Case law
Opinions from 1658 to today.
3,447 results
0.41s
79 Pa. Commw. 305 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Jan 3, 1984
Pew is barred under the doctrine of judicial immunity. 1 ' In addressing the first of the respondents ’ preliminary objections, we note- that in this Commonwealth it is well established that a court of equity lacks jurisdiction … An .important element which must be established before this immunity can apply, however, is whether or not the actions complained of were performed within the quasi-judicial function.
Cited 14 timesPublishedHall v. Southwestern Pennsylvania Water Authority
87 A.3d 998 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Mar 17, 2014
Commonwealth agencies are generally immune from suit, except where immunity has expressly been waived. Pa. Const. … Assuming that the Halls could establish that damages for negligence would be recoverable at common law or under statute, they still have to prove that the real estate exception to sovereign immunity at 42 Pa.C.S. § 8522(b
Cited 5 timesPublishedKoppenhaver v. Department of Community & Economic Development
898 A.2d 654 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · May 3, 2006
Bd. of Revision of Taxes, 574 Pa. 707 , 833 A.2d 710 (2003), for the proposition that a Commonwealth agency will lose its tax immune status if it acts outside its authorized purpose or outside the scope of its immunity. 9 … They raise legal issues clearly beyond the Department’s scope of review under 53 Pa.C.S. § 8211(d). Bundy; Mellinger, Property *667 Owners.
Cited 2 timesPublishedCowell v. Commonwealth, Department of Transportation
883 A.2d 705 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Sep 29, 2005
any exception to sovereign immunity. … Preliminary objections in the nature of a demurrer should be sustained only where the pleadings are clearly insufficient to establish a right to relief; any doubt must be resolved in favor of overruling the demurrer.
Cited 18 timesPublished712 A.2d 345 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Apr 30, 1998
Neither that provision nor any other that this Court has found clearly provides that such an act of designation and taking over constitutes vesting ownership of the street, including the sidewalk, with the Commonwealth. 3 … In view of the comprehensive scheme established in the immunity and exceptions provisions of the Judicial Code, and in view of the applicable provisions of the State Highway Law, the Court cannot conclude that the legislature
Cited 10 timesPublishedBufford v. Pa. Dept. of Transportation
670 A.2d 751 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Jan 25, 1996
The critical issue before the Court is not whether DOT was negligent in maintaining Bufford’s record; clearly, as found by the trial judge, there was negligence in this case, such that it would support a common law cause … It was likewise established that the suspension information was made available to third parties, such as police departments and insurance companies.
Cited 21 timesPublishedR. Scott v. Philadelphia Police Officer B. Canela-Perez & G. Lutz
Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Aug 14, 2025
The interrogatory at issue was clearly not limited to any specific claims. … the established case law.
Cited 0 timesPublished674 A.2d 773 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Apr 11, 1996
Clearly, these cases do not fall within the Love definition of operation because the injuries were not allegedly caused by any movement of the entire vehicles or parts of the vehicles when or after the vehicles were parked … Love, 518 Pa. at 375 , 543 A.2d at 533 . 5 We conclude that the facts, as alleged and accepted as true, establish that the truck was in operation at the time of the injury under the vehicle exception to governmental immunity
Cited 10 timesPublished119 Pa. Commw. 334 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Sep 8, 1988
However, evidence was submitted to the trial court which established that MCS’ designation does not entitle it, in this case, to immunity as a governmental agency. … The record clearly establishes that Cole was a voluntary out-patient and that on three occasions immediately prior to the rape, he requested in-patient treatment.
Cited 3 timesPublishedCornell Narberth, LLC v. Borough of Narberth
167 A.3d 228 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Jul 14, 2017
The trial court reasoned that the letter “is barely a scintilla of evidence and would clearly not survive trial on the merits.” Id. … To establish a contract, all essential elements must exist, including consideration.
Cited 24 timesPublishedLeasoff v. Commonwealth, Department of Transportation
59 Pa. Commw. 45 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Apr 28, 1981
S. §5110 (Act 152 of 1978), which re-established governmental immunity subject to several exceptions in which immunity was waived, such as personal injuries resulting from “[p]otholes and other dangerous conditions.” … Although the Legislature expressed its intent that the re-establishment of immunity should receive retroactive effect, Section 5(b) of the Act of September 28, 1978, P.L. 788 (Act 152), infra note 2, the Supreme Court held
Cited 2 timesPublished59 A.3d 45 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Jan 9, 2013
We affirm the trial court’s holding that an exception from sovereign immunity has not been established for such a claim. The accident occurred on U.S. … In order for a Commonwealth party to be held liable, the plaintiff must establish that the cause of action falls under one of the specifically enumerated exceptions to immunity. Fagan v.
Cited 2 timesPublishedRhoads Et Ux. v. Lancaster Park. Auth.
103 Pa. Commw. 303 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Jan 22, 1987
in this regard, however, is basically one alleging negligent supervision of persons on the property of the governmental body, and while this principle of law is germane to Section 344 of the Restatement and relevant in establishing … Appellants misapprehend the meaning of the above quoted language in Vann , language attributable to this exception to immunity, with the concept of establishing a common law cause of action.
Cited 49 timesPublishedCommonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Jan 29, 2024
clearly established when it occurred. … Therefore, qualified immunity does not shield the Department from Romig’s claim.
Cited 0 timesPublished123 Pa. Commw. 405 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Feb 10, 1989
. §8501, and was, therefore, entitled to governmental immunity. 1 The court also concluded that the real property exception to immunity 2 did not apply. Thus, it held that Rochester was not liable. … Summary judgment is appropriate only when, examining the record in the light most favorable to the nonmoving party, there is no genuine issue of material fact and the movant clearly establishes that he or she is entitled
Cited 13 timesPublishedSEPTA v. City of Philadelphia and Philadelphia Commission on Human Relations
122 A.3d 1163 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Aug 7, 2015
The Metropolitan Transportation Authorities Act also established that SEPTA enjoys sovereign immunity. … and official immunity and remain immune from suit except as the General Assembly shall specifically waive the immunity.
Cited 3 timesPublished688 A.2d 1261 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Feb 11, 1997
, or ruling and such decision impacts on a person’s personal or property rights, privileges, immunities, duties, liabilities, or obligations.” … As such, the letters clearly constituted an “adjudication” under 2 Pa.C.S. § 101, from which Gomez has a statutory right of appeal pursuant to 2 Pa.C.S. § 752.
Cited 7 timesPublishedBickert v. Borough of Riverside
118 Pa. Commw. 91 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Jul 21, 1988
Force, was killed. 1 Bickert filed a complaint against the Borough and Department, averring that the police negligently engaged in pursuit and that the Department negligently failed to train and instruct its officers and establish … Bickert contends that her complaint clearly alleges negligence with respect to the operation of the police vehicle.
Cited 12 timesPublishedLacava v. Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority
157 A.3d 1003 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Mar 29, 2017
The City’s Argument that Lacava failed to establish an exception to governmental immunity under the “streets” exception 8 Although SEPTA asserted in its 1925(b) statement that the trial … ” exception to sovereign immunity.
Cited 9 timesPublishedTransamerica Insurance v. Judie, Inc.
30 Pa. Commw. 259 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · May 20, 1977
Appellant contends that the court below erred in its application of the doctrine of sovereign immunity. … Unlike the Bureau, the Turnpike Commission itself has been given the power to make “necessary rules and regulations for its own government.” 6 Under Section 6 of the Law, it is the Secretary of Revenue who has the power to establish
Cited 5 timesPublished
Ask Donna