Plaintiff must show that the goods were delivered to the carrier “in a condition fit for transportation.”
How later courts described this case
- Plaintiff must show that the goods were delivered to the carrier “in a condition fit for transportation.”
- “[T]here may have been some damage due to bad stowage but how much we cannot say, nor indeed can we say with any certainty whether all of the damage was not due to the original ‘nature of the goods’ when loaded.”
- “The recitals of ‘apparent good order and condition’ in the bills of lading furnished only prima facie proof of the external condition of the bags. But their external condition would not show whether the contents were potentially [damaged].... ”
Written by the judges who cited it.
The opinion
CHASE, Circuit Judge
(dissenting).
As inadequate stowage and ventilation of such a cargo for such a voyage, sufficient to account for the damage, was proved and found; the bills of lading showed receipt in apparent good order and condition; and there was only what I think pure speculation as to any excessive oil or moisture content of the meal when shipped; it seems to me that the trial judge was justified in treating good condition at shipment as sufficiently established. Consequently, I think the rule of Schnell v. The Vallescura, 293 U.S. 296 , 55 S.Ct. 194 , 79 L.Ed. 373 applicable.
I would affirm the decree.