Opinion

Asset Acceptance, LLC v. Newby

  • 437 S.W.3d 119
  • 2014 Ark. 280
  • 2014 Ark. LEXIS 369
  • 2014 WL 2813194
Court
Supreme Court of Arkansas
Filed
Jun 19, 2014
Status
Published
Author
Danielson
On the bench
Courtney Hudson Goodson
Cited by
40 cases
Authority
More cited than 11.4%

concluding that the circuit court’s blanket denial of a motion to compel arbitration constituted a ruling on all of the issues raised by the parties

How later courts described this case

  • concluding that the circuit court’s blanket denial of a motion to compel arbitration constituted a ruling on all of the issues raised by the parties
  • holding that the appellate court lacked jurisdiction over an interlocutory appeal of the denial of sanctions pursuant to Ark. R. Civ. P. 11
  • “In [Alpha Marketing], sovereign immunity was the basis of our jurisdiction, and as such, a specific finding on that issue was necessary for our review.”
  • noting that the arbitration agreement was governed by the FAA and thus our jurisdiction was pursuant to Rule 2(a)(12)

Written by the judges who cited it.

The opinion

PAUL E. DANIELSON, Justice, dissenting.

I dissent from the majority’s opinion in the direct appeal. I simply cannot agree that the instant case can be distinguished from Bank of the Ozarks, Inc. v. Walker, 2014 Ark. 223 , 434 S.W.3d 357 , handed down by this court a mere month ago, and, therefore, I would reverse and remand.

As noted in the majority, this court held in Bank of the Ozarks that a circuit court must rule on the threshold issue of contract formation before determining whether the claims fall within the scope of the arbitration agreement and before considering any defenses that might otherwise invalidate the agreement. Here, Newby argued waiver as a defense below. It is perfectly clear from the circuit court’s oral ruling that it opined that even if there had been an agreement, Asset waived it:

Assuming that it’s in fact a Chase card, or that it’s the information provided that has the arbitration, the plaintiff has invoked the jurisdiction of this Court. The plaintiff did not file arbitration proceedings. The plaintiff invoked the jurisdiction of this Court with respect to the named defendant.

Because the circuit court skipped over the first step of making a determination on the threshold issue of whether there was an agreement, just as the circuit court did in Bank of the Ozarks, we must reverse and remand if stare decisis means anything.

The majority wants to disregard the circuit court’s oral ruling because the written ruling simply reflects that Asset’s motion to compel arbitration was denied. In support of this, 113it cites to a case in which this court held that a circuit court is free to alter its decision on further consideration of the matter and the written order controls. See Nat’l Home Ctrs., Inc. v. Coleman, 370 Ark. 119 , 257 S.W.3d 862 (2007) (citing McGhee v. Arkansas Bd. of Collection Agencies, 368 Ark. 60 , 243 S.W.3d 278 (2006)). While that makes perfect sense in cases where there is some sort of conflict between the oral ruling and the written ruling, it is not called for in a ease in which the oral ruling simply explains the reasoning behind the written order. Cf. McGhee, supra (where this court could not be certain that the circuit court intended to find an act constitutional); cf. also Stills v. Stills, 2010 Ark. 132 , 361 S.W.3d 823 (“To the extent that the court’s bench ruling conflicts with its written order, if at all, the written order controls over the court’s oral ruling.”); Carr v. Nance, 2010 Ark. 25 , 2010 WL 199626 (the oral dismissal of parties was never reduced to a written order); Nelson v. Stubblefield, 2009 Ark. 256 , 308 S.W.3d 586 (where the circuit court orally ruled it would allow certain testimony, but the written order reflected that the testimony would be reviewed at trial).

It is for these reasons that I respectfully dissent.

HANNAH, C.J., and CORBIN, J„ join.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.