Case law

Opinions from 1658 to today.

Filterspacommwct

3,447 results

0.61s

  • Mason & Dixon Lines, Inc. v. Mognet

    166 Pa. Commw. 1 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Jul 13, 1994

    As the trial court correctly noted, summary judgment is only appropriate when, after examining the record in favor of the nonmoving party, there is no genuine issue of material fact and the movant clearly establishes its … We conclude, therefore, that Penn Eastern and Mognet have failed to establish any duty, either at common law or by statute, owed to them by the Commission.

    Cited 21 timesPublished
  • City of Philadelphia v. Patton

    148 Pa. Commw. 141 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · May 19, 1992

    The City disingenuously argues that the enactment of the Political Subdivision Tort Claims Act, Act of November 26, 1978, P.L. 1399, formerly 53 P.S. §§ 5311.101-5311.803, establishing the statutory bar of governmental immunity … Id., 525 Pa. at 9 , 574 A.2d at 1044 . 4 An entire reading of the McHugh decision, however, clearly demonstrates that it does not support the City’s contention.

    Declined to follow by Johnson v. City of Philadelphia, 1995 Pa. Commw. LEXIS 155 (1995)Cited 8 timesPublished
  • Maloney v. City of Philadelphia

    111 Pa. Commw. 634 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Dec 15, 1987

    In his appeal, Maloney contends the facts of the case establish a cause of action which falls within the real property exception to immunity provided for in 42 Pa. C. S. §8542(b)(3). … He then contends this makes the scaffolding a fixture and qualifies it as real property in the possession of the City.

    Cited 29 timesPublished
  • Flood v. Silfies

    933 A.2d 1072 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Oct 2, 2007

    The Supreme Court then noted that the criteria for establishing local agency immunity changed as a result of its decision in Sphere Drake, which broadened the factors that must be analyzed in determining whether an entity … Appellees assert that the test for determining whether a volunteer fire company is entitled to immunity under the PSTCA was established in Guinn , and it was not modified or overruled by either Sphere Drake or Christy .

    Cited 8 timesPublished
  • Pettit v. Namie

    931 A.2d 790 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Aug 10, 2007

    The District Court granted the prosecutors’ motions for summary judgment and dismissed the suit on the grounds the prosecutors were protected by qualified immunity. … immunity.

    Cited 26 timesPublished
  • Rothermel v. Commonwealth, Department of Transportation

    672 A.2d 837 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Mar 6, 1996

    Initially, we note that summary judgment is only appropriate when, after examining the record, there is no genuine issue of material fact and the movant clearly establishes its entitlement to judgment as a matter of law. … Because Administrators have failed to establish a causal connection between the decedents’ accident and the condition of the property within DOT’s control, the real estate exception to state sovereign immunity, 42 Pa.C.S.

    Overruled by Dean v. Commonwealth, Department of Transportation, 1998 Pa. Commw. LEXIS 712 (1998)Cited 13 timesPublished
  • Sweeney v. Merrymead Farm, Inc.

    799 A.2d 972 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Jun 7, 2002

    The affirmative defense, however, must be clearly applica *976 ble on the face of the complaint. … Preliminary objections in the nature of a demurrer should be sustained only where the pleading is clearly insufficient to establish a right to relief.

    Cited 17 timesPublished
  • J. Brown v. Philadelphia Board of Ethics, & J.S. Creamer, Jr.

    Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Mar 25, 2026

    Second, Plaintiffs contend the Executive Director was not a high public official under our well-established case law, and, therefore, Creamer was not entitled to absolute immunity. … Furthermore, Section 8550 of the Act explicitly limits its application to Sections 8545, 8546, 8548, and 8549 of the Act, which establish official immunity protections for local agency employees and do not pertain to immunity

    Cited 0 timesPublished
  • Burgan v. City of Pittsburgh

    115 Pa. Commw. 566 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · May 3, 1988

    . §8522, to waive the Commonwealths immunity only in “specific, clearly-stated situations” and that therefore the enumerated exceptions to immunity must *579 be strictly construed. Davidow v. Anderson, 83 Pa. … It further states that the city is responsible for establishing a *582 detour in accordance with Section 548 of the Law, 36 PS. §670-548.

    Cited 13 timesPublished
  • League of Women Voters of Pennsylvania v. The Commonwealth of Pennsylvania

    Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Feb 9, 2018

    Under federal common law, state legislative privilege and state legislative immunity is “qualified based on the nature of the claim at issue.” … Id. at 334. 5 Legislative Respondents clearly are not invoking qualified legislative privilege and immunity under federal common law; rather, they are invoking

    Cited 0 timesPublished
  • City of Philadelphia v. Melendez

    156 Pa. Commw. 271 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Jun 15, 1993

    The City argues that case law has clearly established that a parked vehicle is not in operation, and that claims involving a parked vehicle are not actionable under the vehicle exception to governmental immunity. … As previously established, the facts of this case do not fall within any *277 of the potentially applicable exceptions to governmental immunity, and therefore, Crowell does not apply.

    Cited 13 timesPublished
  • DuBree v. Commonwealth

    8 Pa. Commw. 567 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Apr 9, 1973

    The Supreme Court, however, has yet to define clearly who is a “high public official.” In Montgomery v. … Clearly, they do not point to such intentionally malicious, wanton or reckless conduct as would overcome a presumption of conditional immunity, and, in no way could they overcome any presumption of absolute immunity.

    Cited 47 timesPublished
  • Herman v. Greene County Fair Board

    112 Pa. Commw. 615 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Jan 21, 1988

    Summary judgment is properly granted where there is no genuine issue of material fact and the moving party has clearly established entitlement to judgment as a matter of law. Kuehner v. Parsons, 107 Pa. … We believe the Legislature has clearly precluded the imposition of liability on itself or its local agencies for acts of third parties by its language of §8541, supra, and that it has not seen fit to waive immunity for these

    Cited 25 timesPublished
  • Roth v. Borough of Verona

    74 Pa. Commw. 352 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · May 17, 1983

    Although the trial court’s order clearly dismissed the Local' Agency Law appeal, there is no discussion of that issue in the trial court’s opinion. … S. §101 is as follows: , , Any final order, decree, decision, determination or ruling by an agency affecting personal or property rights, privileges, immunities, duties, liabilities or obligations of any or all of the parties

    Overruled by Upper Makefield Township v. Pennsylvania Labor Relations Board, 562 Pa. 113 (2000)Cited 7 timesPublished
  • Kuzel v. Krause

    658 A.2d 856 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · May 8, 1995

    A claim for wrongful discharge is made out when the plaintiff establishes that his or her discharge is a violation of a clearly definable right that “strikes at the heart of citizens’ social right, duties and responsibilities … Because of our Supreme Court’s interpretation of 42 Pa.C.S. § 8550, willful misconduct requires Employees here to establish more than wrongful discharge to make the defense of official immunity unavailable to Krause.

    Cited 51 timesPublished
  • Community College v. Aliquippa School District

    4 Pa. Commw. 483 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Feb 22, 1972

    of those actually voting, unless a contrary legislative intention is very clearly expressed.” … Since we have determined that the Board was properly established, there is no need to address ourselves to the question of whether the college was immune from challenge as a de facto college.

    Cited 4 timesPublished
  • Finn v. City of Philadelphia

    165 Pa. Commw. 255 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Oct 12, 1994

    Snyder clearly stated that the critical word in the real estate exception language is “of’ in the phrase “[a] dangerous condition of Commonwealth agency real estate.” … Instead, Finn’s complaint clearly establishes that the accumu *265 lation of grease on the sidewalk was deposited by cars and trucks which were previously parked there.

    Cited 16 timesPublished
  • Ross v. Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority

    714 A.2d 1131 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Jul 10, 1998

    Clearly, under Simpkins , we are unable to conclude that Ross’ cause of action falls within the personal property exception to immunity. Accordingly, we affirm the trial court’s grant of the nonsuit. … Because the General Assembly intended to exempt the Commonwealth from immunity only in specific, clearly defined situations, the exceptions to the Act must be strictly construed as to uphold legislative intent and to insulate

    Cited 6 timesPublished
  • Allen v. County of Wayne

    88 A.3d 1035 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Sep 13, 2013

    Plaintiff also argues that the trial court erred by failing to address his claim that improper maintenance of the lawn tractor’s reverse warning mechanism qualified as an exception to governmental immunity. … The immunity defense, however, must be clearly applicable on the face of the complaint. Id.

    Cited 1 timesPublished
  • Sherman v. City of Philadelphia

    745 A.2d 95 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Jan 31, 2000

    Although we acknowledge that this analysis clearly sets up an “exception” to an exception in governmental immunity, thereby obliterating a distinction between sidewalks owned by a local government and those owned by private … citizens, such an analysis is clearly reasonable and reaches a sensible result.

    Cited 8 timesPublished

Ask Donna

Ask Donna

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.