concluding that the jury should not have been instructed that it could consider whether the defendant should have known that his conduct was highly likely to produce injury since the test for willful and wanton conduct required an active mental attitude
How later courts described this case
- concluding that the jury should not have been instructed that it could consider whether the defendant should have known that his conduct was highly likely to produce injury since the test for willful and wanton conduct required an active mental attitude
- stating, in dicta, "Where it is impossible to determine which line of reasoning a jury adopted, it ... is improper to speculate that it selected the correct theory and disregarded a wrong one."
- holding ordinary or simple negligence should be considered as resulting from a passive mind, while a willful and wanton disregard is the result of an active and purposeful intent
- “Omitting to weigh consequences is simple negligence; refusing to weigh them , is willful.”
Written by the judges who cited it.
The opinion
Mr. Justice Moore
dissenting.
I must dissent from the views expressed in a substantial portion of the opinion of the Court. My dissent is directed to that part of the opinion which holds that, as a matter of law, there was insufficient evidence to warrant submission of the question of liability to the jury. I am in agreement with that portion of the opinion which deals with the instructions given in this case, and according to my views the judgment should be reversed and the cause remanded for a new trial.