Case law
Opinions from 1658 to today.
10,000+ results
3.06s
Merritt Sharp, III v. County of Orange
871 F.3d 901 · Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit · Sep 19, 2017
In its view, the deputies violated clearly established law, thereby precluding qualified immunity, and the district court further held that the asserted state-law immunities were inapplicable as a matter of law and fact. … Qualified immunity is proper unless Plaintiffs establish that (1) the deputies committed a constitutional violation, and (2) the deputies’ specific conduct violated “clearly established” federal law.
Cited 214 timesPublishedIsaac Sparks v. Ronald Stutler and Manuel Largaespada
71 F.3d 259 · Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit · Feb 12, 1996
Until the right in question has been “clearly established,” courts do not demand that public officials dig into their pockets. Harlow v. Fitzgerald, 457 U.S. 800, 818 , 102 S.Ct. 2727, 2738 , 73 L.Ed.2d 396 (1982). … The existence of such line-drawing problems calls for immunity; the rule should be established prospectively rather than at the expense of public employees who predict the development of the law incorrectly.
Cited 30 timesPublished889 F.3d 926 · Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit · May 10, 2018
To determine whether Mannis is entitled to qualified immunity, we ask: (1) whether his conduct violated a constitutional right; and (2) whether the violated right was clearly established. Manning v. … “When a defendant asserts qualified immunity at the summary judgment stage, the plaintiff must produce evidence sufficient to create a genuine issue of fact regarding whether the defendant violated a clearly established right
Cited 34 timesPublished298 F. Supp. 3d 996 · District Court, E.D. Kentucky · Feb 6, 2018
a violation of a clearly established constitutional right. … Thus, where the facts shown by the plaintiff do not make out a clearly established constitutional violation, qualified immunity protects the government official from trial.
Cited 0 timesPublishedCourt of Criminal Appeals of Texas · May 25, 2016
App. 2013) (explaining that an “issue of first impression can sometimes qualify” for extraordinary relief “when the factual scenario has never been precisely addressed but the principle of law has been clearly established
Cited 0 timesPublished136 F. Supp. 3d 838 · District Court, E.D. Michigan · Sep 30, 2015
Indeed, once a defendant raises qualified immunity, it is the § 1983 plaintiffs burden to show that the constitutional right was clearly established when the defendant acted. Webb, 789 F.3d at 659 . … Therefore, the Court finds that to raise the qualified-immunity shield in this case, Clafton must do more than quote legal standards on what counts as clearly-established law. IV.
Cited 6 timesPublishedDistrict Court, D. South Carolina · Feb 28, 2023
The Supreme Court has established a two-step analysis for qualified immunity claims. See Saucier v. Katz, 533 U.S. 194, 201 (2001). … See Hill, 727 F.3d at 322 (considering the impact of Wilkins on the clearly established law prong of qualified immunity cases).
Cited 0 timesUnknown707 F.3d 675 · Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit · Feb 21, 2013
Merits of Thai’s qualified-immunity claim The qualified-immunity doctrine shields government officials performing discretionary functions from civil liability unless their conduct violates clearly established rights … The estate has established that Thai violated a constitutional right and that the right was clearly established. Thai is therefore not entitled to qualified immunity. D.
Cited 200 timesPublishedLionel Alexander v. City of Round Rock
854 F.3d 298 · Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit · Apr 18, 2017
It therefore did not reach the qualified immunity issue. 1. … We hold that Alexander’s claim on this point cannot overcome the officers’ qualified immunity, because “it was not clearly established that an individual has a First Amendment right to refuse to answer an officer’s questions
Cited 131 timesPublishedErika Mabes v. Angela McFeeley
Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit · Apr 28, 2025
Both sets of defendants invoked qual- ified immunity, contending that their actions did not violate the Mabeses’ clearly established rights. … Thompson’s en- titlement to qualified immunity naturally follows from the Mabeses’ failure to carry their “burden of demonstrating the violation of a clearly established right.” Forman v.
Cited 0 timesPublishedAshly Romero v. City of Lansing, Mich.
Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit · Feb 12, 2026
officer] violated the Fourth Amendment [because the officer] was at least entitled to qualified immunity.”); White, 580 U.S. at 78–81 (addressing only the clearly established prong); Mullenix, 577 U.S. at 11 (“We address … Some of our cases have limited the apparent presumption against qualified immunity to the clearly established prong of qualified immunity. See Hart v. Hillsdale Cnty., 973 F.3d 627, 635 (6th Cir. 2020).
Cited 0 timesPublishedMorfin v. City Of East Chicago
349 F.3d 989 · Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit · Nov 18, 2003
Additionally, the district court found that the officers were entitled to qualified immunity because "based upon the factual record these ECPD officers did not violate any clearly established rule prohibiting such conduct … Morfin, the law is clearly established that an officer has a duty to intervene to prevent a false arrest or the use of excessive force if the officer is informed of the facts that establish a constitutional violation and
Cited 34 timesPublishedBrian O'Hagan v. Hector L. Soto
725 F.2d 878 · Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit · Jan 16, 1984
Fitzgerald, 457 U.S. 800, 817-19 , 102 S.Ct. 2727, 2738-2739 , 73 L.Ed.2d 396 (1982), a defendant is entitled to prevail when his conduct does not violate “clearly established” rights, id. at 818 , 102 S.Ct. at 2739 . … Though the Sixth Amendment right to counsel is well established, the uncertainty as to whether it had attached at the time Soto questioned O’Hagan entitles Soto to resist liability on the basis of qualified immunity. 3 For
Cited 17 timesPublishedRussell L. Streetman v. Lt. Gary Jordan, Etc.
918 F.2d 555 · Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit · Jan 4, 1991
We address the merits of Streetman’s second notice of appeal, which correctly identifies the order appealed. 1 Qualified Immunity: A Pleading Problem Qualified immunity cloaks a police officer from personal liability for … discretionary acts which do not violate well-established law.
Cited 39 timesPublished119 F.3d 1156 · Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit · Aug 7, 1997
to a qualified immunity defense.” *1159 I. … of state law. 8 Medford argues on appeal, as he did in the court below, that he is entitled to qualified immunity because the deputies have not alleged a violation of a “clearly established” right; he is immune from suit
Cited 271 timesPublishedChandler v. Secretary of the Florida Department of Transportation
695 F.3d 1194 · Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit · Sep 19, 2012
Consequently, qualified immunity is denied. We review de novo the district court’s denial of the motion to dismiss on qualified immunity grounds. See Long v. Slaton, 508 F.3d 576, 579 (11th Cir.2007). II. … violation of a clearly established law.
Cited 142 timesPublished770 F.3d 224 · Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit · Oct 30, 2014
Qualified Immunity Defendants ask us to find that they are entitled to qualified immunity. … In determining whether the officers are entitled to qualified immunity, the key question is “whether the right in question was ‘clearly established’ at the time of the violation.” Tolan v.
Cited 64 timesPublishedMarshall v. BD. OF CTY. COM'RS FOR JOHNSON CTY.
912 F. Supp. 1456 · District Court, D. Wyoming · Jan 22, 1996
in a qualified immunity case according to clearly established statutory or constitutional rights of which a reasonable person would have known. … Further, a defendant is entitled to qualified immunity if the plaintiff fails to show that the law was clearly established. See, e.g., Pallottino v.
Cited 0 timesPublishedJulious McGruder v. Jeff Heagwood Clyde Murphy, Jr. Bobby Baxter
197 F.3d 918 · Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit · Dec 7, 1999
The District Court 1 granted defendants summary judgment on the basis of qualified immunity. McGru-der appeals, and we affirm. … Qualified immunity shields government officials from liability for civil damages “unless their conduct violated a clearly established constitutional or statutory right of which a reasonable person would have known.”
Cited 10 timesPublished814 F. Supp. 885 · District Court, E.D. California · Feb 24, 1993
Officers are entitled to qualified immunity if their conduct did not violate plaintiffs’ clearly established statutory or constitutional rights or if the officers could reasonably have believed that their conduct was lawful … Alternatively, defendants are entitled to qualified immunity if they prove that a reasonable officer possessing the same information could have believed that the conduct at issue was reasonable in light of the clearly established
Cited 10 timesPublished
Ask Donna