holding that the lack of a § 23-110 hearing was “especially significant” when trial judge reviewing the petition was not the presiding judge at the sentencing
How later courts described this case
- holding that the lack of a § 23-110 hearing was “especially significant” when trial judge reviewing the petition was not the presiding judge at the sentencing
- explaining that “[o]nly three categories of claims do not merit hearings” (emphasis added)
- reversing motion judge’s summary denial, noting that “he had no recollection of the proceedings and was not familiar with the actual events that transpired. In these circumstances, the lack of a hearing becomes especially significant”
- holding defendant’s decision to plead involuntary where the “decision to plead was materially misinformed” by counsel
Written by the judges who cited it.
The opinion
GALLAGHER, Senior Judge,
concurring and dissenting:
I agree that appellant should have been granted a hearing on her motion to vacate her sentence filed pursuant to D.C. Code § 23-110 . The evidence adduced at that hearing would afford the basis for determining whether her guilty plea may be withdrawn.
I do not agree with Part II of the court’s opinion, as I would first await the outcome of the hearing to assess the circumstances surrounding the plea proceedings.