Opinion

Standard Venetian Blind Co. v. American Empire Insurance

  • 503 Pa. 300
  • 469 A.2d 563
  • 1983 Pa. LEXIS 791
Court
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania
Filed
Dec 30, 1983
Status
Published
Author
Nix
On the bench
Roberts, Nix, Larsen, Flaherty, McDermott, Hutchinson, Zappala
Cited by
621 cases
Authority
More cited than 9.0%

holding that where “the policy limitation relied upon by the insurer to deny coverage is clearly worded and conspicuously displayed, the insured may not avoid the consequences of that limitation by proof that [s]he failed to read the limitation or that [s]he did not understand it”

How later courts described this case

  • holding that where “the policy limitation relied upon by the insurer to deny coverage is clearly worded and conspicuously displayed, the insured may not avoid the consequences of that limitation by proof that [s]he failed to read the limitation or that [s]he did not understand it”
  • holding that insured was bound to policy terms and explaining that “[F]ailure to read [the contract] is an unavailing excuse or defense and cannot justify an avoidance, modification or nullification of the contract or any provision thereof.”
  • stating that under the principles stated by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, the term using must be construed in favor of the insured and against the insurer, the drafter of the agreement
  • noting that an insurance company is obligated to defend an insured whenever the complaint filed by the injured party may potentially come within the policy's coverage

Written by the judges who cited it.

The opinion

NIX, Justice,

dissenting.

I dissent. The issue in this appeal is whether an exclusion in a liability insurance policy is enforceable. The majority, relying upon standard principles of contract law, focuses upon the question of ambiguity in the policy’s language. Mr. Justice Hutchinson in his concurrence suggests the use of a “reasonable expectation” test. In my view both tests are equally nebulous and neither is appropriate in the area of insurance contract interpretation.

An insurance contract is essentially a contract of adhesion. Its terms are not bargained for but rather dictated by the insurer. Thus the insured’s awareness and understanding of exclusions set forth in an insurance policy should not be presumed from the mere presence of such exclusions among the policy’s terms. The very fact that the insurer prescribes particular exclusions indicates an assumption that the purchaser could otherwise reasonably expect to be covered against the risk so excluded.

It is therefore crucial that the insurer explain and the insured understand the precise nature of the policy’s limitations. For this reason I would apply the test adopted by the Superior Court in Hionis v. Northern Mutual Insurance Co., 230 Pa.Super. 511 , 327 A.2d 363 (1974), employed by both that court and the trial court in this matter, and hold the insured to a standard of proving the insured was aware of and fully appreciated the effect of exclusions in the insurance policy before permitting the insurer to escape its duty to defend the insured. Because the insurer in the instant case failed to sustain that burden, I would affirm the order of the Superior Court.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.