Opinion

Carolyn Combs v. Nancy A. Berryhill

  • 878 F.3d 642
Court
Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit
Filed
Dec 28, 2017
Status
Published
Author
Smith
On the bench
Kelly, Sippel, Smith
Cited by
305 cases
Authority
More cited than 13.5%

holding that “[b]y relying on his own interpretation of what ‘no acute distress’ and ‘normal movement in all extremities’ meant in terms of [the claimant’s] RFC, the ALJ failed to satisfy his duty to fully and fairly develop the record”

How later courts described this case

  • holding that “[b]y relying on his own interpretation of what ‘no acute distress’ and ‘normal movement in all extremities’ meant in terms of [the claimant’s] RFC, the ALJ failed to satisfy his duty to fully and fairly develop the record”
  • concluding the ALJ “erred in relying on his own inferences as to the relevance of the notations ‘no acute distress’ and ‘normal movement of all extremities’ when determining the relative weight to assign to [two state agency medical consultant’s] opinions.”
  • concluding that an ALJ erroneously “rel[ied] on his own interpretation of what [the notations] ‘no acute distress’ and ‘normal movement of all extremities’ meant in terms of [the claimant’s] RFC”
  • explaining that an ALJ could not permissibly rely “on his own interpretation of what ‘no acute distress’ and ‘normal movement of all extremities’ meant in terms of [a claimant’s] RFC”

Written by the judges who cited it.

The opinion

SMITH, Chief Judge, dissenting.

The majority holds that the ALJ failed to fully and fairly develop the record.- Specifically, thé majority’holds that the ALJ failed to seek clarification of the terms “no acute distress” and “normal movement of all extremities.” I respectfully dissent.

Combs argues that the ALJ failed to fully and fairly develop the record because he failed to seek clarification of the terms “nó acute distress” and “normal movement of all extremities” and improperly relied on his own interpretations of these terms. Combs essentially argues that these terms were unclear and that the ALJ was duty-bound to ask the treating physicians- for more information. “The ALJ’s duty to develop the record, however, does not extend so far” as to necessarily require an ALJ to seek more information when an opinion is arguably unclear. See Stormo; 377 F.3d at 806. “The ALJ must neutrally develop the facts. He does not, however, have to seek additional clarifying statements from a treating physician unless a crucial issue is undeveloped.” Id. (citation omitted). The medical record contains dozens of treatment notes detailing Combs’s physical limitations. In this case, no crucial issue was undeveloped as to create a duty to seek additional information from Combs’s treating physicians. See KKC ex rel. Stoner v. Colvin, 818 F.3d 364, 372 (8th Cir. 2016).

I therefore respectfully dissent.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.