considering the term of a rental lease, including $4000 monthly fee, between rental applicant and third party and noting the unlikelihood that the moral, social and economic considerations underlying imposition of duty to issue alcohol permits to applicant would encompass the risk that a third party contracting with applicant would suffer economic loss
How later courts described this case
- considering the term of a rental lease, including $4000 monthly fee, between rental applicant and third party and noting the unlikelihood that the moral, social and economic considerations underlying imposition of duty to issue alcohol permits to applicant would encompass the risk that a third party contracting with applicant would suffer economic loss
- observing that “[t]he pertinent inquiry [on an exception of no cause of action] is whether, viewed in the light most favorable to the plaintiff, and with every doubt resolved in the plaintiff's favor, the petition states any valid cause of action for relief”
- limiting damages owed by city to lessor whose lessee was denied a retail alcoholic beverage permit
Written by the judges who cited it.
The opinion
HUGHES, J.,
dissenting.
hi respectfully dissent.
Couvillon is the property owner. Cou-villon leased the property to MAW. The terms of the lease specifically tied the rental to the issuance of a permit to sell alcohol. The City admittedly wrongfully delayed the issuance of the permit, which resulted in economic loss to MAW and Couvillon.
There was no “negligent injury to property” resulting in physical damage as occurred in the cases cited by the majority. A City vehicle did not crash into the store and thus interrupt the sale of alcohol. Rather, the City wrongfully delayed issuing a permit to the lessee which, it is easy to see, damaged the lessor as well.