Case law
Opinions from 1658 to today.
5,304 results
4.49s
Smith v. John/Jane Doe Correctional Officers
District Court, S.D. West Virginia · Oct 22, 2024
violate clearly established laws of which a reasonable official would have known.” … The plaintiff in A.B. alleged a correctional officer raped her, which the SCAWV found to be a violation of clearly established law. Id.
Cited 0 timesUnknownDistrict Court, S.D. West Virginia · Aug 3, 2026
An official is entitled to qualified immunity unless (1) they violated a federal statutory or constitutional right and (2) that right was clearly established at the time of its violation. See Owens v. … Qualified immunity shields government officials from liability when they perform discretionary activities in an official capacity so long as they “did not violate clearly established laws of which a reasonable official
Cited 0 timesUnknownIntermediate Court of Appeals of West Virginia · Jun 13, 2024
We consider the circuit court’s order to be an appealable order on the issue of sovereign immunity: “[A] circuit court's denial of a motion to dismiss that is predicated on qualified immunity … Forsyth, 472 U.S. 511, 525 (1985)).11 With our jurisdiction to review the circuit court’s order established, we proceed to consider the principles of our sovereign immunity jurisprudence. A.
Cited 0 timesPublishedWest Virginia Supreme Court · Mar 21, 2022
Code § 55-7-13d(a)(5), and repeats that “[n]othing in this section alters, in any way, the immunity of any person as established by statute or common law[,]” W. Va. Code § 55-7-13d(g). … Clearly, West Virginia workers’ compensation law provides that Mr.
Cited 0 timesPublishedDistrict Court, S.D. West Virginia · Nov 10, 2022
Violation of a clearly established constitutional or statutory right Plaintiff argues that Defendant Lucas is not entitled to qualified immunity because he deprived Plaintiff of a clearly established constitutional … A plaintiff can show an official is not entitled to qualified immunity only by pleading facts sufficient to establish 1) the official violated a statutory or constitutional right and 2) the right was “clearly established
Cited 0 timesUnknown185 W. Va. 569 · West Virginia Supreme Court · Jul 19, 1991
This finding of the trial court, contrary to the jury’s finding in its answers to the special interrogatories, is clearly wrong. … The trial court agreed with the jury’s finding that this element was established here.
Cited 36 timesPublishedSummers v. West Virginia Department of Homeland Security
District Court, S.D. West Virginia · Oct 31, 2022
(2) Qualified Immunity Lastly, Deputy Lester argues that he is entitled to qualified immunity as to Count I of the FAC—unreasonable search and seizure … However, Deputy Lester’s alleged violation occurred before the Supreme Court’s opinion in Caniglia, which does leave him the opportunity to argue that his qualified immunity defense is intact due to the law not being “clearly
Cited 0 timesUnknownDistrict Court, S.D. West Virginia · Jun 25, 2024
“The doctrine of qualified immunity protects government officials ‘from liability for civil damages insofar as their conduct does not violate clearly established statutory or constitutional … The next question in the qualified immunity analysis is whether the deputies violated Mr. Tartt’s clearly established rights.
Cited 0 timesUnknownGloria Allen v. Greenbrier Co. Sheriff's Dept.
West Virginia Supreme Court · Jun 28, 2013
In regard to the special duty exception, we have listed the requirements necessary to establish such an exception as follows: “The four requirements for the application of the ‘special relationship’ exception to … This liability is clearly limited by sections five and six of Article 12A, and section five states that “[a] political subdivision is immune from liability if a loss or claim results from: (5) Civil disobedience, riot, insurrection
Cited 0 timesPublished140 W. Va. 680 · West Virginia Supreme Court · Mar 15, 1955
In the Cosner case, supra, the rule was laid down that such facts must be “clearly” established. Therein it was held: “4. … After a careful appraisal thereof, we are of the opinion that the record fails completely to “clearly” establish that a fair and impartial jury could not have been obtained from available jurors of Clay County.
Cited 25 timesPublishedDistrict Court, S.D. West Virginia · Nov 12, 2025
Qualified Immunity When determining whether a defendant is entitled to qualified immunity for an excessive force claim under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, courts “examine (1) whether the … Va. 2023) (“West Virginia’s qualified immunity jurisprudence mirrors federal law.”).
Cited 0 timesUnknownErie Insurance Property & Casualty Co. v. Stage Show Pizza, JTS, Inc.
210 W. Va. 63 · West Virginia Supreme Court · Jul 9, 2001
By enacting the deliberate intention statute, in W.Va.Code, 23 — 4—2(c) the Legislature specifically stated that it “intended to create a legislative standard for loss of that immunity” established in W.Va.Code, 23-2-6. … Coverage for employees was clearly excluded from Erie’s the commercial general liability policy sold to Stage Show Pizza; we believe it was just as clearly included in the employers’ liability endorsement attached to that
Cited 26 timesPublishedDistrict Court, N.D. West Virginia · Jun 5, 2018
“Government officials performing discretionary functions are entitled to qualified immunity from liability for civil damages to the extent that ‘their conduct does not violate clearly established … The Fourth Circuit has stated: Qualified immunity protects [police] officers who commit constitutional violations but who, in light of clearly established
Cited 0 timesUnknownMorris v. Crown Equipment Corp.
219 W. Va. 347 · West Virginia Supreme Court · Jul 12, 2006
Privileges and Immunities In Austin v. … It is now established that under the Privileges and Immunities Clause there is ordinarily no difference between discrimination based on a person's "residence" and discrimination based on a person’s "citizenship.” ...
Cited 19 timesPublishedEstate of Wayne A. Jones v. The City of Martinsburg
District Court, N.D. West Virginia · Sep 7, 2018
In so holding, the Fourth Circuit reviewed the clearly established law as of October 2012. … Thus, while the force may have ultimately been unreasonable, the clearly established law in March 2013 “fell short of providing sufficient notice” to bar qualified immunity.
Cited 0 timesUnknownCherie and Tony Lawyer v. Morgan Co. War Memorial Hospital
West Virginia Supreme Court · Nov 22, 2013
We note that the issue of “[w]hether a witness is qualified to state an opinion is a matter which rests within the discretion of the trial court and its ruling on that point will not ordinarily be disturbed unless it clearly … However, that statute provides that the applicable standard of care “shall be established in medical professional liability cases by the plaintiff . . .
Cited 0 timesPublishedDistrict Court, S.D. West Virginia · Apr 27, 2022
They further argue that there was no violation of clearly established law. … Thus, the Court finds that the Defendants have not met their burden, at summary judgment, of establishing that the right at issue was not clearly established. A jury crediting Mr.
Cited 0 timesUnknownDistrict Court, S.D. West Virginia · Mar 23, 2020
of a clearly established right and (2) the use of restraints in this case is not a violation of a clearly established right. … “The doctrine of qualified immunity shields government officials from liability for civil damages when their conduct does not violate clearly established constitutional or other rights that a reasonable officer would have
Cited 0 timesUnknownDistrict Court, S.D. West Virginia · Nov 19, 2021
Immunity Defendant first contends that he is entitled to qualified and statutory immunity. … “The doctrine of qualified immunity protects government officials ‘from liability for civil damages insofar as their conduct does not violate clearly established statutory or constitutional rights of which a reasonable
Cited 0 timesUnknownWest Virginia Supreme Court · Nov 17, 2022
But it bypassed the question of whether a heightened deliberate intent claim qualifies as one of the exceptions. … With that immunity established, a heightened deliberate intent claim represents the only potential claim against them. But because Mrs.
Cited 0 timesPublished
Ask Donna