beginning discussion of that case by stating that “no question is raised of the sufficiency of the proof’
How later courts described this case
- beginning discussion of that case by stating that “no question is raised of the sufficiency of the proof’
- “The possibility that the jury may accept as the truth the earlier statements in preference to those made upon the stand is indeed real, but we find no difficulty in it. If, from all that the jury see of the witness, they conclude that what he says now is not the truth, but what he said before, they are none the less deciding from what they see and hear of that person and in court.”
- acknowledging juries’ ability to evaluate the truthfulness of past and current statements in court
Written by the judges who cited it.
The opinion
HOUGH, Circuit Judge
(concurring). I concur, but consider that on one point the court’s opinion does not go far enough. Identification is often a continuing process, and when a witness in court has identified an accused, by every rule of reason previous identification at divers times and under diverse circumstances should constitute legitimate corroboration of such identifying evidence. In just the same manner would evidence of previous failure to identify be legitimate opposing evidence. There is no decision of the Supreme Court to the contrary of this, and I think we should go this far.