Opinion

Heim v. ZONING BD. OF APPEALS OF TOWN OF NEW CANAAN

  • 288 Conn. 628
  • 953 A.2d 877
  • 2008 Conn. LEXIS 332
Court
Supreme Court of Connecticut
Filed
Sep 2, 2008
Status
Published
Author
Schaller
On the bench
Norcott, Katz, Vertefeuille, Zarella, Schaller
Cited by
4 cases
Authority
More cited than 9.8%

The opinion

SCHALLER, J.,

concurring. Although I concur with the decision of the majority to reverse and direct judgment in this case, I agree generally with the rationale expressed in Justice Zarella’s concurrence, which I join. I write separately to emphasize that the key term in chapter 60, article X, § 60-10.1 (B), of the New Canaan zoning regulations 1 is not “ ‘health-oriented’ ” standing alone, which can apply broadly to animals as well as to humans, but “ ‘similar health-oriented’ ” which, in *646 my view, restricts the permitted uses to human health-oriented applications. (Emphasis added.) Even if, as the majority asserts in footnote 9 of its opinion, the terms “medical” and “dental” are not strictly limited to human health purposes (although it would be unusual to refer to an office for animal dentistry), medical and/ or dental offices for veterinary purposes certainly are not similar to human health care facilities in common parlance and understanding. I believe that a reasonable interpretation of the language of the regulation indicates that it is restricted to health-oriented offices for the care of humans. See ATC Partnership v. Coats North America Consolidated, Inc., 284 Conn. 537, 545 , 935 A.2d 115 (2007) (“[i]n construing a statute, common sense must be used and courts must assume that a reasonable and rational result was intended” [internal quotation marks omitted]).

Chapter 60, article X, § 60-10.1 (B), of the New Canaan zoning regulations provides that “medical, dental or similar health-oriented offices shall be permitted” in a business A zone.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.