Opinion

Jared Bretherick v. State of Florida

  • 40 Fla. L. Weekly Supp. 411
  • 170 So. 3d 766
  • 2015 Fla. LEXIS 1470
  • 2015 WL 4112414
Court
Supreme Court of Florida
Filed
Jul 9, 2015
Status
Published
Author
Canady
On the bench
Pariente, Labarga, Quince, Perry, Lewis, Canady, Polston
Cited by
41 cases
Authority
More cited than 11.7%

"Requiring the State to prove its case twice would also cause a tremendous expenditure of time and resources."

How later courts described this case

  • "Requiring the State to prove its case twice would also cause a tremendous expenditure of time and resources."
  • applying in Stand Your Ground context rule of statutory construction to “avoid readings that would render part of a statute meaningless”
  • confirming that the defendant bears the burden of proving entitlement to immunity by a preponderance of the evidence
  • examining the development in the district courts of the burden of proof requirement under the 2011 version of section 776.032

Written by the judges who cited it.

The opinion

CANADY, J.,

dissenting.

I would answer the certified question in the affirmative, quash the Fifth District’s decision, and disapprove the other decisions that have held that a defendant has the burden of establishing entitlement to Stand Your Ground immunity in order to avoid trial. Accordingly, I dissent.

As the majority recognizes, our core holding in Dennis v. State, 51 So.3d 456, 458 (Fla.2010), was that “where a criminal defendant files a motion to dismiss on the basis of section 776.032, the trial court should decide the factual question of the applicability of the statutory immunity.” We reached this conclusion because “thé plain language of section 776.032 grants defendants a substantive right to assert immunity from prosecution and to avoid being subjected to a trial.” Id. at 462 .

The majority’s decision here, however, fails to recognize the essential nature of the factual question that the trial court must decide. The factual question raised by the assertion of Stand Your Ground immunity in a pretrial evidentiary hearing is the same as the factual question raised by a Stand Your Ground defense presented at trial: whether the evidence establishes beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant’s conduct was not justified under the governing statutory standard. The State does not dispute that a defendant presenting a Stand Your Ground defense can only be convicted if the State proves beyond a reasonable doubt that the defense does not apply. See, e.g., Alexander v. State, 121 So.3d 1185, 1188 (Fla. 1st DCA 2013); Leasure v. State, 105 So.3d 5, 13 (Fla. 2d DCA 2012); Montijo v. State, *780 61 So.3d 424, 427 (Fla. 5th DCA 2011); see also Fla. Std. Jury Inst. (Crim.) 3.6(f)-(g). By imposing the burden of proof on the defendant at the pretrial evidentiary hearing, the majority substantially curtails the benefit of the immunity from trial conferred by the Legislature under the Stand Your Ground law. There is no reason to believe that the Legislature intended for a defendant to be denied immunity and subjected to trial when that defendant would be entitled to acquittal at trial on the basis of a Stand Your Ground defense. But the majority’s decision here guarantees that certain defendants who would be entitled to acquittal at trial will nonetheless be deprived of immunity from trial.

The majority’s argument that the burden should be placed on the defendant because it is easier for a defendant to prove entitlement to immunity than it is for the State to disprove entitlement to immunity has no "more force in the context of a pretrial evidentiary hearing than it does in the context of a trial, where it admittedly has no application. That argument has no basis in the text of the Stand Your Ground law. Similarly, the majority’s concern that placing the burden of proof on the State in the pretrial evidentia-ry hearing will potentially result in “two full-blown trials” — by no means a specious concern — cannot justify curtailing the immunity from trial under the Stand Your Ground law for those individuals whose use of force or threat of force is legally justified under the governing statutory standard. Practical problems raised by the Stand Your Ground law are a matter for the Legislature to consider and resolve.

The State has conceded that if the certified question is answered in the affirmative, this case should be remanded to the trial court for reconsideration in light of the appropriate burden of proof. Having concluded that the certified question should be answered in the affirmative, I would therefore quash the decision on review and remand the case for reconsideration by the trial court.

POLSTON, J., concurs.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.