Opinion

Namani v. Workers' Compensation Appeal Board

  • 32 A.3d 850
  • 2011 Pa. Commw. LEXIS 597
  • 2011 WL 6034357
Court
Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania
Filed
Dec 6, 2011
Status
Published
Author
Friedman
On the bench
McGinley, Jubelirer, Friedman
Cited by
29 cases
Authority
More cited than 10.2%

concluding that under principles of collateral estoppel, the claimant could not relitigate the issue of whether he suffered from cervical injuries during a reinstatement proceeding because the claimant knew that he had such injuries prior to the termination proceedings and, therefore, “should have litigated the issue of his cervical injuries during the termination proceedings.”

How later courts described this case

  • concluding that under principles of collateral estoppel, the claimant could not relitigate the issue of whether he suffered from cervical injuries during a reinstatement proceeding because the claimant knew that he had such injuries prior to the termination proceedings and, therefore, “should have litigated the issue of his cervical injuries during the termination proceedings.”

Written by the judges who cited it.

The opinion

DISSENTING OPINION BY

Senior Judge FRIEDMAN.

I respectfully dissent. The majority holds that the doctrine of technical res judicata bars Hakif Namani’s (Claimant) Review Petition, which Claimant filed to amend the notice of compensation payable (NCP) to include additional injuries, because Claimant could have litigated whether he sustained additional injuries during proceedings on the Termination Petition filed by Claimant’s employer. For the following reasons, I cannot agree that technical res judicata applies.

The majority’s own explanation of technical res judicata is that there must be: (1) identity of the thing sued upon or for; (2) identity of the cause of action; (3) identity of the persons or parties to the action; and (4) identity of the quality or capacity of the parties suing or sued. (Majority Op. at 856-57) (quoting Weney v. Workers’ Compensation Appeal Board (Mac Sprinkler Systems, Inc., 960 A.2d 949, 954 (Pa. *859 Cmwlth.2008))). When all four elements are present, technical res judicata bars matters that should have been raised in the prior proceeding. Id.

The first two elements are missing in this case. Claimant filed a Review Petition seeking to correct the NCP to include additional injuries. Claimant’s employer filed the Termination Petition to end Claimant’s benefits due to his full recovery from the injury described in the NCP. These are different causes of action, seeking different things. Thus, technical res judicata does not bar Claimant’s Review Petition.

Accordingly, I would reverse.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.