[COUNSEL for acquiring company A]

Agency decision

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DATE

BY E-MAIL

[COUNSEL for acquiring company A]

[COUNSEL for acquired company B]

Re:

[Transaction]

Dear [COUNSEL]:

This letter (“the Agreement”) sets forth the understanding between the staff of the Bureau

of Competition of the Federal Trade Commission (“FTC Staff”) and [Company A] and

[Company B] (collectively the “Parties”) in connection with the proposed acquisition by [A] of

[B] (the “Proposed Transaction”), which is the subject of Requests for Additional Information

and Documentary Material issued by the Federal Trade Commission on [DATE] (“Second

Requests”) [or commensurate request for non-reportable mergers].

This Agreement does not alter the Parties’ obligations to certify substantial compliance

with the Second Requests, as modified in writing by FTC Staff.

This Agreement does not bind the Federal Trade Commission (“FTC”), any individual

Commissioner, or any other federal or state Government entity, but rather is an agreement with

FTC Staff. This Agreement does not alter the FTC’s legal ability to challenge the Proposed

Transaction, including, but not limited to, after expiration of the timing set out below.

It is agreed as follows:

I.

Timing and Communication

The Parties agree not to close the Proposed Transaction before 11:59 PM Eastern Time

on the [60th–90th] calendar day following the date on which both Parties substantially comply

with the Second Requests, as modified in writing by FTC Staff, unless the FTC earlier (i)

terminates the Hart-Scott-Rodino Act waiting period without issuance of a complaint or

following issuance of a complaint and consent order, and/or (ii) provides written notice that the

FTC has closed its investigation.

February 2019

Commented [A1]: Note for Public Version: The proposed date

range shall not be interpreted as either a cap or a limit on the number

of days the Parties must wait until closing. Some investigations may

require in excess of 90 days for the review contemplated by this

agreement.

A.

Notices

1.

The Parties agree to provide FTC Staff with thirty (30) calendar days

advanced notice before certifying that they have substantially complied with the

Second Requests. Such notice shall be provided no earlier than ten (10) calendar

days following the execution of this Agreement.

2.

The parties agree to provide thirty (30) calendar days advanced notice

before consummating the Proposed Transaction. The date identified for

consummation of the Proposed Transaction shall be deemed the Closing Date for

purposes of this Agreement. The Parties may not provide this advanced notice

more than forty (40) calendar days prior to the Closing Date and must have a

good faith basis for believing that they can consummate the proposed transaction

on that Closing Date.

All notices required in Sections I.A. are to be made in writing in the form of the letters

provided as Attachments A and B to this letter, as appropriate.

B.

Computing Time and Extension of Deadlines

In computing any period specified in this Agreement, the day of the act, event, or default

that triggers the period shall be excluded. The first day of the period shall be the first business

day after the act, event, or default that triggers the period. The last day of the period of time

shall be included unless it is a Saturday, Sunday, or federal holiday, in which case the period

runs until 11:59 PM Eastern Time of the next business day on which the federal government is

open. Any material received by the Bureau of Competition or the FTC after 5:00 PM Eastern

Time shall be deemed received on the next business day.

In the event that the Federal Trade Commission is closed pursuant to a lapse in

appropriations from Congress, all dates specified herein shall be extended day-for-day, for each

calendar day the Federal Trade Commission closure is in place. This day-for-day extension shall

include but is not limited to any date(s) between notice and certification of substantial

compliance and any date(s) between certification of substantial compliance and close. Notices

and certifications of substantial compliance may not be given if the Commission is closed

pursuant to the first sentence of this paragraph. Any portion of a calendar day affected by a

federal government closure shall be considered an entire day for the purposes of extending, dayfor-day, the date(s) specified herein. For example, if the federal government is reopened at noon

on a given calendar day, the date(s) specified herein shall be extended as if the federal

government closure lasted that entire day.

Except as specifically provided herein, the failure of a Party to comply with any deadline

in this Agreement shall cause any subsequent deadlines specified herein to be extended, day-forday, for each calendar day the deadline is not met.

C.

Communication / Exchange of Information

During the course of the investigation, FTC Staff and staff from the FTC’s Bureau of

Economics (“BE”) will make a good faith effort to meet with the Parties, either in person or by

February 2019

phone, as reasonably requested by either FTC Staff or either Party, to promote a continuing

dialogue regarding the facts and the relevant legal and economic issues and to discuss progress in

meeting the agreed-upon schedule discussed in this Agreement. FTC Staff and the Parties intend

that the ongoing dialogue include a good faith exchange of information regarding any

substantive issues, theories, or questions that FTC Staff may have regarding the Proposed

Acquisition.

The Parties are encouraged to provide to FTC Staff the results of their own economic and

econometric analyses, and any underlying data. FTC Staff will make good faith and reasonable

efforts to provide feedback on the Parties’ submissions. Also, as soon as practicable upon

discovery of any deficiencies relating to a Party’s certification, FTC Staff will notify the Party in

writing of the deficiencies.

D.

Investigational Hearings and Document Productions

To the extent investigational hearings (“IHs”) are conducted in this matter, FTC Staff will

use reasonable best efforts to identify IH witnesses no later than the fifteenth (15th) business day

after both Parties certify substantial compliance with the Second Requests (“Compliance Date”).

The Parties agree to make such witnesses available such that their IHs may be completed within

ten (10) business days after FTC Staff identifies each witness, or ten (10) business days after

receipt of documents belonging to each witness, or a later date if agreed to by staff. The Parties

also agree to produce an up-to-date resume for each IH witness at least five (5) business days

prior to the date of that witness’s IH.

For each IH witness identified prior to a Party certifying substantial compliance, the Party

will produce a substantially complete document production, including relevant non-custodial

Specifications identified by FTC Staff, to the FTC at least fifteen (15) business days prior to the

agreed-upon date of the witness’s IH (the “IH Document Production Date”). Contemporaneous

with the substantial completion of the document production for each custodian or at the earliest

practicable date, the Parties shall identify in writing the cut-off date for the collection of

documents for each custodian. If additional responsive, non-duplicative, and non-privileged

documents or information from a witness’s files or in response to relevant non-custodial

productions are produced after this deadline, FTC Staff reserves the right to hold open, re-open,

continue, or reschedule that witness’s IH. If FTC Staff decides to hold open or re-open an IH for

this reason, FTC Staff will use the additional hearing time to question the witness on only the

documents and information produced after the IH Document Production Date and any additional

topics related to those documents and that information.

II.

Second Request Production and Post-Compliance Period

A.

Rolling Production and Priority Custodians/Specifications

The Parties shall use good faith efforts to produce responsive materials on a rolling basis

(i.e., the responsive documents from each individual’s files will be produced as soon as

practicable after such documents are reviewed, processed, and copied, and the Parties’

documents will be produced in multiple, sequential batches). Each production shall be

accompanied by a data overlay updating metadata for the entire production (e.g., updating the

February 2019

alternative custodian field for all documents in the current production and all documents

previously produced).

Within five (5) business days of execution of this Agreement, the Bureau shall identify

no more than [X] Priority Custodians from each Party. The Priority Custodians shall be listed

and attached as an appendix to this Agreement following identification by FTC Staff. The

Parties agree to produce substantially complete document productions from the Priority

Custodians at least thirty (30) business days prior to certifying substantial compliance with the

Second Requests. The Parties shall submit written confirmation of compliance with this

obligation upon completion of its submissions of Priority Custodian materials.

The Parties will substantially comply with Specifications [X-Y] in the Second Requests

(“Priority Data”) at least thirty (30) business days prior to certifying substantial compliance with

the Second Requests. The Parties shall submit written confirmation of compliance with this

obligation upon completion of its submissions of Priority Data.

B.

Second Request Modifications

Staff agrees to work in good faith with the Parties to consider reasonable requests for

modification to the Second Request.

III.

Preliminary Injunction Proceeding

The Parties shall not initiate a declaratory judgment action against the FTC relating to the

Proposed Transaction. In the event that the FTC files an enforcement action pursuant to Section

13(b) of the Federal Trade Commission Act, on or before the Closing Date, seeking to enjoin the

Proposed Transaction, the Parties agree to file a joint stipulation with the court as follows:

A.

The Parties and the FTC hereby stipulate to a Temporary Restraining Order (an

executed version is attached hereto as Attachment C) preventing the Parties from

consummating the Proposed Transaction until after 11:59 PM Eastern Time on the fifth

(5th) business day after a court rules on a motion for a preliminary injunction or the date

set by the District Court, whichever is later; and

B.

The Parties shall take any and all necessary steps to prevent any of their officers,

directors, domestic or foreign agents, divisions, subsidiaries, affiliates, partnerships, or

joint ventures from consummating, directly or indirectly, the Proposed Transaction until

the timing identified in the paragraph immediately above.

This agreement shall not be construed to limit in any way the FTC’s right to seek

additional discovery in the context of any federal court hearing.

IV.

Construction

Nothing in this Agreement affects FTC Staff’s ability to reject a submission that it

determines is not in substantial compliance with the Second Requests, or in the case of an HSR

filing, is deficient. This Agreement may only be amended or modified through a written

instrument signed by the parties.

February 2019

Commented [A2]: Note for Public Version: The proposed

priority custodian range shall vary based on the unique facts and

timing of the second request investigation.

If you agree to the terms set forth in this Agreement, please indicate your agreement by

countersigning below and returning to us.

___________________________________

Counsel for [Company A]

_______________

Date

___________________________________

Counsel for [Company B]

_______________

Date

February 2019

Attachment A: Pre-Certification Notice Template

[FTC Staff and Address]

Re:

Notice of Intent to Certify Substantial Compliance; FTC File No. [XX]

Dear [FTC Staff],

We write on behalf of [Company A] and [Company B] (collectively, “the Parties”) in

connection with the Requests for Additional Information and Documentary Material (“Second

Requests”) issued by the FTC to [Company A] and [Company B] on [Date].

We hereby provide notice to FTC Staff that the Parties intend to certify substantial

compliance with the Second Request and CID on or after [today’s date + 30 calendar days].

___________________________________

Counsel for [Company A]

_______________

Date

___________________________________

Counsel for [Company B]

_______________

Date

February 2019

Attachment B: Pre-Consummation Notice Template

[FTC Staff and Address]

Re:

Notice of Intent to Consummate the Proposed Transaction; FTC File No. [XX]

Dear [FTC Staff],

We write on behalf of [Company A] and [Company B] (collectively, “the Parties”) in

connection with the proposed merger of [Company A] and [Company B] (the “Proposed

Transaction”).

We hereby provide notice to FTC Staff that the Parties intend to consummate the

Proposed Transaction on or after [today’s date + 30 calendar days] as limited by Section I.A.2 of

this Agreement, which shall be deemed the Closing Date for purposes of the timing agreement

executed by the Parties and Commission staff on [Date].

We also hereby confirm that on or after [today’s date + 30 calendar days], the Parties’

good faith belief is that they will be able to close the Proposed Transaction because all conditions

precedent to the closing of the Proposed Transaction (including any described in the Parties’

Letter of Intent dated [Date]) will have been satisfied or waived if the FTC does not sue to block

the Proposed Transaction.

___________________________________

Counsel for [Company A]

_______________

Date

___________________________________

Counsel for [Company B]

_______________

Date

February 2019

Attachment C: Temporary Restraining Order

In the event that the Federal Trade Commission (“FTC”) files an enforcement action

seeking to enjoin the proposed merger of [Company A] and [Company B] (the “Proposed

Transaction”) on or before the date that [Company A] and [Company B] have identified for

consummating the Proposed Transaction, [Company A], [Company B], and the FTC hereby

stipulate to a Temporary Restraining Order in federal district court stating that:

a. [Company A] and [Company B] shall not consummate the Proposed Transaction until

after 11:59 PM Eastern Time on the fifth (5th) business day after the court rules on the

FTC’s motion for a preliminary injunction pursuant to Section 13(b) of the Federal Trade

Commission Act or until after the date set by the District Court, whichever is later; and

b. In connection with paragraph immediately above, [Company A] and [Company B] shall

take any and all necessary steps to prevent any of their officers, directors, domestic or

foreign agents, divisions, subsidiaries, affiliates, partnerships, or joint ventures from

consummating, directly or indirectly, any such transaction; and

c. In computing any period of time specified in this attachment, the day of the act, event, or

default that triggers the period shall be excluded. The term “business day” as used in this

attachment refers to any day that is not a Saturday, Sunday, or federal holiday.

___________________________________

Counsel for [FTC Staff]

_______________

Date

___________________________________

Counsel for [Company A]

_______________

Date

___________________________________

Counsel for [Company B]

_______________

Date

February 2019

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.