid by Respondents in

settlement of the above-captioned Administrative Proceeding.

2.

Plan Administrator. Rule 1105 provides that the Commission “shall have the

discretion to appoint any person, including a Commission employee, as administrator of a plan of

disgorgement or a Fair Fund and to delegate to that person responsibility for administering the

plan.” Respondents have proposed appointing Commission Trial Counsel, Robert L. Mitchell as

Plan Administrator. The Plan Administrator will be responsible for, among other things:

overseeing the administration of the Distribution Fund, obtaining accurate mailing information

for the Harmed Investors, preparing accountings, cooperating with the Tax Administrator in

providing the information necessary to accomplish income tax compliance, distributing money

from the Distribution Fund to the Harmed Investors in accordance with this Plan, and preparing a

final accounting.

3.

Bonds. Because the Plan Administrator is a Commission employee, no bond is

required pursuant to Rule 1105(c).

Distribution Plan and Procedures

2

4.

Receipt of Additional Funds. Rule 1101(b)(l) provides, among other things, that a

distribution plan shall include “[p]rocedures for the receipt of additional funds.” The Distribution

Fund will be deposited at the U.S. Treasury Bureau of Public Debt for investment in government

obligations as each payment is received. Other than interest from these investments, it is not

anticipated that the Distribution Fund will receive any additional funds.

5.

Identifying the Harmed Investors. Rule 1101(b)(2) provides that a distribution

plan shall include a “[s]pecification of categories of persons potentially eligible to receive

proceeds from the fund.” The Harmed Investors are the individuals and entities that invested

with Respondents in the impaired programs (as described in the Order) and paid assets-under

management fees on the impaired investments. Respondents, in consultation with the Staff, have

already identified the seventy-two Harmed Investors and calculated the distribution amounts to

be paid to each Investor. If an individual or entity believes it is a Harmed Investor but has not

received notice in the mail of their status, they can contact the Plan Administrator at the United

States Securities and Exchange Commission, San Francisco Regional Office, 44 Montgomery

Street, Suite 2600, San Francisco, CA 94104.

6.

Methodology for Determining Distribution Amounts. Respondents have

calculated the amounts to be distributed to each Harmed Investor (the “Distribution Amounts”)

by first calculating the total amount of management fees paid to the Respondents by the Harmed

Investors for each impaired investment (as described in the Order). Second, Respondents

calculated the pro rata share for each Harmed Investor based upon the amount each Harmed

Investor paid in management fees for the impaired investments. Finally, Respondents took the

Settlement Amount and applied the pro rata calculation to determine the amount of disgorgement

paid to each Harmed Investor. In the view of the proposed Plan Administrator, this method

constitutes a fair and reasonable allocation of the Distribution Fund.

7.

Locating and Notifying the Harmed Investors. Rule 1101(b)(3) provides that a

plan shall include “[p]rocedures for providing notice to [potential claimants – here, the Harmed

Investors] of the existence of the fund and their potential eligibility to receive the proceeds of the

fund.” In this case, Respondents and the Staff have already identified the Harmed Investors and

calculated the Distribution Amounts to be paid to each. Respondents propose that the Plan

Administrator, on behalf of Respondents, provide each Harmed Investor with (a) a notification of

the posting of the Distribution Plan, (b) the proposed amount of disgorgement to be paid to the

Harmed Investor, and (c) a description of the methodology used to calculate that amount. The

Plan Administrator, on behalf of Respondents, will provide such notice by United States Postal

Service and will request at that time from the Harmed Investor information necessary to

accomplish the distribution, including confirmation of (i) Social Security and Tax Identification

number(s), (ii) the payment address, (iii) contact information, and/or (iv) wiring instructions. If

the Harmed Investor fails to respond to such notice within twenty-one (21) days from the mailing

of the notice, the Plan Administrator will send a second written notice by mail. If the Harmed

Investor does not respond to the second notice within twenty-one (21) days, the Plan

Administrator will make two attempts to contact the Harmed Investor telephonically.

3

8.

No Claims Process. Rule 1101(b)(4) provides, among other things, that a plan

shall include “[p]rocedures for making and approving claims, procedures for handling disputed

claims, and a cut-off date for the making of claims.” The Distribution Fund is not being

distributed according to a claims-made process, so the procedures for providing notice and for

making and approving claims are not applicable.

9.

Checks/Electronic Transfers. The Plan Administrator will make three annual

payments to the Harmed Investors. The payments will be made by March 31 of each year. The

first payment is to commence on or before March 31, 2010. The Plan Administrator may elect to

make payment of any Distribution Amount to a Harmed Investor by check or electronic transfer.

All checks shall bear a stale date of one year. All payments shall be preceded or accompanied

with a communication that includes, as appropriate: (a) a statement characterizing the

distribution; (b) a description of the tax information reporting and other related tax matters; (c) a

statement that checks will be void (non-negotiable) after one year; and (d) the name of a person

to contact with questions concerning the distribution. Distribution checks, on their face, or in the

accompanying communication will clearly indicate that the money is being distributed from a

Distribution Fund established by the Commission pursuant to the Order in this case. Checks that

are not negotiated prior to the stale date shall be voided. Electronic credits will be made only to

cash equivalent accounts (e.g., checking or savings accounts).

10.

Implementation of the Distribution Plan; Financial Management Service;

Validation and Approval of Disbursement of the Fair Fund. The Fair Fund disbursement to

investors will be implemented through the United States Department of the Treasury’s Financial

Management Service (“FMS”), which will electronically transfer funds through the Automated

Clearing House (“ACH”) or mail a check to each payee. The Plan Administrator will compile

the information to be submitted to FMS in the required file format, and Commission staff will

then obtain authorization from the Commission to disburse pursuant to SEC Rule 1101(b)(6).

When the order to disburse is entered, the Commission will transmit the electronic file to FMS

for the transfer of funds in accordance with this plan.

11.

Returned Checks/Electronic Transfer Procedures. Within 24 to 48 hours of

receipt by FMS, funds will be transferred by the ACH or checks will be mailed. FMS will notify

the Commission, which, in turn, will notify the Plan Administrator of any returned items due to

non-delivery, insufficient addresses, and/or other deficiencies. The Plan Administrator is

responsible for researching and reconciling all errors that result in non-delivery and shall submit

a supplemental electronic file for payment of the returned items. The Plan Administrator also is

responsible for accounting for all payments. In the event that any distribution is in the form of a

paper check in lieu of an electronic transfer, each check will state on its face that it is valid for

one year. After one year from the date on the distribution check, FMS shall notify the

Commission staff of all uncashed checks. FMS will credit the SEC account for the Distribution

Fund for the amount of all uncashed checks.

4

12.

Accountings. Once all funds are disbursed through FMS, the Plan Administrator

will submit a final accounting for approval by the Commission prior to termination of the

Distribution Fund and the discharge of the Plan Administrator.

13.

Undisbursed Amounts. Rule 1101(b)(5) requires that the distribution plan make

“provision for the disposition of any funds not otherwise distributed.” Upon exhaustion of all

procedures to identify and locate the Harmed Investors and to reconcile all errors that result in

non-delivery, if any portion of the Distribution Fund remains undisbursed (whether because a

Harmed Investor has failed to supply identifying information, because the Plan Administrator

was unable to locate a Harmed Investor or its successor, because a Harmed Investor or its

successor no longer exists, because a check becomes stale, or for some other reason), it will be

remitted to the U.S. Treasury after the final accounting is approved by the Commission.

14.

Termination of the Distribution Fund. Rule 1101(b)(5) requires that a distribution

plan include a “proposed date for the termination of the fund.. ..” Upon distribution of the funds,

the Plan Administrator shall make arrangement for the final payment of taxes and Tax

Administrator fees, and shall submit a final accounting to the Commission. The Fair Fund shall

be eligible for termination, and the Fund Administrator shall be discharged, after all of the

following have occurred: (1) a final accounting, in an SEC standard accounting format provided

by the staff, has been submitted by the Fund Administrator for approval of, and has been

approved by, the Commission, (2) all taxes, fees and expenses have been paid, and (3) any

amount remaining in the Fair Fund has been received by the Commission. When the

Commission has approved the final accounting, the staff shall seek an order from the

Commission to approve the transfer of any amount remaining in the Fair Fund to the U.S.

Treasury, and shall arrange for the termination of the Fair Fund and discharge of the Fund

Administrator.

15.

Fees and Costs of Administering the Distribution Plan. Fees and other expenses

of administering the plan shall be paid first from the interest earned on the funds, and if the

interest is not sufficient, then from the corpus.

16.

Tax Administrator. The Commission has appointed Damasco & Associates as the

tax administrator for the Distribution Fund (the “Tax Administrator”) In the Matter of

Cornerstone Capital Management, Inc., and Laura Jean Kent, Securities Exchange Act Rel. No.

60327, Admin. File No. 3-13199 (July 17, 2009). The Plan Administrator will cooperate with the

Tax Administrator in providing information necessary to accomplish the income tax compliance,

ruling and advice work assigned to the Tax Administrator by the Commission. The Tax

Administrator shall be compensated first from the interest earned on the funds, and if that interest is

not sufficient, then from the corpus.

17.

Qualified Settlement Fund. The Distribution Fund constitutes a Qualified

Settlement Fund ("QSF") under Section 468B(g) of the Internal Revenue Code, 26 U.S.C. §

468B(g), and related regulations, 26 C.F.R. §§1.468B-1 through 1.468B-5.

5

18.

Amendment. The Plan Administrator will obtain approval from the Commission

prior to the implementation of any material changes to the Distribution Plan. If material changes

are required, this Distribution Plan may be amended upon the motion of the Plan Administrator

or upon the Commission's own motion and receipt of Commission approval.

19.

Review of Procedures and Computations by Cornerstone Capital. The

Commission retains the right to appoint a consultant or firm, at Cornerstone Capital’s expense, to

review, on the Commission’s behalf, Cornerstone Capital’s function, procedures, and

computations in the distribution process should such a review be deemed necessary.

20.

Distribution Timing. The Plan Administrator will use its best efforts to make the

first distribution as soon as practicable, but no later than March 31, 2010. The second

distribution will be made on or before March 31, 2011. The third and final distribution will be

made on or before March 31, 2012.

21.

Deadline Extensions. The Staff may extend any procedural deadline contained in

the Distribution Plan for good cause shown.

Notice of Proposed Distribution Plan

22.

In accordance with Rule 1103, notice of the Distribution Plan shall be published in

the SEC Docket, on the Commission's website at www.sec.gov/litigation/fairfundlist.htm, and on

Cornerstone Capital’s website at www.cornerstonecap.com. Any person or entity wishing to

comment on the Distribution Plan must do so in writing by submitting their comments to the

Commission within thirty (30) days of the publication date of the Notice of Proposed Plan of

Distribution: (a) by sending a letter to the Office of the Secretary, United States Securities and

Exchange Commission, 100 F Street, N.E., Washington, D.C. 20549-1090; (b) by using the

Commission's internet comment form (available at www.sec.gov/litigation/admin.shtml); or (c) by

sending an e-mail to rule-comments@sec.gov. Comments submitted by e-mail or via the

Commission's website should include the Administrative Proceeding File Number (Admin. Proc.

File No. 3-13199) in the subject line. Comments received will be available to the public.

Commenters should therefore only submit information that they wish to make publicly available.

6

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.