Opinion

Southwest Key Program, Inc. v. Gil-Perez

  • 45 Tex. Sup. Ct. J. 1026
  • 81 S.W.3d 269
  • 2002 Tex. LEXIS 116
  • 2002 WL 1431602
Court
Texas Supreme Court
Filed
Jul 3, 2002
Status
Published
Author
Neill
On the bench
Rodriguez, Phillips, Hecht, Enoch, Owen, Baker, Jefferson, O'Neill, Hankinson
Cited by
149 cases
Authority
More cited than 6.7%

holding that, bearing in mind the jury was not convinced by a preponderance of the evidence that 4 the plaintiff’s actions contributed to the injury, there was some evidence to support the jury’s failure to place any responsibility on plaintiff and the preponderance of the evidence does not support an affirmative answer

How later courts described this case

  • holding that, bearing in mind the jury was not convinced by a preponderance of the evidence that 4 the plaintiff’s actions contributed to the injury, there was some evidence to support the jury’s failure to place any responsibility on plaintiff and the preponderance of the evidence does not support an affirmative answer
  • holding that, bearing in mind the jury was not convinced by a preponderance of the evidence that the plaintiff’s actions contributed to the injury, there was some evidence to support the jury’s failure to place any responsibility on plaintiff and the preponderance of the evidence does not support an affirmative answer
  • finding evidence legally insufficient when expert’s testimony, which was only evidence of causal nexus, failed to establish it was more probable than not that plaintiff would not have been injured but for defendant’s failure to provide ordinary protective gear
  • holding that rendition is proper when a no evidence point is sustained

Written by the judges who cited it.

The opinion

Justice O’NEILL

filed a dissenting opinion, in which Justice HANKINSON joined.

The Court determines that Southwest Key’s failure to provide protective equipment is the single “causal nexus” that underlies Gil-Perez’s negligence theories, then concludes that there is no evidence that lack of equipment proximately caused Gil-Perez’s injuries. But the Court conducts an improper legal-sufficiency review by considering evidence contrary to the verdict and ignoring testimony that supports causation. Because there is some evidence to support the jury’s causation finding, I would affirm the court of appeals’ judgment. Accordingly, I respectfully dissent.

*276 Dr. Calhoun testified, as the Court recounts, that it was possible for an injury like Gil-Perez’s to occur even with protective gear, and that there was no guarantee that protective equipment would always prevent an injury like Gil-Perez’s from occurring. But he also testified that in his extensive experience, which included treating “many” sports-injury patients, and “patients ... with similar knee injuries as Mr. Perez’[s] which arose from playing sports,” he had never treated a patient with a similar knee injury who had worn a brace:

[Counsel]: Okay. Well, have you ever treated patients in the past or provided medical care and treatment to patients with similar injuries as Mr. Perez from playing sports who were, in fact, wearing some type of protective equipment that still got injured?

[Dr. Calhoun]: I don’t recall treating a patient that had an injury to the knee that was wearing a brace, a dislocation injury to the knee that was wearing a brace.

Gil-Perez was not required to show that if Southwest Key had provided protective gear his safety was “absolute” or “guaranteed.” Rather, he had to show it was more likely than not that, but for Southwest Key’s failure to provide safety equipment, Gil-Perez would not have dislocated his knee.

Gil-Perez contends Southwest Key and its employees were negligent in allowing the boys to play full-contact tackle football without equipment when reasonable alternative activities, including soccer and touch football, were available. Gil-Perez was tackled and, as a result, suffered a dislocated knee. Given the common knowledge that tackle football is an intensely physical sport with a high risk of injury, and Dr. Calhoun’s testimony that he did not recall ever treating a patient with similar injuries who had worn a brace, the jury could have concluded that Southwest Key’s negligence in allowing Gil-Perez to play tackle football was a “substantial factor” in bringing about his injury. See Lee Lewis Constr., Inc. v. Harrison, 70 S.W.3d 778, 784 (Tex.2001). Viewing the evidence in a light that tends to support the jury’s verdict and disregarding all evidence and inferences to the contrary, Bradford v. Vento, 48 S.W.3d 749, 754 (Tex.2001), I would hold the evidence legally sufficient to support the jury’s causation finding. Because the Court holds otherwise, I respectfully dissent.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.