Case law
Opinions from 1658 to today.
10,000+ results
5.39s
Robinson v. Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority
858 F. Supp. 2d 33 · District Court, District of Columbia · May 1, 2012
because plaintiff has failed to establish a prima facie case of negligence. … Only discretionary activity is protected by sovereign immunity. Id.
Cited 13 timesPublishedRoger Poole v. City of Shreveport
691 F.3d 624 · Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit · Aug 16, 2012
Marcantel, 567 F.3d 156, 169 (5th Cir.2009) (per curiam) (explaining that an arrestee had a clearly established right to be free from excessive force and that it was clearly established that the force officers could use in … Within this qualified immunity inquiry, the parties dispute only whether Stalnaker’s and Creighton’s respective uses of force were clearly excessive and clearly unreasonable. These inquiries are often intertwined.
Cited 361 timesPublished328 F.3d 948 · Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit · May 13, 2003
The district court granted summary judgment for Simpson, concluding that Simpson had immunity for any alleged negligent conduct and that Simpson’s conduct could qualify as neither willful and wanton nor a deprivation of substantive … Illinois case law is unclear on what conduct by a driver of an emergency vehicle may qualify as willful and wanton.
Cited 23 timesPublished903 F.2d 400 · Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit · Jun 19, 1990
Qualified Immunity. … The doctrine of qualified immunity shields a police officer from liability for civil damages when a reasonable officer could have believed that the challenged conduct did not violate clearly established statutory or constitutional
Cited 18 timesPublishedPeggy Sigley v. City of Parma Heights
437 F.3d 527 · Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit · Feb 10, 2006
Qualified Immunity On appeal, Defendants argue, and the dissent asserts, that even if a constitutional violation occurred, Officer Mockler is entitled to qualified immunity. We disagree. … Qualified immunity protects government officials who perform discretionary functions from civil liability “insofar as their conduct does not violate clearly established statutory or constitutional rights of which a reasonable
Cited 434 timesPublished226 F.3d 1249 · Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit · Sep 13, 2000
None of Lee’s proffered evidence established that she was more qualified than Hines, let alone so clearly more qualified for the position than Hines that a reasonable juror could infer discriminatory intent from the comparison … Since Lee’s evidence at trial fell far short of establishing that she was clearly more qualified for the position than Hines, Lee did not meet her burden of establishing that Shaffer’s proffered reason for denying her
Cited 118 timesPublished143 F.3d 473 · Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit · May 5, 1998
A school counselor appealed from an order denying him qualified immunity on the ground that his alleged conduct in failing to take steps to stop sexual harassment violated clearly established rights under Title IX. … We said that in reviewing a denial of qualified immunity, this court has jurisdiction “ ‘only to decide if defendant’s conduct violated ... clearly established [law.]’” Petaluma, 54 F.3d at 1449 (quoting Pelletier v.
Cited 31 timesPublished139 F.4th 281 · Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit · Jun 3, 2025
The court found that Defendants were entitled to qualified immunity under both the constitutional and clearly established prongs. Benton v. Layton, 675 F. Supp. 3d 606, 623 (E.D. Va. 2023). … Therefore, we hold that Defendants are independently entitled to qualified immunity under the clearly established prong. 9 IV.
Cited 19 timesPublishedDistrict Court, M.D. Florida · Feb 18, 2025
[may] be specific enough to establish clearly the law applicable to particular conduct and circumstances to overcome qualified immunity, even in the total absence of case[]law.” … of qualified immunity.”); Dolihite v.
Cited 0 timesUnknownPatterson v. United States of America
999 F. Supp. 2d 300 · District Court, District of Columbia · Dec 19, 2013
The Qualified Immunity Doctrine At the motion to dismiss stage, a plaintiff must allege sufficient facts to establish that the defendants are not entitled to qualified immunity. See Bloem, 920 F. … immunity grounds, because the relevant right is not “clearly established” or otherwise, cannot be accepted.
Cited 25 timesPublished667 F. Supp. 2d 664 · District Court, W.D. Virginia · Oct 30, 2009
Alternative *667 ly, Sutherly and Fauber maintain that they have qualified immunity because they did not violate clearly established federal law, and the Town maintains that neither Suth-erly nor Fauber had the final policymaking … “Qualified immunity shields government officials performing discretionary functions from personal-capacity liability for civil damages under § 1983, insofar as their conduct does not violate clearly established statutory
Cited 0 timesPublishedGleason v. Metropolitan Council Transit Operations
563 N.W.2d 309 · Court of Appeals of Minnesota · Aug 5, 1997
In Section 1983 cases, whether an official is protected by qualified immunity “turns on the ‘objective legal reasonableness’ of the action * * * assessed in light of the legal rules that were ‘clearly established’ at the … legally reasonable or that no “clearly established law” prohibited the conduct.
Cited 35 timesPublished195 F.3d 1208 · Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit · Nov 1, 1999
Williamson also argued that they were entitled to qualified immunity because the plaintiffs had failed to allege that they had violated clearly established law. … As a result, they maintain, the district court erred in concluding that the law was clearly established and in rejecting their arguments that they are entitled to qualified immunity.
Cited 71 timesPublishedDistrict Court, D. Colorado · Apr 14, 2023
See also Cummings, 913 F.3d at 1242 (declining to “reach the first prong of the qualified-immunity analysis” where the plaintiffs “failed to identify clearly- established law” as required under the second qualified immunity … Hoffschneider has failed to meet his burden on the “clearly established” qualified immunity prong, and therefore Defendants Marshall and Pound are entitled to qualified immunity on Mr.
Cited 0 timesUnknown940 S.W.2d 340 · Texas Court of Appeals, 4th District (San Antonio) · Feb 12, 1997
To grant immunity short of absolute privilege to communications relating to pending or proposed litigation, and thus subject an attorney to liability for defamation, might tend to lessen an attorney’s efforts on behalf of … The letter was clearly written in an effort to secure the rights of appellee’s client, the executor of the estate, in property and income belonging to the estate.
Cited 36 timesPublishedDistrict Court, E.D. Michigan · Feb 7, 2024
established Supreme Court and Sixth Circuit precedent to divest these Government Official Defendants of qualified immunity. … Callahan, 555 U.S. 223, 232–36 (2009) (affirming the two prongs of qualified immunity—a violation of the constitution and clearly established law—but allowing courts to analyze these prongs in whichever order they choose
Cited 0 timesUnknownO'Neal Johnson v. Ryan Edwards
Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit · Jan 27, 2026
In the context of qualified immunity, if probable cause is arguable, a plaintiff cannot show an officer violated her clearly established right to be free from arrest. … Merits aside, Johnson cannot overcome qualified immun- ity because he has not shown he had a clearly established right to be free from the unbelted car ride he suffered.
Cited 0 timesPublished605 F. App'x 559 · Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit · Mar 25, 2015
Beyond this, the court added, the undisputed evidence establishes that the two officers had acted reasonably and thus were entitled to qualified immunity. II. … As a fallback these defendants invoke qualified immunity, but their argument is feeble.
Cited 4 timesPublishedPeter M. Garvie v. Charles O. Jackson and George W. Wheeler
845 F.2d 647 · Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit · Apr 27, 1988
“[Defendants] have qualified immunity unless plaintiffs’ ‘rights were so clearly established when the acts were committed that any officer in the defendant’s position, measured objectively, would have clearly un *650 derstood … The relevant inquiry for this court, in light of defendants’ claim of qualified immunity, is whether Garvie’s asserted property interest was clearly established.
Cited 139 timesPublished575 F.3d 1281 · Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit · Jul 31, 2009
clearly established under § 1981. … Furthermore, even if Drew’s misguided interpretation of the “clearly established” prong of the qualified immunity test was correct, it is well-established in this circuit that claims for retaliation are cognizable pursuant
Cited 558 timesPublished
Ask Donna