Case law
Opinions from 1658 to today.
10,000+ results
3.57s
280 F.3d 69 · Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit · Nov 1, 2000
of clearly established rights. … Horne supports the need to address the constitutional question when a court finds that qualified immunity does not exist because the right asserted is clearly established.
Cited 106 timesPublishedScott Allin v. City of Springfield
845 F.3d 858 · Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit · Jan 11, 2017
Qualified Immunity Framework The doctrine of qualified immunity shields public officials from civil liability if their “conduct does not violate clearly established statutory or constitutional rights of which a reasonable … right was clearly established at the time of the alleged violation.”
Cited 45 timesPublished297 Mich. App. 191 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Jun 26, 2012
However, contrary to the parties’ position, we conclude that a person can fail to qualify for immunity from arrest pursuant to § 4(a), but still be entitled to immunity from prosecution or penalty. … This argument is contrary to the plain language of the statute as we have interpreted it, and it is inconsistent with the clearly established law that permits police officers to arrest individuals who commit misdemeanor offenses
Cited 61 timesPublished170 F. App'x 212 · Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit · Oct 19, 2005
Finally, the Court found that because the State is immune from liability under § 1983, the Mierzwas’ due process claim lacks merit. … In addition, the individual Garfield defendants (police and prosecutor) enjoy qualified immunity as their conduct in investigating the incident between Edward and Thomas did not violate clearly established constitutional
Cited 3 timesUnpublishedCourt of Appeals of Kansas · Oct 5, 2018
In claiming qualified immunity, Blecha first contends that the law was not clearly established that he could be personally liable for the FLSA claims; in other words, Blecha asserts that it was not clearly established in … N.Y. 2014) (defendant not entitled to qualified immunity since rules governing its conduct were clearly established, even if the rules about personal liability were not clearly established).
Cited 0 timesUnpublishedANTONIO LACY v. JOHN COUGHLIN & another.
100 Mass. App. Ct. 321 · Massachusetts Appeals Court · Oct 6, 2021
"Thus, if a court decides to grant qualified immunity because there is no violation of clearly established law, it may never answer whether there was a constitutional violation." … While I agree with Justice Massing that the right was clearly established here, the current case is yet another example of the collateral damage done by a qualified immunity doctrine which aggressively terminates cases at
Cited 1 timesPublishedDistrict Court, N.D. Texas · Oct 15, 2021
Where a defendant has asserted a qualified-immunity defense, the Court may, under certain circumstances, permit limited discovery that is narrowly tailored to uncover facts that the Court needs to rule on the qualified-immunity … See Backe, 691 F.3d at 648 (explaining that “this court has established a careful procedure under which a district court may defer its qualified immunity ruling if further factual development is necessary to ascertain
Cited 0 timesUnknownLiu v. New York City Police Department
216 A.D.2d 67 · Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York · Jun 13, 1995
However, we find that the individual defendants should be granted qualified immunity from plaintiffs civil rights claims. … A government official performing a discretionary function is entitled to qualified immunity provided his or her conduct does not violate clearly established statutory or constitutional rights of which a reasonable person
Cited 24 timesPublishedJames P. Crocker v. Deputy Sheriff Steven Eric Beatty
886 F.3d 1132 · Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit · Apr 2, 2018
Rights may be clearly established for qualified immunity purposes by one of three methods: (1) “case law with indistinguishable facts clearly establishing the constitutional right,” (2) “a broad statement of principle within … We further determine that these rights were clearly established at the time of the seizure such that Beatty is not entitled to qualified immunity.
Cited 110 timesPublished696 So. 2d 1249 · District Court of Appeal of Florida · Jun 25, 1997
of the facts alleged, defendant's actions violate clearly established law a `purely legal question.'" … Clearly, under the most favorable version of the facts alleged, appellees' actions objectively violated clearly established law. Accordingly, dismissal of appellant's complaint cannot be supported by qualified immunity.
Cited 6 timesPublished86 F.3d 789 · Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit · Sep 10, 1996
We start our analysis with the well-established proposition that the United States may not be sued without its consent. See Affiliated Ute Citizens v. … that the agency action had transgressed and establish that the statute or regulation applies to the United States.
Cited 48 timesPublished129 F.4th 877 · Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit · Mar 3, 2025
In finding clearly established law, the district court overlooked Espinal v. … particular case at hand” and granting qualified immunity because “the unlawfulness of the officers’ conduct in this case was not clearly established”). 35 See Bailey v.
Cited 12 timesPublishedColiseum Enterprises, Inc. v. Campbell
173 Vt. 585 · Supreme Court of Vermont · Feb 25, 2002
qualified immunity. … To overcome the commissioners’ qualified immunity defense, therefore, plaintiffs must identify a “clearly established” right that was violated by the rescission of their application.
Cited 1 timesPublished2018 Ohio 707 · Ohio Court of Appeals · Feb 22, 2018
Brooks, 436 U.S. 149, 155, 98 S.Ct. 1729, 56 L.Ed.2d 185 (1978). {¶22} A governmental official sued under 42 U.S.C. §1983 may assert the defense of qualified immunity when their conduct “does not violate clearly established … Once the defendant raises the defense of qualified immunity, it is the plaintiff's burden to establish that the defendant is not entitled to qualified immunity. Id. citing Silberstein v.
Cited 2 timesPublished553 S.W.3d 246 · Missouri Court of Appeals · Aug 16, 2018
For all these reasons, the DPA is clearly a state agency to which governmental immunity is extended. … The DPA is clearly not functioning as a profit-driven entity. 3.
Cited 20 timesPublished422 N.J. Super. 426 · New Jersey Superior Court Appellate Division · Oct 18, 2011
In that regard, we conclude, because the right asserted was not clearly established at the time plaintiff was attacked, defendants are entitled to qualified immunity. I. … A government official is entitled to qualified immunity unless his or her conduct violated “ ‘clearly established statutory or constitutional rights of which a reasonable person would have known.’ ” Ibid.
Cited 5 timesPublishedTeresa Graham v. Shannon Barnette
5 F.4th 872 · Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit · Jul 16, 2021
She also argues that probable cause was the clearly established standard at the time, meaning the officers are not entitled to qualified immunity as to this claim. … The officers also argued that they were entitled to qualified immunity as to this claim because their seizure of Graham did not violate clearly established law.
Cited 51 timesPublishedUniversity of Texas Southwestern Medical Center of Dallas v. Margulis
43 Tex. Sup. Ct. J. 288 · Texas Supreme Court · Jan 6, 2000
The motion for summary judgment argued that as a matter of law the plaintiff failed to plead specific facts that would indicate a violation of clearly established law. … The motion then argued extensively that as a matter of law Fain and Winchester were entitled to summary judgment based on qualified immunity.
Cited 16 timesPublished543 U.S. 194 · Supreme Court of the United States · Dec 13, 2004
not entitled to qualified immunity. … We grant the petition on the second, qualified immunity question and reverse.
Reported overruled in part, on other grounds by Pearson v. Callahan, 555 U.S. 223 (2009) — not on the Supreme Court's listCited 2,487 timesPublishedR.Q. v. West Virginia Division of Corrections
West Virginia Supreme Court · Apr 10, 2015
Therefore, she asserts that D.F. does not enjoy qualified immunity in this matter. … The WVRJCFA argued that the training, supervision, and retention of correctional officers were inherently discretionary acts for which the State enjoys immunity and that A.B. failed to identify a clearly established right
Cited 0 timesPublished
Ask Donna