Opinion

Belt v. Turner

  • 25 Utah 2d 230
  • 479 P.2d 791
  • 1971 Utah LEXIS 587
Court
Utah Supreme Court
Filed
Jan 20, 1971
Status
Published
Author
Henriod
On the bench
Tuckett, Henriod, Callister, Ellett, Crockett
Cited by
21 cases
Authority
More cited than 5.1%

Distinguished

  • Distinguished by State v. Yates, 291 Utah Adv. Rep. 4 (1996)

    On appeal, the State suggests Belt and Saxton are distinguishable from the present case because the underlying facts in those cases either were established by a trier of fact or were undisputed.
    Court of Appeals of UtahMay 23, 1996Read it

The opinion

HENRIOD, Justice

(dissenting).

State v. Miller controls here. 1 Mr. Justice Tuckett concurred in that case, which dispelled any concern about the applicability of this case to criminal responsibility. That case, except for time of sentencing, is identical to this.

The main opinion must concede that the defendant is compromising this court by the simple device of absenting himself, in *234 complete defiance of his agreed conditions for probation, from appearance at court on the date for his sentence, which was long before the effective date of the statute that he now invokes. This, with due apology to my learned colleague, Mr. Justice Tuckett, and with due respect for Mr. Ca-hoon, appointee of the court, who has spent a good deal of time on this case.

There is no justification for the main opinion in this case, unless we overrule State v. Miller, supra, or indulge in that sweet but forbidden luxury of legislating.

Mr. Richard Cahoon deserves our thanks for his uncompensated efforts in assisting the defendant and this court, but incidentally disagreeing with this dissent.

CALLISTER, C. J., concurs in the dissenting opinion of HENRIOD, J.

. 24 Utah 2d 1 , 464 P.2d 844 (1970).

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.