Opinion

State v. Cuntapay

  • 104 Haw. 109
  • 85 P.3d 634
  • 2004 Haw. LEXIS 156
Court
Hawaii Supreme Court
Filed
Mar 5, 2004
Status
Published
Author
Nakayama
On the bench
Levinson, Acoba, Duffy, Nakayama, Moon
Cited by
14 cases
Authority
More cited than 11.3%

recognizing that "the record [did] not indicate that the prosecution raised the issue of abandonment in the circuit court” and, therefore, "waived this point as a matter for appeal” (citing State v. Rodrigues, 67 Haw. 496, 498, 692 P.2d 1156, 1158 (1985)

How later courts described this case

  • recognizing that "the record [did] not indicate that the prosecution raised the issue of abandonment in the circuit court” and, therefore, "waived this point as a matter for appeal” (citing State v. Rodrigues, 67 Haw. 496, 498, 692 P.2d 1156, 1158 (1985)
  • adopting Justice Ginsburg’s dissent in Minnesota v. Carter, 525 U.S. 83, 106, 109, 119 S.Ct. 469, 142 L.Ed.2d 373 (1998), that short term guests have a protected right of privacy, inasmuch as " 'a guest should share his [or her] host's shelter against unreasonable searches and seizures' ”
  • adopting Justice Ginsburg's dissent in Minnesota v. Carter, 525 U.S. 83, 106, 119 S.Ct. 469, 142 L.Ed.2d 373 (1998), that short term guests have a protected right of privacy, inasmuch as " 'a guest should share his [or her] host's shelter against unreasonable searches and seizures' ”
  • holding that "under Article I, section 7 of the Hawai`i Constitution, a guest of a homedweller is entitled to a right of privacy while in his or her host's home" (footnote omitted)

Written by the judges who cited it.

The opinion

Dissenting Opinion by

NAKAYAMA, J.,

with whom MOON, C.J., joins.

I respectfully dissent from the majority’s holding that Cuntapay had a reasonable expectation of privacy in the homedweller’s washroom.

Article I, section 7 of the Hawaii Constitution protects persons against unreasonable searches and seizures. To determine if a person’s expectation of privacy is reasonable, *119 this court adopted the two-part test of Katz v. United States, 389 U.S. 347 , 88 S.Ct. 507 , 19 L.Ed.2d 576 (1967). State v. Bonnell, 75 Haw. 124, 139 , 856 P.2d 1265, 1274 (1993). “First, one must exhibit an actual, subjective expectation of privacy. Second, that expectation must be one that society would recognize as objectively reasonable.” Id. (citations and internal quotations omitted). In a motion to suppress, the proponent of the motion bears this burden by a preponderance of the evidence. State v. Taua, 98 Hawai'i 426, 434 , 49 P.3d 1227, 1235 (2002); State v. Edwards, 96 Hawai'i 224, 232 , 30 P.3d 238, 246 (2001).

Even if Cuntapay exhibited an actual, subjective expectation of privacy by hiding the key holder behind the washing machine, he failed to establish that his subjective expectation was one that society would recognize as objectively reasonable. During the hearing on his motion to suppress, Cuntapay testified as follows:

[Prosecution:] Had you been to that residence before?

[Cuntapay:] Yes, but not many times.

[Prosecution:] How many times.

[Cuntapay:] Once a week, sometimes twice.

[Prosecution:] Always for the same thing, to play cards?

[Cuntapay:] Yes, and play dart.

[Prosecution:] Cards and darts. How about to smoke batu?

[Cuntapay:] I admit sometimes.

Relying on this testimony, the majority concludes that Cuntapay held the status of a guest and, thus, was “entitled to share in his host’s security against unreasonable searches and seizures of the dwelling he was visiting.” I must disagree.

Cuntapay’s testimony was, at best, ambiguous, and does not establish an objective, reasonable expectation of privacy beyond the homedweller’s garage. The record is devoid of any evidence that Cuntapay was a friend, relative or business associate of the homed-weller, or that he was invited by the homed-weller and, thus, we are left to guess as to Cuntapay’s relationship with the homedwel-ler. Moreover, the record lacks any evidence that Cuntapay was allowed to move beyond the garage into other areas of the homedwel-ler’s house, that he frequented the washroom, or that he previously stored his personal belongings in the washroom. Society would not accept as reasonable, that a person physically limited to a homedweller’s garage, without more, should expect privacy in all parts of the homedweller’s house. Based on the record, Cuntapay failed to meet the second prong of the Katz test and, thus, failed to establish that he had a reasonable expectation of privacy in the homedweller’s washroom. As such, I would dismiss the application for writ of certiorari as improvidently granted.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.