Opinion

Roll v. Roll

  • 128 Ind. App. 360
  • 146 N.E.2d 553
  • 1957 Ind. App. LEXIS 120
Court
Indiana Court of Appeals
Filed
Dec 19, 1957
Status
Published
Author
Crumpacker
On the bench
Crumpacker
Cited by
2 cases
Authority
More cited than 4.7%

The opinion

On Petition for Rehearing

Crumpacker, J.

Upon consideration of the appellants’ petition for a rehearing we have concluded to withdraw our holding that “Exhibit E” was inadmissible as evidence because it shows no judgment upon the finding that “Lucy Roll is the wife of said J. L. Roll, deceased,” and substitute the following:

When a judgment is offered not merely as evidence of its own existence but as proof of some fact or facts upon the supposed existence of which the judgment was founded, the general rule is that it is not binding upon anyone except the parties thereto, those who might legally have become parties and those in privity with them. Lasher, Administratrix *368 v. Gerlach (1940), 107 Ind. App. 572 , 23 N. E. 2d 296 . It must be borne in mind that the appellant is seeking to compel the appellee Inland Steel Company to pay her compensation, as the natural guardian of and for the benefit of the alleged step-children of J. L. Roll, deceased, claimed to be his dependents at the time of his death. While said appellee does not deny liability for the death of said J. L. Roll it does not admit that compensation for said death is owing to the appellant’s wards. In fact it objected to proof of that issue through a consideration of “Exhibit E” which, as the sole defendant in these proceedings, it had the right to do. It was not a party to the proceedings culminating in the judgment of which “Exhibit E” is a certified copy nor might it have legally become a party thereto nor is it in privity with those who were parties to those proceedings or might have become so. It is our considered opinion that the Industrial Board committed no error in striking “Exhibit E” from the record.

Petition for rehearing overruled.

Note. — Reported in 146 N. E. 2d 553 .

Rehearing denied 147 N. E. 2d 557 .

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.